,]RWUySpVDQL]RWUySIOXLGXPRNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiViQDNYL]VJiODWD HOPpOHWLV]LPXOiFLyVpVNtVpUOHWLPyGV]HUHNNHO
'RNWRUL3K'pUWHNH]pV
.pV]tWHWWH
9DOLVNy0yQLND RNOHYHOHVYHJ\pV]
.pV]OWD9HV]SUpPL(J\HWHP
.pPLD'RNWRUL,VNRODSURJUDPMDNHUHWpEHQ
7pPDYH]HW 'U6]DODL,VWYiQ
)L]LNDL.pPLD7DQV]pN
.LYRQDW
$ GROJR]DWEDQ L]RWUyS pV DQL]RWUyS IOXLGXPRN UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiViQDN PHJKDWiUR]iViYDO IRJODONR]RWW D V]HU] SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWL 0RQWH &DUOR V]LPXOiFLyV pV NtVpUOHWLPyGV]HUHNIHOKDV]QiOiViYDO$UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVPHJDGKDWyDNOV HOHNWURPRVWpU KDWiViUD DGRWW OLQHiULV GLHOHNWURPRV YiODV] DODSMiQ 1DJ\ViJD D GLHOHNWULNXP SRODUL]iOKDWyViJiQDN PpUWpNpW O IJJ pV D] DGRWW DQ\DJUD MHOOHP] MyO PHJKDWiUR]RWW DQ\DJL WXODMGRQViJ$]HJ\V]HU PRGHOOHNGLSROiULVPHUHYJ|PESRODUL]iOKDWyGLSROiULVPHUHYJ|PE YDODPLQW 6WRFNPD\HU SRWHQFLiORN DONDOPD]iViYDO HOPpOHWL ~WRQ PHJEHFVOW UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiVRNDWV]LPXOiFLyVpVNtVpUOHWLDGDWRNNDOLV|VV]HYHWHWWHDV]HU] L]RWUySIRO\DGpNRN HVHWpQ
$ V]HU] NpW ~M PyGV]HUW MDYDVROW SRODUL]iOKDWy IOXLGXPRN UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiViQDN EHFVOpVpUHSHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWLPHJIRQWROiVRNDODSMiQ(OV NpQWHJ\HJ\V]HU V]HPLHPSLULNXV PyGV]HUWYH]HWHWWEHD.LUNZRRG)U|KOLFKHJ\HQOHWDODSMiQ$SRODUL]iOKDWyViJRWPROHNXOiULV V]LQWHQ ILJ\HOHPEH YpYH D UHQRUPiOW SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWHQ DODSXOy HJ\HQOHWHW MDYDVROW D SRODUL]iOKDWyPROHNXOiULVIOXLGXPRNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiViQDNV]iPtWiViUD
6]LV]WHPDWLNXV 0RQWH &DUOR V]LPXOiFLyV WDQXOPiQ\EDQ IRJODOWD |VV]H D V]HU] D UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVPHJKDWiUR]iVDVRUiQNDSRWWHUHGPpQ\HLW|VV]HKDVRQOtWYDD]HOPpOHWL~WRQ EHFVOW DGDWRNNDO pV My HJ\H]pVW WDOiOW PpUVpNHOW GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPRN pV SRODUL]iOKDWyViJRN HVHWpQ
$ NtVpUOHWL PXQND VRUiQ D] DQL]RWUyS DQ\DJRN HJ\ MHOOHJ]HWHV FVRSRUWMiW D IRO\DGpNNULVWiO\RNDWYL]VJiOWDDV]HU] 0pU FHOOiWpVPpUpVLHOMiUiVWIHMOHV]WHWWNLDVV]RFLDWtY IRO\DGpNNULVWiO\RNGLHOHNWURPRVWXODMGRQViJDLQDNYL]VJiODWDFpOMiEyO
7KHRUHWLFDOVLPXODWLRQDQGH[SHULPHQWDOVWXG\RIWKHUHODWLYHSHUPLWWLYLW\
RILVRWURSLFDQGDQLVRWURSLFIOXLGV
$3K'WKHVLV E\
0yQLND9DOLVNy
$EVWUDFW
7KH WKHVLV GHDO ZLWK WKH GHWHUPLQDWLRQ RI WKH UHODWLYH SHUPLWWLYLW\ RI LVRWURSLF DQG DQLVRWURSLF IOXLGV XVLQJ SHUWXUEDWLRQ WKHRUHWLFDO 0RQWH &DUOR VLPXODWLRQ DQG H[SHULPHQWDO PHWKRGV 7KH UHODWLYH SHUPLWWLYLWLHV HVWLPDWHG IURP YDULRXV WKHRUHWLFDO DSSURDFKHV DSSO\LQJ VLPSOH PRGHOV KDYH EHHQ FRPSDUHG WR ERWK VLPXODWLRQ DQG H[SHULPHQWDO GDWD LQ WKH FDVH RI LVRWURSLFOLTXLGV
7ZR QHZ SHUWXUEDWLRQ WKHRUHWLFDO PHWKRGV KDYH EHHQ VXJJHVWHG WR FDOFXODWH WKH UHODWLYH SHUPLWWLYLW\ RI SRODUL]DEOH IOXLGV $ V\VWHPDWLF 0RQWH &DUOR VWXG\ RI WKH GLHOHFWULF SURSHUWLHV RI SRODUL]DEOH PRGHO IOXLGV KDV EHHQ PDGH ,Q WKH H[SHULPHQWDO ZRUN D FKDUDFWHULVWLF FODVV RI DQLVRWURSLF PDWHULDOV KDV EHHQ VWXGLHG WKH OLTXLG FU\VWDOV :H KDYH SURYHG ZLWK RXU GLHOHFWULF PHDVXUHPHQWV WKDW WKH +ERQGV IRUPHG LQ DVVRFLDWLRQ PDNHV WKH OLTXLGFU\VWDOSURSHUWLHVVWURQJHU
8QWHUVXFKXQJGHUUHODWLYHQ'LHOHNWUL]WlWVNRQVWDQWHQYRQLVRWURSHQXQG DQLVRWURSHQ)OXLGHQPLWWHOVWKHRUHWLVFKHUXQGH[SHULPQHWHOOHU0HWKRGHQ
XQG&RPSXWHUVLPXODWLRQHQ
'RNWRUDUEHLW YRQ 0yQLND9DOLVNy
=XVDPPHQIDVVXQJ
,Q GHU YRUOLHJHQGHQ $UEHLW ZXUGH GLH UHODWLYH 'LHOHNWUL]LWlWVNRQVWDQWHQ YRQ LVRWURSHQ XQG DQLVRWURSHQ )OXLGHQ PLW GHU 3HUWXUEDWLRQVWKHRULH PLW 0RQWH &DUOR 6LPXODWLRQ XQG PLW HLQHU H[SHULPHQWDOOHQ 0HWKRGH EHVWLPPW (LQIDFKH 0RGHOOSRWHQWLDOH ZXUGHQ LQ GHU 3HUWXUEDWLRQVWKHRULH XQG LQ 0RQWH &DUOR 6LPXODWLRQHQ YHUZHQGHW 'LH GXUFK GLH 7KHRULH YRUKHUJHVDJWH 'LHOHNWUL]LWlWVNRQVWDQWHQ ZXUGHQ PLW GHQ (UJHEQLVVHQ GHU 6LPXODWLRQHQ XQG PLWH[SHULPHQWHOOHQ'DWHQYHUJOLFK
=ZHLQHXH0HWKRGHQZXUGHQIUGLH(UPLWWOXQJGHUUHODWLYHQ'LHOHNWUL]LWlWVNRQVWDQWHQ YRQ SRODULVLHUEDUHQ )OXLGHQ HQWZLFNHOW 6\VWHPDWLVFKH 0RQWH &DUOR 8QWHUVXFKXQJ ZXUGHQ ]XP 6WXGLXP GHU UHODWLYHQ 'LHOHNWUL]LWlWVNRQVWDQWHQ YRQ SRODULVLHUEDUHQ )OXLGHQ HLQJHVHW]
$XFK LP 5DKPHQ GLHVHU $UEHLW ZXUGHQ GLH 'LHOHNWUL]LWlWVNRQVWDQWHQPHVVXQJHQ HLQHJHU )OVVLJNHLWVNULVWDOOH DOV HLQH W\SLVFKH *UXSSH YRQ DQLVRWURSHQ 0DWHULDOHQ GXUFKJHIUKW
$QKDQG YRQ 'LHOHNWUL]LWlWVNRQVWDQWHQPHVVXQJHQ ZXUGH JH]HLJW GD GLH $XVELOGXQJ GHU :DVVHUVWRIIEUFNHQ]XHLQHU9HUVWlUNHUXQJGHVIOVVLJNHLWVNULVWDOOLQHQ&KDUDNWHUVIKUW
7DUWDORPMHJ\]pN
7DUWDORP««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
%HYH]HWpV
-HO|OpVHNpVU|YLGtWpVHNMHJ\]pNH«««««««««««««««««
(O V]y««««««««««««««««««««««««««
$]LQWHUPROHNXOiULVN|OFV|QKDWiVRN««««««««««««««««
$UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiV
$UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVIHQRPHQROyJLDLV]iUPD]WDWiVD«««««««««
$UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVPROHNXOiULVpUWHOPH]pVH«««««««««««
$UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVVWDWLV]WLNXVPHFKDQLNDLpUWHOPH]pVH««««««
(OPpOHWLPHJN|]HOtWpVHN
,URGDOPLiWWHNLQWpV««««««««««««««««««««««
1HPSRODUL]iOKDWyGLSROiULVIOXLGXPRNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiViQDNV]iPtWiVDD
.LUNZRRGHJ\HQOHWDODSMiQ.LUNZRRGIDNWRU~W««««««««««
1HPSRODUL]iOKDWyGLSROiULVIOXLGXPRNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiViQDNV]iPtWiVD
V]DEDGHQHUJLDDODSMiQ6]DEDGHQHUJLD~W«««««««««««««
6]HPLHPSLULNXVPyGV]HUSRODUL]iOKDWyIOXLGXPRNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiViQDN
V]iPtWiViUD«««««««««««««««««««««««««
$SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWNLWHUMHV]WpVHHOHJ\HNUH««««««««««««
5HQRUPiOWSHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW««««««««««««««««««
0RQWH&DUORV]LPXOiFLyN
$0RQWH&DUORPyGV]HUDODSMDL««««««««««««««««««
3RODUL]iOKDWyPROHNXOiN0RQWH&DUORV]LPXOiFLyMD«««««««««
3RODUL]iOKDWyIOXLGXPRNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVD««««««««««««
$SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWLHUHGPpQ\HN|VV]HKDVRQOtWiVDNtVpUOHWLDGDWRNNDO
$VV]RFLDWtYpVQHPDVV]RFLDWtYIRO\DGpNRNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVD«««««
.DUERQLOYHJ\OHWHNDSROiULVROGyV]HUUHODONRWRWWHOHJ\HLQHNUHODWtY
SHUPLWWLYLWiViUDNDSRWWHUHGPpQ\HLQN«««««««««««««««
.LHJpV]tW PpUpVHN«««««««««««««««««««««««
$QL]RWUySIRO\DGpNNULVWiO\RVYHJ\OHWHNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVD
2ULHQWiFLyVpVKHO\]HWLUHQGH]HWWVpJIRO\DGpNNULVWiO\RNEDQ«««««««
)RO\DGpNNULVWiO\RNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVD««««««««««««««
gVV]HIRJODOiV«««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
,URGDORPMHJ\]pN««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
.|V]|QHWQ\LOYiQtWiV««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
)JJHOpN«««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
-HO|OpVHNpVU|YLGtWpVHNMHJ\]pNH
-HO|OpVHN
D SRODUL]iOKDWyViJ
E UHFLSURNK PpUVpNOHWE N7
G W|PHJV U VpJ
' GLHOHNWURPRVHOWROiVYHNWRUD ( HOHNWURPRVWpUHU VVpJNOV WpU ( HOHNWURPRVWpUHU VVpJ0D[ZHOOWpU
H UHDNFLyWpUJHRPHWULiEDQDPLQWiWN|UOYHY GLHOHNWULNXPUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVD H UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVGLHOHNWURPRViOODQGy
H
' GLHOHNWURPRVDQL]RWUySLD
H /HQQDUG-RQHVHQHUJLDSDUDPpWHU
H QDJ\IUHNYHQFLiVGLHOHNWURPRViOODQGy ) /RUHQW]IpOHEHOV WpU
I HJ\UpV]HFVNHV]DEDGHQHUJLD ) LQWHUPROHNXOiULVSiUSRWHQFLiO
J .LUNZRRGIpOHJIDNWRU J SiUNRUUHOiFLyVIJJYpQ\
N %ROW]PDQQiOODQGy 0 WHOMHVGLSyOXVPRPHQWXP 0 PROiULVW|PHJ
P SHUPDQHQVGLSyOXVPRPHQWXP
Q NpWUpV]HFVNpW|VV]HN|W YHNWRULUiQ\iEDPXWDWyHJ\VpJYHNWRUYDJ\GLUHNWRU Q EHOV W|UpVPXWDWy
Q 1D'YRQDOiQPpUWW|UpVPXWDWy 1 UpV]HFVNHV]iP
3 SRODUL]iFLy 4 iOODSRW|VV]HJ
U
U W|OWpVHORV]OiV U V]iPV U VpJ
U D]LHGLNUpV]HFVNHKHO\YHNWRUD
U D]LHGLNUpV]HFVNpW ODMHGLNKH]PXWDWyYHNWRU
U
U NpWUpV]HFVNHN|]|WWLWiYROViJ
V /-WiYROViJSDUDPpWHUYDJ\PROHNXODiWPpU 8 EHOV HQHUJLD
7 K PpUVpNOHW 9 WpUIRJDW
\ GLSyOXVHU VVpJIJJYpQ\
D]LHGLNPROHNXODRULHQWiFLyMD
5|YLGtWpVHN
'+6 GLSROiULVPHUHYJ|PEGLSRODUKDUGVSKHUH +6 PHUHYJ|PEKDUGVSKHUH
/- /HQQDUG-RQHV
0& 0RQWH&DUOR 0' PROHNXODGLQDPLND
3'+6 SRODUL]iOKDWyGLSROiULVPHUHYJ|PESRODUL]DEOHGLSRODUKDUGVSKHUH 3670 SRODUL]iOKDWy6WRFNPD\HU
37 SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWSHUWXUEDWLRQWKHRU\
5) UHDNFLyWpUUHDFWLRQILHOG
537 UHQRUPiOWSHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWUHQRUPDOL]HGSHUWXUEDWLRQWKHRU\
670 6WRFNPD\HU
5HGXNiOWPHQQ\LVpJHN
UV
U UHGXNiOWV U VpJ
V D
D UHGXNiOWSRODUL]iOKDWyViJ
H E7
UHGXNiOWK PpUVpNOHW6703670
V
H P
P UHGXNiOWGLSyOXVPRPHQWXP6703670
V E P
P UHGXNiOWGLSyOXVPRPHQWXP'+63'+6
!"
1 8
X H
#
UHGXNiOWEHOV HQHUJLD6703670 1
8
X
$
E UHGXNiOWEHOV HQHUJLD'+63'+6
(O V]y
$] L]RWUyS pV DQL]RWUyS IOXLGXPRN UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiViQDN YL]VJiODWiUD KiURP DODSYHW PyGV]HU iOO D NXWDWyN UHQGHONH]pVpUH D NtVpUOHW D] HOPpOHW pV D V]LPXOiFLy (J\
UHiOLV UHQGV]HUU O PRGHOOW DONRWXQN DPLW HOPpOHWL pV V]LPXOiFLyV PyGV]HUHNNHO WDQXOPiQ\R]KDWXQN $] HOPpOHWL PyGV]HUHN J\DNUDQ N|]HOtWpVHNHW pV HOKDQ\DJROiVRNDW WDUWDOPD]QDN $ V]LPXOiFLyN D] DGRWW PRGHOOUH HJ]DNW HUHGPpQ\HNHW V]ROJiOWDWQDN tJ\ HJ\
HOPpOHW YL]VJiODWD WHV]WHOpVH V]HPSRQWMiEyO D V]LPXOiFLyV DGDWRN ÄNtVpUOHWL´ DGDWRNQDN WHNLQWKHW N$PRGHOOWHV]WHOpVpUHDNNRUQ\tOLNOHKHW VpJKDDYDOyViJJDOKDVRQOtWMXN|VV]HD V]LPXOiFLyVHUHGPpQ\HNHW$NtVpUOHWKH]NpSHVWDV]LPXOiFLyND]HOPpOHWV]HUHSpWW|OWLNEH$
IHQWLHNHW$OOHQpV7LOGHVHO\N|Q\YpE OYHWWIRO\DPDWiEUDV]HPOpOWHWL>@
%'&)(+*-,/.1032-,
425(763&)8)9;:-25: <
2583=;(;(>:39?,/@;ACB79?, 425(763&)8)9;:
<
2583=;(;(
:3AD,E9;F?(;=+B ,/@;G
<IH (7.1J+GC*
%39+0K@;9?,E=
%39+0K@;9?,E=
=;(
<
9;(;=>B;G
:-LK@;=;(;ACB;9?,
:3AD,E9;F?(;=+B7G
=;F?=;8
<
9M-6)=;:
=+0K@7&):)BN=;F?=;8
<
9OM-6-=;:
=+0K@7&):)BN=;F?=;8
<
9OM-6-=;:
& <
2583=;(>(;F?=
=;(
<
9;(;=>B;G
PQ*-,E(7&-B>2':
L-,R,/@;=;S'&T,2UMV(;ACB.W, L-,R,/@;=;S'&T,2UMV(;ACB.W,
& <
2583=;(>(
B7=?,/@>B7PD=
&3@N=;(
<
9>(;=>B
B7=?,/@>B7PD=
iEUD
$NtVpUOHWLD]HOPpOHWLpVDV]LPXOiFLyVPyGV]HUHNN|]|WWLNDSFVRODWV]HPOpOWHWpVH>@
$ PDNURV]NRSLNXV pV PLNURV]NRSLNXV WXODMGRQViJRN N|]|WWL NDSFVRODWRN IHOGHUtWpVH D VWDWLV]WLNXV PHFKDQLND DODSYHW IHODGDWD $ VWDWLV]WLNXV WHUPRGLQDPLND D N|OFV|QKDWiVL SRWHQFLiO LVPHUHWpEHQ KDWiUR]]D PHJ D UHQGV]HU PDNURV]NRSLNXV WHUPRGLQDPLNDL WXODMGRQViJDLW$]LQWHUPROHNXOiULVSRWHQFLiORNPHJKDWiUR]iVDPHJOHKHW VHQERQ\ROXOWH]pUW HJ\V]HU EE PRGHOOSRWHQFLiORN EHYH]HWpVH D FpOV]HU tJ\ D YRQ]y pV WDV]tWy SRWHQFLiOMiUXOpNRN NO|QNO|Q pV HJ\PiVWyO IJJHWOHQO LV YL]VJiOKDWyDN $]
LQWHUPROHNXOiULVN|OFV|QKDWiVRNUyOD]IHMH]HWQ\~MWiWWHNLQWpVW
6]WDWLNXVGLHOHNWURPRVWXODMGRQViJRNUyODNNRUEHV]pOQNKDDGLHOHNWULNXPHJ\HQV~O\EDQ YDQ D Ui KDWy HOHNWURPRV HU WpUUHO $ UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV HOWHUMHGW PpJ D V]WDWLNXV GLHOHNWURPRV iOODQGy PHJQHYH]pV LV pUWHOPH]pVpW D NODVV]LNXV HOPpOHWHNNHO HJ\WW D IHMH]HWEHQLVPHUWHWMNNO|QE|] Qp] SRQWRNEyO
$ GLVV]HUWiFLy HJ\LN FpOMD KRJ\ HJ\V]HU PRGHOOHN DONDOPD]iViYDO NO|QE|]
SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWL PyGV]HUHN IHOKDV]QiOiViYDO PHJEHFVOMN D UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiVW $]
DONDOPD]RWW PRGHOOHN D GLSROiULV PHUHYJ|PE '+6 D SRODUL]iOKDWy GLSROiULV PHUHYJ|PE 3'+6 D 6WRFNPD\HU 670 pV D SRODUL]iOKDWy 6WRFNPD\HU 3670 IOXLGXP $] HOPpOHWL PHJN|]HOtWpVHNHW D IHMH]HW WDUWDOPD]]D DKRO HO V]|U D QHP SRODUL]iOKDWy UHQGV]HUHNHW YL]VJiOMXN
$ SRODUL]iOKDWyViJ ILJ\HOHPEH YpWHOpUH NpWIpOH PHJN|]HOtWpVW MDYDVROXQN (OV NpQW V]HPLHPSLULNXV PyGV]HUQNHW PXWDWMXN EH DKRO D PROHNXOiN SRODUL]iOKDWyViJiW LPSOLFLW PyGRQ D W|UpVPXWDWy EHYH]HWpVpYHO YHVV]N ILJ\HOHPEH $] HOPpOHWHW NLWHUMHV]WHWWN HOHJ\HNUHLV
$ PROHNXOiULV SRODUL]iOKDWyViJ PROHNXOiULV V]LQWHQ LV EHpStWKHW D PRGHOOEH GH H]
PHJQHKH]tWL D SUREOpPD VWDWLV]WLNXV PHFKDQLNDL NH]HOpVW PHUW D] LQWHUPROHNXOiULV N|OFV|QKDWiV D WRYiEELDNEDQ PiU QHP DGGLWtY 3RODUL]iOKDWy IOXLGXPRN HVHWpQ D] ~Q UHQRUPiOWSHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWVHJtWVpJpYHOEHFVOMNPHJDUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVW
$ SRODUL]iOKDWy IOXLGXPRN V]LV]WHPDWLNXV 0RQWH &DUOR V]LPXOiFLyMD W|EE V]HPSRQWEyO LV pUGHNHVQHN tJpUNH]HWW (J\UpV]W D] RO\DQ HJ\V]HU PRGHOOHN PLQW D 3'+6 pV 3670 UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiViQDN V]LV]WHPDWLNXV YL]VJiODWD PpJ QHP W|UWpQW PHJ PiVUpV]W D SRODUL]iOKDWy IOXLGXPRNUDNLIHMOHV]WHWWHOPpOHWQNHWLVWHV]WHOKHWMN
$ UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV HOPpOHWL PHJN|]HOtWpVHL XWiQ IHOPHUOW D NpUGpV KRJ\ D] HJ\HV HOPpOHWHN NpSHVHNH UHSURGXNiOQL YDOyV DQ\DJRN NtVpUOHWLOHJ PHJKDWiUR]RWW UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiVDLW
$VV]RFLDWtY pV QHP DVV]RFLDWtY L]RWUyS IRO\DGpNRN HVHWpQ D] HJ\HV HOPpOHWL PyGV]HUHN DODSMiQPHJKDWiUR]RWWUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVRNDWNtVpUOHWLDGDWRNNDOKDVRQOtWMXN|VV]H
0HJPXWDWMXN WRYiEEi KRJ\ D] iOWDOXQN EHYH]HWHWW V]HPLHPSLULNXV PyGV]HU VHJtWVpJpYHO EHFVOW UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiVRN MyO N|]HOtWLN D NDUERQLOYHJ\OHWHN DSROiULV ROGyV]HUUHO DONRWRWW HOHJ\HLQHNNtVpUOHWL~WRQPHJKDWiUR]RWWUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVDLW
$ GROJR]DW HJ\ PiVLN FpONLW ]pVH D IRO\DGpNNULVWiO\RN DPHO\HNHW DQL]RWUyS IOXLGXPQDN WHNLQWKHWQN GLHOHNWURPRV WXODMGRQViJDLQDN YL]VJiODWD NtVpUOHWL ~WRQ $ NtVpUOHWL PXQND D PHJIHOHO PyGV]HU pV HV]N|]|N NLYiODV]WiViYDO HVHWHQNpQW IHMOHV]WpVpYHO NH]G GLN
$] iOWDOXQN YL]VJiOQL NtYiQW IRO\DGpNNULVWiO\RN Ii]LViWPHQHWHL QDJ\ K PpUVpNOHWHQ MHOHQWNH]QHN tJ\ D] HOV GOHJHV FpOXQN RO\DQ PpUpVL HOMiUiV pV FHOOD NLIHMOHV]WpVH YROW DPHO\
DONDOPDV D X & IHOHWWL PpUpVHNUH LV 0XQNiQN VRUiQ QpKiQ\ DVV]RFLDWtY IRO\DGpNNULVWiO\
UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVDLWKDWiUR]WXNPHJ
$GROJR]DWRWD]HUHGPpQ\HNWp]LVV]HU |VV]HIRJODOiVD]iUMD
$]LQWHUPROHNXOiULVN|OFV|QKDWiVRN
$ VWDWLV]WLNXV PHFKDQLNDL PyGV]HUHN DONDOPD]iVD V]HPSRQWMiEyO HOHQJHGKHWHWOHQ D]
LQWHUPROHNXOiULV N|OFV|QKDWiVRN LVPHUHWH H]pUW D WRYiEELDNEDQ HUU O V]HUHWQpQN HJ\ U|YLG iWWHNLQWpVW DGQL (J\ WHUPRGLQDPLNDL UHQGV]HUW MHOOHP] NRQILJXUiFLyV PHQQ\LVpJHN PHJKDWiUR]iViKR] V]NVpJQN YDQ D] LQWHUPROHNXOiULV SRWHQFLiO LVPHUHWpUH (QQHN PHJKDWiUR]iVDD]RQEDQPHJOHKHW VHQQHKp]IHODGDW
$] LQWHUPROHNXOiULV SRWHQFLiORN V]iPtWiViUD W|EE PyGV]HU LV OpWH]LN D NpW OHJHOWHUMHGWHEEH]HNN|]O
.YDQWXPPHFKDQLNDL V]iPtWiVRNDW YpJH]QHN D] HJ\PiVKR] NpSHVW
UZ[Y Z Y KHO\]HWEHQ OHY NO|QiOOy SiURN QDJ\ V]iP~ NRQILJXUiFLyMiUD pV D] HUHGPpQ\HNUH DQDOLWLNXV IJJYpQ\HNHWLOOHV]WHQHN(]D]RQEDQPHJOHKHW VHQV]iPROiVLJpQ\HVIHODGDW*\DNRULEE pV HJ\V]HU EE D] HPSLULNXV PRGHOOSRWHQFLiORN DONDOPD]iVD (]HN D SRWHQFLiORN N|]HOtW IJJYpQ\HN PHO\HN D N|OFV|QKDWiVEDQ UpV]WYHY PROHNXOiNUD MHOOHP]
SDUDPpWHUHNHW WDUWDOPD]QDN $ SDUDPpWHUHNHW NtVpUOHWL DGDWRNKR] YDOy LOOHV]WpVVHO KDWiUR]]iN PHJ(]OHKHWVSHNWURV]NySLDLWUDQV]SRUWYDJ\Ii]LVHJ\HQV~O\LWXODMGRQViJRNUDYDOyLOOHV]WpV 0LQpO W|EE SDUDPpWHUW WDUWDOPD] HJ\ PRGHOO DQQiO SRQWRVDEEDQ OHtUKDWy D] DGRWW IOXLGXPYLVHONHGpVH$SDUDPpWHUHNV]iPiQDNQ|YHOpVpYHOD]RQEDQDV]iPtWiVLLG Q|YHNV]LN PHJ MHOHQW VHQ pV tJ\ D PRGHOOHN NH]HOKHW VpJH QDJ\PpUWpNEHQ OHFV|NNHQKHW (J\UH ERQ\ROXOWDEE PRGHOOSRWHQFLiORN DONDOPD]iViYDO N|]HOHEE MXWKDWXQN HJ\ DGRWW DQ\DJ OHtUiViKR] GH H] yKDWDWODQXO HJ\WW MiU D] iOWDOiQRVViJ EL]RQ\RV IRN~ HOYHV]WpVpYHO (J\
HJ\V]HU EE PRGHOOSRWHQFLiO D]D] NHYpV SDUDPpWHUW WDUWDOPD]y PDWHPDWLNDLODJ HJ\V]HU DODN~ GH IL]LNDL DODSRNRQ Q\XJYy SRWHQFLiO DONDOPDV OHKHW HJ\ DQ\DJFVRSRUW HJ\WWHV MHOOHP]pVUH
$] LQWHUPROHNXOiULV N|OFV|QKDWiVRNQDN D N|YHWNH] DODSYHW WtSXVDLW NO|QE|]WHWKHWMNPHJ>@
$ WDV]tWy N|OFV|QKDWiV RND D 3DXOLIpOH WLODOPL HOYEHQ NHUHVHQG $] DWRPRN pV PROHNXOiNHOHNWURQIHOK LQHNWpUEHOLiWIHGpVHWDV]tWiVWHUHGPpQ\H]
$SROiULV HOHNWURPRV GLSyOXVVDO QHP UHQGHONH] PROHNXOiN N|]|WW OpSQHN IHO D] ~Q GLV]SHU]LyV N|OFV|QKDWiVRN (]HN RO\DQ U|YLG KDWyWiYROViJ~ YRQ]y MHOOHJ N|OFV|QKDWiVRN DPHO\HN D] HOHNWURQIHOK N IOXNWXiFLyMD PLDWW NLDODNXOy SLOODQDWQ\L GLSyOXVRNN|]|WWLN|OFV|QKDWiVRNLG iWODJDNpQWiOOQDNHO
(J\ PROHNXOD DNiU DSROiULV DNiU SROiULV W|OWpVHORV]OiVD NOV WpU LOOHWYH HJ\ PiVLN PROHNXODPXOWLSyOXViQDNKDWiViUDWRU]XOKDWD]D]DPROHNXOiQGLSyOXVPRPHQWXPYDJ\
PDJDVDEE UHQG PXOWLSyOXV LQGXNiOyGKDW $] tJ\ NLDODNXOW LQGXNiOW PXOWLSyOXVRN UpV]YpWHOpYHO NLDODNXOy N|OFV|QKDWiVRNDW SRODUL]iFLyV YDJ\ LQGXNFLyV N|OFV|QKDWiVRNQDNQHYH]]N
$PHQQ\LEHQ D PROHNXOD DV]LPPHWULNXV W|OWpVHOUHQGH]pV DNNRU D PROHNXOiN N|]|WW N|]YHWOHQ HOHNWURV]WDWLNXV N|OFV|QKDWiVRN OpSQHN IHO $ PROHNXOiN W|OWpVHORV]OiViW D PXOWLSyOXVVRUIHMWpVVHOV]RNiVpUWHOPH]QL(V]HULQWIHOOpSKHWQHNW|OWpVHNN|]|WWLLRQRN HVHWpQ &RXORPE N|OFV|QKDWiVRN SHUPDQHQV GLSyOXVRN SROiURV PROHNXOiN HVHWpQ N|]|WWLN|OFV|QKDWiVRNYDODPLQWDPDJDVDEEUHQG PXOWLSyOXVN|OFV|QKDWiVRN
6SHFLILNXVN|OFV|QKDWiVRNHUHGPpQ\H]LND]DVV]RFLiFLyWpVDNRPSOH[NpS] GpVW(]HN D NpPLDL N|WpVHNQpO NLVHEE HQHUJLiM~ U|YLG pV N|]HSHV KDWyWiYROViJ~ ~Q PDUDGpN YHJ\pUWpN N|OFV|QKDWiVRN $ KLGURJpQKtG N|WpV pV D W|OWpViWYLWHOL N|OFV|QKDWiVRN D OHJMHOOHP] EESpOGiL
$] HJ\HV SRQWRN N|]|WW iWIHGpVHN YDQQDN DPHO\QHN D] DODSYHW RND D]
LQWHUPROHNXOiULV N|OFV|QKDWiVRN HOHNWURPiJQHVHV MHOOHJpEHQ NHUHVHQG 9L]VJiOMXN PHJ D]
HJ\HV LQWHUPROHNXOiULV N|OFV|QKDWiVRN KDWyWiYROViJiW $ WDV]tWiV N|]HOL KDWiV tJ\ D] HVHWHN W|EEVpJpEHQ QHP HJ\ WHOMHV PROHNXOiKR] N|W GLN KDQHP D PROHNXOiN HJ\HV UpV]HL N|]|WW pUWHOPH]KHW $WDV]tWyN|OFV|QKDWiVLHQHUJLDH[SRQHQFLiOLVDQFV|NNHQDWiYROViJJDO
.|]YHWOHQHOHNWURV]WDWLNXVN|OFV|QKDWiVRNH]HQDDVpVHVSRQWRNDWpUWMNHVHWpQ NpW PROHNXOD HOHNWURV]WDWLNXV N|OFV|QKDWiVDNRU D GLSyOXVGLSyOXV N|OFV|QKDWiV PHOOHWW GLSyOXVNYDGUXSyOXV NYDGUXSyOXVNYDGUXSyOXV pV HJ\pE PDJDVDEE UHQG N|OFV|QKDWiVRN LV V]HUHSHOQHN $] HJ\HV WDJRN NO|QE|] QDJ\ViJ~DN pV D WiYROViJ UHFLSURNiQDN NO|QE|]
KDWYiQ\DL V]HULQW FV|NNHQHN 3RQWW|OWpVHN SS HVHWpQ D &RXORPE W|UYpQ\QHN PHJIHOHO HQ D]
HQHUJLDDUHFLSURNWiYROViJJDOSHUPDQHQVGLSyOXVpVSRQWW|OWpVS'N|OFV|QKDWiVLHQHUJLiMDD UHFLSURN WiYROViJ QpJ\]HWpYHO FV|NNHQ $ GLSyOXVGLSyOXV '' N|OFV|QKDWiV N|E|VHQ D GLSyOXVNYDGUXSyOXV '4 N|OFV|QKDWiV QHJ\HGLN D NYDGUXSyOXVNYDGUXSyOXV 44 N|OFV|QKDWiVDWiYROViJ|W|GLNKDWYiQ\iQDNUHFLSURNDV]HULQWWDUW]pUXVKR]
\
]
^
_
| )
U
$ U
$ U
$ U
$ U
$ U
`7`
a `
a7a b a
bcb
dQefgDh[i
jlkjmgDenoDip[e
DKROD]$SDUDPpWHUIJJDPXOWLSyOXVRNQDJ\ViJiWyOpVDPROHNXOiNHJ\PiVKR]YLV]RQ\tWRWW N|OFV|Q|V KHO\]HWpW O YDODPLQW LQGXNiOW GLSyOXVRN N|OFV|QKDWiVD HVHWpQ D PROHNXOD
SRODUL]iOKDWyViJiWyO LV >@ 'LV]SHU]LyV N|OFV|QKDWiVRN HVHWpQ RO\DQ KDWYiQ\VRUW NDSXQN DPHO\EHQDUHFLSURNWiYROViJSiURVKDWYiQ\DLV]HUHSHOQHNpVD]HOV WDJDKDWRGLNKDWYiQ\
$]~QW|EEWHVWN|OFV|QKDWiVRND]D]NHWW QpOW|EEPROHNXODN|]|WWLHJ\LGHM KDWiVRN LV MHOHQW V V]HUHSHW NDSQDN $ N|OFV|QKDWiVL HQHUJLD D UHQGV]HUW DONRWy |VV]HV PROHNXOD N|OFV|QKDWiVDNpQW M|Q OpWUH (]W HOV N|]HOtWpVEHQ D PROHNXODSiURN N|]WL N|OFV|QKDWiVRN
|VV]HJpYHODGKDWMXNPHJ
¦)
| ) qr
s sr
(]W D N|]HOtWpVW SiURQNpQWL DGGLWLYLWiVQDN KtYMXN pV J\DNUDQ DONDOPD]]XN +iURP PROHNXOD N|]|WWRO\DQN|OFV|QKDWiVRNLVOpWUHM|KHWQHNDPHO\HNSiURQNpQWQHPDGGLWtYDN
wt wu tvu
wtvu
wtvu {) ) ) )
')
$WHOMHVHQHUJLDDSiUHQHUJLiNpVDPHJIHOHO W|EEOHWHN|VV]HJHNpQWtUKDWyIHO
¦ ')
¦ ')
¦) {
) x x x x x x y
z
{
| |{ z y
z
{
| |{ z
{
|
|{
z
6]LJRU~DQYpYHDSiURQNpQWLDGGLWLYLWiVHU VN|]HOtWpVDSiUSRWHQFLiORNSDUDPpWHUHLD]RQEDQ UpV]EHQ WDUWDOPD]]iN D PDJDVDEEUHQG N|OFV|QKDWiVRN MiUXOpNiW LV H]pUW H]HNHW D SiUSRWHQFLiORNDWVRNV]RUHIIHNWtYSiUSRWHQFLiORNQDNLVQHYH]]N
$ GLVV]HUWiFLyEDQ DONDOPD]RWW PRGHOOSRWHQFLiORN D] LURGDORPEDQ UHQGNtYO HOWHUMHGWHN PHJOHKHW VHQ HJ\V]HU HN pV NHYpV SDUDPpWHUW WDUWDOPD]QDN $ N|YHWNH] NEHQ iWWHNLQWpVWV]HUHWQpQNDGQLD]HJ\V]HU EESRWHQFLiOPRGHOOHNU O
$ PHUHYJ|PE +6 SRWHQFLiO HVHWpEHQ QLQFV YRQ]y N|OFV|QKDWiV D PROHNXOD PHUHY IDO~ GLQDPLNDL V]HPSRQWEyO D PROHNXOiN UXJDOPDVDQ WN|] V iWPpU M JRO\yNNpQW YLVHONHGQHN $] HJ\V]HU FHQWUiOLV SRWHQFLiORN QDJ\ VHJtWVpJHW Q\~MWDQDN D SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWL V]iPtWiVRNQiO 0XQNiQN VRUiQ D PHUHYJ|PE SRWHQFLiOW J\DNUDQ DONDOPD]]XNUHIHUHQFLDUHQGV]HUNpQW$PHUHYJ|PESRWHQFLiOPDWHPDWLNDLDODNMDDN|YHWNH]
°¯
°
®
t f
)
V V U KD
U KD U
}'~
(J\ |VV]HWHWW PRGHOOSRWHQFLiO IHOpStWpVHNRU D SRWHQFLiO IHORV]WKDWy HJ\ YRQ]y pV HJ\
WDV]tWy|VV]HWHY UH$]iOWDOiQRV%XFNLQJKDPSRWHQFLiODODNMDDN|YHWNH]
Q
c
%H )
)
DKRODYRQ]yWDJ J|PEV]LPPHWULNXVpVWDUWDOPD]]DDU|YLGWiY~GLV]SHU]LyVN|OFV|QKDWiVWLV
$WDV]tWyWDJRWHJ\H[SRQHQFLiOLVNLIHMH]pVVHOtUMDOH
+D D YRQ]y pV D WDV]tWy WDJRW KDWYiQ\IJJYpQQ\HO N|]HOtWMN D 0LHIpOH SRWHQFLiOKR]
MXWXQN
$U%U
)
(]DSRWHQFLiOIRO\WRQRVDPROHNXOiNDWQHPWHNLQWLPHUHYW|U]V QHNpViOODQGyiWPpU M QHN tJ\ UHiOLVDEEDQ tUMD OH D]RN N|OFV|QKDWiViW $ WDV]tWy WDJ NLWHY MH NO|QE|]
PROHNXODSiURNQiO pV N|]|WW YiOWR]LN PtJ D YRQ]y WDJp DSROiULV PROHNXOiN HVHWpQ OHJW|EEV]|U
$ 0LHIpOH SRWHQFLiO HJ\ VSHFLiOLV HVHWH D /HQQDUG-RQHV /-SRWHQFLiO $NpWNLWHY NHGYH] YLV]RQ\D PLDWW N|QQ\HQ NH]HOKHW D /- SRWHQFLiO $ J\DNRUODWL DONDOPD]iVRN VRUiQD/-SRWHQFLiOWFpOV]HU EEDN|YHWNH] DODNEDQIHOtUQL
»
»
¼ º
«
«
¬ ª
¸
¹
¨ ·
© §
¸
¹
¨ ·
© ) §
[
U U
U
V
H V
DKROV pVH D SRWHQFLiO SDUDPpWHUHL $ GLSyOXVGLSyOXV N|OFV|QKDWiV D N|YHWNH] PyGRQ tUKDWyIHO
> @
[
[
U
K
Q Q Q Q Q
U Q
) P
DKRO U[ D]U U U YHNWRU DEV]RO~W pUWpNHQ D]LLN PROHNXOD GLSyOXViQDN LUiQ\iEDQ
YHWW HJ\VpJYHNWRU Q D] U[ YHNWRU LUiQ\iEDQ YHWW HJ\VpJYHNWRU P SHGLJ D GLSyOXVPRPHQWXP +D D PHUHYJ|PE SRWHQFLiOW NLHJpV]tWMN D GLSyOXVGLSyOXV SRWHQFLiOODO D GLSROiULVPHUHYJ|PE'+6SRWHQFLiOWNDSMXN
7
+
7+ ) )
)
$PHQQ\LEHQ D /- SRWHQFLiOW HJpV]tWMN NL D GLSyOXVGLSyOXV N|OFV|QKDWiV SRWHQFLiOMiYDOD]~Q6WRFNPD\HU670SRWHQFLiOKR]MXWXQN
¡7¡
¢£
¤v¥¦ ) )
)
$] HGGLJ LVPHUWHWHWW PRGHOOSRWHQFLiORN N|]|V YRQiVD D SiURQNpQWL DGGLWLYLWiV 9L]VJiOMXNPRVWPHJDSRODUL]iOKDWyIOXLGXPRNHVHWpW7HNLQWVQNHJ\RO\DQUHQGV]HUWDPHO\
SRODUL]iOKDWy SRQWV]HU GLSyOXVRNDW WDUWDOPD] $ N|]|WWN OHY N|OFV|QKDWiV QHP DGGLWtY D]
LGLN PROHNXOD HOPR]JDWiViYDO DM pVN PROHNXOiN N|]|WW KDWy HQHUJLD V]LQWpQ YiOWR]LN (J\
LO\HQUHQGV]HUWHOMHVHQHUJLiMDKiURPUpV]UHRV]WKDWy
§
§ ¨©/ª
«>¬Ql®
l¬¯ ) )
)
)
$QHPHOHNWURV]WDWLNXVUHIHUHQFLDUHQGV]HUSRWHQFLiOMDOHKHW+6YDJ\ /-SRWHQFLiOD]
HOHNWURV]WDWLNXVHQHUJLDDSHUPDQHQVGLSyOXVRNN|OFV|QKDWiViQDN
¦
¦ ¦
) ±T² ° ² ± ± ±
±²
±
³>´Qµ[¶ · ·
¸ ··
¹
7 (
pVD]LQGXNFLyVHQHUJLiQDN
¦
¦ ¦
º) »
»
»
»¼Q½
»¿¾
¾
»¾
»
»¼Q½
»¼Q½ À
Á À
Â
7 (
D]|VV]HJHNpQWDGKDWyPHJDKRO
Ä ÃpV ÅÆEÇ Å D]LGLNPROHNXODSHUPDQHQVpVD]LQGXNiOW GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPDYDODPLQW
¦ÈOÉ
Ê Ê
ÉÊ
É Ë
Ë
7
(
D] LHGLN PROHNXOD KHO\pQ D SHUPDQHQV GLSyOXVRN iOWDO NHOWHWW HOHNWURPRV WpU DKRO D]
HOHNWURV]WDWLNXVWHQ]RUDN|YHWNH] PyGRQDGKDWyPHJ
¸
¸
¹
·
¨
¨
©
§
Ì
Í
ÎÏ ÎÏ
ÎÏ
ÎÏÎÏ
ÎÏ
U U
U U 7
G
DKROGÐÑ D.URQHFNHUV]LPEyOXP$]LHGLNPROHNXODKHO\pQD]LQGXNiOWGLSyOXVRNiOWDONHOWHWW
HOHNWURPRVWpU
¦ÒOÓ
Ô Ô
ÓÕ/Ö
ÓÔ
Ó
ÓÕ/Ö
7
(
$]LHGLN PROHNXOD LQGXNiOW GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPD D PROHNXOiUD KDWy WpUHU VVpJHN |VV]HJpYHO DUiQ\RV D] DUiQ\RVViJL WpQ\H] D SRODUL]iOKDWyViJ D DPHO\U O D GROJR]DWEDQ IHOWHVV]N KRJ\VNDOiULVPHQQ\LVpJYDJ\LVD]LQGXNiOWGLSyOXVPRPHQWXPDWpUHU VVpJLUiQ\iEDPXWDW
×Ø/Ù × D>
(Ú × (×Ø/Ù ×@
$ IHQWL NpW HJ\HQOHW pV HJ\HQOHWHN HJ\ |QNRQ]LV]WHQV LWHUiFLyV HOMiUiVW DG
×Ø/Ù × NLV]iPtWiViUD7HNLQWVQNPRVWHJ\GLSROiULVPHUHYJ|PE'+6HOHJ\HWDKRONpWDpVEWtSXV~
PROHNXODN|]|WWLLQWHUPROHNXOiULVSRWHQFLiODIHQWLHNpUWHOPpEHQNpWUpV]UHRV]WKDWy
°¯
°
®
t f
) ÛcÜ
ÛcÜ
ÛcÜ
V V
ÝmÞ ÝmÞ
ÝmÞ
U KD
U KD U
ß+à
DPHUHYJ|PESRWHQFLiOpV
> @
á
âmã
ã
â
ã
â
ã
â
âmã
U U
ä7ä
Q Q Q Q Q
Q
)
å
æ
æå PP
D SRQWV]HU GLSyOXVGLSyOXV N|OFV|QKDWiVL SRWHQFLiO $] HJ\HQOHWEHQ
ç
è
è ç
V V
V DKRO Vé pV
ê
V D PHUHYJ|PEiWPpU N Pë pV P
ì
D PHJIHOHO GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPRN
$UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVpUWHOPH]pVH
$UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVIHQRPHQROyJLDLV]iUPD]WDWiVD
9DODPHO\U U W|OWpVHORV]OiVEyOV]iUPD]y(U HOHNWURPRVWpUHU VVpJD],0D[ZHOO HJ\HQOHWDODSMiQV]iUPD]WDWKDWy
U U
( SU
(] D] HJ\HQOHW YiNXXPEDQ pUYpQ\HV DKRO D] iOWDOXQN YL]VJiOW DQ\DJL UHQGV]HUEHQ MHOHQOHY |VV]HV W|OWpVW EHOHIRJODOMXN D U U W|OWpVHORV]OiVED $] HJ\HQOHW PHJROGiVD VRN UpV]HFVNpW WDUWDOPD]y UHQGV]HU HVHWpEHQ J\DNRUODWLODJ OHKHWHWOHQ GH QHP LV V]NVpJHV PHUW PLQNHW FVDN D QDJ\V]iP~ UHQGH]HWOHQ K PR]JiVW YpJ] PROHNXOiNWyO HUHG KDWiVRN iWODJD pUGHNHO
(] D]W MHOHQWL KRJ\ D PLQWiEDQ KDWy SLOODQDWQ\L HOHNWURPRV WpUHU VVpJHNHW NLiWODJROKDWMXNPLNURV]NRSLNXVDQQDJ\GHPDNURV]NRSLNXVDQNLFVL'9WpUIRJDWRNUD$'9
QHNDPROHNXOiNWpUIRJDWiKR]NpSHVWQDJ\QDNDWHOMHVPLQWDWpUIRJDWiKR]NpSHVWNLFVLQHNNHOO OHQQLH $] iWODJROiV VHJtWVpJpYHO HJ\ PDNURV]NRSLNXV GH PpJ PLQGLJ KHO\IJJ WpUHU VVpJKH]MXWXQNDPLWV]RNiV0D[ZHOOWpUQHNLVQHYH]QL(í >@
)RQWRV OHV]|JH]QL KRJ\ PDNURV]NRSLNXV WpUUH XJ\DQFVDN pUYpQ\HV PiJQHVHV WpU KLiQ\iEDQD,,,0D[ZHOOHJ\HQOHW
u
(î
.OV WpUKDWiViUDHJ\GLHOHNWULNXPSRODUL]iOyGLND]D]W|OWpVV]pWYiOiVM|QEHQQHOpWUH
$W|OWpVV]pWYiOiVPROHNXOiULVpUWHOPH]pVpU ODN|YHWNH] IHMH]HWEHQOHV]V]y)HQRPHQROyJLDL V]LQWHQ HO V]|U HO NHOO G|QWHQL PHO\ W|OWpVHNHW NH]HOQN H[SOLFLWHQ D U U W|OWpVHORV]OiVRQ EHOO H]HNHW V]RNiV V]DEDG W|OWpVHNQHN LV QHYH]QL pV PHO\HN D]RN DPHO\HN KDWiViW NLiWODJROMXNÈOWDOiEDQYDODPHO\GLHOHNWULNXPRWDONRWyVHPOHJHVPROHNXOiNRQEHOOLSDUFLiOLV W|OWpVHNWDUWR]QDND]XWyEELFVRSRUWED$NO|QE|] PROHNXOiNEDQHOWpU OHKHWDNpWIpOHW|OWpV
HORV]OiVD +D D PROHNXOiEDQ D SR]LWtY pV QHJDWtY W|OWpVHN W|PHJN|]pSSRQWMD HJ\EH HVLN DSROiULVPROHNXOiNUyOEHV]pOQN+DDNpWIpOHW|OWpVV~O\SRQWMDQHPHVLNHJ\EHDNNRUSROiULV PROHNXOiUyO YDQ V]y 3ROiULV PROHNXOiN HVHWpQ D] HJ\PiVWyO DGRWW WiYROViJUD OHY W|OWpVHN SHUPDQHQVGLSyOXVPRPHQWXPRWRNR]QDN
(]HQPROHNXOiNSRODUL]iOyGiVDUpYpQHJ\
3
ïUð/ñ
U
SRODUL]iFLyVW|OWpVHORV]OiVM|QOpWUHDKRO
9
3 0
DSRODUL]iFLyYHNWRUDDPLDWpUIRJDWHJ\VpJUHHV QHWWyGLSyOXVPRPHQWXPQDNIHOHOPHJ$], 0D[ZHOOHJ\HQOHWEHQDNpWIpOHW|OWpVWV]pWYiODV]WYDpV(KHO\pEHD0D[ZHOOWHUHWtUYDD N|YHWNH] NLIHMH]pVWNDSMXN
3
U
(ò
S U UïUð/ñ S U
%HYH]HWYHDGLHOHNWURPRVHOWROiVYHNWRUiW
3 (
' ó S
D],0D[ZHOOHJ\HQOHWPDNURV]NRSLNXVGLHOHNWULNXPRNEDQpUYpQ\HVDODNMiKR]MXWXQN
SU
'
$ IHQWL HJ\HQOHW PHJROGiViKR] HJ\ UHOiFLyW NHOO WDOiOQXQN(ô pV3 N|]|WW 1HP W~OViJRVDQ HU VWHUHNHVHWpQIHOWpWHOH]KHWMNKRJ\DNDSFVRODWOLQHiULVD]D]
õ(
3 S H
DKROH D UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV (] iOWDOiQRV HVHWEHQ HJ\ WHQ]RU D]D] D3 SRODUL]iFLy LUiQ\D QHP IHOWpWOHQO HJ\H]LN PHJ (ô LUiQ\iYDO ,]RWUyS GLHOHNWULNXP HVHWpQ D] H VNDOiULV PHQQ\LVpJ $ UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV QDJ\ViJD D GLHOHNWULNXP SRODUL]iOKDWyViJiQDN PpUWpNpW O IJJpVD]DGRWWDQ\DJUDMHOOHP] MyOPHJKDWiUR]RWWDQ\DJLWXODMGRQViJ>@
$UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVPROHNXOiULVpUWHOPH]pVH
6]WDWLNXV GLHOHNWURPRV WXODMGRQViJRNUyO DNNRU EHV]pOQN KD D GLHOHNWULNXP HJ\HQV~O\EDQ YDQ D Ui KDWy HOHNWURPRV HU WpUUHO )RO\DGpNRN HVHWpQ D] HJ\HQV~O\L iOODSRW HOpUpVpKH] UHQGNtYO U|YLG LG WDUWDP V]NVpJHV H]pUW D] DODFVRQ\ IUHNYHQFLiQ PHJKDWiUR]RWW GLHOHNWURPRVWXODMGRQViJRNUHQGV]HULQWPHJHJ\H]QHNDV]WDWLNXVWXODMGRQViJRNNDO
9L]VJiOMXNPHJHOV NpQWDGLHOHNWURPRVSRODUL]iFLyMHOHQVpJpW$SROiULV PROHNXOiEDQ NpW KDWiVEyO HUHG D SRODUL]iOKDWyViJ (OHNWURQSRODUL]iFLyUyO DNNRU EHV]pOQN KD D] DWRP LOOHWYH PROHNXOD HOHNWURQEXUND HOWROyGLN D] DWRPPDJKR] NpSHVW DQpONO KRJ\ D PROHNXOiQ EHOOD]DWRPPDJRNHJ\PiVKR]YLV]RQ\tWRWWKHO\]HWHPHJYiOWR]QD$WRPLSRODUL]iFLyHVHWpQ D NOV HOHNWURPRV WpU KDWiViUD D PROHNXOiQ EHOO PHJYiOWR]LN D] DWRPRN HJ\PiVKR]
YLV]RQ\tWRWW WiYROViJD (]W D NpW SRODUL]iFLyIDMWiW HJ\WWHVHQ HOWROyGiVL SRODUL]iFLyQDN QHYH]]N
3ROiULVPROHNXOiNHVHWpQHJ\KDUPDGLNKDWiVLVQ|YHOLD]DQ\DJSRODUL]iOKDWyViJiWD]
LUiQ\tWiVLSRODUL]iFLy+DDPROHNXODSHUPDQHQVGLSyOXVPRPHQWXPPDOUHQGHONH]LNDNNRUD]
HOHNWURPRV WpU D GLSyOXVRNUD LUiQ\tWy KDWiVW IHMW NL D NOV HOHNWURPRV WpU LJ\HNV]LN D GLSyOXVRNDWDWpULUiQ\iEDUHQGH]QL
7HNLQWVN iW D UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiVUD YRQDWNR]y NODVV]LNXV HOPpOHWHNHW $] DSROiULV DQ\DJRN PROHNXOiL QHP UHQGHONH]QHN SHUPDQHQV GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPPDO (OHNWURPRV WpU KDWiViUD D]RQEDQ GLSyOXVPRPHQWXP LQGXNiOyGLN H]HNEHQ D PROHNXOiNEDQ LV $] LQGXNiOW GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPQDJ\ViJDNLVWpUHU VVpJHVHWpQDUiQ\RVDWpUHU VpJJHO+RPRJpQHU WpUEHQ OHY GLHOHNWULNXP EHOVHMpEHQ J|PE DODN~ UHJHW NpS]HOQN HO HQQHN N|]pSSRQWMiEDQ KHO\H]NHGLN HO D SRQWV]HU QHN WHNLQWKHW PROHNXOD $] UHJ HOpJ QDJ\ DKKR] KRJ\ D] W N|UOYHY GLHOHNWULNXPRW KRPRJpQQHN WHNLQWVN $] UHJ N|]pSSRQWMiEDQ OHY PROHNXOiUD KDWyORNiOLVWpUHU VVpJNpWNRPSRQHQVE OWHY GLN|VV]HD]HJ\LNNRPSRQHQVDGLHOHNWULNXPUD KDWy 0D[ZHOOWpU PtJ D PiVLN D J|PEIHOOHWHQ OHY SRODUL]iFLyV W|OWpVHN HU WHUH 7HKiW D PROHNXOiUDKDWyORNiOLVWpUHU VVpJ
3 (
) ö S
$]) HU WHUHW /RUHQW]IpOH EHOV WpUQHN LV QHYH]L D] LURGDORP >@ $ /RUHQW]IpOH EHOV WpU IHOKDV]QiOiViYDOD&ODXVLXV0RVRWWLHJ\HQOHWYH]HWKHW OH
D SU H
H
$&ODXVLXV0RVRWWLHJ\HQOHWDSROiULVJi]RNUDpVIRO\DGpNRNUDLVpUYpQ\HV
$] HOV RO\DQ HOPpOHW DPHO\ ILJ\HOHPEH YHV]L D PROHNXOiN SHUPDQHQV GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPiW pV H]iOWDO D] LUiQ\tWiVL SRODUL]iFLyW 'HE\HWyO HUHG >@ $] HOPpOHW IHOWpWHOH]LKRJ\DPROHNXOiNN|YHWLND%ROW]PDQQHORV]OiVWtJ\D'HE\HHJ\HQOHW
¸¸
¹
·
¨¨
©
§
N7
÷
D P SU H
H
$ 'HE\HHOPpOHW D /RUHQW]IpOH EHOV WpU IHOKDV]QiOiViYDO HOKDQ\DJROMD D PROHNXOiN N|]|WWL N|OFV|QKDWiVW H]pUW FVDN NLV Q\RPiV~ SROiURV Ji]RNUD pV SROiURV DQ\DJRN DSROiULV ROGyV]HUUHODONRWRWWKtJROGDWDLUDpUYpQ\HV
$ PROHNXOiN N|]|WWL N|OFV|QKDWiVRNDW D] 2QVDJHUHOPpOHW >@ PiU NpSHV NH]HOQL (]
D]HOPpOHWIHOWpWHOH]LKRJ\DPROHNXOiNN|YHWLND%ROW]PDQQHORV]OiVWWRYiEEiIHOWpWHOH]HJ\
RO\DQ UHJHW PHO\QHN N|]pSSRQWMiEDQ HJ\ SRQWV]HU GLSyOXV WDOiOKDWy $] HUHGHWL 2QVDJHU PRGHOO J|PE DODN~ UHJHW WpWHOH] IHO pV D] UHJEHQ YiNXXP YDQ $] UHJ N|]pSSRQWMiEDQ OHY SRQWV]HU GLSyOXVUD KDWy ORNiOLV HU WpU NpW UpV]E O WHY GLN |VV]H D] UHJWpUE O pV D UHDNWtYWpUE O
$] UHJWpU HU VVpJpW D NOV HOHNWURPRV WpUHU VVpJ pV D] UHJHW N|UOYHY H UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV~KRPRJpQQHNWHNLQWHWWGLHOHNWULNXPKDWiUR]]DPHJ$UHDNWtYWHUHWDSHUPDQHQV GLSyOXV KR]]D OpWUH D]iOWDO KRJ\ SRODUL]iOMD D] UHJHW N|UOYHY GLHOHNWULNXPRW $ GLSyOXV iOWDOSRODUL]iOWGLHOHNWULNXPYLVV]DKDWPDJiUDDGLSyOXVUD$UHDNWtYWpULUiQ\DPHJHJ\H]LND]
W OpWUHKR]y GLSyOXVPRPHQWXP LUiQ\iYDO pV HU VVpJH J\HQJH WHUHN HVHWpQ DUiQ\RV D GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPQDJ\ViJiYDO-REEDQN|]HOtWLDYDOyViJRWKDQHPJ|PEKDQHPHOOLSV]RLG DODN~UHJHWDONDOPD]XQN$]2QVDJHUHOPpOHWNLWHUMHV]WpVH6FKROWH>@QHYpKH]I ] GLN
0tJ2QVDJHUV]HULQWDUHDNWtYWpUQHPYiOWR]WDWMDPHJDV]DEDGD]D]N|UQ\H]HWQpONOL PROHNXOD GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPiQDN QDJ\ViJiW DGGLJ %|WWFKHU >@ V]HULQW D GLSyOXV HU WHUH GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPRWLQGXNiOPDJiEDQDGLSyOXVEDQ
$ GLHOHNWULNXPRN WXODMGRQViJDLW PROHNXOiULV PRGHOOHN DODSMiQ OHtUy HOPpOHWHN IXQGDPHQWiOLV HJ\HQOHWpQHN OHYH]HWpVHNRU >@ D HJ\HQOHWEHQ YiODVV]XN NpW UpV]UH D
SRODUL]iFLyW HOWROiVL pV LUiQ\tWiVL SRODUL]iFLyUD 0tJ D] HOWROiVL SRODUL]iFLyW D ORNiOLV WpUHU VVpJKDWiUR]]DPHJDGGLJD]LUiQ\tWiVLSRODUL]iFLyNLDODNtWiViEDQDORNiOLVWpUFVDND]RQ UpV]HMiWV]LNV]HUHSHWDPHO\QHPDSHUPDQHQVGLSyOXVPRPHQWXPWyOHUHGtJ\IHOtUKDWyKRJ\
¿
¾
½
¯
®
øù
N7 ( )
(ú
û
D P U S
H
%HOiWKDWy KRJ\ DSROiULV PROHNXOiN HVHWpQ D ORNiOLV WHUHW D /RUHQW]IpOH WpUUHO D]RQRVtWYD D &ODXVLXV0RVRWWL HJ\HQOHWHW NDSMXN YLVV]D PtJ D ORNiOLV pV D] LUiQ\tWy WHUHW D /RUHQW]IpOH WpUUHO KHO\HWWHVtWYH D 'HE\HHJ\HQOHWHW NDSKDWMXN PHJ *|PE DODN~ SROiURV PROHNXOiUDPHJKDWiUR]YDD]LUiQ\tWyWHUHWDHJ\HQOHWE OD]2QVDJHUHJ\HQOHWiOOHO
ü
ü ü
ü
ü
Q
Q Q
N7 H
H H
P SU
$UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVVWDWLV]WLNXVPHFKDQLNDLpUWHOPH]pVH
7HNLQWVQN HJ\ 9 WpUIRJDW~ 7 K PpUVpNOHW 1 UpV]HFVNpE O iOOy IOXLGXPRW $ UHQGV]HUHJ\HQV~O\LiOODSRWEDQYDQD]D]DWHUPRGLQDPLNDLPHQQ\LVpJHNLG EHQiOODQGypUWpN N|UO IOXNWXiOQDN $ GLQDPLNDL PHQQ\LVpJHN PDNURV]NySLNXV PpUKHW pUWpNHL VRNDViJ V]HULQWLiWODJROiVVDOV]iUPD]WDWKDWyDN$PLNRUHJ\UHQGV]HUWYL]VJiOXQN U|J]tWHQLNHOODQQDN WHUPRGLQDPLNDL KDWiUIHOWpWHOHLW YDJ\LV D UHQGV]HUW KDWiUROy IDODN WXODMGRQViJDLW .DQRQLNXV 197VRNDViJHVHWpQDPHUHYGLDWHUPpVLPSHUPHiELOLVIDOODOKDWiUROWUHQGV]HU7K PpUVpNOHW K WDUWiOO\DOpULQWNH]LN9L]VJiOMXNPHJH]WDNDQRQLNXVVRNDViJRWNOV WpUMHOHQOpWpEHQD]D]
D UHQGV]HUQN HJ\197( VRNDViJ $ NRQILJXUiFLyV iOODSRW|VV]HJ D N|YHWNH] PyGRQ DGKDWy PHJ
> @
þ ýþ
þ
þ
þWÿ =
1 8
G G 1
4
:
³
:
H[S
U E 0(
DKRO:DWHOMHVWpUV]|JOLQHiULVPROHNXOiNHVHWpQS QHPOLQHiULVPROHNXOiNUD
S = D
NRQILJXUiFLyV LQWHJUiO8D SRWHQFLiOLV HQHUJLD pV(D NOV WpU .OV WpU KLiQ\iEDQ D IHQWL HJ\HQOHW D]197 VRNDViJ NRQILJXUiFLyV iOODSRW|VV]HJpW DGMD YLVV]D +D HJ\9 WpUIRJDW~7 K PpUVpNOHW 1 UpV]HFVNpE O iOOy UHQGV]HUUH NOV WHUHW NDSFVROXQN DNNRU D WpU LQWHQ]tY SDUDPpWHUQHNWHNLQWKHW pVHKKH]DWHOMHVGLSyOXVPRPHQWXPWDUWR]LNPLQWNRQMXJiOWH[WHQ]tY WXODMGRQViJ 9DODPHO\% NRQILJXUiFLyV IL]LNDL PHQQ\LVpJ VRNDViJiWODJD197( VRNDViJRQ D N|YHWNH] NpSSHQDGKDWyPHJ
> @
> @
³
³
0(
U
0(
U
8 G
G
8
% G
% G
E Z
E Z
H[S
H[S
$ NRQILJXUiFLyV PHQQ\LVpJHNHQ RO\DQ IL]LNDL PHQQ\LVpJHNHW pUWQN DPHO\HN FVDN D
NRQILJXUiFLyV NRRUGLQiWiNWyO IJJHQHN D]D] 8 8
U Z 0 0U Z pV%
% U Z
7HNLQWVNPRVWDUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVVWDWLV]WLNXVPHFKDQLNDLpUWHOPH]pVpW$UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiVPHJDGKDWyDNOV HOHNWURPRVWpUKDWiViUDDGRWWOLQHiULVGLHOHNWURPRVYiODV]
DODSMiQ$HJ\HQOHWDODSMiQ
(
0 9 H S
DKRO 0 KHO\HWW DQQDN 0 VRNDViJiWODJiW tUWXN $ UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV PDNURV]NRSLNXV iOODQGyIJJHWOHQDKDWiUIHOWpWHOHNW O(]]HOV]HPEHQD0D[ZHOOIpOHEHOV WpU( pVDWHOMHV GLSyOXVPRPHQWXP 0 D KDWiUIHOWpWHOHN IJJYpQ\H +DWiUIHOWpWHOHNHQ MHOHQ HVHWEHQ D
PLQWDDODNMiWpVDPLQWiWN|UOYHY N|]HJWXODMGRQViJDLWpUWMN$NOV WpUDYpJWHOHQEHQYHWW HOHNWURPRVWpUpVDPLQWDKDWiUIHOOHWpQOHY SRODUL]iFLyVW|OWpVHNHOHNWURPRVWHUpQHN|VV]HJH
$ (OV NpQW WpWHOH]]N IHO KRJ\ D] HOOLSV]RLG DODN~ PLQWiW YiNXXP YHV]L N|UO +D D NOV WpU(LUiQ\DPHJHJ\H]LND]HOOLSV]RLGI WHQJHO\pQHNLUiQ\iYDODNNRUDGLHOHNWULNXP EHOVHMpEHQDWpUHU VVpJ
(
(
O H
DKROODGHSRODUL]iFLyVIDNWRU>@9pJWHOHQOHOQ\~MWRWWHOOLSV]RLGHVHWpQO D]D]
(
(
(]W D] HVHWHW IRJMXN DONDOPD]QL D GLHOHNWURPRV iOODQGy ~Q V]DEDGHQHUJLD ~WRQ NHUHV]WOL WiUJ\DOiVDNRU*|PEDODN~PLQWDHVHWpQDGHSRODUL]iFLyVIDNWRUO tJ\D0D[ZHOOIpOH EHOV WpU
( (
H
% 0iVRGLNNpQWWHNLQWVQNHJ\H UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiV~KRPRJpQL]RWUySGLHOHNWULNXPRW pV EHQQH HJ\H UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV~ J|PE|W $ NOV pV D EHOV WpU N|]|WWL NDSFVRODWRW D
N|YHWNH] HJ\HQOHWKDWiUR]]DPHJ
H H H
(
(
$]( pUWpNpWEHtUYDDHJ\HQOHWEHD]~QSRODUL]iFLyVHJ\HQOHWKH]MXWXQN
( 9
!
! S 0
H H
H
H
$WHOMHVGLSyOXVPRPHQWXPiWODJiWDHJ\HQOHWVHJtWVpJpYHOKDWiUR]KDWMXNPHJ%KHO\pEH 0HWtUYD
> @
> @
*³
³ *
G 8
G 8
"#%$&
0(
0(
0 0
E E H[S
H[S
$IHQWLNLIHMH]pVW( N|UOVRUEDIHMWYH>@D]WNDSMXNKRJ\
'
(
'
'
(
(
¸¸
¹
·
¨¨
©
§
w w
¸
¸
¹
·
¨¨
©
§
w w
)
)
( (
(
( * *
+-,.
*
0 0
0
0
$VRUIHMWpVPiVRGIRN~WDJMiQiOPHJiOOYD 0 /012 (UHDN|YHWNH] NLIHMH]pVDGyGLN
3
4
43
3
4
0 0
0
0 E E
(
56%78
DKRODLQGH[DPHJIHOHO iWODJ( WpUHU VVpJQpOYHWWpUWpNpWMHOHQWL.LKDV]QiOWXNKRJ\D UHQGV]HUL]RWUyS 0 9 D]D]DWHOMHVGLSyOXVPRPHQWXPNOV WpUKLiQ\iEDQ]pUXV.OV
HOHNWURPRVWpUKLiQ\iEDQDGLHOHNWURPRViOODQGyD]~QIOXNWXiFLyVIRUPXOiEyOV]iPtWKDWy>
@
:
;<
;<
\J 9
=
SE 0
H H
H
H
DKRO
>
SE P
1 9
\
DGLSyOXVHU VVpJIJJYpQ\pV
?
?
P 1
0
J@
D.LUNZRRGIpOHJIDNWRU>@
$HJ\HQOHWDODSMiQKDHAB DNNRUDKRVV]~WiY~NRUUHNFLyNDWHOKDQ\DJROMXN
$PLQWDLO\HQHVHWEHQYiNXXPEDQYDQpVD]HJ\HQOHWHJ\&ODXVLXV0RVRWWLWtSXV~HJ\HQOHWWp HJ\V]HU V|GLN > @ +D D PLQWiW N|UOYHY GLHOHNWULNXP PHJHJ\H]LN D PLQWiYDO D]D]
H
HCD DNNRU D UHQGV]HU YpJWHOHQ pV D .LUNZRRGHJ\HQOHWHW >@ NDSMXN D IOXNWXiFLyV HJ\HQOHWE O +DUPDGLN HVHWEHQ HEF f H] D] ~Q YH]HW KDWiUIHOWpWHO 0RQWH &DUOR
V]LPXOiFLyN HVHWpQ H]W FpOV]HU DONDOPD]QL >@ $ GLHOHNWURPRV iOODQGyUD D N|YHWNH] W NDSMXN
G\J
H
(OPpOHWLPHJN|]HOtWpVHN
,URGDOPLHO ]PpQ\HN
+D PLNURV]NRSLNXV V]LQWHQ NtYiQMXN WDQXOPiQ\R]QL D IRO\DGpNRN UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiViW RO\DQ PROHNXOiULV PRGHOOUH YDQ V]NVpJQN DPHO\ NpSHV pUWHOPH]QL D GLSROiULV UpV]HFVNpN N|]|WW KDWy LQWHUPROHNXOiULV N|OFV|QKDWiVW $GRWW PROHNXOiN HVHWpQ OHKHW VpJ YDQ NLILQRPXOW pV PHJOHKHW VHQ ERQ\ROXOW PRGHOOHN IHOiOOtWiViUD D] HOPpOHWL N|]HOtWpVHN PHOOHWW D V]iPtWyJpSHV V]LPXOiFLyN LV PHJIHOHO HV]N|]W EL]WRVtWDQDN D PRGHOOHN WDQXOPiQ\R]iViKR]
(J\ ERQ\ROXOWDEE PRGHOO DONDOPD]iVD YDOyV DQ\DJRNUD PiU W|EE PROHNXOiULV SDUDPpWHUW LJpQ\HO
+D D PROHNXOiN HJ\ WHOMHV FVRSRUWMiW V]HUHWQpQN YL]VJiOQL HOV NpQW D GLSROiULV PROHNXOiNDW DNNRU D GLHOHNWURPRV WXODMGRQViJRN OHtUiViUD HJ\ HJ\V]HU PRGHOOW FpOV]HU DONDOPD]QL (]pUW D GLSROiULV PROHNXOiN YL]VJiODWiUD D GLSROiULV PHUHYJ|PE SRWHQFLiOW YiODV]WRWWXN DPHO\ D] HJ\LN OHJHJ\V]HU EE GLSROiULV PRGHOOSRWHQFLiO 0iVLN HO Q\H KRJ\
DODSYHW VWDWLV]WLNXV PHFKDQLNDL PyGV]HUHNNHO WDQXOPiQ\R]KDWy $ GLHOHNWURPRV WXODMGRQViJRNDW PiU D] iWODJRV J|PEL N|]HOtWpVVHO 0HDQ 6SKHULFDO $SSUR[LPDWLRQ 06$
>@D]5+1&5HIHUHQFH+\SHUQHWWHG&KDLQ>@pVV U VpJIXQNFLRQiOHOPpOHWHNNHO')7
>@ LV YL]VJiOWiN ,VPHUHWHLQN V]HULQW FVDN QpKiQ\ SXEOLNiFLy IRJODONR]LN YDOyV DQ\DJRN GLHOHNWURPRV WXODMGRQViJDLQDN PROHNXOiULV DODSRNRQ Q\XJYy HOPpOHWL PyGV]HUHNNHO YDOy EHFVOpVpYHO *ROGPDQ >@ D PiVRGUHQG SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWHW DONDOPD]WD 6WRFNPD\HU IOXLGXP HVHWpQ D GLHOHNWURPRV iOODQGy PHJKDWiUR]iViUD pV D V]LPXOiFLyNNDO |VV]HYHWYH HOIRJDGKDWy HJ\H]pVW WDOiOW *ROGPDQ pV -RVOLQ ERQ\ROXOWDEE SRWHQFLiORNUD LV NLWHUMHV]WHWWH
*ROGPDQNRUiEELHOPpOHWHW>@0yGV]HUNHWYt]PRGHOOHNUHLVDONDOPD]WiNpVHUHGPpQ\HLNHW V]LPXOiFLyVDGDWRNNDOKDVRQOtWRWWiN|VV]H>@
(J\ PiVLN N|]OHPpQ\EHQ >@ QDJ\ K PpUVpNOHW pV QDJ\ Q\RPiV~ Yt] UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiViW SXEOLNiOWiN pV My HJ\H]pVW WDOiOWDN D] HEEHQ D WDUWRPiQ\EDQ PHJOHKHW VHQ KLiQ\RVNtVpUOHWLDGDWRNNDO
$ PDJDVDEE UHQG PRPHQWXPRN ILJ\HOHPEHYpWHOpYHO *ROGPDQ pV -RVOLQ >@
|VV]HKDVRQOtWRWWD D +KtG N|WpVVHO UHQGHONH] pV D GLSROiULV DSURWLNXV PROHNXOiN DONRWWD IRO\DGpNRN GLHOHNWURPRV WXODMGRQViJDLW (OPpOHWN DODSMiQ DUUD D PHJiOODStWiVUD MXWRWWDN KRJ\D]iOWDOXNYL]VJiOW+KtGN|WpVVHOUHQGHONH] PROHNXOiULVIRO\DGpNRNQDJ\REEV]WDWLNXV GLHOHNWURPRViOODQGyWPXWDWQDNPLQWDGLSROiULVDSURWLNXVIRO\DGpNRN
)RO\DGpNHOHJ\HN GLHOHNWURPRV WXODMGRQViJDLQDN LVPHUHWH LV VRN V]HPSRQWEyO OpQ\HJHV (OHJ\HN UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiViQDN NtVpUOHWL PHJKDWiUR]iVD XJ\DQRO\DQ HJ\V]HU PLQW D WLV]WD DQ\DJRNp *\DNUDQ KDV]QiOMiN D UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV PpUW pUWpNpW D] HOHJ\HN
|VV]HWpWHOpQHN PHJKDWiUR]iViUD LV $] HOHJ\HNEHQ IHOOpS DVV]RFLiFLyV IRO\DPDWRN V]LQWpQ N|YHWKHW HN GLHOHNWURPRV PpUpVHNNHO >@ .OV HOHNWURPRV WpU DONDOPD]iViYDO PHJYDOyVtWRWW V]HSDUiFLyV IRO\DPDWRN >@ GHV]WLOOiFLy H[WUDNFLy WHUYH]pVpKH] D] HOHJ\HN UHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiViQDNLVPHUHWHV]LQWpQV]NVpJHV
$ UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV PHJDGKDWy D NOV HOHNWURPRV WpU KDWiViUD DGRWW OLQHiULV GLHOHNWURPRV YiODV] DODSMiQ (] D PyGV]HU D SRODUL]iFLy pV D GLHOHNWULNXP EHOVHMpEHQ OHY HOHNWURPRV WpUHU VVpJ N|]|WWL |VV]HIJJpVHQ DODSV]LN HJ\HQOHW .LV V U VpJ SROiURV Ji]RNHVHWpQD/DQJHYLQIJJYpQ\VHJtWVpJpYHOPHJDGKDWyDSRODUL]iFLy>@
( ( 3
N7 N7
/
H
U P PU P ¸#
¹
¨ ·
©
§
$SRODUL]iFLyH]HQVRUIHMWpVpWpVD0D[ZHOOWHUHWILJ\HOHPEHYpYHD'HE\HHJ\HQOHWKH]>@
MXWXQN
\
H
H
'LSROiULVPHUHYJ|PEIOXLGXPHVHWpUH-HSVHQ>@pV5XVKEURRN>@PHJPXWDWWDKRJ\
DVRUIHMWpVN|YHWNH] HJ]DNWWDJMD
I
\ \
H
H
(EE ODIRUPXOiEyODUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVWD]DOiEELVRUUDOIHMH]KHWMNNL
J
I
\ \ \
H
0HJMHJ\H]]N KRJ\ :HUWKHLP >@ 06$ HOPpOHWpQHN\V]HULQWL VRUIHMWpVH V]LQWpQ D HJ\HQOHWHW HUHGPpQ\H]L $] 2QVDJHU >@ pV 9DQ 9OHFN >@ HOPpOHWHN FVDN D VRUIHMWpV PiVRGUHQG WDJMiLJPHJIHOHO HN
1HPSRODUL]iOKDWyGLSROiULVIOXLGXPRNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiViQDNV]iPtWiVDD .LUNZRRGHJ\HQOHWDODSMiQ.LUNZRRGIDNWRU~W
$ GROJR]DW ~M WXGRPiQ\RV HUHGPpQ\HLQHN LVPHUWHWpVH HO WW V]NVpJpW pUH]WN NO|Q IHMH]HWHNEHQ |VV]HIRJODOQL D GLVV]HUWiFLy NLLQGXOiVL DODSMiW NpSH] LURGDOPL PHJIRQWROiVRNDW
$pVIHMH]HWHNHUU OQ\~MWDQDNiWWHNLQWpVW
$ UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV V]iPtWiViKR] D .LUNZRRGHJ\HQOHWHW >@ DONDOPD]WXN J|PE DODN~PLQWiWIHOWpWHOH]YHHJ\HQOHWH HKL HVHWEHQ
M
\J
H H H
(VHWQNEHQ D PLQWiW N|UOYHY GLHOHNWULNXP PHJHJ\H]LN D PLQWiYDO tJ\ D YpJHV pV YpJWHOHQ UHQGV]HUUH YRQDWNR]y .LUNZRRGIDNWRU HJ\PiVVDO HNYLYDOHQV $ .LUNZRRGIDNWRUW
>@ D UHQGV]HU WHOMHV 0 GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPiQDN IOXNWXiFLyMiEyO NDSKDWMXN PHJ HJ\HQOHW
¦ ' ¦
¦ ¦
N
N
NON
P
Q
P
Q Q P
R P
Q QR
S
M 1 1
J
T
TVU
UWU
T
T
Q Q
Q Q 0
DKRO QX D]LGLN GLSyOXV LUiQ\iED PXWDWy HJ\VpJYHNWRU D] LM U|YLGtWpV
UZ ZUY Y UH YRQDWNR]LN 'LM Q\Q[ pV VRNDViJ V]HULQWL iWODJROiVW MHOHQW $ VRNDViJiWODJRW DSiUNRUUHOiFLyVIJJYpQ\VHJtWVpJpYHONLIHMH]YHD.LUNZRRGIDNWRUDN|YHWNH] PyGRQDGKDWy PHJ
]_^
`
a
J GU
Jb U
³
'
DKRO d c RULHQWiFLyV]HULQWLiWODJROiVWMHOHQW$HJ\HQOHWMREEROGDOiQDNNLV]iPtWiViWD
*XEELQV3RSOH6WHOOIpOH SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW DODSMiQ YpJH]WN >@ $ *XEELQV3RSOH6WHOO
SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW D] LQWHUPROHNXOiULV SRWHQFLiOW HJ\ UHIHUHQFLD pV HJ\ SHUWXUEiFLyV WDJUD RV]WMD)egf YDJ\)hi DUHIHUHQFLDSRWHQFLiOpV)j-j DSHUWXUEiFLyVWDJ$'+6YDJ\670
UHQGV]HU SiUNRUUHOiFLyV IJJYpQ\pQHN IHOtUiVDNRU D %DUNHU pV +HQGHUVRQ >@ iOWDO MDYDVROW SHUWXUEiFLyVVRUIHMWpVWDONDOPD]WXN
l
k
m l
l
n
U G J
J J
J
opo opo
opo
³
) )
)
qU
E
E
DKROJr
pVJs
D UHIHUHQFLDUHQGV]HU NpW pV KiURPUpV]HFVNH NRUUHOiFLyV IJJYpQ\HL
$ KiURPUpV]HFVNH HORV]OiVIJJYpQ\W D .LUNZRRGIpOH V]XSHUSR]tFLyV N|]HOtWpVVHO YHWWN ILJ\HOHPEH
t t t
t JJJ
J
(] D N|]HOtWpV QDJ\ V U VpJHNHQ KLEiNKR] YH]HW GH :DQJ pV PXQNDWiUVDL PHJPXWDWWiN KRJ\ D SHUWXUEiFLyV LQWHJUiORN V]iPtWiViQiO My N|]HOtWpVQHN V]iPtW >@ $ NRQILJXUiFLyV V]DEDGHQHUJLD SHUWXUEiFLyV VRUiQDN IHOtUiVDNRU ) )x )w )v )u
FVDN D]RQ WDJRN ILJ\HOHPEH YpWHOH V]NVpJHV DPHO\HN GLSyOXVGLSyOXV SRWHQFLiO HVHWpQ ]pUXVWyO NO|QE|]QHN $ SHUWXUEiFLyV LQWHJUiORNUyO D IHMH]HW Q\~MW E YHEE iWWHNLQWpVW
$J
SiUNRUUHOiFLyV IJJYpQ\W D HJ\HQOHWEH KHO\HWWHVtWYH NLKDV]QiOYD D ' pV' IJJYpQ\HNRUWRJRQDOLWiViWtUKDWMXNKRJ\
|
z_{ y
{
{
}
~
U U G G J
J E U
³
)p )p '
$V]|JV]HULQWLiWODJROiVHOYpJ]pVHXWiQD.LUNZRRGIDNWRUDN|YHWNH] DODNEDQiOOHO
S
\ ,
J
$], NRQYRO~FLyVLQWHJUiODN|YHWNH] PyGRQDGKDWyPHJ
FRV
U J GU GU GU
U U ,
³
S T
DKROT D] KiURPV]|J DV FV~FVRQ OHY EHOV V]|JH $] , LQWHJUiO J
RQ NHUHV]WO IJJ D UHGXNiOW V U VpJW O pV D UHGXNiOW K PpUVpNOHWW O '+6 IOXLGXP HVHWpQ D]
LQWHJUiO FVDN
U WyO IJJ 670 IOXLGXPQiO D]RQEDQ D K PpUVpNOHWW O LV IJJ $ SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW VHJtWVpJpYHO NLIHMH]HWW J IDNWRUW HJ\HQOHW D HJ\HQOHWEH KHO\HWWHVtWYHD.LUNZRRGHJ\HQOHW
¸
¹
¨ ·
©
§
H S H
H ,
\
\
$ .LUNZRRGHJ\HQOHWE O V]iPtWRWW UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV pUWpNHN '+6IOXLGXP HVHWpQ QHP PXWDWQDN My HJ\H]pVW D V]LPXOiFLyV DGDWRNNDO H]pUW 7DQL pV PXQNDWiUVDL >@
VRUEDIHMWHWWpNH \ WpVDN|YHWNH] NLIHMH]pVWNDSWiN
¸
¹
¨ ·
©
§
S H
,
\
\
\
\
0HJPXWDWWiN KRJ\ D IHQWL VRUIHMWpVE O V]iUPD]y DGDWRN MREE HJ\H]pVW PXWDWQDN D V]LPXOiFLyVDGDWRNNDOPLQWPDJiEyOD.LUNZRRGHJ\HQOHWE OV]iUPD]yHUHGPpQ\HN
9DOyMiEDQ 7DQL pV PXQNDWiUVDL >@ D HV HJ\HQOHWHW D &ODXVLXV0RVVRWWLHJ\HQOHW VRUIHMWpVpE O NDSWiN DKRO D PLQWiW YiNXXP YHV]L N|UO pV QHP D HV .LUNZRRG HJ\HQOHWE O DKRO D PLQWiW |QPDJD YHV]L N|UO D]D] D UHQGV]HU YpJWHOHQQHN WHNLQWKHW 0LQGD]RQiOWDO PLQGNpW PyGV]HUUHO D HJ\HQOHW iOO HO (] HJ\EHQ D]W LV MHOHQWL KRJ\ D IHQWLHJ\HQOHWiOWDOiQRVpUYpQ\ pVIJJHWOHQDKDWiUIHOWpWHOHNW O
-HSVHQ >@ pV 5XVKEURRNH >@ PXQNiL DODSMiQ *ROGPDQ >@ YDOyEDQ PHJPXWDWWD KRJ\H VRUIHMWpVpEHQ D] HOV KiURP WDJ W O D]
\ WDJLJ HJ]DNW YDODPLQW KRJ\ D PiVRGUHQG SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW KHO\HVHQ DGMD YLVV]D D NpWWHVWKR]]iMiUXOiVRNDW NLV V U VpJHVHWpQ
\ WDJ
(]]HOV]HPEHQDKRJ\D]DHJ\HQOHWE OLVOiWV]LNDJ FVDND]HOV QHPWULYLiOLVWDJ D]\ WDJHVHWpQHJ]DNWNLVV U VpJHQ(QQHNDOiWV]yODJRVHOOHQWPRQGiVQDNDPHJpUWpVpKH]
D UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV pV D .LUNZRRGIpOH J IDNWRU IL]LNDL VDMiWRVViJDLW NHOO WLV]Wi]QL $]
HOV HVHWEHQ D SROiURV IOXLGXP HOHNWURPRV WpU KDWiViUD DGRWW YiODV]iW PpUMN 0LYHO HOHNWURPRV YiODV]W HJ\HWOHQ UpV]HFVNH LV DG H]pUW D UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV D] HJ\UpV]HFVNH HORV]OiVEyOV]iUPD]LNHQQpOIRJYDDW|EEUpV]HFVNHMiUXOpNRNFVDNDVRUIHMWpVPDJDVDEEUHQG WDJMDLEDQ MHOHQQHN PHJ (]]HO V]HPEHQ D J IDNWRU LOOHWYH DQQDN W O YDOy HOWpUpVH
|QPDJiEDQLVW|EEWHVWNRUUHOiFLyWMHOHQW
$ IHQW OHtUW pUYHN PDJ\DUi]DWRW DGKDWQDN DUUD KRJ\ PLpUW DG D HJ\HQOHW MREE HUHGPpQ\W D UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV PHJKDWiUR]iVDNRU PLQW D HJ\HQOHW $ HJ\HQOHW DODSMiQ V]iPtWRWW UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV pUWpNHN QDJ\RQ pU]pNHQ\HN D .LUNZRRGIDNWRU QDJ\ViJiUD PtJ D]H VRUIHMWpVH QHP W~OViJRVDQ pU]pNHQ\ D J IDNWRU LQJDGR]iVDLUD PLYHO KDWiVD FVDN D KDUPDGUHQG WDJQiO MHOHQWNH]LN $ HPOtWHWW EL]RQ\WDODQViJRN MHOHQW VVp YiOQDN V U DODFVRQ\ K PpUVpNOHW IRO\DGpNRN HVHWpQ PLYHO D PiVRGUHQG SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW iOWDO HOKDQ\DJROWKiURPpVW|EEWHVWKR]]iMiUXOiVRNV]HUHSHPHJQ
(] D] RND DQQDN KRJ\ D PDJDVDEE UHQG HOPpOHWHN PLQW SpOGiXO D] 5+1& >@ MREE HUHGPpQ\HNHW DGQDN D V]|J V]HULQWL HORV]OiVUD PLQW D PiVRGUHQG SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW GH QLQFVNO|Q|VHEEHO Q\ND]HV]iPtWiVDVRUiQ
1HPSRODUL]iOKDWyGLSROiULVIOXLGXPRNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiViQDNV]iPtWiVD V]DEDGHQHUJLDDODSMiQ6]DEDGHQHUJLD~W
$ V]DEDGHQHUJLD ~W D UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiVW D NOV HOHNWURPRV WpU KDWiViUD DGRWW GLHOHNWURPRVYiODV]DODSMiQDGMDPHJ$SRODUL]iFLyDN|YHWNH] PyGRQV]iPtWKDWyNL
¡
¢(
( ) 9 3
£
£
¸
¹
¨ ·
©
§ w
w
DKRO ) ( D] HOHNWURPRV WpUHU VVpJW O IJJ V]DEDGHQHUJLD $ pV HJ\HQOHWHNE O OiWKDWy KRJ\ D UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV NLV]iPtWiViKR] D V]DEDGHQHUJLiW NOV WpU MHOHQOpWpEHQ
(
) NHOO PHJKDWiUR]QXQN (EEHQ D] HVHWEHQ D] DONDOPD]RWW PRGHOO D '+6IOXLGXP NOV WpUEHQ tJ\ D GLSyOXVGLSyOXV SiUSRWHQFLiOW NL NHOO HJpV]tWHQQN D WpUUHO YDOy N|OFV|QKDWiVW NLIHMH] WDJRNNDO
( ( ¥ ( ¤ ( ) P FRV- P FRV-
)
DKRO-¦ D § pV(YHNWRURNiOWDOEH]iUWV]|J
.DOLNPDQRY >@ HJ\ DOJHEUDL SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWL PyGV]HUW MDYDVROW D V]DEDGHQHUJLD
(
) NLIHMH]pVpQHN PHJKDWiUR]iViUD 6]DODL >@ pV PXQNDWiUVDL NRUULJiOWiN .DOLNPDQRY HJ\HQOHWpQHNKLEiMiWpVNRUUHNWPyGV]HUWDGWDNDKiURPWHVWLQWHJUiORNNLV]iPtWiViUDYDODPLQW EHEL]RQ\tWRWWiN KRJ\ PHJIHOHO NRUUHNFLyNNDO D] HOPpOHW NLV V U VpJ KDWiUHVHWEHQ HJ]DNW D]D] D HJ\HQOHWHW NDSMXN PtJ QDJ\ V U VpJ HVHWpQ D 7DQL pV PXQNDWiUVDL >@ iOWDO NDSRWW|VV]HIJJpVWDGMDYLVV]D
9pJWHOHQO KRVV]~ HOOLSV]RLG DODN~ PLQWD OiVG pV HJ\HQOHWHNHW DONDOPD]iViYDO D GHSRODUL]iFLy HONHUOKHW D] LQWHJUiORN NLV]iPtWiVD HJ\V]HU EE PLQW V]IpULNXV PLQWD HVHWpQ 6]DODL pV PXQNDWiUVDL >@ HJ\ PiVRGUHQG SHUWXUEiFLyV NLIHMH]pVW DGWDN PHJ D '+6 IOXLGXP V]DEDGHQHUJLiMiUD NOV HOHNWURPRV WpU MHOHQOpWpEHQ >@
)HOKDV]QiOYDDSiUNRUUHOiFLyVIJJYpQ\%DUNHU+HQGHUVRQIpOHSHUWXUEiFLyVVRUIHMWpVpW>@D N|YHWNH] NLIHMH]pVWNDSMXNDV]DEDGHQHUJLiUD
»
¼ º
«
¬ ª
¸
¹
¨ ·
©
§
¨
©
ª
©
©
S S
««
¬®%¯
\ ,
\
\ 9(
( ) (
)
$HJ\HQOHWE ODHJ\HQOHWDODSMiQDSRODUL]iFLy
(
3 ¸¸
¹
·
¨¨
©
§
¸
¹
¨ ·
©
§
°
² ±
±
S S
,³³
\
\
\
D SRODUL]iFLyEyO SHGLJ D V]WDWLNXV UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV V]iPtWKDWy NL %HOiWKDWy KRJ\ D HJ\HQOHW VHJtWVpJpYHO PHJKDWiUR]RWW UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiV PHJHJ\H]LN 7DQL pV PXQNDWiUVDL
>@ HUHGPpQ\pYHO HJ\HQOHW (] D]W MHOHQWL KRJ\ D SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW VHJtWVpJpYHO PHJKDWiUR]RWWHpUWpNHIJJHWOHQDPLQWDDODNMiWyOLVDPLD]WLVMHO]LKRJ\DHJ\HQOHW YDOyEDQDUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiVHJ\iOWDOiQRVNLIHMH]pVH
6]HPLHPSLULNXVPyGV]HUSRODUL]iOKDWyIOXLGXPRNUHODWtYSHUPLWWLYLWiViQDN V]iPtWiViUD
(GGLJ D PROHNXOiN SRODUL]iOKDWyViJiW D QHP YHWWN ILJ\HOHPEH $ SRODUL]iOKDWyViJ PROHNXOiULVV]LQWHQEHpStWKHW DPRGHOOEHPpJKR]]iSRODUL]iOKDWyGLSROiULVSRWHQFLiOPRGHOO DONDOPD]iViYDOSpOGiXODSRODUL]iOKDWy'+6YDJ\670SRWHQFLiOVHJtWVpJpYHO(OV NpQWHJ\
HJ\V]HU HPSLULNXV N|]HOtWpVW MDYDVROXQN D W|UpVPXWDWy DONDOPD]iViYDO 7HNLQWVN D .LUNZRRG)U|KOLFKHJ\HQOHWHW>@
´\J
Q
Q Q
µ
µ µ
µ
H
H
H
DKRO Q D EHOV W|UpVPXWDWy $ EHOV W|UpVPXWDWy WDUWDOPD]]D PLQG D] DWRPL PLQG D]
HOHNWURQSRODUL]iOKDWyViJRW $ NtVpUOHWL DONDOPD]iVRN VRUiQ D EHOV W|UpVPXWDWy KHO\HWW D N|QQ\HQ PpUKHW Q¶ W|UpVPXWDWyW KDV]QiOMiN DPHO\ D QiWULXP 'YRQDOiQDN PHJIHOHO KXOOiPKRVV]RQ PpUW W|UpVPXWDWy pUWpN $] Q¶ DONDOPD]iVD HVHWpQ D] DWRPL SRODUL]iFLyW DPHO\DD]HOHNWURQSRODUL]iFLyQDN>@HOKDQ\DJROMiN
1HP V]DEDG D]RQEDQ HOIHOHGNH]QL DUUyO KRJ\ H] D N|]HOtWpV FVDN DEEDQ D] HVHWEHQ KDV]QiOKDWy KD PRGHOOQNHW YDOyV DQ\DJRNUD NtYiQMXN DONDOPD]QL $ HJ\HQOHW MREE ROGDOiQ D .LUNZRRGIDNWRUW HJ\ QHP SRODUL]iOKDWy PRGHOO D '+6SRWHQFLiO VHJtWVpJpYHO KDWiUR]WXN PHJ HJ\HQOHW PtJ D] HJ\HQOHW EDO ROGDOD HJ\ SRODUL]iOKDWy PROHNXOiQDN IHOHOPHJ1\LOYiQYDOyDQH]HJ\N|]HOtWpV(QQHNHOOHQpUHIHOWpWHOH]]NKRJ\D'+6PRGHOO VHJtWVpJpYHO V]iPtWRWW .LUNZRRGIDNWRU MyO N|]HOtWL D SRODUL]iOKDWy '+6PRGHOOUH NDSKDWy
·J pUWpNpW
$KRJ\D]WPiUHPOtWHWWND.LUNZRRGHJ\HQOHWVRUIHMWpVpE OV]iUPD]yHUHGPpQ\HNMREE HJ\H]pVW PXWDWQDN D V]LPXOiFLyV DGDWRNNDO PLQW PDJD D .LUNZRRGHJ\HQOHW (QQHN DODSMiQ IHOWpWHOH]KHWMNKRJ\D.LUNZRRG)U|KOLFKHJ\HQOHWVRUIHMWpVHV]LQWpQMREEHUHGPpQ\HNHWDG PLQW PDJD D .LUNZRRG)U|KOLFKHJ\HQOHW $ 7DQL pV PXQNDWiUVDL >@ iOWDO LV MDYDVROW VRUIHMWpVWHOYpJH]YHD.LUNZRRG)U|KOLFKHJ\HQOHWUHD]WNDSMXNKRJ\
¸
¹
º ¹
º
º
º
º º
º
º º
¸
º ¹
º
º
º º
º
º
º
\ Q
Q , Q
Q Q Q
\ Q
Q
\ Q Q
Q Q Q
\
»»
»
»
¼ º
«
«
¬ ª
¼
S H
/iWKDWy KRJ\ Q HVHWpQ D HJ\HQOHW D HJ\HQOHWHW DGMD YLVV]D (]]HO D PyGV]HUUHO YDJ\LV D W|UpVPXWDWy EHYH]HWpVpYHO ILJ\HOHPEH YHWWN D PROHNXOiN SRODUL]iOKDWyViJiWLV
(]W D] HJ\HQOHWHW YDODPLQW HQQHN HOHJ\HNUH NLWHUMHV]WHWW YiOWR]DWiW PHO\HW D N|YHWNH] NEHQ LVPHUWHWQN DONDOPD]]XN YDOyV DQ\DJRN GLHOHNWURPRV WXODMGRQViJDLQDN WDQXOPiQ\R]iViUD>,,,@$]|VV]HKDVRQOtWiVHUHGPpQ\HLWD]IHMH]HWEHQPXWDWMXNEH
$SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWNLWHUMHV]WpVHHOHJ\HNUH
$ SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW NLWHUMHV]WpVH HOHJ\HNUH iOWDOiEDQ YDODPLO\HQ NHYHUpVL V]DEiO\
DONDOPD]iViYDO YpJH]KHW HO >@ 7HNLQWVN D '+6PROHNXOiN HJ\ PNRPSRQHQV HOHJ\pW DKRO D] LQWHUPROHNXOiULV SRWHQFLiO D] D pV E UpV]HFVNpN N|]|WW D PiU LVPHUW HJ\HQOHWWHO DGKDWy PHJ pV HJ\HQOHW )HOWpWHOH]]N KRJ\ D] HOHJ\ HJ\ RO\DQ WLV]WD '+6IOXLGXPQDN IHOHO PHJ DPHO\QHN V U VpJH D] HOHJ\ V U VpJpYHO HJ\H]LN PHJ GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPiUDSHGLJWHOMHVOKRJ\
½
¾
½ ¿
¿ ¿
P P ¦À
Á
 [
DKRO
Ã
[ D]D NRPSRQHQVPyOW|UWMH9H]HVVNEHD]HOHJ\.LUNZRRGIDNWRUiW>@
¦Ä
Å Æ Ç
ÈÈ
É [[,
\
J Ê
Ë Ì
Ì
Ì
Í
Î Í
Î
Í
Î
P P P S
U
DKROD]HOHJ\GLSyOXVHU VVpJIJJYpQ\H
Ï
UE SPÐ
\
DUHGXNiOWWHOMHVV U VpJHWSHGLJDN|YHWNH] PyGRQV]iPtWMXN
¦Ñ
Ñ
Ñ
V U
U
Ò
[
DKROVÓ D]D LNNRPSRQHQVPHUHYJ|PEiWPpU MH(]HNNHODPyGRVtWiVRNNDOD]HOHJ\UHODWtY SHUPLWWLYLWiVD D WLV]WD IOXLGXPRNNDO DQDOyJ PyGRQ V]iPtWKDWy D YDJ\
HJ\HQOHWDODSMiQ
5HQRUPiOWSHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW
$ SRODUL]iOKDWy GLSROiULV IOXLGXPRN WXODMGRQViJDLQDN YL]VJiODWD D] LURGDOPDW iWWHNLQWYH PHVV]H HOPDUDG D QHPSRODUL]iOKDWy PROHNXOiN YLVHONHGpVpQHN WDQXOPiQ\R]iVD P|J|WW (] QDJ\PpUWpNEHQ N|V]|QKHW DQQDN D WpQ\QHN KRJ\ D SRODUL]iOKDWy GLSROiULV LQWHUPROHNXOiULV SRWHQFLiO QHP DGGLWtY (] D SUREOpPD QDJ\EDQ PHJQHKH]tWL D SRODUL]iOKDWy PROHNXOiNDW WDUWDOPD]y UHQGV]HU VWDWLV]WLNXV PHFKDQLNDL NH]HOpVpW $ OHJW|EE HOPpOHW LQNiEE HONHUOLDVRNWHVWN|OFV|QKDWiVRNNH]HOpVpE ODGyGyQHKp]VpJHNHW$SRODUL]iOKDWyIOXLGXPRW RO\DQUHQGV]HUNpQWNH]HOLDPHO\EHQDSiURQNpQWLDGGLWtYN|OFV|QKDWiVWD]HIIHNWtYSHUPDQHQV GLSyOXVPRPHQWXP DONDOPD]iViYDO EL]WRVtWMD (]W D N|]HOtWpVW DONDOPD]]D D :HUWKHLPIpOH UHQRUPiOW SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW 537 >@ YDODPLQW HQQHN GLSROiULVNYDGUXSROiULV IOXLGXPUD pV HOHJ\HNUH NLWHUMHV]WHWW YiOWR]DWD >@ pV &DUQH\ pV 3DWH\ iOWDO DONDOPD]RWW
|QNRQ]LV]WHQV 0) N|]HOtWpV >@ (]HNQpO D N|]HOtWpVHNQpO RO\DQ HOPpOHW V]NVpJHV DPHO\
NpSHV NLV]iPtWDQL D] HIIHNWtY SiUSRWHQFLiO iOWDO PHJKDWiUR]RWW UHQGV]HU WXODMGRQViJDLW (]
OHKHW D] /+1& YDJ\ 4+1& HOPpOHW > @ YDJ\ D *XEELQV 6WHOO pV PXQNDWiUVDLN iOWDO EHYH]HWHWWWHUPRGLQDPLNDLSHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHW>@
.ULHEHO pV :LQNHOPDQQ V]LV]WHPDWLNXV WDQXOPiQ\W N|]|OW DPHO\EHQ D SRODUL]iOKDWy 6WRFNPD\HU >@ pV D SRODUL]iOKDWy NpWFHQWUXP~ /HQQDUG-RQHV IOXLGXPRN WHUPRGLQDPLNDL WXODMGRQViJDLW YL]VJiOWiN >@ $] HPOtWHWW V]HU] N PROHNXODGLQDPLNDL V]LPXOiFLyV HUHGPpQ\HLNHW :HUWKHLP UHQRUPiOW SHUWXUEiFLyHOPpOHWpE O >@ V]iUPD]y DGDWRNNDO KDVRQOtWRWWiN|VV]HpVMyHJ\H]pVWWDOiOWDN(]HNDODSMiQIHOWpWHOH]WNKRJ\D]537PHJIHOHO HV]N|]W EL]WRVtW D SRODUL]iOKDWy IOXLGXPRN GLHOHNWURPRV WXODMGRQViJDLQDN WDQXOPiQ\R]iViUD DEEDQ D] HVHWEHQ KD D GLSyOXVPRPHQWXP YDJ\ D SRODUL]iOKDWyViJ QHP W~OViJRVDQ QDJ\
/HJMREE WXGiVXQN V]HULQW SRODUL]iOKDWy IOXLGXPRN GLHOHNWURPRV WXODMGRQViJDLQDN V]LV]WHPDWLNXVYL]VJiODWDPpJKLiQ\]LND]LURGDORPEyO
$ UHQRUPiOW HIIHNWtY GLSyOXVPRPHQWXP P D PROHNXOD SHUPDQHQV
GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPiQDN
PÔ pV D] LQGXNiOW GLSyOXVPRPHQWXPQDN DPHO\HW D PROHNXOiNUD KDWy iWODJRV WpU ( HUHGPpQ\H] D] |VV]HJHNpQW GHILQLiOKDWy 6NDOiULV SRODUL]iOKDWyViJUD V]RUtWNR]YDD]HIIHNWtYGLSyOXVPRPHQWXPDN|YHWNH] PyGRQDGKDWyPHJ
( D P
P Õ