&VDOiGQpYYiOWR]WDWiVQpYSROLWLNDpVQHP]HWLVpJLHUYLV]RQ\RN 0DJ\DURUV]iJRQDIHXGDOL]PXVWyODNRPPXQL]PXVLJ

DYDW\NHP|QFp^LW^_EHEHI&W|WWQN_pVDNNRUDEEDVOWHNP|JD_UpDNNRUU|JJHUHYy^XWW|S|UW^V SRJiFVD_SiOLQND_^HpV~*\_PsQWDGLV]Q&^XWRU_

$GLV]QyWPLNRUNLNp^LWIHOHYiNW}NNLY|WWp^LNDEHOHWDNNRUD]DVV]RQ\RNHOYLWWpNDYiMOLQJD^O_pV V]p^LWY|WWp^LNDYp^LNRPEHOHWDYDVWDNWx_pVDYDVWDJEHOHWXW\I|OV]|WWs^LNDNDUMXNUDPp^LWHU|V|NUH_pV DNNRU DV]W HOYLWWs^LN 8W\ NLYiNWiN P|JPRVWiN pV DV]WiQ K~V]WiN P|N Np^LVVH^O _ KRJ\ Yp^LNMQ>@

O|J\|Q_$YDVWDJEpOUOPKJOsV]HWWp^LNDN|Yp^LUHW_pVDV]WLVNLPRVWiNDNNRUD]GU]V|OWpNNXNRUL FiYDO _ FVXWNDWRNNDO _ pV PLNRU DV] WLV]WD O|WW DNNRU RV] O|WW _ EHYtYH _ pV DNNRU IË^WW D NXNR ULFDNiViEXOO|WWDK~UND_DPiMDVKXUNDP|JO|WWDPLQG|QI*^LOHDSU&^XO*^LNRJEXO_DNROEiV]P|N KiWD_K~VRJEXOXJ\sDPsMLNHWOsV]|WWHN_0HUDVRQNiNDWV]RNWDNQDJ\RSVRQNiWKDJ\QLNLV VHEEHW_pVDNNRUtJ\YDQW|SI^HpOH_$NNRURV]W_N|OOXJ\sDERUV_$]|NHWPiHOWWHYDOy^X QDS PLQG|QWHONp^LV]ÎW|WWNDEyUVRW_IRNKDJ\PiW_PLQG_HPL>@KR]]iYDOy^XN|OO|WW_0LNRURV]W Np^LV]Yy^XWDKXUND_P|JDEUVDMW_PiMDV_DNNRUDV]WD]]VGEHIRUWDYt]_DNNRUV]p^LSHQRWNL O|WWDEi^OYDDJ|PE|G]EHP|JO|WWDEUVDMW_DNNRUD]LV^ÆxW\NLO|WWDEiOYDD]PLQG|QNLO|WK&W YH_pVDV]W;t*\_Yp^LJ]G|WV]p^L$NNRURV]WHVWHDYDFVRUD_Y^DyWPLQG|QIp^LOHDNNRUP|JpQYyW OHYHV _ VOW K~V Yy^XW _ V]iUPD _ KXUND NROEiV] Pi DNNRUD Y&^XW VWYH D] DV]WDOUD _ LMHQ Y&^XW DYDFVRvVXWiÈDVRNLYiV

²+RJ\DQNpV]tWLNLWWDV]iUPiW"

²$V]iUP}W"_+iWD_GLV]Q&KXVPHJYDQGDUiOYD_VDEEDP^HpQDULVNiVD_EyUV_IRN KDJ\PD_V&_W|UWSDSULND_pV|VV]HJ\~UMXNpVDNNRUD_NiSRV]WDOHYHOp^LWXJ\sP|JYDQVDYD Q\RGYDDEEDEHJ\&UMN_pVDNNRxJ\UDNMXNDV]WDWD_ID]^HpJED_H]HO|WY&WRMDQFVHUp^LSID]^HpN_

eVDEEDW|WWpN_pVD]P|QGEHDEDQ\DNHP|QFp^LEH_RV]^WDEEDYyWI^YHDM&LJD]LV]iUPD

$GDWN|]O &VDOD )HUHQFQp )|OGHVL -XOLDQQD pYHV*\&MW6]DEy-y]VHI

/$.$7265,7$

6 = ( 0 / (

+DYDV)HUHQF$PDU[L]PXVV]LQGUyPD 6]WiOLQL]PXVpVQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\

6HJpGN|Q\YHNDQ\HOYpV]HWWDQXOPiQ\R]iViKR];97LQWD.|Q\YNLDGy%SODS

$V]HU]PHJOHSWpPiM~N|WHWWHOOpSDQ\HOYpV]WiUVDGDORPHOpDPHO\PiUDFtPpEHQMHO]L DNLKtYiVWD]HOIHOHGHWWQHNKLWWpVtWpOWHOPpOHWpVDN|UppSOWYLWD~MUDJRQGROiViUDDÄSHU´~MUD IHOYpWHOpUH9DMRQpUGHPHVHDWXGRPiQ\W|UWpQHWORPWiUiEyONLiVQLD]WDUpJPHJFiIROWWXGRPiQ\WD ODQ HOPpOHWHW DPHO\ NO|QEHQ MHOHQWV SROLWLNDL HVHPpQQ\p YiOW 6]WiOLQ pYL ÄG|QW EtUiVNRGiViYDO´DPHO\QHNN|YHWNH]WpEHQDGHVSRWDUHQGV]HUHQEHOOOHJDOiEEDQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\L YL]VJiODWRNEDQPHJGOWHJ\YH]HWNOLNNHJ\HGXUDOPD"²JRQGROMXNVRNDQDFtPHOROYDViVDXWiQ pVDN|Q\YHOROYDViVDHOWW+$9$6)(5(1&D]RQEDQPHJJ\]HQHOpQNWiUMDEHEL]RQ\tWMDKRJ\

DNpUGpVpVDYLWDIHOpOHV]WpVHQHPFVXSiQWXGRPiQ\W|UWpQHWLNXULy]XPKDQHPW|EEDQQiO(OHP ]pVHLEHQNLPXWDWMDKRJ\0DUUWp]LVHLWHOOHQIHOHLVRPPiVDQYHWHWWpNHOQHPYL]VJiOWiNiWPLQ GHQHJ\HVWpWHOpWQHPYHWWpNILJ\HOHPEHKHO\HVYDJ\OHJDOiEEJRQGRONRGiVUD|V]W|Q]Qp]HWHLW DV]HPEHQiOOyNpUYHLMyUpV]WIHNHWHIHKpUYpJOHWHNEHQPR]RJWDNW~ODKDV]QiOKDWyJRQGRODWRN QDNNLMiUyLJD]ViJWpWHOHQDPLQGHQNRULWXGRPiQ\RVViJEDYHWHWWKLWPHJNtYiQMDD]HJpV]NpUGpV FVRSRUWWLV]Wi]iViWpVDWpQ\HNWHOMHVIHOWiUiViW6]WiOLQQHPD]WFiIROWDPHJDPLW0DUUiOOtWRWW

EiUW|EEHVHWEHQLJD]DYROWYHOHV]HPEHQGHQHPFiIROWKDQHPFVDNGHNODUiOWtUiVDLLGHROyJLDL MHOOHJ&HNYROWDNSRQJ\RODpVHOOHQWPRQGyPHJIRJDOPD]iVEDQQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\LYRQDWNR]iV~NLMH OHQWpVHLSHGLJOHJW|EEQ\LUHWpYHVHN+DYDVWpWHOHVHQPHJYL]VJiOMD0DUUWDQDLWNULWLNXVDQPL QVtWLHOIRJDGKDWyKLSRWp]LVHLWLOOHWYHHOYHWHQGiOOtWiVDLWDNpUGpVW~OD0DUUYLWDW|UWpQHWpQpV DWpYWDQRNFiIRODWiQDWXGRPiQ\RVViJpVDWXGRPiQ\WDODQViJHOYLILOR]yILDLYRQDWNR]iVDLWpULQWL

$0DUUL]PXVYLWDpYHLEHQPpJNRUWiUVLpVPpJpOKD]DLQ\HOYpV]HNpUGHNOGpVVHOODSR]]iN iWHN|WHWHWNtYiQFVLDQNHUHVLND]J\PDJ\DURUV]iJLNLKDWiViWGHHWHNLQWHWEHQDV]HU]FVDN%e.e6

9(5$PXQNiLUDXWDOY|$KLiQ\]ySDUDGLJPD'HEUHFHQ(UUHPpJNpVEEYLVV]DWpUHN 6]HU]QNLQWHQ]tYWXGRPiQ\RVIHONpV]OWVpJJHOKDMWRWWDYpJUHYiOODONR]iViW0LQWHJ\P&

YHWVRUROI|OD]LURGDORPMHJ\]pNEHQDPHO\QHNW~OQ\RPyUpV]HRURV]Q\HOY&D]RQNtYODYRQDWNR]y QHP]HWN|]LV]DNLURGDORPtUiVDLWLV$PHJMHOHQWSXEOLNiFLyNKR]NLHJpV]tWpVNpQWIHOGROJR]WDDNR UiEEDQQHPLVPHUWLOOHWYHKR]]iIpUKHWHWOHQOHYpOWiULDQ\DJRWEHOHpUWYHD]DNWiNKR]OHYHOHNKH]tUW V]pOMHJ\]HWHNHWWDQiFVNR]iVLMHJ\]N|Q\YHNHWVWE

$]HOVIHMH]HW,0DUU²HOVWHUMHGHOPHVHEEUpV]H²U|YLGHQLVPHUWHWLD]

DSDLiJRQVNyWV]iUPD]iV~*U~]LiEDQIHOQWW1\LNRODM-DNRYOHYLFV0DUU²pOHW~WMiW 0HJWXGMXNKRJ\PiUNRUDILDWDOViJiEDQIHOW&QWVRNLUiQ\~pUGHNOGpVpYHOpVWHKHWVpJpYHOINpSS Q\HOYWXGiViYDODPHO\D]DQ\DQ\HOYpQpVD]|UPpQ\HQNtYONLWHUMHGWDNODVV]LNXVQ\HOYHNUHWHU PpV]HWHVHQD]RURV]UDpVW|EE~MODWLQQ\HOYUHEHQLUDWNR]LNEHDV]HQWSpWHUYiULHJ\HWHPUH EHQPHJNDSMDDPDJLV]WHULIRNR]DWRWHJ\EHQPHJEt]RWWSURIHVV]RULFtPHWEHQGRNWRU pVWHOMHVMRJ~SURIHVV]RUOHV]$WWyONH]GYHKDWDOPDVWXGRPiQ\RVWHOMHVtWPpQ\pUHYDOyWHNLQWHWWHO HJ\UHQDJ\REEPHJEHFVOpVEHQOHWWUpV]HKDOiOiLJVWVRNiLJD]RQW~O

$]HOVIHMH]HWPiVRGLNUpV]H²GRNXPHQWiFLy0DUUQDNDVRNiLJpVVRNDNiOWDOHO LVPHUWPDMGNpVEEVRNDNiOWDOPHJEtUiOWHOYHWHWWOHFVHSOWtUiVDLEyO(]D]DQ\DJD]HJ\HVQp]H WHNHWWDUWDOPD]ytUiVRNQDNKRVV]DEEYDJ\U|YLGHEEOpQ\HJLNLYRQDWDV]HU]QNPDJ\DUIRUGtWiVi EDQ 0LQW LO\HQ ² QHP V]iPtWYD D 0DUUYLWD VRUiQ PHJMHOHQW PDJ\DU Q\HOY& UpV]OHWHNHW ² HOV]|UDGWHOMHVNpSHWDKD]DLQ\HOYpV]HNV]iPiUD(QQHNDWHUMHGHOPHVDOIHMH]HWQHNDFtPHÄ$

Q\HOYUO V]yOy ~M WDQtWiV´ RURV]XO Ä1RYRMH XqHQLMH R MD]\NH´ DKRJ\DQ 0DUU Q\RPiQ INpQW HJ\LNOHJWHNLQWpO\HVHEEKtYH,,0HãqDQLQRYP&YHLEOHOWHUMHGW

$ N|YHWNH] DOIHMH]HWEHQ $ Q\HOYUO V]yOy ~M WDQtWiV pUWpNHOpVH ² HOHP]L +DYDV 0DUUQDNHJ\HVWpWHOHLWQp]HWHLWHOPpOHWHLWWpPiNV]HULQWLUHQGEHQNLURVWiOMDD]pUWpNWHOHQYDOy EDQWXGRPiQ\WDODQIDQWD]PDJyULiNDWDQpKiQ\pUWpNHVHEEYL]VJiODWUDWRYiEEIHMOHV]WpVUHDONDOPDV HOPpOHWQp]HWN|UpEO(O|OMiUyEDQPHJMHJ\]HPKRJ\YROWDNpSSFVDNHJ\PHJNpUGMHOH]HWOHQHOPp OHWHWWDOiOHN|UEHQDVWDGLDOLWiVHOPpOHWpW$]HOYHWHQGWp]LVHNN|]pWDUWR]LNHOVVRUEDQD]~Q QpJ\HOHP&DQDOt]LVD]HOHPHNV]iPDUOUHGXNiOyGRWWPLV]HULQWD]ÄVL´V]DOEHUMRQURV J\|N|NEO NHOHWNH]WHN D W|U]VL I|OGUDM]L QHYHN pV D Q\HOYHN N|]V]DYDL YDJ\LV H]HNQHN D] HOH PHNQHN D] |VV]HWpWHOpEO KDQJDODNL YiOWR]iViEyO SO DV]DO HOHP KYHO\H]KHW NL D7KHVDOLD ,WDOLD7XUDQQHYHNEODURVJ\|NQ\RPiWU]LD5XV¶2URV]I|OG¶pVD]RURV]UXND¶Np]¶² (OYHWHQGKRJ\D]HPEHULEHV]pGDNp]Q\HOYEODODNXOWNL0DUUHOXWDVtWRWWDD]|VV]HKDVRQOtWypV W|UWpQHWLPyGV]HUUHOIHOiOOtWRWWQ\HOYURNRQViJHOPpOHWpWW|EEHNN|]|WWD]LQGRJHUPiQQ\HOYHNpW DPLDEL]RQ\tWpNRNVRUDXWiQNpSWHOHQVpJ7pYHVJRQGRODWD]tUiVUHQGV]HUHNpVDQ\HOYLDODNWDQL WtSXVRNN|]WLSiUKX]DP1LQFVUHiOLVDODSMDD]HJ\HWHPHVQHP]HWN|]LiEpFpNLDODNXOiViQDN$]HJ\

VpJHV YLOiJQ\HOY OpWUHM|WWpUO XJ\DQ OHKHW YLWDWNR]QL GH LUUHiOLV IHOWpWHOH]QL KRJ\ D] QHP KDQJ Q\HOYOHV]$]HPEHULEHV]pGOpWUHM|WWpUOHOPpONHGYH0DUU~J\YpOLKRJ\DPDJiQKDQJ]yNYiOWR]iVD VLEEMHOHQVpJPLQWDPiVVDOKDQJ]yNp(]pSSRO\DQDODSWDODQILNFLyPLQWD]D]HOPpOHWKRJ\

DW|EEHVV]iPHOEEM|WWOpWUHPLQWD]HJ\HVV]iP

$]RURV]V]DYDNpVQHYHNtUiVPyGMiEDQDV]HU]DPDJ\DURViWtUiVWDONDOPD]]DDUHFHQ ]HQVYLV]RQWDV]ODYLV]WLNiEDQKDV]QiODWRViWtUiVWKDV]QiOMD

$ PHJYL]VJiOiVUD DONDOPDV WpWHOHN N|]O D] ~Q JORWWRJyQLD D Q\HOYL IHMOGpV XQLYHU]iOLV YROWDYpJHUHGPpQ\EHQEHOHLOOHV]WKHWD]XQLYHU]iOLiNNXWDWiViQDNN|UpEHDUHFHQ]HQVPDJDLVKDV]

QiOMDDJORWWRJyQLDWHUPLQXVW1\LWRWWDEEWHyULiNN|]pWDUWR]LNDPHGLWHUUiQWpUVpJWOPLQWDNXOW~UD N|]SRQWMiWyOYDOyWiYROViJDD]DUFKDLNXVQ\HOYHNQHNYDJ\LVKRJ\PLQpOWiYRODEENHUOQHNHQ\HOYHN DQQiODUFKDLNXVDEEV]HUNH]HWHWPXWDWQDNI|O$]~QMDIHWLNXVQ\HOYHNUOV]yOyHOPpOHWQHPPRQGKD Wy WXGRPiQ\WDODQQDN D] LQGRHXUySDL Q\HOYHNNHO YDOy |VV]HIJJpVN SOiQH KRJ\ H] XWyEELDN D]

HOEELHNEO V]iUPD]WDN V]pW EL]RQ\tWDWODQ GH QHP NpSWHOHQVpJ NO|QEHQ D ÄMDIHWLWD Q\HOYHN´

PHJMHO|OpV0DUUQiOKROFVDNDNDXNi]XVLQ\HOYHNUHKROPiVQ\HOYHNN|UpUHLVYRQDWNR]LN 0DUUDSROLJHQH]LVKtYHGHHEEHQDWHNLQWHWEHQRV]WR]LNVRNPiVQ\HOYpV]pVQ\HOYE|OFVHO iOOiVSRQWMiYDO

8J\DQFVDNQ\LWRWWKLSRWp]LVDQ\HOYpVDJRQGRONRGiVNLDODNXOiViUyOV]yOyIHOIRJiVD0DUU QDNDNLPLQWDPHQWDOLVWDiOOiVSRQWKtYHDJRQGRONRGiVHOVEEVpJpWYDOOMD

$]DODNWDQLQ\HOYWDQLIRUPiNQDNDN|OFV|Q]pVpWLOOHWHQ+DYDVHOIRJDGKDWyQDNWDUWMD0DUU Qp]HWHLWUiPXWDWYiQKRJ\SpOGiXODV]ORYiNHOVV]yWDJ~KDQJV~O\WW|EEHQPDJ\DUHUHGHW&

QHNYpOLN+DGGHPOtWVHPPHJH]LUiQ\~NpWHO\HPHWDPHO\HWHJ\NRUiEELFLNNHPEHQIHMWHWWHPNL 01\WXGQLLOOLNDNpUGpVQHPYiODV]WKDWyHODFVHKpVDOHQJ\HOKDQJV~O\R]iViWyODPHO\

EL]RQ\iUDDPDJ\DUWyOIJJHWOHQOIHMOG|WWNLD]VV]OiYEyO'HYDQQDNHWpPDN|UEHQKLKHWEE SpOGiN LV tJ\ D NHOHWL V]OiY Q\HOYHN QpYV]yL iOOtWPiQ\D DPHO\ QpPHO\HN V]HULQW D N|]pSNRUWyO DILQQXJRUV]RPV]pGViJKDWiViQDNN|YHWNH]PpQ\H

1pKiQ\PiVIHOKDV]QiOKDWyWpWHOpQW~O+DYDVDVWDGLiOLVV]DNDV]RVYiOWR]iVRNHOPpOHWpWNL IHMH]HWWHQJ\P|OFV|]GHPpJNLpUOHOHWOHQKLSRWp]LVQHNWDUWMD(UUOpUWHNH]LNHJ\NO|QDOIHMH ]HWEHQ$VWDGLiOLVWLSROyJLD²(EEHQD]HOPpOHWEHQDPRQGDWWDQLWLSROyJLDGLDNURQLNXV YL]VJiODWiUyOYDQV]y,O\HQLUiQ\~YL]VJiODWRNPiVPiVQpYHQQ\XJDWLQ\HOYpV]HNUpV]pUOLVW|U WpQWHN$VWDGLDOLWiVWDQXOPiQ\R]iVDYROW0DUUN|YHWLQHN6'.DFQHOVRQQDN,,0HãqDQLQRY QDNpVPiVRNQDNpUGHNOGpVNHJ\LNIWpPiMD.O|QIpOHIHMOGpVLVpPiNDWiOOtWRWWDNI|O0HãqD QLQRYEDQNLDGRWWN|WHWpEHQD]HUJDWtYPRQGDWEyODQRPLQDWtYSOLQGRHXUySDLPRQGDWWt SXVEDYDOyiWPHQHWHWiOODStWMDPHJDPLW|EEYiOWR]DWEDQPiU0DUUQiOPHJMHOHQW

+DYDVHJ\pENpQWNLHPHOL²KRJ\0DUUQDNV]iPRVKLSRWpWLNXVRO\NRUWpYHVJRQGR ODWDPiVYiOWR]DWEDQFVtUiMiEDQD;9,,,V]i]DGXWiQP&N|GNLYiOyQ\XJDWLQ\HOYpV]HNtUiVDLEDQ V]LQWpQPHJWDOiOKDWy

(GGLJYROWV]y0DUUQDNNLIHMH]HWWHQQ\HOYpV]HWLYRQDWNR]iV~JRQGRODWDLUyOÈPDDVpYHN YpJHIHOp0DUUFVDWODNR]RWWDIRUUDGDORPWiERUiKR]pVDPDU[LVWDHV]PpNKtYHOHWWWDYiV]iQ SHGLJD7XGRPiQ\RV$NDGpPLDHOQ|NKHO\HWWHVHXJ\DQHEEHQD]pYEHQDSiUW;9,NRQJUHVV]XViQ 6]WiOLQEHV]pGHYpJH]WpYHOHOVKR]]iV]yOyOHWW1RVPiUNRUiEELQp]HWHLWN|YHWYHDPDU[LLGHROyJLD NHUHWHLEHLOOHV]NHGYHIHOiOOtWRWWDD]WDWpWHOpWPLV]HULQWDQ\HOYIHOpStWPpQ\pVRV]WiO\MHOOHJ&²

$Q\HOYRV]WiO\MHOOHJpW0DUUPpJD]VLW|UWpQHOHPHOWWLWiUVDGDOPLWDJR]yGiVUDYH]HWLYLVV]D DPL²NpVEE6]WiOLQQiOLV²KHYHVHOXWDVtWiVWiUJ\DOHWW+DYDVD]RQEDQUiPXWDWKRJ\DWpYHVHQ pUWHOPH]HWWGHDP~J\LVQHPYLOiJRVDQIRJDOPD]RWWWpWHOP|J|WW0DUUV]RFLROHNWXVWpUWHWWQHP SHGLJWiUVDGDOPLRV]WiO\W2O\DQpUWHOHPEHQYLV]RQWLJD]D]KRJ\DQ\HOYLIJJOHJHVUpWHJH]

GpVEHQDV]RFLROHNWXVRND]HJ\HVWiUVDGDOPLUpWHJHNKH]N|WGQHN$]|WpYWL]HGHNLGROJR]RWWGL JORVV]LDMHOHQVpJHLPLQGHQWiUVDGDORPEDQYLVHOLND]HJ\HVUpWHJHNQ\HOYLVWtOXVMHJ\HLWINpSSDV]y NLQFVEHQGHSpOGiXODMDSiQpVDNRUHDLQ\HOYEHQDODNWDQLPHJQ\LOYiQXOiVDLNLVYDQQDN0DUUQDND]

RV]WiO\pVDQ\HOYUHQGV]HUV]RURVNDSFVRODWiWEL]RQ\JDWyiOOtWiVDD]RQEDQPLQGHQDODSRWQpONO|]

$ Q\HOY IHOpStWPpQ\MHOOHJpUH Qp]YH +DYDV ² INpSS 6]WiOLQ D]RQ iOOtWiViW FiIROMD PHJORJLNDLpUYHNNHOKRJ\DQ\HOYQHPD]GHQHPiOOtWMDPDJDKRJ\DQ\HOYRV]WiO\MHOOHJ&

7HNLQWVQNHODPDU[LVWDLGHROyJLiWyOGHYHJ\NILJ\HOHPEHD]WDWpQ\WKRJ\DWiUVDGDOPLYiOWR ]iVRNDJD]GDViJLLSDULIHMOGpVYLVV]DWNU|]GLNDQ\HOYEHQSRQWRVDEEDQDV]yNLQFVEHQINpQW DP&YHOWVpJLpVV]DNV]DYDNEDQ,O\HQpUWHOHPEHQ+DYDVV]LQWpQHJ\HWpUW0DUUQDND]RQQp]HWpYHO KRJ\ÄDJRQGRONRGiVpVDQ\HOYDWiUVDGDOPLViJIJJYpQ\H´

0LQWDKRJ\DQ+DYDVpUWpNHOpVpEOLVNLW&QLNDNDXND]ROyJXVRNN|UpEHQ2URV]RUV]iJEDQpV Q\XJDWRQ HJ\DUiQW 0DUU JU~] |UPpQ\ pV PiV NDXNi]XVL Q\HOY&V]yWiUDL Q\HOYWDQDL UpJpV]HWL QpSUDM]LVWEPXQNiLWDQXOPiQ\DLDV]DNiJD]DWQDNPDLVHOLVPHUWIRUUiVDL

$N|WHWPiVRGLNUpV]HÄ0DUUL]PXV´FtPDODWW²DQpYDGyWXGRPiQ\RVP&N|GpVpW HOPpOHWpQHNQp]HWHLQHNHOWHUMHGpVpWKtYHLQHNpVHOOHQIHOHLQHNtUiVDLWYLWiLWLVPHUWHWLDKDOiODXWiQL LGNHWLVEHOHpUWYHHJpV]HQD0DUUYLWiLJ$YLWiNDPHO\HNNRUiEEDQYiOWR]yKHYHVVpJJHO IRO\WDN0DUUEHQEHN|YHWNH]HWWKDOiODXWiQMyUpV]WHOFVLWXOWDN$V]WiOLQLWHUURUQDNWyO NH]GYHV]iPRVQ\HOYpV]HVHWWiOGR]DWXONO|Q|VHQDV]ODYLVWiNN|UpEHQYpJ]HWWWLV]WRJDWiVRNIR O\DPiQDNLNHOOHQDQ\XJDWLWXGyVRNNDOYDOyNDSFVRODWXN16]7UXEHFNRMÄKHUFHJ´pVD]yV]OiY HYDQJpOLXPL V]|YHJHNQHN WDQtWiVD YROW D YiG GH D PDUUL]PXV N|YHWpVH YDJ\ HOYHWpVH QHP YROW DOHWDUWy]WDWiVRNUJ\HpVPDUULVWiNVWDQWLPDUULVWiNHJ\DUiQWYHV]WHWWpNpOHWNHWYDJ\UDERVNRGWDN KRVV]~LGHLJDEEDQDNRUV]DNEDQSO9%$SWHNDUpV-H'3ROLYDQRYpVN|]|WWKH YHVpOHVVpJJHO~MXOWDNNLDYLWiNLOOHWYHDSR]tFLyKDUFRNDPHO\HNNtVpULLOOHWYHN|YHWNH]PpQ\HL YROWDNPiVNXOWXUiOLVWpUHQNLUREEDQWNRQIURQWiFLyNQDN/LW\HUDWXUQDMD*D]HWD/LV]HQNRVWE

$KDUPDGLNUpV]0DUUL]PXVYLWD²D]WDYDV]iWyONH]GYHIHOOREEDQWYLWDVR UR]DWQDNDV]&NHEEWXGRPiQ\V]DNRQW~OPHQpVDSiUWSROLWLNiEDEHOHMiWV]yHVHPpQ\HLWWiUMDI|O

(EEHQDUpV]EHQDPDUUL]PXVKtYHLQHN1ýHPRGDQRY0HãþDQLQRYpVPiVRNpVHOOHQIHOH LQHN$6ýLNREDYD9$6HUHEUHQQLNRYVWEYDODPLQWD]LQJDGR]yNN|]YHWtWN*6DQåHMHY tUiVDLQDNWHUMHGHOPHVNLYRQDWDROYDVKDWyD3UDYGDPiMXVpQIRO\WDWyODJN|]|OWODSMDLQ(U UHN|YHWNH]HWW6]WiOLQQDNM~QLXViQQDSYLOiJRWOiWRWWKRVV]DEEFLNNHDPHO\HWPpJNHWWN|YH WHWW6]WiOLQSXEOLNiOiVDLN|]EHQD3UDYGDPpJW|EEFLNNHWN|]|OWN|]WN0DUUNRUiEELKtYHLQHN

|QNULWLNiMiYDOpVDÄE|OFVYH]HW´LUiQWLKR]VDQQiYDO$N|YHWNH]DOIHMH]HWHNEHQ²+DYDV t]HNUHV]HGL6]WiOLQNLMHOHQWpVHLWWRYiEEiWpYHVpVGLOHWWiQVQ\HOYpV]HWLPHJiOODStWiVDLWUiPXWDWHO OHQWPRQGypV]DYDURVQp]HWHLUHD]RV]WiO\MHOOHJpVDIHOpStWPpQ\PDU[LVWDpUWHOPH]pVpWLOOHWHQ ( WHNLQWHWEHQ D Q\HOYpV]HNQHN D 6]RYMHWXQLyEDQ pV PiV RUV]iJRNEDQ QHP YROWDN NpWHO\HLN KDEiU SHUV]HD]RURV]Q\HOYpV]HNH]WQ\tOWDQQHPKDQJR]WDWKDWWiN$]WRYiEEUDLVUHMWpO\PDUDGKRQQDQ YHWWH6]WiOLQDQ\HOYpV]HWLDGDWRNDW6HPPLNpSSHQVHPýLNREDYiWyOKDEiUiSULOLViEDQKi URPV]RULVMiUW6]WiOLQQiODNLV]DNLURGDOPLMDYDVODWRWNpUWWOH$]HJ\LNQDJ\EDNO|YpVH6]WiOLQ QDND]D]iOOtWiVDKRJ\D]RURV]Q\HOYÄQHP]HWLDODSMD´DNXUV]NRUMROLQ\HOYMiUiVOHWW$WpQ\

D] KRJ\ D] LURGDOPL pV D P&YHOW N|]Q\HOY D] pV]DNL pV D GpOL RURV] Q\HOYMiUiVRN N|]WL iWPHQHWL Q\HOYMiUiVOHWW0RV]NYDWpUVpJpQHNN|]SRQWMiYDO.O|QEHQOpWH]LNNXUV]NRUMROLDOQ\HOYMiUiVDGpOL RURV]Q\HOYMiUiVRNN|]pSVGpOLWpUVpJpEHQ+DYDV6]WiOLQIHOOpSpVpWD]IpNWHOHQEHFVYiJ\iYDO PDJ\DUi]]DDPHO\WOYH]HWWHWYHIHODNDUWDWQWHWQLPDJiWDQ\HOYpV]HWLNpUGpVHNV]DNpUWMHNpQW

6]WiOLQFLNNHLXWiQDPDUULVWiNYHUHVpJHWV]HQYHGWHNGH²PLQW+DYDVKDQJV~O\R]]D²RO\DQ V~O\RVPHJWRUOiVRNEDQQHPYROWUpV]NDNiUFVDNHOOHQIHOHLNQHNNRUiEEDQPLQWPiVWXGRPiQ\

V]DNRNP&YHOLQHNP&YpV]HNQHNpVPiVpUWHOPLVpJLHNQHND]HO]LGV]DNRNEDQ'HPpJQHP DODNXOW NL D WXGRPiQ\RV NXWDWiV V]DEDG OpJN|UH pV 6]WiOLQ GLFVtWJHWpVH KDOiOiLJ NLWDUWRWW PDMG 0DUUJRQGRODWDLpVDYHONNDSFVRODWRVYLWDODVVDQIHOHGpVEHPHUOWHNEDQPpJDKUXVFVRYL NRUV]DNEDQMHOHQWPHJ9LQRJUDGRYHODGiVDHJ\WXGRPiQ\RVYLWiEDQDV]WiOLQLÄV]HPpO\LNXOWXV]´

NRUV]DNiUyODPHO\EHQHOtWpOLDPDUUL]PXVMHOHQVpJpWLV

$ QHJ\HGLN UpV] ,9 0HWDPDUUL]PXV ² LVPpW IHOYHWL D WXGRPiQ\RVViJ pV WXGR PiQ\WDODQViJ HOYL ILOR]yILDL SUREOpPiMiW INpQW %pNpV 9HUD HPOtWHWW N|WHWpWO YH]HWWHWYH SHGLJ +DYDV~J\OiWMDKRJ\DPDUULJRQGRODWRNOpQ\HJpEHQDÄJ|WWLQJDL´+XPEROGWQ\HOYV]HPOpOHWWHO D]RQRVtWKDWyNWHKiWDQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\WDWiUVDGDORPWXGRPiQ\RNN|]pLOOHV]WLV]HPEHQDÄNDUWp ]LiQXVL´SDUDGLJPiYDODPHO\DJRQGRONRGiVHOVEEVpJpEONLLQGXOYDWHUPpV]HWWXGRPiQ\LMHOOHJ&QHN WDUWMD+DYDVQDND]HOEELWpPiMiWLOOHWD]RQQp]HWpKH]DPHO\V]HULQWDWXGRPiQ\RVViJYDJ\DQQDN KLiQ\D FVDN D SDUDGLJPiQ EHOO tWpOKHW PHJ XWDORN D PDUUL Wp]LVHNQHN WpWHOHV IHOOEtUiODWiUD

²DPHO\HNEHQW|EEWDQtWiViWYHWLHOWXGRPiQ\WDODQViJDPLDWW$]WYDOORPPDJDPKRJ\

DPtJDWHUPpV]HWWXGRPiQ\EDQiOWDOiEDQHJ\|QWHW&HQPHJiOODStWKDWyKRJ\PLWXGRPiQ\WDODQSO

[ DYt]|VV]HWpWHOH+2DGGLJDWiUVDGDORPWXGRPiQ\RNEDQDQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\EDQH]QHP PLQGLJ OHKHWVpJHV HJ\|QWHW&HQ iOWDOiQRV HJ\HWpUWpVVHO 0DJDP SpOGiXO D JORWWRNURQROyJLiW YD ODPLQWDPDJ\DUpVXUiOLQ\HOYHNVXPHUHUHGHWpQHNILNFLyMiWQHYH]QpPWXGRPiQ\WDODQQDN0LQG NHWWHVHWpEHQ D NLLQGXOiV WpYHV D Q\HOYHN DODSV]yNLQFVpQHN HJ\HQOHWHV YiOWR]iVD HJ\ QDJ\REE LGV]DNDODWWLOOHWYHD]|VV]HYHWHWWV]yDODNRNUHQGH]HWOHQVpJHDKDQJW|UYpQ\HNQHJOLJiOiVDPLDWW

9HVVQNHJ\SLOODQWiVWDKD]DLPDUUL]PXVW|UWpQHWpUH%pNpV9HUDDKiERU~XWiQLLGV]DNWyO DV]WiOLQLFLNNPHJMHOHQpVpLJWpWHOHVHQiWYL]VJiOWDDPHJMHOHQWSXEOLNiFLyNDWpV~J\OiWMDKRJ\

DPDUUL]PXVQDNQpKiQ\KtYHiOWDONLIHMWHWWNDPSiQ\PDUJLQiOLVMHOOHJ&YROWQHPpOHVpVQHPN|

YHWWHPHJWRUOiV$YDOyGLW|UWpQHWD]RQEDQHWWODNpSWOOpQ\HJHVHQHOWpU$KRJ\DQD6]RYMHWXQL yEDQ PLQGHQ GLNWDW~UiEDQ ~J\ 0DJ\DURUV]iJRQ VHP PLQGHQW SXEOLNiOWDN SOiQH QHP NDSWDN Q\LOYiQRVViJRW D KiWWpUEHQ D SiUWN|]SRQWEDQ IRO\y WDQiFVNR]iVRN EHIRO\iVROiVRN D G|QWpVHN PHJKR]DWDODHOWW$PDJ\DUQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\²EHQYiOViJRVKHO\]HWEHQYROWNLYiOyWXGy VDLQN PLQW 3DLV 'H]V =VLUDL 0LNOyV .QLH]VD ,VWYiQ pV PiVRN DWWyO WDUWRWWDN KRJ\ D PDJ\DU ILQQXJRU V]ODYLV]WLNDL pV PiV WDQV]pNHNHW pSSHQ D] ÄHJ\HGO PDU[LVWD PDUUL HV]PpN´ MHJ\pEHQ PHJV]QWHWLNSURIHVV]RUDLWHOERFViWMiND]HJ\HWHPHNUOYDJ\PpJURVV]DEEW|UWpQLNYHONJRQ GROMXQNDUUDKRJ\EHQMDYiEDQIRO\WDNDNLWHOHStWpVHN$6]WiOLQFLNNDPHO\QpKiQ\QDSSDO D3UDYGDFLNNXWiQPDJ\DUXOMHOHQWPHJD6]DEDG1pSEHQyULiVLIHOOpOHJ]pVWMHOHQWHWWWXGyVDLQN PHJN|QQ\HEEOWHQ ROYDVWiN 6]WiOLQ tUiVDLW pV QHP HOHPH]WpN Q\HOYpV]HWL YDJ\ SOiQH PDU[LVWD Qp]HWHLW(UUOD]LGV]DNUyOY|D1\U²FLNNpWNHYpVVHOD6]WiOLQFLNNHNPHJMHOHQp VHHOWWpVD1\U²FLNNpWDYLWiNOH]DMOiVDXWiQ

+DYDV)HUHQFN|WHWHW~OPHJ\DWXGRPiQ\pVDV]RYMHWSROLWLNDW|UWpQHWpUGHNHOWVpJpQWDQXO ViJXOV]ROJiOKDWDM|YNXWDWyLQDNpVDODSXO0DUUYDODPLQWKtYHLpVD]DQWLPDUULVWiNJRQGRODWDLQDN HOPpO\OWNLpUWpNHOpVpUHW|EEPLQW|WYHQpYWiYROiEyO$QJROYDJ\pVRURV]Q\HOY&IRUGtWiVDKDV]

QRVOHQQHD]RURV]pVDQ\XJDWLQ\HOYpV]HNPDLQHP]HGpNpQHN

$PDUULHV]PpNpVDYHONNDSFVRODWRVWXGRPiQ\SROLWLNDLHOOHQWpWHNpVYLWiNDV]RYMHWXUD ORPWyOIJJPiVRUV]iJRNEDQLVMHOHQWNH]WHN(WpPDNO|QYL]VJiODWUDV]RUXO'H0DUUQp]HWHL SODQpJ\HOHPILNFLyMDNHGYH]YLVV]KDQJUDWDOiOWDN7|U|NRUV]iJEDQDKROD.HPiO$WDWUNiO WDOLQGtWWDWRWW~QÄQDSQ\HOY´*QHV'LOHOPpOHWUHKDWRWW0DJD0DUUW|EEV]|UMiUW7|U|NRUV]iJ EDQDKROQDJ\VLNHU&HODGiVRNDWWDUWRWWVW,,0HãþDQLQRYV]LQWpQIHOOpSHWWEHQDW|U|N Q\HOYpV]NRQJUHVV]XVRQ (UUO OiVG $<ù(7(7,. WDQXOPiQ\iW 'HU VRZMHWLVFKH /LQJXLVW 1 -D 0DUUXQGGLHWUNLVFKH6RQQHQVSUDFKWKHRULH$UFKLYXP2WWRPDQLFXP²

)2'25,679È1

.DUiG\9LNWRU².R]PD,VWYiQ1pYpVQHP]HW

&VDOiGQpYYiOWR]WDWiVQpYSROLWLNDpVQHP]HWLVpJLHUYLV]RQ\RN 0DJ\DURUV]iJRQDIHXGDOL]PXVWyODNRPPXQL]PXVLJ

2VLULV.LDGy%SODS

$NpWWiUVDGDORPW|UWpQpV]V]HU]N|WHWHD Q p Y P D J \ D U R V t W i V R N NpUGpVN|UpQHNHO VPRQRJUDILNXVpUWpN&IHOGROJR]iVD0pJDNNRULVtJ\YDQH]KD²PLQWDN|WHWHOV]DYDWXG WXQNUD DGMD ² LWW FVDN D V]HU]N HGGLJL YL]VJiODWDLQDN OHJIRQWRVDEE HUHGPpQ\HLW DQQDN ÄHOV VXPPi]DWiW´ROYDVKDWMXN$IHOGROJR]iViWIRJyDODSRVpVUpV]OHWHVGHÄDQQ\LEDQHJ\ROGDO~KRJ\

WiUJ\XQNDWHOVVRUEDQD²V]i]DGLPDJ\DUªQHP]HWpStWpV©SUREOpPiLpVV]LPEROLNXVDSSDUi WXViEDQEHW|OW|WWV]HUHSHIHOO´N|]HOtWLPHJ$NpWNXWDWypUWHOPH]pVHV]HULQWDQpYPDJ\D URVtWiV WXODMGRQNpSSHQ ÄQRPLQiOLV DVV]LPLOiFLy´ PHO\ D PDJ\DURUV]iJL DOORJpQ KiWWHU& Qp SHVVpJHW