2QWKHSHULRGLVDWLRQRIWKHKLVWRU\RI+XQJDULDQ
7KHDXWKRUDUJXHVWKDWLWLVQHFHVVDU\WRDGRSWDPRUHGLIIHUHQWLDWHGYLHZRIWKHSHULRGLVDWLRQ RIWKHKLVWRU\RI+XQJDULDQLQSDUWLFXODUZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKH0RGHUQ+XQJDULDQSHULRG²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
-(1.,66
'RERNDpVWiUVDL
(UGpO\NRUDLÈUSiGNRULPDJ\DUW|UWpQHWHHJ\iOWDOiQQHPQ\LWRWWN|Q\YDNXWDWy V]iPiUDWHOHYDQKRPiOO\DOUHMWpOO\HO2NDDGYDYDQDIRUUiVKLiQ\$PHJLVPHUpVEHQ~J\
V]yOYiQFVDNDNUyQLNDLURGDORPQHYHLUHV]HPpO\HLUHHVHPpQ\OHtUiVDLUDWiPDV]NRGKDWXQN PHO\HNDJHV]WDpVNUyQLNDtUiVP&IDMLVDMiWViJDLEyOHUHGHQVRNUHQGEHOLKp]DJJDOHOOHQW PRQGiVVDOEL]RQ\WDODQViJJDOD]tUyLNpS]HOHWW|UHNYpVHNVRNIpOHPHJQ\LOYiQXOiViYDO WHU KHVHN 0LQGH] PDJ\DUi]]D D PRGHUQ ILOROyJLiQDN D WpPiYDO NDSFVRODWRV QHKp] N]
GHOPpWNLYiOWMDD] LQWHUSUHWiFLyNW|EEUHQGEHOLVpJpWHOOHQWpWHLWDNHYpVDQ\DJEyONRPEL QiOiVQDNDIDQWi]LDP&N|GWHWpVpQHNDNpQ\V]HUpWpSS~J\PLQWDV]LJRU~EENULWLNDLQp]
SRQWQDNILOROyJLDLDODSiOOiVQDNDV]NVpJHVVpJpW(UGpO\W|UWpQHWpQHNPLQGV]DNLURGDOPL P~OWMDPLQGD]H]LUiQ\~NXWDWiV|UYHQGHWHVHQV]DSRURGyMHOHQHDOiWiPDV]WKDWMDHWpQ\iOOiVW (EEHDN|UEHiJ\D]yGLN.5,67Ï*<8/$IRO\yLUDWXQNQDNH]pYLHOVV]iPiEDQ
²N|]]pWHWWFLNNHPHO\EHQNUyQLNDLURGDOPXQNQDN(UGpO\OHJNRUiEELW|UWpQHWpKH]
NDSFVROW W|EE V]HPpO\pUO pV QHYpUO tU V]HPEHQ H]HN YDOyViJWDUWDOPiUyO Q\HOYpV] pV UpJpV] ROGDOUyO PHJQ\LOYiQXOW ~MDEE NpWHO\HNNHO .O|Q|VHQ Ä$] yPDJ\DU Q\HOY WDQ~
ViJWpWHOH3HU~MtWiV'pO(UGpO\NRUDLÈUSiGNRULW|UWpQHWpUO´FtP&WDYDO\PHJMHOHQWPXQ NiP LGH YiJy NULWLNDL ² V]HULQWH KLSHUNULWLNDL ² pV]UHYpWHOHLW QHKH]PpQ\H]L 0LHOWW UiWpUQpN QpKiQ\ N|Q\YHPEHQ IHOKR]RWW pV .5,67Ï iOWDO NLIRJiVROW NpUGpVUH KiURP PHJMHJ\]pVWV]NVpJHVHOUHERFViWDQRP
6RNUDWDUWRP.5,67Ï*<8/$W|UWpQHWLpVW|UWpQHWLQpYWDQLPXQNiVViJiQDNHJpV]pW VEHQQHNO|QLV|U|PPHOQ\XJWi]RPD]WDQDJ\ILJ\HOPHWPHO\HW(UGpO\NRUDLW|UWpQHWH IHOIHGpVpQHNV]HQWHOHJpV]V]LQWp]LVWIHO|OHOpVLJHQV]iPRVIRQWRVIULVVJRQGRODWpEUHV]W
UpV]OHWWHOLVWHOtWHWWtUiVDLYDO²6]yEDQOHYN|Q\YHPEHQDYRQDWNR]yV]DNLURGDORPQpYL V]HPpO\UHV]yOyXWDOiVDLWQHPFVDNIRUPDLODJWHWWHPMHJ\]HWDQ\DJEDKDQHPDIHOIRJiVRP WyO HOWpU INpQW D 0$..$,/È6=/ÏWyO *<g5))<*<g5*<WO pV .5,67Ï*<8/ÈWyO V]iUPD]y²HJ\pENpQWHJ\PiVWyOLVW|EEYRQDWNR]iVEDQHOWpU²YpOHPpQ\HNHWiOWDOi EDQDV]HPpO\LpOWPLQVtWpVWHONHUOÄGHO´ÄY|PpJ´ÄPiVNpQW´VWEÄVHPOHJHVtW´
NLWpWHOHNNHOLJ\HNH]WHPPHJMHOHQtWHQL0LYHOD]RQEDQPRVWDV]HPEHQiOOyQp]HWHNNpW ROGDO~YiV]&NOpVpYHOPDUNiQVDEEiYiOiViYDOWXGyVWiUVDPDSHUV]RQiOLVYRQDWNR]iVRNDW
²PHJOHKHWUpV]EHQV]NVpJV]HU&HQ²MREEDQHOWpUEHKHO\H]YHQpPLOHJNULWLNDLVWtOXVW YiOWRWWMHOHQHOOHQYHWpVHLPEHQpQLVMREEDQUiNpQ\V]HUOWHPD]DG SHUVRQDPXWDOiVRNUD D PDJDP UpV]pUO SHUV]H WRYiEEUD LV NHUOQL LJ\HNH]YpQ D V]HPpO\L PLQVtWpVHNHW ² +DUPDGLN NLIHMH]HWWHQ WHFKQLNDL MHOOHJ& PHJMHJ\]pVHP KRJ\ YiODV]RPEDQ FVDN D]RNDW D] DGDWRNDW ELEOLRJUiILDL XWDOiVRNDW DGRP PHJ DPHO\HNHW N|Q\YHP YDODPLQW .5,67ÏN|]OHPpQ\HQHPWDUWDOPD]]D
.5,67ϲ)(+e57Ï,.$7$/,1QDOYLWi]YD²V]yEDQOHYN|Q\YHPEHQLVIHQQD NDGD]RQKRJ\$QRQ\PXV'RERNiMiWQHPWDUWRPKLWHOHVV]HPpO\QHNVtJ\(UGpO\W|UWp QHWHV]HUHSOMpQHNVHP5pJyWDH]DQp]HWHPOPiU01\PRVWFVDND]pUW NH]GHPYiODV]RPDWD'RERNDNpUGpVVHOPHUW H E E H Q H O Y L V ] L Q W H Q E H Q Q H Y D Q P L Q G H Q W R Y i E E L H O O H Q W p W Q N DPLUOPRVWYLWi]XQN
3PHVWHUFDSLWXOXPiEDQHJ\V]HUHPOtWL'RERNiW&VDQiGDSMiQDNQHYHNpQWÄ6XQDG ILOLXVGREXFD QHSRV UHJLV´ DQHSRV MHO] &VDQiGUD YRQDWNR]LN $ QpY YLVHOMpUO D JHV]WDV]&NHEEV]|YHJN|UQ\H]HWpEOFVDNDQQ\LWWXGXQNPHJWHKiWKRJ\ 'RERND&VD QiGDSMDNpQWDNLUiO\URNRQDHUGpO\LYRQDWNR]iVDNDSFVRODWDD]RQEDQHJ\iOWDOiQQLQFV D]HPOtWpVQHN$P&WRYiEELV]|YHJUpV]pEHQPiUQLQFVXWDOiV'RERNiUDpVD0DJLV]WHU QHNHKDSD[QpYMHOHQVpJHQHPIRUGXOHODNUyQLNiNEDQVHP
0LQGLJFVRGiONR]iVVDOYHJ\HVNpWNHGpVVHOUHJLV]WUiOWDPKRJ\D]HJ\pENpQWVHPDW|U WpQHWLKLWHOHVVpJPLQWDIRUUiVDLQDNWHNLQWKHWJHV]WiQNNUyQLNiLQNHIIpOHÄiUYD´V]HPpO\
QHYHLEOPLPLQGHQWWXGWDNNLKR]QLDNRUDLPDJ\DUW|UWpQHOHPNXWDWyLDNLNQHNV]iPiUD SHUV]HNRUiEELW|UWpQHWLQ\HOYpV]HLQNLVDGWDNHEEHQQpPLQpYIHMWPXQtFLyW+RJ\QHFVDN SpOGDQpONOEHV]pOMHNLWWYDQPLQGMiUWDNiUDOHJ~MDEELGNW|UWpQpV]HLWO'RERNiUyOYDO ORWWV]HPpO\LpVHVHPpQ\EHOLUDM](V]HULQW'RERNDEDQ6]HQW,VWYiQPHJEt]iViEyO KDGDWYLVHOWÄ=VRPERUJ\XOD´YDJ\Ä3URNXMJ\XOD´HOOHQOHJ\]WHD]WHOIRJODOWDYiUiW PHO\QHNDNLUiO\LVSiQMiYiWHWWHPHJQHYpWLVDGWDDYiUQDNWRYiEEiD]QHYpEOOHWW PpJQpKiQ\PiVHUGpO\LKHO\VpJQHYH LV IHOJ\HOHWpW NLWHUMHV]WHWWH D V]pNL VyEiQ\iUD IHOHVpJOYHWWH.DUROGRW*\XODOHiQ\iWDKyGtWRWWWHUOHWHQPHJKDJ\WDLOOHWOHJDNLUiOO\DO PHJKDJ\DWWDELUWRNDLEDQ*\XODURNRQViJiWDNLNEOD]|WpV]DNHUGpO\LKRQIRJODOyQHP ]HWVpJV]iUPD]LNËJ\QWWHNLPDJiW$QRQ\PXVHJ\V]HP'RERNiMD(UGpO\NRUDLW|U WpQHWpQHNPHJKDWiUR]yV]HPpO\LVpJpYp,JD]KRJ\DIHQWLN|OWHPpQ\QHN.5,67ÏHJ\
NpWPR]]DQDWiWtJ\'RERNDKi]DVViJiWHOKDJ\WDVWNULWL]iOWDD]pOHWUDM]OpQ\HJpWOiW KDWyODJPpJLVYDOOMD$] L O \ H Q W t S X V ~ H O M i U i V R N H O O H Q SUyEiOWDPN|Q\YHP EHQiOWDOiEDQLVNRQNUpWJHV]WDpVNUyQLNDV]HPpO\HNNHONDSFVRODWEDQLVHOOHQYpOHPpQ\H PHWNLIHMWHQLV]HPpO\HVHQV]LQWpQVDMQiOYDKRJ\D]HIIpOH'RERNDMHOOHJ&QHYHNNDS FViQ.5,67ÏWyOWiUJ\DOWW|EEV]HPpO\pVQpYLVEHOHNHUOWHVRUED$ W|UWpQHWLQpYWDQQDN D]RQEDQDW|UWpQHOHPWXGRPiQ\RNLUiQ\iEDQLVV]NVpJHVW~OOpSQLHDNiUDPDJDP~OWEHOL iUQ\pNDLQLVDPLNRUQHPNLVUpV]EHQURPDQWLNXVQpYIHMWHJHWpVHLYHOPDJDLV|V]W|Q]MHYROWD NRUDLPDJ\DUW|UWpQHOHPIDQWi]LDG~VUDM]DLNLDODNtWiViQDN$QpYWDQV]HPOpOHWLWiJXOiVDpV PyGV]HUEHOL~WNHUHVpVHLHOVVRUEDQpVV]NVpJV]HU&HQLUiQ\XOQDNDW|UWpQHWWXGRPiQ\KD WHWV]LNPLQGHQHNHOWWDKLVWRULRJUiILDIHOpGHQHP]iUNy]KDWQDNHOiOWDOiQRVDEEW|UWpQHWL WDQXOViJRN OHYRQiVD HOO VHP (]HN D IRO\DPDWRN ² PLQW EHYH]HWpVNpSSHQ PiU
XWDOWDP Ui ² NRQIOLNWXVRNNDO LV yKDWDWODQXO HJ\WWMiUQDN GH KLV]HP KRJ\ PLQGNpW LUiQ\EDQNLHJ\HQOtWHUHGPpQ\HNHWLVKR]QDN
9LVV]DWpUYH NRQNUpWDQ'RERNiKR] )(+e57Ï,.$7$/,1 01\ ² LV
²KHO\HVHQ²HEEHQDQpYWDQLLUiQ\EDQLJ\HNV]LNKDODGQL%HOOHDV]yEDQOHYYLWDNpU GpVEHQHJ\QDJ\RQIRQWRVPRPHQWXPRWHPHOHNNLD'RERNDQHYHNV]iPEDYpWHOHN|]|WW HPOtWLKRJ\$QRQ\PXVLGHMpEHQD&ViNQHP]HWVpJN|UQ\H]HWpEHQIHOW&QLNHJ\'RERND QHY&V]HPpO\DNLEHNHUOKHWHWWDJHV]WDtUyOiWyN|UpEHLVLKDQpYN|]OpVUHOPiU
*<g5))<%RJOiUD$ILOROyJLDLE~YiUODWQDNH]HQDSRQWMiQOpSKHWiWD'RERND NpUGpVPHJtWpOpVpQHN~WMDDORJLNDLNRPELQiFLyNRQDODSXOyIDQWi]LDG~VPHJROGiVRNKHO\HWW D V]HPpO\W pV QHYpW H J \ H G O L H OI R U G X O i V N p Q W W D U W D O P D ] y D Q R Q \ P X V L P& SUREOHPDWLNiMD NRPSOH[ V]HPOpOHW&YL]VJiODWDLQDN LUiQ\iED 0pJSHGLJ DEEyO DNXWDWiVLWDSDV]WDODWLWpQ\EONLLQGXOYDKRJ\DJHV]WDLJHQV]iPRVUHMWpO\pUHD V]|YHJ HJpV] EHOV |VV]HIJJpVHLQHN D V]|YHJEO NLVXJiU]y tUyL KDELWXVQDN pV V]iQGpNRNQDN DWpUEHQpVLGEHQN|UQ\H]NOVYLOiJV]|YHJEHQWNU|]GDQ\DJLpVWXGDWLiOODSRWi QDNYL]VJiODWDDNXWDWiVHUHGPpQ\HVVpJpQHNHOVUHQG&GRPLQiQVWpQ\H]MH
$QRQ\PXV HOEHV]pOpVH V]LQWH PLQGHQ IRQWRV PDJ\DU pV FVDWODNR]iVXN XWiQ PD J\DUQDN WHNLQWHWW &XPDQXV V]HUHSOMpQHN GH NO|Q|V ILJ\HOHPPHO D] HONHONQHN ² pSSHQH]HNV]iUPD]iVLPpOWyViJiQDNNLHPHOpVpUH² D S i W Y D J \ I L ~ W D G R W W QHYH ]HWW PHJ .LYpWHOHV JRQGGDO N|YHWNH]HWHVHQ PHJDONRWRWW V]|YHJV]HUNHV]WpVpQHN HPH V]DEiO\V]HU&VpJH DOyO NpW NLYpWHO YDQ HJ\UpV]UO D] LGHJHQ IHPEHUHN YH]pUHN 2WWy .RQUiG /DERUF =RERU VWE PiVIHOO D PDJ\DU ÄNXQ´ pV LGHJHQ N|]HPEHUHN (N|OFV7DUFDO&VHSHO+HWpQ\VWEH]HNVHPDSiWVHPILDWQHPNDSWDNOHJI|OMHEED NLYpWHOHVRNRNEyONLHPHOWV]HPpO\HN0pQPDUyW6]DODQ$MWRQWiYROLVW$ÄN|WHOH]´
DSDpVIL~QHYHNiOWDOiEDQKiURPDOFVRSRUWEDVRUDNR]QDNIDQWi]LDQHYHNgUNpQ\DSMD VHÈOPRVDSMDh¬HNVWEKHO\QHYHN6]HPHUHDSMD+RED%RWRQGDSMD.|OSpQVWE 0DJLV]WHU NRUDEHOL WOH UHQGV]HULQW V]HPpO\HVHQ YDJ\ OHJDOiEELV KtUEO LVPHUW V]H PpO\HN%RQJHUILD%RUVY|%RUVLVSiQgVE&ILD6]DOyNY|6]DOyNQHP]HWVpJVWE
'RERNDVHPPLNpSSHQQHPWDUWR]KDWD]NDWHJyULiED$NDWHJyULiWyO3PHVWHU QpYDGiViWNLYpWHOHVKHO\QpYLVPHUHWHPLDWWPiUDOLJKDOHKHWQHHJ\V]HU&HQHOYLWDWQL$UUyO D]RQEDQ HVHWQNEHQ QHPLJHQ OHKHW V]y KRJ\ D V]HPpO\QHYHW D YiUQpYKH] W|UWpQHWL
|VV]HIJJpVWVHMWHWV]iQGpNNDON|W|WWHYROQD1HPFVDND]pUWQHPKLKHWH]PHUWD&VD QiGGDO |VV]HN|W|WW 'RERNiW HPOtW V]|YHJKHO\QHN 0DURV²7LV]D²$O'XQD N|]pUH XWDOyYROWDQHPKR]KDWy|VV]HIJJpVEHD]pV]DNHUGpO\LWHUOHWWHOWRYiEEiKRJ\D]HSL ]yGV]HU&V]|YHJKHO\QHNVLQFVWDUWDOPLNDSFVROiVD(UGpOO\HOKDQHPNpWPiVLNRNPLDWWVHP YDOyV]tQ&H]$QRQ\PXVDKHO\QHYHNEONUHiOWV]HPpO\QHYHNHVHWpEHQPLQGLJIHOYHV]LD V]HPpO\QHND]D]RQRVQHY&KHO\KH]I&]GRWWYpJ]HWWFVHOHNPpQ\pW(VHWQNEHQHQQHN Q \ R P D V L Q F V (]DPDJ\DUi]DWDDQQDNKRJ\Ä1pYpVW|UWpQHOHP´FtP&WDQXOPiQ\
N|WHWHPQHND]DQRQ\PXVLV]HPpO\QpYDGiVKiUPDVKHO\²V]HPpO\²HVHPpQ\NRUUHOiFL yMiWWiUJ\DOyIHMH]HWpEO²DPLQWHJ\IpOV]i]LGHWDUWR]yV]HPpO\pVQHP]HWVpJ QHYHN|]OV]LJRU~DQWXGDWRVDQNLKDJ\WDP'RERNiWHQpYQpOXJ\DQLVDKHO\KH]N|WG HVHPpQ\IDNWRUWKLiEDNHUHVQN7RYiEEiD0HVWHUPLQGHQRO\DQKHO\]HWEHQDPLNRUYDOD PLO\HQpUGHNEOFpO]DWRV|VV]HIJJpVHNHWOHSOH]HQDV]|YHJEHQHOUHMWYHDNDUWXGDWQLD JHV]WD PiV KHO\pQ FpO]iVW PpJLV WHV] UHi DNiU NO|QNO|Q HSL]yGRNDW LV EXUNROWDQ
|VV]HNDSFVROYDY|$P~OWQHYHLVWE'RERNDHVHWpEHQHUUHVLQFVVHPPLMHO 0DUDGWHKiWOHKHWVpJNpQWD]J\QHND]HPOtWHWWDQRQ\PXVLDSDQpYDGiVLMHOHQVpJHN FVRSRUWMiEDDNRUWiUVQHYHNN|UpEHVRUROiVD$0HVWHUNRUWiUVD 'RERNDEHQ PiUNipUWDGWDHOD)HMpUPHJ\HL%RJOiURQOpYI|OGMpWD&ViNQHP]HWVpJEHOL'HPHWHUQHN +D]2NP$'RERNDPLQWV]HPpO\QpYD]yPDJ\DUNRUEDQLVLJHQULWNDYROWD0D JLV]WHUNRUiEyOSHGLJD]LGp]HWWHQNtYOQLQFVLVUiDGDWH]pUWDJHV]WDpVD]RNOHYpOQpY
D]RQRVViJiWQHKp]YROQDHJ\V]HU&HQYpOHWOHQHJ\EHHVpVQHNPLQVtWHQL(]HVHWEHQD]RQ EDQ MyYDO W|EEUO YDQ V]y 1HPUpJLEHQ $ P~OW QHYHL NN W]HWHVHQ WiUJ\DOWDP
$QRQ\PXVQDND&ViNQHP]HWVpJKH]WDUWR]iViW1HPDNDUQiPD]RWWNLIHMWHWWHNHWUpV]
OHWH]QL GHHJ\NpWWiUJ\XQNUDYRQDWNR]yN|UOPpQ\UHLWWPpJLVXWDOQRPNHOODPHO\LJHQ YDOyV]tQ&YpWHV]LKRJ\D0HVWHUQHPFVDNDIHOKR]RWW'RERNDQHYHWKDQHPDONDOPDVLQWD V]HPpO\WLVLVPHUWH$OHJNO|QE|]EEWpQ\HNHJ\EHYHWpVHWDQ~VtWMDKRJ\D1pYWHOHQD 9pUWHVN|U]HWpEHQLOOHWOHJ)HMpUPHJ\pEHQQDJ\RQRWWKRQRVYROWPLQGDWiMPLQGSH GLJD]RWWDQLELUWRNRVUpWHJYRQDWNR]iViEDQ.O|Q|VHQV]RURVYROWD NDSFVRODWD D &ViN QHPHJ\LNDNNRULIHPEHUpYHO0LNOyVLVSiQQDO²DJHV]WDSUROyJXViEDUHMWHWW1QHOY|
6Ï/<20 ,UW|UW.|]OLV%RJOiURWWIHNGWD9pUWHVN|UQ\pNL&ViNELUWRNRNN|U ]HWpEHQPHO\HNMyUpV]pWDEEDQD]LGEHQpSSHQ0LNOyVEtUWD&ViNYiUD%RJOiUV]RPV]pGMD O $ P~OW QHYHL L K ( WiM ELUWRNRV UpWHJpEO LVPHUWH D 1pYWHOHQ D &ViNRNRQ NtYO D
%DUDFVNiNDWpVD6]DOyNRNDWVH]HNQHNLOOHWOHJH]HNELUWRNDLQDNQHYpEO DONRWWDPHJW|EE KRQIRJODOyKVpQHNQHYpWLVtJ\6]DEROFV9DMWD6]DOyNYH]pUpW$]LGp]HWWRNOHYpOEO NLW&QLNKRJ\DERJOiULELUWRNRV'RERNDLVHQHP]HWVpJHNN|]|WWIRUJyHONHOELUWRNRV OHKHWHWW5LWNDQHYpQHNEHpStWpVHDJHV]WiEDV]RURVDQEHOHWDUWR]LN$QRQ\PXVQDNHJ\UpV]
UO HOIHG UHMWHNH] PiVUpV]UO PpJLV D NRUWiUVDNDW URNRQL NDSFVRODWEyO EDUiWViJEyO LVPHUHWVpJEOWLV]WHOHWEOpUGHNEOELUWRNDVSLUiFLyNVHJtWpVpEOVWEW|EEt]EHQJ\DNR UROWQpYDGiVLV]RNiViEDODNRUDEHOL%RUV6]HPHUH7pWpQ=VRPERU9HOHNVWEQHYHNQHN DKRQIRJODOiVW|UWpQHWEHQYDOyYLVV]DYHWtWMHOOHJ&PHJHOHYHQHGpVpW
$PLpUW$QRQ\PXV&VDQiGDSMiQDNQHYpWHOVGOHJHVtUyLV]iQGpNNDOPLQGHQYDOy V]tQ&VpJ V]HULQW NRUWiUV LVPHUVL N|UEO D ERJOiUL ELUWRNRV 'RERND QHYpEO PLQWi]WD WHUPpV]HWHVHQQHPMHOHQWLD]WKRJ\'RERNDYiUQHYpWQHPLVPHUWH+DQHPLVI|OWpWOHQO D;V]i]DGEDQGHD;,,²;,,,V]i]DGEDQRUV]iJRVKtUHYROW'RERNDYiUQDNPLQWLV SiQViJLN|]SRQWQDNPHO\DOLJKDWHWWHYROQDOHKHWYpKRJ\$QRQ\PXVD.iUSiWPHGHQFH MyUpV]HI|OGUDM]iQDNpVSROLWLNDLLJD]JDWiVLNpSpQHNRO\NLW&QLVPHUMHQHWXGRWWYROQD OpWpUO6WLJHQQDJ\YDOyV]tQ&VpJJHOPHJLVIRUGXOWHWiMRQDPLWLGHYRQDWNR]yJHV]WD EHOL XWDOiVDL 7||W|P KDGMiUDWiQDN OHtUiVD D =VRPERU FVDOiG IHOWHKHWLVPHUHWH EL]R Q\tWKDWQDNLV+RJ\PpUWOHKHWHWWIRQWRV3PHVWHUV]iPiUDKRJ\LVPHUVV]HPpO\UOYHWW QpYDGy|WOHWpWMHOHQWpNHQ\V]HUHS&YiUQpYLVDOiWiPDVV]DD]WPHJDQQ\LV]RUJ\DNRUROW W|UWpQHWLKLWHOHVVpJUHW|UHNYpVHROYDVyLYDODUpJP~OWDWIHOLGp]LJ\HNH]HWHPDJ\DUi]]D -yO LVPHUHWHV KRJ\ D YiUQHYHN IHOKDV]QiOiVD QiOD D UpJLVpJHW iOODQGyViJRW PHQQ\LUH VRNUHQGEHOLOHJV]ROJiOWDHJ\HVQDJ\RQIRQWRVV]HPpO\HNJHV]WiMiEDQNO|QIpOHYiUQpYL NDSFVROyGiVRNQpONOQHPLVLJHQV]HUHSHOQHN
'RERNDYiUQHYHD]RQEDQDIHQWHEEPRQGRWWDNDODSMiQFVDN i W W p W H O H V H Q Pi VRGODJRVLQGXNiOyWpQ\H]NpQWNHUOWEHOHD0HVWHUQpYDGyHOMiUiViED$ERJOiUL'RERND QHYpQLVPLQGHQV]HPpO\LLVPHUHWVpJHQW~OpSSHQD]pUWUDJDGKDWRWWPHJ$QRQ\PXVV]H PHPHUWHQpYP|J|WWDVV]RFLDWtYDQRWWiOOWDYHOHDODNLODJHJ\EHHVQHY&RUV]iJRV LVPHUWVpJ&'RERNDYiUPHO\W|UWpQHWLt]W]DPDWRWDGRWWD] DP~J\LVSiUMiWULWNtWyN
O|QOHJHVV]HPpO\QpYQHNMyONtQiONR]yEL]RQ\RVViJXO&VDQiGDSMDKLiQ\]yiPQpYUHQG V]HUpEHQN|WHOH]HQSyWODQGyPHJQHYH]pVHKLWHOHVVpJpQHN+RJ\'RERNDYiUW|UWpQHWHVHQ (UGpO\EHQIHNGWD]HEEODV]HPSRQWEyO W H O M H V H Q N | ] | P E | V DNpS]HWWiUVtWiV FpOMiWKDWiViWWHNLQWYHOHKHWHWWYROQDD]RUV]iJEiUPHO\PiVUpV]pQLV
0LQGH]HNUHKLYDWNR]YDWDUWRPPDJDPDKKR]D]HUHGHWLiOOiVSRQWKR]KRJ\DJHV]WD 'RERNiMDQHPW|UWpQHOPLV]HPpO\KDQHPD0DJLV]WHUDONDOPL|WOHWpQHNIDQWi]LiMiQDN WHUPpNHN|YHWNH]pVNpSSHQQHPpStWKHWUiVHPPLIpOHHUGpO\LV]HUHSOpVHVHPpQ\VRUR ]DWPLQWDKRJ\D0HVWHUQHND]HJpV]&VDQiGHSL]yGGDO VHPYROWHV]HiJiEDQVHP(U GpO\UHXWDOQL
.5,67ÏFLNNpEONLW&QLNKRJ\WOiWKDWyDQD.HiQNpUGpVUOWOHPtURWWDNpULQ WHWWpNOHJPpO\HEEHQ1\LOYiQQHPYpOHWOHQOPLYHOD](UGpO\W|UWpQHWLNRQFHSFLyMiQDN N|]pSSRQWMiEDQ;V]i]DGLGpOHUGpO\LEROJiUXUDORPiOOpOpQ.HiQQDOV]HPEHQD*\XOiN pV]DNHUGpO\LKDWDOPiYDOWRYiEEi.HiQV]HPpO\pWV]HUHSpWHPHOWHNLpVWHWWHQDJJ\iLGH YiJyV]DNLURGDOPLHO]PpQ\HNG]VXQJHOpEOOHOVVRUEDQ$FWD6]HJ²0HJ MHJ\H]QLNtYiQRPKRJ\PLYHON|Q\YHPWiUJ\DHOVGOHJHVHQDG p O H U G p O \ L * \ X O D N p U G p V YROWRWWFVDN DIJJHOpNV]HU&UpV]EHQIRJODONR]WDP .HiQQDO HOVVRUEDQ ÈNRV PHVWHU EHiOOtWiVDLYDO NDSFVRODWEDQ LJD] YLWDSDUWQHUHP Qp]HWHLYHO HUVHQ HOOHQWpWHVHQ ,VPHUYHNUyQLNiLQNWDUWDOPLLQJDWDJViJDLWNURQROyJLDLV]DEDGRVViJiWHEEpOLHOWpUp VHLNQHNQHPV]DEDGW~OViJRVMHOHQWVpJHWWXODMGRQtWDQLGH .HiQWLOOHWHQVHPOHKHW HO PHQQLMHOOHJ]HWHVHOOHQWPRQGiVDLNPHOOHWW$QRQ\PXV .p]DLpVD;,9V]i]DGLNUyQLND HJ\WWHV ÈNRV PHVWHUWO V]iUPD]y LQWHUSROiFLyL .HiQ GROJiEDQ D QpY HPOtWpVpQ NtYO WXODMGRQNpSSHQFVDNHJ\GRORJEDQHJ\H]QHNPLQGKiUPDQDEEDQKRJ\ .HiQDV]OiYRN pVDEROJiURNXUDYROWLGEHOLWHUOHWLpVFVHOHNPpQ\EHOLJ\HLNEHQ.p]DLQDNpVÈNRV PDJLV]WHUQHN,VWYiQNLUiO\WyOYDOyOHJ\]HWpVpUOV]yOiViQNtYOQLQFVHJ\H]pVN.O|QE VpJHLNWiUJ\XQNDWOHJMREEDQpULQWOpQ\HJHKRJ\FVDNÈNRVQDNYDQQDNN|]YHWHWWPHJ MHJ\]pVHLHUGpO\LYRQDWNR]iVRNUyOYDODPLQWV]~UEHDNyGH[V]|YHJEHUpV]OHWHNHW.HiQ HJ\pEGROJDLUyOURNRQViJiUyOI|OGMpUONLQFVHLUOXUDOPiQDNXWyGOiViUyO0LQGHEEO D]
DOpQ\HJHVKRJ\D.HiQUyOV]yOyV]&N|VEL]RQ\WDODQIRUUiVDQ\DJEDQ È N R V P H V W H U D ] D N L D O H J W | E E H W Ä W X G M D ´ . H i Q U y O EiUUpV]EHQD;V]i]DGN|]HSpUH UpV]EHQD;,V]i]DGHOHMpUHYRQDWNR]WDWRWWLGEHOLVpJHWLOOHWHQY|0(/,&++RQI0J VHP PHQWHV EHOV HOOHQWPRQGiVRNWyO 1HP YpOHWOHQ KRJ\ .5,67Ï .HiQNpSH LV ÈNRVDODSMiQERQWDNR]LNNLOHJLQNiEE
+RJ\$QRQ\PXVNRUiEELIRUUiVEyOYHWWHHDQHYHWYDJ\DNDDQWLV]WVpJQpYLVPH UHWpEHQPDJDIRUPiOWDpSS~J\EL]RQ\WDODQpVNpUGpVHVPLQWDKRJ\DQD]LVKRJ\ .p ]DLQDNpVÈNRVQDND]JHV]WiMDDGRWWH|V]W|Q]pVW|WOHWHWD.HiQN|UOLGROJRNWRYiEE V]|YpVpUHYDJ\QHWDOiQD]XWyEELDNLVLVPHUWHNLGHLOOHV]WKHWPiVIRUUiVRNDW²PLQ GHEEHQVRNDQ\LWRWWNpUGpV$]WPiUNUyQLNiLQNQpYDQ\DJDLVPHUHWpEHQV]LOiUGDEEWDOD MRQPR]RJYDOHKHWPRQGDQLKRJ\D.HiQQpYHJ]DNWQpYWDQLPLQVpJHDODNMDHWLPRQMD VWE|QPDJiEDQQHPEL]RQ\tWMDDV]HPpO\OpWpWW|UWpQHWLYDOyVViJiWpVSHUV]HD]WVHPDPLW UyOD NUyQLNiVDLQN PRQGDQDN ËJ\ W|UWpQHWHVHQ.HiQ QHYpQHN PLQGHQ EL]RQQ\DO D W|U|N NDDQ WLV]WVpJQpYYHO YDOy |VV]HIJJpVH QHP EL]RQ\ViJD NUyQLNiVDLQNWyO D V]OiYViJKR]
YDJ\ pSSHQ D EROJiUViJKR] HJ\|QWHW&HQ YDOORWW WDUWR]iViQDN KLV]HQ D V]OiYViJ N|UpEHQ HWLV]WVpJQpYQHPYROWKDV]QiODWRVDGXQDLEROJiURNYH]HWLWLVUpJWOIRJYDVRKDVHPLO OHWWpNLO\HQQpYYHODIRUUiVRN.5,67ÏHOYLOHJEL]RQ\RVDQKHO\HV~WRQLQGXOWDPLNRUQHP LO\HQLUiQ\RNEDQNHUHVWH.HiQW|UWpQHOPLOpWpQHNLJD]ROiViW$]PiUPiVNpUGpVKRJ\
PiVXWWYDOyEDQPHJWDOiOWDH%L]RQ\tWpNDLWQpJ\WpPDN|UpFVRSRUWRVtWMDDD.DMiQWX ODMGRQQHYHNIHQWPDUDGiVDED.iQQHP]HWVpJV]iUPD]iVDFD]RNOHYHOHV.HiQDGDWRN pUWpNHGÈNRVPHVWHUV]HUHSpQHNPHJtWpOpVH(]HNHWYHV]HPVRUUDDN|YHWNH]NEHQDMHO ]HWWWpPiNHJ\EHV]|YGpVHWHUPpV]HWHVHQQpPHO\NRUHONHUOKHWHWOHQ
.$5È&621<,-È12601HP]WDOiOWDNLKRJ\D.DMiQV]HPpO\pVKHO\QH YHND.HiQQpYIRO\WDWyLD]yWDW|UWpQpV]HLQNtJ\*<g5))<pV.5,67ÏLV.HiQOpWpQHN LJD]ROiVDNpQWWHNLQWHQHNHWXODMGRQQHYHNUH.|Q\YHPEHQH]WDÄEL]RQ\tWpNRW´QHPWDU WRWWDPV]NVpJHVQHNW~OUpV]OHWH]HQFiIROQLGHHO|OMiUyEDQWHWWHPHJ\HJ\KDQJW|UWpQHWL PHJMHJ\]pVWDIHOWHWW.HiQ!.DMiQIHMOGpVSUREOHPDWLNiMiUDPHO\HWYLWDWiUVDPPRVW ÄV]pOVVpJHVHQKLSHUNULWLNXVpVHQQpOIRJYDWpYHVHOYLDODSYHWpVQHN´QHYH]+DPiUKDQJ W|UWpQHWLIHOIRJiVRPDWLO\HQV~O\RVNULWLNDpUWHNpQ\WHOHQOHV]HNPpJYLVV]DWpUQLUiGH U|JW|QPHJMHJ\]HPKRJ\EiUV]&NHEEV]DNPDLYRQDWNR]iVEDQYDQDNpUGpVQHNMHOHQW
VpJHD.HiQJ\EHQN|]HOVHPV]iQWDPLGHYiJyQp]HWHLPHOYLDODSYHWpVpQHNFVXSiQ HJ\V]HU&Q\HOYpV]HWLHYLGHQFLiQDN
+DPiUDGRORJEDEHOHPHQWQNVRNNDOLQNiEEOiWRP Q p Y W D Q L D O D S N p U G p V Q H N D]WPLNpQWYROQDOHKHWVpJHVPDJ\DUi]QLDN|YHWNH]W(J\DNUyQLNDLURGDOPXQN EDQHOV]LJHWHOWV]DNLURGDOPLODJD;V]i]DGUDNURQRORJL]iOWpV(UGpO\UHVHMWHWWV]HPpO\
QpYUOD]WJRQGROQLKRJ\DNpVEELQpYIHMOGpVVRUiQPLQGLJFVDN.DMiQIRUPiEDQ U|J]OYH R U V ] i J R V V ] y U W V i J E D Q MHOHQQpNPHJ(]PHJOHKHWVHQIXUFVDIHOWH YpV1\LOYiQ.5,67ÏLVpV]OHOWLWWQpPLHOOHQWPRQGiVWPHUWHQpYPDUDGYiQ\RNNRUOiWR]RWW V]iPiUDXWDOYDHQ\KtWDWp]LVHQ,JD]KRJ\pQFVDN K p W .DMiQWXODMGRQQHYHWDGDWROWDP DN|]pSNRUEyO+XQ\DGWyO%RGURJLJpV.RPiURPLJGHPpJIRO\WDWKDWWDPYROQDNHWWpU EHQpVLGEHQN|]WNYDOyV]tQ&OHJN|]pSNRULHO]PpQ\UHYLVV]DPHQNHWLV(QQ\L.HiQ
!.DMiQQHY&V]HPpO\V]yUyGKDWRWWYROQDV]pWQpYDGiVLODJMyUpV]WKHO\QpYYpLViWPLQ VOYH" +D PHJ.iQDODN~ QHYHNHW LV LGH VRUROQiQN PLQW .5,67Ï JRQGROMD O HUUO DOiEE DNNRU V]iPXN PpJ WRYiEE V]DSRURGKDWQD XJ\DQFVDN RUV]iJRV YLV]RQ\ODWEDQ $ .DMiQDODN~QHYHNQ\LOYiQPDJ\DUi]DWUDV]RUXOQDNW|EEIpOHHUHGHWUHLVYLVV]DPHKHWQHN
²XWDOWDPLVLO\HQHNUHPXQNiPEDQ²GHH]PiUPiVIHOpYH]HWHWLPROyJLDLNpUGpV 9LVV]DWpUYHDWXGyVWiUVDPWyONLIRJiVROWKDQJW|UWpQHWLJ\UHDUUyOHMWHWWHP NRQN UpWDQLVV]yWKRJ\KDPiUHQQ\L.DMiQIpOHQpYIRO\WDWiVWWHV]QNIHOYDOyViJRVFVRGD YROQDKRJ\DNiUDNDDQWLV]WVpJQpYEODNiUDQQDNHOKDVRQXOW.sDQYiOWR]DWiEyONLIHMH ]HWWHQKLiWXVW|OWpVVHO²IpOUHWpYHPRVWD.iQQpYDODNJ\pW²PLQGHQNRUpVPLQGHQKRO FVDN.DMiQQpYIRUPDDODNXOWYROQDNLPiVKLiWXVW|OWNWHOMHVHOPDUDGiViYDO$UUyOQHP LV V]yOYD KRJ\ .DDQ V]HPpO\QpYL HO]PpQ\QHN PHJIHOHO tUiVPyG~ .DKDQ .DFKDQQpYDGDWQDNQ\RPDVLQFVQ\HOYQNEHQKDOHWWYROQDLO\HQDEEDQQHPNHOHWNH ]HWWYROQDKLiWXVRVKHO\]HWPHUW D]{{U|JW|QiYiDODNXOWYROQDY|W|UþDODDQ!P FVDOiQW|UEDDWXU!PEiWRUW|UDDþL!PiFVVWE²$]HOKDVRQXOW.sDQIRUPiEyO OHKHWHWWYROQDXJ\DQKLiWXVW|OWV.sMiQD]tURWW.HDQDODNpSSHQMYHOLVROYDVKDWyYRO QD iP DNNRU DQQ\L QpYL WRYiEEpOpV IHOWHYpVH PHOOHWW LOOHWW YROQD OHJDOiEE QpKiQ\
.HYDQWpV.HKDQWLVWDOiOQLQRKDH]HNQHNSHUV]HQ\RPXNVLQFV.HOOHWW YROQDPpJ SHGLJD]pUWPHUWDPDJ\DUKLiWXVW|OWpVQHNUpJWOIRJYDHJ\LNOHJMHOOHP]EEVDMiWViJDDY
aMaK$WHUOHWLQ\HOYMiUiVLPHJRV]OiVOIHVIYHVaIMHVaIKHVNHVNYHVa NMHVaNKHVVWE(UUHXWDOHOtWpOWPHJMHJ\]pVHP$]WLVKR]]iWHV]HPSHUV]HPLQGHK KH]KRJ\HOKDVRQXOW.sMiQDODNsMHYLV]RQWQHPYiOKDWRWWYROQDDYiD]D]QHPM|KHWHWW YROQDOpWUHEHOOHD]RO\DQQ\LUDIHOWpWHOH]HWW.DMiQDODNPLQWDKRJ\DOsiQ\EyOVHPOHWW ODMiQ\DUsiEyOVHUDMiVWE'HHOpJPiUDUiPNpQ\V]HUtWHWWHJ]DNWQ\HOYpV]NHGpVEO
.5,67Ï*<8/$ V]HPpEHQ .HiQ YDOyViJRV OpWpQHN HJ\LN IRQWRV EL]RQ\tWpND KRJ\
WOHV]iUPD]LND.iQQHP]HWVpJPHO\QHN.HiQWyOV]iPtWRWWHUGpO\LIRO\DPDWRVViJiWYpOL IHOLVPHUQLeQHQQHNÈNRVPDJLV]WHULGHXWDOyNyGH[EHOLEXUNROWW|UHNYpVHLGDFiUDHJ\HWOHQ NRQNUpWEL]RQ\tWpNiWVHPOiWRPHOOHQpEHQYLV]RQWHJpV]VRUN|UOPpQ\V]iPtWiVEDYHHQG
$QQ\LNpWVpJWHOHQKRJ\DNUyQLNiVRN.HiQQHYHpVD.iQQHP]HWVpJQpYDODNLODJ
|VV]HFVHQJHQHNVWD]VHPYLWDWKDWyKRJ\HJ\.siQDODNEyO²PLQWOiWWXN²KD.DMiQ QHP LV GH.iQ IRUPD NLDODNXOKDWRWW (] D WpQ\ N|QQ\& NpS]HWWiUVtWiVVDO D IDQWi]LiW PHJPR]JDWKDWMDXJ\DQGHVHPDQHP]HGpNEHOLQpYLIRO\WRQRVViJWDQ~ViJiUDVHPDQ\HOYL IRO\DPDWEHN|YHWNH]WpQHNLJD]ROiViUDQHPDONDOPDV$NDGiO\DXJ\DQLVHJ\IHOO D]HUGp O\LQHN ; V]i]DGLQDN EROJiUQDN YpOW.HiQQDN PiVIHOO D PDJ\DU QpYDQ\DJEDQ D Q \ H O Y W H U O H W V ] i P R V U p V ] O H J p E H Q NLPXWDWKDWy.iQ QHP]HWVpJ UDJDG YiQ\pVFVDOiGQHYHNYLVHOLQHNYDODPLQWHQHYHNEOOHWWKHO\QHYHNQHNWpUEHQLGEHQpV Q\HOYLNO|QEVpJEHQIHQQiOOyPHUHYHOOHQWpWHeVDNNRUPpJQ\HOYLYLV]RQ\ODWEDQQHPLV EHV]pOWQNDUUyOKRJ\HJ\RO\DQU|YLGHJ\V]yWDJRVQ\HOYLIRUPiWXP~QpYQHNPLQWD.iQ QDN D W|U|NNDDQ WLV]WVpJQpYEO N|]YHWOHQ V]iUPD]iViW LV EHOHpUWYH W|EEIpOH PiV QHP
YDJ\QHKH]HQNLERJR]KDWyHWLPRQMDOHKHWVpJHVPpJVWHQHYHNVRUR]DWDQHPLVEL]R Q\RVDQPLQGD]RQRVHWLPRQ~OHUUON|Q\YHPEHQ
6RNNDOOpQ\HJHVHEEHNHPH]iOWDOiQRVPHJJRQGROiVRNQiOD NRQNUpWDEEDODSRQEL ]RQ\tWKDWyYDJ\YDOyV]tQ&VtWKHWN|UOPpQ\HN$.iQQHP]HWVpJHWMyRNRNPLDWWD O V y ' U i Y D Y L G p N L V ] i U P D ] i V ~ Q D N NHOOWHNLQWHQL$ QHP]HWVpJQpYUHQGV]HULQWL .iQIRUPiMiQDNHOVDGDWDN|UOUO6LPRQILDLW%RFVNRWpV*\XOiWÄGH6XN ORV´HPOtWLDPLHJ\pUWHOP&HQDEDUDQ\DL6LNOyVUDPXWDW8J\DQFVDNLWWYROWD.iQRNQDN DONDOPDVLQWDFVDOiGVLIpV]NpWMHONpSH]QHP]HWVpJLPRQRVWRUDLV%LUWRNDLNV]HUWHNL PXWDWKDWyND'UiYDPLQGNpWROGDOiQDNWpUVpJpEO$QHP]HWVpJVpQHNWHNLQWKHW*\XOD 0DJQXVW|EEt]EHQYROWV]ODYyQLDLEiQpVXWyGDLN|]OLVYLVHOWpNHFtPHW1HPI|OWpWOHQ EL]RQ\tWpNDV]iUPD]iVUDGHPLQGHQHVHWUH%DUDQ\iEDQYROWpVYDQ.iQKHO\VpJ²$V]pS V]iPPDO(UGpO\EHQLVPHJOHY.iQELUWRNRNDW.5,67ÏUpV]EHQKHO\LVL|U|NVpJ&HNQHN WDUWMD HUUH D]RQEDQ QLQFV WpQ\OHJHVIRJyG]y *<g5))< LV V]HU]HWW ELUWR NRNQDNPRQGMDH]HNHW(V]HU]pVNH]GHWHÄ1DJ\´*\XOiQDNLHUGpO\LYDMGDNpQWNL UiO\LNLQHYH]pVpUHWHKHWNpVEEPpJHJ\V]HUPHJNDSWDHWLV]WHWPDMGDYDMGDViJRWYL VHO PiV QHP]HWVpJWDJMDL IRO\WDWWiN 0RKy ELUWRNJ\DUDStWiVL W|UHNYpVHLNHW RNOHYHOHN NLWpWHOHLEL]RQ\tWMiNDIRO\DPDWEHWHW]MHDKtUKHGW.iQ/iV]OyYROW$.iQRNQDNPLQGH QHNHOWW D QHP]HWVpJDODStWy *\XOiQDN NO|QEHQ LV QDJ\ WHNLQWpO\N OHWW 'pO(UGpO\EHQ KHO\QpYDGyN|YHWNH]PpQ\HNNHOLV1DJ\ÄgUHJ´*\XODOHWWDQpYDGyMDNpVEE*\XODIH KpUYiUQDND]QHYpWYLVHOWHDWOHELUWRNROW*\XOD0HJJ\HVVWEOPpJN|Q\YHPPHJ IHOHOKHO\pQ(]HND*\XODHOWDJ~HOVVRUEDQ*\XOD0DJQXVQHYpWKRUGR]yKHO\QHYHN
*\XODIHKpUYiUUDOHJ\WWPLQG ;,,,²;,9V]i]DGLNHOHWNH]pV&HNV]yVHPOHKHWMHO]
MNQHNDKDMGDQLHUGpO\L*\XOiNUDHPOpNH]WHWpVpUO
*RQGRORPYLWi]yWiUVDPPDOHJ\HWpUWQNDEEDQKRJ\D]RND]LQWHUSROiFLyNDPH O\HN D NUyQLNDNRPSR]tFLyEDQ .HiQUyO V]yOQDN È N R V P H V W H U WO V ] i U P D ] Q D N (]HNQHND]XWyODJRVEHV]~UiVRNQDNW|EEMHOOHJ]HWHVVpJNLVYDQD]DODSV]|YHJ EO V]HUNH]HWLOHJ W|EEQ\LUH IHOW&QHQ NLUtQDN PHJOHKHWVHQ KRPiO\RV WDUWDOP~DN D .iQRNUD KLYDWNR]iVRN YDQQDN YDJ\ VHMOHQHN I|O EHQQN VW LUiQ\XNEDQ D] pU]HOPL W|EEOHWVHPKLiQ\]LNEHOON
$NUyQLNDEHWROGiVDLQDNVRUR]DWRVWpQ\pWÈNRVPHVWHUUpV]pUOD.HiQNpUGpVN O | Q O H J H V I R Q W R V V i J ~ N H ] H O p V H N p Q W pUWpNHOHP$PLSHGLJH]HNQHND]LQ WHUSROiFLyNQDND]DYDURVV]|YHJV]HUNHV]WpVpWKRPiO\RVWDUWDOPiWLOOHWLD]WPHUpV]HOHP JRQGROQLKRJ\H]HNHWDPDJDVP&YHOWVpJ&WXGyVNOHULNXVQHP YpOHWOHQOÜQHPVDMiW VSRQWiQV]|YHJHNpQWKHO\H]WHHODNUyQLNiEDQKDQHPWXGDWRVDQtUyLYpQiYDODODNtWRWWD LO\HQHNNpPHVV]LP~OWEyO IHQWPDUDGWV]|YHJW|UHGpNHNVWLOiULVpU]pNHOWHWpVpUH+DVRQOy VWtOXVMHOHQVpJHWWDSDV]WDOWDP3PDJLV]WHUHJ\HJ\V]|YHJUpV]OHWpQHNYiUDWODQEHpNHOpVpEHQ LVSpOGiXOD&ViNQHP]HWVpJHUHGHWpUHXWDOiViEDQD&VDEDPDJ\DUMDW|UWpQHWpEHQVWE
ÈNRVPHVWHU.HiQHSL]yGMDLVDMiWRVDQYLOiJtWMiNPHJÈNRVpVD.iQQHP]HWVpJYL V]RQ\iW(YLV]RQ\EDQQHPOpQ\HJWHOHQHNPiUD]RNDPR]]DQDWRNVHPDPHO\HNHWÈNRV NDSFVRODWDLUyOD]HGGLJLNXWDWiVDNUyQLNDHJ\WWHV.iQQHP]HWVpJLXWDOiVDLQNtYOIHOGH UtWHWW(OVVRUEDQ*<g5))<.UyQLNiLQNNNNO|Q|VHQNNPXWDWRWWUiKRJ\
ÈNRVILDWDONRUiEDQVRNDWIRUJRWW.iOPiQKHUFHJV]ODYyQLDLEiQLXGYDUiEDQDKROD.i QRNIRQWRVV]HUHSHWW|OW|WWHNEHpON|Q1DJ\*\XOiYDO(]DNDSFVRODWDNUyQLNDHJ\QH YH]HWHVKHO\pQ65+ÈNRVNRQNUpWXWDOiViEDQLVPHJQ\LOYiQXO1DJ\*\XODILiWD YHOHHJ\NRU~DONDOPDVLQWEDUiWViJEDQLVOHY/iV]OyWDUpJLHUGpO\L*\XOiNHJ\HQHVOH V]iUPD]RWWMiQDNPRQGMD$]LO\HQV]|YHJEHEHWROGRWWV]HPpO\HVpVFpO]DWRVPHJ|U|NtWpV VHPPLNpSSHQQHPOHKHWYpOHWOHQ²(J\pENpQWDPLPiUD0DJLV]WHUNUyQLNDEHOLXWDOi VDLWLOOHWLD*\XODpVD.HiQQHYHNW|EEV]|U|VHJ\WWHPOHJHWpVpEHQ*\XODOHJ\]pVH XWiQW|UWpQOHJ\]pVH.HiQQDN.HiQKDMiQiOIRJYDHOUiQJDWRWWHPOtWpVH*\XODOHiQ\D
6DUROWKi]DVViJDJ\pEHQ.HiQpV*\XODNLQFVHLQHN|VV]HKR]iVD|VV]NHYHUpVHVWEMHO ]LNKRJ\ÈNRVJRQGRODWYLOiJiEDQSRQWRVDEEDQ.HiQYH]pU!.iQQHP]HWVpJOHV]iUPD ]iVLHOJRQGROiViEDQPHVV]HEEUOD.iQ*\XOiNHUGpO\LOHV]iUPD]iViQDNHONpS]HOpVpEHQ QDJ\V]HUHSMXWRWWHJ\IHOODQHP]HWVpJEHOL*\XODQHYHNQHNPiVIHOOD.iQQHP]HWVpJ QpYQHNDFVDOiGHJ\HVV]HPpO\HLUHQp]YHLVpUYpQ\HVOQpYEHOLNDSFVRODWDY|Ä*\XOD GHJHQHUH.DQ´(KKH]WXGQLNHOOKRJ\D.iQQHP]HWVpJEHQHUVHQLVPpWOG|WWDQHP ]HGpNHNVRUiEDQD*\XODPHO\PpJDQiOXNV]LQWpQGLYDWRV/iV]OyWLVIHOOP~OWD1H PLJHQNpS]HOKHWHOKRJ\D.iQ*\XOiNQpYD]RQRVViJDD]HUGpO\L*\XOiNpYDO HJ\EH N|WYH H]]HO D.iQ QHP]HWVpJQpY QDJ\IRN~ KDVRQOyViJiW D.HiQ QpYYHO QH PRWLYiOWD YROQDÈNRVWOHV]iUPD]iVL|WOHWHLQHNNLDODNtWiViEDQ.HiQQDNpVD]HUGpO\L*\XOiNQDND .iQ*\XOiN V]iUPD]iViKR] HOYH]HWpVpEHQ 0È/<86= LV XWDOW D 0DJLV]WHUQHN D QHYHN N|UpEHQPHJQ\LOYiQXOyIDQWi]LiMiUD(J\V]yPLQWV]i]ÈNRVPHVWHUNUyQLNDEHOL.HiQ MDEL]RQ\RVDQQHPYiODV]WKDWyHOVDMiWNRUiQDN.iQ*\XOiLWyOH]DN|UOPpQ\D]RQEDQ
²PLQWPiUXWDOWDPUi²QHPOHV]iUPD]iVLEL]RQ\tWpNOHJI|OMHEEtUyLLQYHQFLyDPHO\ÈNRV QpYL JRQGRODWYLOiJiW $QRQ\PXV QpY|WOHWHLYHO KR]]D HJ\ VRUED 3HUV]H QHPFVDN D.HiQ
J\EHQ KDQHP DNiU D] ÈNRVWyO .HiQURNRQViJED WHWW%HO\|G pV.XOiQ HVHWpEHQ LV H]
DKHO\]HWDPLNRU²6DUROWPHJNpUpVHUJ\pQ²H]HNHWLVNDSFVROMDUpV]EHQ .HiQKR]
UpV]EHQDKDMGDQL*\XOiKR]PHJDONRWMDQHYNHWLVY|D%pOGKHO\QpYUOpVD.DOiQ QHP]HWVpJUOLGHYRQDWNR]yDQN|Q\YHPEHQ²PRQGRWWDNDW
.5,67ÏV]HULQWNpWRNOHYpOLVWDQ~VtWMDKRJ\D.HiQQpYLO\HQDODNEDQLVWRYiEEpOW DIHPEHUQHNDNUyQLNDNRPSR]tFLyPHJMHO|OWH,VWYiQHOOHQpEHQYDOyEXNiVDXWiQLVKtU QHYpQHNIHQWPDUDGiVDD.iQRNLJHOMXWyLYDGpNLIRO\WRQRVViJDEL]RQ\tWpNDNpQWpQYLV]RQW PpJLVD]LGHYRQDWNR]yDGDWRNÄKLWHOWHOHQtWpVpQIiUDGR]WDP´)iUDGR]iVRP HJ\LN WiUJ\D YDOyEDQHJ\RO\DQEOV]iUPD]yNLDGDWODQRNOHYpOEHQV]HUHSHOPHO\WDUWDOPLiWtUiVD HJ\EDQNHOWHO]PpQ\QHN9LWDSDUWQHUHPPHJiOODStWMDKRJ\DNLDGDWODQRNOHYHOHW QHPOiWWDP FVDNV]DNLURGDOPLKLYDWNR]iVDODSMiQHOHP]HP0HJMHJ\]pVH IpOLJ PLQGHQ NpSSHQMRJRVXOWD QHPOiWiVWpQ\pWPDJDPLVMHOH]WHPN|Q\YHPLGHYRQDWNR]yKHO\pQ iPQHPILOROyJLDLJRQGDWODQViJUyOYDQLWWV]yKDQHPDNNRULHJpV]VpJLiOODSRWRPDNDGi O\R]RWW DPLUH PXQNiP HOV]DYiEDQ XWDOWDP $ OiWDWODQEyO HOHP]pV IHOWHYpVpKH] NpW V]y PpJLVIpUKHW*<g5))<W|UWpQHWLI|OGUDM]iEDQEUpV]OHWHWV]yV]HULQWN|]|OD]RNOHYpOYR QDWNR]y KHO\pUO PHO\ W|EE PLQGHQEHQ DG WiMpNR]WDWiVW D EHQQH IRJODOWDNUyO WRYiEEi )(+e57Ï,.$7$/,1 V]tYHVVpJpW LV NpUWHP KRJ\ Qp]]HQ XWiQD D] 2UV]iJRV /HYpOWiUEDQ DV]iPRPUDNULWLNXVSUREOpPiNQDNPHO\V]LQWpQMyOVHJtWHWWYpOHPpQ\HPIRUPiOiViEDQ OHUUODN|Q\YHPEHQWDOiOKDWyMHJ\]HWDQ\DJRW
1RVDPLDNpUGpVpUGHPLUpV]pWLOOHWLYLWiQND] L V P H U W | V R N O H Y p O Q H N Ä G H Y L O O D . H D Q´ K H O \ Q p Y D G D W D LOOHWOHJHOYHV]HWWRVHO]Pp Q\H PHJIHOHOMpQHN PLQVpJH N|UO IRURJ .5,67Ï V]HULQW PLQGNpW HVHWEHQ FVDN.HDQ DODNUyOOHKHWV]yPHUWD]HO]PpQ\PLQGHQJ\DQ~I|O|WWiOOyKLWHOHVNRUK&LUDWD]iWLUDW SHGLJHQQHNSRQWRVPHJIHOHOMHDPLEHD.HDQIRUPiWEHQHPWHKHWWpNLOOHWOHJD]WQHP YiOWR]WDWKDWWiN %HQQHP IHOPHUOW pV WRYiEEUD LV pO D J\DQ~ KRJ\ D] HOYHV]HWW HO] PpQ\EHQ.iQDODNOHKHWHWWDPiVRODWH]WYiOWR]WDWKDWWD&VDNiOWDOiQRVViJEDQHPOtWHPV H]WYLWDSDUWQHUHPN|]pSNRULRNOHYHOH]pVQNNLYiOyLVPHUMH LV MyO WXGMD KRJ\ D] iWtUW RNOHYHOHN V]|YHJH NO|Q|VHQ D QpYDODNRN K&VpJH V]HPSRQWMiEyO PHQQ\L EL]RQ\WDODQ ViJJDODODNYiOWR]WDWiVVDOWHUKHVPHO\ NO|QEVpJHN D] LGSRQWRN WiYROViJiYDO D W|EE V]|UL²HOYHV]HWWYDJ\ IHQWPDUDGW²PiVROiVRNNDOFVDNQ|YHNHGQHNH]pUWYLV]RQ\XN SUREOHPDWLNiMiEDQEL]WRVNLMHOHQWpVHNHWQHPLJHQOHKHWWHQQL NO|Q|VNpSSHQDPLNRUD]
RO\DQQpYWpPDP|J|WWPLQWDPLO\HQD.HiQDQQ\LEL]RQ\WDODQViJYDQ
.pWHO\HPHWSHUV]HQHPHOVVRUEDQLO\HQiOWDOiQRVWp]LVHNUHDODSR]RPKDQHPNpW PiVLNNRQNUpWDEENLLQGXOiV~PHJJRQGROiVUD(J\UpV]UODQHYH]HWWKHO\VpJD]RNOHYpO
V]|YHJN|UQ\H]HWHDODSMiQYLV]RQ\ODJMyOORNDOL]iOKDWyDUpJL%DUDQ\DPHJ\pQHND'Ui YiQW~OLWHUOHWpQNpVEEL9DONyPHJ\HIHNGWDPDL.yUyJ\YLGpNpQO*<g5))<
LV0LYHOH]HQD]DOVy'UiYDYLGpNHQKHO\H]NHGWHNHOD.iQQHP]HWVpJHUHGHWLELU WRNDL V V]iUPD]iVXN OHJNRUiEEL EL]RQ\ViJDL iOWDOiEDQ LV HKKH] D WHUOHWKH] N|WGQHN EODGDWROWÄGHJHQHUH.DQ´QHP]HWVpJQHYNLVHUUHDWiMUDXWDODKHO\VpJQpYEiU PHO\LNIRUPiMDSHGLJQ\LOYiQYDOyDQQHYNNHOIJJ|VV]HHJ\iOWDOiQQHPNpSWHOHQVpJDUUD JRQGROQLKRJ\D]HUHGHWLLVPHUHWOHQRNOHYpOSpOGiQ\EDQDUyOXNQHYH]HWWKHO\VpJV]RN YiQ\RVWHUPpV]HWHVQHYN|Q.iQDODNEDQIRUGXOKDWRWWHOD]D].HDQQiFVDNDPiVR ODWEDQYiOW(]WDOHKHWVpJHWDWHUOHWHJ\NRULWHOHSOpVW|UWpQHWLHVHPpQ\HLLVDOiWiPDV]W KDWMiN $ W|U|NG~OiV N|YHWNH]WpEHQ D 'UiYD DOVy IRO\iVD VtNYLGpNpQHN W|PpQ\ PDJ\DU ODNRVViJDNHYpVNLYpWHOOHOHOSXV]WXOWVHOW&QWDQHYH]HWWKHO\VpJLV|VDGDWDXWiQPiU QHP WDOiOMXN Y| &6È1., 9DONy P 8J\DQDNNRU QDJ\RQ IHOW&QHQ NpVHL DGDWWDO EHQ IHOEXNNDQ %DUDQ\iEDQ D 3pFVWO pV]DNUD OHY KHJ\HVGRPERV YLGpNHQ HJ\
.iQQHY&KHO\VpJ*<g5))<PHO\QHYpWPiLJU]L+DILJ\HOQNDGiWXPRNUD D]DGRWWWHUPpV]HWLpVW|UWpQHWLYLV]RQ\RNUDVWHNLQWHWEHYHVV]NDNRUDGDWRNNDODOiWi PDV]WKDWyEDUDQ\DLWHOHSOpVW|UWpQHWLPR]]DQDWDLWDW|U|NHOOpV]DNLLUiQ\EDQPHQHN
OpVW WRYiEEi D PLQGNpW KHO\HQ OHKHWVpJHV .iQELUWRNOiVW QHP KRUULELOH GLFWX IHOWHYpV D NpW KHO\VpJ ODNRVViJiQDN |VV]HIJJpVpUO EHV]pOQL $] D PDJ\DUEyO pV LGHJHQ Q\HO YHNEOLVPHUWQpYDGiVLMHOHQVpJSHGLJKRJ\D]iWN|OW|]ODNRVViJPLO\VRNSpOGDWDQ~
ViJDV]HULQWYLV]LPDJiYDONRUiEELKHO\pQHNQHYHLWQHPV]RUXONO|QEL]RQ\tWpNUDtJ\
D] pV]DNEDUDQ\DL.iQN|]VpJQHYpWDPHO\PLQGHQEL]RQQ\DOV]LQWpQDQHP]HWVpJQpY YHOIJJ|VV]HDYDONyLPDJ\DUViJKR]KDWWDPDJiYDO
.5,67ÏNLIRJiVROMDKRJ\D]|VRNOHYpONHDQDGDWiWKDSD[QDNPRQGRP6]H ULQWHPNpWV]HUHVHQLVD]D'UiYDPHQWLKHO\VpJQHNH]D]HJ\HWOHQDGDWDpVPiV.HiQ KHO\QpYVHKRQQDQVHPLVPHUHWHV$PLHKHO\VpJ ORNDOL]iFLyMiWLOOHWL .5,67ÏDIHQWHEE MHO]HWW.yUyJ\PHOOHWWLYLGpNQpOWiJDEEN|UQ\H]HWEHQYpOLOiWQLDIDOXKHO\pWpQD]RNOH YpOEHQOHtUWDNDODSMiQH]WVHPPLNpSSHQQHPWHQQpP
5pV]EHQD].HDQKHO\QpYDODNORNDOL]iFLyMiYDOIJJ|VV]HD]DNpUGpVKRJ\
PLNpQWNHUOKHWHWWYROQDH]DQpYIRUPD²KDOHWWYROQDRWWYDODKDLO\HQ²DPHVV]LHU GpO\LWiMUyO K H O \ Q p Y N p Q W D'UiYDY|OJ\pEH0LYHOSHUV]HDKHO\QpYQHPYiODV]W KDWyHOD.iQRNQHP]HWVpJQHYpWOKHO\QHYHVHGpVpQHN~WMDV]NVpJV]HU&HQNDSFVROyGLN HQHP]HWVpJKHO\]HWpKH]W|UWpQHWpKH]$]RPLQy]XVKHO\QpYLDODNOpWUHM|WWHpVDV]yEDQ OHYRNOHYpOV]|YHJpEHEHNHUOpVHSXV]WiQHOYLOHJNpWIpOHNpSSHQYROQDPDJ\DUi]KDWy
$]HJ\LNOHKHWVpJV]HULQWDQpYIRUPDV S R Q W i Q Q p S L Q \ H O Y L I H M OG p V
~ W M i Q M|WWOpWUHYDJ\~J\KRJ\DQHP]HWVpJD]HJ\NRUL.HiQYH]pUQpYDODNMiW(UGpO\
EOYiOWR]DWODQViJiWPHJUL]YHKR]WDPDJiYDOQ\XJDWUDYDJ\~J\KRJ\DEDUDQ\DL.i QRNQDND]HUGpO\L.HiQYH]pUWOIJJHWOHQHUHGHWL.iQQHYH.siQIpOHWiMLQ\HOYLYiO WR]DWiEDQKHO\QHYHVHGHWWLWW$]HOEELW .HiQPRQGDLOpWpQHN QHYHQHP]HWVpJQpYNpQW IRO\WDWiViQDN YDODPLQW D .iQRN HUGpO\L V]iUPD]iViQDN W|EE PLQW NpWVpJHV YROWD WHV]L WHOMHVHQ YDOyV]tQ&WOHQQp D] XWyEELQDN D.iQ QHP]HWVpJQpY EDUDQ\DL V]RNYiQ\RVViJD .HiQYiOWR]DWiQDND]RNOHYpOKDSD[iQNtYOWHOMHVLWWHQLLVPHUHWOHQVpJHYDODPLQWHJ\
.iQ!.HiQDODNIHMOGpVQHNLWWHQLVSRQWiQQ\HOYLYiOWR]iVVDONL]iUKDWyYROWDD]HOKiUtW KDWDWODQDNDGiO\D
0DUDGFVXSiQHJ\WRYiEELOHKHWVpJD]RPLQy]XVRNOHYpODGDW L U R G D O P L V ] L Q W& P H V W H U V p J H V Q p Y D G i V HUHGPpQ\H(]DWpQ\iOOiVKR]WDNpSEHHOWWHPÈNRV PHVWHUN|]YHWHWWV]HUHSpQHNH]J\EHQLVIHOPHUtWKHWVpJpW3HUV]H F V D N N | ] Y H W H W W UpV]YpWHOUOOHKHWV]yPLYHOD]RNOHYpOHO]PpQ\NHOWHNRUEDQÈNRVPpJ FVDN LIM~NRUiWpOWHEHQSHGLJPiUUpJKDORWWYROW9LWDFLNNpQHNHJ\NpVEELUpV]pEHQ .5,67ÏD]WYHWLIHOKRJ\D]N|UOLHUGpO\LHVHPpQ\HNIV]HUHSOLQHNWOHHPOtWHW
WHQ.DUROGQDN'RERNiQDN.HiQQDN%HO\|GQHN.XOiQQDN6]ROWiQQDN*\XOiQDN6D UROWQDNKDJ\RPiQ\DIRONORUL]iOyGRWWVRUiOLVV]LQWUOMXWRWWHOD;,,,V]i]DGtUiVEHOLVp JpLJ(KKH]D]HJpV]IRO\DPDWKR]V]HULQWHPDOHJW|EEV]HUHSOHVHWpEHQV~O\RVNpWVpJHN IpUQHNXJ\DQGHOiWKDWyDQYLWDSDUWQHUHPLVD]tUiVEHOLVpJV]HUHSpQHNLUiQ\iEDQ NHUHVL D.HiQQpYDODNIHOW&QpVpQHNLVDEL]WRVtWpNiW(]pUWNHYpVEppUWHPD.HiQSUREOpPDLWW WiU J\DOWKHO\QpYLYRQDWNR]iViEDQÈNRVWyOPHQWHVtWpVpQHNW|UHNYpVpWÈNRVPHVWHUYROWXJ\DQLV D;,,,V]i]DGtUiVEHOLVpJpQHND]D WpQ\H]MH²QHPFVDNDJHV]WDtUiVNHUHWpEHQ²DNLUO PLQWWiUJ\DOWXNMyOEL]RQ\tWKDWyKRJ\D.iQRNQDNQHPFVDNN|]HOLLVPHUVHKDQHPHO N|WHOH]HWW KtYH LV YROW $ .iQRN W|UWpQHWpEHQ D .HiQWyO OHV]iUPD]iV JRQGRODWiW D;,9V]i]DGLtUiVWXGyRNOHYpOtUyNOpUXVN|]HJpEHQDPDJDV]HPpO\HVWHNLQWpO\pYHOYDJ\
pSSHQ D NUyQLNDNRPSR]tFLy LQWHUSROiFLyLQDN IpOUHpUWKHWHWOHQ.HiQHPOHJHWpVpYHO ÈNRV VXJDOPD]WD HOVVRUEDQ 0LpUW YROQD WHOMHVHQ NL]iUKDWy D] D OHKHWVpJ KRJ\ D WiUJ\DOW RNOHYpOEHQiWtUyMDHJ\EHiOOtWyMDD]RUV]iJRVKtU&.iQQHP]HWVpJW|UWpQHWpWHEEHQ D] ÈNRVIpOH LQWHUSUHWiFLyEDQ LVPHUWH pV D NpUGpVHV IDOXQHYHW DNiU PLQGHQ V]HPpO\HV pUGHN WXGDWRV V]iQGpN QpONO LV HKKH] D] pUGHNHV ÄW|UWpQHOPL´ QpYDODNKR] LJD]tWVD"
ÈNRVPDJLV]WHUQHN.HiQN|UOLEX]JDOPiWLVPHUYHQHPKLV]HPKRJ\H]D .5,67ÏPL QVtWpVHV]HULQWÄNULPLV]HU&|WOHW´NULPLKH]KDVRQOtWKDWyEEYROQDPLQW.HiQW;V]i]DGL GpOHUGpO\LEROJiUXUDORPIHMHNpQWHONpS]HOQL²7HUPpV]HWHVHQDWiUJ\DOWRNOHYpO EDQ NHOW HUHGHWLMpEHQ D.HiQ YiOWR]DW LURGDOPL ~WRQ PHJMHOHQpVH W|EEIpOH NURQROyJLDL RNEyOPpJNHYpVEpYROQDPDJ\DUi]KDWyDKHO\QpYRUiOLVWHUMHGpV~WMiQ%DUDQ\iEDNH UOpVHSHGLJHJ\iOWDOiQQHP
E H Q N H O W D ] D P i V L N R N O H Y p O DPHO\EHQD.HiQQpYDODNV]LQ WpQIHOEXNNDQ$]LUDWDUUyOV]yOKRJ\ ,9%pODD]DNNRUPiUKDORWW*\XODEiQ*\XOD 0DJQXV%RUVRGPHJ\HLWDUGRQDLELUWRNiWHODMiQGpNR]WD$]RNOHYpOÄGHJHQHUH.HDQ´
MiUyOWOHPPRQGRWWDNDW.5,67ÏPLQGHQYRQDWNR]iViEDQQpJ\WpWHOUHERQWYDHOXWDVtWMD (UUHD]RNOHYpOUHYRQDWNR]yDQDN|]WQNOHYYLWDOHJOpQ\HJHVHEESRQWMDPHO\EO MyUpV]WDPiVLNKiURPLVN|YHWNH]LN D V ] | Y H J T X R Q G D P V ] D Y i Q D N p U W p N H 7XGyV WiUVDP V]HULQW D Ä-XOD %DQXV TXRQGDP GH JHQHUH.HDQ´ V]|YHJUpV]W IpOUHpUWHP D]]DOKRJ\DTXRQGDPRW¶KDMGDQUpJHQHJ\NRU¶MHOHQWpVVHOpUWHOPH]HPKRORWWD]HJ\
V]HU&HQ¶QpKDL¶WMHOHQWDODWLQRNOHYpOV]|YHJEHQ-XOiUDpVQHPDQHP]HWVpJUHYRQDWNR ]LNH]pUWPDJDÄ.HDQQHPEHOLQpKDL*\XODEiQ´UyOEHV]pO6]HULQWHPpSSHQ.5,67ÏD]
DNLWpYHGDGRORJEDQDTXRQGDPQHPPHOOpNQpYKDQHPKDWiUR]yV]yDV]HUNH]HWEHQQHP D-XOD%DQXVMHO]MHKDQHPDGHJHQHUH.HDQWFpO]yNRUMHO|OKDWiUR]y¶KDMGDQUpJHQ HJ\NRURQ¶MHOHQWpVVHOtJ\DV]|YHJpUWHOPH¶*\XODEiQHJ\NRURQD.HiQQHP]HWVpJpEO YDOyDQ¶0LQGHUUOWDQ~VNRGLNDTXRQGDPHWLPRQMDKDWiUR]yV]yQDNPHJIHOHOPRUIR OyJLiMDPLQGDNODVV]LNXVPLQGDN|]pSNRULODWLQEDQUHQGV]HULQWPRQGDWKDWiUR]yL KDV]
QiODWDpVDWiUJ\DOWV]|YHJEHQV]yUHQGLKHO\]HWH(JUDPPDWLNDLSUREOpPDIHV]HJHWpVHHOV SLOODQDWUD WDOiQ V]UV]iOKDVRJDWiVQDN OiWV]LN SHGLJ D YLWDWRWW HVHWEHQ QDJ\RQLV IRQWRV D SRQWRVV]|YHJpUWHOPH]pV WXGQLLOOLND KDMGDQiQ .HiQWyO V]iUPD]y QHP]HWVpJUO YDQ V]y HQHP]HWVpJVLVpJpUOQHPSHGLJN|]YHWOHQO1DJ\*\XODN|UOYLVHOWQHP]HWVpJ QHYpUO2O\DVIpOHH]PLQWNUyQLNiLQN$USDGGHJHQHUH$WKLOHPHJMHO|OpVHPHO\EHQQHP OHKHWyPDJ\DUQHP]HWVpJQHYHWNHUHVQLY|PpJÄYJHNGHJHQHUHPDJRJUHJLV´ÄYJHNGH JHQHUHDWKLOHUHJLV´ÄDOPXPGXFHPGHJHQHUHDWKLOHUHJLVGHÕFHQGLÕÕH´VWE$Q
*RQGRORP.5,67ÏD]pUWUDJDV]NRGKDWLNDÄQpKDL*\XODEiQ´IRUGtWiVKR]PHUWDTXRQ GDPKDV]QiODWiEDQpUWHOPH]pVpEHQDPDJXNN|]|QVpJHVLVPHUWVpJpYHOPHJWpYHV]WKHWWpN
$QRQ\PXV SUROyJXVDTXRQGDPMiQDN VRUR]DWRVDQ KLEiV YDJ\ WDOiQ D JHV]WD NURQRORJL ]iOiViWFpO]yV]iQGpNRVDQWpYHVIRUGtWiVDLD Ä Q p K D L MyHPOpN&GLFVVpJHV%pOiQDN MHJ\]MH´NLWpWHOPHO\HWFVDN :(6=35e0</È6=/ÏQDN~MJHV]WDIRUGtWiVDKR]RWWKHO\UH Ä H J \ N R U R Q MHJ\]MH´PHJROGiVVDOMypU]pNNHOpV]UHYpYHDJHV]WDNRUPHJKDWiUR
]iVDV]HPSRQWMiEyODODSYHWHQIRQWRViPD]HO]PpQ\IRUGtWiVRNEDQJUDPPDWLNDLODJpV WDUWDOPLODJHJ\DUiQWHON|YHWHWWKLEiW
.5,67ÏQHKH]PpQ\H]LKRJ\D]RNOHYpOEHQ1DJ\*\XOiKR]SRQWRVDEEDQD.iQRN KR]NDSFVROW.HDQIRUPiWQHP]HWVpJQpYNpQWLVHJ\HGOiOOyQDNPRQGWDP3HGLJD]LPpQW WiUJ\DOWDPDJDQHPpEHQHJ\HWOHQ.HDQKHO\VpJQpYKH]KDVRQOyDQKDSD[H]LVQHPFVDND .iQRNUD V]iUPD]iVL XWDOiVNpQW KDQHP DNiU D .iQRNUD WpQ\OHJHVHQ KDV]QiOW QHP]HWVpJ QpYNpQWLVKLV]HQHP]HWVpJQHNÄGHJHQHUH.DQ´PHJMHO|OpVHVHKROPiVXWWQHPKHO\HWWH VtWGLN.HDQIRUPiEDQ(J\pENpQWLVDQHP]HWVpJQpYKDV]QiODWiEDQHIRUPDLHJ\HWOHQVpJ PHOOHWWH]D]RNOHYpODGDWD]HJ\HWOHQ.HDQRVDGDWYROQDD]HOVHOIRUGXOiVKLV]HQ² OiWWXN ² D YDOyViJRV QHP]HWVpJQpYL ÄGH JHQHUH .DQ´ FVDN EHQ M|Q HO D E D U D Q \ D L . i Q R N U D YRQDWNR]WDWYD .5,67Ï V]HULQW D] HV DGDW KLWHOHVtWL D .iQRNQDN EHQ.HiQ QHP]HWVpJQpYHQ V]HUHSHOWHWpVpW D] pV N|]|WW FVHNpO\LGWiYROViJPLDWWLVeQD]WQHPYLWDWWDPEiUDGDWRNQHPLJD]ROMiNKRJ\D.i QRNPiUEHQLVYLVHOKHWWpNQHP]HWVpJQHYNHWGHLWWQHPHUUOKDQHPDÄSVHXGR´
QHP]HWVpJQpY.HiQIRUPiMiQDNDQHP]HWVpJQpYLVRUEDQLVIHOW&QHOVVpJpUOYDQV]y
² 8J\DQFVDN D] HV.HiQ DODN RNOHYHOHV LJD]ROiViW OiWMD .5,67Ï DEEDQ KRJ\
EDQ PiU LO\HQ DODN IRUGXO HOKHO\QpYEHQ O HOEE 'H LWW PHJ D] D EDM KRJ\
NRQNUpWDGDWDKHO\QpYLIRUPiUDFVDNEOYDQpVHQQHNNpWVpJHNHWNL]iUyRV OpWpEHQPLQGHQHNHOWWKLQQLNHOO
$]EOYDOy.HDQÄSVHXGR´QHP]HWVpJQpYYHONDSFVRODWEDQI|OYHWHWWHPKRJ\
HIRUPiYDOD]RNOHYpOtUyIHOW&QHQpVWXGDWRVDQKDQJV~O\R]QLDNDUWDD.iQRNVLVpJpW DOHJHQGiVQpYYHOHJ\H]pVpWDPLÈNRVPHVWHUIHOIRJiVDLUiQ\iEDPXWDWKDW.5,67ÏH]]HO V]HPEHQNpWHOOHQYHWpVWLVWHV]6]HULQWHÈNRVQHPOHKHWEHQQHD]J\EHQPHUWD]RNOH YpOtUy*\XODEiQQDOV]HPEHQOiWKDWyHOOHQpU]OHWWHOYLVHOWHWHWWPLYHOKRJ\DEiQQDNDNL UiO\HOOHQLE&QHLWiUXOiViWD]RNOHYpOV]|YHJQDJ\RQNLHPHOLÒJ\YpOHPH]HNDYDOyEDQ RWWOHYNLWpWHOHNDNLUiO\LRNOHYpOEO1DJ\*\XODNHJ\YHV]WpVHXWiQNHYpVLGYHOV]LQWH KLYDWDOEyOVHPKLiQ\R]KDWWDNGHKRJ\D]tUyV]LPSiWLiMDUHMWHWWHQPpJLVRWWEXMNiODV]|
YHJEHQD]D]pUWNLFVHQGODEEyODPHJMHJ\]pVpEOKRJ\DELUWRNQpSHQRV]WDOJLNXVHPOp NHW iOOtWRWW D EiQQDN YDJ\ KDJ\RWW PHJ LO\HQQHN ² 7RYiEEi D]]DO LV pUYHO SDUWQHUHP KRJ\EHQÈNRVPpJQHPYROWNLUiO\LV]ROJiODWEDQH]pUWQHPIRJDOPD]KDWWDD]RNOH YHOHW+RJ\ÈNRVPDJLV]WHUtUWDYROQDD]RNOHYHOHWD]WpQVHPiOOtWRWWDPQHPLViOOtWKDW WDPYROQDDVFULEiWQHPLVPHUMND]RNOHYpOWDUWDOPipUWIHOHOVNDQFHOOLVWiWD]RQEDQLJHQ ÄSHUPDQXV0DJLVWUL%HQHGLFWL3UHSRVLWL$OEHQVLV´ÈÒ2&VDNDQQ\LWPRQGWDP HUUO D] J\UO KRJ\ D] RNOHYpO EHOHHVLN ÈNRV P&N|GpVL LGHMpEH YDODPLQW KRJ\
D.HiQ²*\XODNRPELQiFLyD].HiQIHOIRJiViUDYDOO+RJ\%HQHGHNSUpSRVWNDSFVR OyGRWWHpVKRJ\DQÈNRVLVPHUVLN|UpKH]D]WQ\RPR]QLEDMRVYROQDKDQHPOHKHWHWOHQ
$]YLV]RQWWXGRWWGRORJKRJ\ÈNRVDKDUPLQFDVpYHNEHQ.iOPiQKHUFHJV]ODYyQLDLXG YDUiEDQPDMGWOSHVWLSOpEiQRVNpQWPDJDVpUWHOPLVpJLN|UEHQWXGyVNOHULNXVRN VRUiYDOpULQWNH]HWWVV]HU]HWWRWWV]HPpO\HVLVPHUHWVpJHNHWWXGiViYDOWHNLQWpO\W *<g5))<
pV0È/<86=NXWDWiVDLEyOD]WLVWXGMXNKRJ\DIHOVEENOpUXVWDJMDLN|]|WWHNRUEDQPiU HUVHQIHONHOWD]pUGHNOGpVDPDJ\DURNHUHGHWHW|UWpQHWHLUiQWDPLEHEYHQEHOHWDUWR ]RWWDQHP]HWVpJHNHO]PpQ\HLQHNJ\HLV0LQGHQHVHWUHWDOiQQHPYpOHWOHQKRJ\DNiU
%HQHGHNSUpSRVWDNiUPiVDWiUJ\DOWTXRQGDPNLWpWHOOHOWHQGHQFLy]XVQDNOiWV]yLJ\HNH ]HWWHOQHPD.iQKDQHPD]RNOHYHOHNEHQLVPHUHWOHQÄÈNRVIpOH´.HiQIRUPiWLOOHV]
WHWWHD]LUDWED(]WpQ\D]HUUHYDOyILJ\HOpVQpOW|EEHWXJ\DQQHPWHKHWQNGHDNpS]HO JpVQpOWDOiQW|EEUOYDQLWWV]y
$]RQ|WV]HPpO\N|]|WWDNLNHW.5,67ÏV]HULQWNLDNDURNLNWDWQLDPDJ\DUW|UWp QHOHPEORWWYDQ%HO\|GpV.XOiQLV0LYHODNUyQLNiEDQPLQGNHWWMNQHNFVDNHSL]yG
V]HUHSMXWRWWN|Q\YHPEHQYLV]RQ\ODJNHYHVHEEHWV]yOWDPV]HPpO\NUOpVQHYNUO 6RPPiVYpOHPpQ\HPYDOyEDQ D]UyOXNKRJ\ÈNRV PDJLV]WHU WDOiOPiQ\DL D OHtUW FVH OHNPpQ\*p]DpV6DUROWKi]DVViJDDEEDQD]LGEHQV]RNiVRVPLQpOV]pOHVHEEQpYLN|
UtWpVpQHNKLWHOHVtWpVpQHNpUGHNpEHQ6RNNDOW|EEHW%HO\|GUOpV.XOiQUyOPRVWVHPWXG QpN PRQGDQL OHJI|OMHEE D] XWyEELQDN D] HOPDUDGW QpYPDJ\DUi]DWiW NtVpUHOKHWHP PHJ QpPLOHJSyWROQL(OEED]RQEDQ.5,67ÏQDNHQHYHNNHONDSFVRODWRVNpWiOWDOiQRVDEENpU GpVI|OYHWpVpUHNtYiQRNNLWpUQL
9LWDWiUVDPDUUDILJ\HOPH]WHWKRJ\D KLWHOWHOHQtWpVHPWiUJ\iWNpSH]QpYFVRSRUW SUREOHPDWLNiMiQDNV~O\DYDQQHPV]DEDGNHWDPDJ\DUW|UWpQHOHPEOHJ\V]HU&HQNLLN WDWQLW|U|OQLeQHÄW|UWpQHOHPEONLLNWDWiV´IpOHIRJDOPDNpVWHUPLQXVRNKDV]QiODWiWDWX GRPiQ\RVPHJLVPHUpVVtNMiQVHPWDUWRPV]HUHQFVpVQHNPHUWDW|UWpQHWLYDOyViJIHOWiUi VLIRO\DPDWiUDQp]YHPDJiEDQKRUGR]KDWMDHJ\HVNpUGpVHNpU]HOPLDODSRQNH]HOpVpQHN YHV]pO\pW LOOHWOHJ JiWROKDWMD D WXGRPiQ\ HOHQJHGKHWHWOHQ NHOOpNpEHQ D NULWLNiEDQ D]
DQWLWp]LVHNpUYpQ\HVtWpVpW'HQHPWDUWRPV]HUHQFVpVQHNPDJiQDNDW|UWpQHWLYDOyViJQDND V]HPOpOHWHV]HPSRQWMiEyOVHPPHUWVRKDVHPOpWH]HWWFVHOHNPpQ\HNpVV]HPpO\HNPLQ GHQNRUEHQQHYDQQDNPDUDGQDNDGRWWLGNWiUVDGDOPLWXGDWiEDQDPHO\XJ\DQFVDNW|U WpQHOPLUHDOLWiVDPDJ\DUP~OWV]HOOHPLP&YHOWVpJpQHNUpV]H+RJ\WpPiQNQiOPDUDG MXQN NUyQLNiVDLQN EiUPLO\HQ VRKDVHP OpWH]HWW W|UWpQpVHNHW QHYHNHW tUWDN LV PHJ D ; V]i]DGUDQp]YHD;,,,V]i]DGV]HOOHPLNLQFVpEHQRWWYROWDNDNNRULVWUpV]EHQNpVEEL pUWHOPLVpJQN H V ] P H Y L O i J i Q D N D O N R W y H O H P H L N p Q W WHKiWDPDJ\DUW|UWp QHOHPEONLW|U|OKHWHWOHQWDUWDORPNpQW0LQGH]V]HUYHVHQ|VV]HWDUWR]y SUREOHPDWLNDNH ]HOQLFVDNHJ\WWHVHQOHKHW
.5,67ÏD]WPRQGMDWRYiEEiKRJ\pQ$QRQ\PXVQDNPHJYDOORWWDQWOHLVHOIRJDGRWW QpYL HOMiUiVPyGMDLW W|EEL W|UWpQHWtUyQNUD LV NLWHUMHV]WHQL NtYiQRP QRKD D] HOEEL D]
XWyEELDNUDQHPiOWDOiQRVtWKDWy$QQ\LWH]HQPLQGHQNpSSHQKHO\HVEtWHQHPNHOOKRJ\DW|U WpQHWLKLWHOHVVpJHWLOOHWNpWVpJHLPHWFVDN;,,,V]i]DGLNUyQLNiVDLQNUDVWNRQNUpWDQFVDN ÈNRVUDYRQDWNR]WDWRP0iVWQHPLVQDJ\RQWHKHWQpNKLV]HQPLQWLVPHUHWHV .p]DLD NUy QLNDHJ\WWHVPDJ\DUW|UWpQHWpQHNV]|YHJpWNLYRQDWROWD|QiOOyQpYDGiVDVHPDQQ\LUDPHJ KDWiUR]yKRJ\|VV]HYHWpVLDODSNpQWV]iPtWiVEDM|KHWQH9LWDSDUWQHUHPV]HULQWD]DQRQ\PXVL J\DNRUODWWDOV]HPEHQDKROD0HVWHUVDMiWJ\|Q\|U&VpJpUHiOWDODPHJWHUHPWHWWILJXUiNNDO NtYiQWDEHQpSHVtWHQLDSHUJDPHQWN|]pSNRULW|UWpQHWtUyLQNW~OQ\RPyUpV]HPpJLVFVDND]
LJD]DWDYDOyWDNDUWDOHtUQLPLNpQWD]WÈNRVLVWHWWH1\LOYiQYDOyKRJ\DPLNRUHWpUHQ KDVRQOyViJRNUyOpVHOOHQWpWHNUOEHV]pOQNQHPV]DEDGV]iPtWiVRQNtYOKDJ\QXQND3 PHVWHUpVÈNRVPHVWHUPXQNiMDN|]WLP&IDMLNO|QEVpJHNHWJHV]WD²NUyQLNDpVSHUV]H D]WVHPKRJ\ÈNRVD]DQRQ\PXVLV]HPpO\LpVQpYLDQ\DJRWPiUIHOKDV]QiOKDWWD0LQGH ]HNEHV]iPtWiViYDOVHPOiWRPPpUWNHOOHQHHWpUHQDODSYHWHQPiVPpUFpYHOPpUQQN
$ NpW PDJLV]WHU tUiVP&YpW FVDN QpKiQ\ pYWL]HG YiODV]WMD HO GH PpJ H QHP NRPRO\DQ V]iPEDM|KHWLGNO|QEVpJHWLVEYHQiWKLGDOMDN|UOPpQ\HLNP&YHOWVpJNW|UWpQHOPL pUGHNOGpVLN|UNWiUVDGDOPLN|]HJNQDJ\IRN~D]RQRVViJDPHO\QpYDGiVLHOYHLNFH]~
UDV]HU& YiOWR]iViW DOLJKD LGp]KHWWH HO 7|UWpQHWHLN OHtUiViEDQ PLQGNHWWHQ HUV QpYL DQ\DJKLiQQ\DO NV]N|GWHN PHO\HW FVDN WHWp]HWW D] D P&IDML KDJ\RPiQ\RNEyO IDNDGy N|WHOH]YpQ\KRJ\DFVHOHNPpQ\HNHWV]HPpO\HNQHNDV]HPpO\HNHWSHGLJQHYHNQHNQD J\RQV]RURVWDUWR]pNNpQWNHOOPHJMHOHQtWHQLN(]WDN|]|VJRQGRWÈNRVVHPROGKDWWD V]HULQWHPQHPLVROGRWWDPHJVDMiWQpYL NUHiFLyNSRQWRVDEEDQLQQHQRQQDQI|OFVLSHJH WHWWV]HPpO\QHYHNDONDOPD]iVDQpONO0LQWDKRJ\D]WDYpOHPpQ\WVHPRV]WDQiPKRJ\
$QRQ\PXVN|QQ\HGpEEHQDKLWHOHVVpJOiWV]DWiUDNHYpVEpDGYD|WOHWHLLJD]ViJWDUWDOPiEDQ NHYpVEpKLYHDGWDYROQDQHYHLWPLQWDKRJ\ÈNRVDVDMiWWHUHSpQWHWWH0LpUWNHOOHQHSpOGi XOHJ\MRWWiQ\LYDOLVKLWHOHVHEEQHNLJD]PRQGyEEQDNWDUWDQXQNÈNRVKpWYH]pUQpYVRUiW3
PHVWHUpQpO"0iUSHGLJMHO|OW²MHO|OYLV]RQ\iEDQPLQGHQNpSSHQMyFVNiQYDQQDNN|]
WNHJ\HGLQpYHOWpUpVHN
0LQGHQHVHWUHÈNRVPHVWHU%HO\|GMHpV.XOiQMDXJ\DQ~J\PDJiQKRUGMDDV]yEDQ OHY LQWHUSROiFLy WDUWDOPD PHJN|YHWHOWH N p Q \ V ] H U& Q p Y D O N R W i V M H J \ H L W PLQW3PHVWHULO\HQKHO\]HW&V]HPpO\QHYHLQLQFVRNXQNDUUDKRJ\DW|UWpQHOPLKLWHOHV VpJYDJ\KLWHOWHOHQVpJV]HPSRQWMiEyODNpWPDJLV]WHUQpYDGiVLPyGMiWV]HPEHiOOtWYDH]HNHW DW|UWpQHWLYDOyViJWDUWDORPPHJWHVWHVtWLQHNMHOHQWVNNL%HO\|GQpYDGiVLKiWWHUpUHN|Q\
YHPEHQPHJNtVpUHOWHPPDJ\DUi]DWRWDGQLPHUWÈNRVNUyQLNDtUyLNpQ\V]HUV]OWHKHO\]H WpEHQHQQHNRNiWOiWWDPPiVNpUGpVKRJ\QpYiWYLWHOLHONpS]HOpVHP%HOHGKHO\VpJQpY KHO\HVH.XOiQQHYpYHOH]WD]LWWLVIHQWiOOyV]NVpJV]HU&VpJHOOHQpUHVHPWHWWHPVWW|U|N HWLPRQMiQDN VHPPLYHO DOi QHP WiPDV]WKDWy YDG |WOHWpW XJ\DQ~J\ HOYHWHWWHP PLQW
*<g5))< JRQGRODWiW D.DOiQ QHP]HWVpJQpYYHO YDOy D]RQRVViJiUyO 0RVW iOOiVSRQWRPDW DQQ\LEDQPyGRVtWRPKRJ\*<g5))<|WOHWpWIRQWROJDWYDWDOiQPpJLVOHKHWVpJHVQHNYpOHP ÈNRVD.DOiQQHP]HWVpJQHYHWKDV]QiOWDIHO;V]i]DGUDWHWWV]HPpO\pQHNPHJQHYH]pVpUH
$IHOWHYpVPHJRNROiViUDSHUV]HPHVV]HQHPYROQDHOpJDUUDXWDOQRPKRJ\DNUyQLND.XODQ tUiVPyG~DODNMDD]LGWpVÈNRVPDJLV]WHUMHO|OpVLUHQGV]HUpWWHNLQWYHQHPFVDN>X@VKD QHP>R@V.ROiQNLHMWpVVHOpSS~J\ROYDVKDWy6WD]LVFVXSiQiOWDOiQRVWiPDV]WpNOHKHW QHKRJ\ÈNRVDQHP]HWVpJHNP~OWMDIHOpLJHQQDJ\pUGHNOGpVVHOIRUGXOW6RNNDOIRQWR VDEE pV INpQW NRQNUpWDEE PLQGH]HNQpO KRJ\ ÈNRV PDJLV]WHU LJHQ N|]HOL NDSFVRODWEDQ YROWD%RU%DU².DOiQQHP]HWVpJWDJMDLYDOO*<g5))<LP²DNLNQHP]HWVpJ QHYpWYDJ\NLFVLWPiVtWYD.XODQYDJ\DNRUDEHOLNLHMWpVQ\tOWN|]pS]iUWYiOWDNR]iViUD KDJ\DWNR]YDPHJ|U|NtWHWWH+RJ\H]DYLVV]DYHWtWpVLOHKHWVpJIHQQiOOKDWWDOiQMHO]LKRJ\
%RU V]HPpO\ pV QHP]HWVpJQpY EXNNDQ I|O D NUyQLNDNRPSR]tFLyQDN ÈOPRV YLVV]DPHQ JHQHDOyJLiMDIHOVRUROiViEDQLV65+.|]HOLLVPHUVQHP]HWVpJHNQHYpQHNP~OW KVHLNpQWYDOyPHJMHOHQtWpVHPDJDLVHUV$QRQ\PXVUHPLQLV]FHQFLDpVSHUV]HÈNRVQiOLV QpYKLiQ\EHOL NpQ\V]HU YDODPLQW D] tUiV HUHMpYHO HOpUKHW QHP]HWVpJL PHJWLV]WHOpVHJ\
V]HUVPLQG (EEpOL OHKHWVpJHV PDJ\DUi]DWRP DPHO\ OHJDOiEELV ÈNRVNRUDEHOL V]HPpO\HV NDSFVRODWRNNDOpVNUyQLNDtUyLQpYDGiVLJ\DNRUODWWDOPHJWiPRJDWKDWy WHUPpV]HWHVHQQHP WDUWDOPD]]D*<g5))<.XOiQ .DOiQ|WOHWpQHND]WDUpV]pWKRJ\DNUyQLNDHJ\WWHV.XODQ MDD%DU.DOiQQHP]HWVpJYDOyGLVpW|U|NtWHWWHYROQDPHJHQQHND]LGpVDWpUHOWpUpVHL HOOHQWPRQGDQDN HJ\V]HU& V]RNYiQ\RV NUyQLNDtUyL IRJiVUyO OHKHW LWW V]y FVXSiQ PLNpQW .XOiQWiUViUD%HO\|GUHYRQDWNR]yPDJ\DUi]DWRPEDQLVLO\HVPLUHJRQGROWDP
$ PDJ\DU W|UWpQHOHPEO iOWDODP NLLNWDWDQGy V]HPpO\NpQW .5,67Ï |W|GLNQHN (UGpHOYL6]ROWiQWKR]]DI|O6]ROWiQDNUyQLNiEDQLVNO|Q|VHQSHGLJYLWDSDUWQHUHPIHO IRJiViEDQ(UGpO\NRUDLW|UWpQHWpQHNHJ\LNNXOFVV]HUHSOMHDNLQHNKLWHOHVYDJ\KLWHOWHOHQ YROWDPLQGHQNpSSHQNRPRO\ILJ\HOPHWpUGHPHO$KR]]iI&]GSUREOHPDWLNDNpWHJ\
PiVVDO|VV]HIJJUpV]UHERQWDQGy
ÈNRVPDJLV]WHUQHND]D EHWROGiVDDPHO\EHQ(UGpHOYL6]ROWiQV]HPpO\HpVQHYHIHO EXNNDQWDUWDOPL]DYDURVViJiYDOHOOHQWPRQGiVRVViJiYDODOLJPDUDGHOD .HiQ²%HO\|G² .XOiQIpOH HSL]yGWyO 0LQGHQHNHOWW IHOW&Q EHQQH D] D ORJLNDL EXNIHQF KRJ\ ,VWYiQ SURDYXViWWHKiWHOWWHpOQHP]HGpNHWDJMiWQHYH]LNL(UGpO\XUiYi.5,67ÏPHJKDWiUR ]iViEDQ J\XODIHKpUYiUL LVSiQQi 7HWp]L D V]|YHJ HOOHQWPRQGiVRVViJiW KRJ\ EiUPLNpQW QHYH]]NLVDWLWXOXVW,VWYiQQDNDNUyQLNiNEDQiOWDOiQRVDQWDUWRWWE|OFVHVVpJpYHODOLJKD IpU|VV]HKiERU~VLGNXWiQIHOHOVVpJWHOMHVSHUVSHNWLYLNXVIHODGDWUDY|ÄTXLSRVWHDKH UHGLWDYLWLOODVSDUWHV7UDQVVLOYDQDV´ÄVXSHUJHQWHVRSXOHQWDV´65+²LO\HQDJ JDW\iQNLQHYH]pVHÈNRVPDJDLVpUH]KHWWHD]HOOHQWPRQGiVWDOLJKDQHPH]pUWHPHOWHNL PpJÄXWyLUDWNpQW´LV6]ROWiQÄDQWLTXLVVLPXV´YROWiYDOHJ\WWKRJ\D]PpJ6]HQW,VWYiQ NRUiWLV PHJWXGWDpUQL$OLJKDQHPLJD]DOHKHW0È/<86=QDN9,VWYiQNRULJHV]WD
DNLH]J\EHQDUUDJRQGROKRJ\ÈNRVPHVWHUÈ U S i G I L i Q D N 6 ] R O W i Q D N 6 ] R O W i Q Q D N DIHOPHUOWHPOpNpWKR]WDDQDNURQLNXVDQNpVEEUH$]LQWHUSROiFLyHJpV]pUH Qp]YHLVHJ\HWNHOOpUWHQHP*<g5))<YHODNLD]WtUWDÄHQQHNDEHV]~UiVQDNVHPPLW|UWp QHWLKLWHOWQHPNHOODGQXQN´LP1HPV]RNWDPQp]HWHLPHWV]DNPDLWHNLQWpO\HNNHO HUVtWJHWQL D] HO]HNEHQ VHP WHWWHP H]W NRUiEEL V]DNLURGDORPUD KLYDWNR]iVRNNDO LWW D]RQEDQ²D]HGGLJWiUJ\DOWDNNDOMyUpV]WHOOHQWpWEHQ²LQNiEED*\XOiNKR]PpUKHWHQ IRQWRVHUGpO\LW|UWpQHWLV]HPpO\LVpJUOOpYpQV]yWDOiQQHPpUGHNWHOHQKRJ\QHPHJ\H GOpQIRUJDWWDPIHMHPEHQÄNLLNWDWy´JRQGRODWRNDWHNpUGpVEHQVHP
.5,67ÏHUVHQNLIRJiVROMDKRJ\ÈNRVD](UGpHOYL6]ROWiQQpYKDV]QiODWiUyOÄpS SHQVpJJHORUGtWD]DQDNURQL]PXV´NLWpWHOOHOQ\LODWNR]WDP0HJYDOORPFVRGiONR]RPDPD J\DUW|UWpQHWLQpYWDQQDNRO\VRNMHOHVV]ROJiODWRWWHYV]HU]H]HQYpOHPpQ\pQ1HPWX GRNDUUyOKRJ\EiUPHO\LNNRUDLNUyQLNiQNEDQV]HUHSOV]HPpO\QHYHLO\HQWtSXV~PD J\DUQ\HOYLIRUPiEDQHIIpOHV]HUNH]HWEHQLO\HQQpYVRUUHQGEHQLO\HQ PRUIROyJLiM~MHO]L WDJJDOYROQDWDOiOKDWy,WWQHPFVDNDUUyOYDQV]yDPLWYLWDWiUVDPSHG]HJHWKRJ\WXGQLLOOLN QHP HVLN D]RQRV PHJtWpOpV DOi D ; V]i]DGUD YDJ\ D ;,,, V]i]DGUD YRQDWNR]WDWYD OHtUW V]HPpO\QHYH+DQHPDUUyOKRJ\VHPHO\LNPLQVpJpEHQVHPDNpS]HOWDODNpOHWpQHN LGHMpUHVHPDQpYOHtUiVLGHMpUH Q H P L O O L N L O \ H Q Q p Y D ] D G R W W V ] | Y H J E H 0pJHJ\PHJIHOHO=ROWDQ8OWUDVLOYDQXV7UDQVVLOYDQXVYDJ\=ROWDQGH8OWUDVLOYD QLD7UDQVVLOYDQLDLVNLUtQDHV]|YHJEO'HERQWVXNDQpYV]HUNH]HWHOHPHLWUpV]HNUH
$6]ROWiQQpYHOYLOHJD0HVWHUQHNNpWPHJJRQGROiViEyOLVSHQQiMDDOiNHUOKHWHWW .|QQ\HQ OHKHWVpJHV 0È/<86= HPOtWHWW JRQGRODWD KRJ\ WXGQLLOOLN PLQWHJ\ pYV]i]DGRV NURQROyJLDLWpYHV]WpVVHOÈUSiGILiQDNHPOpNpWÄHOHYHQtWHWWH´NpS]HOWV]HPpO\pQHNQHYp Yp NUyQLNiVDLQNQiO D] HIIpOH LGHOWROyGiVRN iOWDOiEDQ QHP NpSH]WHN W~O QDJ\ JRQGRW /HKHWHWWH]DQQDNDMHOHKRJ\ÈNRV²HJ\pENpQWpUWKHWHQ²QHPYROWHOpJJpWLV]WiEDQ D;V]i]DGNURQROyJLDLpVJHQHDOyJLDLYLV]RQ\DLYDO'HV]iPtWiVEDYHKHWHJ\PiVLN QpYDGiVLOHKHWVpJLVD0DJLV]WHUHJ\V]HU&HQFVDNHUGpO\LYRQDWNR]iV~QHYHWDNDUWDGQL V]HUHSOMpQHNVDMiWNRUiEyOYpYHDSpOGiWD6]ROWiQUD$]HJ\HOHP&6]ROWiQQpYXJ\DQ YLV]RQ\ODJULWNDYROWDPDJ\DUN|]pSNRUEDQOSO=ROWDQLJHQÈÒ2 VDGDWDLQDNHJ\UpV]HLVORNDOL]iOKDWDWODQGHD]NpWVpJHQIHOOiOOKRJ\DV]pNHO\VpJKH]
HUVHQN|WG|WW(OVVRUEDQDV]pNHO\VpJQHNDEEyODUpV]OHJpEOPXWDWKDWyNLDPHO\YL V]RQ\ODJNRUDLLGNWONH]GYHD*\XODIHKpUYiUN|UOLiWMiUyNDWUL]WHV]HPpO\QpYLpV KHO\QpYL Q\RPDL D .p]GL SDWDN Y|OJ\pWO GpONHOHW IHOp D PDL 6]pNHO\I|OG GpOL UpV]pLJ V]pSHQPHJPXWDWNR]QDNOSO=ROWDQJ\SHZ*<g5))<(V]pNHO\6]ROWiQ RNQDNSHUV]HFVDNDQpYHWLPRQMiEDQYDQN|]ND]ÈUSiGRNKR]+RJ\ÈNRVRPLQy]XV V]HPpO\H QHYpEHQ D6]ROWiQW V]HUHSHOWHWL HVHWOHJ DOiWiPDV]WKDWMD D] PiV NULWpULX PRNNDOLVPHJWiPRJDWKDWy*\XODIHKpUYiUYLGpNLLVPHUHWpWKDWDOiQQHPLVV]HPp O\HVHQWDUWy]NRGiVGHSpOGiXOD.iQRNN|]OpVHUpYpQLV
$QpYHJpV]INpUGpVHVHJ\~WWDODQpYDGiVOHJMHOOHP]EEDQDNURQL]PXVDSHUV]HD]
(UGpHOYLQpYUpV].H]GMND]RQKRJ\ÈNRVHOYLOHJNpWIpOH V]HPDQWLNDLDODSRQDGKDWRWW 6]ROWiQQDNLNpS]V(UGpHOYLMHO]WKDQpYDGiViEDQDNpS]YHO(UGpO\EOYDOyV]iU PD]iVWDNDUWMHO|OQLYDJ\KDD]RGDNHUOpVLOOHWOHJD]RWWXUDONRGiVWpQ\pWDNDUWDLO\
PyGRQXWyODJRVUDJDGYiQ\QpYYHOPHJHUVtWHQL
$]HOVOHKHWVpJHWYDOyV]tQ&OHJNLOHKHW]iUQLWXGQLLOOLN6]ROWiQWPLQWD]ÈUSiG Ki]LJHQN|]HOLpVUpJLWDJMiWÈNRVDOLJKDiOOtWKDWWDYROQDEHHUGpO\LV]OHWpV&QHNKLV]HQ H]D] HOOHQVpJHV*\XODFVDOiGKR]VRUROiVWLVMHOHQWKHWWHYROQD7RYiEEiQ p Y p V N p S ] p O H W W D Q L V ] H P S R Q W E y O V H P I R J D G K D W y H O H]DYDULiFLyXJ\DQLVD]RN D NpWHOHP&QpYLV]HUNH]HWHNDPHO\HNKHO\LFVDOiGKDJ\RPiQ\UDV]iUPD]iVLKHO\UHXWDO QDND0DJLV]WHULGHMpQPpJIHKpUKROOyV]iPEDLVDOLJPHKHWWHND]RNOHYHOHNGH KHO\
VpJQpYWtSXV~V]HPpO\PHJMHO|OpVHLQHNPDJ\DULNpS]VPHJIHOHOLD;,,,V]i]DGXWROVy
KDUPDGiEDQNH]GHQHNIHOWQHGH]QLOWOHP5pJLPV]QDGiV.RQNUpWDQSHGLJD]
¶HUGpO\L(UGpO\EOV]iUPD]y¶MHOHQWpV&HNUHUDJDGYiQ\pVFVDOiGQpYLYRQDORQFVDNEyO WDOiOMXNHOV SpOGiMXNDW(UGHO\.È=0e5 &VDO6] ² ² 0DUDGQD D KHO\L RWWOH YpVWV]HUHSOpVWELUWRNOiVW NLIHMH] L NpS]V QpYL HOWDJ OHKHWVpJH DPHO\UH WXODMGRQ NpSSHQDV]|YHJLVXWDOQLOiWV]LNÄLGHRYXOJDULWHUVLFGLFLVROHW(UGHHOXL=ROWDQ´65+
,WWPHJD]LVEDMKRJ\DV]|YHJV]HULQWDQHYHWQHPDNLUiO\DGMDD](UGpO\EH NOGpVFpOMiQDNHJ\HGOLLVPHUHWpEHQKDQHP6]ROWiQUDRGDNHUOpVHXWiQN|UQ\H]HWHUD JDV]WMDUiRWWYLV]RQWHQpYQHPYiOKDWHJ\HGLOHJPHJKDWiUR]yYiDKROPLQGHQNL¶HUGpO\L¶
ÈNRVPHVWHULNpS]VPHOOpNQpYEODONRWRWWQpYDGiVDWHKiWHJ\IHOOQHPOHKHWSUHNRQ FHSFLy]XVVHPPiVIHOOLGHQWLILNiOyVHP,O\HVIpOHQHYHNQHNQHPLVLJHQYDQ NRQNUpW Q\HOYLSpOGiMXN
1HPOHKHWWHKiWNpWVpJHVKRJ\D](UGpO\L6]ROWiQQpYPLQWQ\HOYLIRUPiFLy N L O y J D N R U D L P D J \ D U Q p Y D G i V E y O p V IN p Q W D N U y Q L N i E y O ÈNRV PHVWHU P&YL WDOiOPiQ\D pSS~J\ PLQW D P|J|WWH OpY V]HPpO\ LV 0iV NpUGpV KRJ\
ÈNRV PLO\HQ PHJJRQGROiVEyO FVHOHNHGWH H]W (EEH EHOHOiWQXQN SHUV]H PHJOHKHWVHQ EDMRV $QQ\L DOLJKDQHP Q\LOYiQYDOy KRJ\ H QpYDGiVVDO LV D] HJpV] J\ HUGpO\LVpJpW
*\XOiKR].HiQKR]YDOyLGEHOLpVWHUOHWLN|W|WWVpJpWNtYiQWDKDQJV~O\R]QL+RJ\H]HQ IHOO QpYLQ\HOYL P&YHOWVpJpKH] NHYpVEp LOO NO|QOHJHV DQDNURQLNXV V]HUNH]HWWHO pOW DUUDWDOiQPHJNRFNi]WDWKDWyKRJ\ H]W VHP YpOHWOHQO KDQHP WXGDWRVDQ VDMiWRVVWtOXV MHJ\NpQWWHWWH.RUDLNUyQLNiVDLQNHV]PHYLOiJiEDQpUWKHWHQHUVHQPXQNiOWD]DW|UHN YpVKRJ\DKRPiO\RVDQKLiQ\RVIRUUiVRNEyOLVPHUWP~OWYDOyVYDJ\NpS]HOWFVHOHNPp Q\HLW NpQ\V]HU&HQ NLWDOiOW V]HPpO\HNNHO LOOHWOHJ H]HNHW PHJWHVWHVtW QHYHNNHO KLWHOHVtWVpNNO|QIpOHJ\HVHQDONDOPD]RWWtUyLHV]N|]|NNHOpOYH(QQHNHJ\LNPyGMDD]
HJ\NRUL QpYDGiV PHJW|UWpQWpQHN RNiUD N|UOPpQ\HLUH KLYDWNR]iV (VHWQNEHQ ÈNRV D UpJP~OWKLWHOHVWDQ~MDNpQWD]HJ\NRULN|]V]RNiVUDÄVLF GLFL VROHW´XWDOiVWYDODPLQW D QpSLQ\HOYLV]LQWHQ W|UWpQHPOHJHWpVW ÄYXOJDULWHU´ YiODV]WRWWD PHO\ XWyEELWXJ\DQ PHJOHKHWVHQULWNiQDONDOPD]WDGHH]DQQiOLQNiEEPHJHUVtWNLHPHOMHOOHJJHOKDW KDWRWWDV]|YHJEHQIHOHGWHWYHD]ROYDVyYDOD]DQDNURQL]PXVpVDORJLNiWODQViJWpQ\pWLV
0HUVHEXUJL7KLHWPDUDNRUWiUVLPDJ\DUYH]HWUpWHJQpJ\V]HPpO\pWHPOtWL&KUR QLFRQMiEDQ:DLF,VWYiQNLUiO\3URFXL*\XOD'HYLX[']VpFVD*p]D%HOHNQHJLQL 6DUROW (]HN N|]O N|Q\YHPEHQ D *\XODNpUGpV HSL]yGMDNpQW FVDN3URNXMMDO IRJODO NR]WDP YDODPHQQ\LUH LV pUGHPOHJHVHQ D%HOHNQHJLQL QHYHW3URNXM DQDOyJLiMDNpQW PpJ pULQWOHJHVHEEHQ KR]WDP I|O 9DMNUyO FVXSiQ MHJ\]HWEHQ WHWWHP IXWy PHJMHJ\]pVW 'HYLX[UyO SHGLJ PLYHO 7KLHWPDU D IHMHGHOHP LVPHUW QHYpW N|]|OWH QHP WDUWRWWDP V]NVpJHVQHN V]yOQL .5,67Ï*<8/$ D]W PRQGMD KRJ\ D] HPOtWHWW V]HUHSON PiVRGLN QHYpW HOYLWDWWDP +RJ\ HUUH D PHJiOODStWiVUD MXWKDWRWW D] D] pQ KLEiPEyO LV IDNDGKDW PHUWV]&NUHIRJRWWPRQGDQLYDOyPDWQ\LOYiQQHPIHMWHWWHPNLNHOOHQYDJ\pSSHQIpOUH pUWKHWYpWHWWHP0RVWH]pUWLVNpQ\WHOHQYDJ\RNKDSHUV]HLWWLVNRUOiWR]RWWWpUEHQSy WROQL D PXODV]WRWWDNDW PiU FVDN D]pUW LV PHUW D ] H G G L J W i U J \ D O W N | O W | W W V ] H P p O \ H N N H O V ] H P E H Q H N | U E H Q K L W H O H V p O V ] H P p O \ H N UO YDQV]yDNLNUiDGiVXODPDJ\DUW|UWpQHOHPIRQWRVV]HUHSOL
0LQGHQHNHOWWDUUDNHOOXWDOQRPPpUWILJ\HOWHPI|ONO|QDPHUVHEXUJLSVS|NQp YLHOMiUiVPyGMiUD$]HPOtWHWWV]HPpO\HNQHPFVDNNRUXNEDQYROWDNKHO\]HWNQpOIRJYD N|]LVPHUWHNKDQHPQHYNDNRUDLKD]DLpVUpV]EHQNOI|OGLW|UWpQHWtUiVSURGXNWXPDLEDQLV MyFVNiQ V]HUHSHO 'H PLQGLJ FVDN iOWDOiQRVDQ LVPHUW HJ\HWOHQ QHYN|Q D 7KLHWPDU HPOHJHWWpQ V R K D V H P $SVS|NYLV]RQWQHPFVDNKRJ\DW|EELIRUUiVEyOLVPHUWQH YNHWQHPKDV]QiOMDKDQHPV]OiYQ\HOYLIRUPiNQDNPHJIHOHOQHYN|QQHYH]LPHJNHW 5iDGiVXODISDSUyOWXGQLOHKHWKRJ\OHJDOiEEHJ\V]OiYQ\HOYHWEL]WRVDQEHV]pOWH]PLQ
GHQYDOyV]tQ&VpJV]HULQWDQ\DQ\HOYHYDJ\OHJDOiEELVPiVRGLNDQ\DQ\HOYHD V]RUEYROW V]OiYViJiWV]OHWpVLKHO\HpVINpQWQpYKDV]QiODWDPHJDKKR]I&]|WWPHJMHJ\]pVHLWi PDV]WMiNDOi0LQGH]HNDODSMiQPHUOIHODNpUGpVRO\OHKHWHWOHQGRORJHD]KRJ\H]J\
EHQ ² DPLQW pQ JRQGRORP ² QHPFVDN YpOHWOHQ HJ\EHHVpVUO OHKHW V]y pV D SVS|N QHPFVDNSXV]WDDGDWN|]OMHHQQHND]HJ\HQNpQWLVNLYpWHOHVQHY&FVRSRUWQDNKDQHPD QHYHN HJ\WWHV SUREOHPDWLNiMD LV WRYiEEL PDJ\DUi]DWRW NtYiQ 0HJJ\]GpVHP KRJ\
H]WDWXGRPiQ\ UpV]pUO LV NHUHVQL V]NVpJHV D] PiV GRORJ KRJ\ HVHWOHJ QHP OHKHW PLQGHQUpV]OHWpQHNDQ\LWMiUDMXWQL
.pWN|UOPpQ\WPLQGHQNpSSHQOHNHOOV]|JH]QQN0HUVHEXUJL7KLHWPDUWXGDWiEDQ YROWDPDJ\DUYLV]RQ\RNQDNPpJSHGLJDOLJKDHOVVRUEDQNOI|OGLtURWWIRUUiVRNEyOKD QHPN|]YHWOHQHEEKD]iQNEyOYDOypUWHVOpVHNNHO+RJ\HEEHQN|]UHMiWV]RWWHDWHUOHWL N|UQ\H]HWpEHNHUOW*\XODWiMpNR]WDWiVDD]IHOYHWKHWXJ\DQGHQHPEL]RQ\tWKDWyD]
YLV]RQW NpWVpJWHOHQQHN W&QLN KRJ\ D V]yEDQ OHYQHYHN YLVHOLQHN GROJDLW D OpQ\HJHV YRQiVRNEDQLVPHUWHPLQWDKRJ\Q\LOYiQLVPHUWHRWWKRQiOWDOiQRVDQKDV]QiOWQHYNHWLV PpJVHPtUWDOHVHP*\XOipWVHP6DUROWpWVHPOHJDOiEELVD]HJ\Ki]LQ\HOYEHQtJ\KDV]
QiOW6WHSKDQXVW8J\DQDNNRUQHPLJHQIpUKHWNpWVpJKR]]iKRJ\HJ\LNQpYVHPIRUGtWiV 7KLHWPDUQiOKLV]HQV]iPiUDPHJIHOHOLN²D6WHSKDQXVY|J|U|J¶NRV]RU~¶IHOWHKHW NLYpWHOpYHO²V]HPDQWLNDLODJYDJ\pSSHQHWLPROyJLDLODJpUWHOPH]KHWHWOHQHNOHWWHNYRO QDËJ\DWOHDONDOPD]RWWPHJQHYH]pVHNHWLOOHWHQFVDNDV]HPpO\NUOWXODMGRQViJDLN UyO KHO\]HWNUO UHQGHONH]pVpUH iOOy LVPHUHWHNUH WiPDV]NRGKDWRWW *\XOD3URNXM HVHWp EHQH]²PLQWPiUXWDOWDPUi²V]HPpO\HVpULQWNH]pVYDJ\QDJ\RQN|]HOLKHO\LIRUUiV
%ROHVODYXGYDUDN|UQ\H]HWHLVVHJtWVpJpUHOHKHWHWW%HOHNQHJLQLpV9DMNHVHWpEHQD]RQEDQ FVDN0DJ\DURUV]iJUyONLVXJiU]yKtUQHYNM|KHWV]iPtWiVED
'HYDQQDNHQHYHNN|UONRQNUpWV]HPDQWLNDLSUREOpPiNLV*\XODQHYHW|U|N PpOWyViJQpYEO LJHQ NRUiQ YDOyGL PDJ\DU V]HPpO\QpYYp YiOW DSMD XWiQ NDSRWW*\XOD QHYpW PHO\HW D NUyQLNiVRN W|EEV]|U|VHQ PHJHUVtWHWWHN Q\LOYiQ J\HUPHNNRUD yWD YL VHOWH 7KLHWPDUWyO IHOMHJ\]HW3URNXM QHYH V]OiY HUHGHW&|VV]HWpWHO MHOHQWpVH ¶HOKDJ\RWW PHJPDUDGW QDJ\EiW\D¶ WLSLNXVDQ UDJDGYiQ\ MHOOHJ& FVDN pOHPHGHWW NRUEDQ YLVHOKHW ÄEHV]pO QpY´ ( QHYHW PHO\ NpWVpJEHYRQKDWDWODQXO XQRND|FFVpKH] D]W IRJViJED YHW PDMG V]iP&] ,VWYiQKR] YDOy YLV]RQ\iW WDUWDOPD]]D 0 D J \ D U R U V ] i J R Q Q H P N D S K D W W D 1HPFVXSiQD]pUWPHUWKD]DLIRUUiVRNQHPLVPHULNKDQHPpSSHQ MHOHQWpVHPLDWWVHP0RVWKDJ\MXND]WKRJ\DIHKpUYiUL*\XOiNXGYDUiEDQQHPI|OWpW OHQOOHKHWHWWQpYDGyV]HUHS&DV]OiYQ\HOYLPLOLGHHUGpO\LV]OiYN|UQ\H]HWEHQQHPLV QHYH]KHWWpNYROQDtJ\KLV]HQFVDNRQQDQHONHUOYH,VWYiQWyOV]iPNLYHWHWWHQUDJDGKDWRWW UiH]D]HOQHYH]pV0DJ\DURUV]iJUDKXUFROiVDLOOHWOHJE|UW|QEHYHWpVHVHPLJHQOHKHWHWW DONDOPDV WpQ\H] V]OiY QpYDGiV PHJW|UWpQWpUH $] RUV]iJRQ NtYOUH V]OiY FVHK OHQJ\HOV]RUEQ\HOYLN|UQ\H]HWEHNHUOYHYLV]RQWSRQWRVDQLOOHWWUiH]DUDJDGYiQ\QpY
$%HOHNQHJLQLQpYHVHWpEHQLVYDQEL]RQ\RVKDVRQOyViJD]HOEELKH]*\XODOi Q\DD6DUROWQHYHWPHO\0(/,&+V]HOOHPHVPDJ\DUi]DWDV]HULQWW|U|NEiUNRUiQWVHPEL ]RQ\RVDQEROJiUW|U|NHUHGHW&Y|/,*(7, 7|U.DSFVPpJ)HKpUYiURWWJ\HUPHN NRUiEDQNDSKDWWD$]D]RQEDQPiUW|EEPLQWNpWVpJHVKRJ\HQQHND]HWLPRQMDV]HULQW
¶IHKpUV]NHKHUPHOLQILDWDOQ¶MHOHQWpV&GHPiUDPDJ\DUQ\HOYKDQJW|UYpQ\HLKH]LJD ]RGRWWQpYQHNEiUPLN|]YHWOHQN|]HOHQQH 7KLHWPDU%HOHNQHJLQLMpKH]SOiQHKRJ\ DQ QDN PLQW V]OiY Q\HOYL |VV]HWpWHOQHN D ¶IHKpUV]pS IHMHGHOHPQ¶ MHOHQWpVpUH D OHJMREE HVHWEHQLVFVDNDQ\HOYHNN|]WL S i U K X ] D P R V Q p Y D G i V V]pSSpOGiMiYDOiOOKDWXQN LWWV]HPEHQ$PHUVHEXUJLSVS|N6DUROWRW²V]|YHJpEONLWHWV]HQPiUD3URNXMQpY KDV]QiODWWDO D]RQRV LGEHQ ² WLV]WpKH] pV KtQHYpKH] LOOQpYHQ Q\LOYiQ D UyOD NDSRWW pUWHVOpVHNQHNPHJIHOHOHQQHYH]LPHJDV]OiYQ\HOYLQpYDGiVWpQ\pQHNNO|QKDQJV~
O\iQ W~O ROYDVyL V]iPiUD Q\LOYiQYDOyYi WpYH D] HOQHYH]pV V]HPDQWLNDL DODSMDLW LV Ä%HOHNQHJLQLLGHVWSXOFKUDGRPLQD6FODYRQLFHGLFWD´*20%26
6]HUI|O|WWNpWVpJHVWHKiWKRJ\HNpWQpYNHOHWNH]pVpQHNLOOHWOHJDONDOPD]iViQDN Q\HOYLN|]HJHDPDJ\DURUV]iJLN|]HOHEEUOD]HUGpO\LV]OiYViJEDQYROQDNHUHVHQG 0iV OHKHWVpJQNWHKiWQHPLJHQYDQPLQW7KLHWPDUYRQ0HUVHEXUJN|UONHUHVNHGQL3URNXM pV%HOHNQHJLQLGROJDD]RQEDQD&KURQLNRQEDQHJ\WWHVPHJMHOHQpVNLYpWHOpYHODSVS|N Q\HOYLV]HUHSpWWHNLQWYHDOLJKDQHPV]pWYiOLN0LYHO*\XODD]RQDQ\XJDWLV]OiYWHUOHWHQ NDSRWW PHQHGpNHW Q\HUW HO KLYDWDOL IXQNFLyW pOWH OH IHOHVpJpYHO HJ\WW WRYiEEL pOHWpW DPHO\ D SVS|NQHN LV V]OHWpVpQpO IRJYD Q\HOYL N|U]HWH YROW YDOyV]tQ&EE KRJ\ LQQHQ V]OiYpOQ\HOYLQpYDGiVUpYpQQ\HUWHHOUiLOOUDJDGYiQ\QHYpWpVDSVS|NHQQHNDPiU V]RFLiOLVViYiOWQpYKDV]QiODWQDNLQNiEEFVDNtURWWQ\HOYLI|OKDV]QiOyMDN|]YHWtWMHOHKH WHWW(YRQDWNR]iVEDQWHKiWSRQWRVtWDQiPD]WDNRUiEEDQIRJDOPD]RWWNLWpWHOHPHWKRJ\
D3URNXMQpY7KLHWPDUÄVDMiWP&YLDONRWiVD´KLV]HQWDOiQMREEKDD]WPRQGRPtUyLDO NDOPD]iVDEiUWRYiEEUDVHP]iUQiPNLWHOMHVHQD]WDOHKHWVpJHWKRJ\SRQWRVPDJ\DU RUV]iJLpUWHVOpVHLWV]OiYRVtWyQpYV]RNiViWpVQ\HOYLWHNLQWpO\pWV]iPtWiVEDYpYHHVHWOHJ PpJLVYROWHQpYV]ODSMDNpQWDQQDNHOWHUMHV]WMHLV$OpQ\HJD]RQEDQQHPH]HNEHQ D QpYDGiVL pV QpYWHUMHGpVL iUQ\DODWRNEDQ YDQ KDQHP DEEDQ DPL D*\XOD YDJ\J\XOD NpUGpVW DODSMDLEDQ LV pULQWL D*\XOD pV D3URNXM WXODMGRQQpY QHP IXQNFLRQiOW QHP LV IXQNFLRQiOKDWRWW V]LQRQLPDNpQW HJ\D]RQ V]RFLiOLV²Q\HOYL N|UQ\H]HWEHQ D * \ X O D V ] H P p O \ Q p Y Y R O W Q H P W L V ] W V p J Q p Y 3URNXMJ\XODHPOHJHWpVHPLQGDQ\HOYL N|]HJPLQGDQpYLWDUWDORPV]HPSRQWMiEyOIiEyOYDVNDULND² 7KLHWPiU%HOHNQHJLMpQpO YLV]RQWDQpYV]OiYViJDPHOOHWWDOLJKDOHKHWNpUGpVHVDQQDN t U R W W p V Q H P E H V ] p O W Q \ H O Y L Y R O W D PLYHO H] D ISDS Q\LOYiQYDOy tUyL P&YL DONRWiVD KtUQpYL DODSRQ ÄVFODYRQLFH´pUWHOPH]pVH
$OHJNpQ\HVHEEHVHWNpWVpJNtYO7KLHWPDU9DMNKDSD[D0LQGHQHNHOWWD]WNHOOKDQJ V~O\R]QRPKRJ\,VWYiQNLUiO\QDNHQpYHQHPOtWpVpUOQHPFVDND]pUWV]yOWDPKDFVDN pULQWOHJHVHQLV3URNXMMDOpV%HOHNQHJLYHOHJ\VRUEDQHJ\SUREOpPDN|WHJEHQPHUWDPHU VHEXUJLSVS|NV]|YHJpEHQHJ\WWV]HUHSHOYHONKDQHPD]pUWLVPLYHOQDJ\YDOyV]tQ&
VpJJHOXJ\DQFVDN V ] O i Y H U H G H W& Q p Y 6]|YHJpEONLWHWV]HQ.5,67ÏQ\LOYiQH]
XWyEELWKHO\WHOHQtWHWWH ,WW QLQFV HOHJHQGKHO\ iOOiVSRQWRP UpV]OHWHVHEE PHJRNROiViUD NO|QEHQLVHOiWKDWyDQNpQ\HVQpYV]iUPD]WDWiVLNpUGpVDPDJ\DUQ\HOYpVW|UWpQHWWX GRPiQ\W|UWpQHWHHJ\HVMHOOHJ]HWHVIi]LVDLEDNHOOEHiJ\D]iVQpONOQHKH]HQWiUJ\DOKDWy 0pJLVQpKiQ\LGHYiJyPHJMHJ\]pVWQHPNHUOKHWHNNL
6]DNLURGDOPXQNEDQpYWL]HGHNyWDPiLJN|]KHO\QHNV]iPtWHOVNLUiO\XQN9DMNQHYp QHNW|U|NHUHGHWH3HGLJQHPYROWH]PLQGLJtJ\3pOGiXOPRGHUQW|UWpQHWLQpYWXGRPi Q\XQNPHJDODStWyMiQDNpVNLYiOyViJiQDN0(/,&+-È126QDN01\LVMyYROWPpJ DV]i]DGHOQHQpYV]OiYEyOYDOyPDJ\DUi]DWD5OHQJ\HO9DMN EHFp]V]HPpO\QpY'H WXGRPiQ\XQNPiVLNQDJ\DODNMD*20%2&==2/7È19g01\7.V]VHP VRUROWD V]HQWNLUiO\XQNYLOiJLQHYpWUpJLW|U|NV]HPpO\QHYHLQNN|]pGDFiUDDQQDNKRJ\D],VWYiQ NLUiO\9DMN QHYpYHO NDSFVRODWEDQ NpVEE WXGRPiQ\RV ÄVOiJHUUp´ YiOW W|U|N pV PDJ\DU
%DMW|UEDMEDMDQ¶JD]GDJ¶ULWNiEEDQ¶JD]GDJKVYH]pU¶V]HPpO\QHYHWpVFVDOiGMiW W]HWHVHQV]iPEDYHWWHXR²$]WiQD7ULDQRQXWiQNLDODNXOWMHOOHJ]HWHVQpYWDQLIHO IRJiVQDNPHJIHOHOHQ1e0(7+*<8/$+RQI.LDO²²PpJLVtJ\ÄIHMWHWWH PHJ´ H QHYHW W|UEDM ¶JD]GDJ VWE¶ PpOWyViJQpY PN NLFVLQ\tW PDJ\DUi]DWiEDQ
*20%2&=RWPLQWHQQHND9DMNNDOYDOyÄ|VV]HYHWMpW´"HPOHJHWWHVPDJ\DUYDODPLQW RV]PiQOL E ! Y KDQJYiOWR]iVUD KLYDWNR]RWW $]yWD D] HOIRJDGiV QHPERO\JDWiV"
FVHQGMHXUDONRGLNDQpYN|UOFVXSiQ5È621<,/È6=/Ï$FWD2U²NtVpUHOWH PHJHQpYQHN~MDEEW|U|NPDJ\DUi]DWiWDGQLW|UED\wT¶LJD]V]LQWHPHJEt]KDWy¶
WRYiEEiPpJ*<g5))<WO,VWYiQNLUROYDVWDPHJ\yYDWRVPHJMHJ\]pVWH]J\EHQ"
PYDM¶]VtU¶pV.,66/$-26)1(6]MHO]HWWD9DMN9DMNDKHO\VpJQHYHNPD J\DUi]DWiEDQDW|U|N%DMpVDPDJ\DUYDMV]HPpO\QpYLV]iUPD]WDWiVPHOOHWWÄOD]RQEDQ´
QDOV]OiYOHKHWVpJHNHW9LV]RQWW|EEHQWXGQLYpOWpNKRJ\D9DMNSRJiQ\NRUEyOKR]RWW QpY KRJ\ ,VWYiQ J\HUPHNNRUiEDQ YLVHOWH VWE 1e0(7+ PHJIHMWpVpQHN VLNHUH D 7ULDQRQ XWiQLVRNNRNR]WDPDJ\DUOHONLpVWXGRPiQ\SROLWLNDLKHO\]HWHWWHNLQWYHPDJ\DUi]KDWyXJ\DQ DQpYNpUGpVHUHYLGHiOiViQDNHOPDUDGiVDPiUNHYpVEp
3HGLJ1e0(7+HWLPRQMDH]HUVHEEOYpU]LN0iUD]VHPPHOO]KHWKRJ\DW|U|N Q\HOYHNEHQ9DMNV]HPpO\QpYQLQFVDW|U|NN|]QpYPDJ\DUNpS]pVHSHGLJSXV]WDILNFLy PpJ3$,6LVDNLSHGLJDW|U|NQpYHWLPRQRNDWLJHQNHGYHOWHW|EEV]|ULVV]yWHPHOWDW|U|N N|]V]yPDJ\DUQpYNpS]WDUWDOPD]WDDGRWWLGNEHQIXWyV]DODJRQNpV]OWPDJ\DUi]DWL HOYHOOHQ0pJQDJ\REEEDMH PDJ\DUi]DWN|UOD]KRJ\W|EEV]i]W|U|NHWLPRQXQNN|]W WDOiQHJ\NpW>Y@VNH]GHW&KDYDQKRJ\W|EEWXFDW>E@NH]GHW&PDJ\DUV]yHWLPRQEDQD N|]W|U|N >E@ a FVXYDV >S@ NH]GHW PLQGLJ PHJPDUDG VRKD >Y@Yp QHP YiOLN PpJ D PHOOpNDODNYiOWR]DWRNV]LQWMpQVHPKRJ\D]VpVyPDJ\DUUDNLPXWDWKDWy>@N|UO]DMOy
>E@a >Y@YiOWDNR]iVRNQDNQLQFVHQHNyW|U|NYRQDWNR]iVDLHOOHQWpWEHQNpVEELN|OFV|Q]p V&V]OiYpV ~MODWLQ M|YHYpQ\V]DYDLQNNDO $ PDJ\DU%DMN %DMND WXODMGRQQHYHNQHN D 9DMNKR]VHPPLN|]NQLQFV-yOWXGWDPLQGH]W*20%2&=LVEL]WRVYDJ\RNEHQQHKRJ\
KDHVHWOHJQHPLVJRQGROWDV]OiYUDHPLDWWQHPM|KHWHWWQiODV]iPEDDPDJ\DUQpYW|U|N HWLPRQMDPiVNpUGpVKRJ\²VRNDQPiVRNNDOHJ\WW²PpUWQHPFiIROWD1e0(7+HW
$]yPDJ\DUEDQWHUPpV]HWHVHQPHJYROWD9RMN!9DMNWXODMGRQQpYVWV]pSV]iP PDONLPXWDWKDWyPLQGV]HPpO\PLQGKHO\QHYHLQNN|UpEHQD.iUSiWPHGHQFHV]iPRV YLGpNpQW|EEV]|UPDJ\DU²V]OiYYDJ\PDJ\DUQ\HOYLN|UQ\H]HWHNEHQ$GDWDLW|EE |VV]H iOOtWiVEDQ PHJWDOiOKDWyN LWW QHP W|OW|P YHON D WHUHW FVXSiQ D]W HPOtWHP PHJ KRJ\
OHJ~MDEEDQ*<g5))<W|UWpQHWLI|OGUDM]iEDQD1\LWUDPHJ\HL9DMNKHO\VpJQpYUO D]WWHWWHI|OKRJ\6]HQW,VWYiQLIM~NRULQHYpWU]LDPLSHUV]HLO\HQQpYDGiVLYLV]RQ\EDQ DOLJKLKHW²$PDJ\DU9DMNV]HPpO\QpYQHNDV]OiYQ\HOYHNEHQHOVVRUEDQDQ\XJDWL V]OiYEDQGHDQpYFVDOiGNpS]VYiOWR]DWDLEDQPpJDNHOHWLV]OiYQ\HOYHNEHQLVEVpJH VHQPHJYDQQDNDV]HPpO\QpYLpVD]H]HNEOOHWWKHO\QpYLHO]PpQ\HLUpJHEEUOLVNp VEEUOLVV]pSV]iPPDONLPXWDWKDWyDQOSOOHQJ\HO:RMNV]RUE9yMNFVHK9RMN² XNUiQ<hbdZ VWE O .,66 L K LV $ QpY D GpOV]OiY Q\HOYHNEHQ XJ\DQ ULWNiEE YROW GH DPDJ\DUQHP]HWVpJHNVRUiEDHPHONHGHWWGpOLV]OiYHUHGHW& 9RMNQHP]HWVpJLVYLVHOWH PHO\D3R]VHJDPHJ\HL.HUHV]W~UYLGpNpQELUWRNROWÄGHJHQHUH:R\N´Ä.H UHVWKXUDG JHQHUDWLRQHP:R\NSHUWLQHQV´ÈÒ2² 6=(173 +(//(5
&RP3RVOPpJ.$5È&621<, 01HP]
7KLHWPDUSVS|N,VWYiQNLUiO\XQN9DMNQHYpWWHOMHVHQQ\LOYiQYDOyDQQHPPDJDDO NRWWD1pYKDV]QiODWiQDNPDJ\DURUV]iJLpUWHVOpVHNLOOHWOHJPDJ\DUYRQDWNR]iV~IRUUiVRN OHKHWWHNDWiPDV]DL~J\DKRJ\,VWYiQDSMiQDN'HYL[QHYHHVHWpQLV(J\YLV]RQWEL]RQ\RV D9DMNQHYHW,VWYiQUDPLQWIHOQWWUHPLQWNHUHV]WpQ\NLUiO\UDKDV]QiOWDV]|YHJpEOH]YL OiJRVDQNLW&QLNÄ:DLFLQUHJQRVXLPHWHSLVFRSDOHVFDWKHGUDVFRURQDPHWEHQHGLFFLRQHP DFFHSLW´*20%26$OLJKDOHKHWNpUGpVHVKRJ\HOVNLUiO\XQNKD]DL9DMNQHYH NHOHWNH]pVpEHQ PHJHO]WH D NHUHV]WVpJEHQ IHOYHWW 6WHSKDQXV,VWsYDQ QHYHW +RJ\
D9DMNRWV]OHWpVpWOLOOHWOHJJ\HUPHNNRUiWyOYLVHOWHH D]OHKHWVpJHVGHSHUV]HQHP EL]RQ\tWKDWy1HYpQHNV]OiYHUHGHWHWHUPpV]HWHVHQQHPMHOHQWLKRJ\,VWYiQNLIHMH]HWWHQ V]OiYQHYHWNDSRWWKLV]HQHQpYDPDJ\DUViJN|UpEHQHOWHUMHGWVpJpQpOIRJYD²DQpYGL YDWJ\RUVWHUMHGpVHIRO\WiQ²PiUEYHQDPDJ\DULOOHWOHJDPDJ\DUViJiOWDOKDV]QiOW QpYNLQFVWDUWR]pNDLVOHKHWHWW$9DMNSHUV]HOHJDOiEEIDPLOLiULVN|UEHQDNHUHV]WpQ\NL UiO\UDWRYiEEUDLVKDV]QiODWEDQOHKHWHWWD PHUVHEXUJLISDSIHOMHJ\]pVHH]WDOiWiPDV]W KDWMD$]NHYpVVpKLKHWKRJ\7KLHWPDUDNLUiO\HJ\Ki]LQHYpWQHLVPHUWHYROQDIHOW&Q YLV]RQWKRJ\D6WHSKDQXVDONDOPD]iViWDODWLQtUiVEHOLVpJEHQPpJLVHONHUOWH2NDDOLJKD
OHKHWPiVPLQWWXGDWRVDONDOPD]iVpU]pNHOWHEHQQHD]iOWDODQ\LOYiQMyOLVPHUWV]OiYQH YHNNHORWWLVI|OWHKHWHQHOVVRUEDQDV]RUE9yMNNDOYDOyD]RQRVViJiWDPLPpJMyOEHOH LVLOOHWWV]OiYRVtWyV]RUERVtWyQpYKDV]QiODWiEDY|QiODD]LO\HVPLNLWpWHOHNHWLVÄDE +HLQULFRPLOLWHTXL6FODYRQLFH=ROXQWDYRFDWXU´
7KLHWPDUUyOV]yOYDPpJPHJNHOOMHJ\H]QHPKRJ\.5,67ÏMRJRVDQNLIRJiVROWDD]WD ILJ\HOPHWOHQVpJHPHWKRJ\D]tUyHJ\Ki]LPpOWyViJiWpUVHNQHNHPOtWHWWHPKRORWWFVDNSV S|NYROW
$3URNXM%HOHNQHJLQL9DMNSUREOpPDN|UUHONDSFVRODWEDQ.5,67ÏD]WiOOtWMDKRJ\
HQHYHNUOV]yOyQp]HWHPEHQHJ\FVDSiVUDHODNDURPWQWHWQLÄDJ\XOiNN|UQ\H]HWpEODV]OiY PLOLW´pVD]WDV]OiYN|]HJHWSUyEiOQiPVHPPLVVpWHQQLPHO\HWHV]HPpO\HNNHONDSFVR ODWEDQD%HOJUiGKHO\QpYpVDYDMGDWLV]WVpJQpYWDQ~VtW0LQWD]LWWPRQGRWWDNEyOLVOiWKDWy DEEDQYDOyEDQQHPKLWWHPpVQHPKLV]HNKRJ\HQHYHNPDJ\DURUV]iJLV]OiYQ\HOYLN|
]HJEHQ V]OHWKHWWHN YROQD PHJ $]W YLV]RQW HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP pUWHP KRJ\DQ M|Q LGH
*\XODIHKpUYiUV]OiY%HOJUDGQHYHpVDYDMGDWLV]WVpJQpY+LV]HQpSSHQYLWDSDUWQHUHP iOOiVSRQWMDD]²INpQWH]]HOYLWi]RPV]yEDQOHYN|Q\YHPEHQ²KRJ\D*\XOiNV]H ULQWH J\XOiN HUGpO\L N|]SRQWMD D ; V]i]DGEDQ eV]DN(UGpO\EHQ OHWW YROQD )HKpUYiU
%HOJUiGEDQYLV]RQW.HiQOHWWYROQDD]~U+DH]WpQ\OHJtJ\iOOQDDNNRUKRJ\DQEL]R Q\tWKDWQipSSHQD%HOJUiGQpYV]OiYViJDD*\XOiNQDNLOOHWOHJD*\XODFVDOiGNpWIRQ WRVWDJMiQDN3URNXMQDNpV%HOHNQHJLQLQHNDV]OiYQHY&VpJpW"ÒJ\V]LQWpQQHPpUWHP KRJ\DPLQW.5,67ÏYDOOMDD*\XOiNFVDOiGILQHNDFtPHYROWDJ\XODDNNRUKRJ\DQYR QDWNR]KDWQDUiMXNDYDMGDFtPLVpVKRJ\DQEL]RQ\tWKDWQiH]DV]OiYHUHGHW&FtPD]IH KpUYiUL²GHHQJHGMNPHJDNiUpV]DNHUGpO\L²V]OiYQpYDGyN|UQ\H]HWNHWLV"$UUyO PiUQHPLVV]yOYDPLWEL]RQ\tWD*\XOiN;V]i]DGLHUGpO\LV]OiYQpYDGyN|UQ\H]HWpUH iOWDOiEDQLVDQHPI|OWpWOHQO;V]i]DGLHUGpO\LKDQHPYDOyV]tQ&HQN|]PDJ\DUiWYpWHO&
YDMGDV]DYXQN)pOUHpUWpVQHHVVpNVHPPLEDMRPD]HUGpO\LV]OiYViJEKHO\QpYLDQ\DJ JDOEL]RQ\tWKDWy;V]i]DGLOpWpYHOXJ\DQ~J\%HOJUiG!URPiQ5%OJUDGpVDYDMGD V]OiYViJiYDOFVXSiQD*\XODFVDOiGiOOtWyODJRVKHO\LV]OiYHOQHYH]pVHLEL]RQ\tWpNDLQDN ORJLNDLEXNIHQFHL]DYDUQDN
1HPHOpJD]RQEDQD*\XODJ\EHQD]HUGpO\LV]OiYQpYDGiVWOHPÄVHPPLVVpWHYp VpQHN´IHOWpWHOH]pVHDÄW|U|NHOOHQHVVpJ´iOWDOiQRVtWyFtPNpMpWLVPHJNDSRPD]]DOKRJ\
6]HQW,VWYiQW|U|NEOPDJ\DUi]RWW9DMNQHYpWPHJDÄV]OiYRVtWiV NDWHJyULiMiED´VRURO WDP +D WUpIiOQL DNDUQpN ² pV H Myt]&YLWiEDQ PpUW QH WHKHWQpP" ² D]W PRQGDQiP KRJ\H]WQHPpQWHWWHPKDQHPDPHUVHEXUJL7KLHWPDUSVS|NGHSHUV]HH]VHPtJ\iOO HJpV]HQKLV]HQ9DMNRWVHPV]OiYRVtWMDFVDNHOMiUiVPyGMiYDODQpYV]OiYViJiWUHJLV]W UiOMD(]HVHWEHQLVQ\XJRGWOHONLLVPHUHWWHOKLV]HPKRJ\QHPYpWHWWHPVHPDWXGRPi Q\RVHWLNDVHPDW|U|NQ\HOYpVILOROyJLiMDHOOHQD]]DOKRJ\QHPIRJDGRPHOD]WD]HJ\
NRUL VDMiWRV WXGRPiQ\SROLWLNDL N|]HJEHQ KDQJXODWEDQ WDOiQ MyO KDWy GH V]DNPDLODJ
|VV]HWiNROWN|QQ\HQFiIROKDWyQpYHWLPRQWPHO\KHO\pEHDNNRULVN|QQ\HQOHWWYROQDiO OtWKDWypVPDLVV]LQWHPDJiWyOQDJ\REEOpOHJ]HW&EL]RQ\tWiVQpONOiOOKDWPiV0pJNH YpVEpKLV]HPKRJ\pSSHQiOODPDODStWyV]HQWNLUiO\XQNHPOpNHV]HQYHGKHWQpPHJHOMiUi VRPDW (]W tJ\ SHUV]H .5,67Ï*<8/$ VHP iOOtWMD FVDN D]pUW WHV]HP V]yYi PHUW QHP V]HUHWQpPKRJ\ V]OiYpV W|U|NHOOHQHVVpJHP HPOHJHWpVH H YLWDyYDWODQ ROYDVyMiWLO\HQ IHOWHYpVUHYH]HVVH$NLPHJPXQNiVViJRPDWYDODPHQQ\LUHLVLVPHULD]²UHPpOHP²WXG MDKRJ\D PDJ\DUW|UWpQHOPHWPHJpSSHQQHPNHOOYHOHPV]HPEHQYpGHOPH]QL
.5,67Ï*<8/$ D]]DO IHMH]L EH (UGpO\ NRUDL W|UWpQHWpQHN WOH NLYiODV]WRWW V]H PpO\HLKH]QHYHLKH]I&]|WWKR]]iV]yOiViWKRJ\pQH]HNNHONDSFVRODWEDQN|Q\YHPEHQ ÄKLSHUNULWLNXV iOOiVSRQWUD´ KHO\H]NHGWHP DPLQHN RNDL V]HULQWH ÄV]HPpO\L WpUHQ´ NHUH VHQGN0LQGH]PHJtWpOpVNpUGpVHDV]&NHEEV]DNPDLNHUHWHNHQNtYOLVHVLNQHNHPPLQ
GHQHVHWUHQHPLVLOOHQGHUUOWRYiEEYLWi]QL$QQ\LWD]pUWiOWDOiQRVÄPHQWVpJHPUH´PpJLV I|OKR]RNKRJ\HOHYHHOXWDVtWiVUD|QFpO~HOOHQWPRQGiVUDH]DV]iPRPUDLJHQNHGYHVUp JyWDGpGHOJHWHWWWpPDDERYRQHPLVDGKDWRWWYROQDDONDOPDWN|Q\YHPEHQLVMHOHQYiOD V]RPEDQ LV F V D N L V p U Y H N U H D G D W R N U D L J \ H N H ] W H P W i P D V ] N R G Q L VDMiWNXWDWiVDLPHUHGPpQ\HLEONLLQGXOYD3HUV]HKRJ\iOOiVSRQWRPDWHJ\HVNpUGpVHN EHQPRVWEYHEEHQLVNLIHMWKHWWHPYLWDSDUWQHUHPIHOYHWpVHLQHNLVN|V]|QKHW
7LV]WiEDQYDJ\RND]]DOKRJ\DYLWDWpPiQNEDQNHYpVEpMiUDWRVDWXGRPiQ\W|UWp QHWLHO]PpQ\HNHWEHOHpUWYHNHWWQNNRUiEELLGHYiJyHJ\HVQp]HWHLWQHPI|OWpWOHQOLV PHUROYDVyNV]iPiUDHYLWDSRQWRNRNR]KDWWDNHOLJD]RGiVLQHKp]VpJHWpVINpQWD]pQ WHUMHGHOPHV YiODV]RP H]W FVDN IRNR]KDWWD (]pUW HOQp]pVW NpUHN 'H D]W PHUHP UHPpOQL KRJ\Qp]HWHLQNLWWHQLWN|]WHWpVHKR]]iMiUXOWYDODPHO\HVWDNRUDLPDJ\DUW|UWpQHOHPH IRQWRVNRUV]DNiQDNHUHGPpQ\HLKH]
%(1./25È1'
'RERNDDQGRWKHUQDPHV
7KLV DUWLFOH LV D UHSO\ WR *\XOD .ULVWy¶V SDSHU LQ WKLV \HDU¶V ILUVW LVVXH RI7KH +XQJDULDQ /DQJXDJH SS ² LQ ZKLFK KH UHIHUV WR VRPH REVHUYDWLRQV PDGH E\ WKH SUHVHQW DXWKRU FRQFHUQLQJWKHKLVWRULFDODQGRQRPDWRORJLFDODXWKHQWLFLW\RIFHUWDLQFKDUDFWHUVRIWKHHDUO\FKUR QLFOHVDVµRYHUO\FULWLFDO¶REVHUYDWLRQVWKDWZHUHLQFOXGHGLQP\ERRNHQWLWOHG7KHHYLGHQFH RI2OG+XQJDULDQ5HRSHQLQJWKHFDVHRIWKHKLVWRU\RI6RXWKHUQ7UDQV\OYDQLDLQWKHHDUO\ÈUSi GLDQDJH7KHSRLQWVPDGHLQWKDWERRNFULWLFLVLQJ.ULVWy¶VFODLPVDPRQJRWKHUVDUHVXSSOHPHQWHG E\IXUWKHUGHWDLOVDQGDUJXPHQWVKHUH,FRQWLQXHWRFODLPWKDW'RERND.HiQ%HO\|G.XOiQDQG (UGpHOYL6]ROWiQZHUHQRWUHDOKLVWRULFDOILJXUHVDQGWKDWWKHLUQDPHVDUHDUWLILFLDOFRLQDJHVLQOLQH ZLWKDVSHFLDOZULWHU¶VSUDFWLFHRIWKHSHULRGZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRI'RERNDWKH\ZHUHFUHDWHGE\
DPLGWKLUWHHQWKFHQWXU\FKURQLFOHUNQRZQDV0DVWHUÈNRV7XUQLQJWRVRPHLPSRUWDQWILJXUHVRI +XQJDULDQKLVWRU\,DOVRVHHWKHQDPHV9DMNIRU6W6WHSKHQ%HOHNQHJLQLIRUKLVPRWKHUDQG 3URNXMDVWKHQDPHRIRQHRIWKH7UDQV\OYDQLDQSULQFHVLQTXLWHDGLIIHUHQWOLJKWWKDQ.ULVWyGRHV )RU WKHVH QDPHV , FRQVLGHU WKH ZULWHU¶V UROH RI %LVKRS 7KLHWPDU RI 0HUVHEXUJ HOHYHQWK FHQWXU\DVWKHGHFLVLYHRQH:LWKUHVSHFWWRWKHQDPH9DMN,GRQRWRQO\RSSRVH.ULVWy¶VYLHZEXW DOVRWKHFXUUHQWO\SUHYDLOLQJDVVXPSWLRQ
/25È1'%(1.
/H[LNDOL]iOyGiVLpVJUDPPDWLNDOL]iOyGiVLIRO\DPDWRN IUD]HROyJLDLHJ\VpJHNEHQ
&0LHOWWDPRUIRIOH[LyVU|J]OpVHJ\pEWtSXVDLWLVVRUUDYHQQpQNWHJ\QNLWWHJ\
NLWpUWVSUyEiOMXQNPHJYiODV]WDGQLDUUDNpUGpVUHP L p U W PDUDGHODQpYHOpVDELU WRNYLV]RQ\H]HNEODV]HUNH]HWHNEO
$ YiODV]DGiVKR] pUGHPHV EHYRQQXQN D YL]VJiODW N|UpEH D IUD]HROyJLDL HJ\VpJHN HJ\VSHFLiOLVFVRSRUWMiWLV$]RNUDDNLIHMH]pVHNUHJRQGRORNDPHO\HNHUHGHWLOHJ IUD]p PiNYROWDNXJ\DQPiUDD]RQEDQDQQ\LUD|VV]HWDSDGWDNKRJ\|VV]HWDUWR]iVXNDWKHO\HV tUiVXQNLVMHO|OLSOFVHUEHQ_KDJ\W|QNUH_PHJ\KHO\EHQ_KDJ\VWE(]DN|UOPpQ\W|EE SUREOpPiWLVIHOYHWYHONNDSFVRODWEDQ(J\UpV]WHOYLOHJNLV]RUXOQDND]iOODQGyVXOWV]y