0$*<$51<(/9

0$*<$51<(/9

&e9) '(&(0%(5 6=È0

/HLEQL]pVDILQQXJRUViJ

$]W JRQGROKDWQiQN KRJ\ *RWWIULHG :LOKHOP /HLEQL]² Q\HOYWXGR

PiQ\WLVpULQW PXQNiVViJDHQQHNHO ]PpQ\HLpVD]RNKDWiVDPHJOHKHW VHQWiYROHVLN NRUXQNPDJ\DUQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\iQDNYDOyViJiWyO7HNLQWHWWHODUUDKRJ\QDSMDLQNEDQVHP NHYpVD]RNV]iPDDNLNPpJPLQGLJDJJiO\RVQDNWDUWMiNDILQQXJRUQ\HOYURNRQViJEyOID NDGyWpQ\HNHWQHPKLiEDYDOyLVPpWYLVV]DSLOODQWDQLDUUDD]LG V]DNUDDPLNRUHJ\HVMH OHQNRULWpYHV]PpNHJ\PHJKDWiUR]yFVRSRUWMDFVtUi]iVQDNLQGXOW

/HLEQL]YROWD]DNRUWiUVDLWpVD]HO G|NHWLVPHJKDWiUR]yDQ|VV]HIRJyHU DPHO\

²HJ\HEHNPHOOHWW²DV]NtWiNQDNpVDNHOWiNQDNPLQW VUpJLQpSHNQHNVDMiWNRUDpVD]

XWyGRNV]iPiUD~MpUWHOPH]pVWDGRWW.|]WXGRWWKRJ\DÄV]NtWiN´HJ\LNMHOHQW VNtVpUW HV]PpMHYROWpVQpKDPpJPDLVD]DKD]DLSDUDNRPSDUDWtYQ\HOYKDVRQOtWiVRNQDN8J\DQ DNNRU/HLEQL]DILQQ²PDJ\DUQ\HOYLHJ\YpWDUWR]iVWLVPHJIRJDOPD]WD

$Q\HOYWXGRPiQ\W|UWpQpV]HNW|EEVpJpQHNYpOHNHGpVHV]HULQW/HLEQL]Q\HOYpV]NpQW LVMHOHQW VDODNMDD]iOWDOiQRVWXGRPiQ\W|UWpQHWQHN,JD]/HLEQL]DQ\HOYHWQHPDQ\HOY NHGYppUWNXWDWWDPLQW)(5',1$1''(6$86685(KDQHPD]HJ\HWHPHVQ\HOY8QLYHUVDO VSUDFKHYpJV J\|NHUHLQHNIHOWiUiVDYpJHWWI NpQWDQQDNFpOMiEyOPLNpQWOHKHWQHDNiU V]iPMHJ\HNNHOLVOHNpSH]KHW RO\DQIRJDOPLUHQGV]HUWPHJDONRWQLDPHO\²W~OOpSYHD]

HJ\HGLQ\HOYHNVRNIpOHHVHWOHJHVVpJHLQ²EiUPHO\Q\HOYHWEHV]pO V]iPiUDpUWHOPHVN|]

OpVHNNpiOOQD|VV]H

,VPHUHWHV KRJ\ /HLEQL]NLW QW WXGRPiQ\RV VRNROGDO~ViJiYDO MHOHQW VHQ KR]]iMi UXOWDWHUPpV]HWWXGRPiQ\IHMO GpVpKH]tJ\SpOGiXOPHJVHMWHWWHD]HQHUJLDPHJPDUDGiVi QDNW|UYpQ\pW7LV]WHOWpNNLYiOyPDWHPDWLNXVNpQWLV)LOR]yILiMiEDQD]WKLUGHWWHKRJ\D]

XQLYHU]XPYpJWHOHQV]iP~|QiOOy~QPRQiV]EyOiOO|VV]HDPHO\HND]RQEDQUDFLRQiOLV N|OFV|QKDWiVEDIRQyGYDWDUWMiNIHQQDYLOiJHJ\HWHPLVWHQLUHQGHOWHWpV |U|NSLOOpUHLW (]HN D V]pOHV pUGHNO GpVL WHYpNHQ\VpJL N|U|N D]RQEDQ /HLEQL]QpO QHP HJ\PiVWyO IJ JHWOHQOIXWySiUKX]DPRVYRQDODNVRKDQHPWDOiONR]iVDNpQWMHOHQWNH]WHNKLWWHJ\PDJD VDEEUHQG pUWHOPQNHWPHJKDODGyKDUPyQLiEDQVtJ\²PHJtWpOpVHPV]HULQW²H]DKDU PyQLDNHUHVpVI ]LHJ\EHD]HJ\HVHJ\PiVWyOWiYROLQDNWHWV] WXGRPiQ\iJDNDWHNNpQW Q\HOYpV]HWLNXWDWiVDLWLV/HLEQL]IHOIRJiVDV]HULQWXJ\DQLVDQ\HOYEHQLVDPDWKHVLVXQL YHUVDOLVYDJ\LVDKDUPyQLDHJ\LNV]XEOLPiOWIRUPiMDVHMOLNIHO$]pUWSHUV]HWDOiOXQNQpPL HOOHQWPRQGiVWLVQp]HWHLEHQPHUWDKDUPyQLDPHOOHWWVWDOiQD]RQW~OLV/HLEQL]DQ\HO YHNEHQIHOIHGH]QLYpOWEL]RQ\RVHONO|QtW HJ\HGLVpJHW.HUHVWHXJ\DQLVDQHP]HWLNDUDNWHUW pVWXGDWRWDPLQGHQNRUMHOHQYDOypVPHJKDWiUR]yYRQiVRNHJ\WWHVpWD]WDPLPHJNO|Q E|]WHWLDQ\HOYV]HOOHPpEHQD]HJ\LNQpSHWDPiVLNWyO(WHNLQWHWEHQ+(5'(5+80%2/'7 )5%2$6:(,6*(5%(56$3,5:+25)QpPHO\Qp]HWHLQHNHO IXWiUiYiYiOLN(]DPLQ VtWpVWDOiQW~O]iVXJ\DQLVPpJMyYDO/HLEQL]IHOOpSpVHHO WWLVYROWDNLO\HQHO IXWiURNJRQ GROMXQNSpOGiXO3/$7Ï1pVDKRVV]~V]i]DGRNDWiWtYHO N|YHW LQHNDOHJNO|QIpOpEEIHO IRJiVEHOLiUQ\DODWDLUD

/HLEQL]Q\HOYpV]HWLWHYpNHQ\VpJpWDILQQXJRUQ\HOYKDVRQOtWiVNLDODNXOiViEDQWHNLQ WpO\HVPDJ\DUQ\HOYpV]HN=6,5$,0,./Ï63È3$<-Ï=6()pVPiVRNLVPpOWiQ\ROWiN$]

HOLVPHUpVD]RQEDQPHJOHKHW VHQV] NWpUUHNRUOiWR]yGLNYDJ\LVQHPLOOHV]NHGLN/HLEQL]

VRNUpV]OHWE O|VV]HWHY G Q\HOYpV]HWLNRQFHSFLyMiKR]DPHO\ERQ\ROXOWDEEiUQ\DOWDEE DQQiOVHPKRJ\D]WHJ\NpWPRQGDWEDQiWOHKHWQHIRJQL7RYiEEiILJ\HOHPEHNHOOYHQQL KRJ\/HLEQL]²EiUPHQQ\LUHLVPHVV]HEEUHOiWRWWNRUWiUVDLQiO²PpJLVFVDNNRUiQDNV]HUp Q\HQIHMOHWWQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\iWNpSYLVHOWH0LQGHPHOOHWW ² V]LQWH OiWQRNL PyGRQ ² VRN RO\DVPLWLVPHJVHMWHWWDPHO\KH]DQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\FVDNNpV EEWXGRWWIHOQ QL(O GMHLQpO YLOiJRVDEEDQOiWWDpVPHJLVIRJDOPD]WDKRJ\ÄDQ\HOYHNiOWDOiEDQDQpSHNOHJUpJLEE HPOpNP YHLPpJD]tUiVpVDP YpV]HWHNHO WWNHOHWNH]WHNDOHJMREEDQLVPXWDWMiNH]HN HUHGHWpWOHV]iUPD]iViWpVYiQGRUOiViW´ÒMDEEYL]VJiOyGiVRND]HPEHULpUWHOHPU O%S (UHGHWLOHJ /HLEQL] KDOiOD XWiQ EHQ MHOHQW PHJ IUDQFLiXO .RUiEEDQ HJ\LNOHYHOpEHQDN|YHWNH] NHWtUWDÄ$Q\HOYHND]HPEHULIDMOHJUpJLEEHPOpN P YHLpVOHJMREEDQH]HNPDJ\DUi]]iNPHJDQpSHNHUHGHWpW´-7:$7(50$1/HLEQL]

DQG/XGROIRQ7KLQJV/LQJXLVWLFH[FHUSWVIURP7KHLU&RUUHVSRQGHQFH² 8QLYRI&DOLIRUQLD3UHVV%HUNHOH\²/RV$QJHOHV²/RQGRQeUH]KHW KRJ\

LWWKDQJV~O\RVDQD]HUHGHWU OYDQV]y

$PDJ\DUQ\HOYKRYDWDUWR]iViQDNV]HPSRQWMiEyO/HLEQL]QHNDOHJLVPHUWHEEQ\LODW NR]DWDDN|YHWNH] Ä$ILQQHNQHNYDJ\I|OGUpV]QNpV]DNNHOHWLUpV]pQHNQ\HOYHDPHO\HW DODSSRNLVEHV]pOQHNDJHUPiQYDJ\LQNiEEDQRUYpJyFHiQWyOHJpV]D.DVSLWHQJHULJ WHUMHGKDEiUPHJPHJV]DNtWYDV]OiYQpSHNW ODNLNN|]pMNpNHO GWHNpV|VV]HN|WWHWpV EHQiOODPDJ\DUQ\HOYYHODPHO\D]RNEyOD]RUV]iJRNEyOHUHGDPHO\HNPRVWUpV]EHQ 2URV]RUV]iJDOiWDUWR]QDN´ÒMDEEYL]VJiOyGiVRN$]WKRJ\DILQQQ\HOYVRNN|

]|VYRQiVWPXWDWIHODPDJ\DUUDOW|EEV]|ULVHPOtWLtJ\SpOGiXODÄ6lPWOLFKH6FKULIWHQ XQG%ULHIH´FtP J\ MWHPpQ\EHQ%HUOLQ7RYiEELDNEDQ/6%$]RQEDQ XJ\DQH]HQD]ROGDORQPHJOHS GKHWQN/HLEQL]HNpUGpVpQÄQHPWXGRPYDMRQD]HUGpO\L V]pNHO\HNQ\HOYHªOLQJXD6LFXORUXP7UDQVV\OYDQLDH©PDJ\DUHYDJ\V]OiY´(NpUGpV NDSFViQWXGQXQNNHOOKRJ\D;9,,V]i]DGIRO\DPiQW|EENOKRQLWXGyVLVIHOWHWWHH]WDPLQ GHQDODSRWQpONO|] NpUGpVW

$PLD]RQEDQD/HLEQL]iOWDOpULQWHWWPDJ\DU²ILQQQ\HOYLN|]HOVpJHWLOOHWLNRUiE EDQD]YROWDKLHGHOHPKRJ\/HLEQL]HWDKLYDWNR]RWWiOOiVIRJODOiVUD&20(1,86HJ\DNpW Q\HOYHW pULQW PHJMHJ\]pVH |V]W|Q|]WH &20(1,86 D]RQEDQ D ;9,, V]i]DG N|]HSpQ PLQG|VV]HDQQ\LWPRQGRWWKRJ\YDQQDNRO\DQQ\HOYHNDPHO\HNEHQDÄVHJpGV]DYDNDW´

ÄYRFXODV´YDJ\LVWXODMGRQNpSSHQDSUHSR]tFLyNDWLOOHWYHÄSRV]WSR]tFLyNDW´QHPHO UH KDQHPKiWUDKHO\H]LNSRVWSRQXQWD] HXUySDL Q\HOYHN N|]O LO\HQ D PDJ\DU pV D ILQQ Q\HOY9e57(62$1'5È6PHJMHJ\]LKRJ\ÄPDLWXGiVXQNV]HULQW D]HOV DNLNLHPHOL DPDJ\DUpVDILQQQ\HOYHJ\N|]|VQ\HOYWDQLVDMiWRVViJiW´QRKDDNpWQ\HOYURNRQViJiW V]yEDVHPKR]]D&RPHQLXVDPDJ\DUpVILQQQ\HOYHJ\N|]|VVDMiWRVViJiUyO1\.

²$SRV]WSR]LFLRQiOLVMHOOHJU OYDJ\LVOpQ\HJpEHQDPDJ\DUQ\HOYDJJOXWL QiOyV]HUNH]HWpU OD]RQEDQNRUiEELVHMWpVHNLVPHJIRJDOPD]yGWDNËJ\SpOGiXO²EiU PLO\HQKLKHWHWOHQLV²(XUySiEDQHO V]|UpSSHQDPDJ\DU6</9(67(5-È126HPHOLNL DPDJ\DUQ\HOYSRV]WSR]LFLRQiOLVDJJOXWLQiOyDODSVDMiWRVViJiWV]HPEHiOOtWYDD]iOWDOD LVPHUWHXUySDLODWLQJ|U|JQpPHWpVD](XUySiQNtYOLQ\HOYYHOKpEHU9|-+(*(

' 6-RDQQHV6\OYHVWHURI+XQJDU\WKH)LUVW/LQJXLVW3XEOLVKLQJRQ6WUXFWXUH &RPSD ULVRQLQ(XUDVLDQ6WXGLHV<HDUERRN²6</9(67(5Q\HOYWDQDD]RQ EDQDPDJ\DURUV]iJLYpU]LYDWDURVLG NEHQVDMQiODWRVPyGRQHONDOOyGRWWtJ\NOI|OG|Q VHPLVPHUKHWWpNPHJ(]pUWLVILJ\HOHPUHPpOWy%.(&.(50$11HSLJUDPPiMDDPHO\HW DFtP]HWW6=(1&=,02/1È5$/%(57ODWLQ²PDJ\DUV]yWiUiEDQDÄ3UDHIDWLRDG/HFWRUHP´HW N|YHW HQN|]]pWHWW'LFWLRQDULYXP/DWLQRYQJDULFYXP1RULEHUJDH$]HSLJUDP

PDOpQ\HJLPRQGDQLYDOyMDD]KRJ\PLNpQWDKpEHUEHQ~J\DPDJ\DUQ\HOYEHQLVD]LJp NHWpVDI QHYHNHWDIIL[XPRNUDJRNN|YHWLN(]WDNO|Q|VQ\HOYLVDMiWRVViJRW.(&.(5 0$11Q\RPyVpUYQHNWHNLQWLDPDJ\DUQ\HOYKpEHUKH]I ] G KDVRQOyViJiEDQY|

+(*(' 6+LHGHOHPpVYDOyViJ%S,JHQpUGHNHVKRJ\&20(1,86LVPHUWH WHWWPHJMHJ\]pVpYHOQDJ\MiEyOHJ\LGHM OHJLVPHULIHO*+251DILQQQ\HOYNDSFViQDSRV]W SR]LFLRQiOLVWHKiWDJJOXWLQiOyMHOOHJHWHJ\PHJK|NNHQW IHOYHWpVpYHOPHO\V]HULQWDILQQHN Q\HOYHKDVRQOtWDÄEUD]tOLDL´Q\HOYKH]XJ\DQLVHQpSpVDILQQHNDSUHSR]tFLyNDWDI QpY XWiQKHO\H]LN'H2ULJLQLEXV$PHULFDQLV/LEULTXDWXRU+DJDH&RPLWLV (OPRVyGRWWN|UYRQDODNEDQWHKiWPiUIHOVHMOHWWD]DJJOXWLQiFLyIRJDOPLNHUHWHH]SHGLJ KR]]iWDSDGWPLQGDILQQPLQGDPDJ\DUQ\HOYKH]

9LWDWKDWyD]RQEDQKRJ\/HLEQL]DILQQpVDPDJ\DUQ\HOYURNRQViJiQDNIHOLVPHUp VpKH]HJ\HGO&20(1,86iOWDOMXWRWWHOPLQWH]WW|EEHQLVVHMWHWQLHQJHGLN0HJJ\ ] EE D]DPLW*-67,3$iOOtWPLV]HULQWHQ\HOYURNRQViJIHOWHYpVHDVYpG*67,(51+,(/0

²pVI NpQW%(1*76.<77(²PiUNRQNUpWDEE²V]yKDVRQOtWi VRNNDOLVDOiWiPDV]WRWWSOILQQSllPI ²NXWDWiVDLQYDJ\LQNiEEV]HUHQFVpVWDOi ODWDLQDODSXOW*-67,3$)LQQLVFKXJULVFKH6SUDFKIRUVFKXQJ+HOVLQNL² 67,3$IHOWpWHOH]WHWRYiEEiKRJ\PLQGHUUHPDJ\DUi]DWRWDGKDW0$57,1)2*(/KiWUDKDJ\RWW PXQNiLQDNpVI NpQWNp]LUDWDLQDN/HLEQL]iOWDOYpJ]HWWUHQGH]pVHNDWDORJL]iOiVDN|]

EHQHVHWOHJHO NHUOWÄ'H)LQQLFDHOLQJXDHLQGROHREVHUYDWLRQHV´FtP Np]LUDWD 0)2*(/HEEHQHOV NpQWIRJDOPD]WDPHJ²JUDPPDWLNDLpVV]yNLQFVEHOLEL]RQ\tWyDS SDUiWXVVDO²DILQQpVPDJ\DUQ\HOYURNRQViJiW,VPHUHVKRJ\H]DNp]LUDWHONDOOyGRWW FVDND;,;V]i]DGXWROVyKDUPDGiEDQEXNNDQWUiYpOHWOHQODILQQ6(7b/b/HLEQL]

XJ\DQW|EEV]|ULVV]yO0)2*(/N|Q\YHLQHNNp]LUDWDLQDNUHQGH]pVpU OGHQHPXWDOD]

HPOtWHWWNp]LUDWUD+DFVDNQHPWHNLQWMNVHMWHWpVQHN/HLEQL]&KULVWLDQ+DEEHXVKR]FtP ]HWWMDQXiULOHYHOpWDPHO\EHQN|]OLKRJ\HJ\QDJ\RQÄNO|Q|V´Np]LUDWUDEXN NDQW/6%6DMQRVH]DÄNO|Q|V´PLQ VtWpVQHPVRNDWPRQGPHUW0)2*(/

²PLQWSROLKLV]WRU²PpJPDWDPDWLNiYDOLVIRJODONR]RWWKDQHPLVRO\DQPpO\VpJEHQ PLQW/HLEQL]1DJ\DYDOyV]tQ VpJHDQQDNKRJ\H]DÄNO|Q|V´Np]LUDWQHPILQQ²PD J\DUQ\HOYpV]HWLWpPiWpULQWHWWPHUWDNNRU/HLEQL]VRNNDOPDUNiQVDEEDQQ\LODWNR]RWW YROQDDILQQ²PDJ\DUQ\HOYLKDVRQOyViJUyO

/HLEQL]DNRUDEHOLWXGyVRNQiOMREEDQpU]pNHOWHD]iOWDOiQRVQ\HOYpV]HWLpUGHNO GpVL N|UpEHYiJyQ\HOYLDQ\DJRNKLiQ\iWpVQ\RPDWpNRVDQKDQJV~O\R]WDDJ\ MWpVLPXQNiOD WRN DODSYHW IRQWRVViJiW ( FpOEyO DNLW O HOYiUKDWyQDN WDUWRWWD V]RUJDOPD]WD NO|QIpOH Q\HOY 0LDW\iQNV]|YHJHNIHONXWDWiViWJ\ MWpVpWKRJ\tJ\UHQGHONH]pVUHiOOMRQHJ\N|]|V Ä|VV]HKDVRQOtWiVLPpUWpN´ÄXWKDEHDPXVFRPPXQHPPHQVXUDPFRPSDUDWLRQLV´/6%

EHQPpJD]RURV]FiUWLVIHONpUWHKRJ\J\ MWHVVHQ0LDW\iQNV]|YHJHNHWD]

XUDOPDDODWWpO QpSHNQ\HOYHLE O/6%0LDW\iQNV]|YHJHNPiU/HLEQL]IHOOp SpVHHO WWLV²HJ\UHQDJ\REEV]iPEDQ²NHUOWHNNLDQ\RPGiNEyO1\LOYiQYDOyD]RQ EDQKRJ\/HLEQL]YROWD]DNLQHND]LO\HQVRNQ\HOYLDODSNpUGpVUHYiODV]WDGyHJ\V]HU V]|YHJHN NDSFViQ Q\HOYHJ\EHYHWpVL W|UHNYpVH PLQGHQ NRUWiUViW PHJKDODGy V]LQWHQ LV PHUKHW IHO0 YHLEHQV]iPRVKHO\HQV]LQWHPRWWyNpQWLVPpWOLKRJ\PLQGHQQ\HOYD]

8UDWGLFVpULÄRPQLVOLQJXD'RPLQXPODXGHW´/6%

/HLEQL]pUGHNO GpVWPXWDWRWWQHPFVDNDPDJ\DUQ\HOYKDQHPDPDJ\DURUV]iJLYL V]RQ\RNLUiQWLVVQHPNHYpVEpIRJODONR]WDWWDDPDJ\DU VKD]DNpUGpVHLVEHQKL YDWNR]RWWDPDJ\DU2752.2&6,)Ï5,6)(5(1&UHPLQWÄHLQJHZLVVHU2WURVNL´VLFDNL EDQDGWDNLD]Ä2ULJLQHV+XQJDULFDH´FtP PDJ\DU VW|UWpQHWLpVQ\HOYpV]HWLPXQ NiMiW6,*5,'921'(56&+8/(1%85*/HLEQL]DOV6SUDFKIRUVFKHU)UDQNIXUWDP0DLQ 0HJHPOtWKHW KRJ\2752.2&6,PLQW)yULV)UDQFLVFXVPiUKHO\HWpUGHPHOW NLD]EHQPHJMHOHQW&+5*277/,(%-g&+(5iOWDO|VV]HiOOtWRWWÄ$OOJHPHLQHV*H

OHKUWHQ/H[LFRQ´EDQ 2752.2&6,UyO /HLEQL]PHJpUW HQ V]HOtG LUyQLiYDO V]yO W|EEpNHYpVEHRO\DQKDQJQHPEHQDKRJ\DQ258'%(&.Ä$WODQGHOOHU0DQQKHLP´8S VDODHFtP PXQNiMiWEtUiOMD58'%(&.XJ\DQLVHJ\HEHNN|]WD]WiOOtWRWWDKRJ\

DPLWLNXV$WODQWLV]KDMGDQ6YpGRUV]iJEDQWHUOWHOVLWWV]OHWWHND]LVWHQHNLV/6%

/HLEQL]tJ\Q\LODWNR]LN58'%(&.Wp]LVHLU OÄ1HPWXGWDPPHJiOOQLKRJ\QHQHYHV VHNDPLNRUOiWWDPD]DUJRQDXWiN~WMiW~J\DKRJ\D]W5XGEHFN~UOHtUWD0pJLVWHOMHVHQ YHOHpU]HNDWHNLQWHWEHQKRJ\DK\SHUERUHXVRN6NDQGLQiYLiEDQOHKHWWHNGHDPL$WODQ WLV]WLOOHWLDEEyOVHPPLWQHPKLV]HN´/6%/HLEQL]D]RQEDQPHJERFViMWyPHUW 58'%(&.N|Q\YpE ODNRUiUDRO\DQQ\LUDMHOOHP] V]HUWHOHQKD]DV]HUHWHWHWYpOLNLROYDVQL 1DJ\MiEyOH]WJRQGROKDWWDDPDJ\DU2752.2&6,UyOLV

/HLEQL]W|EEV]|ULVNLIHMH]LD]RQPHJJ\ ] GpVpWKRJ\DPDJ\DURNÄV]NtWLDL´ VKD ]iMDD0DJQD+XQJDULDYDODKROD.DV]SLWHQJHUpVD9ROJDN|]|WWWHUOKHWHWWHO/6%

GHQHP]iUMDNLDÄ3DVFDWLU´EyO%DVNtULDYDOyV]iUPD]iVOHKHW VpJpWVHPPLQW DKRJ\HUU O-2%/8'2/)KR]LQWp]HWWHJ\LNOHYHOpEHQQ\LODWNR]RWW%0,&+$(/,6 -REL/XGROILHW*RGRIUHGL*XLOLHOPL/HLEQLWLLFRPPHUFLXPHSLVWROLFXP*RWWLQJDH ÈPHJ\QDJ\ÄKtUpUWpN ´HVHPpQ\KDWiViUDYpJOPpJLVLQNiEED.DV]SLWHQJHU²9ROJD UpJLyMDPHOOHWWOiWV]LNiOOiVWIRJODOQL$]W|UWpQWXJ\DQLVKRJ\HJ\5yPiEyO.HOHWUHNO G|WWPDJ\DUV]iUPD]iV~MH]VXLWDKLWWpUtW W;9,,V]i]DGN|]HSHD.DV]SLWHQJHUN|UQ\p NpQDW|U|N|NHOUDEROWDNPDMGHODGWDNDWDWiURNQDN$V]HQ]iFLyV]iPEDPHQ ÄKtU´

D]RQEDQQHPH]KDQHPD]KRJ\DIRJViJEDHVHWWMH]VXLWDSDSPHJtUWD5yPiEDWDOiOWRWW

²D.DV]SLWHQJHUN|UQ\pNpQ²HJ\PDJ\DUXOEHV]pO QpSHWDNLNN|UpEHQDSRVWROLWpUtW PXQNiWYpJH]KHWHWW/6%6$-129,&6-È126LVpULQWL

²QpPLOHJSRQWDWODQXO²H]WDKtUDGiVW.È//$<)(5(1&VHPKDJ\MDHPOtWpVQpONOH]W DNO|Q|VHVHWHW)LQQPDJ\DUQ\HOY3HVWKDVRQOyNpSSHQ9e57(62$1'5È6 KR];9,,V]i]DGLN|]OpVD9ROJDPHQWLPDJ\DURNUyO1\.²0HJOHS D]KRJ\HUUHD]HVHPpQ\UHPpJD;,;V]i]DGHOHMpQDVSDQ\ROQ\HOYpV]+(59$6<

3$1'852LVIHOILJ\HO&DWRORJRGHODVOHQJXDVGHODVQDFLRQHVFRQRFLGDV9RO,,, 0DGULG5HSULQW0DGULG+(59$6PHJMHO|OLDYpJV IRUUiVWLV$'$0 6&+$//+LVWRULFDQDUUDWLRGHLQLWLRHWSURJUHVVXPLVVLRQLV6RF-HVX9LHQQDH$XVWULDH /HKHWKRJ\/HLEQL]D]~QDOWDMLQ\HOYpV]HWNDSXMiQDN]iUMiWLVSUyEiOJDWWD"7|EE ILJ\HOHPUHPpOWyPHJMHJ\]pVWNRFNi]WDWRWWPHJDWDWiUW|U|NPRQJROpVI NpQWDNtQDL Q\HOYU OpVHJ\HEHNN|]WNLPRQGMDYDQQDNKDWDOPDVWpUVpJHND]i]VLDL6]NtWLiEDQDKRO DQpSHNDPDJ\DUKR]KDVRQOyQ\HOYHNHQEHV]pOQHN/6%,JHQYDOyV]tQ KRJ\

D]iOWDODDNNRUPpJFVDNDVHMWpVV]LQWMpQpUOHO G IRJDORPUD²D]DJJOXWLQiOyQ\HOYHN UH²XWDOW

$]HGGLJYi]ROWDND]RQEDQNHYpVVpYLOiJtWDQDNUiHJ\VRNNDOPpO\HEEV]pOHVHEE YRQXODWUD6]iPXQNUD²DPDJ\DUQ\HOYHUHGH]WHWpVHURNRQViJDV]HPSRQWMiEyO²YRO WDNpSSHQQHPD]DOHJIRQWRVDEEKRJ\/HLEQL]QpKiQ\PHJMHJ\]pVpYHOUiWDSLQWRWWDILQQ pVDPDJ\DUQ\HOYHJ\QDJ\RQMHOOHP] iOWDOiQRV|VV]HIJJpVpUH$PDJ\DUQ\HOYKDVRQ OtWiVQHKH]HQNLERQWDNR]yNH]GHWLV]i]DGDLXJ\DQLVDUUyOWDQ~VNRGQDNKRJ\DV]iPXQNUD LVPHJKDWiUR]yQ\XJDWHXUySDLKiWWpUEHQV]LQWHiWOiWKDWDWODQQ\HOYHUHGH]WHWpVLQp]HWHN NDRWLNXVDQ|UYpQ\OHQHNpVWN|]QHN|VV]H0HJHPOtWHQG WRYiEEiKRJ\DPDJ\DUQ\HOY YHOQ\HOYURNRQViJJDO|VV]HIJJ tUiVRNLWWKRQ²DNRUDEHOLPpUYDGyHXUySDLQp]HWHN KH]NpSHVW²DOLJMHOHQWNH]WHN(]N|YHWNH]PpQ\HYROWDW|U|NKyGROWViJQ\RPiQNLDOD NXOWV]i]DGRNUDQHJDWtYDQNLKDWyJD]GDViJLpVP YHO GpVEHOLNpQ\V]HU OHPDUDGiVXQNQDN

$KRJ\.È//$<)(5(1&LVPHJMHJ\]LLP0DJ\DURUV]iJRQPpJD;,;V]i]DGHOH MpQpVPpJNpV EELVDN|Q\YWiUDNLJHQV]HJpQ\HViOORPiQ\DPLDWWDNXWDWiVV]HUIHOHWW

VRNQHKp]VpJEHWN|]|WW.LHPHONHG WXGyVDLQNSO*\DUPDWKL6iPXHOFVDNNOI|OG|Q I NpQWQ\XJDWLHJ\HWHPHNHQMXWKDWWDNKR]]iDV]NVpJHVIRUUiVRNKR]

$Q\HOYHUHGH]WHWpVDQ\HOYKDVRQOtWiVNLDODNXOiVDNO|QIpOHHJ\HGLDODN]DWRNUDFVH UpO GpVHQDJ\RQQHKH]HQiWOiWKDWyV]LQWHNDRWLNXVQDNW Q IRO\DPDWVPLQGH]²~J\

W QLN²/HLEQL]NRUiEDQV U V|G|WW|VV]HXJ\DQLV²IHOWHYpVHPV]HULQW²DQDJ\I|OG UDM]LIHOIHGH]pVHNQ\RPiQDPHO\QHNVRUiQD](XUySiWyOWiYROHV Q\HOYHNLVIHOWiUXOWDN D]DGGLJLVPHUWQ\HOYLYLOiJNpSLPPiUHOEL]RQ\WDODQRGRWW$]LJHQJD]GDJ;9,²;9,,V]i ]DGLVSDQ\ROPLVV]LRQiULXVJUDPPDWLNDLURGDORPDN|]pSpVGpODPHULNDLLQGLiQI OHJ NHFVXDpVDMPDUDQ\HOYHNNDSFViQ²KDVRQOyDQD]DIULNDLQ\HOYHNKH]²HU VHQPHJ NpUG MHOH]WHDODWLQV]DEiV~JUDPPDWLNDXQLYHU]DOLWiViW*RQGROMXQNSpOGiXO+%58,6

&,2772RODV]KLWWpUtW J\|WUHOPHLUHPLN|]EHQHJ\.RQJyPHOOpNLEDQWXQ\HOYHWSUyEiO DODWLQJUDPPDWLNDLJiMiEDW|UQL5HJYODHTYDHGDPSURGLIILFLOOLPL&RQJHQVLXPLGLRPDWLV IDFLOLRULFDSWX*UDPPDWLFDH1RUPDPUHGDFWDH5RPDHeVDNNRUPpJQHPLV HPOtWHWWNDNtQDLQ\HOYHW/HLEQL]EHQD]WtUMD6LPRQGH/RXEqUQHNKRJ\D]DPH ULNDLDWiYRONHOHWLpVD]DIULNDLQ\HOYHNRO\DQQ\LUDNO|QE|]QHNHJ\PiVWyOVI OHJDPL HXUySDLQ\HOYHLQNW OPLQWKDD]WPRQGDQiQNH]HNHJ\WHOMHVHQPiViOODWIDMWNpSYLVHOQHN /6%+DQJV~O\R]QLV]NVpJHVKRJ\/HLEQL]H]WDKDVRQODWRWHJ\iOWDOiQQHPHO PDUDV]WDOyPLQ VtWpVQHNV]iQWDFpOMDDKDVRQODWWDOD]yULiVLNO|QEVpJpU]pNHOWHWpVHYROW /HLEQL]PXQNiVViJDEHOHpUWYHV]pOHVN|U OHYHOH]pVpWV]iPXQNUDOHJDOiEELVNpW V]HPSRQWEyOOHKHWILJ\HOHPUHPpOWyPLQWPiUHPOtWHWWNDILQQ²PDJ\DUQ\HOYLDQD OyJLDPHJVHMWpVHDPLWXGRPiQ\W|UWpQHWLV]HPSRQWEyOIRQWRVPR]]DQDWEiUKDWiVDQHP YROWiWW HUHM D] VQ\HOYHNNpUGpVN|UpQHN] U]DYDUD/HLEQL]V]HOOHPLYH]pUHJ\pQL VpJHN|UOV U V|G|WW|VV]H0LQGH]PpO\HQEHIRO\iVROWDDPDJ\DUQ\HOYKDVRQOtWiVLQ GXOiViWpVDODNXOiViW0DLV]HPPHOQp]YHH]D]LQGXOiV QHJDWtY LUiQ\~ KLV]HQ LQQHQ D;9,,V]i]DGPiVRGLNIHOpW ONHOWH]KHW DSDUDNRPSDUDWtYQ\HOYHUHGH]WHWpVIHOW QpVH tJ\ D KHWHURJpQ Q\HOYKDVRQOtWiV LV SpOGiXO 2752.2&6,)Ï5,6)(5(1&QpO 3HUV]H PpOWDWODQGRORJOHQQHSiOFiWW|UQLDUpJLQ\HOYpV]HNI|O|WWQHKDOOJDVVXNHOKRJ\DN

O|QEHQpOHVV]HP W|UWpQpV]JHRJUiIXVpVQ\HOYpV]-(%(5+$5'),6&+(5DÄIHOYLOiJR VRGiV´V]i]DGiEDQLV~J\WXGWDKRJ\DYLOiJPLQWHJ\KpWH]HUpYHV6LELULVFKH*HVFKLFKWH (UVWHU7KHLO6W3HWHUVEXUJ5pV]EHQLO\HQHOOHQWPRQGiVRVYROWDNRUWXGR PiQ\DPLN|]EHQD]RQEDQDPHFKDQLNDDV]WURQyPLDPDWHPDWLNDVWEWHUpQMHOHQW VIHO IHGH]pVHNV]OHWWHN

$WiUJ\DOWNRUV]DNEDQRO\DQIRQWRVQ\HOYLPR]JDOPDNUyOYDQV]yDPHO\HNHV]PH YLOiJiEDQDKpEHU VQ\HOYpVQ\HOYL VURNRQViJDEiEHOLQ\HOY]DYDUGRPLQDQFLiMDPHOOHWW HU WHOMHVHQMHOHQWNH]QHNDN|YHWNH] Ä VQ\HOYHN´V]NtWDNHOWDV]NtWD²NHOWDYDJ\NHOWD² V]NtWDLQGRV]NtWDWHXWRQVYpGEHOJDKROODQGQpPHWGiQNtQDLVWE$PLDKpEHU V Q\HOYHWLOOHWL/HLEQL]UHV]RNiV~J\WHNLQWHQLPLQWDNLÄV~O\RV´FVDSiVWPpUWHUUHDN|

]pSNRUEyOiWKDJ\RPiQ\R]RWWGRJPiUD$]LJD]ViJD]RQEDQiUQ\DOWDEE''52,;+(V]H ULQW/HLEQL]DKpEHUQ\HOY VLVpJpYHONDSFVRODWEDQEpNHVVpJUHpVNRPSURPLVV]XPUDW|UHN V]LNOHKHWVpJHVQHNWDUWMDKRJ\DKpEHUDOHJDUFKDLNXVDEEQ\HOY/HYR\DJHGH¶6FKUHLWHQ¶

²/HLEQL]HWOHVGpEXWVGXFRPSDUDWLYLVPILQQRRXJULHQ,Q/HLEQL]+XPEROGWDQGWKH 2ULJLQVRI&RPSDUDWLYLVP(G78//,2'(0$852²/,$)250,*$5,$PVWHUGDP²3KL ODGHOSKLD0LQGDPHOOHWW/HLEQL]~J\YpOLKRJ\DQpPHWW|EEHUHGHWLYRQiVW UL]

PLQWDKpEHUYDJ\D]DUDE6&+8/(1%85*LPV W~J\KLV]LKRJ\DKpEHUQ\HOYWXODM GRQNpSSHQHJ\PpJ VLEEpVJD]GDJDEEQ\HOYPDUDGYiQ\DÄW|UPHOpNH´:$7(50$1 LP7HUPpV]HWHVHQ/HLEQL]YpOHPpQ\pQHNKDWiViUDVHPV] QLNPHJDKpEHUQ\HOY YHOIRO\WDWRWW|VV]HKDVRQOtWiVLEX]JDORP(POpNH]WHWQQNNHOODUUDKRJ\EHQMHOHQW PHJ5yPiEDQ)56$/9$725(),/,32*,/,,Ä(QVD\RGHKLVWRULDDPHULFDQD´FtP PXQ

NiMDDNDULELQ\HOYHNU O$V]HU] QDJ\RQJ\HOWDUUDKRJ\NLMHOHQWVHH]HNDQ\HOYHN QHPDKpEHUE OpVD]DUDEEyOV]iUPD]WDNPLQWDKRJ\H]WDEEDQD]LG EHQJ\DNUDQiO OtWRWWiN6RXWK$PHULFDQ,QGLDQ/DQJXDJHV(G+$55,(7(0$1(/,6./(,1²/8,6$5 67$5.8QLYRI7H[DV3UHVV²(J\pENpQWDKpEHU VQ\HOYQHN²QpKiQ\

KRQLQ\HOYNXWDWyW QHP LV HPOtWYH ² (XUySiEDQ PpJ D ;,; V]i]DGEDQ LV YROWDN KtYHL EiUPLO\HQKLKHWHWOHQNO|QEHQPLpUWtUWDYROQD$6&+/(,&+(5EDQPHJURYyDQ KDDQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\QHPIRJDGWDYROQDHOD]HPEHUQHND]HOV HPEHUSiUWyOYDOyV]iUPD ]iViQDNKpEHUPtWRV]iWDNNRUÄHJ\HWOHQWXGyVQDNVHPMXWRWWYROQDHV]pEHD]DNDODQGRV JRQGRODWKRJ\DNO|QE|] Q\HOYLRUJDQL]PXVRNDWWHOMHVHQHJ\Q\HOYE OYH]HVVHQOH´

'LHGHXWVFKH6SUDFKH6WXWWJDUW

/HLEQL]QHNpVI NpQWHO GHLQHNpVPDMGHJ\HVSURPLQHQVXWyGRNQDNNHGYHOWNX WDWiVLWHUOHWHDV]NtWDpVDNHOWDYDJ\V]NtWD²NHOWDNHOWD²V]NtWDQ\HOYHN VHUHGHWL VpJpUHD]HXUySDLQ\HOYHNKH]I ] G YpOWV]HUYHVNDSFVRODWiUDWHUMHGWNL)HOIRJiViUD MHOOHP] DKRJ\DJ|U|JpVDWHXWRQQ\HOYHNHW|VV]HNDSFVROMDÄ%iUQHPJRQGROMXNKRJ\

DWHXWRQDJ|U|JE OHUHGPpJLVD]WWDUWRPKRJ\DJ|U|JpVDWHXWRQHJ\N|]|VV]NtWDIRU UiVEyOV]iUPD]LN´/HLEQL]2SHUD2PQLD(G/'87(16*HQHYD² 9LWDWKDWDWODQQDNW QLNKRJ\/HLEQL]HWQDJ\UpV]W&6$/0$6,86HOPpOHWHEHIRO\iVROWD DNLV]HULQWDJ|U|JQ\HOYHWpVPiVQ\HOYHNHWLVDV]NtWDQ\HOYPpO\UHKDWyDQiWLWDWWD'H +HOOHQLVWLFD &RPPHQWDULXV /XJGXQL %DWDYRUXP ² $] HO G|N N|]O PHJHPOtWKHWMN PpJ ² W|EEHN N|]|WW ² -86786*(25*,866&+277(/,86 /HLEQL]UH J\DNRUROWKDWiViWLV6&+277(/²QHPPHOO ]YHD] VLV]NtWDQ\HOYLKDWiVW²HOV VRUEDQ DNHOWDQ\HOYPHJKDWiUR]yV]HUHSpWHPHOLNLV W~J\KLV]LKRJ\PLQGHQQpSDPHO\HW DJ|U|J|NpVDUyPDLDNNHOWiNQDNQHYH]QHNDWHXWRQQ\HOYHWEHV]pOWH%V]NpQYDOOMD KRJ\D] VDSiNDQpPHWQ\HOYHWQHPNROGXOWiNKDQHPHJ\HQHVHQ%DELORQEDQWDQXOWiN PHJVHQ\HOYDWHUPpV]HWUHPHNP YH0HLVWHUVWFN$XVIKUOLFKH$UEHLWGHU7HXWVFKHQ +DXEW6SUDFKH%UDXQVFKZHLJ6&+277(/QHPKDJ\NLHJ\IULFVNiWD]

DQJROQ\HOYNDSFViQPHO\HWÄVSXPDOLQJXDUXP´QDNDQ\HOYHNW|UPHOpNHKRUGDOpNDPL Q VtWLP$ÄQ\HOYHNKDUFiEDQ´HVRPPiVPLQ VtWpVWPiVNRUDEHOLQ\HOYWXGyVRN LVDONDOPD]WiN

7DOiQMREEDQPHJpUWMNKDQHPLVIRJDGKDWMXNHODJ\pUV]iP~HJ\NRU~GHNp V EEVRNDVRGyPDJ\DUQ\HOYNXWDWyNHU VYRQ]yGiViWDV]NtWD²PDJ\DUURNRQViJKR]KD DUUD JRQGROXQN KRJ\ H] D V]NtWD YDJ\ V]NtWD²NHOWD Q\HOYL YRQXODW PLO\HQ PDNDFVXO WDUWRWWDPDJiWPpJ/HLEQL]NRUiEDQpVMyYDOKDOiODXWiQLV(POtWVQNPHJIXWy ODJQpKiQ\QHYHWDVRNN|]O$VRUEDQNLHPHONHGLN$1'5($6-b*(5DNLDÄ'HOLQJXD YHWXVWLVVLPD(XURSDH´6WRFNKROPFtP QDJ\KDWiV~N|Q\YpWDV]NtWD²NHOWDQ\HOY VHUHGHWLVpJHHOHP]pVpQHNV]HQWHOWH$QpPHWLURGDOPLQ\HOYPHJWHUHPW MH&+5,6723+

*2776+('²EDQNLIHMWLKRJ\DQpPHWQ\HOYDV]NtWD²NHOWD VQ\HOYE O V]iUPD]LN PLQW DKRJ\ D VYpG Q\HOY LV $ %2567 'HU 7XUPEDX YRQ %DEHO ²

²EHQ-2+$11,+5(²PHJMHOHQWHWWHDÄ*ORVVDULXP

6XLJRWKLFXP´FtP P YpWDPHO\EHQD]WIHMWHJHWLKRJ\DKpEHUQ\HOYRO\DQ VLPLQW DYLOiJpVQ\RPDLWDOHJW|EEQ\HOYPpJ U]LÈPDKpEHUQ\HOYXWiQDUDQJVRUEDQ²PLQW VURNRQ²PLQGMiUWDV]NtWDQ\HOYN|YHWNH]LN6F\WKXVPLQW V-DIHWYDJ\*RPHUXWyGD

$V]NtWiNXWyGDLYLV]RQWDJyWRNJpWiNVYpGHNDNHOWiNWRYiEEiDJ|U|J|NpVDSHU]ViN

%2567LP((+5(1)(/'=6&+$&.:,7=²EDQSXEOLNiOW tUiViEDQtJ\RNRVNRGLNDKpEHUDI|QtFLDLpVDJ|U|JDQpPHWQ\HOYÄOHiQ\DL´YLV]RQW PLQGHPHQ\HOYHND] VUpJLV]NtWDQ\HOYE OVDUMDGWDN(]V]HULQWHD]WEL]RQ\tWMDKRJ\

OpWH]HWWNH]GHWEHQHJ\V]NtWD²JHUPiQ VQ\HOY%2567LP

9DQQDNNXWDWyNDNLN²QHPLVLQGRNRODWODQXO²DV]NtWDNpUGpVW~J\WHNLQWLN PLQWD]LQGRHXUySDLQ\HOYpV]HWKH]YH]HW NLN|YH]HWWXWDWËJ\YpOHNHGLNSpOGiXO*-

0(7&$/)LV7KH,QGR(XURSHDQ+\SRWKHVLVLQWKH6L[WHHQWKDQG6HYHQWHHQWK&HQWXULHV ,Q 6WXGLHV LQ WKH +LVWRU\ RI /LQJXLVWLFV (G '(//+<0(6 %ORRPLQJWRQ²/RQGRQ

²1DJ\YRQDODNEDQ''52,;+(LVHJ\HWpUWD]LQGRHXUySDLViJLO\HQIpOH IHMO GpVLKXOOiPYRQDOiYDOGHKR]]iWHV]LKRJ\D]HXUySDLI NpQWJHUPiQLOOÄWHXWRQ´

Q\HOYpV]HWHWHEEHQDNRUEDQDYDOyGLQ\HOYURNRQViJpVD]LJp] VLHUHGHWNHWW VV]RUtWi ViEDQDÄV]NtWD´LOOHWYHDÄNHOWRPiQLD´V WÄVYpGPiQLD´MHOOHPH]WH$IUDQFLDQ\HOY V]iUPD]WDWiVLYLWiNEDQSHGLJHJ\HQHVHQDÄIXULDFHOWLFD´MiUWD'52,;+(LP² 6$8528;Qp]HWHV]HULQWDIUDQFLiNDWDOLJpUGHNHOWHD]LQGRHXUySDLÄiUMD´

Q\HOYLURNRQViJNpUGpVH$](XUySiQNtYOLQ\HOYHNNXWDWiViEDQLVV]HUpQ\HUHGPpQ\H NHWpUWHNHOSpOGiXO-)/$),7$8²D]WiOOtWMDKRJ\D]DPHULQGLiQQpSHN SHOD]JHUHGHW HN-'(*8,*1(6²SHGLJ~J\WDUWMDKRJ\DNtQDLDN(J\LS WRPEyOV]iUPD]QDN6$8528;5HSUHVHQWDWLRQDQGWKH3ODFHRI/LQJXLVWLF&KDQJH EHIRUH&RPSDUDWLYH*UDPPDU,Q7'(0$852²/)250,*$5,LP² 7pQ\KRJ\/HLEQL]NRUiEDQDQpPHWQ\HOYpV]HN(XUySiEDQPiUGRPLQiQVSR]tFLyW NH]GWHNHOIRJODOQLNO|Q|VHQDW|UWpQHWL|VV]HKDVRQOtWyQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\EDQQHPNHYpVEp DQ\HOYV]iUPD]WDWiVpVDQ\HOYILOR]yILDWHUOHWpQ

$QDJ\I|OGUDM]LIHOIHGH]pVHNQ\RPiQOiWyN|UEHNHUO QpSHNpVD]HJ\UHW|EELV PHUHWOHQQ\HOYIHOWiUXOiVDW|EEHNHWDUUD|V]W|Q]|WWKRJ\DPiULVPHUWQpSHNpVQ\HOYHN V]pWYiQGRUOiViUDJRQGROMRQ(OV VRUEDQ$PHULNDEHQpSHVHGpVHIRJODONR]WDWWDDJRQGRO NRGyNHJ\FVRSRUWMiWËJ\SpOGiXO+*527,86~J\YpOWHKRJ\$PHULNDHJ\HVUpJLyLED VNDQGLQiYQpSHNWHOHSOWHNEHGHQHP]iUNLDPLJUiFLyEyOHJ\HVKpEHUW|U]VHNHWVHP 'HRULJLQH$PHULFDQDUXPGLVVHUWDWLR>VLQHORFR@$NRUiEEDQPiUKLYDWNR]RWWPXQ NiMiEDQD]RQEDQDV]iUQ\DOyEENpS]HOHW *+251HOYHWHWWH*527,86Qp]HWHLWVD]W DIHOIRJiVWNpSYLVHOWHKRJ\$PHULNiWQHPDVNDQGLQiYRNI NpQWQHPDQRUYpJHNKD QHPDV]NtWiNpVUpV]EHQDI|QtFLDLDNQpSHVtWHWWpNEHGHQHPPDUDGWDNNLDKXQRNWDWi URNW|U|N|NVHPDPLJUiFLyVPR]JDOPDNEyO7DOiQYDODPLNpSSHQDPDJ\DURNHJ\UpV]H LVUpV]WYHKHWHWW"HQDJ\YiOODONR]iVEDQPHUWD]HJ\LNV]NtWDYH]pUW*+2510DG\D QDNQHYH]L$PDG\LiNPDJ\iNNpV EEPDJ\DURNNpQWW QQHNIHOHJ\HV;;V]i]DGL IDQWDV]WLNXVPDJ\DU VW|UWpQHWLtUiVRNEDQ0DJ\DUW|U]VHNEHYiQGRUOiViQDNIHOWHYpVpUH +251QDNPpJD]DPHJMHJ\]pVHLVXWDOKRJ\DÄ7]XUXNL´QpSHN$PHULNiEDYiQGRUROWDN H]HNHWHUHGHWLOHJ,\UNDVQDNQHYH]WH+e52'2726=+251LP0HJOHS KRJ\My YDOW|EEPLQWV]i]pYP~OYDEHQD]tU-$0(63$56216V]LQWpQD]WiOOtWRWWDKRJ\

DV]NtWiNQpSHVtWHWWpNEHeV]DN$PHULNiW%2567LP²

'HWDOiONR]KDWXQNDV]NtWiNYiQGRUOiViQDNKyGtWiVDLQDNHJ\pEQ\RPDLYDOLVpVSH GLJDWDWiURNpYDODNLN/HLEQL]V]HULQWV]LQWpQDV]NtWiNN|]pVRURODQGyN-:$//,6DQJRO JUDPPDWLNXVIHOYHWLKRJ\DVNyWRNQHPV]NtWDHVHWOHJJyWHUHGHW HNH*UDPPDWLFD /LQJXDH$QJOLFDQDH+DPEXUJL3UDHIDWLR(KKH]NDSFVROyGLNDPDJ\DU/,6=

1<$,3È/PHJOHS NLMHOHQWpVHPLV]HULQWDÄKLGHJÏFHiQXV´PHOOHWWLWDWiURNHJ\NRUKRV]

V]~KDMyNUDV]iOOWDN6NyFLiEDKDMy]WDND]RUV]iJRWPHJKyGtWRWWiNtJ\DVNyWRNWDWiU HUHGHW HNPpJSHGLJÄ3LFWXVRN´0DJ\DURN&KURQLFDMD'HEUHFHQ²$OLJ KDVHMWKHWWH/,6=1<$,KRJ\DSLNWHNPHJQHYH]pVHLVPHUHWOHQHUHGHW QHPLQGRJHUPiQ QpSHWpVQ\HOYHWtJ\VHPPLNpSHQVHPVNyWRWMHO|O

,WWV]NVpJHVPHJMHJ\H]QQNKRJ\DPDJ\DUQ\HOYURNRQtWiVV]i]DGRNRQiWDPHJ KDVRQORWWViJ] U]DYDURVNpSpWPXWDWWD(J\UpV]WUpJW OIRJYDpOWDKXQYDJ\DV]NtWDLO OHWYHVRNV]RUFVDNKXQ²V]NtWDV]iUPD]iVWXGDWDQHP]HWpVDQ\HOYQNU OJRQGRONRGyN NROOHNWtYWXGDWiEDQYLV]RQWD]HPOpNH]HWKH]QHPWiUVXOWDKXQYDJ\DV]NtWDQ\HOYPLYHO QHPYROWWDOiOKDWyLO\HQQ\HOYHPOpN0iVUpV]WHJ\HVJUDPPDWLNXVDLQN²DNOI|OGLW|

UHNYpVHNHWV]LQWHNpQ\V]HU HQXWiQR]YD²DKpEHUKH]KDVRQOtWRWWiNDPDJ\DUQ\HOYHW (EEHQDUHOiFLyEDQXJ\DQPHJYROWDQ\HOYLDODSYLV]RQWKLiQ\]RWWD]HWQLNDLHUHGHWKiW

WHUH9pJOLVQDJ\iOWDOiQRVViJEDQ²V]i]DGRNUDYHWtWYH²DV]NtWDLOOHWYHKXQ²V]NtWD V]iUPD]iVKLWHJ\ ]HGHOPHVNHGHWW1HIHOHMWVNHOKRJ\/HLEQL]NRUiEDQDKDUPDGLNOH KHW VpJ²DILQQXJRUURNRQViJtJpUHWHVNpUGpVH²KDWiUR]RWWDQPpJQHPYHW G|WWIHO

.OI|OGU O Qp]YH D KXQ HUHGHWKH] YDOy UDJDV]NRGiV QHP W QW PHJNpUG MHOH]KHW QHN0DJD/HLEQL]LVH]WPRQGMDDPDJ\DUQ\HOYU OÄOLQJXDKXQJDULFDVHXKXQQLFD´

'52,;+(LP$MHOHVRULHQWDOLVWD-2$11(632'(67$SHGLJNRUiEEDQD]WDIHOWH YpVWNRFNi]WDWWDPHJKRJ\DW|U|NHWQLNXP~EROJiURNJDUJKDUW|U]VH|VV]HNHYHUHGHWW DKXQRNNDOtJ\DODNXOWNLDKXQJDU KXQJDUQpS'LVVHUWDWLR$FDGHPLFD9LHQQDH (]DPHJKDVRQORWWViJNO|Q|VHQpOHVHQPXWDWNR]LNPHJDV]NtWDNpUGpVEHQXJ\DQLV YDQYDODPLO\HQPHJKDWiUR]yDQHOW MHOOHJ]HWHVVpJDPDJ\DURNiOWDONpSYLVHOWV]NtWDNpS pVDNOKRQLIHOIRJiVN|]|WW0tJDQ\XJDWLWXGyVRNDV]NtWiWKROPLQWHJ\HWOHQ VQ\HOYHW DJHUPiQViJ VpYpDYDWMiNKROSHGLJDV]NtWiNHJ\EHROYDGQDNDNHOWiNNDOQpPHO\IHOIR JiVEDQD]RQEDQDNHOWDPHJHO ]LDV]NtWiNDW$KD]DLJRQGRONRGiVEDQFVXSiQDV]NtWD YDJ\KXQ²V]NtWDHUHGHWMHOHQWNH]LN

0LQWPiUNRUiEEDQpULQWHWWN*-0(7&$/)V]HULQWDV]NtWDQ\HOYpV]HWYDUJDEH W NNHOXJ\DQGHHJ\HQHVHQHOYH]HWHWWD]LQGRHXUySDLQ\HOYpV]HWNLDODNXOiViKR]6DMQRV H]DPHWDPRUIy]LVQHPW QLNLO\HQHJ\V]HU QHN$]LJD]KRJ\/HLEQL]pVNRUWiUVDLV]H ULQWDV]NtWiNDSHU]ViNDWLVPDJXNEDIRJODOMiNVH]HQDPiUNRUiEEDQLVVHMWHWHWWSHU]VD

|VYpQ\HQHO UHKDODGYDFVDNKDPDUNLUDM]ROyGLND]ÄiUMD´!LQGRHXUySDLQ\HOYHNURNRQ ViJD:-21(6)596&+/(*(/)5%233:+80%2/'7pVPiVRNQ\RPGRNDLQËJ\

D]LQGRHXUySDLQ\HOYpV]HWNLDODNXOiVDXWiQDV]NtWDQ\HOYpV]HWQHNHRLSVRHONHOOHWWYROQD KDOQLD

+D]iQNEDQD]RQEDQDV]NtWDNpUGpVQHNYROWHJ\IDMWDVSHFLILNXVMHOOHJHPHO\HOWpUW DQ\XJDWLIHOIRJiVWyO(]WVXJDOOMiNNUyQLNiLQNpVV]iPRVNOI|OGLWXGyVLVPLQW$%21 ),1,35$1=$186%5+(1$186pVVRNDQPiVRN$]RQEDQPiUD;9,V]i]DGWyONH]GYH

²I OHJQpPHWQ\HOYpV]HN²DV]NtWiNDWLJ\HNH]WHNÄNLVDMiWtWDQL´$1($1'(5PiU LO\HQV]yIHMWpVWDMiQOVF\WKD6FKXW]VFKLHVVHQpVV]iV]JHUPiQV]yOiVEDQVNHLWHQ D]D]DV]NtWDDQQ\LWWHV]PLQW¶Q\LOD]O ¶&KURQLFRQVLYHV\QRSVLVKLVWRULDUXP/LSVLDH .pV EED]RQEDQNOI|OG|QDV]RURVDEEDQYHWWV]NtWD²PDJ\DUHWQLNDL URNRQViJHU VWiPRJDWiVUDWDOiOW+(59$6<3$1'852SpOGiXOD;,;V]i]DGHOV pYHL EHQV]LOiUGDQYDOOMDDV]NtWD²PDJ\DUURNRQViJRWLP²~J\KRJ\DKX QRNDWDV]NtWiNNDOD]RQRVtWMD1DJ\MiEyOH]D]DSHULyGXVDPHO\EHQPiUEL]WRVSLOOpUHNUH KHO\H] G|WWD]LQGRHXUySDLQ\HOYURNRQViJHV]PpMHDQpPHWQ\HOYpV]HNW~OV~O\DPHOOHWW eVXJ\DQFVDNHNNRUWiMWDV]NtWiNPiUNLOpSWHND*-0(7&$/)iOWDOVHMWHWWNpSE OV W PDNDFVXOW~OpO QpSQHNEL]RQ\XOWDN(OpJKDPHJHPOtWMNKRJ\PpJD;,;V]i]DGN|

]HSpQLVGLDGDOPHQHWEHQYRQXOWDNUpJLyEyOUpJLyEDDNpS]HOHWKDGL~WMDLQ+&5$:/,1 621EHQtUWÄ1RWHVRQWKH(DUO\+LVWRU\RI%DELORQLD´FtP WDQXOPiQ\iEDQIHOYi ]ROMDDV]NtWiNK VN|OWHPpQ\V]HU DODNpVQpYYiOWR]iVDLWNiQDiQLDNKHWWLWiNHWUXV]NRN VWE5$:/,1621NO|QKDQJV~O\R]]DKRJ\DILQQXJRUQpSHNpVQ\HOYHNNLYiOWDPD J\DURNPpJPDLVDV]NtWiNVD]RNQ\HOYpWNpSYLVHOLN0pJV]iPWDODQNOI|OGLNXWDWyWLV WDQ~QDNKtYKDWQiQNGHV]NVpJWHOHQ0$&$675e1(WKQRORJLVFKH9RUOHVXQJHQEHUGLH DOWDLVFKHQ9|ONHU6W3HWHUVEXUJQ\RPiQDV]NtWDQpSHNpVQ\HOYHNDWXUiQLDN NDOHJ\WWDOWDMLYiOpQ\HJOQHNiWDQpONOKRJ\DUyOXNDONRWRWWV]HPOpOHWOpQ\HJEHYiJyDQ PyGRVXOWYROQD$NO|QEVpJDQQ\LKRJ\D]DOWDMLPLQ VtWpVNRQNUpWDEEQDNPHJIRJKD WyEEQDNEL]RQ\XOWiPpYWL]HGHNNHONpV EEV]iPRVEHOV HOPpOHWLYiOWR]iVRQpVYiOVi JRQPHQWiW&$675e1LGHMpEHQGLQDPL]iOyGLNDÄWXUiQL´QpSHNpVQ\HOYHNJRQGRODWD VHNNRUW QLNIHODQ\HOYLKRUL]RQWRQDVXPHUQ\HOYLV(QQHNHOOHQpUHDV]NtWiNQHPV] QWHN PHJOpWH]QLHJ\HVHUHGHWPDJ\DUi]yNV]iPiUDDNiUH]]HODQpYYHOMHO|OYHDNiUNO|Q|V

PHWHPRUIy]LVRNDWiWpOYHDNiUWXGRPiQ\RVDQN|YHWKHWHWOHQHUHGHWPtWRV]RNKRPiO\iEDQ VRGUyGQDNQHPNHYpVKRQILWiUVXQNWXGDWiEDQ

'H/HLEQL]LVNRUiQDNHPEHUHYROWNRUiQQHPOpSKHWHWWW~OVtJ\QHPPHJOHS KRJ\KLWWDKDQJRNKDQJ]yNPLV]WLNXVPiJLNXVWHUPpV]HWIJJ PLYROWiEDQ3/$7Ï1Ä.UD WORV]´iW²PLQWNRUiEEDQVRNDQPiVRNLV²MyOLVPHUWHVV]LQWHYiOWR]DWODQXOYHWWHiW DI V]HUHSO QHN6]yNUDWpV]QHND]HJ\HVKDQJ]yNPpO\pQUHMWH] ÄWHUPpV]HWL´DODSIXQN FLyNEDYHWHWWKLWpW3pOGiXOD]UPR]JiVWJ\RUVDViJRWPtJD]OVLPDViJRWOiJ\ViJRWFV~

V]iVWNpSYLVHOY|+1)2:/(53/$72ZLWKDQ(QJOLVK7UDQVODWLRQ&DPEULGJH0DVV +DUYDUG8QLY3UHVV/RQGRQ.LN|YHWNH]WHWKHW KRJ\/HLEQL]pVNRUWiUVDL QDN ÄKDQJPHWDIL]LNDL´ WDOiOJDWiVDL KDWiVVDO YROWDN QpKiQ\ PDJ\DU Q\HOYE~YiUUD LV .|

]pMNWDUWR]LNSpOGiXO'5.29È76)5,*<(6EDQSXEOLNiOWGtV]HVGHDOXOP~OKDWDW ODQN|Q\YpYHOÄ$PDJ\DUE|OWVpV]HWYDJ\HPLQGHQVpJDONRWiViQDNWLWND´3HVW$PL SHGLJDJ|U|JQ\HOYEHQLWWRWWHO IRUGXOyLGHJHQHVKDQJ]iV~V]DYDNDWLOOHWLPiU3/$7Ï1 LVIHOLVPHULKRJ\SpOGiXODSX ¶W ]¶QHPJ|U|JKDQHPÄEDUEiU´HUHGHW V]y)2:/(5 LP/HLEQL]H]WKHO\HVHQDJHUPiQItUIHXHUV]DYDNNDOD]RQRVtWMDY|6&+8/(1%85*

LP²/HLEQL]URNRQtWDJHUPiQQDOHJ\VHUHJNHOWDV]yWI NpQWtUZDOHVLQ\HOY E OPHUtWYH)HOWpWHOH]LSpOGiXOKRJ\PDJDDNHOWDV]yDQpPHW¶KHOG¶EHQUHLQNDUQiOy GRWW6&+8/(1%85*LP/HLEQL]DIHOWpWHOH]HWWNHOWD²V]NtWD VQ\HOYHWNpWQ\HOYiJ

|VV]HIRO\iViQDNWHNLQWLDV]NtWiNNpSYLVHOLND]i]VLDLiJDWW|U|NWDWiUILQQPDJ\DUV]DU PDWDSHU]VDPtJDNHOWDDJHUPiQÄWHXWRQ´J|U|JODWLQQ\HOYHNHWIRJODOMDPDJiEDQ /HLEQL]Q\HOYWXGRPiQ\LJRQGRONRGiViQDNHJ\LNIRQWRViOORPiVDD]KRJ\HU VHQ NpWHONHGLNDEiEHOLQ\HOY]DYDUPHJW|UWpQWpEHQI OHJDEEDQKRJ\D]HJ\IDMWDLVWHQLÄiWRN´

N|YHWNH]PpQ\H,QNiEE~J\YpOLKRJ\DQ\HOY]DYDUWNH]GHWW OIRJYDD]HPEHULWHUPpV]HW QDJ\IRN~NO|QE|] VpJHLGp]WHHO .O|Q|VHQYDOyVQDNOiWMDD]HPEHUHNQpSHNpVQ\HO YHNN|]|WWLNO|QE|]pVWDPLNRUV]yEDKR]]DD]DPHULQGLiQD]DIULNDLQ\HOYHNWRYiEEi DEDV]NQ\HOYMHOHQW VHOWpUpVpWD]HXUySDLQ\HOYLPRGHOOW O)HOIRJiViEDQXJ\DQDNNRUpV SiUKX]DPRVDQHJ\IHOROGKDWDWODQHOOHQWPRQGiVMHOHQLNPHJD]WXGQLLOOLNKRJ\NDX]iOLV NDSFVRODWRWWpWHOH]IHODV]DYDNpVDGROJRNN|]|WWYDJ\LVÄDV]DYDNQHPFVDNDJRQGRODW KDQHPDGROJRNV]LPEyOXPDLLV´:$7(50$1LP(QQHNHOOHQpUHYDJ\WDOiQpS SHQH]pUW"V]LOiUGDQKLWWD]LG WOHQOWiYROLHJ\HWOHQ VQ\HOY8UVSUDFKHOpWH]pVpEHQ

$] VLEiEHOLQ\HOY]DYDUKLWHD]RQEDQ/HLEQL]NpWNHGpVHHOOHQpUHLVIHQQPDUDGWpV H]]HO |VV]HIJJpVEHQ QDJ\MiEyO D ;9,, V]i]DGWyO NO|QIpOH ² VRNV]RU D UDFLRQDOLWiV MHOHLWLVPXWDWy²HOPpOHWHNLVV]OHWWHN$]HJ\LNKRVV]~pOHW HOJRQGROiVV]HULQWDQ\HOY

|VV]H]DYDURGiVD V]LQWH D YLOiJWHUHPWpVVHO HJ\HQpUWpN IHOPpUKHWHWOHQO KDWDOPDV LVWHQL WHWW8J\DQLV²DKRJ\SpOGiXO*(/(-,.$721$,679È1HOPpONHGLN²DQ\HOYHN|VV]H]D YDUiViYDOSiUKX]DPRVDQpVXJ\DQDEEDQDÄV]HPSLOODQWiVQ\L´LG EHQHJ\WHOMHVHQÄPiV LGHJHQ Q\HOYQHN NHOOHWW D¶KHO\HWW >WXGQLLOOLN D] HUHGHWL Q\HOY KHO\HWW@ HOPpO\HNEHQ Q\R PDWQLD´7LWNRNWLWND*\XOD)HMtU9DUDWW²9pOKHW HQ/HLEQL]D]LO\HQ YLOOiPFVDSiVV]HU KLUWHOHQVpJJHOEHiOOyQ\HOY]DYDUWXWDVtWRWWDHOGHN|]HOiOOKDWRWWKR]]i DQDJ\KtU 6$08(/%2&+$57pUYHOpVHDNLV]HULQWD] VLWiUVDGDORPV]pWKXOORWWQpSHNNp DWRPL]iOyGRWWPLW|EE²tUMD%2&+$57²ÄDQ\HOY]DYDUPpJPDLVWDUWpVWDUWDQLIRJDYL OiJYpJH]HWpLJ´*HRJUDSKLDH6DFUDHSDUVSULRU3KDOHJVHXGHGLVSHUVLRQHJHQWLXPHWWHU UDUXP&DGRPL²

0DPiULJHQNO|Q|VHQKDWGHWpQ\KRJ\/HLEQL]V]HULQWDUpJLpV]WHNQ\HOYHN|]HO iOODÄEULWDQQLDLKR]´IHOWHKHW HQDZHOVKQ\HOYUHJRQGRO(]WDYpOHNHGpVW7DFLWXVÄ*HU PDQLD´MDLVVXJDOOMDDPHO\EHQDUyPDLtUy~J\Q\LODWNR]LNKRJ\D]pV]WDHVWLXVQ\HOY DÄEULWDQQLDLKR]´iOON|]HOHEE7DFLWXV|VV]HVP YHL%S$ZHOVKQ\HOY E O PDJD 2752.2&6,)Ï5,6)(5(1& LV PHUtWHWW HJ\HV KDVRQOyQDN W Q PDJ\DU V]DYDN HJ\EHYHWpVHNRUSpOGiXOOOHLDQ¶YHV]WDV] ]¶²POHiQ\2ULJLQHV+XQJDULFDH

;9,,/HLEQL]HJ\pENpQWMDYDVROMD-RE/XGROIQDNKRJ\V]OiYJHUPiQpVEUHWRQWHKiW HJ\PiVLNÄEULW´Q\HOYPHOOpD]pV]WQ\HOYHWLVEHNHOOYRQQLDKDVRQOtWiVRNED/6%

²$]RQEDQD]pV]WQ\HOY²/HLEQL]KHO\HVVHMWpVHDODSMiQ²QHPDV]OiYKR]

KDQHPDILQQQ\HOYKH]N|]HOtW$]WLVVHMWLKRJ\DODSSRNILQQHNpV]WHNN|]|WWQ\HOYL QpSLURNRQYRQiVRNW QQHNHO

)HOWHKHW HQ/HLEQL]D0LDW\iQNV]|YHJHNNHONDSFVRODWEDQ YDODPLIpOH V]HPDQWLNDL HJ\H]pVUHKtYWDIHODILJ\HOPHWDPLNRUEHQHJ\LNOHYHOpEHQNLIHMWLKRJ\QLQFVN

O|Q|VHEEWiYROViJDV]LiPL6DYDQJDILQQ7DLZDQD]DQJRO+HDYHQDZDOHVLQHIRHGG DPDJ\DUPHQQ\HJEHVLFVWEMHOHQWpVHNN|]|WW/6%

/HLEQL]PLQGHQNRUWiUViQiOQDJ\REEMHOHQW VpJHWWXODMGRQtWRWWDUpJLI|OGUDM]LHOQH YH]pVHNQHNNO|Q|VHQDKHJ\HNpVIRO\yN VLQHYHLQHN(]HNDODSMiQ~J\YpOLKRJ\DJHU PiQQ\HOYE OVRNVNDQGLQiYKHJ\pVIRO\yQHYHWQHPOHKHWPHJIHMWHQLtJ\IHOWpWHOH]L KRJ\H]HNHWHJ\UpJHEELQHPJHUPiQQ\HOYHWEHV]pO QpSDGWDQDJ\YDOyV]tQ VpJJHO DODSS²ILQQQpSUpWHJ6&+8/(1%85*LP/HLEQL]V]HULQW(XUySDpV]DNLUpJLyMiW HJpV]HQ 6]LEpULiLJ D ODSS²ILQQ VQpSHVVpJ XUDOKDWWD PLQW DKRJ\ (XUySD GpOL UpV]HLQ ,EpUIpOV]LJHW²WDOiQ$IULNiEyOEHYiQGRUROYD²DEDV]NRNNpSH]WpNDOHJ VLEEQpS UpWHJHWËJ\²/HLEQL]V]HULQW²IHOWpWHOH]KHW HJ\LJHQNRUDLQpSYiQGRUOiV(XUySiED 6&+8/(1%85*LP/HLEQL]PpJEHQLVD]WtUMD-RE/XGROIQDNKRJ\DVNDQ GLQiYIpOV]LJHWHQDILQQHNYROWDND] VODNyNVFVDNNpV EEIRNR]DWRVDQK~]yGWDNIHORGD DJHUPiQW|U]VHN:$7(50$1LP$UUDD]RQEDQ/HLEQL]PiUQHPDGYiODV]WPL NpQWNpS]HOLHODILQQ²PDJ\DUQ\HOYLN|]HOVpJHWLO\HQLG NHUHWEHQpVLO\HQI|OGUDM]L PHVV]HVpJEHQ EDQ D]RQEDQ HJ\LN OHYHOH V]HULQW IHOWpWHOH]L KRJ\ D ÄILQQODSSRN´

)LQQRODSSHQHUHGHWL VLNLWHUMHGpVH.DOHGyQLiWyO6NyFLDD.DV]SLWHQJHULJK~]yGRWW 6&+8/(1%85*LPËJ\PiUpSSHQVpJJHOHONpS]HOKHW KRJ\DPDJ\DUViJ VKD ]iMDD/HLEQL]iOWDOMDYDVROW9ROJD².DV]SLWHQJHUN|UQ\pNHpVQ\HOYLNDSFVRODWDHOYL OHJEHLOOHV]WKHW HEEHDKDWDOPDVI|OGUDM]LWpUVpJEH

1HPWXGQLPLE OKRQQDQWiSOiONR]KDWRWW/HLEQL]D]RQPHJJ\ ] GpVHKRJ\DILQ QHNeV]DN(XUySD VODNRVDL7DOiQDILQQHNpV]WHNPDJXNJHUMHV]WHWWpNH]WDKLHGHOPHW YDJ\D]RNDGHiNRNDNLND;9²;9,,V]i]DGIRO\DPiQQpPHWHJ\HPHNHQWDQXOWDN/H KHWKRJ\%$/È=6-È126LVYDODPLLO\HVPLUHJRQGROW")LQQLVFKXJULVFKHV7UHIIHQEHL 0HODQFKWRQ8UDO$OWDLVFKH-DKUEFKHU;;;,,,²²0LQGHQHVHWUHN

O|Q|VKRJ\H]DPHJJ\ ] GpV²NLVVpiWDODNtWRWWN|QW|VEHQ²D;;V]i]DGPiVRGLN IHOpEHQLVIHOEXNNDQWpVN|YHW NUHWDOiOW$NOI|OG|QpO pV]WLUy9('*$56$.6SpOGi XONLIHMWHWWHKRJ\(XUySD VQpSHVVpJHHUHGHWLOHJILQQXJRUYROWVFVDNMyYDONpV EEK~

]yGWDNIHOHEEHDUpJLyEDDJHUPiQVNDQGLQiYKyGtWyNDNLNIRNR]DWRVDQHJ\UHLQNiEE pV]DNIHOpV]RUtWRWWiNDILQQVpJLQpSHNHWPHJKyGtWYDWHOHSOpVHLNHW(VWR(XURSD$7UH DWLVHRQWKH)LQQR8JULF3ULPDU\FLYLOL]DWLRQ0RQWUHDO

$NHOHWHXUySDLW|UWpQHOHPDODSRVLVPHU MH2+$/(&.,~J\OiWMDKRJ\HJ\QDJ\RQ NRUDLLG V]DNEDQILQQW|U]VHNWHOHSHGWHNPHJD%DOWLNXPEDQ6]iPRVQDJ\OpOHNV]iP~

ILQQW|U]VpOW²tUMD²QHPFVDNDPDL)LQQRUV]iJWHUOHWpQKDQHP6NDQGLQiYLiEDQLV PtJQHPD;,,V]i]DGEDQDVYpGHNHOIRJODOWiNH]WDWHUOHWHW6]HULQWHILQQHNpOWHND9ROJD PHGHQFpEHQD]eV]DNLyFHiQpVD]8UiOKHJ\VpJWiMpNiQLV%RUGHUODQGRI:HVWHUQ&LYL OL]DWLRQ+LVWRU\RI(DVW&HQWUDO(XURSH1HZ<RUN²$PHOOHWWKRJ\DILQQ VpJL QpSHN WHUOHWL HORV]OiVD NDSFViQ +$/(&., D WDJODOW OHLEQL]L HOJRQGROiVKR] N|]HOtW PHOOHVOHJiOOiVWIRJODODILQQHNQHNpVDPDJ\DURNQDNDPRQJROUDVV]KR]YDOyWDUWR]iVDPHO OHWWLVLPDPL²EiUKRJ\DQLVQp]]N²RNR]QpPLPHJOHSHWpVW

$;;V]i]DG]iUypYWL]HGpEHQWDOiQPpJHU WHOMHVHEEHQpUYHOWQpKiQ\ILQQQ\HO YpV]DPHOOHWWKRJ\DILQQVpJLQpSHNQHPÈ]VLiEyOYiQGRUROWDNMHOHQOHJLODNKHO\NUHKD QHPPLQGLJLVRWWpOWHN7|EEHQD]WYDOOMiNKRJ\HQpSHNDFURPDJQRQLHPEHUHJ\HQHV

IRO\WDWiViWNpSH]LN9H]HW WHRUHWLNXVXN.$/(9,:,,.D]WiOOtWMDKRJ\DVNDQGLQiY JHUPiQQ\HOYHNEHQHOV VRUEDQDVYpGEHQPpJPDLViWW QLNHJ\ VLILQQXJRUIRQHWLNDL VDMiWRVViJ 5e'(,.È52/< VW|UWpQHWQN NpUGpVHL $ Q\HOYpV]HWL GLOHWWDQWL]PXV NULWL NiMD%S²UpV]OHWHVHQHOHP]LpVV]DNDYDWRWWDQEtUiOMD.$/(9,:,,.pVN|

YHW LQHNHOPpOHWHLW'e&6<*<8/$²DQpONOKRJ\EiUPLIpOHYLWiEDERFViWNR]QD² NLMHOHQWLÄ0HJOHKHWKRJ\DILQQHN)LQQRUV]iJEDQDVNDQGLQiYJHUPiQRNQDJ\FVRSRUW MDLWDVV]LPLOiOWiNDW|UWpQHOHPHO WWLLG NEHQD.UXV]i]DGLJ´7KH/LQJXLVWLF ,GHQWLW\RI(XURSH3DUW,,%ORRPLQJWRQ

1\LOYiQYDOyQDNW QLNKRJ\/HLEQL]DNLWMRJJDOWDUWXQNV]HOOHPyULiVQDNEL]RQ\RV PpUWpNLJKLYDWNR]iVLDODSMDOHKHWDOHJ~MDEEYLWiNQDNHOPpOHWHNQHNDNiUDPDJ\DUQ\HOYU O YDJ\DPDJ\DU VKD]iUyODNiUDILQQVpJLQpSHNU OYDQV]yIHOIRJiVDHJ\IDMWDÄN|]EHHV ´ iOORPiVNpQWKDWRWWDNpV EELNRURNQp]HWHLUHDWHyULiNLUiQ\DLUD$]RQEDQiWWpWHOHVPy GRQOHJLQNiEEDV]NtWDQpSpVQ\HOYYHO|VV]HIJJpVEHQJ\DNRUROWPiLJNLVXJiU]yKDWiVW DPDJ\DUQ\HOYKDVRQOtWiVHJ\LN~WWpYHV]W iUDPODWiUDXJ\DQDNNRUDPDJ\DUpVDILQQVpJL Q\HOYHNHJ\YpWDUWR]iViUDLVIHOKtYWDDILJ\HOPHW(]DN|]HOVpJKRVV]~NpVpVVHOXJ\DQ GHJHQHWLNDLQ\HOYLURNRQViJJipUHWWpVPDPiUMRJJDOXUDONRGySR]tFLyWIRJODOHODPD J\DUW|UWpQHWLQ\HOYWXGRPiQ\EDQ

+(*(' 6-Ï=6()

/HLEQL]DQGWKH)LQQR8JULDQV

/HLEQL]RQHRIWKHPRVWSURPLQHQWVFKRODUVRIKLVWLPHZDVLQWHUHVWHGQRWRQO\LQQDWXUDO VFLHQFHVPDWKHPDWLFVSKLORVRSK\HWFEXWLQOLQJXLVWLFVDVZHOO$VLVNQRZQKHZDVSUHVXPDEO\

WKHILUVWWRGHFODUHWKHFORVHOLQJXLVWLFFRQQHFWLRQEHWZHHQWKH)LQQLFODQJXDJHVDQG+XQJDULDQ,Q DFFRUGDQFHZLWKKLVSUHFXUVRUVDQGFRQWHPSRUDULHVKHZDVGHHSO\LPPHUVHGLQWKH³SULPHYDO´

6F\WKLDQDQG&HOWLFRU6F\WKR&HOWLF&HOWR6F\WKLFODQJXDJHVKHFRQVLGHUHGWKHPDVFKURQROR JLFDOO\GLVWDQWDQFHVWRUVRIWKH*HUPDQLFODQJXDJHV/RWVRIZRUGVZHUHWKRXJKWE\KLPWRKDYH FRPHIURP&HOWLFODQJXDJHVHJ.HOW!*HUP+HOG²/HLEQL]ZDVDGHWHUPLQHGSURSRQHQWRI WKH)LQQODQGHUVDQG/DSSRQLDQVEHLQJWKHRULJLQDOVHWWOHUVSRSXODWLQJWKH6FDQGLQDYLDQ3HQLQVXOD ,QWHUHVWLQJO\HQRXJKWKHUHDUHSUHVHQWGD\)LQQLVKOLQJXLVWVFODLPLQJWKDWWKH)LQQLVKSHRSOHKDYH QRWFRPHIURP$VLDWKDWWKH\UHSUHVHQWWKHRULJLQDOSRSXODWLRQOLYLQJLQWKHVDPHUHJLRQIURP WLPHVLPPHPRULDO²$VWRWKH+XQJDULDQV/HLEQL]ZDVFRQYLQFHGWKDWWKHLURULJLQDOKRPHODQG PLJKWKDYHEHHQQHDUWKHYDVW9ROJD²&DVSLDQ6HDUHJLRQ/HLEQL]¶V6F\WKLDQWKHRULHVKDYHOHIW GHHSUHVRQDQFHVRQ+XQJDULDQODQJXDJHFRPSDULVRQV(YHQWRGD\ZHILQGSDUDFRPSDUDWLYHZULW LQJVIRFXVLQJRQWKHDOPRVWP\WKLFDO6F\WLDQRULJLQVRIWKH+XQJDULDQODQJXDJHLQVSLWHRIWKHIDFW WKDWWKH)LQQR8JULDQRULJLQVRI+XQJDULDQKDYHORQJEHHQSURYHG

-Ï=6()+(*(' 6

$KDQJYiOWR]iVRNUyO

+DFVXSiQYi]ODWRVDQWHNLQWMNLViWDQ\DQ\HOYQNYDJ\PiVQ\HOYHNW|UWpQHWpW OiWMXNKRJ\DPDLQ\HOYiOODSRWNLDODNXOiVDV]HPSRQWMiEyONO|Q|VHQIRQWRVKHO\HWIRJ ODOQDNHOEHQQH²DPLQWHUUHHJ\NRUPiUD]~MJUDPPDWLNXVRNUiPXWDWWDN²DKDQJYiOWR ]iVRNDPHO\HNSpOGiXODV]OiYQ\HOYHNIHMO GpVpEHQMHOHQW VPRUIROyJLDLpVV]yNpS]pV EHOLN|YHWNH]PpQ\HNNHOLVMiUWDN7HUPpV]HWHVHQQHPHVHWOHJHVYDJ\YpOHWOHQMHOHQVpJHN H]HNQHPLVDQ\HOYHNV]HV]pO\HLKLV]HQDPLQWDQQDNLGHMpQ$/(6.,(1LVKDQJV~