.pWHOWpU WDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVLPyGV]HUKDWiViQDNYL]VJiODWD D]HO QHYHOWVOO 6WL]RVWHGLRQOXFLRSHUFD/Q|YHNHGpVpUH
0ROQiU7+DQF]&V0ROQiU06WHWWQHU*
.DSRVYiUL(J\HWHPÈOODWWXGRPiQ\L.DU.DSRVYiU*XED6X
g66=()2*/$/È6
7HUPpV]HWHV YL]HLQNEHQ KDODVWDYDLQNEDQ D VOO WHUPHOpV IRNR]iViQiO D] HJ\LN QHKp]VpJHW D PHJIHOHO PpUHW LYDGpN HO iOOtWiVD MHOHQWL $ VOO OHJYHV]pO\H]WHWHWWHEE NRURV]WiO\DLQDN D] HPEULy ]VHQJH pV D ILDWDO LYDGpN pOHWOHKHW VpJHLW NHOO HPEHUL EHDYDWNR]iVRNNDOVHJtWHQQNDWHUPHOpVVRUiQ(]D]HO QHYHOWPpUHWHOpUpVpLJEL]WRVtWRWW D WDYL N|UOPpQ\HN N|]W D]RQEDQ D ILDWDO LYDGpN WHUPHOpVpQHN Q|YHOpVpUH D] HJ\LN OHKHWVpJHV PHJROGiV D WDYL HO QHYHOW LYDGpN LQWHQ]tY WRYiEEQHYHOpVL WHFKQLNiMiQDN NLGROJR]iVD OHKHWQH 9L]VJiODWDLQNEDQ pV D WDYL HO QHYHOW VOO pOHWWHOHQ WiSOiOpNUD YDOy iWV]RNWDWiViQDN OHKHW VpJpW WDQXOPiQ\R]WXN D .DU +DOODERUDWyULXPiEDQ WDOiOKDWy LQWHQ]tY UHFLUNXOiFLyV UHQGV]HUEHQ $ QpJ\KHWHV NtVpUOHWHNDODWWD]RRSODQNWRQUyOGDUDEROWKDOHWHWpVUHYDOyIRNR]DWRVpViWPHQHWQpONOL iWiOOiV KDWiViW YL]VJiOWXN $] HUHGPpQ\HLQNDODSMiQ PHJiOODStWKDWyKRJ\ D] HO QHYHOW VOO LQWHQ]tY WRYiEEQHYHOpVH PLQGNpW iWiOOiVL PyGV]HU DONDOPD]iViYDO PHJROGKDWy $ WHUPHOpVLSDUDPpWHUHNEHQD]DOiEELNO|QEVpJHNHWWDOiOWXND WDNDUPiQ\IRJ\DV]WiVEDQ IRNR]DWRV iWPHQHWWHO iWPHQHW QpONO JHJ\HG D WDNDUPiQ\
pUWpNHVtWpVEHQLOOHWYHJJ3 V]LQWHQDW|PHJJ\DUDSRGiVEDQ
pV JHJ\HG 3 V]LQWHQ EL]RQ\XOW V]LJQLILNiQVQDN D NO|QEVpJ D]
iWPHQHWWHO WRYiEEi D] iWPHQHW QpONO YpJ]HWW WDNDUPiQ\YiOWiV N|]|WW $] HOKXOOiVEDQ LOOHWYH QHP MHOHQW V D NO|QEVpJ pV NDQQLEDOL]PXV FVDN D] iWPHQHW QpONOLiWiOOiVEDQIRUGXOWHO D]HOV YDODPLQWDPiVRGLNKpWHQWRYiEEi .XOFVV]DYDNVOO WDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVLQWHQ]tYQHYHOpV
$%675$&7
6WXG\RQWKHHIIHFWRIWZRGLIIHUHQWPHWKRGVRIGLHWFKDQJHRQWKHJURZWK RISRQGUHDUHGSLNHSHUFK6WL]RVWHGLRQOXFLRSHUFD/
70ROQiU&V+DQF]00ROQiU*6WHWWQHU
8QLYHUVLW\RI.DSRVYiU)DFXOW\RI$QLPDO6FLHQFH.DSRVYiU+*XED6X
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iU)DFXOW\RI$QLPDO6FLHQFH.DSRVYiU
]RRSODQNWRQ IHHGLQJ SLNHSHUFK IU\ WR IHHG RQ QRW OLYLQJ IRRG 'XULQJ WKH ZHHNV RI H[SHULPHQWVWKHHIIHFWRIFKDQJLQJWKHGLHW IURP ]RRSODQNWRQ WR PLQFHG ILVK ZLWK DQG ZLWKRXW DFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ ZDV VWXGLHG LQ DTXDULD ZRUNLQJ LQDQ LQWHQVLYH UHFLUFXODWLQJ V\VWHP$FFRUGLQJWRRXUUHVXOWVWKHFRQYHUWLQJRIIHHGLQJRISRQGUHDUHGSLNHSHUFKIU\
WRPLQFHGILVKLVIHDVLEOHZLWKERWKRIWKHFRQYHUVLRQWHFKQLFVEXWWKHUHZHUHGLIIHUHQFHV EHWZHHQWKHSURGXFWLRQSDUDPHWHUV7KHIRRGLQWDNHZLWKDFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ
ZLWKRXWDFFOLPDWLVDWLRQJILVKDQGIHHGFRQYHUVLRQDQGJJZHUH LQIOXHQFHGVLJQLILFDQWO\3 E\WKHGLHWFKDQJLQJPHWKRG7KHHIIHFWRQWKHDYHUDJH ZHLJKW JDLQ DQG JILVK ZDV DOVR IRXQG VLJQLILFDQW 3 ,Q FDVHRIPRUWDOLW\DQGWKHGLIIHUHQFHZDVQRWVLJQLILFDQW&DQQLEDOLVPZDV RQO\GHWHFWHGLQFDVHRIFRQYHUVLRQZLWKRXWDFFOLPDWLVDWLRQLQWKHILUVWWZRZHHNV DQG.H\ZRUGVSLNHSHUFKFRQYHUVLRQRIIHHGLQJLQWHQVLYHUHDULQJ
%(9(=(7e6
+D]iQNKDOWHQ\pV]WpVpQHND]DVpYHNW OPHJEHFVOWKDODDVOO (QHPHVUDJDGR]y WHQ\pV]WpVpEHQIHOQHYHOpVLPyGV]HUHLQHNNLGROJR]iViEDQ0DJ\DURUV]iJPLQGLJD]pOHQ MiUW6RNPDJ\DUV]DNHPEHUHUHGPpQ\HV]DYDWROMDKRJ\H]WDKDOIDMWDQQDNHOOHQpUH KRJ\DN|UQ\H]HWLKDWiVRNNDOV]HPEHQLpU]pNHQ\VpJHQDJ\REEPLQWD0DJ\DURUV]iJRQ V]DSRUtWRWWKDODN]|PpQHNHUHGPpQ\HVHQIHOOHKHWQHYHOQL$KDOWHUPHOpVV]HPSRQWMDLW ILJ\HOHPEH YpYH PHJiOODStWKDWMXN KRJ\ D KDQJV~O\ HJ\UH LQNiEE D PLQ VpJL KDOWHUPHOpVUHKHO\H] GLN(XUySiEDQ(]DWHQGHQFLDDKDJ\RPiQ\RVWDYL KDODN PHOOHWW PLQWSpOGiXODSRQW\HO WpUEHKHO\H]LDV]iUD]IHKpUK~V~UDJDGR]yKDODLQNHOV VRUEDQ DVOO WHUPHOpVpQHNIRQWRVViJiW(]DKDOPLQGSLDFLpUWpNpWPLQGELROyJLDLV]DEiO\R]y V]HUHSpWWHNLQWYHLVILJ\HOPHWpUGHPHO
$VOO OHJYHV]pO\H]WHWHWWHEENRURV]WiO\DLQDND]HPEULyOiUYDpVDILDWDOLYDGpN FPpOHWOHKHW VpJHLWNHOOHPEHULEHDYDWNR]iVRNNDOVHJtWHQQNDWHUPHOpVVRUiQ
$ VOO HPEULy YpGHOPH IHMO GpVpQHN HO VHJtWpVH D SiUDNDPUiV NHOWHWpV :R\QiURYLFK VRUiQ PHJROGRWWQDN WHNLQWKHW $ PHJIHOHO PpUHW ÄWpOiOOy´ LYDGpN HO iOOtWiVD D]RQEDQHOHQJHGKHWHWOHQIHOWpWHOHDWHUPHOpVIRNR]iViQDNpVD]XWiQSyWOiVEL]WRVtWiViQDN
$VOO QHYHOpVKD]DLJ\DNRUODWiKR]KDVRQOyDQD]pV]DNDPHULNDLZDOOH\QiO6WL]RVWHGLRQ YLWUHXP LV QHKH]HQ PHJROGKDWy D PHJIHOHO PpUHW WiSOiOpNKDO NHOO LG EHQ W|UWpQ IRO\DPDWRVEL]WRVtWiVDD]HO QHYHOpVVRUiQ&ROHVDQWHHWDO$ZDOOH\HHVHWpEHQD QDJ\V]iP~ PPHQ IHOOL LYDGpN HO iOOtWiViKR] D] HO QHYHOWHN PPHV PpUHWEHQW|UWpQ OHKDOiV]iVDDPLDVOO QpO LV KDVRQOyDQ W|UWpQLN pV D]W N|YHW HQ D]
HO QHYHOWLYDGpNLQWHQ]tYUHQGV]HUHNEHW|UWpQ iWWHOHStWpVHLOOPHVWHUVpJHVWiSOiOpNRNUD YDOy iWV]RNWDWiVD V]NVpJHV &KHVKLUH pV 6WHHOH (]HN DODSMiQ D VOO QpO LV D SUREOpPiQDN D] HJ\LN OHKHWVpJHV PHJROGiVD OHKHW D WyEDQ HO QHYHOW LYDGpN LQWHQ]tY XWyQHYHOpVL PyGV]HUpQHN NLGROJR]iVD (] DQQiO LV LQNiEE LQGRNROWQDN W QLN PLYHO D ZDOOH\HQiO D] LQWHQ]tY QHYHOpV W|EEpNHYpVEp PHJROGRWWQDN WHNLQWKHW .XLSHUV pV 6XPPHUIHOW &KHVLUH pV 6WHHOH &ROHVDQWH HW DO pV D] RWW V]HU]HWW WDSDV]WDODWRNIHOKDV]QiOKDWyN$VOO OiUYiNPHVWHUVpJHVWiSOiOpNRQW|UWpQ HO QHYHOpVH D NLVHEE N|OWVpJ My KDWiVIRN~ WDYL HO QHYHOpV KHO\HWW QHP LQGRNROW PLYHO D] LO\HQ SUyEiONR]iVRN ODVV~ Q|YHNHGpVW LOOHWYH PDJDV PRUWDOLWiVW HUHGPpQ\H]WHN .OHLQ
%UHWWHOHU5XXKLMlUYLHWDO6FKOXPEHUJHUpV3URWHDX
9L]VJiODWDLQNEDQDQpJ\KHWHVNtVpUOHWHNDODWWDWDYLHO QHYHOW VOO pOHWWHOHQWiSOiOpNUDYDOyiWV]RNWDWiViQDNOHKHW VpJpWDIRNR]DWRVpViWPHQHWQpONOL iWiOOiVKDWiVIRNiWYL]VJiOWXN
$1<$*e60Ï'6=(5
EHQpVEHQEHQHO QHYHOWVOO WWHOHStWHWWQND.DSRVYiUL(J\HWHP +DOODERUDWyULXPiQDN UHFLUNXOiFLyV UHQGV]HUpEHQ ]HPHO OLWHUHV OHYHJ ]WHWHWW DNYiULXPRNED $ NtVpUOHWHN EHiOOtWiViW PHJHO ] HQ NpWKHWHV V]RNWDWiVL SHULyGXVW DONDOPD]WXQN PLDODWW D] HO QHYHOW LYDGpNRNDW OLWHUHV LYDGpNQHYHO YiO\~NEDQ KHO\H]WNHODKROJ\ MW|WW]RRSODQNWRQWWXELIH[HWYDODPLQWpO NHV]HJLYDGpNRWHWHWWQN$
V]LQWH D]RQQDO IHOOpS GDUDNyU IHUW ]pV HOOHQ PDODFKLW]|OGHV IUGHWpVW DONDOPD]WXQN $ KDODNDW EHQ pV EHQ PtJ EHQ DNYiULXPED KHO\H]WN iW DNYiULXPRQNpQWDWDV]RNWDWiVLSHULyGXVWN|YHW HQ$NtVpUOHWLLG V]DNPLQGDKiURP pYEHQQpJ\KpWLJWDUWRWWEHQDWHOHStWpVWN|YHW HQiWPHQHWQpONOKDOGDUDERWHWHWWQN DG OLELWXP QDSL NpW DONDORPPDO IHONtQiOYD EHQ pV EHQ DPtJ D VOO N QHP IRJ\DV]WRWWiN EL]WRQViJJDO D KDOGDUDERNDW YiJRWW WXELIH[HW LV IHONtQiOWXQN )DJ\DV]WYD WiUROW EDODWRQL NHV]HJHW HWHWWQN DPLW NH]GHWEHQ D E U HOWiYROtWiVD XWiQL GDUiOiVVDO NpV]tWHWWQNHO PDMGDNpV EELHNEHQDPpUHWHWDVOO NLJpQ\HLQHNPHJIHOHO HQQ|YHOWN NEîFPHVPpUHWUHDKDOK~VNHYpVEpILQRPUDYDOyGDUiOiViYDO
$ UHFLUNXOiFLyV UHQGV]HUEHQ P N|G DNYiULXPRNEDQ & iWODJRV Yt]K PpUVpNOHWHWUHJLV]WUiOWXQN
$ VWDWLV]WLNDL DQDOt]LVW D] 6366 IRU :LQGRZV SURJUDPFVRPDJ VHJtWVpJpYHO YpJH]WN $ NO|QE|] WDUWiVL PyGRN KDWiViW HJ\WpQ\H] V YDULDQFLDDQDOt]LVVHO LOOHWYH W~OpOpVYL]VJiODWWDOORJUDQNWHV]WpUWpNHOWN
(5('0e1<e6e57e.(/e6
$ NpWIpOH WDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVL PyGV]HU WDNDUPiQ\IRJ\DV]WiVUD W|PHJJ\DUDSRGiVUD pV WDNDUPiQ\pUWpNHVtWpVUH NLIHMWHWW KDWiViW |VV]HKDVRQOtWy VWDWLV]WLNDL YL]VJiODWRN V]LJQLILNDQFLDpUWpNHLWD]WiEOi]DWWDUWDOPD]]D
WiEOi]DW
$NpWIpOHWDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVLPyGV]HUKDWiViQDN|VV]HKDVRQOtWiViKR]WDUWR]y V]LJQLILNDQFLDpUWpNHNDWDNDUPiQ\IRJ\DV]WiVEDQDW|PHJJ\DUDSRGiVEDQpVD
WDNDUPiQ\pUWpNHVtWpVEHQ
3DUDPpWHU KpW KpW KpW KpW 7HOMHVSHULyGXV
7DNIRJ\DV]WiV
7|PHJJ\DUDSRGiV
7DNDUPiQ\pUWpNHVtWpV
7DEOH6LJQLILFDQF\OHYHOVRIWKHGLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQWKHWZRPHWKRGVRIGLHWFKDQJHLQ WKHGDLO\IHHGLQWDNHDYHUDJHZHLJKWJDLQDQGIHHGFRQYHUVLRQ
3DUDPHWHUWKZHHNQGZHHNUGZHHNWKZHHN:KROHSHULRG'DLO\
IHHGLQWDNH$YHUDJHZHLJKWJDLQ)HHGFRQYHUVLRQ
$ NpWIpOH PyGV]HU WDNDUPiQ\IRJ\DV]WiV YiOWR]iViUD NLIHMWHWW KDWiViW D] iEUD V]HPOpOWHWL
$ VWDWLV]WLNDL YL]VJiODW D WDNDUPiQ\IRJ\DV]WiVEDQ FVDN D] HOV pV D KDUPDGLN KpWHQ LOOHWYHD]HJpV]SHULyGXVUDJLOOHWYHJD]iWPHQHWQpONOLWRYiEEiD]
iWPHQHWHV FVRSRUWQiO PXWDWRWW NL V]LJQLILNiQV HOWpUpVW $ PiVRGLN pV QHJ\HGLN KpWHQ D]
iWPHQHW QpONO iWV]RNWDWRWW FVRSRUWQiO OpY QDJ\ V]yUiV OHKHW D] RND D V]LJQLILNDQFLD KLiQ\iQDN$]iWPHQHWQpONOiWV]RNWDWRWWFVRSRUWWDNDUPiQ\IRJ\DV]WiVDDWHOMHVSHULyGXVEDQ DODWWDPDUDGD]iWPHQHWWHOiWV]RNWDWRWWFVRSRUWpQDND]HOV KiURPKpWEHQDQQDNiWD QHJ\HGLN KpWHQ iW WHV]L NL $] iWPHQHWWHO W|UWpQ iWV]RNWDWiV PHOOHWW D WDNDUPiQ\IRJ\DV]WiV pUWpNH J N|UO PR]RJ PtJ D] iWPHQHW QpONOL FVRSRUWEDQ IRNR]DWRVDQ Q UyO UH +D D WHVWW|PHJ V]i]DOpNiEDQ IHMH]]N NL D QDSL iWODJRV WDNDUPiQ\IRJ\DV]WiVWDNNRUD]iWPHQHWHVFVRSRUWQiOD]UyOUDFV|NNHQDQpJ\KpW DODWWPtJD]iWPHQHWQpONOLFVRSRUWQiOH]DFV|NNHQpVUyOUDNLVHEE
iEUD
$NpWIpOHWDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVLPyGV]HUKDWiVDDWDNDUPiQ\IRJ\DV]WiVYiOWR]iViUD
.tVpUOHWLKpW 7DND
UP iQ\I RJ\D V]Wi VJ HJ\
HGK pW
ÈWPHQHWQpONO
ÈWPHQHWWHO
33
)LJXUH&KDQJHVLQWKHGDLO\IRRGLQWDNHDFFRUGLQJWRWKHFRQYHUVLRQPHWKRGV
'DLO\IRRGLQWDNHJLQGLYLGXDOZHHN([SHULPHQWDO ZHHNV :LWK DFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ :LWKRXWDFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ
$W|PHJJ\DUDSRGiVEDQiEUDD]HOWpUpVHNPLQGDQpJ\KpWHQpVDWHOMHVSHULyGXVEDQ LVJLOOHWYHJD]iWPHQHWQpONOLWRYiEEiD]iWPHQHWHVFVRSRUWQiO V]LJQLILNiQVDN YROWDN $] iWPHQHW QpONOL FVRSRUW PLQGYpJLJ MyYDO J\HQJpEE J\DUDSRGiVWPXWDWRWWDPLD]HOV NpWKpWEHQD]iWPHQHWWHOiWV]RNWDWRWWFVRSRUWpUWpNpQHN iWPtJDKDUPDGLNQHJ\HGLNKpWHQiWMHOHQWL
$] iWODJW|PHJ YiOWR]iVD iEUD MyO N|YHWL D W|PHJJ\DUDSRGiVEDQ OHtUW WHQGHQFLiNDW$]HOV NpWKpWEHQD]iWPHQHWQpONOLFVRSRUWEDQNLVHEEPDMGDN|YHWNH]
NpW KpWEHQ QDJ\REE Q|YHNHGpVW ILJ\HOKHWQN PHJ PtJ D] iWPHQHWWHO W|UWpQ WDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVHVHWpEHQDQ|YHNHGpVHJ\HQOHWHVQHPILJ\HOKHW PHJW|UpVSRQW$NpW FVRSRUW iWODJW|PHJH N|]WL HOWpUpV D QHJ\HGLN KpWHQ YROW FVDN V]LJQLILNiQV 3 D]RQEDQPiUDKDUPDGLNKpWHQLVPHJN|]HOtWHWWHD]W3
iEUD
$NpWIpOHWDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVLPyGV]HUKDWiVDDW|PHJJ\DUDSRGiVYiOWR]iViUD
.tVpUOHWLKpW 7|P
HJJ\
DUDS RGiV JH J\HG KpW
ÈWPHQHWQpONO ÈWPHQHWWHO
)LJXUH&KDQJHVLQWKHDYHUDJHZHLJKWJDLQDFFRUGLQJWRWKHFRQYHUVLRQPHWKRGV
$YHUDJHZHLJKWJDLQJLQGLYLGXDOZHHN([SHULPHQWDOZHHNV:LWKDFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ :LWKRXWDFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ
iEUD
$NpWIpOHWDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVLPyGV]HUKDWiVDD]iWODJW|PHJYiOWR]iViUD
,QGXOy KpW KpW KpW KpW 0pUpVHN
ÈWOD JW|P HJJ
ÈWPHQHWQpONO ÈWPHQHWWHO
)LJXUH&KDQJHVLQWKHDYHUDJHZHLJKWDFFRUGLQJWRWKHFRQYHUVLRQPHWKRGV
$YHUDJH ZHLJKW JLQGLYLGXDOZHHN 6DPSOLQJ WLPH :LWK DFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ :LWKRXWDFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ
3 3
$ WDNDUPiQ\pUWpNHVtWpVEHQ D KDUPDGLN KpW NLYpWHOpYHO D] iWPHQHWHV FVRSRUW D WHOMHV SHULyGXVEDQV]LJQLILNiQVDQDODFVRQ\DEEHUHGPpQ\HNHWPXWDWRWWDPLJJN|UOLpUWpNHW MHOHQW$]iWPHQHWQpONOLFVRSRUWQiOD]HOV NpWKpWEHQPDJDVpUWpNHNHWpVQDJ\V]yUiVW WDSDV]WDOWXQN D]RQEDQ D KDUPDGLN QHJ\HGLN KpWUH HQQpO D FVRSRUWQiO LV JJ pUWpN iOODQGyVXOW$WDNDUPiQ\pUWpNHVtWpVWDiEUDV]HPOpOWHWL
iEUD
$NpWIpOHWDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVLPyGV]HUKDWiVDDWDNDUPiQ\pUWpNHVtWpVYiOWR]iViUD
.tVpUOHWLKpW 7DND
UP iQ\p UWpN HVtWp VJ J
ÈWPHQHWQpONO ÈWPHQHWWHO
3
)LJXUH&KDQJHVLQWKHIHHGFRQYHUVLRQDFFRUGLQJWRWKHFRQYHUVLRQPHWKRGV
)HHG FRQYHUVLRQ JJ ([SHULPHQWDO ZHHNV :LWK DFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ :LWKRXW DFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ
$] iWODJRV PHJPDUDGiV D] iWPHQHW QpONOL FVRSRUWEDQ PtJ D] iWPHQHWWHO iWV]RNWDWRWWFVRSRUWEDQYROW$iEUDPXWDWMDEHDNXPXODWtYPHJPDUDGiVWDNpW FVRSRUWEDQ $] HOKXOOiVEDQ PHJILJ\HOKHW NO|QEVpJHN QHP YROWDN V]LJQLILNiQVDN 3 $]iEUDLVMyOPXWDWMDD]RQEDQKRJ\D]iWPHQHWWHOW|UWpQ iWV]RNWDWiVNRUD PHJPDUDGiV D WHOMHV SHULyGXV DODWW D PiVLN FVRSRUWEDQ PpUW pUWpNHN I|O|WW PDUDGW $]
HOKXOOiVRN QDJ\ UpV]H PLQG D NpW FVRSRUWEDQ D] HOV KiURP KpWHQ PHJW|UWpQW HJ\HQOHWHVHQN|]HOKDVRQOyPHJRV]OiVEDQ
.DQQLEDOL]PXVW FVDN D] iWPHQHW QpONO W|UWpQ WDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVNRU WDSDV]WDOWXQN
$NNRULVFVDND]HOV LOOHWYHDPiVRGLNKpWHQHOpJDODFVRQ\pUWpNHQMHOHQWNH]HWWpV DPLIHOWHKHW HQD]pOHWWHOHQWiSOiOpNIHOYpWHOpQHNPHJWDQXOiViKR]V]NVpJHVNpW KpW DODWWL pKH]pV N|YHWNH]PpQ\H $ NDQQLEiO HJ\HGHN HOWiYROtWiViYDO D KDUPDGLN QHJ\HGLNKpWUHDNDQQLEDOL]PXVPHJMHOHQpVHHONHUOKHW YROW
iEUD
$NpWIpOHWDNDUPiQ\YiOWiVLPyGV]HUKDWiVDD]HOKXOOiVYiOWR]iViUD
.tVpUOHWLQDSRN
0HJ PDU DGiV
0yGV]HU ÈWPHQHWWHO ÈWPHQHWQpONO
)LJXUH&KDQJHVLQWKHVXUYLYDOUDWHDFFRUGLQJWRWKHFRQYHUVLRQPHWKRGV
&XPPXODWLYH 6XUYLYDO 0HWKRG :LWK DFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ :LWKRXW DFFOLPDWLVDWLRQ([SHULPHQWDOGD\V
.g9(7.(=7(7e6(.
$]HUHGPpQ\HNDODSMiQMyOOiWV]LNKRJ\PLQGNpWWtSXV~iWiOOiVVDOVLNHUHVHQPHJROGKDWy D VOO pOHWWHOHQ WiSOiOpNUD YDOy iWV]RNWDWiVD $ YiJRWW WXELIH[HV NLHJpV]tWpVVHO D]
iWPHQHWWHO W|UWpQ WiSOiOpNYiOWiV D]RQEDQ NtPpOHWHVHEE pV D W|PHJJ\DUDSRGiVEDQ WDNDUPiQ\IRJ\DV]WiVEDQ YDODPLQW D WDNDUPiQ\pUWpNHVtWpVEHQ LV V]LJQLILNiQVDQ MREE HUHGPpQ\HNHW pUKHWQN HO YHOH $] HOKXOOiVEDQ QHP YROW V]LJQLILNiQV D NO|QEVpJ D FVRSRUWRN N|]|WW D]RQEDQ D PHJPDUDGiV V]LQWpQ PLQWHJ\ NDO PDJDVDEE YROW D WXELIH[HV V]RNWDWiV HVHWpEHQ DPL DEEyO V]iUPD]KDW KRJ\ D WDQXOiVL LG V]DN DODWW QHP OpSIHOWDUWyVpKH]pVD]DNNRUPpJQHPQDJ\WDUWDOpNRNNDOUHQGHONH] LYDGpNRNQiO(]W PHJHU VtWHQL OiWV]LN KRJ\ NDQQLEDOL]PXV V]LQWpQ FVDN D] iWPHQHW QpONOL WDNDUPiQ\YiOWiV HVHWpEHQ OpSHWW IHO DNNRU LV FVDN D] HOV NpW KpWEHQ WHKiW D] pKH]pV HONHUOpVpYHO DQQDN PHJMHOHQpVH YDODPLQW D VLNHUWHOHQ WiPDGiVRNEyO V]iUPD]y VpUOpVHNpVD]RNiOWDOLHOKXOOiVRNPHJHO ]KHW N$WXELIH[HVV]RNWDWiVVRUiQD]HOV NpW KpWHQ EHN|YHWNH] W|UpV HONHUOpVpYHO D W|PHJJ\DUDSRGiV KD HO QHP LV pUL GH PHJN|]HOtWL D] D]RQRV N|UOPpQ\HN N|]W QHYHOW pO KDODW IRJ\DV]Wy VOO QpO PpUW pUWpNHNHW 0ROQiU HW DO D]RQEDQ PHJKDODGMD D=DNHV HW DO iOWDO SLV]WUiQJWiS HWHWpVH PHOOHWW PpUW pUWpNHW KpW DODWW J )RQWRV PHJHPOtWHQL D]RQEDQD]WLVKRJ\DWDNDUPiQ\pUWpNHVtWpVpUWpNHPpJD]iWV]RNWDWiVQpONOLFVRSRUWEDQ LVDODFVRQ\DEEQDNPXWDWNR]RWWPLQWD]LURGDORPEDQD]pO KDOIRJ\DV]WiVUDPHJDGRWW JJRVpUWpN7DVQiGLD]RQEDQPHJKDODGWDYDJ\N|]HOD]RQRVpUWpN YROWD WiSIRJ\DV]WiVDPHOOHWWPpUWJJRVpUWpNNHO+LOJH
,52'$/20
&KHVLUH :) 6WHHOH ./ +DWFKHU\ UHDULQJ RI ZDOOH\H XVLQJ DUWLILFLDO IRRG 3URJUHVVLYH)LVK&XOWXULVW
&ROHVDQWH57<RXPDQV1%=LRONRVNL%,QWHQVLYHFXOWXUHRIZDOOH\HIU\
ZLWKOLYHIRRGDQGIRUPXODWHGGLHWV3URJUHVVLYH)LVK&XOWXULVW
+LOJH92EVHUYDWLRQVRQWKHUHDULQJRISHUFKSLNH6WL]RVWHGLRQOXFLRSHUFD/
LQWKHODERUDWRU\$UFKLYIXU)LVFKHUHLZLVVHQVFKDIW
.OHLQ%UHWWHOHU-3*,QWHQVLYHFXOWXUHRISLNHSHUKIU\ZLWKOLYHIRRG ,Q $TXDFXOWXUH D ELRWHFKQRORJ\ LQ SURJUHVV 'H3DXZ HW DO (GV (XURSHDQ
$TXDFXOWXUH6RFLHW\%UHGHQH
.XLSHUV./6XPPHUIHOW5&&RQYHUWLQJSRQGUHDUHG:DOOH\HILQJHUOLQJVWR IRUPXODWHG IHHGV (IIHFWV RI GLHW WHPSHUDWXUH DQG VWRFNLQJ GHQVLW\ -RXUQDO RI
$SOOLHG$TXDFXOWXUH
0ROQiU7 +DQF] &V 0ROQiU 0 6WHWWQHU * 1pKiQ\ WHFKQROyJLDL SDUDPpWHU YL]VJiODWDD VOO 6WL]RVWHGLRQ OXFLRSHUFD / LQWHQ]tY QHYHOpVH VRUiQ $FWD $JU .DSRV
5XXKLMlUYL - 9LUWDQHQ ( 6DOPLQHQ 0 0X\XQGD 0 7KH JURZWK DQG VXUYLYDORISLNHSHUFK6WL]RVWHGLRQOXFLRSHUFD/ODUYDHIHGRQIRUPXODWHGIHHGV ,Q/DUYL3/DYHQVHWDO(GV($66SHFLDO3XEOLFDWLRQ*HQW 6FKOXPEHUJHU23URWHDX-33URGXFWLRQGHMXYHQLOHVGHVDQGUH6WL]RVWHGLRQ
OXFLRSHUFD$TXD5HYXH
7DVQiGL5+DOWDNDUPiQ\R]iV0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW :R\QiURYLFK ( (UEUWXQJ YRQ )LVFKHLHUQ LQ 6SUKUDXP $UFK )LVFK:LVV
=DNHV = 'HPVND=DNHV . (IIHFW RI GLHWV RQ JURZWK DQG UHSURGXFWLYH GHYHORSPHQW RI MXYHQLOH SLNHSHUFK 6WL]RVWHGLRQ OXFLRSHUFD / UHDUHG XQGHU LQWHQVLYHFXOWXUHFRQGLWLRQV$TXDFXOWXUH5HVHDUFK
/HYHOH]pVLFtPFRUUHVSRQGLQJDXWKRU 0ROQiU7DPiV
.DSRVYiUL(J\HWHPÈOODWWXGRPiQ\L.DU .DSRVYiU3I
8QLYHUVLW\RI.DSRVYiU)DFXOW\RI$QLPDO6FLHQFH +.DSRVYiU32%R[
7HO)D[
HPDLOPROQDUW#PDLODWNXNDSRVYDUKX
![$NLVYLUiJ~QHEiQFVYLUiJ,PSDWLHQVSDUYLIORUD'&pVD NHUHV]WODSX(UHFKWLWHVKLHUDFLIROLD5]()