• Nem Talált Eredményt

Gyógypedagógiai Szemle 2016/3

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Ossza meg "Gyógypedagógiai Szemle 2016/3"

Copied!
112
0
0

Teljes szövegt

(1)
(2)

*<­*<3('$*­*,$,6=(0/(

$0DJ\DU*\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJXVRN(J\HVÖOHWÃQHNIRO\ÍLUDWD

$ODSÇWÍIÏV]HUNHV]WÏ )ÏV]HUNHV]WÏ 7HUYH]ÏV]HUNHV]WÏ 6]ÐYHJJRQGR]»V 6]HUNHV]WÏEL]RWWV»J

'LJLW»OLVV]HUNHV]WÃV 'LJLW»OLVPHJMHOHQÃV 6]HUNHV]WÏVÃJLWLWN»U

*RUGRVQÃGU6]DEÍ$QQD 9LU»Q\L$QLWD

)25(121RQSURILW.IW 35$(+8.IW

%HQF]ÔU0LNOÍVQÃ

&V»Q\L<YRQQH )DUNDVQÃ*ÐQF]L5LWD )HKÃUQÃ.RY»FV=VX]VD

*HUHEHQ)HUHQFQà 0RKDL.DWDOLQ 6WHIDQLN.ULV]WLQD 6]HNHUHV›JRWD

3»O'»QLHO/HYHQWHSDOGDQLHO#JPDLOFRP ZZZJ\RJ\SHGV]HPOHKX

6]HNHUHV6]DEROFVJ\RJ\SHGV]HPOH#JPDLOFRP

$V]HUNHV]WÏVÃJHOÃUKHWÏVÃJHJ\RJ\SHGV]HPOH#JPDLOFRP 0HJY»V»UROKDWÍ.UDV]Q»UÃV7»UVD.ÐQ\YNHUHVNHGHOPL%W

%XGDSHVW'ÃVL+XEHUX

+8,661

)HOHOÏVNLDGÍ

*(5(%(1)(5(1&1£'5HOQÐNr0DJ\DU*\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJXVRN(J\HVÖOHWH

%XGDSHVW'DPMDQLFKXJHUHEHQ#EDUF]LHOWHKX

'5=›6=.$/,&=.<3£7(5GÃN»Qr(/7(%»UF]L*XV]W»Y*\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJLDL.DU

%XGDSHVW(FVHULÔW7HO

(OÏIL]HWÃVEHQWHUMHV]WLD0DJ\DU3RVWD=UW+ÇUODS¶]OHW»JD

%XGDSHVW2UF]\WÃU

(OÏIL]HWKHWÏYDODPHQQ\LSRVW»QNÃ]EHVÇWÏQÃO HPDLOHQKLUODSHORIL]HWHV#SRVWDKXID[RQ 7RY»EELLQIRUP»FLÍ

(J\V]»P»UD)W ,QGH[V]»P 0HJMHOHQLNQHJ\HGÃYHQNÃQW

0LQGHQ MRJ IHQQWDUWYD $ IRO\ÍLUDWEDQ PHJMHOHQW NÃSHNHW »EU»NDW ÃV V]ÐYHJHNHW D NLDGÍ HQJHGÃO\H QÃONÖO WLORV NÐ]]ÃWHQQL UHSURGXN»OQL V]»PÇW»VWHFKQLNDL UHQGV]HUEHQ W»UROQL ÃV WRY»EEDGQL $ V]HU NHV]WÏVÃJNÃSHNHWÃVNÃ]LUDWRNDWQHPÏUL]PHJÃVQHPNÖOGYLVV]D

1<20'$

)25(121RQSURILW.IWq6RSURQ)UDNQÍLX )HOHOÏVYH]HWÏ)ÐOGHV7DP»VÖJ\YH]HWÏLJD]JDWÍ

ʹͲͳ͸ǤŒïŽ‹—•Ȃ•œ‡’–‡„‡”

(3)

149

E R E D E T I K Ö Z L E M É N Y E K

ELTE Bárczi Gusztáv Gyógypedagógiai Kar, Atipikus Viselkedés és Kogníció Gyógypeda- gógiai Intézet

Pest Megyei Pedagógiai Szakszolgálat Gödöllői Tagintézménye

Enyhén értelmi fogyatékos gyermekeket integráló „jó” és „rossz” közösségek

összehasonlítása

1

HERBAINÉ SZEKERES ERIKA – SZEKERES ÁGOTA szekereseri@gmail.com, szekeres.agota@barczi.elte.hu

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Absztrakt

Tanulmányunkban az enyhén értelmi fogyatékos gyermekeket integráló, szociometriai mutatóik alapján “jó” és “rossz” közös- ségnek számító osztályok (24 osztály) összehasonlító elemzésével a szociális integrációt elősegítő, illetve nehezítő feltételek, csoportszerkezeti sajátosságok megragadására törekedtünk.

Az eredményekből kiderült, hogy az integrált gyermekek beilleszkedése általában sikeresnek mondható, társas pozíciójuk – különösen 4. osztályban – nem mutat eltérést a többségi gyermekekéhez képest. Megállapítható továbbá, hogy az alacso- nyabb osztálylétszám nem garancia a kapcsolatok alakulására, nem biztosít hatékonyabb integrálódást. Végül a vizsgált osztá- lyok szociogramjainak szerkezete egyértelművé tette a „jó” és „rossz” közösségek közti különbségeket: jól látható, egymástól jelentősen eltérő szerkezeti struktúrák jellemzik őket.

Kulcsszavak: szociometria, integráció, enyhe értelmi fogyatékosság, közösségek

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

1. Bevezetés

Napjaink egyik legfontosabb megoldandó feladatai közé tartozik a marginális helyzet- ben lévő csoportok társadalmi integrációja. Ennek segítését már fiatal gyermekkorban, az intézményes nevelés elején el kell kezdeni. Minél korábban tapasztalja meg ugyanis egy kisgyermek a világ sokszínűségét, minél korábban kerül kapcsolatba eltérő fejlődé- sű, és lehetőségekkel rendelkező társakkal, annál természetesebben fog felnőttkorában nyitni feléjük (FISCHER 2009).

1 A kutatást a Bolyai János Kutatói Ösztöndíj támogatta.

(4)

!%

$] LQWHJU»OW RNWDW»V D] HOVĈ DODSYHWĈ OÃSÃV DQQDN ÃUGHNÃEHQ KRJ\ PHJY»OWR]]RQ DGLV]NULPLQDWÇYV]HPOÃOHWÃVNLDODNXOKDVVRQDEHIRJDGÍW»UVDGDORP$WDQXO»VLQHKÃ]VÃ JHNNHO ÃV IRJ\DWÃNRVV»JJDO ÃOĈ HPEHUHN WHOMHV LQWHJU»FLÍMD D W»UVDGDORP JD]GDV»JL ÃV V]RFL»OLV ÃOHWÃEH r DEHIRJDGÍ QHYHOÃVEHQ YDOÍ UÃV]YÃWHO OHKHWĈVÃJÃYHO YDOÍVXOKDW PHJ

3$33

$]LQWHJU»OWRNWDW»VQHYHOÃVOHJJ\DNUDEEDQKDQJR]WDWRWWHOĈQ\HLDNÃVĈEELW»UVDGDOPL LQWHJU»FLÍ PHJNÐQQ\ÇWÃVH PHJIHOHOÃV D PDJDVDEE NÐYHWHOPÃQ\HNQHN LOOHWYH D UH»OLV ÃQNÃS ÐQÃUWÃNHOÃV NLDODNXO»V»QDN HOĈVHJÇWÃVH $] LQWHJU»OW NÐUÖOPÃQ\HN NÐ]ÐWW QHYHO NHGĈWDQXOÍIRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNHNHVHWÃEHQNLHPHOWMHOHQWĈVÃJHYDQD]ĈNHWEHIRJDGÍ NÐ]ÐVVÃJQHN+DH]W»PRJDWÍVHJÇWĈHPSDWLNXVDNNRUDIRJ\DWÃNRVV]HPÃO\J\HUPHN V]RFL»OLVDONDOPD]NRG»VDLVPHJIHOHOĈHQDODNXOKDW&6›.9›5,

$VLNHUHVEHLOOHV]NHGÃVDODSMDDEEDQDV]RFL»OLVNÐ]ÐVVÃJEHQUHMOLNDEEDQDNÐ]HJ EHQDKROPDJDDIRO\DPDW]DMOLN$IRJ\DWÃNRVHPEHUHNHVHWÃEHQLJHQJ\DNRULDNDW»U VDV NDSFVRODWRNEDQ D V]RFL»OLV LQWHUDNFLÍNEDQ MHOHQWNH]Ĉ QHKÃ]VÃJHN (]ÃUW P»U NLV LVNRO»V NRUEDQ HO NHOO NH]GHQL D V]RFL»OLV NÃV]VÃJHN NLDODNÇW»V»W IHMOHV]WÃVÃW V HUUH D]HJÃV]LVNRODLS»O\DIXW»VDODWWQDJ\KDQJVÔO\WNHOOIHNWHWQL6=(.(5(6§J\VHJÇW KHWĈ HOĈ D J\HUPHNHN V]»P»UD D V]HPÃO\NÐ]L NDSFVRODWRNEÍO V]»UPD]Í ÃOPÃQ\HN IHO GROJR]»VDDNDSFVRODWRNNLDODNÇW»VDDV]RFL»OLVDNWLYLW»VEDQYDOÍUÃV]YÃWHOÃVDNÖOÐQ IÃOHV]RFL»OLVVWUXNWÔU»NEDQYDOÍW»MÃNR]ÍG»VHJ\DU»QW0LQGH]HNHOVDM»WÇW»VDKR]]»M»UXO DJ\HUPHNHNÐQLVPHUHWÃQHNNLDODNXO»V»KR]0(67(5+›=,

$] LVNRO»EDQ D SHGDJÍJXVRN KR]]»»OO»VD D NRUW»UV FVRSRUW YLVV]DMHO]ÃVHL HOIRJDGÍ YDJ\ HOXWDVÇWÍ PDJDWDUW»VXN PLQGPLQG KR]]»M»UXOQDN D] LQWHJU»OW GL»NRN ÃQNÃSÃQHN V]HPÃO\LVÃJÃQHN DODNXO»V»KR] $E»Q»VPÍGEDQ OHNÃSH]ĈGLN D] LVNRODL ÃV D W»UVDGDOPL KLHUDUFKLDDODNXOD]ÐQÃUWÃNHOÃVÃVDNÐ]ÃU]HW6=$%­›

.XWDW»VRN EL]RQ\ÇWM»N KRJ\ ÐVV]HIÖJJÃV YDQ D] ÃQNÃS ÃV D FVRSRUWRQ EHOÖOL HOIR JDGRWWV»J NÐ]ÐWW &$0%5$r6,/9(675( 3,-/r)5267$' (] D]W MHOHQWL KRJ\

DNLNHWQHPIRJDGQDNHODWÐEEVÃJL»OWDO»QRVLVNRO»EDQDODFVRQ\DEEÐQÃUWÃNHOÃVVHOUHQ GHONH]QHN$IRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNHNRNWDW»VD»OODQGÍWÐUHNYÃVWMHOHQWDP»VV»JHOIRJDG»

V»UD ÃVHOIRJDGWDW»V»UD D] HJ\ÖWWQHYHOÃVW YÃJ]Ĉ Y»OODOÍ LQWÃ]PÃQ\HNQHN 725'$

V PLQGHQ V]HUHSOĈMÖNQHN SHGDJÍJXVRNQDN WÐEEVÃJL GL»NRNQDN V]ÖOĈNQHN HJ\DU»QW )RQWRV ILJ\HOHPPHO NÇVÃUQL VHJÇWHQL IRUP»OQL D] RV]W»O\EDQ NLDODNXOÍ NDSFVRODWRNDW H]»OWDOPDJXNDWDNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNHWKRJ\D]RNPLQGHQWDQXOÍV]»P»UDÃSÇWĈHNOHJ\HQHN

1HP]HWNÐ]LNLWHNLQWÃVD]LQWHJU»FLÍDODNXO»V»UÍO

$] DPHULNDL SHGDJÍJXVW»UVDGDORPEDQ D Q\ROFYDQDV ÃYHN YÃJÃUH D] LQWHJU»FLÍ P»U D] HJÃV] RUV]»JUD NLWHUMHGĈ PHJIHOHOĈ WÐUYÃQ\L SÃQ]ÖJ\L ÃV V]DNPDL K»WWÃUUHO UHQGHO NH]ĈUHIRUPIRO\DPDWW»Y»OW1\XJDW(XUÍS»EDQP»UDKDWYDQDVKHWYHQHVÃYHNEHQrHOĈ V]ÐUDVNDQGLQ»Y»OODPRNEDQrNH]GHWWWHUMHGQLDEHIRJDGÍQHYHOÃVJRQGRODWDD]RQEDQ FVDNDNLOHQFYHQHVÃYHNEHQNHUÖOWVRUD]LQWHJU»FLÍIRQWRVV»J»QDNWÐEEÃNHYÃVEûOWD O»QRV HOLVPHUÃVÃUH $ VDODPDQFDL NRQIHUHQFLD HUHGPÃQ\HNÃQW XW»Q IHOJ\RUVXOW D] LQWHJU»OWQHYHOÃVWHUMHGÃVH $ OLVV]DERQL IRO\DPDW FÃONLWĖ]ÃVHLYHOÐVV]KDQJEDQ NHUÖOW

(5)

!%!

DSROLWLNDLÃVV]DNPDLILJ\HOHPIÍNXV]»EDD]HJ\ÖWWQHYHOÃVD]RNWDW»VLUHQGV]HUHNPHJ ÔMÇW»V»QDNUÃV]ÃNÃQW&6›1<,

1ÃK»Q\NÖOIÐOGLJ\DNRUODWLVPHUWHWÃVÃYHOV]HUHWQÃQNDO»W»PDV]WDQLDQHP]HWNÐ]LWÐ UHNYÃVHNVRNIÃOHVÃJÃW

,QGL»EDQDIRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNHNNÐ]ÖOD]ÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVRNYDQQDNOHJQDJ\REE V]»PEDQD]»OWDO»QRVLVNRO»EDQ£SSHQH]ÃUWD]ĈÃUGHPEHQPHJYDOÍVXOÍLQWHJU»FLÍMXN D OHJIRQWRVDEE(QQHN ÃUGHNÃEHQ D] LVNRO»NEDQ DKDQJVÔO\ HJ\ VSHFL»OLV D] HJ\HVIR J\DWÃNRV J\HUPHNHNUH ÐVV]H»OOÇWRWW WDQWHUYUH KHO\H]ĈGLN DPHO\ D] ÃOHWNRUL LOOHWYH D]

ÃYIRO\DP V]HULQWL HOKHO\H]ÃVÖNHW D MHOHQOHJL J\DNRUODWWÍO HOWÃUĈHQ MDYDVROMD $ VSHFL»OLV V]ÖNVÃJOHWÖNQHN PHJIHOHOĈ IHMOHV]WÃVEHQ SHGLJ D IHMOHV]WĈ V]RE»EDQ UÃV]HVÖOQHN D J\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJXVWÍO'-.r%$/$.56+1$1

6Y»MFEDQDNDQWRQRNIHOHOĈVHNDVDM»WRVQHYHOÃVLLJÃQ\ĖWDQXOÍNRNWDW»V»ÃUWÃSSÔJ\

PLQWDWLSLNXVIHMOĈGÃVWPXWDWÍWDQXOÍNÃÃUW$]XWÍEELÃYHNEHQDdV]DEDGÔV]ÍV]DNÃUWĈNp V]»PDLVHJ\UHQÐYHNV]LNV]ROJ»ODWRNLQWÃ]PÃQ\HNQÃK»Q\PDJ»QNÃ]EHQYDQHVHWOHJ V]ÖOĈLNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNPĖNÐGWHWLNP»VHVHWEHQNÐ]LQWÃ]PÃQ\HNNDQWRQRNYDJ\KHO\LKDWÍ V»JRNIHQQWDUW»VDDO»WDUWR]QDN

$ VÃUÖOW J\HUPHNHN VSHFL»OLV LVNRO»EDQ YDJ\ D WÐEEVÃJL LVNRO»EDQ PĖNÐGĈ VSHFL»OLV RV]W»O\RNEDQ WDQXOQDN (]HN D NLVHEE OÃWV]»PÔ r OHJIHOMHEE IĈEĈO »OOÍ r NÐ]ÐVVÃJHN PÍGRVÇWRWW WDQWHUY V]HULQW KDODGQDN $ NLV V]»PEDQ MHOHQOÃYĈ LQWHJU»OW LVNRO»NDW SHGLJ DVSHFL»OLVLVNRO»NW»PRJDWM»N$O»W»VKDOO»VPR]J»VÃUWHOPLEHV]ÃGIRJ\DWÃNRVYLVHO NHGÃVLOOHWYHVÔO\RVPDJDWDUW»V]DYDUWPXWDWÍJ\HUHNHNQHNYDODPLQWDNUÍQLNXVEHWHJHN QHNNÖOÐQNÖOÐQVSHFL»OLVLVNRODWÇSXVV]ROJ»OMDD]LQWÃ]PÃQ\HVQHYHOÃVÃW($61,(

/HQJ\HORUV]»JEDQD]EHQNLDGRWWRNWDW»VLUHQGHOHWP»UWDUWDOPD]WDDIRJ\DWÃNRV J\HUPHNHNRNWDW»V»QDNQHYHOÃVÃQHNJRQGR]»V»QDNYDODPLQWD]RNWDW»VLLQWÃ]PÃQ\EH WÐUWÃQĈEHLOOHV]WÃVÃQHNPÍGMDLW$]EDQPHJMHOHQĈRNWDW»VLPLQLV]WÃULXPLUHQGHOHW SHGLJHOĈÇUWDD]LQWHJU»OÍLQWÃ]PÃQ\HNDODSÇW»V»QDNIHOWÃWHOHLWDSHGDJÍJLDLÃVSV]LFKR OÍJLDLJRQGR]»VLIRUP»NDWHJ\DU»QW*$-'$$VSHFL»OLVV]ÖNVÃJOHWHNNLHOÃJÇWÃVÃUH V]ROJ»OÍD]LQQRY»FLÍUDÃVNÇVÃUOHWH]ÃVUHÃSÖOĈVSHFL»OLVWDQWHUYEHQDV]HUYH]HWLV]HUYH ]ÃVL PÍGV]HUWDQL ÃVRNWDW»VL WHUY PHOOHWW D VSHFL»OLV RNWDW»VW YÃJ]Ĉ J\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJXVRN DONDOPD]»V»QDN ÃV PĖNÐGÃVÃQHN IHOWÃWHOHL LV UÐJ]ÇWYH YDQQDN $] LQWHJU»FLÍ IHODGDWD D] HJ\ÃQUH V]DERWW V]ÖNVÃJOHWHN ILJ\HOHPEHYÃWHOÃYHO YÃJ]HWW HJ\ÖWWQHYHOÃV D J\HUH NHNV]ÖOĈNSHGDJÍJXVRNLQWÃ]PÃQ\HNDNWÇYUÃV]YÃWHOÃYHODPHO\QHPOHKHWPĖNÐGĈ NÃSHVD]RNWDW»VSROLWLNDDJRQGRONRG»VDWDQÇW»VWDQXO»VY»OWR]»VDGLQDPLNXVHJ\P»V KR]DONDOPD]NRG»VDQÃONÖO0('<16.$

$ JÐUÐJ NÐ]QHYHOÃVEHQ D] ÃUWHOPL IRJ\DWÃNRV WDQXOÍNQDN FVDN NLV V]»]DOÃND WDQXO D WÐEEVÃJL RNWDW»VEDQ 3HGLJ D W»UVDN HOIRJDG»VD IRQWRV PHJKDW»UR]ÍMD D VLNHUHV EHLO OHV]NHGÃVQHN D V]RFL»OLV YLVV]DXWDVÇWRWWV»J SHGLJ KR]]»M»UXO ÃU]HOPL ÃV YLVHONHGÃVEHOL SUREOÃP»N NLDODNXO»V»KR] 7HK»W DIRJ\DWÃNRV J\HUPHNHN EHIRJDGÍNÐUQ\H]HWEHQ QH YHONHGÃVH SUHYHQFLÍV IXQNFLÍW LV EHWÐOW D NÃVĈEEL W»UVDGDOPL LQWHJU»FLÍ WHNLQWHWÃEHQ

*(25*,$',r.$/<9$r76$.,5,6

(6)

!%"

+D]DLIRO\DPDWRN

$]HOPÔOWÃYHNIRO\DP»QDKD]DLNÐ]QHYHOÃVLLQWÃ]PÃQ\HNEHQDVDM»WRVQHYHOÃVLLJÃQ\Ė WDQXOÍNQHYHOÃVHDVSHFL»OLVLQWÃ]PÃQ\HNEĈOQDJ\UÃV]W»WNHUÖOWDWÐEEVÃJLÍYRG»NLVNR O»N NÐUÃEH 3$33 £6 076$, 0ÇJ EHQ WÐEEVÃJL NÐ]RNWDW»VL LQWÃ]PÃQ\HLQN PLQGÐVV]HDVDM»WRVQHYHOÃVLLJÃQ\ĖWDQXOÍN»WO»WW»NHODGGLJUHP»UXN WDQXOLQWHJU»OWDQ.6+(]DY»OWR]»VD]ÍYRGDLQHYHOÃVWOÃQ\HJLOHJQHPÃULQWHWWH PHUWD]LQWHJU»OWQHYHOÃVDU»Q\DD]ÍYRGDLV]ÇQWÃUHQNRU»EEDQLVPDJDVYROWD]LVNRO»]WD W»VWYLV]RQWDQQ»OLQN»EE

$ r NÐ]ÐWW IRO\WDWRWW NXWDW»VRN HUHGPÃQ\HL 0$<(5r.ć3$7$.,1£

D]WPXWDWW»NKRJ\DOHJMREEEHIRJDGÍLQWÃ]PÃQ\HNEHQHJ\ÃUWHOPĖHONÐWHOH]HWWVÃJQ\LO Y»QXOWPHJD]LQWÃ]PÃQ\LJ\DNRUODWEDQY»OWR]RWWDWDQ»URNV]HUHSIHOIRJ»VDJD]GDJRG WDNDWDQ»ULNRPSHWHQFL»N$]LQWHJU»FLÍHUHGPÃQ\HVVÃJÃWHUĈVHQEHIRO\»VROWDDYH]HWĈL ÃVDQHYHOĈWHVWÖOHWLHONÐWHOH]HWWVÃJ

3$33 £6081.$7›56$,YL]VJ»ODW»EDQD]HJ\ÖWWQHYHOÃVEHQHUHGPÃQ\HVWÐEEVÃJL LQWÃ]PÃQ\HNWDQÇWÍLWDQ»UDLHJ\ÃQLPHJÔMXO»VLIHMOĈGÃVLOHKHWĈVÃJHNUĈOÃVD]RNV]DNPDL VLNHUNÃQWHONÐQ\YHOWPHJÃOÃVÃUĈOV]ÍOQDNDIHOWÃWHOHNÃVDNÐUQ\H]HWVHJÇWĈÃVDNDG»O\R ]Í NÖOVĈ WÃQ\H]ĈLW LV PÃUOHJHOYH $] LVNRO»NEDQ D]RQ SHGDJÍJXVRN FVRSRUWMD DNLN WD SDV]WDODWRNNDO UHQGHONH]QHN D] HJ\ÖWWQHYHOÃV PHJYDOÍVÇW»VD WHUÃQ HOLVPHUÃVW Q\HUQHN NROOÃJ»LNÃVYH]HWĈLNNÐUÃEHQÃVIHONÃV]ÖOWHQIRJDGM»ND]ÔMRQQDQÃUNH]ĈLQWHJU»ODQGÍ WDQXOÍNDW $] LQWHJU»FLÍYDO V]HPEHQ NLDODNÇWRWW »OO»VSRQW KR]]»»OO»V PHJKDW»UR]ÍEE OHKHW D VLNHUHVVÃJÃEHQ PLQW EL]RQ\RV HOĈÇU»VRN EHWDUW»VD YDJ\ PHJV]HJÃVH 0$-2526

$]LQWHJU»FLÍSR]LWÇYKDW»V»WD]LQWÃ]PÃQ\HNDJ\HUHNHNW»UVDVNDSFVRODWDLEDQÃU]LNOHJ LQN»EE )RNR]ÍGLN EHQQÖN D NÐ]ÐV ÃOPÃQ\HN V]HU]ÃVH LU»QWL Y»J\ ÃV PHJWDSDV]WDOM»N DNDSFVRODWRNEDQUHMOĈV]ÃSVÃJHWÃVVHJÇWVÃJHWH]»OWDOQĈD]ÃU]ÃNHQ\VÃJÖND]LVNROD»OOÇ WRWWDNLKÇY»VRNUDLV$ WDSDV]WDODWRND]W LV PXWDWM»NKRJ\ D] HJ\ÖWWQHYHOÃVNHUHWÃQEHOÖO DVDM»WRVQHYHOÃVLLJÃQ\ĖILDWDORNWHOMHVÇWPÃQ\HMÍYDOPDJDVDEEPLQWDV]HJUHJ»OWLQWÃ]Pà Q\HNEHQWDQXOÍNÃÃVMHOHQOÃWÖND]RV]W»O\NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQDWÐEEVÃJLWDQXOÍNUDLVNHGYH]Ĉ KDW»VVDO YDQ $ IRJ\DWÃNRV J\HUPHNHNNHO YDOÍ UHQGV]HUHV NDSFVRODW D WLSLNXV IHMOĈGÃVĖ J\HUPHNHNÃU]HOPLÃVHUNÐOFVLIHMOĈGÃVÃUHNHGYH]ĈKDW»VWJ\DNRURO6=(*›/E

9L]VJ»ODW

+LSRWÃ]LVHN

$]HQ\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNHNV]RFL»OLVLQWHJU»FLÍMDQHPDIRJ\DWÃNRVV»

JXNWÍO IÖJJ )ÖJJHWOHQÖO DWWÍO KRJ\ D YL]VJ»OW NÐ]ÐVVÃJHN dMÍQDNp YDJ\ dURVV]QDNp V]»PÇWDQDNH]HNPHJKDW»UR]»VDD0LQWDDOIHMH]HWEHQROYDVKDWÍD]LQWHJU»OWWD QXOÍNQDJ\UÃV]ÃQHNYDQNÐOFVÐQÐVNDSFVRODWDD]RV]W»O\»EDQ

725'$V]HULQWDIRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNHOIRJDGRWWV»J»WD]LQWHOOLJHQFL»MDPHO OHWWEHIRO\»VROM»N PÃJ HVHWOHJHVIHOWĖQĈ MHJ\HL NÖOVĈ PHJMHOHQÃVLNÃSH PDJDWDUW»V

(7)

!%#

PÍGMDÐQÃUWÃNHOÃVH LV (]HN D MHOOHP]ĈN D] LQWHJU»OW ÃV D VSHFL»OLV LVNRO»NEDQ HJ\

DU»QW ÃUYÃQ\HVÖOQHN 1.2//›5 D LV ÔJ\ WDO»OWD KRJ\ D FVRSRUWEDQ HOIRJODOW KHO\UHÃVDNRUW»UVDN»OWDOLHOIRJDG»VUDKDW»VVDOYDQQDNDJ\HUPHNWXODMGRQV»JDLPLQW DIL]LNDLYRQ]HUĈÃVDPDJDWDUW»V$]HOIRJDG»VHOXWDVÇW»VQHPDQQ\LUDDP»VV»JUDLQ N»EEDJ\HUPHNV]HPÃO\LVÃJÃUHYRQDWNR]LN

$]WJRQGROMXNKRJ\D]RV]W»O\IRNQÐYHNHGÃVÃYHOIRUGÇWRWWDU»Q\WPXWDWD]LQWHJU»FLÍ VLNHUHVVÃJH9DJ\LVRV]W»O\EDQKDWÃNRQ\DEED]HQ\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVGL»NRN EHLOOHV]NHGÃVHPLQWÃVRV]W»O\RVW»UVDLNÃ

$] RV]W»O\IĈQÐNÐN V]HPÃO\H DOVÍ WDJR]DWRQ PHJKDW»UR]Í KLV]HQ RWW D OHJWÐEE WDQÍU»WĈNWÐOWLNDJ\HUPHNHNNHO0$-2526$]HJ\LOOHWYHNÃWWDQÇWÍQĈLGĈEHQ ÃVWÃUEHQHJ\DU»QWQDJ\REEHUĈNHWHQHUJL»NDWWXGPR]JÍVÇWDQLHJ\NÐ]ÐVVÃJNLDOD NXO»V»QDNHOĈLOOHWYHPHJVHJÇWÃVÃEHQPLQWD]DIHOVĈVWDQ»URV]W»O\IĈQÐNDNLY»OWR ]ÍUHQGV]HUHVVÃJJHOrKHWLrDONDORPPDOrWDO»ONR]LND]RV]W»OO\DO$SHGDJÍJXVRN

»OWDO»QRVDWWLWĖGMHV]HPSRQWM»EÍOLVNÖOÐQEVÃJPXWDWNR]LND]DOVÍÃVDIHOVĈWDJR]DWRQ WHYÃNHQ\NHGĈN NÐ]ÐWW &6›1<, (QQHN WHUPÃV]HWHV RN»W D] HPHONHGĈ LVNRODL NÐYHWHOPÃQ\HNEHQDWDQNÐQ\YHNOH[LN»OLVWDUWDOP»QDNMHOHQWĈVPHJHPHONHGÃVÃEHQ D]D]RQRVRV]W»O\EDQWDQÇWÍSHGDJÍJXVRNHPHONHGĈV]»P»EDQNHUHVKHWMÖN

0LQÃONLVHEED]RV]W»O\NÐ]ÐVVÃJDQQ»ONÐQQ\HEEHQDODNXOQDNEHQQHNDSFVRODWRN

$ NLV RV]W»O\OÃWV]»P YÃGĈIDNWRU D SHUHPKHO\]HW D NLUHNHV]WHWWVÃJ HOOHQ ´J\ YÃO MÖN D MÍO PĖNÐGĈ NÐ]ÐVVÃJHN OÃWV]»PXNDW WHNLQWYH D r IĈV NLVFVRSRUWRN NÐ ]ÖONHUÖOQHNNL

6]»PRVNXWDW»VLJD]ROWDP»UKRJ\DFVRSRUWPĖNÐGÃVÃQHNMHOOHP]ĈLÐVV]HIÖJJQHN D PÃUHWÃYHO 0LQÃO WÐEEHQ YDQQDN D] RV]W»O\EDQ DQQ»O QHKH]HEE D NÐOFVÐQÐV NDS FVRODWRN NLDODNÇW»VD (] NLVHEE NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ NÐQQ\HEE r PXWDWRWW U» 6=(.(5(6r +259›7+ LV $ r IĈV NLVFVRSRUWRN WDJMDL J\DNRUL LQWHUDNFLÍEDQ YDQQDN HJ\P»VVDODONDOPDVDND]HJ\ÖWWHVPXQNDYÃJ]ÃVUHÃVRO\DQWHYÃNHQ\VÃJHNUHDKROD NÐOFVÐQÐVEL]DORPHOIRJDG»VHJ\P»VW»PRJDW»VDV]ÖNVÃJHV1.2//›5E$MÍO PĖNÐGĈFVRSRUWRNOÃWV]»PXNDWWHNLQWYHNLVFVRSRUWRN

$dMÍpÃVdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNQHPFVDNV]RFLRPHWULDLPXWDWÍLNEDQIRJQDNHOWÃUQLHJ\

P»VWÍOKDQHPDV]RFLRJUDPRNIHOUDM]RO»V»YDOPDMGHOHP]ÃVÃYHOVWUXNWXU»OLVV]HUNH ]HWLNÖOÐQEVÃJHNLVPXWDWNR]QDNNÐ]ÐWWÖN

0LQWD

$ YL]VJ»ODWL PLQW»W DEEÍO D] RUV]»JRV PLQWDYÃWHOEĈO YHWWÖN DPHO\HW 6]HNHUHV ›JRWD J\ĖMWÐWW ÃV GROJR]RWW IHO GRNWRUL GLVV]HUW»FLÍM»EDQ .XWDW»V»EDQ RO\DQ »OWDO»QRV LVNRO»NYHWWHNUÃV]WDPHO\HNEHQDRVWDQÃYEHQÃVRV]W»O\RVHQ\KÃQ ÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNHNWDQXOWDNLQWHJU»OWNÐUÖOPÃQ\HNNÐ]ÐWW

.XWDW»VXQNEDQDGRNWRULPLQWDP»VRGHOHP]ÃVÃWYÃJH]WÖNV]LJRUÔV]HPSRQWRNPHQ WÃQ$]RUV]»JRVPLQWDYÃWHOEHQV]HUHSOĈRV]W»O\RNNÐ]ÖOD]WDHWHOHPH]WÖNDPHO\HN DV]RFLRPHWULDLPXWDWÍLNFVRSRUWOÃJNÐUPXWDWÍMDW»UVDVMHOHQWĈVÃJV]RFLRPHWULDLV]HUHS

(8)

!%$

WDJROÍG»VL GLPHQ]LÍN Y»ODV]W»VL UHSHUWR»U V]ÃOL KHO\]HW PXWDWÍMD NL]»U»VL PXWDWÍ ÃV DNRKÃ]LÍVPXWDWÍNrNÐOFVÐQÐVVÃJLLQGH[VĖUĖVÃJLPXWDWÍNRKÃ]LÍVLQGH[YLV]RQ]RWW V»JLPXWDWÍDODSM»QdMÍpÃVdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNQHNV]»PÇWDQDN

$YL]VJ»ODWLPLQW»WDONRWÍRV]W»O\EDQÐVV]HVHQJ\HUPHNWDQXOILÔÃV O»Q\$]LQWHJU»OWIRJ\DWÃNRVWDQXOÍNV]»PD$PLQWDDGDWDLD]W»EO»]DWEDQLOOHWYH D]r»EU»QO»WKDWÍN

W»EO»]DW$YL]VJ»ODWLPLQWDDGDWDL

»EUD0LQWDRV]W»O\IRNV]HULQWLPHJRV]O»VD »EUD0LQWDQHPHNV]HULQWLPHJRV]O»VD

»EUD,QWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNDU»Q\DDPLQW»EDQ

(9)

!%%

0ÍGV]HU

9L]VJ»ODWXQNPÍGV]HUÃÖO0ÃUHLWÐEEV]HPSRQWÔV]RFLRPHWUL»M»WY»ODV]WRWWXNDPHO\DEH LOOHV]NHGÃVW QHP V]HPÃO\LVÃJMHJ\HNNHO KDQHP D] HJ\ÃQ W»UVDV SR]ÇFLÍM»YDO KDW»UR]]D PHJ $ YL]VJ»OW FVRSRUW WDJMDL NRQNUÃW IRQWRV ÃOHWKHO\]HWHNUH YRQDWNR]Í NÃUGÃVHNUH IHOHOQHN(]HNDY»ODV]W»VRNPHJIHOHOQHND]ÃU]HOPLYH]ÃUOÃVĖVSRQW»QNDSFVROÍG»VQDN D FVRSRUWRQ EHOÖO NLDODNXOW K»OÍ]DWUHQGV]HUQHN $ YL]VJ»OW W»UVDV PH]Ĉ Y»]ODWD D W»UVDV PH]ĈWDONRWÍNDSFVRODWRNWÃUNÃSHDV]RFLRJUDP0£5(,

0ÃUHL)HUHQFV]RFLRPHWUL»MDQHPFVDND]HJ\ÃQKHO\ÃWPXWDWMDPHJDW»UVDVPH]ĈEHQ KDQHPPDJ»WDNÐ]ÐVVÃJHWLVMHOOHP]L§J\SHGDJÍJLDLÃVV]HUYH]ÃVLWHUYH]ÃVLW»PSRQWR NDWQ\ÔMWKDWD]DGRWWFVRSRUWEDQNRQIOLNWXVRNPHJHOĈ]ÃVÃKH]DFVRSRUWNÐ]ÐVVÃJLHUHMÃ QHNIHMOHV]WÃVÃKH]0£5(,

$]DONDOPD]RWWV]RFLRPHWULDLYL]VJ»ODWFÃOM»WDNÐYHWNH]ĈNÃSSHQIRJDOPD]WXNPHJ Ɣ DV]RFLRJUDPRNV]HUNH]HWLPXWDWÍLQDNÃUWHOPH]ÃVÃYHOW»PSRQWRWDGMRQDFVRSRUW

WDJMDLQDN W»UVDV KHO\]HWÃUĈO K»OÍ]DWL SR]ÇFLÍM»UÍO NÖOÐQÐV WHNLQWHWWHO D] RV]W»

O\RNEDQWDQXOÍHQ\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVWDQXOÍNÃUD

Ɣ DYL]VJ»OWW»UVDVDODN]DWUÍOPLQWNÐ]ÐVVÃJUĈOLVNÃSHWNDSMXQNDV]RFLRJUDPRNIHO UDM]RO»V»YDO

Ɣ DV]RFLRJUDPRNRQPHJMHOHQĈDODN]DWRNWRY»EELV]HUNH]HWLPXWDWÍLQDNHOHP]ÃVÃ YHOSHGLJDdMÍpÃVdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNNÐ]ÐWWLNÖOÐQEVÃJHN»UQ\DOWDEEO»WKDWÍEE PHJUDJDG»V»UDWÐUHNHGWÖQN

$ V]RFLRPHWULDL IHOPÃUĈODSEDQ ÐW IDNWRU PHQWÃQ FVRSRUWRVÇWKDWÍ NÃUGÃV V]HUHSHOW URNRQV]HQYLY»ODV]W»VRNDWIHOWÃWHOH]ĈNÐ]ÐVVÃJLU»WHUPHWWVÃJUHYHUVHQJÃVUHIXQNFLÍUD YRQDWNR]Í HJ\ÃQL WXODMGRQV»JRNUD NÃSHVVÃJHNUH NÃV]VÃJHNUH DGRWWV»JRNUD U»NÃUGH ]Ĉ EHLOOHV]NHGÃVL QHKÃ]VÃJHNUH LU»Q\XOÍ ÃV YHUE»OLV DJUHVV]LÍW IHOWÃUNÃSH]Ĉ NÃUGÃVHN

6=(.(5(6

$] DGDWRN IHOGROJR]»VD HJ\ ZHE DODSÔ V]RIWYHUUHO D 6PHWU\YHO WÐUWÃQW 6=(.(5(6r +259›7+$V]RFLRJUDPRNIHOUDM]RO»V»KR]DrNÐOFVÐQÐVVÃJLW»EO»]DWEDQUÐJ]ÇWHWWr URNRQV]HQYLNÃUGÃVHNUHDGRWWY»ODV]RNYROWDNV]ÖNVÃJHVHN

(UHGPÃQ\HN

$V]RFLRJUDPRNDWDEEÍODV]HPSRQWEÍOYL]VJ»OWXNKRJ\PHQQ\LUHVWUXNWXU»OWD]DW»UVDV PH]ĈDPHO\HWY»]ODWRVDQ»EU»]RO(KKH]DYL]VJ»OWDODN]DWJORE»OLVPHJÇWÃOÃVHV]ÖNVÃJHV DV]HUNH]HWLPXWDWÍNVHJÇWVÃJÃYHO

$dMÍpÃVdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNV]HUNH]HWLPXWDWÍLWYDODPLQWDYLV]RQ\ÇW»VDODSM»WNÃSH ]Ĉ»WODJÃUWÃNHNHWD]DO»EELW»EO»]DWIRJODOMDÐVV]H

(10)

!%&

W»EO»]DW$NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNV]HUNH]HWLPXWDWÍL

&0PXWDWÍ

$&0FHQWU»OLVPDUJLQ»OLVPXWDWÍV]»]DOÃNEDQIHMH]LNLDW»UVDVPH]ĈNÐ]SRQWLDODN]D W»QDNYDODPLQWD]HQQHNEHIRO\»VDDO»YRQWW»UVDVÐYH]HWQHN&ÃVD]HWWĈOHONÖOÐQÇWKH WĈ SHUHPQHN 0 D] DU»Q\»W .Ð]SRQWQDN WHNLQWMÖN D] RO\DQ ]»UW DODN]DWEDQ r K»URP V]ÐJQÃJ\V]ÐJÐWV]ÐJVWErOÃYĈNHWDNLNQHNDNDSFVRODWLNÐUHVDM»WPDJ»WLVEHOHV]»

PÇWYDHOÃULDFVRSRUWHJ\QHJ\HGÃW1.2//›5F›WODJÃUWÃNHV]»]DOÃNEDQNLIH MH]YH

$dMÍpRV]W»O\NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNV]RFLRJUDPMDLEDQDNÐ]SRQWRNKR]FVDNQHPDWHOMHVFVR SRUWDNDSFVROÍGLNDPLD]WMHOHQWLKRJ\DNÐ]ÐVVÃJQHNHJ\ILJ\HOHPUHPÃOWÍUÃV]H NRPPXQLN»FLÍV FVDWRUQ»NRQ WDUWMD HJ\P»VVDO D NDSFVRODWRW $ NÐ]ÐVVÃJ WÐEEL WDJMD rDNLNQLQFVHQHNNDSFVRODWEDQDW»UVDVPH]ĈNÐ]SRQWLDODN]DW»YDOrDONRWMDDSHUHPHW (]D]DU»Q\NHGYH]ĈEEPLQW0ÃUHLÃ

$dURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNQHNV]»PÇWÍRV]W»O\RNEDQDNÐ]SRQWKR]rKDYDQHJ\»OWDO»Qr ÃVDYRQ]»VNÐU]HWÃEHWDUWR]ÍÐYH]HWKH]D]RV]W»O\RNOÃWV]»P»QDNFVXS»QDIHOHNDSFVR OÍGLN$WÐEELWDJSHUHPKHO\]HWĖPDJ»Q\RVYDJ\dS»URVHOV]LJHWHOWVÃJEHQpLOOHWYHK»

URPV]ÐJEHQYDQMHOHQ$SHUHPKHO\]HWĖHNDU»Q\»WPXWDWÍDdMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNPDUJL Q»OLVKHO\]HWEHQOÃYĈ WDQXOÍLQDNWÐEE PLQW NÃWV]HUHVHÃV D 0ÃUHLIÃOH »WODJÃUWÃNQHNLV P»VIÃOV]HUHVH$NLWHUMHGWSHUHPÐYH]HWDNÐ]ÐVVÃJQHKH]HQPR]JÍVÇWKDWÍV»J»UDDNÐ]

SRQWLPDJNLFVLEHIRO\»V»UDXWDO

$ODN]DWRN

$W»UVDVPH]ĈVWUXNWÔU»M»WD]»UWDODN]DWRNrK»URPV]ÐJQÃJ\V]ÐJÃVQDJ\REEDODN]DWr DFVLOODJRNHOUHQGH]ÃVHDO»QFRNKRVV]ÔV»JDÃVDPDJ»Q\RVRNV]»PDLVMHOOHP]L

(11)

!%'

$dMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQD]»UWDODN]DWRNGRPLQDQFL»MDILJ\HOKHWĈPHJ$]»UWDODN]DWRN DU»Q\DDV]HUYH]HWWVÃJQHNDNÐ]YÃOHPÃQ\DODNÇWÍNÃSHVVÃJQHNDIRNPÃUĈMH0£5(,

$ ]»UW DODN]DWRNKR] O»QF LV NDSFVROÍGLN DPHO\ D YÃOHPÃQ\HN WRY»EEÇW»V»W D NÐ]YÃOH PÃQ\WLOOHWYHHJ\NLVHEEHJ\VÃJ»OO»VSRQWM»QDNDNLDODNXO»V»WVHJÇWLHOĈ$NÐ]SRQWRNEÍO HO»JD]ÍFVLOODJRNV]HUHSHDV]ÃW»JD]ÍKÇUÃVYÃOHPÃQ\NÐ]OÃVEL]WRVÇW»VDOHQQHGHFVLO ODJEÍOQDJ\RQNHYÃVYDQDV]RFLRJUDPRNRQD0ÃUHLIÃOHWÍOLJHQHOPDUDGYD$

S»URV NDSFVRODWRN LOOHWYH D PDJ»Q\RVRN YLV]RQ\ODJ DODFVRQ\ V]»PD IHODGDWNÐ]SRQWÔ WHOMHVÇWÃVUHLU»Q\XOÍMÍOLU»Q\ÇWRWWQ\XJRGWOÃJNÐUĖNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNUHXWDO0LQGDPDJ»Q\R VRN PLQG D S»UEDQHOKHO\H]NHGĈN DU»Q\D NHYHVHEE D] »WODJÃUWÃNWĈO r 1DJ\REE ]»UW DODN]DWRNEDQ D] RV]W»O\NÐ]ÐVVÃJHN FVDNQHP D V]HUHSHO DPL PDJDVDQIHOÖOPÔOMDD]»WODJÃUWÃNHW

$dURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQVRNDSHULIÃUL»UDV]RUXOWWDQXOÍDPLQHPFVDNDNÐO FVÐQÐVNDSFVRODWWDOQHPUHQGHONH]ĈNHWKDQHPDS»UEDQ»OOÍNDWLVMHOHQWL$S»URV NDSFVRODWRN D] LQWLPLW»VQDN D EDU»WL NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNQHN D VRN PDJ»Q\RV V]HPÃO\ SHGLJ DNHYÃVV]ROLGDULW»VQDNDPÃUFÃMH0£5(,$PDJ»Q\RVGL»NRNRVDU»Q\DH]HN EHQD]RV]W»O\RNEDQQDJ\RQPDJDVDdMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNPDJ»Q\RVDLQDNÐWV]ÐUÐVH GHD]»WODJÃUWÃNQHNLVWÐEEPLQWNÃWV]HUHVH

»EUD$]LQWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNPHJRV]O»VDDNÖOÐQEÐ]ĈDODN]DWRNEDQDNÐ]ÐVVÃJHN V]RFLRJUDPMDLEDQ

$] RV]W»O\RNEDQ LQWHJU»OWDQ WDQXOÍ HQ\KÃQ ÃUWHOPL IRJ\DWÃNRV J\HUPHNHN SR]ÇFLÍM»W LV ÃUGHPHVPHJQÃ]QLDdMÍpÃVdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ6]HPEHWĖQĈDNÖOÐQEVÃJPÇJDdMÍp NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNLQWHJU»OWWDQXOÍLQDNDOHJDO»EEHJ\NÐOFVÐQÐVNDSFVRODWWDOUHQGHONH]LN ÃV XN PDJ»Q\RV DGGLJ D dURVV]p RV]W»O\NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ FVXS»Q XN V]HUYHV UÃV]H RV]W»O\»QDN $ QDJ\REELN UÃV]ÖN YDJ\ HJ\HGÖO YDJ\ HJ\ P»VLN WDQXOÍYDO HJ\ÖWW S»UEDQ NHUÖOW SHUHPKHO\]HWEH $ O»QFEDQ HOKHO\H]NHGĈN DU»Q\D LVQDJ\

(12)

!%(

NÖOÐQEVÃJHWPXWDWDdMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNIRJ\DWÃNRVGL»NMDLQDNDPÇJDdURVV]pNÐ]ÐV VÃJHNEHQFVDNXNWDUWR]LNO»QFKR]D]LQIRUP»FLÍNDWKRUGR]ÍÃVD]RV]W»O\WPR]JÍ VÇWÍHJ\VÃJKH]

9DOÍM»EDQ DK»URPV]ÐJHW DONRWÍNVHP NDSFVROÍGQDNEH D NÐ]ÐVVÃJ ÃOHWÃEHKLV]HQ NÖOÐQNLVV]LJHWHWNÃSH]QHNVDM»WÃUGHNOĈGÃVLNÐUÖNHWQÃ]ĈSRQWMXNDWV]RN»VDLNDWNÃSYL VHOYHrDWÐEELHNWĈOHONÖOÐQÖOYHdPĖNÐGQHNp

6]HUNH]HWLWÇSXVRN

.LDODNÇWRWWXQNHJ\»OWDO»QRVNÃSHWDV]RFLRJUDPRNVHJÇWVÃJÃYHODPHO\D]RV]W»O\NÐ]ÐVVÃ JHNV]HUNH]HWÃWLJ\HNV]LNPHJUDJDGQL$V]HUNH]HWLWÇSXVRNDNÐYHWNH]ĈNKDOPD]OD]D HJ\NÐ]SRQWÔWÐPEÃVWÐEENÐ]SRQWÔV]HUNH]HW0£5(,$IHMOĈGÃVLVRUEDUHQGH]HWW ÐWWÇSXVHONÖOÐQÇWÃVHD]DODN]DWRNIHMOHWWVÃJÃQHNÃUHWWVÃJÃQHNDPHJÇWÃOÃVHV]HPSRQWM»EÍO IRQWRV$MHOHQYL]VJ»ODWEDQUÃV]WYHYĈRV]W»O\RNV]HUNH]HWLWÇSXVDLWD]»EUDWDUWDOPD]]D

»EUD$NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNV]HUNH]HWLWÇSXVDLGE

$ dMÍp NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNUH D WÐPE ÃV WÐEENÐ]SRQWÔ V]HUNH]HW MHOOHP]Ĉ PLYHO D] RV]W»O\RN WDJMDLQDNOHJQDJ\REEUÃV]H]»UWDODN]DWEDQKHO\H]NHGLNHOPHO\HWPHO\HNHWFVLOODJRNÃV O»QFRN IĖ]QHN K»OÍ]DWED .ÐOFVÐQÐVVÃJL LQGH[ÖN »WODJD VĖUĖVÃJL PXWDWÍMXN IÐOÐWWL ,O\HQ SDUDPÃWHUHNNHO D MÍO V]HUYH]HWW MÍO PĖNÐGĈ FVRSRUWRN UHQGHONH]QHN$ YL]VJ»OWdMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNNÐ]ÖO»EU»]RONHWWĈWDÃV»EUD$V]RFLRJUDPRNRQDNÃN V]ÇQD]LQWHJU»OWILÔDSLURVV]ÇQD]LQWHJU»OWO»Q\WDQXOÍNDWMHOÐOL

(13)

!%)

»EUDd-ÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJV]RFLRJUDPMD

»EUDd-ÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJV]RFLRJUDPMD

(14)

!&

$ dURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNQÃO OD]D ÃV HJ\NÐ]SRQWÔ V]HUNH]HW GRPLQ»OGH OÃWH]LN HJ\r NÐ ]ÐVVÃJQHNDOLJQHYH]KHWĈrKDOPD]V]HUNH]HWĖRV]W»O\LV$NÐOFVÐQÐVVÃJLLQGH[HNr NÐ]ÐWW V]ÍUÍGQDN ÃV VĖUĖVÃJL PXWDWÍLN LV D] »WODJRV ÃUWÃN DODWW KHO\H]NHGQHN HO ,O\HQ VWUXNWÔU»N D] ÃUHWOHQ NÐ]ÐVVÃJHN MHOOHP]ĈL 5RVV] NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNUH PXWDW SÃOG»W DÃV»EUD

»EUD5RVV]NÐ]ÐVVÃJV]RFLRJUDPMD

»EUD5RVV]NÐ]ÐVVÃJV]RFLRJUDPMD

(15)

!&!

,QWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNDNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ

9ÃJÖODV]RFLRJUDPRNVHJÇWVÃJÃYHODNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQOÃYĈNDSFVRODWRNDWIRJODOMXNÐVV]H NLHPHOYHD]LQWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNDGDWDLW

$dMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQWDQXOÍGL»NRNDUHQGHONH]LNNÐOFVÐQÐVNDSFVRODWWDOÃV XN PDJ»Q\RV »EUD $ dURVV]p NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ D] DU»Q\ URVV]DEE DQQDN HOOHQÃUH KRJ\NHYHVHEEWDQXOÍM»UD]RV]W»O\RNEDNLVHEED]RV]W»O\RNOÃWV]»PD$»EUDV]HP OÃOWHWL H]HNEHQ D NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ D NÐOFVÐQÐV NDSFVRODWRN LOOHWYH D NDSFVRODWWDO QHPUHQGHONH]ĈPDJ»Q\RVRNDU»Q\»W

»EUD.DSFVRODWRNDU»Q\D »EUD.DSFVRODWRNDU»Q\D

dMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ DURVV]NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ

7RY»EEERQWYDDPDJ»Q\RVWDQXOÍNDWD]WO»WKDWMXND»EU»QKRJ\DSHULIÃUL»QOÃYĈN PDMGQHP IHOÃW D] LQWHJU»OW WDQXOÍN WHV]LN NL D dMÍp RV]W»O\NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ ,JD] KRJ\

DPDJ»Q\RVRNDU»Q\DD]ÐVV]OÃWV]»PRWWHNLQWYHNHGYH]ĈQHNLNYLV]RQWD D]RV]W»O\RNEDQWDQXOÍHQ\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNO»VGNRU»EEDQDYL]VJ»OW PLQW»EDQNÐ]ÖONHUÖONL

$»EUDPXWDWMDKRJ\DdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNPDJ»Q\RVKHO\]HWEHQOÃYĈWDQXOÍLQDN DD]RV]W»O\RNEDQLQWHJU»OWDQWDQXOÍIRJ\DWÃNRVGL»NO»VGNRU»EEDQDYL]V J»OWPLQW»EDQYDODPHO\LNH

$ YL]VJ»OW NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ MHOHQ OÃYĈ PDJ»Q\RV IRJ\DWÃNRV ÃV WÐEEVÃJL J\HUPHNHN V]»P»WD»EU»UÍOROYDVKDWMXNOH$]ÐVV]HVHQPDJ»Q\RVNÐ]ÖOIĈD]HJ\ÖWWQH YHONHGĈHQ\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVWDQXOÍIĈSHGLJDWÐEEVÃJLGL»NRNNÐ]ÖONHUÖOWNL

$]W LVO»WKDWMXNKRJ\ D NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ WDQXOÍ ÐVV]HVHQ LQWHJU»OW J\HUPHN O»VG NR U»EEDQDYL]VJ»OWPLQW»EDQNÐ]ÖOPDJ»Q\RV

(16)

!&"

»EUD0DJ»Q\RVRNV]»PDDNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQIĈ

$ PDJ»Q\RV IRJ\DWÃNRV WDQXOÍEÍO ILÔ ÃV O»Q\$ dMÍp NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNQÃOQLQFVQDJ\

NÖOÐQEVÃJDV]»PXNEDQGHHOHYHNHYHVHQLVYDQQDN$QHPHNNÐ]WLNÖOÐQEVÃJDdURVV]p NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQV]»PRWWHYĈDPDJ»Q\RVO»Q\RNK»URPV]RUDQQ\LDQYDQQDNPLQWDPD J»Q\RVILÔN$»EU»QMÍONLYHKHWĈHND]LPÃQWHPOÇWHWWDGDWRN

»EUD0DJ»Q\RVLQWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNQHPHNV]HULQWLPHJRV]O»VDIĈ

2V]W»O\IRNV]HULQWV]HPOÃOYHDPDJ»Q\RVLQWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNDWD]WO»WKDWMXND»EU»QKRJ\

RV]W»O\EDQ YDQQDN D OHJWÐEEHQ $ dMÍp NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ NLHJ\HQOÇWHWWHEE D] DU»Q\XN GHDdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQGXSO»MDDRV]W»O\RVPDJ»Q\RVRNV]»PDDLOOHWYH RV]W»O\RVRNÃQDN

(17)

!&#

»EUD0DJ»Q\RVLQWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNRV]W»O\IRNV]HULQWLPHJRV]O»VDIĈ

8WÍEELHOHP]ÃVEĈOPHJ»OODSÇWKDWÍKRJ\DdMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQQDJ\REEDNÐOFVÐQÐVNDS FVRODWRNÃVNLVHEEDPDJ»Q\RVRNV]»PDPLQWDdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ$PDJ»Q\RVLQ WHJU»OWWDQXOÍNWÐEEV]HPSRQWÔYL]VJ»ODW»EÍOSHGLJNLWĖQLNKRJ\DdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHN RV]W»O\DLEDM»UÍO»Q\RNYDQQDNDOHJURVV]DEEV]RFLRPHWULDLNÐ]ÐVVÃJLKHO\]HWEHQNÐ]ÖOÖN

$ O»Q\RNUD D NHYHVHEEGH LQWHQ]ÇYHEEEDU»WV»J D ILÔNUD D QDJ\REE OÃWV]»PÔ LQN»EE DFVRSRUW»OWDONÐ]YHWÇWHWWÃUWÃNHNHQDODSXOÍW»UVDVNDSFVRODWDMHOOHP]Ĉ$ILÔNFVRSRUW MDLUDMHOOHP]ĈEEDKLHUDUFKLDDYH]HWĈGLUHNWLU»Q\ÇWÍV]HUHSH1.2//›5D$ILÔN ÃVO»Q\RNHOWÃUĈLQWHUDNFLÍVVWÇOXVDDILÔNGRPLQDQFL»M»WDO»Q\RNDO»UHQGHOĈGÃVÃWHUHG PÃQ\H]L)/$66´

+LSRWÃ]LVHNEHY»O»V»QDNYL]VJ»ODWD

9L]VJ»ODWXQNHOHMÃQ QÃJ\KLSRWÃ]LVWIRJDOPD]WXQN PHJ.Ð]ÖOÖNNHWWĈ MÍO O»WKDWÍ HUHG PÃQ\HNEHQUHDOL]»OÍGRWWNHWWĈSHGLJUÃV]EHQLJD]ROÍGRWWEH

$]HOVĈIHOWHYÃVÖQND]YROWKRJ\D]HQ\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNHNV]RFL»OLV LQWHJU»FLÍMDQHPDIRJ\DWÃNRVV»JXNWÍOIÖJJ)ÖJJHWOHQÖODWWÍOKRJ\DYL]VJ»OWNÐ]ÐV VÃJHN dMÍQDNp YDJ\ dURVV]QDNp V]»PÇWDQDN D] LQWHJU»OW WDQXOÍN QDJ\ UÃV]ÃQHN YDQ NÐOFVÐQÐVNDSFVRODWDD]RV]W»O\»EDQ

$PHJILJ\HOWK»URPNÖOÐQEÐ]ĈÃYIRO\DPKR]WDUWR]ÍWHUÖOHWLOHJÃVV]RFL»OLVV]RFLR NXOWXU»OLVV]HPSRQWEÍOLVHOWÃUĈLVNRO»NWDQXOÍLWWHNLQWYHNLWĖQLNKRJ\D]LQWHJU»OWJ\HU PHNHNW»UVDVSR]ÇFLÍLQHPPXWDWQDNHOWÃUÃVWDWÐEEVÃJLJ\HUPHNHNÃLKH]NÃSHVWEHLO OHV]NHGÃVÖN»OWDO»EDQVLNHUHVQHNPRQGKDWÍ0DJ\DU»]DWDOHKHWDJ\HUPHNNÐ]ÐVVÃJHN UHDYL]VJ»OWÃOHWNRUEDQMHOOHP]ĈÃUWÃNUHQGÃVD]H]HQDODSXOÍY»ODV]W»VDLNV]HPÃO\HV V]LPS»WL»QDODSXOÍGRPLQDQFL»MD$]HQ\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVLQWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNÃSSÔJ\

YRQ]ÍDNOHKHWQHNDNÐ]ÐVVÃJÖNEHQMÍNDSFVRODWWHUHPWÃVLNÃSHVVÃJÖNEDU»WV»JRVV»JXN

(18)

!&$

ÃUGHNOĈGÃVÖNNHGÃO\ÖNNÖOVĈPHJMHOHQÃVÖNDODSM»QPLQWWÐEEVÃJLRV]W»O\W»UVDLN

$]HOIRJDG»VÃVDNLUHNHV]WÃVWDSDV]WDODWXQNV]HULQWDNLVNDPDV]NRUEDQWÐEEQ\LUH LQN»EEV]LWXDWÇYDNRQIOLNWXVRNUÐYLGHEEOH]DMO»VÔDNQHPMHOOHP]ĈDKDUDJWDUW»VLQ N»EEDIRO\DPDWRVNÐWÐ]NÐGÃVGHDdFÃOSRQWpVRNV]RUY»OWR]Í1HIHOHGNH]]ÖQNPHJ DUUÍOVHPKRJ\HEEHQDNRUEDQPÃJQHPRO\DQPDJDVDJ\HUPHNHNLQGLYLGX»OLVWR OHUDQFLDNÖV]ÐEHKRJ\D]WHJ\LQWHJU»OWW»UVXNdQHXJUDQ»»Wp

0»VRGLN KLSRWÃ]LVÖQN r PLV]HULQW RV]W»O\EDQ VLNHUHVHEE OHV] D] HQ\KÃQ ÃUWHOPL IRJ\DWÃNRVWDQXOÍNEHLOOHV]NHGÃVHPLQWÃVRV]W»O\EDQrUÃV]EHQLJD]RO»VWQ\HUW

$YL]VJ»ODWWDQÔV»JDV]HULQWDdMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNDDRV]W»O\RNEÍODdURVV]pNÐ ]ÐVVÃJHNDSHGLJDRV]W»O\RNEÍOWHYĈGLNÐVV]H$]RV]W»O\RNDU»Q\DD]RQ EDQPLQGNÃWHVHWEHQ

0LÃUWLO\HQMHOHQWĈVDdMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNDU»Q\DDÃYIRO\DPRQÃVPLWÐUWÃQLNRV]

W»O\UDDJ\HUHNHNNHO"(UUHDNÃUGÃVUHDIHOWHYÃVÖQNHWLQGRNROÍNRU»EELNXWDW»VRNRQ NÇYÖOQÃK»Q\VDM»WWDSDV]WDODWRWLVPDJ\DU»]DWNÃQWHPOÇWÖQN6]HULQWÖQNNÃWIRQWRVWÃ Q\H]Ĉ D D WDQÇWÍQĈN D dNHYÃVSHGDJÍJXVRVV»Jp E D J\HUPHNL dVRUVNÐ]ÐVVÃJ Y»OODO»VpUHMOLNDWÃQ\HNPÐJÐWW

D$]D]HJ\LOOHWYHNÃWWDQÇWÍQĈDNLDJ\HUPHNHWrD]LVNRO»EDQWÐOWÐWWLGĈQDJ\

UÃV]ÃEHQ r WDQÇWMDÍYMDYLJ\»]]DILJ\HOL LGĈEHQ ÃV WÃUEHQ HJ\DU»QW QDJ\REE HUĈNHW HQHUJL»NDW WXG PR]JÍVÇWDQL HJ\ NÐ]ÐVVÃJ NLDODNXO»V»QDN HOĈ LOOHWYH PHJVHJÇWÃVÃEHQ PLQW D] D WDQ»U DNL Y»OWR]Í UHQGV]HUHVVÃJJHO KHWL r DOND ORPPDO WDO»ONR]LN D] RV]W»OO\DO 7ÐEE ÃV DODSRVDEE ILJ\HOHP LU»Q\XO HJ\HJ\

J\HUPHNUHWLV]W»EEDQÃVQ\ÇOWDEEDQÃU]ÃNHOKHWĈÃVÃUWÃNHOKHWĈD]RV]W»O\NDS FVRODWUHQGV]HUHÃVPÃJMXWKDWLGĈDFVDSDWÃSÇWÃVUHLVNÐ]ÐVM»WÃND]XGYDURQ KRVV]DEEUÐYLGHEE VÃW»N NLU»QGXO»VRN NÐ]ÐV ÖQQHSHN dIHO»OGR]RWWp WDQÍU»N HJ\HJ\NRQIOLNWXVYDJ\WUDXPDD]RQQDOLNH]HOÃVÃUHIHV]ÖOWVÃJHNdYLOO»PK»UÇW»

V»UDp$V]DE»O\R]RWWV»JUDDNÐ]ÐVWHYÃNHQ\VÃJHNÃVD]ÃULQWNH]ÃVMÍ]DQUHQGMà UHQHPFVDNDQHYHOĈWDUWLJÃQ\WKDQHPY»J\QDNHUUHDWDQXOÍNLV-›5­

E$J\HUPHNLdVRUVNÐ]ÐVVÃJY»OODO»VpDODWWOHJIĈNÃSSHQD]WÃUWMÖNKRJ\DIHQWL HNKH]YDOÍDONDOPD]NRG»VLOOHV]NHGÃVNLYÃWHOQÃONÖOPLQGHQJ\HUPHNV]»P»UD IRQWRV$J\HUPHNHNV]HPÃEHQD]RV]W»O\IĈQÐNWDQÇWÍÃSSHQV]HUYH]HWLSR]Ç FLÍM»Q»OIRJYDD]DKLYDWDORVV]HPÃO\DNLD]LVNRODLNÐYHWHOPÃQ\HNQHNOHJNÐ]

YHWOHQHEENÃSYLVHOĈMHÃVÃUYÃQ\HVÇWĈMH-›5­$WDQÇWÍV]HUHWHWHDKR]]»

ÃVVWÇOXV»KR]PÍGV]HUHLKH]YDOÍDONDOPD]NRG»VDYHOHYDOÍFÃOV]HUĖNRPPX QLN»FLÍPHJWDQXO»VDÃVIHQQWDUW»VDPLQGDQQ\LXNEDQrWÐEEVÃJLÃVLQWHJU»OWWD QXOÍNEDQHJ\DU»QWrDODSYHWĈLJÃQ\

$ UÃV]EHQ YDJ\ WHOMHVHQ LVPHUHWOHQ J\HUPHNHNNHO YDOÍ HJ\ÖWWPĖNÐGÃV D]HJ\ÃQLVW»WXV]RNPHJWDO»O»VDÃVPHJWDUW»VDDNÐ]ÐVVÃJEHQD]HOKDQJ]ÍLQ IRUP»FLÍNEHIRJDG»VDV]LQWÃQPLQGHQNLQHNHJ\IRUP»QOÃQ\HJHV.Ð]ÐVHNDFà ORNÃVYDJ\NÐ]ÐVHNDFVHOHNYÃVLLQGÇWÃNRND]HJ\ÖWWHVWHYÃNHQ\VÃJDV]HPà O\HVNDSFVRODWÃVNÐOFVÐQÐVIÖJJÃV1.2//›5ENÐ]ÐVVÃJDODNÇW»VUDLOOHW YH DQQDN Y»OODO»V»UD ÐV]WÐQ]L D] HJ\ RV]W»O\ED M»UÍ DOVÍ WDJR]DWRV GL»NRNDW

$rÃYHVJ\HUPHNHNHWD]HVHWHNWÔOQ\RPÍWÐEEVÃJÃEHQEL]RQ\RVIRNÔNRQ IRUPL]PXV WHNLQWÃO\WLV]WHOHW MHOOHP]L 6]LJRUÔDQ HOÇWÃOLN D]RNDW DNLN YÃWHQHN

(19)

!&%

D V]DE»O\ HOOHQ $] LVNRO»VNRU NH]GHWÃQ D] DOVÍ WDJR]DWEDQ D J\HUHNHN QHP NÃUGĈMHOH]LNPHJDV]DE»O\RNDWV]»PXNUDDV]DE»O\RNQDNPÃJDEV]ROÔWÃUYÃ Q\HYDQMÍYDOKDMODPRVDEEDNDSHGDJÍJXVVDOYDOÍORMDOLW»VUD9$-'$

$IHOVĈWDJR]DWEDQrMHOHQHVHWEHQRV]W»O\EDQrD]RV]W»O\IĈQÐNYDQHVHWHQNÃQW DOHJNHYHVHEELGĈWD]RV]W»O\»YDO,WWP»UDNXGDUFRULHQW»OWILDWDORNWDQXO»VL]DYDUD PHOOÃ W»UVXOQDN LGĈQNÃQW HJÃV]HQ NRPRO\ PDJDWDUW»V ÃV YLVHONHGÃV]DYDURN LV (]HNNH]HOÃVHD]RV]W»O\IĈQÐNÐNIHODGDWDLVDPLEHQDJ\RQJ\RUVDQEHOHI»VXOQDN OHPRQGDQDNDJ\HUPHNUĈOQHPKDMODQGÍNVHJÇWHQL0$-2526$YDODPLO\HQ V]HPSRQWEÍO SUREOÃP»V GL»NQDN QHP IRQWRV HJ\ NÐ]ÐV FÃO YDJ\ IHODGDWPHJRO G»V(]HNDGROJRNVHPPLNÃSSHQQHPDNÐ]ÐVVÃJLÃU]ÃVDNÐ]ÐVVÃJÃUWWHQQLDND U»VHUĈVÐGÃVHDVLNHUHVDONDOPD]NRG»VEHLOOHV]NHGÃVIHOÃYH]HWQHN

$]WJRQGROWXNKRJ\NLVHEEOÃWV]»PÔRV]W»O\NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQNÐQQ\HEEHQDODNXOQDN NDSFVRODWRN NHYHVHEE EHQQÖN D SHULIÃUL»UD V]RUXOW WDQXOÍN V]»PD )HOWÃWHOH]WÖN KRJ\DdMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNDrIĈWV]»PO»OÍRV]W»O\RNEÍONHUÖOQHNNL$]EHLJD]ROÍ GRWW KRJ\ D dMÍp NÐ]ÐVVÃJHN D NLVFVRSRUWRNDW NÃSYLVHOLN IĈV »WODJRV OÃWV]»PXN DODSM»QGHDdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNLVHEEHDNDWHJÍUL»EDWDUWR]QDN6ĈWRV]W»O\OÃWV]»

PDLN»WODJDPÃJNHYHVHEEDdMÍpNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNÃLQÃOPLQGÐVV]HIĈ

(]DUUDHQJHGNÐYHWNH]WHWQLKRJ\DVLNHUHVLQWHJU»FLÍQDND]HQ\KÃQÃUWHOPLIR J\DWÃNRV J\HUPHNHN EHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃQHN QHP REOLJ»W IHOWÃWHOH D NLV RV]W»O\OÃWV]»P

$]WLVMHOHQWLKRJ\DNLVOÃWV]»PÔFVRSRUWRNEDQQHPIHOWÃWOHQÖODODNXOQDNMÍODNDS FVRODWRN QHPFVDN D] LQWHJU»OWWÐEEVÃJL GH D WÐEEVÃJLWÐEEVÃJL WDQXOÍN NÐ]ÐWW VHP ÃVQHPLVEL]WRVKRJ\NÐ]ÐVVÃJJÃIRUP»OÍGQDNWDJMDL(J\URVV]XOPĖNÐGĈRV]W»O\

EDQQHPDIRJ\DWÃNRVGL»NRNNHYÃVNDSFVRODWDLOOHWYHD]RNKL»Q\DGRPLQ»OKLV]HQ D]YRQDWNR]LNPLQGHQWDQXOÍUD1HPFVDNIRJ\DWÃNRVV»JPLDWWOHKHWYDODNLPHOOĈ]ÐWW PDJ»Q\RV HJ\ NÐ]ÐVVÃJEHQ QHP D IRJ\DWÃNRVV»J WÃQ\H D GÐQWĈ r KD D NÐ]ÐVVÃJ URVV]PLQGHQNLV]»P»UDURVV]OHJ\HQDWDQXOÍVDM»WRVQHYHOÃVLLJÃQ\ĖYDJ\WLSLNXV IHMOĈGÃVĖ(]PHJHUĈVÇWLD]KLSRWÃ]LVW

$V]RFLRPHWULDLYL]VJ»ODWP»VRGLNUÃV]ÃWĈOD]WY»UWXNKRJ\DV]RFLRJUDPRNIHOUDM]RO»

V»YDOO»WKDWÍY»WHJ\HDV]»PRNEDQNLIHMH]HWWHUHGPÃQ\HNHWDdMÍpÃVdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃ JHNNÐ]WLNÖOÐQEVÃJHNHW(]PHJYDOÍVXOWKLV]HQMÍOO»WKDWÍHJ\P»VWÍOMHOHQWĈVHQHO WÃUĈV]HUNH]HWLVWUXNWÔU»NMHOOHP]LNĈNHW

$dMÍpRV]W»O\NÐ]ÐVVÃJHNrDIHMOĈGÃVLVRUEDQHOÐOHOKHO\H]NHGĈrWÐPEÃVWÐEE NÐ]SRQWÔV]HUNH]HWWHOUHQGHONH]QHNPHO\HNDMÍONRRSHU»OÍNÐ]ÐVIHODGDWRNYÃJUH KDMW»V»UDVRNHJ\ÖWWHVÃOPÃQ\PHJÃOÃVÃUHKLYDWRWWNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNVDM»WMDL7DJMDLULWN»Q FVDN S»UEDQ WÐEEHQ O»QFEDQ ÃV D WDJRN QDJ\ UÃV]H ]»UW DODN]DWRNEDQ NDSFVROÍGLN HJ\P»VKR](EEHQDRV]W»O\EDQPLQGÐVV]HGL»NQDNQLQFVNÐOFVÐQÐVNDSFVROD WDNÐ]ÖOÖNLQWHJU»OW$WÐEELIRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNV]HUYHVUÃV]HRV]W»O\»QDN

$ dURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNEHQ D OD]D ÃV HJ\NÐ]SRQWÔ FVRSRUWV]HUNH]HWGRPLQ»O DPL QHPNHGYH]VHPWDJMDLQDNVHPDNÐ]ÐVWHYÃNHQ\VÃJHNQHN(]HNÃUHWOHQNOLNNHNEĈO HJ\P»VWÍO HOV]LJHWHOWHQ MHOHQ OÃYĈ NLV FVRSRUWRVXO»VRNEÍO YDODPLQW HJ\ NÐ]SRQWEÍO

»OOÍ NÐ]ÐVVÃJHN.HGYH]ĈWOHQ IHOÃSÇWÃVÖN ÃV PĖNÐGÃVÖN PHJPXWDWNR]LN D] PD J»Q\RVGL»NV]»P»EDQLVDNLNNÐ]ÖOHQ\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRV$]LQWHJU»OWWDQX OÍNQDNÃSSHQDQQ\LUDQHPLGH»OLVH]DFVRSRUWOÃJNÐUPLQWWÐEEVÃJLW»UVDLNQDN

(20)

!&&

$YL]VJ»ODWEDQrDV]»PRNPXWDWWDÃUWÃNHNDODSM»QrDNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNUĈONLDODNXOWNÃSPHJ IHOHODQQDNDPLWD]HJ\HVNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNK»OÍ]DW»QDV]RFLRJUDPRNRQO»WXQN

°VV]HJ]ÃV

$dMÍpÃVdURVV]pNÐ]ÐVVÃJHNWXODMGRQV»JDLQDNV]HUNH]HWÃQHNÃVPĖNÐGÃVÃQHNHOHP]ÃVH KDV]QRVWDSDV]WDODWRNNDOV]ROJ»OWQHPFVDND]HQ\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVWDQXOÍNLQWHJ U»FLÍMDKDQHPDWÐEEVÃJLWDQXOÍNV]HPSRQWM»EÍOLV6HJÇWVÃJHWQ\ÔMWRWWD]RV]W»O\RNEDQ YÃJEHPHQĈIRO\DPDWRN»UQ\DOWDEEV]HPOÃOÃVÃKH]DJ\HUPHNHNNÐ]ÐWWNLDODNXOWNDSFVR ODWRNPHJÃUWÃVÃKH](]HQNÇYÖOV]HPOÃOHWHWDGRWWDFVRSRUWRNDODNÇW»V»KR]VWUXNWÔU»MXN RSWLP»OLVDEE»WÃWHOÃKH]YDODPLQWDV]XEMHNWÇYFVRSRUWSUREOÃP»NÃVDV]HPÃO\HVNRQIOLN WXVRN PHJROG»V»KR] $ V]RFLRPHWULD MÍO KDV]Q»OKDWÍKDV]QRVÇWKDWÍ PÍGV]HU PLQGHQ SHGDJÍJXVQDNrNÖOÐQÐVHQLQWHJU»FLÍEDQRNWDWÍNQDNrVDM»WPXQN»MXNPHJNÐQQ\ÇWÃVÃ UHD]HJ\ÖWWQHYHONHGĈGL»NRNEHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃQHNVHJÇWÃVÃUHSHGDJÍJLDLKDWÃNRQ\V»JXN QÐYHOÃVÃUHHJ\DU»QW

,URGDORPMHJ\]ÃN

&$0%5$&r6,/9(675(16WXGHQWVZLWKVSHFLDOHGXFDWLRQDOQHHGVLQWKHLQFOXVLYHFODVVURRP VRFLDOLQWHJUDWLRQDQGVHOIFRQFHSW(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI6SHFLDO1HHGV(GXFDWLRQ9RO 1Rr

&6›.9›5,-V]HUN,QNOX]ÇYQHYHOÃVr$M»QO»VRNÃUWHOPLOHJDNDG»O\R]RWWJ\HUPHNHNWDQX OÍN NRPSHWHQFLD DODSÔ IHMOHV]WÃVÃKH] 6]RFL»OLV ÃOHWYLWHOL ÃV NÐUQ\H]HWL NRPSHWHQFL»N 6XOL1RYD.KW%XGDSHVW

&6›1<,<,QWHJU»FLÍÃVLQNOÔ]LÍ1HP]HWNÐ]LÃVKD]DLNÐUNÃS,Q*,5$6(.-V]HUN,QNOX ]ÇYQHYHOÃVr$WDQXOÍNKDWÃNRQ\PHJLVPHUÃVH6XOLQRYD.KW%XGDSHVWr

'-.&r%$/$.5,6+1$1- ,QFOXVLYH (GXFDWLRQ IRU 6WXGHQWV ZLWK ,QWHOOHFWXDO 'LVDELOLW\

rKWWSGFLGMRUJDUWLFOHYLHZ/HWÐOWÃVLGHMHMÔOLXV

(8523($1$*(1&<)2563(&,$/1(('6$1',1&/86,9(('8&$7,21($61,(V]Q6SHFLDO1HHGV (GXFDWLRQZLWKLQWKH(GXFDWLRQ6\VWHPr6ZLW]HUODQG

KWWSVZZZHXURSHDQDJHQF\RUJFRXQWU\LQIRUPDWLRQVZLW]HUODQGQDWLRQDORYHUYLHZVSHFLDO QHHGVHGXFDWLRQZLWKLQWKHHGXFDWLRQV\VWHP

)/$66´=6$]LVNRO»EDQPHJILJ\HOKHWĈSV]LFKROÍJLDLQHPLNÖOÐQEVÃJHNÃVKDVRQOÍV»JRN ,Q1.2//›5.r6=$%­£V]HUN3V]LFKROÍJLDSHGDJÍJXVRNQDN2VLULV.LDGÍ%XGDSHVW r

),6&+(5*$]LQWHJU»FLÍYDONDSFVRODWRVDWWLWĖGÐNNXWDW»VD*\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJLDL6]HPOHr

*$-'$0S\DńRV]NROęLQWHJUDF\MQą,QWHJUDFMD

*(25*,$',0r.$/<9$(r76$.,5,69<RXQJ&KLOGUHQnV$WWLWXGHV7RZDUG3HHUVZLWK,QWHO OHFWXDO'LVDELOLWLHV(IIHFWRIWKH7\SHRI 6FKRRO-RXUQDO RI $SSOLHG 5HVHDUFK LQ ,QWHOOHFWXDO 'LVDELOLWLHVr

KWWSZZZDFDGHPLDHGX<RXQJB&KLOGUHQBVB$WWLWXGHVB7RZDUGB3HHUVBZLWKB,QWHO OHFWXDOB'LVDELOLWLHVB(IIHFWBRIBWKHB7\SHBRIB6FKRRO/HWÐOWÃVLGHMHMÔOLXV

(21)

!&'

.6+V]Q2NWDW»VLDGDWRN6WDWLV]WLNDL7ÖNÐU

KWWSZZZNVKKXGRFVKXQ[IWSLGRV]DNLRNWDWRNWDWDVSGI/HWÐOWÃV LGHMH V]HSWHPEHU

-›5­.6]ÐYHWVÃJEHQDNÐ]ÐVVÃJJHO,Q0£6=›526$V]HUN$]LVNRODV]RFL»OSV]LFKROÍ JLDLMHOHQVÃJYLO»JD(/7((ÐWYÐV.LDGÍ%XGDSHVWr

0$<(5-r.ć3$7$.,1£0£6=›5260V]HUN$V]DYDNÃVDWHWWHN6DM»WRVQHYHOÃVLLJÃQ\Ė WDQXOÍN D NÐ]RNWDW»VEDQ D V]»]DG HOVĈ ÃYWL]HGÃEHQ 0DJ\DURUV]»JRQ 2NWDW»VNXWDWÍ ÃV)HMOHV]WĈ,QWÃ]HW%XGDSHVW

0$-2526$(6HPPLUHNHOOĈNQDSORSÍNeDYDJ\D]LQWHJU»FLÍHJ\GÃOPDJ\DURUV]»JLNLV WÃUVÃJEHQ*\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJLDL6]HPOHr

0('<16.$00RGHOHNV]WDáFHQLDLQWHJUDF\MQHJRZ3ROVFHLQDĞZLHFLH KWWSZZZVSPLDVWR]JLHU]SOPRGHOHGRF/HWÐOWÃVLGHMHMÔOLXV 0£5(,).Ð]ÐVVÃJHNUHMWHWWK»OÍ]DWD2VLULV.LDGÍ%XGDSHVW

0(67(5+›=,=6$QHKH]HQWDQXOÍJ\HUPHNHNLVNRODLQHYHOÃVH%»UF]L*XV]W»Y*\ÍJ\SHGD JÍJLDL7DQ»UNÃS]Ĉ)ĈLVNROD%XGDSHVW

1.2//›5.D$FVRSRUWEDQHOIRJODOWKHO\ÃOHWNRULÃVHJ\ÃQLMHOOHP]ĈL,Q1.2//›5.r

6=$%­£V]HUN3V]LFKROÍJLDSHGDJÍJXVRNQDN2VLULV.LDGÍ%XGDSHVWr

1.2//›5.E7»UVDVNDSFVRODWRNV]HPÃO\NÐ]LYRQ]DORPÃVDFVRSRUWIRO\DPDWRNr$FVRSRUW ,Q1.2//›5.r6=$%­£V]HUN3V]LFKROÍJLDSHGDJÍJXVRNQDN2VLULV.LDGÍ%XGDSHVW r

1.2//›5.F $ FVRSRUWV]HUNH]HW IHOW»U»VD D V]RFLRPHWULD ,Q1.2//›5.r6=$%­£ V]HUN3V]LFKROÍJLDSHGDJÍJXVRNQDN2VLULV.LDGÍ%XGDSHVWr

3$33*r3(5/86=$r6&+,))(5&6r6=(.(5(6›r7$.›&6,.ÃWÔWYDQHOĈWWHPe"6SHFL»OLV ÃVWÐEEVÃJLLQWÃ]PÃQ\HNNÐ]ÐWWLNRRSHU»FLÍÃVNRQNXUHQFLDDVDM»WRVQHYHOÃVLLJÃQ\ĖWDQX OÍNRNWDW»V»EDQ*\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJLDL6]HPOHr

3$33*$]LQWHJU»FLÍLQNOÔ]LÍIRJDOPDNWDUWDOPLHOHP]ÃVHJ\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJLDLPHJNÐ]HOÇWÃV EHQrQHP]HWNÐ]LÃVPDJ\DUV]ÇQWÃUHQ*\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJLDL6]HPOHr

3,-/6r)267$'33HHUDFFHSWDQFHDQGVHOIFRQFHSWRIVWXGHQWVZLWKGLVDELOLWLHVLQUHJXODU HGXFDWLRQ(XURSHDQ-RXUQDORI6SHFLDO(GXFDWLRQ9ROXPH1Rr

6=$%­›$NÃSHVVÃJIHMOHV]WÃVÃVD]ÃOHWPÍGÐVV]HIÖJJÃVHLWDQXO»VEDQDNDG»O\R]RWWDN Q»O,Q*25'261£6=$%­$V]HUN*\ÍJ\ÇWÍSHGDJÍJLD0HGLFLQD%XGDSHVWr 6=(*›/%D$VDM»WRVQHYHOÃVLLJÃQ\ĖÃVK»WU»Q\RVKHO\]HWĖWDQXOÍNLQWHJU»OWRNWDW»V»QDNÃV

QHYHOÃVÃQHNPHJDODSR]»VD,Q*,5$6(.-V]HUN,QNOX]ÇY QHYHOÃV r $WDQXOÍN KDWÃNRQ\

PHJLVPHUÃVH6XOLQRYD.KW%XGDSHVWr

6=(*›/% E (J\ÖWW YDJ\ NÖOÐQ" ,QWHJU»OW QHYHOÃV SUR ÃV NRQWUD ,Q *,5$6(.- V]HUN ,QNOX]ÇYQHYHOÃVr$WDQXOÍNKDWÃNRQ\PHJLVPHUÃVH6XOLQRYD.KW%XGDSHVWr 6=(.(5(6›r+259›7+((Q\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNHNHWLQWHJU»OÍLVNRODLRV]W»

O\RNV]RFLRPHWULDLMHOOHP]ĈL0DJ\DU3V]LFKROÍJLDL6]HPOHr

6=(.(5(6›(Q\KÃQÃUWHOPLIRJ\DWÃNRVJ\HUPHNHNV]RFL»OLVLQWHJU»FLÍMDD]»OWDO»QRVLVNROD ÃVRV]W»O\»EDQ'RNWRULGLVV]HUW»FLÍ(/7(33.%XGDSHVW

725'$›$]LQWHJU»OWLVNRO»]WDW»VKDW»VDDJ\HUPHNV]HPÃO\LVÃJIHMOĈGÃVÃUH,Q*25'261£

6=$%­$V]HUN*\ÍJ\ÇWÍSHGDJÍJLD0HGLFLQD%XGDSHVWr

9$-'$=6 $ W»UVDVNDSFVRODWRN ÃVYLVHONHGÃV IHMOĈGÃVH NLVLVNRO»V NRUWÍO VHUGÖOĈNRULJ ,Q 0£6=›526$ V]HUN$] LVNROD V]RFL»OSV]LFKROÍJLDL MHOHQVÃJYLO»JD (/7( (ÐWYÐV .LDGÍ

%XGDSHVWr

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

(22)

!&(

%DUDQ\D0HJ\HL3HGDJÍJLDL6]DNV]ROJ»ODW3ÃFVL7DJLQWÃ]PÃQ\H

°WÐGLNRV]W»O\RVGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍN V]RFL»OLVEHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃQHNYL]VJ»ODWD DSHGDJÍJXVRNLQWHJU»FLÍYDONDSFVRODWRV DWWLWĖGMÃQHNWÖNUÃEHQ

*ć%/1£/20%26+$11$

PHJJ\PDJ#JPDLOFRP

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

$EV]WUDNW

$WDQXOP»Q\D]HOPÔOWÃYHNKD]DLV]RFLRPHWULDLÃVDWWLWĖGYL]VJ»ODWRNQDJ\OÃSWÃNĖEHPXWDW»VDXW»QHJ\ÐWÐGLNHVRV]W»O\PLQĈ VÃJLHOHP]ÃVÃQHNYL]VJ»ODWLPÍGV]HUHLWÃVHUHGPÃQ\HLWPXWDWMDEHPHO\QHNFÃOMDGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍV]RFL»OLVEHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃ QHNYL]VJ»ODWDYROWLOOHWYHD]H]]HOS»UKX]DPED»OOÇWKDWÍSHGDJÍJXVDWWLWĖGYL]VJ»ODWDÃVDNÃUGH]HWWHNGLIIHUHQFL»O»VLV]RN»VDL QDNIHOW»U»VD$V]RFLRPHWULDLHUHGPÃQ\HNEHWHNLQWÃVWHQJHGQHNHJ\WDQXO»VEDQDNDG»O\R]RWWÃVHJ\PDJDWDUW»VLQHKÃ]VÃJHN NHONÖ]GĈWDQXOÍRV]W»O\RQEHOÖOHOIRJODOWKHO\ÃQHNNÃSÃEHLV

.XOFVV]DYDNGLV]OH[LDLQWHJU»FLÍV]RFL»OLVEHLOOHV]NHGÃVSHGDJÍJXVDWWLWĖG

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

%HYH]HWÃV

$]HOPÔOWrÃYEHQWÐEERO\DQKD]DLYL]VJ»ODWO»WRWWQDSYLO»JRWPHO\HNDWHVWLÃU ]ÃNV]HUYL YDJ\ ÃUWHOPL IRJ\DWÃNRV WDQXOÍN V]RFL»OLV EHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃW YL]VJ»OW»N 3(5/86=

3$33$/762025-$,6=(.(5(652+26.$(]]HOV]HPEHQ DGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNLO\HQMHOOHJĖYL]VJ»ODW»UDHGGLJQHPNHUÖOWVRU.XWDW»VRPVRU»QHJ\

GLV]OH[L»V WDQXOÍNDW LQWHJU»OÍ ÐWÐGLNHV RV]W»O\W NHUHVWHP IHO DKRO D WDQXOÍN V]RFL»OLV EHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃWÃVD]RV]W»O\EDQWDQÇWÍSHGDJÍJXVRNLQWHJU»FLÍYDONDSFVRODWRVDWWLWĖGMÃW YL]VJ»OWDP

$EEÍOLQGXOWDPNLKRJ\D]LQWHJU»FLÍKDWÃNRQ\V»JDNDSFV»QDSHGDJÍJXVNXOFVIRQ WRVV»JÔ V]HUHSHWWÐOW EH PHUW D] RV]W»O\EDQ WDQXOÍ J\HUPHNHN UÍOD YHV]QHN SÃOG»W IL J\HOLND]LQWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNNDOV]HPEHQLPDJDWDUW»V»WÃVKR]]»»OO»V»W7ÐEEV]HU]ĈLVIHO KÇYMDDILJ\HOPHWDSHGDJÍJXVRNV]DNPDLIHONÃV]ÖOWVÃJÃQHNÃVVHJÇWĈHOIRJDGÍKR]]»»O O»V»QDN IRQWRVV»J»UD 6=(*ć*$›/ ,'),6&+(5)¶9(6321*5›&=

E5£7+<

(23)

!&)

9L]VJ»ODWRPVRU»QDUUDYROWDPNÇY»QFVLKRJ\PLO\HQD]RV]W»O\EDQWDQÇWÍSHGDJÍJX VRNLQWHJU»FLÍKR]YDOÍKR]]»»OO»VDÃVH]S»UKX]DPED»OOÇWKDWÍHD]LQWHJU»OWGLV]OH[L»V WDQXOÍV]RFL»OLVEHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃYHO(]HQNÇYÖOV]HUHWWHPYROQDNÃSHWNDSQLDSHGDJÍJX VRNGLIIHUHQFL»O»VLV]RN»VLUÍOÃVDUUÍOKRJ\H]S»UKX]DPED»OOÇWKDWÍHD]LQWHJU»OWGLV]

OH[L»VWDQXOÍV]RFL»OLVEHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃYHO

.RU»EELNXWDW»VRN

%»U D KD]DL ÃV NÖOIÐOGL V]DNLURGDORPEDQ V]»PRV V]HU]Ĉ IRJODONR]RWW P»U IRJ\DWÃNRV V]HPÃO\HN V]RFL»OLV EHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃYHO VDM»W YL]VJ»ODWRP V]HPSRQWM»EÍO6]HNHUHV ›JRWD V]RFLRPHWULDL YL]VJ»ODWD YROW OHJLQN»EE PHJKDW»UR]Í 321*5›&=D6=(.(5(6

6=(.(5(66=(.(5(6

$V]HU]ĈÃVRV]W»O\RVWDQXO»VEDQDNDG»O\R]RWWWDQXOÍNDWLQWHJU»OÍRV]W»O\RNDW NHUHVHWWIHOÃVWÐEEP»VLNNÃUGĈÇYYHONLHJÃV]ÇWYHYHWWHIHOD]»OWDODPLVKDV]Q»OWV]RFLR PHWULDLNÃUGÃVVRUW$]HUHGPÃQ\HNDODSM»QD]GHUÖOWNLKRJ\DWDQXO»VEDQDNDG»O\R]RWW WDQXOÍNV]RFL»OLVLQWHJU»FLÍMDURVV]DEEPLQWW»UVDLNÃĈNNHYHVHEENÐOFVÐQÐVY»ODV]W»VW LV NDSWDN LOOHWYH V]LJQLILN»QVDQ WÐEEHW Y»ODV]WRWW»N ĈNHW D EHLOOHV]NHGÃVLQHKÃ]VÃJHNUH YRQDWNR]ÍNÃUGÃVHNEHQ6=(.(5(6

7ÐEEDWWLWĖGNXWDW»VLVSXEOLN»O»VUDNHUÖOWP»UD]XWÍEELLGĈEHQH]HNNÐ]ÖO+RUY»WK QÃ0ROGYD\,ORQD)LVFKHU*DEULHOOD6]HJĈ›JQHVLOOHWYH)RUOLQÃVPXQNDW»UVDLQDNYL]V J»ODWL DQ\DJ»W YHWWHP DODSXO VDM»W DWWLWĖGNÃUGĈÇYHP ÐVV]H»OOÇW»V»KR] +259›7+1£

),6&+(56=(*ć)25/,1r($5/(r/25(0$1r6+$50$

$ IHQW HPOÇWHWW V]HU]ĈN WÐEEHN NÐ]ÐWW D]W WDO»OW»N KRJ\ »OWDO»QRV W»MÃNR]DWODQV»J ÃVLQIRUP»FLÍKL»Q\MHOOHP]LDSHGDJÍJXVRNDWXJ\DQDNNRUDNLNQHNWÐEEOHWLVPHUHWÖNYDQ D] LQWHJU»FLÍUÍO LOOHWYH D] LQWHJU»OW V]HPÃO\HNUĈO D]RNQDN DWWLWĖGMÖN LV SR]LWÇYDEE

$NÃUGH]HWWHNUHQGNÇYÖOIRQWRVQDNWDUWRWW»ND]LQWHJU»FLÍNDSFV»QDIRJDGÍSHGDJÍJXV KR]]»»OO»V»WÃVV]DNPDLIHONÃV]ÖOWVÃJÃWÃVQDJ\REEUÃV]ÖNHOIRJDGWDD]LQWHJU»FLÍWE»U D J\DNRUODWL PHJYDOÍVÇW»VVDO NDSFVRODWEDQ V]NHSWLNXVDN YROWDN $ GLIIHUHQFL»O»VL V]RN»

VRN IHOPÃUÃVHNRU NLGHUÖOW KRJ\ LQN»EE D IHODGDW V]HULQWL GLIIHUHQFL»O»VW DONDOPD]]»N J\DNUDEEDQ D SHGDJÍJXVRN ÃV ULWN»EEDQ NHUÖOQHN HOĈWÃUEH D] LQGLYLGXDOL]»OW PÍGV]H UHN3R]LWÇYXPKRJ\DSHGDJÍJXVRNDKDV]Q»OYDODPLO\HQGLIIHUHQFL»O»VLPÍGV]HUW )ÃQ\GHUÖOW DUUD LV KRJ\ DNLN LQGLYLGXDOL]»OW PÍGV]HUHNHW KDV]Q»OQDN D]RNQDN SR]LWÇ YDEED]DWWLWĖGMÖN+259›7+1£),6&+(56=(*ć

+LSRWÃ]LVHN

-HOHQNXWDW»VRPVRU»QHJ\WÐEEV]HPSRQWÔV]RFLRPHWULDLNÃUGÃVVRUWYHWWHPIHOD]LQWHJ U»OÍRV]W»O\EDM»UÍWDQXOÍNNDOLOOHWYHHJ\VDM»WNÃV]ÇWÃVĖDWWLWĖGNÃUGĈÇYNLWÐOWÃVÃUHNÃUWHP D]RV]W»O\EDQWDQÇWÍSHGDJÍJXVRNDW

$]WIHOWÃWHOH]HPKRJ\KDD]DWWLWĖGNÃUGĈÇY/LNHUWWÇSXVÔVN»O»M»QDSHGDJÍJXVRNLQ WHJU»FLÍYDONDSFVRODWRV»OWDO»QRVEH»OOÇWÍG»V»UDÃVD]HOIRJDG»VUDYRQDWNR]ÍNÃUGÃVHNUH

(24)

!'

DGRWWY»ODV]DLN»WODJDIÐOÐWWOHV]ÃVWÐEEVÃJÖNLQGLYLGXDOL]»OWGLIIHUHQFL»O»VLWHFKQLN»

NDWLVDONDOPD]DNNRU

D]LQWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNQHPOHV]QHNSHUHPKHO\]HWEHQ

D] LQWHJU»OW WDQXOÍN D 0ÃUHLIÃOH W»UVDV MHOHQWĈVÃJ PXWDWÍLW YL]VJ»OYD QHP OHV]QHN ÃULQWHWWHN D QHJDWÇY ÇWÃOHWHNEHQ ÃV D] HORV]O»VL PXWDWÍ DODSM»Q QHP IRJQDN QHJDWÇY V]HUHSHWEHWÐOWHQL

D NÐOFVÐQÐVVÃJL LQGH[ DODSM»Q D] »WODJRVQ»O NHYHVHEE OHV] D PDJ»Q\RVRN V]»PD D]RV]W»O\EDQ*ć%/1£0£5(,

$PLQWDÃVPÍGV]HUHNEHPXWDW»VD

$YL]VJ»ODWRWHJ\SÃFVL»OWDO»QRVLVNRO»EDQYHWWHPIHOPHO\WÐEEPLQWÃYHVLQWHJU»FLÍV PÔOWWDO UHQGHONH]LN $ IHONHUHVHWW IĈV ÐWÐGLNHV RV]W»O\EDQ GLV]OH[L»V WDQXOÍ HJ\

WDQXO»VEDQDNDG»O\R]RWWÃVHJ\PDJDWDUW»VLQHKÃ]VÃJHNNHONÖ]GĈWDQXOÍYROWLQWHJU»OYD

$]RV]W»O\EDQWDQÇWÍSHGDJÍJXVRNNÐ]ÖOIĈWÐOWÐWWHNLD]DWWLWĖGNÃUGĈÇYHWH]DOHKHWVÃ JHVY»ODV]DGÍNQDNNÐUÖOEHOÖODIHOH

W»EO»]DW$SHGDJÍJXVDWWLWĖGYL]VJ»ODW»OOÇW»VDL*ć%/1£r

(25)

!'!

$] LQWHJU»OW WDQXOÍN V]RFL»OLV EHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃQHN YL]VJ»ODW»W6]HNHUHV ›JRWD WÐEE V]HP SRQWÔV]RFLRPHWULDLNÃUGÃVVRUDDODSM»QYÃJH]WHPPHO\NÃUGÃVHLIDNWRUDODSM»QFVRSRU WRVÇWKDWÍNNÃSHVVÃJHNEHLOOHV]NHGÃVLQHKÃ]VÃJHNURNRQV]HQYLY»ODV]W»VRNYHUVHQJÃV YHUE»OLVDJUHVV]LÍ6=(.(5(6

$]DWWLWĖGYL]VJ»ODWDV]HPÃO\HVDGDWRNRQNÇYÖOWDUWDOPD]HJ\IRNR]DWÔ/LNHUWWÇSXVÔ VN»O»WDPLQHNNDSFV»QDSHGDJÍJXVRNV]DNPDLNRPSHWHQFL»M»WV]DNPDLQ\LWRWWV»J»WÃV PHJÔMXO»VUDYDOÍKDMODQGÍV»JXNDWHOĈÇWÃOHWPHQWHVVÃJÖNHWÃVD]LQWHJU»FLÍYDONDSFVROD WRV»OWDO»QRVEH»OOÇWÍG»VXNDWV]ROLGDULW»VXNDWPÃUWHPIHOW»EO»]DW(]HQNÇYÖOU»NÃU GH]WHPGLIIHUHQFL»O»VLV]RN»VDLNUDWRY»EE»KRJ\NDSWDNHYDODPLO\HQVHJÇWVÃJHWDVDM»

WRV QHYHOÃVL LJÃQ\Ė WDQXOÍN LQWHJU»O»V»KR] LOOHWYH KRJ\ D] LQWHJU»FLÍ IHOWÃWHOHL NÐ]ÖO PHO\HNHWWDUWM»NDOHJIRQWRVDEEQDNÃVPHO\HNHWNHYÃVEÃIRQWRVQDN

(UHGPÃQ\HN

$ IHOYHWW V]RFLRPHWULD DODSM»Q HJ\ YLV]RQ\ODJ ÃUHWOHQ NÐ]ÐVVÃJ NÃSH UDM]ROÍGRWW NL »EUD DPHO\ SHUHPÐYH]HWH QDJ\ EĈO IĈ PDJ»Q\RV IĈ S»URV NDSFVRODW EDQ »OO 1HPHN V]HULQW NÃW ]»UW NÐ]ÐVVÃJHW DONRWQDN D WDQXOÍN GL»N D]RQEDQ QHP NDSFVROÍGLNHJ\LNFVRSRUWKR]VHPÇJ\D&0PXWDWÍNULWÃULXPDLDODSM»QQLQFVNÐ]SRQWMD D] RV]W»O\QDN $] LQIRUP»FLÍ»UDPO»V ÃV GÐQWÃVKR]DWDO »OWDO»EDQ ODVVÔ ÃV QHKÃ]NHV HJ\

LO\HQNÐ]ÐVVÃJEHQ$NÐOFVÐQÐVNDSFVRODWRNV]»PDNHYHVHEED]»WODJRVQ»ONÐOFVÐQÐV VÃJLLQGH[PÇJD]»WODJrHJ\IĈUHSHGLJNHYHVHEENÐOFVÐQÐVNDSFVRODWMXW D]»WODJRVQ»OVĖUĖVÃJLPXWDWÍD]»WODJrH]LVD]RV]W»O\V]ÃWHVHWWVÃJÃWPX WDWMD$FVRSRUWOÃJNÐUPXWDWÍMDDODSM»QDUUDNÐYHWNH]WHWKHWÖQNKRJ\DURNRQ V]HQYLY»ODV]W»VRNEDQLVPHJKDW»UR]ÍV]HUHSHYDQDNÐ]YÃOHPÃQ\QHNWHK»WDWÐEEVÃJ V]HULQWSULYLOHJL]»OWWDQXOÍNUDWHNLQWHQHNDOHJWÐEEHQEDU»WNÃQWdÇWÃOHWLVDEORQRNp0£5(, ÃUYÃQ\HVÖOQHNDNDSFVRODWRNEDQQHPDV]XEMHNWÇYÃU]ÃVHNDPHJKDW»UR]ÍDN 9DQWHK»WRV]W»O\RQEHOÖOLNÐ]YÃOHPÃQ\D]HJ\ÃQHNHWLOOHWĈHQÃVH]O»WKDWÍDQEHIRO\»

VROMDDURNRQV]HQYLY»ODV]W»VRNDWLV0£5(,

$ GLV]OH[L»V WDQXOÍN NÐ]ÖO NHWWHQ S»URV NDSFVRODWEDQ »OOQDN HJ\ WDQXOÍ SHGLJ NÐOFVÐQÐV NDSFVRODWWDO HJ\ ]»UW DODN]DW WDJMD DPL MÍ HUHGPÃQ\QHN V]»PÇW DKKR] NÃSHVW KRJ\ PLO\HQ PDJDV D PDJ»Q\RV WDQXOÍN DU»Q\D (] DODSM»Q ÔJ\ WĖQLN KRJ\D]ÃULQWHWWWDQXOÍNV]RFL»OLVLQWHJU»FLÍMDNLHOÃJÇWĈ

$W»UVDVMHOHQWĈVÃJPXWDWÍLWYL]VJ»OYDPHJ»OODSÇWKDWÍKRJ\WDQXOÍOHWWMHOHQWĈVDND SRWW Y»ODV]RN DODSM»Q H]HN NÐ]ÖO ÐWHQ HOVĈUHQGĖHQ MHOHQWĈVHN .Ð]ÖOÖNK»UPDQ OHWWHN QHJDWÇY HOVĈUHQGĖ MHOHQWĈVÃJĖGL»NRNGHHJ\LNÖNVHPGLV]OH[L»V WDQXOÍ $V]ĖNÇWHWW ÃV DJORE»OLVV]HUHSLQGH[HWLVILJ\HOHPEHYÃYHHJ\LNGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍQDNVLQFVVHPSR]L WÇYVHPQHJDWÇYV]HUHSHD]RV]W»O\EDQ

(OJRQGRONRGWDWÍD]RQEDQKRJ\DWDQXO»VEDQDNDG»O\R]RWWÃVDPDJDWDUW»VLQH KÃ]VÃJHNNHONÖ]GĈWDQXOÍPDJ»Q\RVÃVPLQGNHWWHQQHJDWÇYDQHOVĈUHQGĖMHOHQWĈVÃ JĖHNÃVQHJDWÇYV]HUHSHWWÐOWHQHNEHD]RV]W»O\EDQ(]HNDODSM»QD]ĈV]RFL»OLVEHLOOHV]

NHGÃVÖNMÍYDOHOPDUDGDGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNV]RFL»OLVEHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃWĈO

(26)

!'"

»EUD6]RFLRJUDP

$]DWWLWĖGNÃUGĈÇYHUHGPÃQ\HLDODSM»QW»EO»]DWDSHGDJÍJXVRNWÐEEVÃJHV]DNPDLODJ NRPSHWHQVQHNÃU]LPDJ»WDGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNRNWDW»V»UDÃVQ\LWRWWDNDV]DNPDLPHJÔMX O»VUD$NÃUGH]HWWHNPD[LP»OLVDQHJ\HWÃUWHWWHNDEEDQKRJ\V]ÖNVÃJÖNYDQPÍGV]HUWDQL VHJÇWVÃJUHDGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNLQWHJU»OWRNWDW»V»KR]DPLDUUDHQJHGNÐYHWNH]WHWQLKRJ\

D SHGDJÍJXVRN V]ÖNVÃJHVQHN WDUWM»N D KDJ\RP»Q\RV PÍGV]HUHNWĈO YDOÍ HOV]DNDG»VW D]HUHGPÃQ\HVWDQÇW»VÃUGHNÃEHQ

$GLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNHOIRJDG»V»UDYRQDWNR]ÍNÃUGÃVHNNÐ]ÖOOHJNHYÃVEÃD]]DOÃUWHWWHN HJ\HW DSHGDJÍJXVRNKRJ\ D]LQWHJU»OWJ\HUPHN MÍKDW»VVDO YDQD NÐ]ÐVVÃJ DODNXO»V»UD

»WO(]D]HJ\HWOHQ»OOÇW»VD]HJÃV]NÃUGÃVVRUEDQDPHO\QHN»WODJDQHPÃUWHHODY»UW DVÃUWÃNHW$P»VLNNÃWNÃUGÃV»WODJDLPDJDVDEEDNYROWDNGHILJ\HOHPIHOKÇYÍKRJ\NÃW SHGDJÍJXVPÃJPLQGLJUÃV]EHQQHPÃUWHJ\HWDGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNLQWHJU»O»V»YDO°VV]HV VÃJÃEHQPÃJLVPHJ»OODSÇWKDWÍKRJ\DSHGDJÍJXVRNQDJ\REEUÃV]WHOIRJDGM»NDGLV]OH[L»V GL»NRNDWXJ\DQDNNRUQHPÃUWHQHNHJ\HWDNÐ]ÐVVÃJUHJ\DNRUROWSR]LWÇYKDW»VXNNDO

(]]HOIÖJJKHWÐVV]HKRJ\D]LQWHJU»FLÍYDONDSFVRODWRV»OWDO»QRVEH»OOÇWÍG»VUDYRQDWNR ]ÍXWROVÍNÃUGÃVUHPHJOHSĈHUHGPÃQ\V]ÖOHWHWW$NÃUGH]HWWHNIHOHQHPDGRWWY»ODV]WDUUD D NÃUGÃVUH KRJ\ ÐUÐPPHO YHQQÃH KD VDM»W J\HUPHNÃQHN GLV]OH[L»V RV]W»O\W»UVD OHQQH (EEĈODUUDNÐYHWNH]WHWWHPKRJ\NHYÃVEÃÐUÖOQÃQHNKDÇJ\OHQQH.ÃWSHGDJÍJXVLVFVDN UÃV]EHQ ÐUÖOQH HJ\ V]HPÃO\ Q\LODWNR]RWW DUUÍO KRJ\ QDJ\REEUÃV]W ÐUÖOQH KD ÇJ\ OHQQH

»WO$P»VLNNÃWNÃUGÃV»WODJDLDODSM»QPÃJLVÐVV]HVVÃJÃEHQD]»OODSÇWKDWÍPHJKRJ\

DSHGDJÍJXVRNLQN»EEHOIRJDGM»ND]LQWHJU»FLÍWPLQWQHPGHHOĈQ\HLWHOVĈVRUEDQDGLV]

OH[L»VWDQXOÍNUDYRQDWNR]WDWM»NÃVNHYÃVEÃO»WM»NHOĈQ\ÐVQHNDWÐEELGL»NUDQÃ]YH

(27)

!'#

W»EO»]DW/LNHUWDODSÔVN»OD»WODJDL

»EUD'LIIHUHQFL»O»VLV]RN»VRN

(28)

!'$

$SHGDJÍJXVRNGLIIHUHQFL»O»VLV]RN»VDLSR]LWÇYNÃSHWPXWDWQDN»EUD0LQGHQNÃUGH ]HWW KDV]Q»O YDODPLO\HQ PÍGV]HUW D OHJWÐEEHQ r WÇSXVW LV PHJMHOÐOWHN D IHOVRUROWDN NÐ]ÖO $] LQGLYLGXDOL]»OW PÍGV]HUHN NÐ]ÖO D] HJ\ÃQL V]»PRQNÃUÃVW D] HJ\ÃQL WDQXO»VL WHPSÍWÃVDGLIIHUHQFL»OWÃUWÃNHOÃVWKDV]Q»OM»NDOHJWÐEEHWEÍOIĈ(J\HGÖODNRRSH U»FLÍVFVRSRUWPXQN»WQHPDONDOPD]]»ND]DGRWWRV]W»O\EDQ

$] LQWHJU»OWRNWDW»VKR] NDSRWWVHJÇWVÃJNÃQW D J\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJXVVDO YDOÍ NRQ]XOW»FLÍW ÃV D] LQWÃ]PÃQ\EHQ UHQGHONH]ÃVUH »OOÍ V]DNLURGDOPL IRUU»VRNDW HPHOWÃN NL OHJLQN»EE DSHGDJÍJXVRN

.RU»EELNXWDW»VRNNDO),6&+(5KDVRQOÍHUHGPÃQ\WPXWDWRWWD]LQWHJU»FLÍIHOWÃW HOHLQHNUDQJVRURO»VDLVW»EO»]DW$KDWSHGDJÍJXVNÐ]ÖOQÃJ\WÐOWÐWWHNLDNÃUGĈÇYQHN H]W D UÃV]ÃW (J\ NLYÃWHOOHO PLQGHQNL D IRJDGÍ SHGDJÍJXV KR]]»»OO»V»W ÃV D] LQWHJU»OW J\HUPHNV]HPÃO\LVÃJÃWWHWWHDOLVWDHOHMÃUHPÇJDSÃQ]ÖJ\LK»WWÃUPLQGHQNLQÃOD]XWROVÍ NÃWKHO\HJ\LNÃQV]HUHSHOW$NÃWREMHNWÇYWÃQ\H]ĈrDSÃQ]ÖJ\LK»WWÃUÃVDVSHFL»OLVWDQ HV]NÐ]ÐNrDÃVDKHO\HQYÃJ]HWW

W»EO»]DW$]LQWHJU»FLÍREMHNWÇYÃVV]XEMHNWÇYIHOWÃWHOHLUDQJVRUROYD

$KLSRWÃ]LVHNEHY»O»VD

$/LNHUWWÇSXVÔVN»ODDODSM»QDSHGDJÍJXVRNLQWHJU»FLÍYDONDSFVRODWRV»OWDO»QRVEH»OOÇWÍ G»V»UDÃVD]HOIRJDG»VUDYRQDWNR]ÍNÃUGÃVHNUHDGRWWY»ODV]DLN»WODJDrHJ\NÃUGÃVNLYÃWH

(29)

!'%

OÃYHOrIÐOÐWWYROWÃVWÐEEVÃJÖNKDV]Q»OLQGLYLGXDOL]»OWGLIIHUHQFL»O»VLWHFKQLN»NDW(]HN DODSM»QD]WY»UWDPKRJ\D]LQWHJU»OWWDQXOÍNQHPOHV]QHNSHUHPKHO\]HWEHQQHPOHV]QHN ÃULQWHWWHNQHJDWÇYÇWÃOHWHNEHQQHPIRJQDNQHJDWÇYV]HUHSHWEHWÐOWHQLD]RV]W»O\EDQLOOHW YHKRJ\D0ÃUHL»OWDOPHJ»OODSÇWRWW»WODJQ»ONHYHVHEEHQOHV]QHNPDJ»Q\RVKHO\]HWEHQ

$KLSRWÃ]LVHNEHY»O»V»WLOOHWĈHQD]HOVĈNÃWIHOWÃWHOH]ÃVHPLJD]ROÍGRWWEHDGLV]OH[L»V WDQXOÍNWHNLQWHWÃEHQćNYDOÍEDQQLQFVHQHNSHUHPKHO\]HWEHQKLV]HQNHWWHQS»URVNDS FVRODWWDOHJ\WDQXOÍSHGLJKDWNÐOFVÐQÐVNDSFVRODWWDOUHQGHONH]LN7RY»EE»HJ\LNÖNVHP ÃULQWHWWQHJDWÇYÇWÃOHWHNEHQÃVQHPWÐOWHQHNEHQHJDWÇYV]HUHSHWD]RV]W»O\EDQ8J\DQ DNNRUPÃJLVPHJNÃUGĈMHOH]LD]LQWHJU»FLÍWHOMHVVLNHUHVVÃJÃWD]DWÃQ\KRJ\DWDQXO»VEDQ DNDG»O\R]RWWÃVDPDJDWDUW»VLQHKÃ]VÃJHNNHONÖ]GĈWDQXOÍPDJ»Q\RVKHO\]HWEHQYDQD]

RV]W»O\RQEHOÖOÃULQWHWWHNDQHJDWÇYÇWÃOHWHNEHQÃVQHJDWÇYV]HUHSHWWÐOWHQHNEHD]RV]

W»O\EDQ

(]DODSM»QE»USR]LWÇYNÃSHWPXWDWDSHGDJÍJXVRNLQWHJU»FLÍYDONDSFVRODWRVDWWLWĖGMH ÃV Y»OWR]DWRV WDQÇW»VL PÍGV]HUHNHW KDV]Q»OQDN PXQN»MXN VRU»Q H] PÃJVHP HOHJHQGĈ DKKR]KRJ\DWDQXO»VEDQDNDG»O\R]RWWÃVDPDJDWDUW»VLQHKÃ]VÃJHNNHONÖ]GĈJ\HUPHN V]RFL»OLV EHLOOHV]NHGÃVH LV SR]LWÇY OHJ\HQ $ SHGDJÍJXVNÃUGĈÇYKL»Q\RVV»JD KRJ\ FVDN D GLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNUD YRQDWNR]WDWYD MHOHQQHN PHJ D] »OOÇW»VRNQHP WÃU NL D P»VLNNÃW ÃULQWHWW FVRSRUWUD (ONÃS]HOKHWĈ KRJ\ P»V HUHGPÃQ\ V]ÖOHWHWW YROQD KD »WIRJÍEEDN DPHJIRJDOPD]RWW»OOÇW»VRN

$KDUPDGLNKLSRWÃ]LVPLV]HULQWDMÍOPĖNÐGĈLQWHJU»FLÍPHOOHWWD]»WODJRVQ»ONHYH VHEEOHV]DPDJ»Q\RVRNV]»PDD]RV]W»O\EDQQHPQ\HUWDO»W»PDV]W»VW$NÐOFVÐQÐVVÃJL LQGH[ ÃUWÃNH D] »WODJRV rKR] NÃSHVW WHK»W NHYÃV D NÐOFVÐQÐV NDSFVRODWRN V]»PDD]RV]W»O\EDQ1LQFVHQHNV]LO»UGDQNLDODNXOWEDU»WV»JRNHUĈVNÐWHOÃNHNDJ\HUH NHNNÐ]ÐWWÃVNÃWV]HUWÐEEHQYDQQDNPDJ»Q\RVKHO\]HWEHQPLQWD]HOIRJDGKDWÍOHQQH (QQHNRNDOHJLQN»EED]RV]W»O\NÐ]ÐVVÃJWROHUDQFL»M»QDNKL»Q\»EDQÃVÃUHWOHQVÃJÃEHQ NHUHVHQGĈPHO\UÃV]EHQMHOOHP]ĈMHLVD]DGRWWNRURV]W»O\LFVRSRUWRNQDN$SHGDJÍJX VRN SR]LWÇY DWWLWĖGMH ÃV Y»OWR]DWRV WDQÇW»VL PÍGV]HUHL WHK»W QHP EHIRO\»VROW»N SR]LWÇYDQ D]HOPDJ»Q\RVRGRWWWDQXOÍNMREEEHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃW0£5(,

°VV]HIRJODO»V

%»UHOVĈVRUEDQDYL]VJ»OWRV]W»O\EDLQWHJU»OWGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNV]RFL»OLVEHLOOHV]NHGÃVÃUH YROWDPNÇY»QFVL HJ\WDQXO»VEDQ DNDG»O\R]RWW ÃVHJ\ PDJDWDUW»VL QHKÃ]VÃJHNNHO NÖ]GĈ WDQXOÍKHO\]HWÃUĈOLVNÃSHWNDSWDP

$] HUHGPÃQ\HN D]W PXWDWW»N KRJ\ HEEHQ D] DODFVRQ\ WROHUDQFLDV]LQWĖ YLV]RQ\ODJ ÃUHWOHQ NÐ]ÐVVÃJEHQ DGLV]OH[L»V WDQXOÍNQLQFVHQHN HOPDJ»Q\RVRGYDQHPWÐOWHQHNEH QHJDWÇY V]HUHSHW ÃV QHP MHOHQWĈVHN QHJDWÇY ÃUWHOHPEHQ $ IHQWL SR]LWÇYXPRN HOOHQÃUH D]RQEDQ PHJHPOÇWHQGĈ KRJ\ SR]LWÇY V]HUHSHW VHP WÐOWHQHN EH D] ÃULQWHWWHN ÃV QHP MHOHQWĈVHNSR]LWÇYÃUWHOHPEHQVHP0LQGHPHOOHWWHJ\ÃUWHOPĖKRJ\DNÃWP»VLNLQWHJU»OW WDQXOÍ V]RFL»OLV EHLOOHV]NHGÃVH MHOHQWĈVHQ HOPDUDG GLV]OH[L»V W»UVDLNÃKR] NÃSHVW ćN PDJ»Q\RVDN HOVĈUHQGĖHQ QHJDWÇY V]HUHSHW WÐOWHQHN EH D] RV]W»O\EDQ ÃV QHJDWÇY ÃUWH

OHPEHQMHOHQWĈVHN

(30)

!'&

$SHGDJÍJXVDWWLWĖGNÃUGĈÇYDODSM»QDNÃUGH]HWWHNV]DNPDLODJNRPSHWHQVQHNWDUWM»N PDJXNDWDGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNQHYHOÃVÃUHRNWDW»V»UDÃVQ\LWRWWDNDV]DNPDLPHJÔMXO»VUD

°VV]HVVÃJÃEHQQDJ\REEUÃV]WHOIRJDGM»NDGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNDWGHDNÐ]ÐVVÃJUHJ\DNR UROWSR]LWÇYKDW»VXNDWPHJNÃUGĈMHOH]LN$]LQWHJU»FLÍJRQGRODW»YDODODSYHWĈHQHJ\HWÃUWH QHNGHHOĈQ\HLWLQN»EEDGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍUDQÃ]YHÃUWHOPH]LNÃVNHYÃVEÃYRQDWNR]WDW M»ND]RV]W»O\EDQWDQXOÍWÐEELGL»NUD

$Y»ODV]DGÍNGLIIHUHQFL»O»VLV]RN»VDLNLHOÃJÇWĈHNDOHJWÐEEHQLQGLYLGXDOL]»OWPÍGV]H UHNHWKDV]Q»OQDNDPLWDO»QD]LQWÃ]PÃQ\UÃJUHYLVV]DQ\ÔOÍLQWHJU»FLÍVPÔOWM»QDNLVNÐ V]ÐQKHWĈ0HJQ\XJWDWÍWRY»EE»KRJ\PLQGHQSHGDJÍJXVNDSRWWYDODPLO\HQVHJÇWVÃJHW D] LQWHJU»OW RNWDW»VKR] E»U HOJRQGRONRGWDWÍ KRJ\ FVDN HJ\ YDODNL Q\LODWNR]RWW ÔJ\

KRJ\WHOMHVNÐUĖIHONÃV]ÇWÃVWNDSRWWWDQXOP»Q\DLVRU»Q

$]LQWHJU»FLÍIHOWÃWHOHLNÐ]ÖOPLQGHQNÃUGH]HWWV]XEMHNWÇYIHOWÃWHOHNHWD]RQEHOÖOLVD IRJDGÍSHGDJÍJXVKR]]»»OO»V»WÃVD]LQWHJU»OWJ\HUPHNV]HPÃO\LVÃJÃWWDUWRWWDNXOFVIRQ WRVV»JÔQDNPÇJD]REMHNWÇYIHOWÃWHOHNPLQGHQNLQÃOK»WWÃUEHNHUÖOWHN

$IHQWLHNDODSM»QWHK»WPHJ»OODSÇWKDWÍKRJ\DSHGDJÍJXVRNSR]LWÇYDWWLWĖGMHÃVY»O WR]DWRV WDQÇW»VL PÍGV]HUHL PHOOHWW r D Y»UWQDN PHJIHOHOĈHQ r NLHOÃJÇWĈQHN PRQGKDWÍ D GLV]OH[L»V WDQXOÍN V]RFL»OLV EHLOOHV]NHGÃVH 8J\DQDNNRU D YL]VJ»ODW KL»Q\RVV»JDNÃQW IRJDOPD]KDWÍ PHJ KRJ\ D SHGDJÍJXV NÃUGĈÇY NÃUGÃVHL NL]»UÍODJ D GLV]OH[L»V WDQXOÍN LQWHJU»FLÍM»UD YRQDWNR]WDN ÇJ\ D] RV]W»O\EDQ WDQXOÍ NÃW P»VLN LQWHJU»OW WDQXOÍYDO NDS FVRODWRVDWWLWĖGUĈOQHPNDSKDWWXQNNÃSHW

$WDQXO»VEDQDNDG»O\R]RWWÃVDPDJDWDUW»VLQHKÃ]VÃJJHONÖ]GĈWDQXOÍHOÃJWHOHQEHLO OHV]NHGÃVÃQHNK»WWHUÃEHQ»OOKDWKRJ\DSHGDJÍJXVRNQLQFVHQHNV]DNPDLODJIHONÃV]ÖOYH DNÃWWDQXOÍLQWHJU»OWQHYHOÃVÃKH]YDJ\D]KRJ\DWWLWĖGMÖNQHPPHJIHOHOĈ9DOÍV]ÇQĖQHN WDUWRPKRJ\DGLV]OH[L»VWDQXOÍNKR]KDVRQOÍDQUÍOXNLVD]WIHOWÃWHOH]LNDSHGDJÍJXVRN KRJ\QLQFVHQHNMÍKDW»VVDOD]RV]W»O\UDÃVNHYÃVEÃÐUÖOQÃQHNKDVDM»WJ\HUPHNÖNQHN OHQQHWDQXO»VEDQDNDG»O\R]RWWYDJ\PDJDWDUW»VLQHKÃ]VÃJJHONÖ]GĈRV]W»O\W»UVD(ONÃS ]HOKHWĈXJ\DQDNNRU D] LVKRJ\ D] ÃULQWHWW WDQXOÍNV]HPÃO\LVÃJH »OO PHJIHOHOĈEHLOOHV]

NHGÃVÖNK»WWHUÃEHQ),6&+(5

$NXWDW»VWRY»EELNRUO»WMDKRJ\PLQGÐVV]HHJ\RV]W»O\ÃVKDWSHGDJÍJXVPHJNÃUGH]Ã VÃQDODSXOÇJ\»OWDO»QRVÃVPHVV]HPHQĈNÐYHWNH]WHWÃVHNQHPYRQKDWÍNOHDIHQWOHÇUWDNEÍO

,URGDORPMHJ\]ÃN

$/73'LIIHUHQFL»O»VrHJ\HQVÔO\,Q%›1)$/9<&6V]HUN$]LQWHJU»FLÍVFXQDPL7DQXO P»Q\RNDIRJ\DWÃNRVHPEHUHNLVNRODLÃVW»UVDGDOPLLQWHJU»FLÍM»UÍO(/7(%**<).r(/7(

(ÐWYÐV.LDGÍ%XGDSHVWr

),6&+(5*$]LQWHJU»FLÍYDONDSFVRODWRVDWWLWĖGÐNNXWDW»VD,Q*\ÍJ\SHGDJÍJLDL6]HPOH r

KWWSZZZSUDHKXSUDHJ\RV]HSKS"PHQXBLG MLG MDLG /HWÐOWÃV LGHMH IHEUX»U

)25/,1&r($5/(&r/25(0$17r6+$50$87KH6HQWLPHQWV$WWLWXGHVDQG&RQFHUQV DERXW ,QFOXVLYH (GXFDWLRQ 5HYLVHG 6$&,(5 6FDOH IRU 0HDVXULQJ 3UH6HUYLFH 7HDFKHUVn 3HUFHSWLRQVDERXW,QFOXVLRQ([FHSWLRQDOLW\(GXFDWLRQ,QWHUQDWLRQDOr

Hivatkozások

KAPCSOLÓDÓ DOKUMENTUMOK

$] iOWDODP NLGROJR]RWW VWUHVV]WHV]W VHJtWVpJpYHO Qp]WHP D Q\DNV]tMMDO pV PĦWpWWHO JiWROW YDODPLQW D QHP JiWROW OHYHJĘQ\HOĘ pV NRQWURO ORYDN VWUHVV]NH]HOpVL VWUDWpJLDEHOL

9L]VJ»ODWRPEDQ HQ\KÃQ ÃUWHOPL IRJ\DWÃNRV ÃV »WODJRV LQWHOOHNWXVÔ J\HUPHN YLVHONHGÃVL ÃV SV]LFKÃV SUREOÃP»UD

$ V]iPtWiVWHFKQLND IRNR]DWRV HOWHUMHGpVH V]iPRV SR]LWtY KDWiVVDO YROW D KD ]DL YH]HWpV pV V]HUYH]pVWXGRPiQ\UD PpJ KD FVXSiQ iWWpWHOHVHQ LV $ NO|Q IpOH V]iPtWyJpSHV

HV]N|]|NNHODOHKHW OHJNLVHEEN|OWVpJHNPHOOHWWpUMNHO$HVpYHNyWDHJ\UHQDJ\REE ILJ\HOPHW NDSQDN D N|UQ\H]HWYpGHOHPEHQ D N|]JD]GDViJL V]DEiO\R]yHV]N|]|N ± N|]WN D V]HQQ\H]pVL DGyN

$] HOLVPHUWVpJ D]W MHOHQWL KRJ\ PDJDV V]tQYRQDO~ D NpS]pV NLYiOyDN D] HOKHO\H]- NHGpVL OHKHWĘVpJHN D] LWW V]HU]HWW GLSORPi- YDOLOOHWYHKRJ\D]LQWp]PpQ\DPXQNDDGyN N|UpEHQ LV

$ IēRUYRVQē £OWDO£EDQ UHȵHNW£O D] HJ\HV YLV]RQ\ODWRNEDQ D Q«YV]µL PHJ V]µO¯W£VRN OHKHWēV«JHLUH «V PHJN«UGH]L D EHWHJHW KRJ\ KRJ\DQ V]µO¯WKDWMD (] D JHV]WXV RO\DQ

(]HQ DGDWRN DODSM£Q WHK£W D KLSRW«]LV PLV]HULQW D EHV]«OēN D] DQ\D

A megállapodás alapjául továbbra is az 1606-ban kötött Zsitva-torkolati béke V]ROJiOW DPHO\HW D] D]yWD N|W|WW V]HU]ĘGpVHNNHO HJ\WW PHJHUĘVtWHWWHN WRYiEEi néhány új