6]RFLROLQJYLV]WLNDLV]HPSRQWRNDPROGYDLPDJ\DU²URPiQNpWQ\HOY &

(1)

6]ypVV]yOiVPDJ\DUi]DWRN

² %LEOLDL OH[LNRQ 6]HUN +(5%(57+$$* %S 0LQGHKKH] PDJ\DU SiUKX ]DPNpQWOiVGPpJSpOGiXOER]yWRVaER]RQWRVKDMV&U&KDMpVV&U&¶V&U&HUGER]yWHUGPp O\H¶e.V]ORPERVaORPSRVY|0,.(6<LP²7(6]$MXKJ\DSM~YDOERUtWRWWEUH HJ\HUVV]U&iOODWYDODPLQWDUpWYDJ\D]HUGN|]|WWWDOiQDNNRUOHJQ\LOYiQYDOyEEDKDVRQOyViJ KDHJ\I&YHOYDJ\ER]yWWDOIiYDOERUtWRWWWHUOHWHWGRPEYDJ\KHJ\ROGDOWPHVV]LUOQp]QN

$02/1È5)(5(1&².867È5=2/7È1

-HVV]H

$ N|]HOP~OWEHQ /8':,*(0,/QHN DSUy WpYHGpVpW WHWWH V]yYi 5,72Ï.=6,*021' XJ\DQLVD5HMW]N|G0DJ\DURUV]iJFtP&VRUR]DWEDQDJ\|QJ\|VSDWDLWHPSORPPDONDSFVRODWRVDQ e]VDLiVW,]DLiVWHPOtWHWWHVD]WtUWDKRJ\HELEOLDLV]HPpO\HNQpSLHVQHYH-HVV]H

5,72Ï.H]WtUMDÄ(]WpYHGpV-HVV]HDKpEHU-LVDMEyO9XOJDWD,VDLXJ\DQtJ\DUHYLGHiOW.iUR O\LHUHG+RJ\PLNRUNLQpOpVPLpUWOHWWEHOOH-HVV]HQHPWXGRP,V]DL-HVV]H'iYLGNLUiO\

DSMDVtJ\-p]XVQDNVH´0DJ\DU1HP]HWGHFHPEHU7HKiW,VDL,]iM-LV]iMDYDJ\

-HVV]HQHYpWWpYHV]WHWWH|VV]H/8':,*,V]DLiVVDOD.UHDVpYHNHOHMpLJpOSUyIpWiYDODNL QHNQHYpWPDJ\DURVDQe]VDLiVQDNJ|U|J|VHQ+pV]DLRV]QDNODWLQRVDQ,VDLDVQDNKpEHUHVHQ-HVD MiK~QDNV]RNiVtUQL

7HKiW'iYLG6DODPRQPDMG-p]XV-HVV]HIiMiEyOW|U]V|NpEOV]iUPD]WDWQDNY|6iP

²e]V$]LPpQWHPOtWHWW'iYLGNLUiO\,VDLQDNOHJNLVHEEILDYROW5,72Ï.PHJMHJ\

]LÄ+RJ\PLNRUNLQpOpVPLpUWOHWWEHOOH>D-LV]iMEyO@-HVV]HQHPWXGRP´$-HVV]HYDJ\-HVVH QpY D] ~MV]|YHWWVpJL UpV]EHQ IRUGXO HO/N &VHO 5yP SpOGiXO Ä6DODPRQ DXWHPJHQXLW%RR]GH5DKDE%RR]DXWHPJHQXLW2EHGH[5XWK2EHGDXWHPJHQXLW,HVVH,HVVH DXWHPJHQXLW'DYLGUHJHP´1RYXP7HVWDPHQWXP*UDHFHHW/DWLQDH'HXWVFKH%LEHOJHVHOOVFKDIW 6WXWWJDUWXWiQQ\RPiV0WpVDJ|U|JPHJIHOHO6DOPØQGayJQQKVHQWÃQ%ÂH]yN W¤] e5DFE %ÂH] Ga yJQQKVHQ WÃQ d,ZE£G yN W¤] e5RÌT d,ZE£G Ga yJQQKVHQ WÃQ ,HVVD¹ ,HVVD¹GayJQQKVHQWÃQ'DQºGWÃQEDVLOD

1RVDKpEHU,VDLDJ|U|JQ\HOY&ELEOLDV]|YHJHNEHQPDJ\DUUDiWtUYD-HVV]iL(V]yYpJOH JHVKDQJV~O\~NHWWVKDQJ]yYDOGLIWRQJXVVDO]iUyGLNDPHO\HWDODWLQUDDHEHW&NNHOV]RNWDNiWtUQL NLHMWHQLSHGLJEL]RQ\iUDPLQWKD]iQNEDQSpOGiXOD&DHVDUQpYEHQLVV]RNiVpQHNYDJ\LVDJ|

$0QFK.EHQKiURP,H³³HHOIRUGXOiVYDQUDUDYEDPiUHPOtWHWW0WpV /NKHO\HNHQO1<Ë5,$17$/V]HUND0QFKHQL.yGH[ODWLQ±PDJ\DUV]yWiUD$NDGpPLDL .LDGy%S$IRUGtWyNYDJ\1pPHWL*\|UJ\YHWWHiWDNOKRQLQpYPLQWiWDOLJKDWXG KDWyPHJ

%h.</È6=/Ï

2U0LNOyVGRPEMD²HJ\N|]pSNRULKHO\QpY1DJ\UpYKDWiUiEDQ

1DJ\UpY KDWiUiEDQNHOHWHQDV]ONN|]|WWOiWKDWyHJ\NXQKDORPPHO\HW=VLGyKDORPQDNQHYH]QHN$N|UQ\pNH HJ\NRUOHJHOYROWPDMGD;,;V]i]DGLV]OWHOHStWpVHNQ\RPiQLWWD]iUWpUPDJDVSDUWMiQDNN|

]HOpEHQNHUOWHOVHKDORPUyONDSWDQHYpWD]DMHOHQWVWHOOMHOOHJ]HWHVVpJHNHWLVYLVHONRUD EURQ]NRULOHOKHO\PHO\HWD]DNNRULELUWRNRV.XELQ\L$OEHUWURNRQDDUpJpV].XELQ\L)HUHQFIH GH]HWWIHOVWHWWYLOiJV]HUWHLVPHUWWpVDPHO\UOD]~QQDJ\UpYLNXOW~UiWHOQHYH]WpN

0DJDD=VLGyKDORPHJ\VYDJ\QpSYiQGRUOiVNRULNXUJiQ0DLiOODSRWDHUVHQYHV]pO\H]

WHWHWWNHUHV]WOYH]HWWHNUDMWDHJ\NHUtWpVWpVHJ\YLOODPRVYH]HWpNHWNpWROGDOiEyOPXQNDJpSHNNHO KRUGWDNHOVDPH]JD]GDViJLP&YHOpVLVSXV]WtWMD/HJQDJ\REEUHODWtYPDJDVViJDN|UOEHOOP

(2)

6]ypVV]yOiVPDJ\DUi]DWRN

$KDORPWyOD7LV]DiUWHUHIHOp²DEURQ]NRULWHOHSOpVN|]YHWOHQV]RPV]pGViJiEDQ²ÈUSiG NRULOHOKHO\D]HJ\NRUL0LQGV]HQWIDOXKHO\HIHNV]LN$IDOXWHOV]|UpVXWROMiUDEDQHPOtWL LVPHUWtURWWIRUUiV.OWHUOHWHPHO\QHND=VLGyKDORPN|UOEHOODKDWiUiQIHNKHWHWWDNpVN|

]pSNRUEDQ²DQQDNNOWHUOHWpWOPHJNO|QE|]WHWYH²1DJ\UpYKH]WDUWR]RWWPDMGD]~MNRUUD DIDOXKDWiUiEDROYDGWM~O$Q\XODNV]LJHWLDSiFiNiWDGMiN3HWXUNHILD,VWYiQILD/iV]Oy QDND6]ROQRNPHJ\HL3RFKELUWRNRWPHO\HW)RONXVILD=HULHHJ\NRUQHNLNDGRWWGHD]HPOtWHWW /iV]OyUpJyWDPDJiQDNN|YHWHOW3RFKELUWRN*DOR=HQWKP\NORV0HQG]HQWK+\PXGpV%DED ELUWRNRNN|]|WWLQWHUIHNGW²%È57)$,6=$%Ï/È6=/Ï3HVWYiUPHJ\HW|UWpQHWpQHNRNOHYHOHV HPOpNHL %S EHQ 1DJ\UpYYHO HJ\WW HPOtWLN0\QG]HQWKHONH SUHGLXPRW ² 'OUHJHV]WiMDWpYHVKHO\QHYHNNHO%(1('(.*<8/$²=È'251e=62/'260È5,$-iV]

5pYIDOXN|]HOpEHQ1DJ\5pYIDOXODNRVDLQDNKDV]QiODWiEDQ´²È*26721*È%25$V]ROQRNL V]DQG]ViN²pYL|VV]HtUiVD,,UpV]=RXQXN²8WyEELHVHWEHQDNpUG MHOOHODNLDGyD]ROYDVDW EL]RQ\WDODQViJiW MHOH]WH V D WRU]XOW QpYDODN HOOHQpUH PLQGHQ EL]RQQ\DO 0LQGV]HQWSXV]WiUyOYDQV]y$QHYHDODSMiQtWpOYHWHPSORPRVIDOXYROWPHO\QHNHPOpNpWDQDJ\

UpYLHNPpJD;,;V]i]DGEDQLVUL]WpN3(67<)5,*<(6KHO\QpYJ\&MWpVpEHQtJ\tUWDNÄD¶ PLQW PRQGDWLN KDMGDQ H¶ KHO\HQ 0LQGV]HQW QHY&IDOX WHPSORPD OHKHWHWW´ ² 3HVW\ )ULJ\HV Np]LUDWRV KHO\QpYWiUiEyO.OV6]ROQRN.|]]pWHV]L%2*1È5$1'5È6.HFVNHPpW²6]ROQRN

$=VLGyKDORPQpYPDJ\DUi]DWDQHPLVPHUHWHV$KHO\QpYLVPHUHWHLQNV]HULQWD;9,,,V]i ]DGHOVIHOpEHQIRUGXOHOHOV]|UD]DOiEEPpJLGp]HQGKDWiUSHUEHQVDOHJNRUiEELWpUNpSHV iEUi]ROiVRNWyONH]GYH,NDWRQDLIHOPpUpV6LGyKDORPDPDLQDSLJNLPXWDWKDWypVpOKHO\QpY 3HVW\)ULJ\HVKHO\QpYJ\&MWpVHDONDOPiYDOLV|VV]HtUWiND]LWWHQLDGDWN|]ONPHJMHJ\H]YHÄKRJ\

D]HOQHYH]pVKRJ\UDJDGWUHiQHPWXGDWLN´LP

$1DJ\UpYpVDV]RPV]pGRV6iSSXV]WDLOOHWYH,QRNDELUWRNRVDLN|]|WWEHQNH]GG|WW KDWiUSHUVRUiQNpV]OWWDQ~YDOODWiVLMHJ\]N|Q\YHNEHQLJHQVRNpUWpNHVUpJpV]HWLQpSUDM]LpVW|U WpQHWLDGDWN|]|WWV]iPRVNRUDEHOLPiUDHOW&QWKHO\QHYHWWDOiOKDWXQN$SHUDQ\DJKR]HJ\V]tQH]HWW WpUNpSLVNpV]OW$WpUNpSHQDPHO\XJ\DQHOQDJ\ROWpV²PLYHOQHPPpUQ|NKDQHPIHOWHKHWOHJ HJ\tUQRNNpV]tWHWWH²PHJOHKHWVHQSRQWDWODQD=VLGyKDORPQDNHJ\pUWHOP&HQPHJIHOHOKHO\HQ iEUi]ROWKDORPQiOD6WUi]VDKDORPQpYROYDVKDWy(]PHJQ\XJWDWyDGDWQDNOiWV]LNDKDORPPHJ HO]HUHGHWLQHYpWLOOHWHQ

$WDQ~YDOORPiVRNEDQW|EEPiVKRQQDQLVPHUHWOHQHJ\NRULKHO\QpYN|]WWDOiONR]KDWXQND]

ÒUPLNOyVGRPEMDLOOHWYHKDOPDQpYYHO+HYHV0HJ\HL/HYpOWiU7|UYpQ\V]pNLLUDWRNIRO ÄFXPXOXPÒUPLNOyVGRPEMDYRFLWDULVROLWXP´$]DWpQ\KRJ\H]WDIXUFVDiPpUWHOPH]KHWKHO\

QHYHWW|EEHVHWEHQLV²PpJSHGLJQHPDWDQ~YDOORPiVRNEDQKDQHPDKLYDWDORVNpUGtYHNHQ² 2U0LNOyVYDJ\ÏU0LNOyVGRPEMiQDNQHYH]WpNXRIROÄ$]ÏU0LNOyV'RPEMDDODWWOHY ODSRVViW´HUHGHWpKH]PHJOHKHWVHQSRQWRVWiPSRQWRWQ\~MWPHO\HWDOiEEWiUJ\DOXQN

$NRQWH[WXVpVHJ\pELVPHUHWHLQNDODSMiQSRQWRVDQQHPORNDOL]iOKDWyKHO\QpYFVDN~MDEE UHMWpO\OHQQHDN|UQ\pNW|UWpQHWLWRSRJUiILiMiYDONDSFVRODWEDQKDHJ\ODWLQQ\HOY&KDWiUOHtUiVEDQ QHPWHWWpNYROQDDN|YHWNH]PHJKDWiUR]iVWÄFROOHÒU0LNOyVKDORPLPPRSHUDEXVXPMDP HWLDP=VLGyKDORPQXQFXSDWR´YDJ\LVÄD]ÒU0LNOyVKDORPQDNN|]|QVpJHVHQ=VLGyKDORP QDNLVPRQGRWWGRPE´XRIRO$]2U0LNOyVGRPEMDYDJ\ÒU0LNOyVGRPEKDORPWHKiW D=VLGyKDORPNRUiEELQHYHPHO\HOQHYH]pVPHOOHWWPiUHNNRUPHJMHOHQWDPDLHJ\HOUHLVPH UHWOHQHUHGHW&QpY

1DJ\UpYUOPHJOHKHWVHQV]yUYiQ\RVDNDN|]pSNRULIRUUiVRN7XGMXNKRJ\DNpVN|]pSNRU EDQ W|EE IHOWHKHWOHJ V]iPRV NO|QE|]NLVQHPHVL FVDOiG ELUWRNROWD PHO\QHN FVDN V]yUYiQ\RV HPOtWpVHNEOLVPHUMNHJ\HJ\WDJMiW.|]ONHJ\LNNHOV]HUHQFVpVHQD]RQRVtWKDWMXNDKDORPQDN QHYHWDGyV]HPpO\WEHQ7yV]HJpV3DOiGLFVKDWiUMiUiViKR]NLUiO\LHPEHUNpQWQHYH]WpNPHJ PDMG NOGWpN NL D QDJ\UpYL 2U 0LNOyVW1LFRODXV 2U GH 1DJKUHZ ² 'O $ ]LFKL pV

(3)

eOQ\HOY YiVRQNHLJUyI=LFK\FVDOiGLGVEiJiQDNRNPiQ\WiUD6]HUN1$*<,05(²1$*<,9È1²9e*

+(/<'(=6².$00(5(5(51²/8.&6,&63È/3HVW%XGDSHVW²$FVD OiGYDJ\UDJDGYiQ\QpYD¶WROYDM¶MHOHQWpV&UpJLPDJ\DURUV]yEyOPDJ\DUi]KDWy$V]yDN|]pS NRUEDQW|EEV]|UV]HUHSHOV]HPpO\QpYNpQWLVPDDPiVRGODJRVDQNLDODNXOWRUYDODNEDQD]HUHGHWL DODNSHGLJNpS]HWWV]DYDNEDQRUR]LOOHWYH|VV]HWpWHOHNEHQSORUJD]GDIRUGXOHO7(6]&VQ6]

(QDJ\UpYLQHPHVVHOW|EEIRUUiVEDQQHPWDOiONR]XQNpVH]DFVDOiGQpYVHPIRUGXOHOW|EEV]|U 0pJLVQDJ\YDOyV]tQ&VpJJHOIHOWpWHOH]KHWKRJ\DQpSQ\HOYD]V]HPpO\pYHOYDJ\XJ\DQD]RQFVDOiG YDODPHO\WDJMiYDONDSFVROWD|VV]HH]WDKDOPRWIHOWHKHWOHJD;9V]i]DGEDQLWWHQLWDOiQKRVV]~

LGHLJELUWRNROWI|OGMHHVHWOHJHJ\iOWDOXQNLVPHUHWOHQiPDKHO\EHOLHNV]iPiUDMHOHQWVpVHPOpNH ]HWHVHVHPpQ\YDJ\V]RNiVUpYpQ

8J\DQDNNRU HQQHN D] HJ\H]pVQHN DODSMiQ iOOtWKDWMXN KRJ\ D ;9,,, V]i]DGL HOQHYH]pVHN N|]ODKDORPHUHGHWLQHYHYDOyEDQDV]RNDWODQDEE2U0LNOyVGRPEMDYROWVD]ÒU0LNOyVKDORPY GRPEHQQHNDQpYQHND]HUHGHWHOKRPiO\RVXOiVDIRO\WiQQpSHWLPROyJLiYDOPyGRVXOWYiOWR]DWD

(]D]DGDWD]pUWNO|Q|VHQpUGHNHVPHUWKLWHOHVD]~MNRULJIHQQPDUDGWVHJpV]HQSRQWRVDQOR NDOL]iOKDWyN|]pSNRULKHO\QHYHWKDJ\RPiQ\R]UiQNRO\DQYLGpNHQDKRODN|]pSNRUEyOIDOYDNHJpV]

VRUiUyO ² N|]WN 1DJ\UpYUO ² QHPKRJ\ WRSRJUiILDL KDQHP D NLUiO\L HPEHUHN HPOtWpVHLQ NtYO ELUWRNW|UWpQHWLDGDWRNDWLVFVDNHOYpWYHLVPHUQNVXJ\DQDNNRUYDODPHO\HVWHQpYHUHGHWpUHLVUiYLOiJtW (]HNXWiQD]HPOtWHWWWpUNpSPHOOpNOHWHQV]HUHSO6WUi]VDKDORPNLIHMH]pVWQHKH]HQWXGMXN HOKHO\H]QLPHUWDWDQ~YDOORPiVRNEDQHGGLJQHPWDOiOWXNPHJFVXSiQN|YHWNH]WHWKHWMNKRJ\

DKDV]QiODWEyOPiUNLNRSyN|]pSNRULHUHGHW&pVD]~MHOQHYH]pVPHOOHWWHNNRUSiUKX]DPRVDQpO KDUPDGLNYiOWR]DWUyOYDQV]y(]DQpYIHOWHKHWOHJDW|U|NNRUEyOHUHGH]WHWKHWpVORJLNXVDQOH YH]HWKHWDKDORPVWUDWpJLDLIHNYpVpEOXJ\DQLVDIpOV]LJHWHQIHNY1DJ\UpYIDOXKR]EHYH]HW~W QiOD]RUV]iJ~WKR]N|]HOIHNV]LN$KDORPNpVN|]pSNRUWPHJHO]PDJ\DUQHYHWHUPpV]HWHVHQ WRYiEEUDLVLVPHUHWOHQPDUDGV]iPXQNUD

5È&=0,./Ï6

e / 1 < ( / 9

6]RFLROLQJYLV]WLNDLV]HPSRQWRNDPROGYDLPDJ\DU²URPiQNpWQ\HOY &

EHV]pON|]|VVpJHNNXWDWiViEDQ

$ PROGYDL PDJ\DU²URPiQ NpWQ\HOY& EHV]pON|]|VVpJHN NXWDWiViEDQ PHJMHOHQ V]RFLROLQJYLV]WLNDL V]HPSRQWRN UpV]EHQ D KDJ\RPiQ\RVDQ ÄPROGYDL FViQJyN´QDN YDJ\

ÄFViQJyPDJ\DURN´QDN QHYH]HWW FVRSRUWRN iOWDODP DONDOPD]RWW PHJMHO|OpVpYHO iOOQDN |VV]HIJ JpVEHQ $ FtPEHQ V]HUHSO PROGYDL PDJ\DU²URPiQ NpWQ\HOY& EHV]pON|]|VVpJHN WHUPLQXV WHFKQLFXVEHYH]HWpVHXJ\DQLVNpWRO\DQIEENpUGpVKH]NDSFVROyGLNDPHO\HNQHNDYL]VJiODWDQHPNLV UpV]EHQV]RFLROLQJYLV]WLNDL IHODGDW $ FVRSRUWRN PHJMHO|OpVpUH EHYH]HWHWW N|UOtUiV N|YHWNH]HWHV DONDOPD]iVDpUGHNpEHQGROJR]DWRPEDQDKDJ\RPiQ\RVNOVHWQRQLPiWD]LGp]HWHNPHOOHWWD]RN EDQDSDUDIUi]LVRNEDQLVLGp]MHOHNN|]|WWKDV]QiORPDPHO\HNEHQMHOHQWVpJHYDQDPHJQHYH ]pVQHN$]HJ\LNNpUGpVD] LO\HQPyGRQN|UOKDWiUROWFVRSRUWRNHWQRQLPiLWpULQWLDPiVLNSHGLJ D NpWQ\HOY& N|]|VVpJHN Q\HOYL UHSHUWRiUMiW DONRWy HJ\LN Q\HOYL NyG D KHO\L PDJ\DU HUHGHW&

Q\HOYMiUiVVWiWXViQDNPHJKDWiUR]iViUDWHKiWNOVpVEHOVOLQJYRQLPiLUDYRQDWNR]LN

0LQGNpWNpUGpVEHQN|]|VKRJ\DUiMXNDGRWWYiODV]RNHOVGOHJHVHQDODLNXVEHV]pONN|Up EHQ pOQ\HOYL LGHROyJLiN PHQWpQ IRJDOPD]yGWDN PHJ pV ² H]]HO |VV]HIJJpVEHQ ² NHYpVEp YHWWpNILJ\HOHPEHDKHO\LN|]|VVpJHNKHWHURJpQQp]SRQWMDLW(]HNQHND]LGHROyJLiNQDND]HJ\LN UpWHJHSpOGiXODÄFViQJyVRUVNpUGpVHN´NRQWH[WXViEDQUDJDGKDWyPHJDKRODPROGYDLN|]|VVpJHNUH DONDOPD]RWW HJ\VpJHV HOQHYH]pV LQGRND OHKHW KRJ\ ² PLQW +$726 3È/ 6]HPSRQWRN D