)RUUiV%UD]VLOHWDO
iEUD $ YL]VJiOW OWHWYpQ\ QHWWy MHOHQpUWpNH )WKD NO|QE|]
GLV]NRQWOiEDNpVHOWpU V] O iUDNHVHWpQDWHOHStWpVKH]DGRWWRViOODPL
WiPRJDWiVVDO
0(*È//$3Ë7È62..g9(7.(=7(7e6(.-$9$6/$72.
$ NXWDWiVL SUREOpPiYDO NDSFVRODWEDQ D PHJIRJDOPD]RWW KLSRWp]LVHN EL]RQ\tWiVD YDJ\
PHJG|QWpVH pUGHNpEHQ YpJ]HWW NXWDWiVRN D NLYiODV]WRWW NXWDWiVL PyGV]HUHN VHJtWVpJpYHO D
YL]VJiOW FVDOiGL JD]GDViJEDQ YpJ]HWW PpUpVHN DODSMiQ D N|YHWNH] PHJiOODStWiVRNDW WHWWpN
OHKHW Yp
$ERUV] O WHUPHV]WpVEHQDYL]VJiOWKpWpYEHQDM|YHGHOPH] VpJWRYiEEURPORWW(QQHN
N|YHWNH]WpEHQDM|YHGHOHPYpJOHOW QWV WRVYHV]WHVpJPXWDWNR]LNËJ\DMHOHQOHJL
WHUPHOpVN|OWVpJKDV]RQDUiQ\DLDP N|GWHWpVWVHPEL]WRVtWMiN-|YHGHOHPKLiQ\iEDQD
IHMOHV]WpVLOHKHW VpJHNPHJV] QQHN(EE ON|YHWNH] HQQDSMDLQNEDQQHPDWHUPHOpVEHQ
NHOHWNH]HWWSpQ]HV]N|]|NV]ROJiOMiNHOV GOHJHVDODSMiWD]~MUDWHUPHOpVQHNKDQHP
YDOyV]tQ VtWKHW HQDJD]GiNWiMpVQ|YpQ\V]HUHWHWHPHOOHWWLRSWLPLVWDV]HPOpOHWH
$]OWHWYpQ\HNWDJROWViJDPpUHWHHJ\DGRWWJD]GDViJEDQDGRWWLG SRQWEDQDGRWWViJQDN
WHNLQWHQG D]]DOKRJ\DJD]GDViJRNIHMOHV]WpVpQpODNRQFHQWUiFLyUDNHOOW|UHNHGQLDGiV
YpWHOpVFVHUHDONDOPD]iViYDOLVDKHO\HVWiEODPpUHWNLDODNtWiVDpUGHNpEHQ$WiEODPpUHWpV
JD]GDViJLPpUHWQ|YHOpVHHOV VRUEDQDERUV] O M|YHGHOHPWHUPHO NpSHVVpJpQHNIJJYpQ\H
$WiEODPpUHWDKDWpNRQ\WHUPHOpVWNHOOVHJtWVHD]RSWLPiOLVWiEODPpUHWNLDODNtWiViYDOD
PXQNDWHUOHWYiOWR]WDWiViQDNLGHMpWPLQLPDOL]iOQLOHKHVVHQ$]DONDOPD]RWWP YHOpVL
PyGRNIHMOHV]WpVWLJpQ\HOQHNNLVHEEWpUiOOiVPHOOHWWLQDJ\REEKHNWiURQNpQWLW NHV]iP
NLDODNtWiVDLQGRNROWDPLQ VpJLWHUPpNHO iOOtWiVpUGHNpEHQ$P YHOpVLPyGRNWHOHStWpVL
DQ\DJLJpQ\HpVPXQNDLG V]NVpJOHWHHOWpU $]HOYpJ]HWWPXQNDLG HOHP]pVHN
DOiWiPDV]WMiNKRJ\DWpUiOOiVFV|NNHQWpVpYHODPXQNDLG V]NVpJOHWQ D]pO PXQND
KDWpNRQ\ViJDFV|NNHQ
$]HJ\HVIJJ|Q\pVDPDJDVNRUGRQP YHOpVPyGGDOHJ\DUiQWOHKHWVRNDWpVMyPLQ VpJHW
WHUPHOQLKDDWHFKQROyJLDLP YHOHWHNHWELROyJLDLODJWHFKQLNDLODJPXQNDV]HUYH]pVLpV
N|OWVpJROGDOUyOMyOiWJRQGROMXN$PDJDVNRUGRQP YHOpVPyGVRNNDOIHV]HVHEE
PXQNDUHQGHWN|YHWHOpVDP YHOHWLVRUUHQGPyGRVtWiViWLVNHYpVEpW ULPLQWD]HJ\HV
IJJ|Q\$P YHOpVPyGNLYiODV]WiVDN|UOWHNLQW V]DNPDLG|QWpV)LJ\HOHPEHNHOOYHQQLD
N|OWVpJNO|QEVpJHNHWpVDUHiOIRO\DPDWRNV]HUYH]pVpQHNOHKHW VpJHLWDPHO\QHNHJ\LN
OHJNRPSOH[HEEPyGV]HUHDKiOyGLDJUDPHOMiUiVRN$WHUPpVEL]WRQViJiQDNpVPLQ VpJpQHN
IRNR]iVDpUGHNpEHQORJLNXVOHQQHDPXQNDLJpQ\HVHEEWpUiOOiVYDJ\LVDPDJDVNRUGRQ
P YHOpVPyGYiODV]WiVDGHYHOHDPXQNDKDWpNRQ\ViJDLOOHWYHNDOFV|NNHQ
$KiOyWHUYH]pVLPyGV]HUHNDUHiOIRO\DPDWRNOHERQ\ROtWiViWiWWHNLQWKHW VpJpWPHJN|QQ\tWLN
KDDJ\RUVV]iPtWyJpSHVHONpV]tWKHW VpJpVPyGRVtWKDWyViJUHQGHONH]pVUHiOO$WHUPHOpV
UHiOIRO\DPDWDLQDNWHUYH]pVpKH]HO Q\|VHQDONDOPD]KDWyDQRUPDWtYPXQNDLG V]NVpJOHWL
pUWpNHNLVPHUHWpEHQpVIHOKDV]QiOiViYDOD&30PyGV]HUUHONpV]tWHWWKiOyGHD
UHQGHONH]pVUHiOOyHU pVPXQNDJpSHNNLKDV]QiOiViQDNRSWLPDOL]iOiVDV]HPSRQWMiEyOD
5$036PyGV]HUWHNLQWKHW FpOUDYH]HW EEQHN$MHOHQpUWHNH]pVHUHGPpQ\HLDKiOyGLDJUDP
HOMiUiVHOWHUMHV]WpVpWpVV]pOHVN|U DONDOPD]iViWWiPRJDWMiN$IHQROyJLDLIi]LVRNUDDODSR]RWW
KiOyWHUYH]pVDGWDN|OWVpJFV|NNHQWpVLOHKHW VpJHNNLKDV]QiOiVDpUGHNpEHQMDYDVORPD
NO|QE|] WtSXVKiOyNNLGROJR]iViWpVWHUMHV]WpVpW$IHQROyJLDLIi]LVRNUDpSO
KiOyWHUYH]pVLPyGV]HUHNHWMDYDVORPDV] O WHUPHV]WpVVHOIRJODONR]yYDODPHQQ\L
IHOV RNWDWiVLLQWp]PpQ\WDQDQ\DJiEDEHpStWHQLpVRNWDWQL$NXWDWiVLHUHGPpQ\HNDODSMiQ
LJD]ROWQDNWDUWRPKRJ\DWHUPpVPLQ VpJHJ\LN]iORJDDV]DNV]HU Q|YpQ\YpGHOHPPHO\D
PHJHPHOWYHJ\V]HUiUDNPHOOHWWLVHOIRJDGKDWyN|OWVpJV]LQWHQWDUWKDWy(]WD
KiOyWHUYH]pVLHOMiUiVLVKDWpNRQ\DQVHJtWL
(OWpU LG MiUiVHVHWpQPHJiOODStWKDWyKRJ\DPXQNDLG V]NVpJOHWLpUWpNHNLVpVDN|]YHWOHQ
N|OWVpJHNLVPHJYiOWR]QDNPHO\HWPLQGHQJD]GDViJLpYEHQREMHNWtYWpQ\H] QHNNHOO
WHNLQWHQQN$WiSDQ\DJYLVV]DSyWOiVV]QHWHOWHWpVHDWHUPHV]WpVVRUiQFVDNLGHLJOHQHV
MHOOHJ OHKHWDV]QHWHOWHWpVE ODGyGyOiWV]DWM|YHGHOPHNQHPWHNLQWKHW NYDOyV
M|YHGHOPHNQHN
$WpQ\OHJHVpVYDOyVN|OWVpJHOHPHNWXGDWRVJ\ MWpVpYHOpVHOHP]pVpYHONHOOD
ERUV] O WHUPHV]WpVWLV]WDM|YHGHOPpQHNNLV]iPtWiViWEL]WRVtWDQL$WHUPpNSiO\DUpV]WYHY L
QDJ\REEWROHUDQFLiWWDQ~VtWKDWQiQDNHJ\PiVLUiQWPLYHOMHOHQKHO\]HWEHQD]DODSDQ\DJ
WHUPHO NLV]ROJiOWDWRWWViJDDOHJQDJ\REE$WHUPHO WDV] O NXOW~UDLUiQWLV]HUHWHW
QDSMDLQNEDQpVN|]pSWiYRQYDOyV]tQ OHJiWVHJtWLDJD]GiONRGiVQHKp]VpJHLQ$]LG
HO UHKDODGWiYDODV]HUHWHWpU]pNHOKHW FV|NNHQpVpWLVWDSDV]WDOKDWMXN$]DODSDQ\DJWHUPHO
FVDOiGLJD]GDViJRNEDQ|NRQyPLDLWpQ\H] NPHOOHWWMHOHQYDQDWHUP I|OGDV] O D
V]DEDGEDQYpJ]HWWPXQNDDWHUPHOpVLWUDGtFLyV]HUHWHWHDPHO\DV] O WHUPHV]WpV
IHQQWDUWKDWyViJiQDNHJ\LNDODSMiWNpSH]L(]PDDWHUPpNSiO\DWRYiEELUpV]WYHY LQpO
NLHOpJtW KDV]RQQDONHFVHJWHW
$WiMHJ\VpJDJURWHFKQLNDLVDMiWRVViJDLDERUV] O IDMWDLJpQ\HpVDPXQNDV]HUYH]pV
|VV]KDQJMDDODSMiQNHOOPHJKDWiUR]QLDWHOHStWpVPyGMiWpVWHFKQROyJLiMiW$]iOODPL
WiPRJDWiVPpUWpNHDN|OWVpJV]HUNH]HWEHQNLPXWDWRWWpVDW|UYpQ\EHQPHJIRJDOPD]RWWQiO
NLVHEEPLYHODVDMiWPXQNDpVDQ\DJHOV]iPROiViWDV]iPYLWHOLW|UYpQ\QHPWHV]LOHKHW Yp
$WHOHStWpVHNQDJ\ViJDDJD]GDViJPpUHWHLW OIJJHWOHQOpYHQWHPLQLPiOLVDQRV
OpSWpN NHOOOHJ\HQWHUP pYHWIHOWpWHOH]YH$]LQSXWiUDNDWHOHStWpVHN~MUDLQGXOiViYDO
XJUiVV]HU HQPHJQ WWHN+iURPpYDODWWNDO
g66=()2*/$/È6
$ ERUV] O WHUPHV]WpV D PDJ\DU PH] JD]GDViJ HJ\LN OHJW|EE JRQGGDO N]G iJD]DWD DQQDN
HOOHQpUHKRJ\DIHOKDOPR]yGyNXWDWiVLHUHGPpQ\HNDWHUPHV]WpVIHMO GpVpWHUHGPpQ\H]WpN$
KDJ\RPiQ\RN iSROiVD iWKDWMD D] iJD]DWRW $ ERUV] O WHUPHV]WpV WHOMHV UHQGV]HUpEHQ
YLOiJV]HUWH pV QiOXQN LV IRUUDGDOPL YiOWR]iVRN N|YHWNH]WHN EH $ IHMO GpV HOOHQpUH D Q|YpQ\L
NXOW~UiN HJ\LN OHJPXQNDLJpQ\HVHEE Q|YpQ\H D V] O PHO\QpO D WHUPHV]WpVWHFKQROyJLD
IHMOHV]WpVH PLQGLJ D WHUPpV PHQQ\LVpJL pV PLQ VpJL Q|YHOpVpW pV D UiIRUGtWRWW Np]LPXQND
FV|NNHQWpVpWH]HQNHUHV]WOYpJV VRURQDM|YHGHOHPPD[LPDOL]iOiViWFpOR]WDPHJ
.XWDWyPXQNiP VRUiQ YL]VJiOWDP D NO|QE|] P YHOpVPyGRN HOWpU PXQNDLG V]NVpJOHWpW
KiOyWHUYHW NpV]tWHWWHP D PXQNDLG V]NVpJOHWUH DODSR]YD HOWpU LG MiUiVL YiOWR]DWRNUD
WRYiEEi YL]VJiOWDP D NXWDWiVL LG V]DNEDQ D WHUPHV]WpVL N|OWVpJHN DODNXOiViW $] OWHWYpQ\HN
IHQQWDUWKDWyViJiQDNPHJiOODStWiViKR]DWHOHStWpVHNN|OWVpJHLQHNYiOWR]iViWYL]VJiOWDPPHJ
$ NXWDWiV QpJ\ MyO HOKDWiUROKDWy UpV]WHUOHWUH RV]WKDWy $] pUWHNH]pVHOV UpV]pEHQ D NXWDWiVL
SUREOpPD EHKDWiUROiViYDO IRJODONR]WDP NLHPHOWHP D]RNDW D FpORNDW DPHO\HNHW D NpV EELHN
VRUiQ PHJYiODV]ROWDP $] pUWHNH]pVPiVRGLN UpV]pEHQ D WpPiKR] NDSFVROyGy V]DNLURGDORP
IHOGROJR]iViWHOHP]pVpWYpJH]WHPHO
$KDUPDGLN IHMH]HWEHQ D NXWDWiV WiUJ\iYDO pV PyGV]HUHLYHO IRJODONR]WDP %HPXWDWWDP D
PRGHOOJD]GDViJRW DKRO D] DGDWJ\ MWpVW OHIRO\WDWWDP PDMG D PXQNDLG V]NVpJOHWL pUWpNHN
PHJiOODStWiViKR]KDV]QiOWPXQNDV]HUYH]pVLPyGV]HUHNHWVRUROWDPIHOpVHOHPH]WHP
$] pUWHNH]pV QHJ\HGLN IHMH]HWpEHQ D VDMiW NXWDWiVL HUHGPpQ\HNHW IRJDOPD]WDP PHJ $
SUREOpPD WiUVDGDOPL N|UOKDWiUROiViYDO NH]GWHP D OHJQDJ\REE IHMH]HWHW 0XQNDV]HUYH]pVL
PRGHOOHNHW NpV]tWHWWHP PHO\EHQ IHQROyJLDL Ii]LVRN ILJ\HOHPEHYpWHOpYHO D PXQNiN
VRUUHQGMpEHQ PHJiOODStWRWWDP D] HJ\HV WHYpNHQ\VpJHN PXQNDLG V]NVpJOHWpW
gVV]HKDVRQOtWRWWDPNpWP YHOpVLPyGWHYpNHQ\VpJpVPXQNDLG V]HUNH]HWpWHOWpU WpUiOOiVRN
PHOOHWW $ WHYpNHQ\VpJHN NDSDFLWiVLJpQ\pQHN LVPHUHWpEHQ HONpV]tWHWWHP pV HOHPH]WHP D
PRGHOOJD]GDViJ KiOyWHUYpW HOWpU LG MiUiVL YiOWR]DWRNUD $ NLDODNtWRWW KiOy DONDOPDV D
UHiOIRO\DPDWRNWpUEHQpVLG EHQW|UWpQ PHJMHOHQtWpVpUHYDODPLQWVHJtWVpJpYHOWHYpNHQ\VpJHN
$] HONpV]tWHWW KiOyWHUYHN WHYpNHQ\VpJHLQHN LVPHUHWpEHQ HONpV]tWHWWHP D] HJ\HV LG MiUiVL
YiOWR]DWRNN|OWVpJHLQHN|VV]HKDVRQOtWiViW0HJiOODStWRWWDPKRJ\D]HOWpU LG MiUiVLIHOWpWHOHN
PHOOHWWMHOHQWNH] N|OWVpJHNNO|QEVpJHV]LJQLILNiQV
7RYiEELDNEDQ PHJYL]VJiOWDP D WHUP OWHWYpQ\HN N|OWVpJV]HUNH]HWpW PHO\E O
PHJiOODStWRWWDPKRJ\DNXWDWiVLLG V]DNEDQDM|YHGHOPH] VpJURPORWWpVD]2ODV]UL]OLQJIDMWD
HVHWpQ YHV]WHVpJHVVp YiOW D WHUPHV]WpV $ YL]VJiODWDLP D]W PXWDWWiN KRJ\ D NLPXWDWRWW
N|OWVpJHNHJ\UpV]pYHODWHUPHV]W QHPV]iPROtJ\M|YHGHOHPpU]HWHQ
$ VDMiW NXWDWiVL HUHGPpQ\HN XWROVy UpV]pEHQ D] OWHWYpQ\HN IHQQWDUWKDWyViJiQDN pV
PHJWpUOpVpQHN OHKHW VpJHLYHO IRJODONR]WDP 0HJiOODStWRWWDP KRJ\ MHOHQ iUYLV]RQ\RN
PHOOHWW RV iOODPL WiPRJDWiV ILJ\HOHPEHYpWHOpYHO D] ~M OWHWYpQ\HNQpO D EHOV
PHJWpUOpVLNDPDWOiE
(QQHN N|YHWNH]WpEHQ D WHUPHOpVW IHQQWDUWMD D QHKp] JD]GDViJLSLDFL IHOWpWHOHN PHOOHWW LV
iWPHQHWLOHJOHPRQGYDPpJD]HJ\V]HU ~MUDWHUPHOpVOHKHW VpJpU O$]LO\HQM|YHGHOPLKHO\]HW
D] pOHWV]tQYRQDO pOHWPLQ VpJ URYiViUD LV PHKHW (]W D MHOHQVpJHW QHYH]LN PpJ D
V]DNLURGDORPEDQLVDNLVHEEJD]GDViJRNQDJ\REEpOHWNpSHVVpJpQHNNUt]LVW UpVpQHN
6800$5<
:LQHJUDSH JURZLQJ LV RQH RI WKH PRVW SUREOHPDWLF EUDQFKHV RI +XQJDULDQ DJULFXOWXUH LQ
VSLWH RI WKH IDFW WKDW DFFXPXODWLQJ UHVXOWV LQ UHVHDUFK KDYH XOWLPDWHO\ UHVXOWHG LQ WKH
GHYHORSPHQWRIJURZLQJ&KDULVKLQJWUDGLWLRQKDVDOZD\VEHHQSUHVHQWLQYLQHFXOWLYDWLRQ,Q
WKH ZKROH V\VWHP RI ZLQHJUDSH JURZLQJ WKHUH KDYH EHHQUHYROXWLRQDU\FKDQJHVDOORYHUWKH
ZRUOG LQFOXGLQJ +XQJDU\ DV ZHOO 'HVSLWH DOO WKH GHYHORSPHQW RI DOO WKH SODQW YDULHWLHV
XQGRXEWHGO\ LW LV YLQH WKDW LV WKH PRVW ODERXU LQWHQVLYH SODQW 'HYHORSLQJ WKH WHFKQRORJ\ RI
JURZLQJKDVDOZD\VEHHQDLPHGDWLQFUHDVLQJTXDQWLW\DQGTXDOLW\WKURXJKGHFUHDVLQJPDQXDO
ODERXUZKLFKXOWLPDWHO\WHQGHGWRLQFUHDVHSURILWDELOLW\
'XULQJ P\ UHVHDUFK , LQYHVWLJDWHG WKH GLIIHUHQW ZRUNLQJWLPH GHPDQGV RI YDULRXV PRGHV RI
FXOWLYDWLRQ , PDGH QHWZRUN DQDO\VLV EDVHG RQ ZRUNLQJ WLPH GHPDQG GLIIHUHQW ZHDWKHU
FRQGLWLRQV , ZDV DOVR GRLQJ UHVHDUFK LQWR WKH WUHQGV RI JURZLQJFRVWV 7R VWDWH WKH
PDLQWDLQDELOLW\RIYLQHODQGV,VWXGLHGFKDQJLQJFRVWVRISODQWLQJ7KLVUHVHDUFKLQYROYHVIRXU
VHSDUDWH ILHOGV ,Q WKHILUVW SDUW RI WKH GLVVHUWDWLRQ , ZDV WU\LQJ WR ILQG WKH ERXQGDULHV RI WKH
UHVHDUFK WRSLF LGHQWLI\LQJ WKH DLPV , ODWHU RQ IRXQG DQ DQVZHU WR ,Q WKHVHFRQG SDUW, ZDV
GHDOLQJZLWKVSHFLDOOLWHUDWXUHUHODWLQJWRWKHWRSLF
,QWKHWKLUGSDUW,GHDOWZLWKWKHWRSLFRIWKHUHVHDUFKDQGLWVPHWKRGVLQWURGXFLQJWKHPRGHO
IDUP ZKHUH , FROOHFWHG GDWD WKHQ , HQOLVWHG DQG DQDO\VHG WKHPHWKRGVRIZRUNRUJDQLVDWLRQ,
XVHGWRVWDWHWKHYDOXHVRIZRUNLQJWLPHUHTXLUHPHQWV
,QWKHIRXUWKSDUW,GHVFULEHGP\RZQUHVHDUFKDQGLWVUHVXOWV7KHORQJHVWVHFWLRQZDVGHDOLQJ
ZLWKWKHVRFLDODVSHFWRIWKHSUREOHP,PDGHZRUNRUJDQLVDWLRQDOPRGHOVZKHUHLQWKHRUGHU
RI ZRUNLQJWDVNV FRXULGHULQJ SKHQRORJLFDO SKDVHV , ZRUNHG RXW WKH ZRUNLQJ WLPH GHPDQGV
IRUFHUWDLQDFWLYLWLHV,FRPSDUHGWKHVWUXFWXUHRIDFWLYLWLHVDQGZRUNLQJWLPHUHTXLUHPHQWVIRU
WKH WZR PRGHOV RI FXOWLYDWLRQ ZLWK GLIIHUHQW VSDFLQJV /HDUQLQJ WKH FDSDFLW\ UHTXLUHPHQW RI
WKH DFWLYLWLHV , PDGH DQG DQDO\VHG QHWZRUN SODQQLQJ IRU GLIIHUHQW W\SHV RI ZHDWKHU 7KH
QHWZRUN , ZRUNHG RXW LV VXLWDEOH IRU UHSURGXFLQJ UHDO SURFHVVHV LQ VSDFH DQG WLPH DQG IRU
FDUU\LQJRXWFHUWDLQDFWLYLWLHVXQGLVWXUEHGO\.QRZLQJKRZWKHQHWZRUNSODQVZRUNHG,PDGH
D FRPSDULVRQ UHJDUGLQJ FRVWV EHWZHHQ FHUWDLQ ZHDWKHU W\SHV , VWDWHG WKDW WKH GLIIHUHQFH LQ
FRVWVIRUYDULRXVZHDWKHUYHUVLRQVZDVVLJQLILFDQW
, DOVR VWXGLHG WKH VWUXFWXUH RI FRVWV IRU \LHOGLQJ YLQHODQGV DQG , VWDWHG WKDW SURILWDELOLW\
GHWHULRUDWHG GXULQJ WKH SHULRG RI UHVHDUFK LQ WKH FDVH RI ,WDOLDQ 5LHVOLQJ YDULHW\ LW EHFDPH
ORVLQJ %DVHG RQ P\ ILQGLQJV , IRXQG WKDW WKH JURZHU GLG QRW WDNH SDUW RI WKH H[SHQVHV LQWR
DFFRXQWVRKHPXVWKDYHKDGWKHIHHOLQJRIJURZLQJLQFRPH
,Q WKH ODVW VHFWLRQ RI P\ GLVVHUWDWLRQ GHDOLQJ ZLWK WKH UHVXOWV RI P\ UHVHDUFK , ZDV VWXG\LQJ
WKHSRVVLELOLWLHVRIWKHYLQHODQGV¶PDLQWDLQDELOLW\DQGWKHLUSD\EDFN,FDPHWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQ
WKDWDWSUHVHQWSULFHFRQGLWLRQVDWJRYHUQPHQWDOVXEVLG\WKHLQWHUQDOUDWHRIUHWXUQZDV
$V D FRQVHTXHQFH WKH JURZHU ZLOO XSNHHS SURGXFWLRQ HYHQ XQGHU GLIILFXOW HFRQRPLFPDUNHW
FRQGLWLRQV WHPSRUDULO\ JLYLQJ XS WKH FKDQFH RI VLPSOH UHSURGXFWLRQ 7KLV LQFRPH VLWXDWLRQ
PLJKWEHDFKLHYHGRQO\DWWKHH[SHQVHRIWKHVWDQGDUGRIOLYLQJ7KLVLVWKHSKHQRPHQRQRIWHQ
FDOOHGWKHJUHDWHUYLWDOLW\RIVPDOOIDUPVWKHLUVSHFLDOFULVLVHQGXULQJDELOLW\
.g6=g1(71<,/9È1Ë7È6
(]~WRQ LV N|V]|Q|P PLQGD]RNQDN DNLN NXWDWyPXQNiPEDQ pV pUWHNH]pVHP PHJtUiViEDQ
VHJtWVpJHPUH YROWDN .O|Q LV N|V]|QHWHW PRQGRN 3K' 6RPRJ\L 6iQGRU SURIHVV]RU ~UQDN
WpPDYH]HW PQHN 'U 6]pOHV *\XOD SURIHVV]RU ~UQDN SURJUDPYH]HW PQHN 'U %X]iV *\XOD
SURIHVV]RU ~UQDN DOSURJUDPYH]HW PQHN 3K' KDELO .RFVRQGL -y]VHI HJ\HWHPL WDQiU ~UQDN
WDQV]pNYH]HW PQHN 'U .RYiFV $WWLOD FtP]HWHV HJ\HWHPL GRFHQV ~UQDN 'U /DNQHU =ROWiQ
HJ\HWHPLGRFHQV~UQDN6]|OO VV\,VWYiQOHNWRU~UQDN3yFVDL&VDEDYDODPLQW+DQJ\iVL=VROW
RNOHYHOHV DJUiUPpUQ|N XUDNQDN pV D *\DNRUODWL 6]HUYH]pVL pV 9H]HWpVL 7DQV]pN
NROOHNWtYiMiQDN
.|V]|Q|P 'U GU PS[KF +DMyV /iV]Oy SURIHVV]RU ~UQDN pV 'U .RFVLV /iV]Oy HJ\HWHPL
GRFHQV ~UQDN D PXQNDKHO\L YLWD RSSRQHQVHLQHN KRJ\ QHP FVDN EtUiOWiN pUWHNH]pVHPHW
KDQHPKDV]QRVV]DNPDLWDQiFVRNNDOLVVHJtWHWWpNPXQNiPDW
.|V]|Q|PFVDOiGRPQDNDVHJtWVpJHWWUHOPHWpVEt]WDWiVWDPHO\HWDPXQNiPYpJ]pVHN|]EHQ
NDSWDPW ON
6]DNLURGDORPMHJ\]pN
$&.2))5/2SHUiFLyNXWDWiVpVYiOODODWLWHUYH]pV
.|]JD]GDViJLpV-RJL.|Q\YNLDGy%XGDSHVW
$',=(6,5HQGV]HUHOHP]pVpVLUiQ\tWiV6WDWLV]WLNDL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
$.,,KWWSZZZDNLLKX,1)25067$7,6=7
$.,,KWWSZZZDNLLKX,1)25067$7,6=7
$5&+,%$/'5'9,//25,$5/+iOyVLUiQ\tWiVLUHQGV]HUHN
.|]JD]GDViJLpV-RJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
$](XUySD8QLy$JUiUJD]GDViJD,,pYIRO\DPV]iPS
È1*<È1-0(1<+e57=32'0$1,&=.</.,66-)HQQWDUWKDWy
pUWpN U] DONDOPD]NRGyN|UQ\H]HWpVWiMJD]GiONRGiVGHILQtFLyNpV
MHOOHP] N;;;9,,*HRUJLNRQ1DSRN.HV]WKHO\,N|WHWS
%$&+0$11:$UEHLWVSV\FKRORJLVFKH%HZHUWXQJVNULWHULHQIUGLH
$UEHLWVJHVWDOWXQJ$UEHLWVZLVVHQVFKDIWpYIV]iPS
%(1(7,$ILQQPH] JD]GDViJIHQQWDUWKDWyViJDD](XUySDL8QLyEDQ
;;;9,,*HRUJLNRQ1DSRN.HV]WKHO\,,N|WHWS
%(1(7,$]~MDJUiUSROLWLNDpVDPH] JD]GDViJIHQQWDUWKDWyViJD
;;;9,,*HRUJLNRQ1DSRN.HV]WKHO\,,N|WHWS
%e1<(,)=$1$7+<*0HUUHWDUWDYLOiJpV0DJ\DURUV]iJ"
.HUWpV]HWpV6] OpV]HWV]S
%2726($W NHKLiQ\pVW NHSyWOiVMHOHQW VpJHD]OWHWYpQ\JD]GDViJLpOHWpEHQ
6] O WHUPHV]WpVpV%RUiV]DW,9pYIV]S
%2726(&6(35(*,332/Ï1<,%$V] O pVERUWHUPHOpVNDWDV]WHUHLpV
PHJYDOyVXOiViQDNOHKHW VpJHLDKD]DLWHUPHOpVEHQ
6] O WHUPHOpVpV%RUiV]DW9,,pYIV]S
%2726(6] O IDMWiNNRPSOH[YL]VJiODWD]HPLWHUPHV]WpVEHQ
6] O WHUPHV]WpVpV%RUiV]DW9,,,pYIV]S
%2726(&6(1.,50DJ\DURUV]iJERUYLGpNHLQHN|NRQyPLDLpV|NROyJLDL
SRWHQFLiOMD6] O WHUPHV]WpVpV%RUiV]DW9,,,pYIV]S
%2726(*È/1e%256Ï',-6] O OWHWYpQ\HLQNpOHWJ|UEpMH
6] O WHUPHV]WpVpV%RUiV]DW,;pYIV]S
%2726(6] O pVERUWHUPHOpVYHUWLNXPDIRO\DPDWYL]VJiODWiQDNDODSMDL
6] O WHUPHV]WpVpV%RUiV]DW;pYIV]S
%2726(3$33/1<(6 .$V] O WHUP KHO\LNDWDV]WHUpQHNIHMOHV]WpVH
pVERUYLGpNLIHOGROJR]iVD6] O WHUPHV]WpVpV%RUiV]DW
;,,pYIV]S
%5$=6,/-$V] O pVERUWHUPHOpVYHUWLNXPM|YHGHOPH] VpJpQHNYL]VJiODWD
%DODWRQIHOYLGpNLWHUPHO V]|YHWNH]HWHNEHQ
'RNWRULpUWHNH]pV.HV]WKHO\
%5$=6,/-.2&621',-/$.1(5=$V] O WHUPHV]WpVPXQNDV]HUYH]pVL
IHODGDWDLQDNUDFLRQDOL]iOiVDDKiOyWHUYH]pVDONDOPD]iViYDO
;;9,,,ÏYiUL7XGRPiQ\RV1DSRN,9N|WHWS
%8=È6*<%$.21<,/6] O OWHWYpQ\HNOpWHVtWpVH
*D]GDViJL6]DNWDQiFVRN.HV]WKHO\V]
&6È.,&60e6=È52662SHUiFLyNXWDWiVLPyGV]HUHNDONDOPD]iVD
DPH] JD]GDViJEDQ0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVWS
&6(35(*,3$V] O PHWV]pVHpVILWRWHFKQLNDLP YHOHWHL
0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
&6(35(*,36] O WHUPHV]WpVLLVPHUHWHN0H] JD]GD.LDGy%XGDSHVW
&6(35(*,3$V] O N|UQ\H]HWIRUPiOyWiMDODNtWyOHKHW VpJH
$.HUW%XGDSHVWS
&6(35(*,36] O WHUPHV]WpVLLVPHUHWHN0H] JD]GD.LDGy%XGDSHVW
',(75,&+67(,1+(J\KX]DORVWiPEHUHQGH]pVD0HWWHUQLFKUHQGV]HU
6] O ERU,QIRUPpYIV]S
',0e1<,*pSHVtWpVIHMOHV]WpVDNHUWpV]HWLiJD]DWRNEDQ
$NDGpPLDL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
',Ï)È6,/$PLQ VpJLERUV] O WHUPHV]WpVWXGRPiQ\RVDODSMDL
0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
',Ï)È6,/.g51<(,%Qp,--È6=,9e=(5e1<,($GDWRNDV] O
pYLWpOLIDJ\NiURVRGiViUyO'pO'XQiQW~ORQ
6] O WHUPHV]WpVpV%RUiV]DW9,,,pYIV]
'<621(eOHWQNDGLJLWiOLVNRUEDQ+9*
(3(5-(6,,.È//$,00$*<$5,%RUiV]DW
0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
(8)LJ\HO V]S
)(//(*-6=$%ÏÈ6HJpGOHWDPXQNDV]HUYH]pVLJ\DNRUODWRNKR]
$JUiUWXGRPiQ\L(J\HWHP.HV]WKHO\(J\HWHPLMHJ\]HWS
)(//(*-0H] JD]GDViJLPXQNDV]HUYH]pViOWDOiQRVUpV]
0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
)(//(*-0XQNDWHOMHVtWPpQ\PHJKDWiUR]iVDQ|YpQ\WHUPHV]WpVEHQ
0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
)(//(*-0XQNDV]HUYH]pVDQ|YpQ\WHUPHV]WpVEHQ
0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
)(5(1&=ÈhOWHWYpQ\EHUXKi]iVRNWiPRJDWiVD7ROQDPHJ\pEHQ
;/,*HRUJLNRQ1DSRN.HV]WKHO\S
)(5(1&=ÈÈOODPLWiPRJDWiVKDWiVDD]OWHWYpQ\HNOpWHVtWpVpUH
9,,1HP]HWN|]L$JUiU|NRQyPLDL7XGRPiQ\RV1DSRN*\|QJ\|V
,N|WHWS
*g%/g6*-$.$%%.,66).,661e%256=e.,e
./(1&=1(5$Qp$V] O WHUPHV]WpVpVIHOGROJR]iV]HP
pVPXQNDV]HUYH]pVH0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
*25'26È$](XUySDL8QLyEHOV SLDFD(XUySD)yUXP,9pYIV]S
+$-Ï6/-$/$66*6&+:$5=%$&+50XQNDV]HUYH]pV1pPHWRUV]iJ~M
WDUWRPiQ\DLQDNPH] JD]GDViJL]HPHLEHQ
*D]GiONRGiV;;;9,,pYIS
+$-Ï6/0$*<$5,-$WXGiViEUi]ROiVpVD]LQIRUPiFLyWHFKQROyJLD
IHOKDV]QiOiViQDNOHKHW VpJHLDPH] JD]GDViJLPXQNiNV]HUYH]pVpEHQ
*D]GiONRGiV;/pYIV]S
+$-Ï6/0$*<$5,-$NLV]HPLWHYpNHQ\VpJHNWHUYH]pVH
*D]GiONRGiV;/,,pYIV]S
+$-Ï6/)(5(1&=È:RUNRUJDQLVDWLRQDQGHFRQRPLFYDOXDWLRQRIYLQH
JUDIWSURGXFWLRQLQ+XQJDU\:RUNVFLHQFHVLQVXVWDLQDEOHDJULFXOWXUH
3URFHHGLQJV;;9,,,&,267$&,*59&RQJUHVV+RUVHQV'HQPDUN
:DJHQLQJHQ3HUVS
+$/0$,3$](XUySDL8QLyDJUiUUHQGV]HUH
0H] JD]GD.LDGy%XGDSHVW
+$00(50$11632+/(:/(,7+2/'+5DWLRQDOLVLHUXQJXQG
ZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH$UEHLWVRUJDQLVDWLRQ]ZHL6HLWHQHLQHU6DFKH
.RRSHUDWLRQV]iPS
+259È7+&6.HYHVHEEDERUH[SRUW.HUWpV]HWpV6] OpV]HWV]S
+867,,$IHQQWDUWKDWyPH] JD]GDViJLP V]DNLIHMOHV]WpVDODSHOYHL
;;;9,,*HRUJLNRQ1DSRN.HV]WKHO\,,N|WHWS
-8+26/'XQiQW~OLNLVJD]GiNM|YHGHOPLKHO\]HWH
3pFVL(J\HWHPL.|Q\YNLDGy3pFV
.È1725%:(,1,1*(5,6] O YDJ\Q\DUDOy"
0DJ\DU0H] JD]GDViJ/,,,pYIV]S
.$,6(5*6] O WHUPHV]WpVQNIpQ\EHQpViUQ\pNEDQ
0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
.$77:,1.(/:1HW]ZHUNWHFKQLN3UDNWLVFKH(UIDKUXQJHQ
1HXH%HWULHEVZLUWVFKDIWV]iP
.$8)0$11$'(6%$=(,//(*$NULWLNXV~WPyGV]HUpQHNPDWHPDWLNDL
DODSMDL
.(&6.e6/$](*.MRJKDUPRQL]iFLyMiUyOPiUPDJ\DUV]HPPHOLV
.p]LUDW%XGDSHVWS
.,66($]HJ\HVIJJ|Q\P YHOpVPyGNLDODNtWiVD
0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
./(1&=1(5$Qp$V] O P YHOpVJpSLWHFKQROyJLiMD
0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
./(1&=1(5$Qp$V] O pVERUWHUPHOpV|NRQyPLiMD.HUWpV]HWLpV
eOHOPLV]HULSDUL(J\HWHPgNRQyPLDL,QWp]HW%XGDSHVW
.23&6$</0LO\HQWDODMWV]HUHWDV] O "
.HUWpV]HWpV6] OpV]HWpYIV]S
.29È&6$1$*<,7,021%+iOyGLDJUDPPyGV]HUHNDONDOPD]iVDD
3pFVL ÈOODPL *D]GDViJ NHUWpV]HWpEHQ ÈFV .RYiFV %HOiN
0H] JD]GDViJL]HPHNYH]HWpVpQHNJ\DNRUODWD
0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVWS
.29È&6$%$8(5)$]RUV]iJPyGRVtWiVUDNLGROJR]RWWVSHFLiOLVLQWp]NHGpVL
WHUYHN YpJUHKDMWiViQDN YH]pQ\OpVH KiOyGLDJUDP PyGV]HUUHO
.DQGLGiWXVLeUWHNH]pV%XGDSHVW
.29È&6$$ONDOPD]RWWUHQGV]HUHOPpOHWpVLQIRUPDWLND
(J\HWHPLMHJ\]HW6RSURQ
.2=0$3$V] O WHUPHV]WpVH,0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
.2=0$36] O pVWHUPHV]WpVH$NDGpPLDL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
.5,6=7(1*<6] O ERU,QIRUPpYIV]S
/$'Ï/6]HUYHVHOPpOHWpVPyGV]HUWDQ
.|]JD]GDViJLpV-RJL.|Q\YNLDGy%XGDSHVW
/$.1(5=.2&621',-$PH] JD]GDViJLNLVpVN|]pSYiOODONR]iVRN
KHO\]HWHV]HUHSHOHKHW VpJHLpVNRUOiWDLDPDJ\DUJD]GDViJLWiUVDGDOPL
PRGHUQL]iFLyEDQ0DJ\DU9iOODONR]iVIHMOHV]WpVL$ODStWYiQ\%XGDSHVW
/$326$-6] O KHJ\HND%DODWRQIHOYLGpNHQ0H] JD]GDViJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
/e1È5')$ONDOPD]RWWSV]LFKROyJLD*RQGRODW.|Q\YNLDGy%XGDSHVW
/,&+71(&.(57$%DODWRQIUHG&VRSDNLERUYLGpNW|UWpQHWH
9HV]SUpPPHJ\HL/HYpOWiUNLDGYiQ\D9HV]SUpP
/8.È&623$3326Ï)$,&67g5g.)%HYH]HWpVDKiOyWHFKQLND
V]iPtWyJpSHVIHOKDV]QiOiViED.6+%XGDSHVW
0(,1+$5'7+'DV$XIGHFNHQGHU8QIDOOXUVDFKHQHUVWHU6FKULWW]XLKUHU
%HVHLWLJXQJ$UEHLWXQG$UEHLWVUHFKWV]iPS
0e6=È526625%È11e1$*<0,PSRUWV]DEiO\R]iVpVSLDFYpGHOHPD]
DJUiUiJD]DWEDQ(XUySD)yUXP,,,pYIV]S
0(= *$='$6È*,67$7,6=7,.$,e9.g1<9
0(= *$='$6È*,67$7,6=7,.$,e9.g1<9
0,.8/È6,$](8N|]|VERUSLDFLV]HUYH]HWH
$JURLQIRUP.LDGypV1\RPGD.)7%XGDSHVW
0,.8/È6,6] OpV]HWLERUiV]DWLV]DEiO\R]iVD](XUySD8QLyEDQ)90(8
,QWHJUiFLyV2V]WiO\$JURLQIRUP.LDGypV1\RPGD.)7%XGDSHVW
3$5È1<*<.RUV]HU PXQNDV]HUYH]pV.|]JD]GDViJLpV-RJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
32/75-$*,1%2/7<$16=.,-2SWLPiOLVIRO\DPDWRNHOPpOHWH
.|]JD]GDViJLpV-RJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
5$0365HVXOVHDOORNDWLRQDQGPXOWLSURMHFWVFKHGXOLQJ&HLU/WG/RQGRQ
O6&+1(&.(1%85*(5$QDJ\WpUiOOiV~pVDQRUPiOOWHWYpQ\HNJD]GDViJRVViJD
pVSUREOHPDWLNiMD
6&+8/7=+5)RUVFKXQJLP:HLQEDX7UDGLWLRQXQG,QQRYDWLRQ
'LH6WHOOXQJ'HXWVFKODQGV3URYLQFLD$XWRQRPDGL7UHQWRS
6(1*(31$WDQXOyV]HUYH]HWNLDODNtWiViQDNHOPpOHWHpVJ\DNRUODWD+9*
6/(,=,1*(5*($]LUiQ\tWiVLPXQNDV]HUYH]pVH
.|]JD]GDViJLpV-RJL.LDGy%XGDSHVW
6202*<,6*D]GiONRGiVLUHQGV]HUHNU OÄ$JUR´)]HWHNV]S
6=(17(/(.,.0$-=,.=6+259È7+7$ERUWHUPHOpV
pVERUNHUHVNHGHOHPIHMOHV]WpVpQHNLQIRUPiOLVIHOWpWHOHL
;;;9,,*HRUJLNRQ1DSRN.HV]WKHO\,,N|WHWS
6=(17,679È1(*<(7(0KWWSZZZNHHERULQIRKX
6=,/È*<,=6(OV G|QWpVHND3KDUHWiPRJDWiVLSiO\i]DWRNEDQ
$](XUySDL8QLyDJUiUJD]GDViJDV]
6= .(/6] O WHUPHV]WpVLWHFKQROyJLDKHO\]HWHIHMOHV]WpVpQHNOHKHW VpJHL
6] O WHUPHV]WpVpV%RUiV]DW;pYIV]S
6= .(/6] O WHUPHV]WpV-HJ\]HW.e(.HUWpV]HWL) LVNRODL.DU.HFVNHPpW
6= .(/*È63È59$V] O N|UQ\H]HWEDUiWWHUPHV]WpVH
0H] JD]GD.LDGy%XGDSHVW
7$1È&6,$ERUKiERU~IRO\WDWyGLN.HFVNHPpWL/DSRN.)7.HFVNHPpW
7|UYpQ\DV] O WHUPHV]WpVU OpVERUJD]GiONRGiVUyO&;;,%RUiV]DWI]HWHN
PHOOpNOHWHV]S
75$&,)eOHOPLV]HUWHUPHOpVpVPH] JD]GDViJDSLDFJD]GDViJEDQ
0H] JD]GD.LDGy%XGDSHVW
85),3$KDWpNRQ\P WUiJ\i]iVpVDIHQQWDUWKDWyIHMO GpVNRQIOLNWXVDLQDN
YL]VJiODWDGXQiQW~OL]HPLDGDWRNDODSMiQ
'RNWRUL3K'eUWHNH]pV.HV]WKHO\
9$-'$/$PDJ\DUDJUiUJD]GDViJ(8FVDWODNR]iVLVWUDWpJLiMD
$JURLQIRUP.LDGypV1\RPGD.)7%XGDSHVWS
9(6=(/,70H] JD]GDViJLPXQNDIRO\DPDWRNV]HUYH]pVpQHNPyGV]HUWDQL
DODSMDL(J\HWHPLMHJ\]HW0RVRQPDJ\DUyYiU
=,(*/(5-hOWHWYpQ\WHOHStWpVKH]LJpQ\HOKHW iOODPLWiPRJDWiVRNYL]VJiODWD
.HUWpV]HWLpVeOHOPLV]HULSDUL(J\HWHP) LVNRODL.DU.HFVNHPpW