$QHW\PRORJLFDOGLFWLRQDU\RI7XUNLVKDQGWKHKLVWRU\
RIWKH+XQJDULDQODQJXDJH
7KLVSDSHUJLYHVDGHWDLOHGVXUYH\VWDUWLQJZLWKÈUPLQ9iPEpU\¶VGLFWLRQDU\RIWKHKLVWRU\
RI7XUNLVKHW\PRORJLFDOGLFWLRQDULHVDQGUHODWHGDVSHFWVRIHW\PRORJLFDOUHVHDUFK$UHFHQWSURGXFWRI WKDWUHVHDUFKLV³$Q(W\PRORJLFDO'LFWLRQDU\RIWKH7XUNLVK/DQJXDJH´FRPSLOHGE\WKHDXWKRU WKDWFDQEHVHHQDVDFRQFLVHSUHOLPLQDU\VDPSOHRIWKHRULJLQDOO\SODQQHGSURMHFW,QWKHVHFRQG SDUWRIWKHSDSHUWKHDXWKRUGHVFULEHVVRPH+XQJDULDQUHODWHGHW\PRORJLFDODQDO\VHVDVVRFLDWHG ZLWKWKDWSURMHFWHJRQ+PRJ\RUyµKD]HOQXW¶WDQ~µZLWQHVV¶WDSVLIOHVµEXQQ\¶WRUµIXQHUDO EDQTXHW¶ HWF WKDW DUH HVSHFLDOO\ UHOHYDQW ZLWK UHVSHFW WR WKH OLQJXLVWLF DQG FXOWXUDO KLVWRU\ RI +XQJDULDQ
+$6$1(5(1
$PDJiQKDQJ]yNDSFVRODWRNIRQROyJLiMiEyO
$PDJiQKDQJ]yNDSFVRODWRNSRQWRVDEEDQD]HJ\PiVWyOV]yWDJKDWiUUDOHOYiODV]
WRWWGHHJ\pENpQWV]RPV]pGRVPDJiQKDQJ]yNNDSFVRODWDLYDJ\LV D K L i W X V R N V]i PRV Q\HOYEHQ KiWUiQ\RV NHUOHQG DODN]DWQDN V]iPtWDQDN (J\HV Q\HOYHNEO WHOMHVHQ KLiQ\R]QDNPiVQ\HOYHNDKLiWXVEL]RQ\RVHVHWHLQHNNLDODNXOiViWNO|QIpOHHV]N|]|NNHO PHJDNDGiO\R]]iNGHPiVHVHWHLWYiOWR]DWODQIRUPiEDQYDJ\YDODPLO\HQIHOV]tQL IRQROyJLDL IRO\DPDWVHJtWVpJpYHOIHOROGYDKDJ\MiNPHJMHOHQQL$KLiWXVRNHONHUOpVpQHNIHOROGiV i QDNLOOHWYHNLW|OWpVpQHNPyGMDLN|]|WWPHJWDOiOKDWyD]HJ\LNYDJ\DPiVLNPDJiQKDQJ]y W|UOpVHDNpWPDJiQKDQJ]yN|]|VV]yWDJEDYRQiVD|VV]HROYDGiVVDO GLIWRQJL]iFLyYDO YDJ\D]HJ\LNPDJiQKDQJ]yIpOPDJiQKDQJ]yYiDODNtWiViYDOWRYiEEiYDODPLO\HQPiV VDOKDQJ]yEHWROGiVDDNpWPDJiQKDQJ]yN|]p(]HNDIEEWtSXVRNWRYiEERV]WiO\R]KD WyNDOWtSXVRNUD$]DOiEELDNEDQD±SRQWEDQHOV]|UiWWHNLQWMNH]HNHWD]DOWtSXVRNDW
$WDQXOPiQ\PiVRGLNUpV]pEHQD±SRQWEDQDV]iPEDYHWWPDJ\DU IRQROyJLDLMH OHQVpJHNHOHP]pVHN|YHWNH]LNRSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWLNHUHWEHQ
$ K L i W X V I H O R O G i V L V W U D W p J L i N W L S R O y J L i M D ± $PL D PDJiQ KDQJ]yW|UOpVWLOOHWLQ\LOYiQYDOyDQNpWDODSHVHWOHKHWVpJHVD]HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVH PLQWD]DODWWLSpOGiNEDQLOOHWYHDPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVHPLQWDDODWWLDN EDQ $] D pV D SpOGD UpV]OHWHVHEE WiUJ\DOiViW O 52*(5/$66 3KRQRORJ\ $Q LQWURGXFWLRQWREDVLFFRQFHSWV&DPEULGJHD]EpVESpOGipW52'(5,&)
&$6$/, 9RZHOHOLVLRQLQKLDWXVFRQWH[WVZKLFKYRZHOJRHV"/DQJXDJH±
NOD]FGpVFGSpOGipW6,37È53e7(5+LiWXV,Q.tVpUOHWLIRQHWLND ODERUDWyULXPLIRQROyJLD6]HUN+81<$',/È6=/Ï 'HEUHFHQ±8 +RZWR JHWULGRIKLDWXVHV ,Q&RQWHPSRUDU\ +XQJDULDQ SHUVSHFWLYHV RQOLQJXLVWLFV OLWHUDWXUH DQGSHGDJRJ\6]HUN%È5'26-(1±5$9,6+(25(<±6=(17*<g5*<,6=,/È5'±3$8/
7,7&+0$56+9HV]SUpP0HJMHOWW D VYpG
HNKMÖC WT o >HNKMÖWT@
OiQ\ W|EEHV ¶OiQ\RN¶
E HFDNyQLJHUNRQJyLQ\HOY
F' CMRC o >FCMRC@
YHV] E|JUH ¶E|JUpWYHV]¶
F PDJ\DUPRUIRIRQROyJLDLIRO\DPDWODSRQWRW
UQOQTWQFKM o >UQOQTQFKM@V]RPRURGLN G PDJ\DUIHV]WHOHQJ\RUVEHV]pG
'ÕÖKGÖTVo='ÕÖGÖT?a='ÕÖGÖ?HQQ\LpUW D VYpG
HNKMÖC HP o >HNKMÖCP@
OiQ\ D ¶DOiQ\¶
E HFDNy
CMRC nPKMG6G o =CMRCPKMG6G?
E|JUH NLFVL ¶NLFVLE|JUH¶
F PDJ\DUPRUIRIRQROyJLDLIRO\DPDWODSRQWRW MQV5K QP o >MQV5KP@NRFVLQ G PDJ\DUIHV]WHOHQJ\RUVEHV]pG
TCÖ nFCÖ5WNo =TCÖFCÖ5WN?UiDGiVXO
$]LO\HQW|UOpVHNPRUIpPiQEHOOLVHOIRUGXOKDWQDNOH[LNDOL]iOyGYDPLQWDNCÖÕ N'CÖÕOiQ\aOHiQ\TCÖT'CÖUiaUHiWtSXV~HVHWHNEHQLOOHWYHDQHPN|]Q\HOYLGH V]pOHVN|UEHQKDV]QiOWMQN'ICÖNK5MQNÖ'IKCÖNK5NROOHJLiOLVJKIGÖPKnJKIKGÖPKnKL JLpQLDO'V'TQNQÖIKnO'V'QTQNQÖIKnPHWHRUROyJLDIpOpNEHQ$]LO\HQSpOGiNEDQ W|EEQ\LUHD]HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVpYHOWDOiONR]KDWXQNDPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]yW|U OpVHPLQWDOHJXWROVyIHQWLSpOGiEDQULWNiEEDKLiWXVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVVHOYDOyIHOR O GiViQDND]LO\HQOH[LNDOL]iOWHVHWHLEHQ
$ GLIWRQJL]iFLy LV W|UWpQKHW ÄEDOUD´ D]D] D] HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yQDN V]yWDJPDJRQ EHOOLIpOPDJiQKDQJ]yYiDODNtWiViYDOPLQWDEHOLSpOGiNEDQLOOHWYHÄMREEUD´D]D]
DPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]yWpULQWPyGRQPLQWDEHOLHNEHQ$SpOGiNEDQDONDOPD]RWW SRQWRNV]yWDJKDWiUWMHO|OQHN$DSpOGDIRUUiVD -$&48(6'85$1'±6,37È53e7(5
%HYH]HWpVDIRQROyJLiED%SDESpOGip&$6$/,LPDDSpOGiUyO O6,37È5+LiWXVDESpOGiUyOSHGLJ 6,37È53e7(5±7g5.(1&=<0,./Ï67KH SKRQRORJ\RI+XQJDULDQ2[IRUG±pVDOiEED]SRQWRW
D IUDQFLD
NK G o =NLG? NW G o =NYG?
N|W LQILQLWtYXV] ¶N|WQL¶ EpUHO LQILQLWtYXV] ¶EpUHOQL¶
E QJLWL=DLUpEDQEHV]pOWN|]pSV]XGiQLQ\HOY
K\Q nM7 o =K\QnM7?
QiG FXNRUQiG ¶FXNRUQiGIDMWD¶
D EULWDQJRO
6+3VT o =6+V?¶V]tQKi]¶Y|6+3VT +MN o =6+3VT+MNB?¶V]tQKi]L¶
E PDJ\DUIDNXOWDWtYSRV]WOH[LNiOLVIRO\DPDW
nWVQÖ o =nYVQÖ?DXWy'WTQÖRno ='YTQÖRn?(XUySD
$ IpOPDJiQKDQJ]yVRGiVQDN D]RN D] HVHWHL DPHO\HNEHQ QHP M|Q OpWUH GLIWRQJXV DEEDQNO|QE|]QHNDIHQWLHNWOKRJ\DOpWUHM|YIpOPDJiQKDQJ]yDV]yWDJPDJRQNtYO KHO\H]NHGLNHOYDJ\LVDV]yWDJNH]GHWEHQPLQWD]DODWWLSpOGiNEDQLOOHWYHDV]yWDJ ]iUODWEDQPLQWDDODWWLDNEDQ
D LJHGHQ\XJDWDIULNDLQ\HOY&$6$/,LP
IW nDC o =IYnDC?
V] J\pNpQ\ ¶J\pNpQ\WV]¶
E PDJ\DUIHV]WHOHQOH[LNDOL]iOW
OCÖTKn o =OCÖTLn?a=OCÖTKLn?0iULD D PDJ\DUIHV]WHOHQOH[LNDOL]iOW
MnN'KFQUMQÖR o =MnN'LFQUMQÖR?NDOHLGRV]NyS E PDJ\DUIHV]WHOHQJ\RUVEHV]pG
TCÖK5O'T o =TCL5O'T?UiLVPHU
$PDJiQKDQJ]y|VV]HROYDGiVpULQWKHWNpWNO|QE|]PDJiQKDQJ]yWDPHO\HNYD ODPLO\HQN|]EOVPLQVpJ&YpROYDGQDN|VV]HPLQWDDSpOGiEDQNpWD]RQRVU|YLG PDJiQKDQJ]yWDPHO\HNHJ\HWOHQKRVV]~YiYiOQDNPLQWDEEHQYDJ\SHGLJNpWD]R QRV±DNiUU|YLGDNiUKRVV]~±PDJiQKDQJ]yWDPHO\HNHWHJ\HWOHQSpOGiQ\XNKHO\HWWHVtW PLQWDFEHQ(QQHNDOHJXWROVyWtSXVQDND]HUHGHWHKRPiO\RVWHNLQWKHW|VV]HROYD GiVQDND]HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVpQHNYDJ\DPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVpQHN DOHJW|EEHVHWEHQOHKHWHWOHQPHJPRQGDQLPHO\LNIRO\DPDWUyOYDQV]yWXODMGRQNpSSHQ
D V]DQV]NULW/$66LP UCÖ WÖXCV5C o =UQXCV5C?
EHV]pOW ¶EHV]pOW¶
E V]DQV]NULW/$66LP
PC CUVK KJCo =PCÖUVKÖJC?
QHJ YDQ LWW ¶QLQFVLWW¶
F PDJ\DUIHV]WHOHQJ\RUVEHV]pG
TCÖ CÖNFQ\ o =TCÖNFQ\? UiiOGR]
QÖTn nNnVÖ o =QÖTnNnVÖ? yUDDODWW
$FWtSXVQDNLVYDQQDNOH[LNDOL]iOWYDJ\IpOLJOH[LNDOL]iOWHVHWHLPLQWSpOGiXO In]FnUÖQÕIn\FnnUÖQÕJD]GDVV]RQ\LOOHWYHVWFPKNÖKMVWFPKKNÖKMWXGQLLOOLN
$ PiVVDOKDQJ]yEHWROGiVQDN XJ\DQFVDN W|EE DOHVHWH YDQ $ OHJHJ\V]HU&EE D]
DPLNRUDEHWROGRWWPiVVDOKDQJ]yD]DGRWWQ\HOYDODSPiVVDOKDQJ]yMDGHIDXOWFRQVRQDQW WHKiWHJ\RO\DQPiVVDOKDQJ]yDPHO\QHNDPLQVpJHVHPPLO\HQPyGRQQHPIJJDN|U Q\H]PDJiQKDQJ]yNpWyOPLQWDDODWWLSpOGiNEDQ$DDODWWLSpOGiYDONDSFVRODWEDQ OPpJ5(1e.$*(5 2SWLPDOLW\7KHRU\&DPEULGJH±D EDODWWLUyOUpV]
OHWHVHEEHQO*((57%22,-7KHSKRQRORJ\RI'XWFK2[IRUG
D DVLQLQNDNDPSD3HUXEDQEHV]pOWDQGRNLHJ\HQOtWLQ\HOY&$6$/,LP
PQ 1 RKUK K o =PQORKUKVK?
VJ M|Y V|S|U M|Y ¶V|S|UQLIRJRN¶
E KROODQG
CnTVCo =C!nTVC?¶DRUWD¶GHZCnU o =ZCnU?=ZC!nU?¶NiRV]¶
$KROODQGSpOGDHVHWpEHQILJ\HOMNPHJKRJ\DV]yKDQJV~O\PLQWiMiWyOIJJNL W|OWGLNHDKLiWXVHJ\JpJH]iUKDQJJDOYDJ\VHPD]DRUWDV]yDPDJiQKDQJ]yNDSFVRODW PiVRGLN WDJMiQ KDQJV~O\R]yGLN PtJ DFKDRV V]y D] HOVQ $ PDJ\DUUDO NDSFVRODWEDQ IHOPHUOW KRJ\ HQQHN D Q\HOYQHN D=X? YROQD D] DODSPiVVDOKDQJ]yMD O 52%(570
9$*2 (PSW\ FRQVRQDQWV LQ WKH PRUDLF SKRQRORJ\ RI +XQJDULDQ $/+ ± GHMREEDQPHJYL]VJiOYDDGROJRWNLGHUOKRJ\H]QHPtJ\YDQ/DOiEEDSRQWRW 0iVUpV]WDKLiWXVRO\DQPiVVDOKDQJ]yYDOLVNLW|OWKHWDPHO\QHNPLQVpJHDN|U Q\H]PDJiQKDQJ]yNHJ\LNpWOYDJ\PiVLNiWyOIJJD]LO\HQKLiWXVW|OWPiVVDOKDQJ]y EL]RQ\RVpUWHOHPEHQYDODPHO\LNV]RPV]pGRVPDJiQKDQJ]yEyOÄV]iUPD]LN´
D EULWDQJROÄN|WU´
XbFM 3PF VbP+Mo =XbFMTPVbP+M?¶YRGNDpVWRQLN¶
E KROODQG%22,-LP
DKnUMQR o =DKLnUMQR?¶PR]L¶\G P o =\GLP?¶WHQJHUHN¶
F PDJ\DU6,37È5LPODSRQWRW
RKQÖVUn o =RKLQÖVUn?SLyFDFKV51Ö KÖV o =FKV51ÖLKV?GLFVtW
(]]HO D KLiWXV HONHUOpVpQHNIHOROGiViQDN NO|QE|]HVHWHLYHO IRJODONR]y IXWyODJRV iWWHNLQWpVQNYpJpUHpUWQN$WRYiEELDNEDQN|]HOHEEUOLVV]HPJ\UHYHVV]N D]RNDW DWtSXVRNDWDPHO\HNDPDJ\DUEDQHOIRUGXOQDN
$ ] H O V P D J i Q K D Q J ] y W | U O p V H ±(]W|UWpQLNDPDJ\DUEDQDPHO OpNQpYEO LJpW NpS]tWXOO pVRGLNHGLN|GLNHOWWEDUQDEDUQtWOD]DOD]XO V]RPRU~V]RPRURGLNIHNHWHIHNHWHGLNO6,37È5±7g5.(1&=<LP±7g5.(1
&=<±6,37È5 0DJiQKDQJ]yaVHPPLYiOWDNR]iVRNDPDJ\DUEDQ 1\.±
NO(]DV]yEDQIRUJyWROGDOpNRNpVQHPDW|YHNVDMiWRVViJDDPLWRQQDQWXG KDWXQNKRJ\XJ\DQH]HNDW|YHNPiVPDJiQKDQJ]yNH]GHW&WROGDOpNRNHOWWPHJWDUWMiN YpJVPDJiQKDQJ]yMXNDW3pOGiXODEDUQiEEOD]iEEV]RPRU~EEIHNHWpEEN|]pSIRN~
DODNRNEDQDWYpJLPDJiQKDQJ]yPHJPDUDGpVDN|]pSIRN9EEMHOpQHNPDJiQKDQJ]yMD D]DPHO\LNQHPMHOHQLNPHJDIHOV]tQHQODSRQWRW$W|UOGPDJiQKDQJ]yPLQVp JpUHYDJ\KRVV]iUDQp]YHVHPPLO\HQPHJN|WpVQHPpUYpQ\HVOLQQHQWXGMXNKRJ\ W|U OpVUO QHP SHGLJ EHWROGiVUyO YDQ V]y /HKHW IHOV J|PE|O\& J|PE|O\|GLN N|]pSV IDNyIDNtWYDJ\DOVyQ\HOYiOOiV~FVRUEDFVRUEXOOHKHWHO|OYDJ\KiWXONpS]HWWOHKHW NHUHNYDJ\QHPNHUHNOHKHWKRVV]~YDJ\U|YLG(J\HVPDJiQKDQJ]yYpJ&W|YHNXWiQD]RQ EDQ±DPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVHKHO\HWW±HJ\VWROGyGLNEHD]HPOtWHWWNpS]NHOpSOROFVy VtWNDUFV~VtWiOODQGyVXOIHOIRUUyVRGLN(UUOUpV]OHWHVHEEHQODOiEEDSRQWRW (J\PiVLNSpOGDDKLiWXVKHO\]HWQHND]HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVpYHOW|UWpQIHORO GiViUDDIQpYLLJHQpYQLMpQHNHVHWHYiUQLYiUQLDYiUQLXNGHYiUQRPYiUQ RGYiUQXQNYiUQRWRN$]RQEDQLWWIHOPHUOHJ\pUGHNHVSUREOpPDYDMRQPLpUWQHP W|UOGLND]LDYiUQLDYiUQLXNWtSXV~WHKiWKDUPDGLNV]HPpO\&DODNRNEDQLV"0$*186
2/6621V]HULQWDOiWV]DWHOOHQpUHD]LD]HIIpOHDODNRNEDQLVW|UOGLNGHD]XWiQMEHWROGiV W|UWpQLN DNiUFVDN D ELUWRNRV V]HPpO\UDJRV IQpYL DODNRNEDQ WHKiWYiUQRPYiUQRG YiUQMDPLQWEiUGRPEiUGRGEiUGMDÄ$]tURWWDODNHV]HULQWKDJ\RPiQ\RVQHPSH GLJNLHMWpVDODS~´WHV]LKR]]i 2/6621+XQJDULDQ SKRQRORJ\ DQGPRUSKRORJ\ /XQG
&VDNKRJ\NpWMyRNXQNLVYDQHQQHNDV]HOOHPHV±GHHOKDPDUNRGRWW±PHJ ROGiVQDND]HOYHWpVpUH(J\UpV]WDYiUQLDDODNQ\LOYiQYDOyDQKiURPV]yWDJ~DPLWW|E EHNN|]|WWDNpUGKDQJOHMWpVHQDODSXOyWHV]WLVEL]RQ\tWOSO6,37È5 &KDSWHUVIURPWKH VHJPHQWDOSKRQRORJ\RI+XQJDULDQ07$GRNWRULpUWHNH]pV%S±.HOOYiU nQLpD" QHP SHGLJ .HOOnYiUpQLD" PiVUpV]W D]L >M@ HOHP]pV D]W MyVROQi KRJ\ D V]yEDQIRUJyDODNNLHMWpVpQHN>YDÖUÕn@QDNNHOOHQHOHQQLHY|NRQV]HUQMH>N}ÖVHUÕH@D QD]iOLVRNUDYRQDWNR]yV]DEiO\RNUyOiOWDOiEDQO 6,37È52UUKDQJ~DN,Q6]tQHVHV]PpN QHPDOV]DQDN6]pSH*\|UJ\V]OHWpVQDSMiUD6]HUN$1'25-Ï=6()±6=%&67,%25± 7(576,679È13pFV±2/6621MDYDVODWDPpJLVMyKHO\HQWDSRJDWyG]LN
ILJ\HOMN PHJ KRJ\ D YiUQLD YiUQLXN DODNRN SRQWRV NLHMWpVH >YDÖUQLMn@ LOOHWYH
>YDÖUQLMXN@(]D>M@OHKHWQHXJ\DQDV]RNYiQ\RVKLiWXVW|OWLVODOiEEDSRQWRWGH QHPNHOOV]NVpJNpSSHQDQQDNOHQQLH7HJ\NIHOKRJ\LWWDKDUPDGLNV]HPpO\& V]H PpO\UDJRNYDOyEDQMDMXNDODN~DND]D]PiVVDOKDQJ]yYDONH]GGQHN$]KRJ\H]DM EHWROGRWWH DPLQW 2/6621 IHOWpWHOH]L YDJ\ D WROGDOpN V]yWiUL iEUi]ROiViQDN UpV]H LWW PRVWQHPVRNDWV]iPtW$KDUPDGLNV]HPpO\&ELUWRNRVV]HPpO\UDJRNMVpVMQpONOLYiO WR]DWDLQDNHORV]OiViUyOO 1$1&<$5,77(57KH+XQJDULDQSHUVRQDOSRVVHVVLYHVXIIL[
UHYLVLWHG,Q$SSURDFKHVWR+XQJDULDQ3DSHUVIURPWKH%XGDSHVWFRQIHUHQFH6]HUN .(1(6(,,679È1±6,37È53e7(5%S±pVD]RWWLGp]HWWLURGDOPDW(EEHQ D]HVHWEHQWHOMHVHQpUWKHWYpYiOLNKRJ\PLpUWQHPW|UOGLNDQLPDJiQKDQJ]yMDQHP PDJiQKDQJ]y KDQHP PiVVDOKDQJ]y HOWW iOO 3DUDGR[ PyGRQ WHKiW 2/6621 LGp]HWW PHJMHJ\]pVHPpJLVFVDNLJD]EiUQHPDPHJIHOHOHOHP]pVEOMXWRWWHOKR]]iD]pULQWHWW tURWWDODNRNYDOyEDQKDJ\RPiQ\RVDNQHPSHGLJNLHMWpVDODS~DNSRQWRVDEEDQDNLHMWpVW PpJFVDNFVDNWNU|]LNKDILJ\HOHPEHYHVV]NKRJ\DWpQ\OHJKLiWXVW|OWpVHQDODSXOy
>LMn@V]HNYHQFLiNtUiVPyGMDLDSOILDP>ILMnP@GH±KDIHOWHYpVQNKHO\HV±D]WKRJ\
DV]HPpO\UDJPHO\LNDOORPRUIMDYDQpULQWYHQHP
(EEHQ D SRQWEDQ NpW RO\DQ PRUIRIRQROyJLDL HVHWHW YHWWQN V]HPJ\UH DPHO\EHQ DKLiWXVIHOROGiVDD]HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVpYHOW|UWpQLN$]HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOp VpQHN PiV D] GEHQ LGp]HWWKH] KDVRQOy HVHWHL IHV]WHOHQJ\RUV EHV]pGEHQ IRUGXOQDN HOH]HNUHU|YLGHQNLWpUQNPDMGDN|YHWNH]SRQWYpJpQ
$ P i V R G L N P D J i Q K D Q J ] y W | U O p V H ±ÈWWpUYHDPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpV PiVLNOHKHWVpJHVWtSXViUDHUUHLVLJD]PLQWD]HO]UHKRJ\HOVVRUEDQPRUIpPDKDWiURQ ILJ\HOKHWPHJFVDNKRJ\H]~WWDOpUWHOHPV]HU&HQQHPDWIHOOLEDOKDQHPDWROGDOpN IHOOLMREEROGDORQ
$WROGDOpNRNpOpQiOOyPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVHpVYDJ\QHPEHWROGiVDV]pOHVHEEN|U&
pVERQ\ROXOWDEEMHOHQVpJPLQWDWYpJLHNp1HPNRUOiWR]yGLNFVXSiQQpKiQ\WROGDOpNUD V]iPRV WROGDOpN NH]GGLN LQJDWDJ ± YDJ\LV D VHPPLYHO |QQ|Q KLiQ\iYDO YiOWDNR]y ± PDJiQKDQJ]yYDOH]HNHWKDJ\RPiQ\RVDQÄN|WKDQJ]yQDN´LVV]RNiVQHYH]QL$]LURGDORP PHJRV]OLNHPDJiQKDQJ]yNPRUIROyJLDLKRYDWDUWR]iViWLOOHWHQQLQFVHJ\HWpUWpVDEEDQ KRJ\D]pULQWHWWLQJDWDJPDJiQKDQJ]yDWUpV]HÄWYpJKDQJ]y´DWROGDOpNUpV]HÄWRO GDOpNNH]GPDJiQKDQJ]y´YDJ\SHGLJYDOyEDQV]RURVpUWHOHPEHQYpYHÄN|WKDQJ]y´
D]D]DWpVDWROGDOpNN|]|WWiOOy|QiOOyHJ\VpJHO$17$//È6=/Ï(J\~MPDJ\DUQ\HOYWDQ IHOp%S3$33)(5(1&$PDJ\DUIQpYSDUDGLJPDWLNXVUHQGV]HUH%SpV D]RWWLGp]HWWLURGDOPDW,WWDWROGDOpNUpV]pQHNIRJMXNWHNLQWHQLGHO .È/0È1/È6=/Ï 5(%5863e7(5pV7g5.(1&=<0,./Ï6HOHP]pVpWDPHO\EHQD]HJpV]V]HOHWHOpVLNpUGpV iOSUREOpPiQDNEL]RQ\XO$PDJ\DUN|WKDQJ]yNDQDOyJLiVDODS~PHJN|]HOtWpVH(ODGiVD 9,,1HP]HWN|]L0DJ\DU1\HOYWXGRPiQ\L.RQJUHVV]XVRQ%SDXJXV]WXV±
.pW WtSXViW NO|QE|]WHWKHWMN PHJ D] LGH WDUWR]y WROGDOpNRNQDN DWWyO IJJHQ KRJ\PLLQGRNROMDEHQQNDWROGDOpNHOHMLPDJiQKDQJ]yaVHPPLYiOWDNR]iVWUpV]OHWH VHEEHQO7g5.(1&=<±6,37È5LP±
$]Ä$WtSXV~´WROGDOpNRNEDQFVDNDNNRUQHPMHOHQLNPHJPDJiQKDQJ]yKDPD JiQKDQJ]yUD YpJ]G WK|] MiUXOQDN PiVVDOKDQJ]yYpJ& W|YHN XWiQ PLQGLJ PDJiQ KDQJ]yYDONH]GGQHNIJJHWOHQODPiVVDOKDQJ]yPLQVpJpWO(EEHDWtSXVEDWDUWR]LN D W|EEHVNDNRNHN|N D V]XSHUHVV]tYXV]LQRQHQ|Q D] HJ\HV V]iP HOV V]H PpO\&ELUWRNRVPDPRPHP|P VWE $] LO\HQ WROGDOpNRNEDQ D PDJiQKDQJ]y MH OHQOpWHYDJ\KLiQ\DQHPDV]yYpJLPiVVDOKDQJ]yNDSFVRODWRN IRQRWDNWLNiMiQDODSXOYD J\LV D PDJiQKDQJ]y QHP D]pUW YDQ RWW KRJ\ HJ\pENpQW URVV]XO IRUPiOW NDSFVRODWRNDW IHOROGMRQKDODN KDONSiURNSDUNWDQRNWDQNVWE
$Ä%WtSXV~´WROGDOpNRNpOpQPHJILJ\HOKHWPDJiQKDQJ]yaVHPPLYiOWDNR]iVYL V]RQWIRQRWDNWLNDLODJPRWLYiOWLGHWDUWR]LNSpOGiXODWiUJ\UDJ$]LO\HQWROGDOpNRNHOWW QHPMHOHQLNPHJPDJiQKDQJ]yKDDWROGDOpNPiVVDOKDQJ]yMD HQpONOLVMyOIRUPiOWV]y WDJ]iUODWUpV]HOHKHWYDJ\LVQLQFVN|WKDQJ]yPDJiQKDQJ]yNXWiQKROOyWNRFVLW WHYpWYDODPLQWRO\DQWYpJLPiVVDOKDQJ]yNXWiQDPHO\HNNHODWHOiJD]y]iUODWRWNpSHV DONRWQLOiQ\WGDOWUpVW(J\pENpQWDWWN|WKDQJ]yHO]LPHJQ\RPRWSDGRWNpSHW (NpWIpOHWROGDOpNWtSXVHOWpUYLVHONHGpVpW6,37È5pV7g5.(1&=<LP±D]
]DO PDJ\DUi]]D KRJ\ D] $WtSXV~DN pOpQ iOO HJ\ UpV]OHJHVHQ PHJKDWiUR]RWW PDJiQ KDQJ]yDPHO\KLiWXVKHO\]HWEHQW|UOGLNSOKDMy8QNoKDMyQNNRFVL2QoNR FVLQNHV]W\&9NoNHV]W\&NNLYpYH~J\QHYH]HWWQ\LWyW|YHNXWiQSpOGiXOIpUILDNNH VHU&HQ O 6=(17*<g5*<,6=,/È5' /RZHULQJ 7KH LQWHUDFWLRQ RI SKRQRORJ\ DQG PRUSKRORJ\LQ+XQJDULDQ3K'pUWHNH]pV6]HJHG6,37È5±7g5.(1&=<LP±
)LJ\HOMNPHJH]]HO NDSFVRODWEDQSpOGiXODQHPYLGiPDQKDQHPV]RPRU~DQ QHPDYLGiPRQKDQHPDV]RPRU~QV]ySiUW$]WWDSDV]WDOMXNKRJ\DV]XSHUHVV]tYXV]L RQHQ|QPDJiQKDQJ]yMDDNNRULVW|UOGLNKLiWXVPiVRGLNWDJMDNpQWKDQ\LWyWXWiQ iOODPLQ\LOYiQ|VV]HIJJD]]DOKRJ\QHPLVQ\LWKDWySOKi]DNGHKi]RQQHPKi]
DQ(]]HOV]HPEHQD%WtSXV~DNpOpQQHPiOOPDJiQKDQJ]yD]RQEDQD]HO]EHNH]GpV V]HULQWLKDUPDGLNHVHWEHQYDJ\LVKDDWYpJLPiVVDOKDQJ]yDWYHOQHPWXG MyOIRUPiOW V]yWDJ]iUODWRWDONRWQLEHWROGyGLNN|]pMNHJ\PDJiQKDQJ]y$ %WtSXV~WROGDOpNRNWHKiW FVXSiQDQQ\LEDQWDUWR]QDNPRVWLGHKRJ\H]DEHWROGiVHOPDUDGW|EEHNN|]|WWDNNRU KDKLiWXVWKR]QDOpWUHKDMyWoKDMyWKDMyRWPpJQ\LWyW|YHNXWiQLVIpUILWNHVHU&W (EEHQDSRQWEDQDPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]y W|UOpVpYHOQHPEHLOOHV]WpVpYHOMiUyKLi WXVIHOROGiVW WHNLQWHWWN iW +D PRVW YLVV]DWHNLQWQN D± SRQWUD I|OPHUO D NpUGpV YDMRQ PHJMyVROKDWyH YDODPHO\ DGRWW HVHWEHQ KRJ\ PLO\HQ LUiQ\EDQ N|YHWNH]LN EH D PDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVWHKiWKRJ\D]HOVYDJ\DPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]yW&QLNHHO52'(5,&
)&$6$/,LPpSSHQH]WDNpUGpVWYL]VJiOMDDYLOiJQ\ROFYDQKpWNO|QE|]Q\HOYpEO YHWWDGDWRNDWWDUWDOPD]yKDWDOPDVDGDWEi]LVVHJtWVpJpYHOpV RSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWLPHJROGiVW MDYDVRODIHOIHGH]HWWXQLYHU]iOLVV]DEiO\V]HU&VpJHNPHJUDJDGiViUD$PDJ\DUPLQWDYL V]RQ\ODJ HJ\V]HU& EDOIHOp W|UOpV W|UWpQLN PHOOpNQpYL W|YHNEHQ DPHO\HNHW HJ\V]HU&HQ IHOVRUROKDWXQNEL]RQ\RVWROGDOpNRNN|UQ\H]HWpEHQDPHO\HNHWPpJHJ\V]HU&EEIHOVRUROQL KLV]HQFVDNKiURPYDQEHOONYDODPLQWDQLIQpYLLJHQpYLWROGDOpNEDQKDV]HPpO\
UDJRNN|YHWLNMREEIHOpW|UOpVSHGLJD]$WtSXV~WROGDOpNRNDOXOV]DERWWPDJiQKDQJ]yLQ PLQGHQPiVPRUIROyJLDLODJ|VV]HWHWWHVHWEHQDKLiWXVRNYDJ\PHJPDUDGQDNDIHOV]tQHQ LVYDJ\SHGLJYDODPLO\HQPiVIHOROGyVWUDWpJLDVHJtWVpJpYHOV]DEDGXOXQNPHJWON
$ J\RUVIHV]WHOHQ EHV]pGEHQ PHJILJ\HOKHW EiUPHO\LN LUiQ\~ W|UOpVHN WHOMHVHQ IJJHWOHQHN D IHQWL PLQWiWyO $] LO\HQ HVHWHNEHQ D W|UOpVHN LUiQ\D D NDSFVRODW PDJiQ KDQJ]yLQDNKRVV]~ViJiWyOpVYDJ\Q\HOYiOOiViWyOIJJHJ\KRVV]~pVHJ\U|YLGPDJiQ KDQJ]yEyO iOOy NDSFVRODWRNEDQ EiUPHO\ VRUUHQG HVHWpQ D U|YLG PDJiQKDQJ]y W|UOpVH YiUKDWy±OD]GpVGSpOGiW±HJ\pENpQWDNHYpVEpKDQJ]yVPDJDVDEEQ\HOYiOOi V~ PDJiQKDQJ]y NLHVpVH YDOyV]tQ&EENLHMWKHWHWOHQ=M'LV'V'VN'P?EHLQGXO=D'PFWN?
0LQGNpW WpQ\H] KDWiVD PHJILJ\HOKHW D] RO\DQ SpOGiNEDQ PLQWOyXJUiV=NQÖITCÖ5?
KR]]iROYDV=JQ\ÖCÖNXn5?0HJMHJ\]HQGKRJ\DPLWHEEHQDEHNH]GpVEHQÄW|UOpV´QpYHQ HPOHJHWWQN WDOiQ MREEDQ MHOOHPH]KHW D ÄQHP WHOMHV PHJYDOyVtWiV´ NLIHMH]pVVHO D]
LO\HQQHPWHOMHVPHJYDOyVtWiVKDWiUHVHWEHQD]LOOHWV]HJPHQWXPV]LQWHWHOMHVHOKDJ\i ViYDOMiUKDWD]RQEDQUHQGV]HULQWD]DUWLNXOiFLyVJHV]WXVOHJDOiEEYDODPLO\HQFV|NHYp Q\HVIRUPiEDQMHOHQYDQFVDND]pV]OHOpVV]iPiUDRO\DQD]LOOHWKDQJÄPLQWKDRWWVHP OHQQH´(]HQDWHUOHWHQVRNPXQNiUDYDQPpJV]NVpJHOVVRUEDQNLWHUMHGWHPSLULNXV DGDWJ\&MWpVUH pV HV]N|]IRQHWLNDL HOHP]pVUH PLHOWW EiUPL HQQpO YpJOHJHVHEEHW OHKHWQH PRQGDQLUyOD
' L I W R Q J X V N L D O D N X O i V D I p O P D J i Q K D Q J ] y V R G i V p V | V V ] H R O Y D G i V ±$]RNEDQD]HVHWHNEHQDPHO\HNEHQHJ\LNPDJiQKDQJ]yVHPW|UOGLNHJ\
WRYiEELOHKHWVpJDKLiWXVIHOROGiViUDD]HJ\LNYDJ\DPiVLN PDJiQKDQJ]y IpOPDJiQ KDQJ]yYiDODNtWiVD(]D IpOPDJiQKDQJ]yD]XWiQV]yWDJROKDWyD V]yWDJPDJ UpV]HNpQW PLQWDIHQWL±SpOGiNEDQYDJ\V]yWDJNH]GHWNpQWV]yWDJNH]GHWUpV]HNpQWYDJ\
SHGLJ V]yWDJ]iUODWNpQW V]yWDJ]iUODW UpV]HNpQW PLQW D] ± DODWWLDNEDQ *\DNUDQ QHPN|QQ\&HOG|QWHQLKRJ\NHWWVKDQJ]yM|QOpWUHYDJ\FVDNHJ\V]HU&V]yWDJSHUHP EHOLIpOPDJiQKDQJ]yJRQGROMXQNFVDNDUUDDUpJLYLWiUDKRJ\YDQQDNHGLIWRQJXVRND PDJ\DU N|]Q\HOYEHQ ( YLWD OHJIRQWRVDEE GRNXPHQWXPDL PRVW NpQ\HOPHVHQ WDQXOPi Q\R]KDWyNPHUW|VV]HJ\&MWYHNRPPHQWiURNNDO~MUDPHJMHOHQWHN,Q.tVpUOHWLIRQHWLND ODERUDWyULXPLIRQROyJLDDJ\DNRUODWEDQ6]HUN+81<$',/È6=/Ï'HEUHFHQ±
(QQHNDNpUGpVN|UQHNDOHJV]HPEHW&QEEUpV]HD]DXHXV]DYDNJ\DNUDQV]yEDKR ]RWWHVHWHSODXWy(XUySDO1È'$6'<È'È0±6,37È53e7(5$PDJiQKDQJ]yN,Q 6WUXNWXUiOLV PDJ\DU Q\HOYWDQ )RQROyJLD 6]HUN .,()(5)(5(1& %S ± NO6,37È5+DQJWDQ,Qe.,66.$7$/,1±.,()(5)(5(1&±6,37È53e7(5 ÒMPDJ\DUQ\HOYWDQ%S± NO±6,37È5±7g5.(1&=<LP±
pVD]RWWLGp]HWWLURGDOPDW,WWPRVWQHPLGp]HPIHOD]RNDWD WHV]WHNHWDPHO\HNHWDQQDN PHJiOODStWiViUDMDYDVROWDPD]LGp]HWWKHO\HNHQKRJ\D]DXWyIpOHV]DYDNDXYDOtUWUpV]H HJ\YDJ\NpWV]yWDJHD]D]GLIWRQJXVHYDJ\SHGLJKLiWXV.$66$,,/21$D]HPOtWHWWHN QpO WDOiQ NHYpVEp N|UP|QIRQW NtVpUOHWHW WDOiOW NL GH D]W YpJUH LV KDMWRWWD HJ\V]HU&HQ PHJNpUGH]HWW PLQWHJ\ V]i] HJ\HWHPL KDOOJDWyW pV V]i] SHGDJyJXVW KRJ\ D PHJDGRWW V]yWDJROiVRNN|]OPHO\LNHWWDUWMDWHUPpV]HWHVHEEQHN)HOQWWQ\HOYKDV]QiOyNV]yWDJV]HU NH]HWLSUHIHUHQFLiL,Q6]yWDJIRJDORP±V]yWDJUHDOL]iFLyN6]HUN.$66$,,/21$%S
±NO$NDODX]V]yWKiURPV]yWDJ~QDNPLQVtWHWWHDGLiNRND LOOHWYHDWDQiURNDD]DXWyV]yWSHGLJDGLiNRNDPtJDWDQiURNQDNPLQ G|VV]HDYDJ\LVXNYpOHPpQ\HV]HULQWGLIWRQJXVYDQEHQQH$OpQ\HJD]
KRJ\DIHOV]tQHQLQJDGR]iVWWDOiOXQNDGLIWRQJXVRVpVDKLiWXVRVPHJYDOyVtWiVN|]|WWKD PiUPRVWIHOWpWHOH]]NKRJ\D]pULQWHWWV]HNYHQFLiNP|J|WWHVHQKLiWXVWWDUWDOPD]QDND]
nWo>nY@PHJYDOyVtWiVLV]DEiO\SHGLJHJ\HVEHV]pONQpOPHJYDQPiVEHV]pON QpOQLQFVPHJLVPpWPiVRNQiOSHGLJIDNXOWDWtYDNNRUpSSHQD]WDPLQWiWMyVROMXNDPLWD YDOyViJEDQ LV NDSXQN UiDGiVXO D] HJpV] MHOHQVpJ LVNRODSpOGiMD D KLiWXV IpOPDJiQKDQJ]yVtWiVVDOYDOyPHJV]QWHWpVpQHN
$]DXHXV]DYDNPHJYDOyVtWiViQDNPiVLNPyGMDNpQWVRNEHV]pOPDJiQKDQJ]y
|VV]HROYDGiVWDONDOPD]EHQQNDXWy=nÖVQÖ?(XUySD='ÖTQÖRn?(]WDIRO\DPDWRW PRQR IWRQJL]iFLyNpQWLVIHOIRJKDWMXNKDIHOWHVV]NKRJ\D]pULQWHWWV]DYDNEDQHOEEGLIWRQ JXVDODNXONLD]HO]EHNH]GpVEHQMHO]HWWPyGRQ$PDJiQKDQJ]y|VV]HROYDGiVIHQWHEE V]DQV]NULWSpOGiNNDOEHPXWDWRWWNpWDODSYHWPyGMDN|]ODDEHOLWtSXVNpWNO|QE|
] PDJiQKDQJ]y YDODPLO\HQ N|]WHV PLQVpJEHQ YDOy |VV]HROYDGiVD QHP LVPHUHWHV D PDJ\DUEDQ.pWD]RQRVU|YLGPDJiQKDQJ]yQDNDPHJIHOHOKRVV]~EDQYDOy|VV]HROYD GiVDPLQWDEEHQRO\NRUHOIRUGXOSONRRSHUiO=MQÖR'TCÖN?GHDPDJ\DUEDQLQNiEE V]RNiVRV|VV]HROYDGiVLWtSXVNpWD]RQRVDNiUU|YLGDNiUKRVV]~PDJiQKDQJ]yKHO\HW WHVtWpVHD]DGRWWPDJiQKDQJ]yHJ\HWOHQSpOGiQ\iYDOPLQWDFEHQ7RYiEELSpOGiN NRRUGLQiWD =MQTFKPCÖVn?YiNXXP =XCÖMWO?NLLNWDW =MKMVnV? a =MKVÖnV? V]HPH HOWW
=U'O'N1ÖVÖ? $KRJ\DQ IHQWHEE D SRQWEDQ PHJMHJ\H]WN H]W D WtSXVW PDJiQKDQJ]y W|UOpVNpQWLVOHKHWHOHPH]QLKDtJ\IRJMXNIHOOHKHWHWOHQPHJPRQGDQLKRJ\HEEHQD]
HVHWEHQDNHWWN|]OPHO\LNPDJiQKDQJ]yD]DPHO\LNW|UOGLN
0 i V V D O K D Q J ] y E H W R O G i V ± 2O\DQ EHWROGRWW PiVVDOKDQJ]yN DPHO\HN QHNDPLQVpJHQHPIJJDN|UQ\H]PDJiQKDQJ]yNpWyO±D]HOOHQNH]HVHWUHOIHQW
DODWWpVDSRQWEDQ±UHQGV]HULQWPRUIpPDKDWiURQOpWUHM|YKLiWXVRNHVHWpEHQMHOHQQHN PHJpVHOYEHQKiURPIpOpNOHKHWQHND]DGRWWQ\HOYiOWDOiQRVMHO|OHWOHQGHIDXOWPiVVDO KDQJ]yMD PLQW DEDQ YDJ\ D] HJ\LN PRUIpPiKR] WDUWR]y ÄOHEHJ´ PiVVDOKDQJ]y YDJ\ SHGLJ RO\DQ DPHO\QHN PLQVpJH D V]DYDN NLVHEEQDJ\REE FVRSRUWMiQ DODSXOy DQDOyJLiVKDWiVQDNN|V]|QKHW$]HOVHVHWUHQ\LOYiQYDOySpOGiWDPDJ\DUEDQQHPWD OiOXQNGH9$*2LPHOHP]pVHDODSMiQLO\HQOHQQHDYEHWROGiVD]~J\QHYH]HWWÄYiOWD NR]yYNH]GHW&WROGDOpNRN´FVRSRUWMiEDQLGHWDUWR]LND]HV]N|]KDWiUR]yLYDOYHOUDJ VyYDOPp]]HOYDODPLQWDWUDQV]ODWtYXV]LYiYpVyYiPp]]p$ÄQHPYiOWDNR]yY NH]GHW&WROGDOpNRN´YDQYHQKDWYDQYiQ\YpQ\OiWYiQ\YDYHORSYDXJ\DQFVDN
>X@YHONH]GGQHNPDJiQKDQJ]yUDYpJ]GW|YHNXWiQGHXMNPiVVDOKDQJ]yUDYpJ ]GW|YHNXWiQLVYiOWR]DWODQPDUDG$NpWIpOHWROGDOpNWtSXViEUi]ROiVDHJ\EHWROGiVRQ DODSXOyHOHP]pVEHQDN|YHWNH]NpSSHQIHVWKHWQH
YDOYHO u u u YDYH u u
~ ~ ~ ~
$ O Y $
+D DYDOYHO PDJiQKDQJ]yUD YpJ]GWK|] MiUXO UHV KHO\pUH EHWROGyGQD HJ\
Y VyYDOKDHJ\HWOHQPiVVDOKDQJ]yUDYpJ]GWK|]OH]DMODQDHJ\WHUMHGpVLIRO\DPDW DPHO\DWYpJLPiVVDOKDQJ]yV]HJPHQWiOLVWDUWDOPiWDWROGDOpNpOpQiOOyUHVKHO\UHWHU MHV]WLH]iOWDOKRVV]~PiVVDOKDQJ]yWKR]YDOpWUHPp>\Ö@HOYpJOKDPiVVDOKDQJ]yNDS FVRODWUDYpJ]GWK|]MiUXOHJ\LO\HQWROGDOpNQHPW|UWpQQHVHPPLpVD]UHVuUHVLV PDUDGQDGRP>D@DOO6,37È5 'HJHPLQiFLy,QÒMDEEWDQXOPiQ\RNDVWUXNWXUiOLVPD J\DUQ\HOYWDQpVDQ\HOYW|UWpQHWN|UpEO.LHIHU)HUHQFWLV]WHOHWpUHEDUiWDLpVWDQtWYiQ\DL 6]HUN%$.5Ï1$*<0$5,$11(±%È15e7,=2/7È1±e.,66.$7$/,1%S
±(]DNpWIpOHYNH]GHW&WROGDOpNRNYLVHONHGpVpQHNNp]HQIHNYHOHP]pVHOHQQH FVDNKRJ\DPLQW6,37È5±7g5.(1&=<LPUiPXWDWDOLJKDV]HUHQFVpVHJ\RO\DQ iOWDOiQRVGHIDXOWYEHWROGyV]DEiO\UDpStWHQLD]HOHP]pVWDPHO\PLQG|VV]HVHQNpWWRO GDOpN pOpUH WROGDQD EHYW pV IOHJ HQQHN DODSMiQ NLMHOHQWHQL KRJ\ D PDJ\DU GHIDXOW PiVVDOKDQJ]yDY,JD]KRJ\9$*2HOHP]pVpEHQDYEHWROGiVDONDOPD]iVLN|UHQpPLOHJ V]pOHVHEEPLYHOD]~J\QHYH]HWWYYHOEYOW|YHNOHYH]HWpVpEHQLVV]HUHSKH]MXW(]HN DW|YHN|QPDJXNEDQPDJiQKDQJ]yUDYpJ]GQHNGHPDJiQKDQJ]yYDONH]GGV]LQWHWL NXVWROGDOpNRNHOWWHJ\WYpJL>X@LVPHJMHOHQLNEHQQNO6,37È5&KDSWHUV±pV D]RWWLGp]HWWLURGDOPDWOyORYDNOO|Y|N(]D]RQEDQDV]XSSOHWtYDOORPRUILDWLSL NXVHVHWHDPLD]WMHOHQWLKRJ\DIRQROyJLiQDNQHPNHOOD] DOORPRUIRNDWHJ\D]RQP|
J|WWHViEUi]ROiVEyOOHYH]HWQLH$]LO\HQYa YiOWDNR]iVWPXWDWyW|YHNV]iPDXJ\DQLV LJHQDODFVRQ\K~V]QiOLVNHYHVHEEpVUiDGiVXORO\NRUDWEHOLPDJiQKDQJ]yPLQVpJp QHNpVYDJ\KRVV]iQDNVHPPLEOVHPPHJMyVROKDWyYiOWDNR]iVDNtVpULEHQQNDYa
YiOWDNR]iVW SOW W|YHN GHE EYHN LOOHWYHOy ORYDN GHWy WDYDN 9DQ N|]|WWN RO\DQ W LV DPHO\ V]DEiO\RV YLVHONHGpVW LV PXWDW DYYHO EYOpV PHOOHWWV]y V]DY DNV]yNIDOXIDOYDNIDOXN0LQGH]HNDODSMiQHW|YHNYLVHONHGpVHQHPNtYiQIRQROyJL DLOHtUiVW7HKiWD]iOOtWyODJRV GHIDXOWYPLQG|VV]HDÄYiOWDNR]yYNH]GHW& WROGDOpNRN´
NpWWDJRWV]iPOiOyFVRSRUWMiEDQMHOHQQHPHJ(]pUW6,37È5pV7g5.(1&=<LPDUUD D N|YHWNH]WHWpVUHMXWKRJ\HWROGDOpNRNEDQDXP|J|WWHVHQMHOHQYDQpVPiVVDOKDQJ]y XWiQHJ\V]HU&HQOHNDSFVROyGLNW|UOGLN 9&YpJ&W|YHNEHQ H]W N|YHWL D & WHUMHGpVH
&&YpJ&W|YHNEHQSHGLJQHP9YpJ&W|YHNEHQH]]HOV]HPEHQHOPDUDGDOHNDSFVROyGiV pVDYPHJMHOHQLNDIHOV]tQHQ
$ODSPiVVDOKDQJ]yEHWROGiViUDWHKiWQHPWDOiOXQNSpOGiWDPDJ\DUEDQ0LDKHO\
]HWDOHEHJPiVVDOKDQJ]yYDO"(UUHHVHWOHJD]Da D] YiOWDNR]iV HJ\IDMWD OHKHWVpJHV
HOHP]pVHKR]KDWyIHOSpOGDNpQW +DIHOWHVV]NKRJ\HJ\UpV]WDKDWiUR]RWWQpYHOV]yWiUL iEUi]ROiViEDQD\OHEHJD]D]LG]tWpVLSRQWKR]Yi]SRQWKR]QHPN|W|WWPiVVDOKDQJ]y NpQWYDQMHOHQPiVUpV]WDIRQHWLNDLODJPDJiQKDQJ]yYDONH]GGV]DYDNOHJHOHMpQWXODM GRQNpSSHQQHPDPDJiQKDQJ]yKDQHP±HOWWH±HJ\UHVYi]SRQWYDJ\UHVV]yWDJNH]
GHWiOODNNRUD]WPRQGKDWMXNKRJ\DOHEHJ\UiWHUMHGHUUHD]UHVYi]SRQWUDD]pV]
LOOHWYHPHJYDOyVtWDWODQPDUDGKDDN|YHWNH]V]yQHPUHVYi]SRQWWDOKDQHPPiVVDO KDQJ]yYDONH]GGLNDUpV]5pV]OHWHVHEEHQO6=,*(79È5,3e7(56]yWDJWDODQIRQROy JLD,Q6]DEiO\WDODQIRQROyJLD6]HUN6,37È53e7(5%S±NO±(UUHD]
HOHP]pVUH PRQGKDWQiQN XJ\DQ KRJ\ XJ\DQRO\DQ DSUy V]HJOHWpUH YRQDWNR]LN D PD J\DUIRQROyJLiQDNPLQWDYiOWDNR]yYNH]GHW&WROGDOpNRNIHQWHPOtWHWWHVHWHVWD]RQ EDQYHJ\NILJ\HOHPEHKRJ\DMDYDVROWPHJROGiVLWWQHPYDODPLO\HQ GHIDXOW]EHLOOHV]
WpVpWWpWHOH]LIHOKDQHPpSSHQDKDWiUR]RWWQpYHOHJ\HGLWXODMGRQViJDNpQWWQWHWLIHOD]
XWiQDOHEHJPiVVDOKDQJ]yWpVFVXSiQD]DPHFKDQL]PXViOWDOiQRVDPHOO\HOH]DPiVVDO KDQJ]yEHOHLOOHV]NHGLNDV]yWDJV]HUNH]HWEHpVH]iOWDOIRQHWLNDLODJPHJYDOyVXO
8J\DQH]]HOPDJ\DUi]KDWQiQNDSRQWEDQPiUHPOtWHWWROFVyVtWNDUFV~VtWiOODQ GyVXOIHOIRUUyVRGLNWtSXV~HVHWHNEHQYDODPLQWDIDOXVLWDQ\DVLWtSXV~DNEDQDEHWROGyGy VPHJMHOHQpVpW&VDNKRJ\LWWILJ\HOHPEHNHOOYHQQQNDKi]DVtWIiVtWPHJVHEHVOKDV]
QRVXO HOKRPiO\RVRGLNVWE LOOHWYH DYiURVL DQDOyJLiV KDWiViW LV $] D Q D O y J L D KD J\RPiQ\RVIRJDOPiQDNDPRGHUQIRQROyJLiEDYDOyEHYH]HWpVpUOLOOHWYHLGN|]EHQHO YHV]tWHWWMRJDLEDYDOyYLVV]DKHO\H]pVpUOO-$0(60<(56/H[LFDO3KRQRORJ\DQGWKH OH[LFRQ.p]LUDW1DWLRQDO&KXQJ&KHQJ8QLYHUVLW\0LQ+VLXQJ7DLZDQ/PpJ .È/0È1±5(%586±7g5.(1&=<LPDKRODV]HU]NDPHOOHWWpUYHOQHNKRJ\D]DQDOy JLiWNHOOHQHDPRUIRIRQROyJLDVDURNN|YpQHNPHJWHQQLVDQDOyJLiVDODSRQNHOOHQHV]i PRW DGQL SpOGiXO D N|WKDQJ]yN NpUGpVN|UpUO pV iOWDOiEDQ PLQGDUUyO DPLUO IHQWHEE D±SRQWEDQV]yHVHWW(UUHNpVEEPpJYLVV]DWpUQN
'HPLpUWOHQQHMREEHEEHQD]HVHWEHQDQDOyJLiV=5?EHWROGiVUDKDJ\DWNR]QLPLQW KDOHEHJ5MHOHQOpWpWIHOWpWHOH]QpQND]DaD]YiOWDNR]iVOHEHJ\UHDODSR]RWWHOHP ]pVpKH]KDVRQOyDQ"1HIHOHGMNKRJ\DQpYHO]MHPLQGHQPDJiQKDQJ]yYDONH]GG V]yHOWWDXWRPDWLNXVDQPHJMHOHQLNPtJD]VFVXSiQD]tWXOOpVRGLNHGLN|GLN LJHNpS]NLOOHWYHPpJNLVHEEN|UEHQD]LPHOOpNQpYNpS]HOWW+DD]VHWIHOYHQ QpQNOHEHJPiVVDOKDQJ]yNpQWD]ROFVyNDUFV~VWELOOHWYHDIDOXWDQ\DV]yWiULHOHPHN YpJpUH QHP WXGQiQN PHJPDJ\DUi]QL KRJ\ YDMRQ PLpUW QHP MHOHQLN PHJ SpOGiXO D DEHOLV]DYDNEDQ5iDGiVXOSpOGiXODV&U&V]yD]&W|UOpVpWYiODV]WMDDV&UtWGHD]V EHWROGiVWYiODV]WMDDV&U&V|GLNDODNEDQEKDD]WiOOtWDQiQNKRJ\PRQGMXNDNDUFV~
VtWHVHWpEHQDOHEHJVDNDGiO\R]]DPHJD]~ W|UOpVpWNDUFVtWDNNRUDV&U&YpJpQOH EHJVPLpUWQHPWXGMDHOHMpWYHQQLD]&W|UOpVpQHNDV&UtWEHQ"
D ROFVyDN =QNV5QÖnM? =QNV5QÖ5nM?
NDUFV~pUW =MnTV5WGÖTV? =MnTV5W5GÖTV?
IDOXLJ =HnNWLKI? =HnNW5KI?
WDQ\iXO =VnÕCÖWN? =VnÕn5WN?
EV&U& =5[ÖT[?
V&UtW =5[ÖTKV?
V&U&V|GLN =5[ÖT[51FKM?
(EEHQDSRQWEDQDPHOOHWWpUYHOWQNKRJ\D]iOOtWyODJRV=X?EHWROGiVQHPD]DODS PiVVDOKDQJ]yPHJMHOHQpVpQHNHVHWHDPDJ\DUEDQKRJ\D]DaD]YiOWDNR]iVOHEHJ\ IHOWpWHOH]pVpYHONH]HOKHWpVKRJ\D]5EHWROGiVWOHJMREEDQDOyJLiVIRO\DPDWNpQWpUWHO PH]QL0RVWiWWpUQNDV]yV]RURVpUWHOPpEHQYHWWKLiWXVW|OWpVUHYDJ\LVD]RNUDD]HVHWHNUH
DPHO\HNEHQDKLiWXVIHOROGiViUyOYDODPLO\HQ V]HJPHQWiOLVDQ\DJQDNDV]RPV]pGRVPD JiQKDQJ]yUyO D] UHV V]yWDJNH]GHWSR]tFLyUD YDOy i W W H U M H G p V p Y H O DGKDWXQN V]i PRW
+ L i W X V W | O W p V =L?Y H O ±0LQGD]RNUDDKLiWXVRNUDDPHO\HNHWQHPV]QWH WHWWPHJD]HJ\LNYDJ\DPiVLNPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVHYDJ\ IpOPDJiQKDQJ]yYiJ\HQJtWp VHVHPSHGLJYDODPLO\HQOHEHJYDJ\DQDOyJLiVDQPHJMHOHQPiVVDOKDQJ]yEHWROGiVD NpWIpOHVRUVHJ\LNHYiUYDJ\PHJPDUDGQDNKLiWXVQDNSOIiUDyYDJ\SHGLJKDDN|U Q\H]PDJiQKDQJ]yNH]WOHKHWYpWHV]LNKLiWXVW|OWMYHOW|OWGQHNNLOF
$KLiWXVW|OWMPHJMHOHQpVHWHKiWV]HPEHQD]HGGLJWiUJ\DOWIRO\DPDWRNW|EEVpJp YHOQHPIJJDPRUIpPDKDWiUWyODNLiOWiVpVDNLiOOtWiVHJ\DUiQWMYHOMHOHQLNPHJDNiU FVDND]KRJ\NLiOOLWW"D%HDpVDEHDGiVHJ\DUiQWMQpONODNiUFVDNDEHDGRER]ED 0LQGLJNLW|OWGLNDKLiWXVKDHJ\LNYDJ\PiVLNROGDOiQL YDJ\tiOOOD$]pYHO DONRWRWWpVSHUV]HLtWQHPWDUWDOPD]yNDSFVRODWRNHVHWpEHQDKLiWXVW|OWpV IDNXOWDWtY OE9pJOKDPLQGNpWROGDORQDOVyYDJ\NHUHNPDJiQKDQJ]yiOODKLiWXVPHJPD
UDGQHPW|OWGLNNLOF/PpJ6,37È5+XQJDULDQ\RG$/+±
D GLpWD =FKLGÖVn? ODLNXV =NnLKMWU?
VLHW =5KL'V? QL =P1ÖLK?
SLyFD =RKLQÖVUn? VtHO =5KÖL'N?
IL~ =HKLW? GLFVtW =FKV51ÖLKÖV?
ENHWWpRV]W =M'VÖGÖQUV? a=M'VÖGÖLQUV?
UipU =TCÖGÖT? a=TCÖLGÖT?
SRpQ =RQGÖP? a=RQLGÖP?
FUiDGiV =TCÖnFCÖ5? =TCÖLnFCÖ5? Ri]LV =QCÖ\K5? =QLCÖ\K5?
LGHiOLV =KF'CÖNK5? =KF'LCÖNK5? RERD =QDQn? =QDQLn?
NDODX] =MnNnW\? =MnNnLW\? P&~W =O[ÖWÖV? =O[ÖLWÖV?
QHRQ =P'QP? =P'LQP? IOXRU =HNWQT? =HNWLQT?
+DVRQOyNpSSHQNpWD]RQRVPDJiQKDQJ]yN|]|WW±KDQHPROYDGQDN|VV]HOIHQ WHEED]SRQWRW±PHJMHOHQLNHJ\>L@KDDNpWPDJiQKDQJ]yLPHJMHOHQKHWHJ\>L@KD PLQGNHWWpYpJOPHJPDUDGDKLiWXVPLQGHQPiVHVHWEHQ
D NLLNWDW =MKLKMVnV?
NRFVLLJ =MQV5KLKI?
EHOppU ='NGÖGÖT? a='NGÖLGÖT?
NHIpp =M'HGÖGÖ? a=M'HGÖLGÖ?
FIDDUF =HnnTVU? =HnLnTVU?
DOiiV =nNCÖCÖ5? =nNCÖLCÖ5?
WHHQG =V''PF1Ö? =V'L'PF1Ö?
iOOyyUD =CÖNQÖQÖTn? =CÖNQÖLQÖTn?
PH]U =O'\1Ö1ÖT? =O'\1ÖL1ÖT?
(]WDIRO\DPDWRWUpV]OHWHVHQWiUJ\DOMDOHYH]HWpVHVNHUHWEHQ6,37È5±7g5.(1&=<LP
±RSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWLHOHP]pVHPHJWDOiOKDWyDOiEEDSRQWEDQYDODPLQW6,37È5 2SWLPiOLVKLiWXVW|OWpV,Q%HV]pGNXWDWiV6]HUN*Ï6<0È5,$%S±
g V V ] H J ] p V ±0LHOWW UiWpUQpQN PLQGH]HQ MHOHQVpJHN RSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWL HOHP]pVpUHWHNLQWVNiWD]WKRJ\DKLiWXVRNPHJV]QWHWpVpQHNIHQWLPyGMDLN|]OPHO\LN
PLO\HQPRUIROyJLDLN|UQ\H]HWEHQOpSKHWpOHWEH(KKH]HOV]|UGHILQLiOQXQNNHOOKRJ\
PLWpUWQNV]LQWHWLNXVLOOHWYHDQDOLWLNXVPRUIROyJLDLWDUWRPiQ\RQ$WHUPLQXVRNDNR U PiQ\]iVIRQROyJLiEyOV]iUPD]QDNGHPDJDDNO|QEVpJWpWHODJHQHUDWtY IRQROyJLDN
O|QIpOH YiOWR]DWDLEDQ UpJyWD LVPHUHWHV /pQ\HJpEHQ PHJHJ\H]LN D Ä´ KDWiURV pV Ä´
KDWiURVWROGDOpNROiVLOOHWYHD]V]LQW&pVV]LQW&WROGDOpNROiVN|]|WWLNO|QEVpJJHO Y| -2+1 +$55,6 (QJOLVK VRXQG VWUXFWXUH 2[IRUG $] DQDOLWLNXV PRUIROyJLDL WDUWRPiQ\RN KDWiUDL iWKDWROKDWDWODQRN D IRQRWDNWLNDL PHJV]RUtWiVRN V]iPiUD 0iV V]yYDO D] LO\HQ PHJV]RUtWiVRN QHP pUYpQ\HVOQHN UDMWXN NHUHV]WO $ PDJ\DUEDQ D]
|VV]HWpWHOKDWiUpVD]LJHN|W±LJHKDWiUDQDOLWLNXV$WROGDOpNRNHOWWLKDWiUOHKHWDQDOLWL NXVSOLJpUWYDJ\V]LQWHWLNXVSOWDWRWHW|W$]HJ\V]HU&VpJNHGYppUWPDJX NDWDWROGDOpNRNDWLVDQDOLWLNXVQDNLOOHWYHV]LQWHWLNXVQDNQHYH]]NDWWyOIJJHQKRJ\
PLO\HQKDWiUYDQHOWWN$V]LQWHWLNXVWROGDOpNRNHOWWLKDWiUDV]yWDJROiVpVDPiVVDO KDQJ]yNUD YRQDWNR]y IRQRWDNWLNDL PHJV]RUtWiVRN V]iPiUD OiWKDWDWODQ HEEO D V]HP SRQWEyOWHKiWHJ\V]LQWHWLNXVDQWROGDOpNROWDODNpVHJ\PRQRPRUIHPLNXVWHJ\HQpUWpN&
9LV]RQWpSSHQDKLiWXVV]HPSRQWMiEyODKHO\]HWIRUGtWRWWPRUIpPiQEHOOpV DQDOLWLNXV KDWiURQOHKHWVpJHVKLiWXVNLDODNXOiVDPtJV]LQWHWLNXVKDWiURQQHP
0RUIpPiQ EHOO WHKiW OHKHWVpJHV OH[LNiOLV KLiWXV DPHO\ YDJ\ PHJPDUDGIiUDy Ri]LV YDJ\ SHGLJ YDODPLO\HQ SRV]WOH[LNiOLV IRO\DPDW UpYpQ ROGyGLN IHO (] OHKHW KLi WXVW|OWpV±VL>L@HWIL>L@~Y|D±IpOPDJiQKDQJ]yYiYiOiV±D>Y@WyY|E±YDJ\
D]RQRV PDJiQKDQJ]yN |VV]HYRQiVDYiNXXP >YDÖNXP@ $] LO\HQ IRO\DPDWRN NLPHQHWH LGYHO OH[LNDOL]iOyGKDWLVH]HVHWEHQSHUV]HPiUOH[LNiOLVKLiWXVUyO VHP EHV]pOKHWQN NDOH=L?GRV]NySOiQ\KL=IGÖ?QLNXV
$QDOLWLNXVPRUIpPDKDWiURQEHOHpUWYHD]|VV]HWpWHOVWDV]yKDWiUWLVOpQ\HJpEHQ XJ\DQH]DKHO\]HWDKLiWXVYDJ\PHJPDUDGKD]DHQJHGUiXQE~FV~HVWNDSXJ\HOHW YDJ\SRV]WOH[LNiOLVDQROGyGLNIHO(QQHNHV]N|]HLOHEHJPiVVDOKDQJ]yÄEHWROGiVD´D]
HPEHUKLiWXVW|OWpVpMMHOL>L@UKt>L@DKD]DRGi>L@LJDGy>L@tYVt>L@XJUiVIpOPDJiQKDQJ ]yYiYiOiVOED]HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVHOGDPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOp VHOGD]RQRVPDJiQKDQJ]yN|VV]HYRQiVDOF
(]]HOV]HPEHQV]LQWHWLNXVKDWiURQVRKDQHPDODNXONLKLiWXVH]pUW D IHQWL MDYtWy PHFKDQL]PXVRNDONDOPD]iViUDVHPNHUOVRU(UUOHOVVRUEDQDPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]y W|UOpVHKDMy8QNoKDMyQNNRFVL2QoNRFVLQNHV]W\&9NoNHV]W\&NIHNHWH 9EEoIHNHWpEELOOHWYHQHPEHWROGiVDKROOyWNRFVLWWHYpWJRQGRVNRGLNGHV]HUH SHWMiWV]LNEHQQH±KDV]&NHEEN|U&WLV±D]DQDOyJLiVPiVVDOKDQJ]yEHWROGiVNDUFV~VtW iOODQGyVXOIHOIRUUyVRGLNIDOXVLLOOHWYHD]HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVHLVEDUQDEDUQtW IDNyIDNXOV]RPRU~V]RPRURGLNYiUQLYiUQRP
$ ] R S W L P D O L W i V H O P p O H W UO ±(EEHQD]HOPpOHWLNHUHWEHQD IRQROyJLD QHPDONDOPD]V]DEiO\RNRQDODSXOyOHYH]HWpVHNHWpVQHPGHILQLiOVHPPLO\HQN|]EOV WHKiWDV]yWiULV]LQWpVDIHOV]tQLIRQROyJLDLiEUi]ROiVD]D]DEHPHQHWpVDNLPHQHWN | ]|WWLV]LQWHW (J\ RSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWLQ\HOYWDQ KiURP I|VV]HWHYEO iOO D V]yWiUEyO DPHO\HJ\pELQIRUPiFLyNN|]|WWDQ\HOYYDODPHQQ\LV]DYiQDNPRUIpPiMiQDNP|J|WWHV IRQROyJLDLiEUi]ROiViWWDUWDOPD]]DD]~J\QHYH]HWWJHQHUiWRUEyODPHO\PLQGHQEHPHQ DODNRW NLPHQHWMHO|OWHN HJ\PiVVDO YHUVHQJ OHKHWVpJHV NLPHQHWHN HJ\ YpJWHOHQ KDO PD]iUDNpSH]OHYDODPLQWHJ\NLpUWpNHONRPSRQHQVEODPHO\H]HNN|]ODOHKHWVpJHV NLPHQHWHNN|]ONLYiODV]WHJ\HWD]~J\QHYH]HWWRSWLPiOLVDODNRWDPHO\D]DGRWWEHPHQHW QHNPHJIHOHOYDOyViJRVNLPHQHWOHV]$]pUWpNHOWUDQJVRUEDiOOtWRWWNRUOiWRNPHJV]R UtWiVRNDONRWMiNPLQGHQHPEHULQ\HOYSRQWRVDQXJ\DQD]RNDWD NRUOiWRNDWWDUWDOPD]]D±
DPLEHQD]HJ\HVQ\HOYHNHOWpUQHNHJ\PiVWyOD]DNRUOiWRNUDQJVRUROiVD$NRUOiWRNiW
KiJKDWyNDPLD]WMHOHQWLKRJ\DNLPHQHWLDODNPHJVpUWKHWEL]RQ\RVPHJV]RUtWiVRNDWiP H]PpJQHPWHV]LD]DGRWWDODNRWIHOWpWOHQOYHV]WHVVpHEEHQDYHUVHQ\EHQ
$ NLPHQHWL MHO|OWHNQHN D NRUOiWRN VHJtWVpJpYHO W|UWpQpUWpNHOpVpW ~J\QHYH]HWW WiE OiNEDQV]HPOpOWHWMN(]HNQHND]HOVRV]ORSiEDQIHOVRUROMXNDUHOHYiQVMHO|OWHNHWPtJD W|EEL RV]ORS HJ\HJ\ NRUOiWQDN IHOHO PHJ PpJSHGLJ EDOUyO MREEUD UDQJVRU V]HULQW HOKH O\H]YHNH]GYHDOHJPDJDVDEEUDUDQJVRUROWUHOHYiQVNRUOiWWDO&VLOODJJDOMHO|OMND]WKD YDODPHO\MHO|OWiWKiJMDD]pULQWHWWNRUOiWRWIHONLiOWyMHOOHOSHGLJD]WKDH]DNRUOiWiWKiJiV YpJ]HWHVYDJ\LVRO\DQDPHO\QHNN|YHWNH]WpEHQD]DGRWWMHO|OWDYHUVHQ\EHQHWWO NH]GYH QHPYHV]UpV]W$WiEOiNQDND]RNDWDUpV]HLWDPHO\HNPiUQHPpUGHNHVHNPHUWD] pULQWHWW MHO|OWPiUNLHVHWWDYHUVHQ\EOiUQ\pNROiVMHO]LDV]HPOpOHWHVVpJNHGYppUW-REEUDPXWDWy NH]HFVNH MHO]L D] RSWLPiOLV MHO|OWHW D]W D] DODNRW DPHO\ D YDOyViJRV NLPHQHWL DODN OHV]
$] RSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWEHQDKLiWXVKHO\]HWiOWDOiEDQ YHWW KiWUiQ\RVViJiW D .(='(7
QHY&iOWDOiQRVNRUOiWNpSYLVHOLDD]RNEDQDQ\HOYHNEHQDPHO\HNHOW&ULNDKLiWXVR NDWH]DNRUOiWYLV]RQ\ODJDODFVRQ\UDYDQUDQJVRUROYDPtJD]RNEDQDQ\HOYHNEHQDPHO\HN HJ\HWOHQKLiWXVWVHPW&UQHNHOYLV]RQ\ODJPDJDVUD$NpWiOWDOiQRVMDYtWyVWUDWpJLDDW|UOpV pVDEHWROGiVD0,1'ELOOHWYHD&6$.FNRUOiWiWKiJiVDNpQWpUWHOPH]KHW D]
RSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWUO iOWDOiEDQ O .$*(5 L P PDJ\DUXO 5(%5863e7(5 2SWLPDOLWiV HOPpOHW,Q6]DEiO\WDODQIRQROyJLD6]HUN6,37È53e7(5%S±6,37È5± 6=(17*<g5*<, $PDJ\DU+IpOHKDQJRNRSWLPiOLVHOHP]pVH1\.±
D .(='(7 0LQGHQV]yWDJWDUWDOPD]NH]GHWHW
E 0,1' 0LQGHQEHPHQHWLV]HJPHQWXPQDNYDQPHJIHOHOMHDNLPHQHWEHQ W|U|OQLWLORV
F &6$. 0LQGHQNLPHQHWLV]HJPHQWXPQDNYDQPHJIHOHOMHDEHPHQHWEHQ EHWROGDQLWLORV
$WWyOIJJHQKRJ\HKiURPNRUOiWN|]OPHO\LNYDQDOHJDODFVRQ\DEEUDUDQJVR UROYDD]HOPpOHWD±EHOLKiURPDODSKHO\]HWHWMyVROMDPHJDKRODV]DJJDWRWWYR QDOD]WMHO]LKRJ\D]DGRWWNpWNRUOiWHJ\PiVKR]NpSHVWQLQFVUDQJVRUROYD!MHO]LHJ\
V]HJPHQWXPW|UOpVpWYDVWDJEHW&SHGLJHJ\V]HJPHQWXPEHWROGiViWDV]yWDJKDWiUWSRQW MHO|OL
&99 0,1' &6$. .(='(7
) &99
&9!9
&99!
&9&9
(]DUDQJVRUPHJIHOHODPDJ\DUEDQDIiUDyPRQRPRUIHPLNXVKLiWXVV]RPRU~DN V]LQWHWLNXVPRUIpPDKDWiUNXW\iXODQDOLWLNXVPRUIpPDKDWiUNXW\DyO|VV]HWpWHOKDWiU pVV]RPRU~DUFV]yKDWiUWtSXV~HVHWHNUH$]RQEDQPLQGHQUpV]OHJHVIHOROGiVLVWUDWp JLDNH]HOpVHWRYiEELNRUOiWRNEHYH]HWpVpWLJpQ\OL
&99 0,1' .(='(7 &6$.
&99
&9!9
&99!
) &9&9
(]DUDQJVRUDPDJ\DUEDQKHO\WHOHQEiUDPiVVDOKDQJ]yEHWROGiV VSHFLiOLVHVHWHL HOIRUGXOQDNNDUFV~VtWD]DOPDIL>M@~H]HNUOYDODPLO\HQPiVPyGRQNHOOV]iPRW DGQXQN$&6$.NRUOiWOHJDOXOUDUDQJVRUROiVDQHPDPHJIHOHOPyGMDDNH]HOpVNQHN
&99 &6$. .(='(7 0,1'
&99
) &9!9
) &99!
&9&9
$]WKRJ\DNHWWN|]OPHO\LNPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOGLNWRYiEELNRUOiWRNQDNNHOOHO G|QWHQLNO&$6$/,LP(]DUDQJVRUPHJIHOHOQHNOiWV]LND]RNUDD]HVHWHNUHDPH O\HNEHQD]HOVWLV]WDtW:WLV]WtWYDJ\DPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOGLNKDMyXQN :KDMyQN'HQHPHOpJVpJHVDPDJ\DUKHO\]HWPHJUDJDGiViKR]KLV]HQKHO\WHOHQOD]W MyVROMDKRJ\DIiUDypVIL~WtSXV~HVHWHNEHQLVW|UOGQLHNHOOHQHD]HJ\LNYDJ\DPiVLN PDJiQKDQJ]yQDN+DVRQOtWVXN|VV]HDV]RPRU~!RGLNV]RPRU~!tW V]RPRU~DN V]RPRU~DQ V]RPRU~R!QV]RPRU~D!EEWtSXV~HVHWHNHWPHJOHKHWVHQ|QNpQ\HV QHNW&QLNKRJ\D]HOVYDJ\DPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]yWNHOOW|U|OQQNYDJ\pSSHQVpJJHO HJ\LNHWVHP
$ P i V R G L N P D J i Q K D Q J ] y W | U O p V p Q H N H V H W H L ± 7HNLQWVN HOV]|U D]RNDW D] HVHWHNHW DPHO\HNEHQ $WtSXV~ WROGDOpNRN PDJiQKDQJ]yMD W|UOGLN
$PLQWDWiEOiEDQOiWKDWyDDODWW GHILQLiOWKiURPDODSYHWNRUOiWV]HULQWL UDQJVRUDQHPDKHO\HVNLPHQHWHWDGMDDV]RPRU~DUFRFVNDD]WMHO]LKRJ\D]pUWpNHOpV V]HULQWLRSWLPiOLVNLPHQHWQHPHJ\H]LNPHJDYDOyViJRVNLPHQHWWHO
KDMyN>JnLQÖM@
JnLQÖ9M 0,1' &6$. .(='(7
/ JnLQÖQM
JnLQÖVQM
JnLQM
JnLQÖM
JnLM
(POpNH]]QNYLVV]DKRJ\D]$WtSXV~WROGDOpNRNDNNRUpVFVDNDNNRUMHOHQQHN PHJN|WKDQJ]yQpONOKDPDJiQKDQJ]yUDYpJ]GWK|]MiUXOQDNLO\HQNRUWHKiWDW YpJLPDJiQKDQJ]yPHJPDUDGpVDSRWHQFLiOLVKLiWXVDN|WKDQJ]yW|UOpVpYHOROGyGLNIHO (]pUWGHILQLiOXQNHJ\~MDEENRUOiWRW0,1'WQpYHQpVD.(='(7NRUOiWRWD0,1'W
pVD 0,1'N|]pUDQJVRUROMXN$]HUHGPpQ\DWiEOiEDQOiWKDWy 0,1'W 7EHQW|U|OQLWLORV
0,1'7ª.(='(7ª0,1'
KDMyN>JnLQÖM@
JnLQÖ9M &6$. 0,1'W .(='(7 0,1'
JnLQÖQM
JnLQÖVQM
JnLQM
) JnLQÖM
JnLM
,WWDPiVRGLNMHO|OWiWKiJMDDPDJDVUDUDQJVRUROW&6$.NRUOiWRWPtJDKDUPDGLNpV D] |W|GLN D 0,1'WW $ IHQQPDUDGy NpW MHO|OW N|]O D OHJIHOV DPHO\ KHO\WHOHQO DJ\]WHVQHNOiWV]RWWDWiEOiEDQiWKiJMDD .(='(7HWDPHO\PRVWPDJDVDEEUDYDQ UDQJVRUROYD D] iOWDOiQRV 0,1' NRUOiWQiO (QQpOIRJYD D KHO\HV NLPHQHW OHV] D J\]WHV PLYHOD]FVDNH]XWyEELWKiJMDiW
(]DPHJROGiVDPRUIpPiQEHOOLKLiWXVRNHVHWpEHQLVP&N|GLN IiUDy>HCÖTnQÖ@
HCÖTnQÖ &6$. 0,1'W .(='(7 0,1'
) HCÖTnQÖ
HCÖTnVQÖ
HCÖTn
HCÖTQÖ
HCÖT
$PiVVDOKDQJ]yEHWROGiVWLWWLVD&6$.]iUMDNLPtJD]HOVYDJ\DPiVRGLNYDJ\
pSSHQPLQGNpWPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVpWD 0,1'W$]HOVMHO|OWEiUiWKiJMDD .(='(7 HWJ\]
1p]]ND]RQEDQDDWDKROD]HGGLJL NRUOiWDLQNpVUDQJVRUXQNDN|WKDQJ]y W|UOpVpWMyVROQiN
V]RPRU~DN>UQOQTWnM@
UQOQTW9M &6$. 0,1'W .(='(7 0,1'
UQOQTWQM
UQOQTWVQM
UQOQTQM
/ UQOQTWM
UQOQTWnM
$KRJ\IHQWHEEDSRQWEDQOiWWXNDQ\LWyW|YHNHWDNNRULVN|YHWLHJ\Q\tOWN|W KDQJ]yKDPDJiQKDQJ]yUDYpJ]GQHN$Q\LWyW|YHNHWOHEHJ>DOVy@MHJ\pUWpNMHOOHP ]LDPHO\HWU|YLGtWYHDOVy LQGH[EHtUW$YDOIRJXQNMHO|OQL)HOWHVV]NWRYiEEiKRJ\D OHEHJ MHJ\HN IHOV]tQUH NHUOpVpW HJ\ VSHFLiOLV NRUOiW V]RUJDOPD]]D DPHO\ D .(='(7I|OpYDQUDQJVRUROYD
0,1'V]XE 6]XEV]HJPHQWiOLVDQ\DJW|UOpVHWLORV
0,1'6=8%ª.(='(7
(]DKHO\HVNLPHQHWKH]YH]HW $WtSXV~WROGDOpNNDOHOOiWRWWPDJiQKDQJ]yYpJ&Q\L WyW|YHNHVHWpEHQ+DHJ\DGRWWMHO|OWN|]pSVQ\HOYiOOiV~N|WKDQJ]yWWDUWDOPD]YDJ\
VHPPLO\HWiWKiJMDD0,1'V]XENRUOiWRWOiVGD]HOVpVDQHJ\HGLNMHO|OWHW$WPDJiQ KDQJ]yW|UOpVHPLQWDKDUPDGLNMHO|OWEHQLOOHWYHHJ\PiVVDOKDQJ]yEHWROGiVD PLQW DPiVRGLNEDQHOHJHQGDKKR]KRJ\D]pULQWHWWMHO|OWHWNL]iUMDDYHUVHQ\EODNiUPHJ MHOHQLNEHQQHDOHEHJMHJ\pUWpNDNiUQHP
V]RPRU~DN>UQOQTWnM@
UQOQTW$9M &6$. 0,1'W 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
UQOQTWQM
UQOQTWVQM
UQOQTnM
UQOQTWM
) UQOQTWnM
'HKDPRVWPHJQp]]NPLW|UWpQLNDQ\LWyPHOOpNQHYHNN|]pSIRN~DODNMiEDQD]W OiWMXNKRJ\HGGLJLHOHP]pVQND>UQOQTWnDÖ@DODNRWKR]]DNLJ\]WHVNpQW
V]RPRU~EE>UQOQTWDÖ@
UQOQTW$9DÖ &6$. 0,1'W 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
UQOQTWQDÖ
UQOQTWVQDÖ
UQOQTnDÖ
UQOQTWDÖ
/ UQOQTWnDÖ
(]pUWHOV]|ULVGHILQLiOMXND0,1'WpVD 0,1'V]XEN|]|WWLUDQJVRUWH]]HOMHOH]YH KRJ\IRQWRVDEEPHJWDUWDQLDWYpJLPDJiQKDQJ]yWPLQWpUYpQ\UHMXWWDWQLDOHEHJMHJ\
pUWpNHW
0,1'7ª0,1'6=8%
&VDNKRJ\DPLQWDWiEOiEDQOiWKDWyH]PpJQHPHOpJtJ\LVXJ\DQD]DMHO|OW J\]PLQWD]LPpQWWRYiEEUDLVDWpQ\HNNHOV]HPEHQ
V]RPRU~EE>UQOQTWDÖ@
UQOQTW$9DÖ &6$. 0,1'W 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
UQOQTWQDÖ
UQOQTWVQDÖ
UQOQTnDÖ
UQOQTWDÖ
/ UQOQTWnDÖ
$SUREOpPDDEEyODGyGLNKRJ\DN|]pSIRNMHOpWD]$WtSXV~WROGDOpNRNN|]pVR UROWXNEH6,37È5±7g5.(1&=<LPQ\RPiQ+DD]RQEDQiWVRUROMXND %WtSXV~DN N|]pYDJ\LVV]yWiULiEUi]ROiViWHJ\V]HU&HQEÖDODN~QDNYHVV]NLQJDWDJPDJiQKDQJ]y QpONODQHKp]VpJPDJiWyOPHJROGyGLN
¶N|]pSIRNMHOH¶ EÖ%WtSXV
(]WOiWKDWMXNDWiEOiEDQDKROPRVWPiUPLQGHQN|WKDQJ]yWWDUWDOPD]yMHO|OW iWKiJMDD&6$.NRUOiWRW
V]RPRU~EE>UQOQTWDÖ@
UQOQTW$DÖ &6$. 0,1'W 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
UQOQTWQDÖ
UQOQTWVQDÖ
UQOQTnDÖ
) UQOQTWDÖ
UQOQTWnDÖ
9LV]RQWPRVWPHJDPiVVDOKDQJ]yUDYpJ]GPHOOpNQHYHNNHOOHV]EDMH]HNLViW KiJMiN D &6$.RW KD N|WKDQJ]yW LOOHV]WQN N|]pSIRN~ DODNMXNED SHGLJ HVHWNEHQ D KHO\HVNLPHQHWEHQOHQQLHNHOOHJ\Q\tOWN|WKDQJ]yQDN
YLGiPDEE>XKFCÖOnDÖ@
XKFCÖO$DÖ &6$. 0,1'W 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
XKFCÖOQDÖ
XKFCÖOnDÖ
XKFCÖDÖ
/ XKFCÖODÖ
)LJ\HOMNPHJKRJ\DEHOLJ\]WHVGHKHO\WHOHQMHO|OWPHJHQJHGKHWHWOHQ V]yYpJL PiVVDOKDQJ]yNDSFVRODWRW WDUWDOPD] 1\LOYiQYDOyDQ OHQQLH NHOO HJ\ NRUOiWFVR SRUWQDNDPHO\HOYiODV]WMDD IRQRWDNWLNDLODJMyOIRUPiOWDODNRNDWDQHPMyOIRUPiOWDNWyO (]WDNRUOiWFVRSRUWRWPRVWHJ\V]HU&HQ6=Ï7$*6=(5.QpYHQ|VV]HIRJODOYDpVOHJIHOOUH UDQJVRUROYDH]DSUREOpPDLVPHJROGyGLN
6=Ï7$*6=(5.ª&6$.0,1'W
YLGiPDEE>XKFCÖOnDÖ@
XKFCÖO$DÖ 6=Ï7$*6=(5. &6$. 0,1'W 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
XKFCÖOQDÖ
) XKFCÖOnDÖ
XKFCÖDÖ
XKFCÖODÖ
1p]]N PRVW D] RO\DQ PDJiQKDQJ]yNH]GHW& WROGDOpNRNDW PLQWLJpUWXOO +D H]HN PDJiQKDQJ]yUD YpJ]G WK|] MiUXOQDN VHPPL VHP W|UWpQLN HJ\LN PDJiQ KDQJ]yVHPHVLNNLpVQ\tOWN|WKDQJ]yVHPOpSDWROGDOpNPDJiQKDQJ]yKHO\pUHD]D]D OHEHJ MHJ\ pUYpQ\HVtWHWOHQO PDUDG 'H MHOHQ HV]N|]HLQNNHO QHP H]W D] HUHGPpQ\W NDSMXN
V]RPRU~LJ>UQOQTWKI@
UQOQTW$KI &6$. 0,1'W 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
UQOQTWKI
UQOQTWVKI
UQOQTKI
UQOQTWI
/ UQOQTWnI
$]tJ\YLVHONHGWROGDOpNRNPLQGHJ\LNHDQDOLWLNXV(]pUWPpJHJ\YLV]RQ\ODJPD JDVUDUDQJVRUROW0,1'WtSXV~NRUOiWUDYDQV]NVpJQNDPHO\D 0,1'V]XEI|OpYDQ UDQJVRUROYD$PLQWDWiEOiEDQOiWKDWyH]]HONp]HQIHNYHQPHJROGyGLNH]D]
HVHWLV
0,1'DQDO $QDOLWLNXVWROGDOpNEDQW|U|OQLWLORV 0,1'DQDOª 0,1'V]XE
V]RPRU~LJ>UQOQTWKI@
UQOQTW$KI &6$. 0,1'W 0,1'DQDO 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
) UQOQTWKI
UQOQTWVKI
UQOQTKI
UQOQTWI
UQOQTWnI
(EEHQ D SRQWEDQ RSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWL HOHP]pVW DGWXQN D PiVRGLN PDJiQKDQJ]y W|UOpVpYHOMiUypVDW|UOpVQpONOLHVHWHNUO$]XWyEELDNN|]|WWV]HUHSHOWHNDPRUIpPiQ EHOOLDQ\LWyWpVV]LQWHWLNXV$WtSXV~WROGDOpNN|]|WWNLDODNXOyYDODPLQWD] DQDOLWL NXVWROGDOpNROiVEyOHUHGKLiWXVHVHWHL$N|YHWNH]SRQWEDQiWWpUQND]RNUDDSpOGiNUD DPHO\HNEHQ D] HOVPDJiQKDQJ]y W|UOpVpYHO ROGyGLN IHO D V]LQWHWLNXV PRUIpPDKDWiURQ NLDODNXOyKLiWXV
$ ] H O V P D J i Q K D Q J ] y W | U O p V p Q H N H V H W H L ±$PLQWDWiE OiEDQOiWKDWyDSUREOpPDKDVRQOtWDEHOLKH]GHQHPROGKDWyPHJD0,1'DQDOVHJtW VpJpYHOPLYHOHOV]|ULVD]tJ\YLVHONHGWROGDOpNRNQHPDQDOLWLNXVDNPiVRGV]RUSHGLJ PpJKDD]RNOHQQpQHNLVHOHP]pVQND>UQOQTWKÖV@DODNRWMyVROQi±DPLQWiMiUD±
QHPSHGLJDKHO\HV>UQOQTKÖV@DODNRW
V]RPRUtW>UQOQTKÖV@
UQOQTW$KÖV &6$. 0,1'W 0,1'DQDO 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
UQOQTWKÖV
UQOQTWVKÖV
UQOQTKÖV
UQOQTWV
/ UQOQTWnV
ÒJ\OiWV]LNKRJ\NpW~MDEENRUOiWUDYDQV]NVpJQNHJ\UHDPHO\WLOWMDD]LO\HQ WtSXV~KLiWXVIHQQPDUDGiViWpVHJ\UHDPHO\QHNpUWHOPpEHQD]pULQWHWWWROGDOpNRNPD JiQKDQJ]yMiQDNPHJNHOOPDUDGQLD
>VtW $]tWWtSXV~WROGDOpNRNQHPiOOKDWQDNN|]YHWOHQOV]yWDJKDWiUXWiQ 0,1'tW 7|U|OQLWLORVtWWtSXV~WROGDOpNEDQ
+DPLQGNpW~MNRUOiWXQND0,1'WI|OpYDQUDQJVRUROYDDWPDJiQKDQJ]yQDNNHOO W|UOGQLHDPLQWDWiEOiEDQOiWKDWy$N|YHWNH]SRQWYpJpQPpJYLVV]DWpUQNHK KH]D]HOHP]pVKH]
>VtW 0,1'tWª0,1'W
V]RPRUtW>UQOQTKÖV@
UQOQTW$KÖV &6$. >VtW 0,1'tW 0,1'W 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
UQOQTWKÖV
UQOQTWVKÖV
) UQOQTKÖV
UQOQTWV
UQOQTWnV
0 i V V D O K D Q J ] y E H W R O G i V ± $]DaD]YiOWDNR]iVUyODSRQWEDQD]W PRQGWXNKRJ\OHEHJ\YHOFpOV]HU&HOHPH]QL(]WD]HGGLJIHOpStWHWWUHQGV]HUQNHOpJ HJ\V]HU&HQ NpSHV NH]HOQL DPLQW D WiEOD PXWDWMD $ OHJIRQWRVDEE NRUOiW LWW D0,1'V]XEDPHO\V]HULQWDOHEHJV]XEV]HJPHQWiOLVDQ\DJQDNpUYpQ\HVOQLHNHOODIHO V]tQHQKDH]OHKHWVpJHV)LJ\HOMNPHJKRJ\PiVVDOKDQJ]yYDONH]GGIQpYHOWWD OHEHJ\FVDNDNNRUWXGQDPHJYDOyVXOQLDIHOV]tQHQKDEHV]~UQiQNHJ\NO|QLG]tWpVL SRQWRW DPHO\KH] NDSFVROyGKDWQD (] D]RQEDQ PHJVpUWHQp D PDJDVUD UDQJVRUROW &6$.
NRUOiWRWpVtJ\EL]WRVDQNLHVQHDYHUVHQ\EO D]HPEHU>n\'OD'T@
n='OD'T &6$. 0,1'W 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
n'OD'T
nV'OD'T
nOD'T
'OD'T
) n\'OD'T
+DVRQOy HOHP]pVW DGKDWQiQN D]RNUyO D] HVHWHNUO DPHO\HNEHQ=5? WROGyGLN EH RO\DQWROGDOpNRNHOpDPHO\HNUHQGHVHQDWYpJLPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVpWYiOWMiNNL$KR J\DQPXWDWMDD]RQEDQH]~WWDOD]HOHP]pVQHPN|YHWNH]LNHJ\V]HU&HQD]HGGLJIHO pStWHWWNRUOiWUHQGV]HUEO
iOODQGyVtW>CÖNnPFQÖ5KÖV@
CÖNnPFQÖ$KÖV &6$. >VtW 0,1'tW 0,1'W 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
CÖNnPFQÖKÖV
CÖNnPFQÖ5KÖV
/ CÖNnPFKÖV
CÖNnPFQÖV
CÖNnPFQÖnV
3UyEiONR]KDWQiQND&6$.NRUOiWiWUDQJVRUROiViYDOD0,1'WDOiDKRJ\DQ±
PXWDWMD
0,1'Wª&6$.
iOODQGyVtW>CÖNnPFQÖ5KÖV@
CÖNnPFQÖ$KÖV >VtW 0,1'tW 0,1'W &6$. 0,1'V]XE .(='(7 0,1'
CÖNnPFQÖKÖV
) CÖNnPFQÖ5KÖV
CÖNnPFKÖV
CÖNnPFQÖV
CÖNnPFQÖnV
(]PHJROGDQi D]iOODQGyVtWSUREOpPiMiWGH HOURQWDQi DV]RPRUtW WtSXV~ HVHWHNUH DGRWWHOHP]pVQNHWOeVQHPROGDQiPHJD]WDNpUGpVWVHPKRJ\PLpUWpSSHQ>5@
WROGyGLNEH$SRQWEDQPiUDGWXQNHUUHHJ\HOIRJDGKDWyYiODV]WD]ROFVyVtWNDUFV~VtW iOODQGyVXO IHOIRUUyVRGLNWtSXV~ HVHWHNEHQ D] >5@ IRUUiVD DKi]DVtW IiVtW PHJVHEHVO KDV]QRVXOHOKRPiO\RVRGLNVWESpOGiNDQDOyJLiMDDIDOXVLWDQ\DVLHVHWpEHQSHGLJDYi URVLDODNp'HKDD]H]HNUODGRWWOHtUiVXQNDQDOyJLiVDODS~W|EEpQLQFVV]NVpJIRQROy JLDLPDJ\DUi]DWUDpVtJ\ RSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWLHOHP]pVUHVHP7RYiEEPHQYHKDPiUHOIR JDGWXND]DQDOyJLiWPLQWPDJ\DUi]yHOYHWO0<(56LPDQQDNVLQFVVHPPLDNDGiO\D KRJ\DV]RPRUtWHOV]RPRURGLNWLV]WtWWLV]WXOVWEHVHWHWD]HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVpQHN HVHWHLWXJ\DQFVDNNL]iUyODJDQDOyJLiVDODSRQPDJ\DUi]]XNVWDNiUDYLGtWYLGXOWtSXV~
HVHWHNHW LV DPHO\HNQHN NDSFVRODWD DYLGiPWtSXV~ DODSV]DYXNKR] PpJ iWWpWHOHVHEE .È/0È1±5(%586±7g5.(1&=<LPMDYDVODWDDODSMiQSHGLJPpJDN|WKDQJ]yNHJpV]
NpUGpVN|UpWYDJ\LVDPiVRGLNPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVpWLVOHKHWQH DQDOyJLiVDODSRQNH]HO QLYROWDNpSSHQD]WMDYDVROMiNKRJ\D]HJpV]PRUIRIRQROyJLDDODSMDOHJ\HQD]DQDOyJLD N|YHWNH]pVNpSS V]DEiO\RNUD OHYH]HWpVHNUH GH PpJ NRUOiWRNUD PHJV]RUtWiVRNUD VH KL YDWNR]]XQNDOHtUiViEDQ(EEOD]N|YHWNH]QHKRJ\D±SRQWEDQDGRWWHOHP]pVHLQN WHOMHVPpUWpNEHQFpOWWpYHV]WHWWHNpVHJpV]PiVNpSSNHOOHQHD GRORJKR]KR]]iIRJQXQN
$]RQEDQDMHOHQGROJR]DWEDQWiUJ\DOWWHUOHWQHNDPDJiQKDQJ]yNDSFVRODWRNNpUGpVN|Up QHNYDQHJ\RO\DQIHOV]tQLIRQROyJLDLV]HOHWHLVDPHO\UHPLQGHQNpSSHQWLV]WiQIRQROy
JLDLPHJROGiVWNHOOWDOiOQXQN(]SHGLJDKDJ\RPiQ\RVDQ K L i W X V W | O W p V QHNQHYH]HWW MHOHQVpJ$WRYiEELDNEDQHUUODGXQNHJ\OHKHWVpJHVRSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWLHOHP]pVW
$ K L i W X V W | O W p V R S W L P D O L W i V H O P p O H W L H O H P ] p V H ±$SRQW EDQD]WPRQGWXNKRJ\iOWDOiEDQVHPDEHWROGiVVHPDW|UOpVQHPM|QV]iPEDDPDJ\DU EDQ D IHOV]tQL KLiWXVRN PHJV]QWHWpVpQHN HV]N|]HNpQW $]RQEDQ ILJ\HOMQN IHO DUUD KRJ\D±DODWWVHPDWLNXVDQPHJDGRWWMHO|OWHND]HOYEHQYpJWHOHQV]iPEDQJHQH UiOW DODNRNQDN FVXSiQ W|UHGpNpW NpSYLVHOLN $ JHQHUiWRU H]HNHQ NtYO PpJ V]iPWDODQ DODNRWHOiOOtWLJD]KRJ\H]HNOHJQDJ\REEUpV]HHOHYHHOEXNLND]pUWpNHOpVVRUiQ$]RQ EDQYDQHJ\PyGMDDKLiWXVPHJV]QWHWpVpQHNDPHO\UHHGGLJQHPJRQGROWXQND]KRJ\
DN|UQ\H]PDJiQKDQJ]yNV]HJPHQWiOLVDQ\DJDNLWHUMHGD]UHVNH]GHWSR]tFLyUDH]iOWDO PHJV]QWHWYHDQQDNUHVVpJpWDQpONOKRJ\YDODPHO\PiVVDOKDQJ]yWRGDDV]yV]RURV pUWHOPpEHQEHWROGDQiQN0LYHODJHQHUiWRUNpSHVEiUPHO\PDJiQKDQJ]yWD]UHVSR]tFL yUDiWWHUMHV]WHQL PpJSHGLJ DNiU MREEUyO DNiU EDOUyO D PHJIHOHONRUOiWRNQDN pV D]RN UDQJVRUROiViQDN D GROJD OHV] D QHP OpWH] OHKHWVpJHN NLV]&UpVH $PLQW D SRQWEDQ OiWWXND]RNEDQD]HVHWHNEHQDPHO\HNEHQDWHUMHGPDJiQKDQJ]yDOVy >CÖn0@YDJ\
NHUHN >nQÖ1ÖWÖ[Ö@DOpWUHM|YDODNRNQHPOHKHWQHNRSWLPiOLVDN$VHQHP DOVyVHQHPNHUHNPDJiQKDQJ]yNN|]OD>IHOV@MHJ\&>K@>KÖ@pVD>QHPIHOV@MHJ\&>GÖ@
WHUMHGpVHHJ\DUiQW>L@PHJMHOHQpVpWHUHGPpQ\H]LFVDNKRJ\D]>K@>KÖ@EO HUHG>L@WWDU WDOPD]yDODND]HJ\HWOHQRSWLPiOLVNLPHQHWPtJD]>GÖ@EO HUHG>L@VDODNRWpVDWHUMH GpVQpONOL±D .(='(7 NRUOiWRW iWKiJy ± DODNRW HJ\DUiQW PHJ NHOO HQJHGQLH D Q\HOY WDQQDNPLQWRSWLPiOLVNLPHQHWHW
(V]HULQWDN|YHWNH]WRYiEELNRUOiWRNUDOHV]V]NVpJQNO 6,37È52SWLPiOLVKL iWXVW|OWpV
D >DOVy@& 0iVVDOKDQJ]ySR]tFLyKR] QHP N|WGKHW >DOVy@ MHJ\HW WDU WDOPD]yPDJiQKDQJ]y
E >NHUHN@& 0iVVDOKDQJ]ySR]tFLyKR] QHP N|WGKHW >NHUHN@ MHJ\HW WDU WDOPD]yPDJiQKDQJ]y
F >QHPIHOV@& 0iVVDOKDQJ]ySR]tFLyKR] QHP N|WGKHW >QHPIHOV@ MHJ\HW WDUWDOPD]yPDJiQKDQJ]y
G >IHOV@& 0iVVDOKDQJ]ySR]tFLyKR] QHP N|WGKHW >IHOV@ MHJ\HW WDU WDOPD]yPDJiQKDQJ]y
$DpVDENRUOiWQDNDIHQWLHNpUWHOPpEHQD .(='(7I|OpNHOOUDQJVRUROYD OHQQLHDGQHNDOiMDPtJDFNRUOiWpVD .(='(7N|]|WWQHPiOOIHQQUDQJVRU (NNRUSRQWRVDQDPHJIHOHOHUHGPpQ\HNHWNDSMXN
>DOVy@&>NHUHN@&ª.(='(7>QHPIHOV@&ª>IHOV@&
+RJ\DQEROGRJXOQDNDDODWWLNRUOiWRNpVV]HULQWLUDQJVRUROiVXNDN|WHOH]
KLiWXVW|OWpVVHODKLiWXVW|OWpVHOPDUDGiViYDOYDODPLQWD IDNXOWDWtYKLiWXVW|OWpV VHO"
IL~>HKLW@
HKW 0,1'W &6$. >DO@& >NHU@& .(='(7 >QI@& >IHO@&
HKW
HK
HW
HKVW
) HKLW
HKYW
HKmW
$]WiEODHOVMHO|OWMHDEHPHQHWKH]WHOMHVHQK&DODNiWKiJMDD.(='(7NRUOiWRW DPLH]~WWDOYpJ]HWHVQHNEL]RQ\XO$PiVRGLNpVKDUPDGLNMHO|OWDPHO\EHQDPiVRGLN LOOHWYHD]HOVPDJiQKDQJ]yW|UOpVpYHOSUyEiOQiQNHONHUOQLDKLiWXVKHO\]HWHWD 0,1'W
NRUOiWRWKiJMDiWPtJDQHJ\HGLNDPHO\EHQYDODPHO\WHWV]OHJHVPiVVDOKDQJ]yEHWROGi ViYDOSUyEiONR]XQND&6$.NRUOiWRW$KDWRGLNMHO|OWEHQD>Y@D]WMHO]LKRJ\D]>W@
DPDJD>NHUHN@pV>IHOV@MHJ\HLYHOiWWHUMHGD]UHVSR]tFLyUDH]D]DODND>NHU@&NRU OiWRWKiJMDiWPHJD>IHO@&NRUOiWRWLVGHH]PiUPLQGHJ\$KHWHGLNMHO|OWEHQD]>m@ D]W LJ\HNV]LN pU]pNHOWHWQL KRJ\ D] UHV KHO\UH EHWROGXQN HJ\ >DOVy@ MHJ\& IpOPDJiQ KDQJ]yW,O\HQV]HJPHQWXPDPDJ\DUEDQQHPOpWH]LNXJ\DQGHDJHQHUiWRU±PLQWWXG MXN±V]DEDGRQOpWUHKR]KDWEiUPLWYDJ\LVD]LO\HQHOHYHUHPpQ\WHOHQMHO|OWHNNLV]&UpVp UOLVJRQGRVNRGQLDNHOOD]pUWpNHOQHNeSSHQHUUHV]ROJiOD>DOVy@&NRUOiW0LYHOHQQHN DIpOPDJiQKDQJ]yQDNHVHWQNEHQHJ\LNV]RPV]pGRVPDJiQKDQJ]yEDQVLQFVIRUUiVD DEHWROGiVVDOD&6$.pVD]>DO@&NRUOiWRWHJ\DUiQWiWKiJMXNH]DNpWNRUOiWHJ\PiVKR]
NpSHVWQLQFVUDQJVRUROYDH]pUWPLQGNpWFVLOODJPHOOpIHONLiOWyMHOHWtUXQN±PLQGHJ\KRJ\
PHO\LNiWKiJiVWWHNLQWMNYpJ]HWHVQHN9pJOD]|W|GLNMHO|OWFVXSiQDOHJDOXOUD UDQJVR UROW>IHO@&NRUOiWRWKiJMDiWpVHQQHNN|YHWNH]WpEHQH]OHV]D]RSWLPiOLVNLPHQHWLDODN
0RVWQp]]NDIiUDyV]yWDPHO\EHQQHPW|UWpQLNKLiWXVW|OWpV IiUDy>HCÖTnQÖ@
HCÖTnQÖ 0,1'W &6$. >DO@& >NHU@& .(='(7 >QI@& >IHO@&
) HCÖTnQÖ
HCÖTn
HCÖTQÖ
HCÖTnVQÖ
HCÖTnLQÖ
HCÖTnYQÖ
HCÖTnmQÖ
(]~WWDODPiVRGLNKDUPDGLNQHJ\HGLNMHO|OWXJ\DQ~J\pVXJ\DQD]pUWHVLNNLDYHU VHQ\EOPLQWD]HOEE$]|W|GLNMHO|OWHVHWpEHQD>L@QHPWXGKRQQDQWHUMHGQLWHKiW FVDNEHWROGiVVDONHUOKHWRGDDPLYHOYLV]RQWiWKiJMDD &6$.NRUOiWRW$KDWRGLN pV DKHWHGLNMHO|OWQHNYDQKRQQDQYHQQLHD>NHUHN@LOOHWYHD]>DOVy@IpOPDJiQKDQJ]yWH]pUW D&6$.NRUOiWRWQHPFVXSiQD>NHU@&LOOHWYHD]>DO@&NRUOiWRWKiJMiNiWGHH]LVHOpJ DKKR]KRJ\NLHVVHQHN$>Y@IRUUiVDD]>QÖ@D>m@IRUUiVDSHGLJD]>n@YDJ\LVDKDWRGLN DODN D >QI@& NRUOiWRW LV iWKiJMD D KHWHGLN SHGLJ D] >DO@& PHOOHWW D >NHU@&W pV
D >QI@&W LV 0DUDG D] HOV MHO|OW PLQW RSWLPiOLV DODN LJD] KRJ\ H] PHJ iWKiJMD D.(='(7NRUOiWRWGHDGGLJUDD]|VV]HVYHWpO\WiUVDHOEXNRWWpVtJ\DWHOMHVHQK&VpJHV DODNJ\]
9pJO YHJ\N DNHWWpRV]WDODNRW DPHO\EHQ D KLiWXVW|OWpV IDNXOWDWtY /iWKDWMXN KRJ\NRUOiWDLQNpVUDQJVRUXQNHEEHQD]HVHWEHQLVDYiUWHUHGPpQ\WDGMiN
NHWWpRV]W>M'VÖGÖQUV@a>M'VÖGÖLQUV@
M'VÖGÖQUV 0,1'W &6$. >DO@& >NHU@& .(='(7 >QI@& >IHO@&
) M'VÖGÖQUV
M'VÖGÖUV M'VÖQUV
M'VÖGÖVQUV
) M'VÖGÖLQUV
M'VÖGÖYQUV
M'VÖGÖmQUV
,WWDYpJHUHGPpQ\G|QWHWOHQDPLD]WMHOHQWLKRJ\D]HOVpVD]|W|GLNMHO|OWHJ\D UiQWRSWLPiOLVYDJ\LVDNHWWpRV]WpVNHWWp>M@RV]WHJ\IRUPiQKHO\HVN|]|WWNV]DEDGYiO WDNR]iVYDQ$W|EELMHO|OWVRUVDKDVRQOyDIHQWWiUJ\DOWDNKR]
g V V ] H I R J O D O i V ±$]HEEHQDGROJR]DWEDQiWWHNLQWHWWMHOHQVpJFVRNRULJHQ VRNIpOHV]iOEyOiOOFVDND]EHQQNDN|]|VKRJ\tJ\YDJ\~J\PLQGHJ\LNNNDSFVRODWED KR]KDWyDKLiWXVRNHONHUOpVpYHOYDJ\IHOROGiViYDO$]HJ\LNYpJOHWHWDOHiQ\aOiQ\Wt SXV~OH[LNDOL]iOWHVHWHNNpSYLVHOLNDPHO\HNEHQWHOMHVHQQ\LOYiQYDOyDQVHPPLIpOH IRQR OyJLDLWHHQGQLQFV$PiVLNYpJOHWDpVSRQWEDQWiUJ\DOWIL>L@~WtSXV~KLiWXVW|OWpV DPHO\PLQGHQNpSSHQIRQROyJLDLOHtUiVWLJpQ\HOOHJ\HQD] RSWLPDOLWiVHOPpOHWLPLQWLWW YDJ\ EiUPLO\HQ PiV HOPpOHWL NHUHW&SpOGiXO DXWRV]HJPHQWiOLV O 6,37È5±7g5.(1&=<
LP±$NpWYpJOHWN|]|WWV]iPRViWPHQHWLMHOHQVpJHWWDOiOXQN$WLV]WDaWLV]WtW WtSXV~ W|UOpV SpOGiXO LQNiEE D NRQWLQXXP OH[LNDOL]iOW YpJpKH] HVLN N|]HOHEE D N|W KDQJ]yNW|UOpVHLQNiEEDIRQROyJLDLODJOHtUDQGySURGXNWtYYpJpKH]EiUOiWWXNKRJ\HU UH LV MDYDVROWDN OH[LNDOLVWDDQDOyJLiV WHKiW QHP IRQROyJLDL PDJ\DUi]DWRW $] V EHWROGiVRVHVHWHNV&U&V|GLNpVD]DaD]YiOWDNR]iVKDYDQQDNLVIRQROyJLDLYRQDWNR ]iVDLNLQNiEEDOH[LNRQEHOVJ\HLKH]WDUWR]QDNPtJD]DXWyIpOpNKLiWXVRVGLIWRQJX VRV pV PRQRIWRQJXVRV PHJYDOyVtWiVDLQDN HORV]OiVD LQNiEE IRQROyJLDL pV V]RFLROLQJYLV]WLNDLNpUGpV.tYOHVLNH]HQDVNiOiQDIHV]WHOHQJ\RUVEHV]pGÄW|UOpVHL QHN´|VV]HYRQiVDLQDNHVHWHSOUiDGiVXO=TCÖFCÖ5WN?DPHO\HNNHONDSFVRODWEDQHOVVRU EDQHV]N|]IRQHWLNDLpVYDJ\NRUSXV]Q\HOYpV]HWLNXWDWiVRNUDOHQQHLQNiEEV]NVpJ
6,37È53e7(5
7KHSKRQRORJ\RI+XQJDULDQYRZHOFOXVWHUV
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
D µIORDWLQJ¶ FRQVRQDQWDO PHORG\ RU WKH VSUHDG RI VRPH FRQVRQDQWDO PHORG\ IURP RQH RI WKH YRZHO SRVLWLRQV IODQNLQJ WKH HPSW\ RQVHW SRVLWLRQ 7KLV SDSHU VXUYH\V WKH PDMRU KLDWXV DYRLG DQFHUHVROXWLRQSDWWHUQVWKDWDUHDWWHVWHGLQ+XQJDULDQWKHVHWXUQRXWWRLQFOXGHQHDUO\DOORIWKH ORJLFDOO\SRVVLEOHSDWWHUQV,QSDUWLFXODUHOLVLRQRIWKHILUVWYRZHOV]RPRURGLNµEHFRPHVDG¶
WKDW RI WKH VHFRQG YRZHO NRFVLQ µRQ D FDUW¶ GLSKWKRQJ IRUPDWLRQ DXWy µFDU¶ FRQVRQDQW HSHQWKHVLVNDUFV~VtWµPDNHVOLP¶IORDWLQJFRQVRQDQWUHDOLVDWLRQD]DOPDµWKHDSSOH¶DVZHOO DVKLDWXVUHVROXWLRQLQWKHVWULFWVHQVHIL>M@~µER\¶DUHGLVFXVVHGLQPRUHRUOHVVGHWDLO,QWKHVHF RQGSDUWRIWKHSDSHUWKHVHSKHQRPHQDDUHJLYHQDQRSWLPDOLW\WKHRUHWLFDQDO\VLV
3e7(56,37È5
$MHQV]ypVDPLN|UO|WWHYDQ
$MDSiQRNQDN± DKROODQGQ\HOYKHO\HWWDPHO\QHNN|]YHWtWpVpYHOKR]]iIpUKHWWHN D]HXUySDLWXGRPiQ\RVViJYLOiJiKR]D]HO]iUW-DSiQEDQ± D0HLG]VLNRUEDQPiUPLQGH QHNHOWWDQJROXONHOOHWWWDQXOQLXNQDJ\REE LQWHQ]LWiVVDOVH]]HOHJ\WWDODWLQEHW&NLV VRNNDOV]pOHVHEEN|UEHQNH]GWHNHOWHUMHGQLPLQWNRUiEEDQDPLEHQD]HJ]RWLNXPLUiQWL YRQ]DORP LV V]HUHSHW MiWV]KDWRWW 0LQGHQ EL]RQQ\DO V]HPEHVOWHN D]]DO D NpUGpVVHO LV KRJ\DQtUMiNiWDV]HPpO\QHYHNHWKHO\QHYHNHWVWEODWLQEHW&NNHO$0HLG]VLUHVWDXUiFLy LGHMpQpUGHNHVPyGRQVRNRO\DQNLVN|Q\YHWYDJ\I]HWHWLVNLDGWDNDPHO\QHPD]DQJRO Q\HOYWDQXOiViWW&]WHFpOXOKDQHPFVXSiQDMDSiQV]yWDJRNQDND]DQJROLOOHWYHODWLQEH W&NNHOYDOyiWtUiViQDNWDQtWiViUDV]RUtWNR]RWW+$6+,=80(.$1¶,&+,EHQ± DPLNRU pSSHQD]~MSpQ]QHPHWDMHQWLVEHYH]HWWpN ± PHJMHOHQWHWWHD]Ä(LJDNXQDJDVKLUDML´
DV]HU]iWtUiVDV]HULQW(LKJDNXQDKJDVKLUDML $FVDOiGQHYHNHOVtUiVMHJ\pQHNDQJRO EHW&V iWtUiVD FtP& KDVRQOy MHOOHJ&I]HWHFVNpMpW PHO\EHQ D] iWtUiVRN QHP D NLHMWpVW KDQHPQDJ\MiEyODNRUDEHOLNXV]DNDQDKDV]QiODWRWYHWWpNDODSXO0RVWt]HOtWOQp]]QN PHJ QpKiQ\ V]iPXQNUD pUGHNHV V]yW V]yWDJRW ]iUyMHOEH WpYH PHOOp D PDL +HSEXUQ UHQGV]HU&iWtUiVWKDHWWOHOWpU!d\HHUpV×d\HLHL7\HWV]HWVX çfHQ$NDQDKDV]QiODWQHPN|YHWNH]HWHVLOOHWYHQHPPLQGLJIHOHOPHJDW|UWpQHWL NDQDKDV]QiODWQDNPLV]HULQWLWWD]d QHND]fSHGLJdfQHNtUDQGyVWDOD WLQEHW&ViWtUiVRNVHPN|YHWNH]HWHVHN
(POtWpVUHPpOWyKRJ\%$%$7$768,±EDQDPLNRU/RQGRQEDQ MRJRWWDQXOWPHJMHOHQWHWHWWHJ\MDSiQQ\HOYWDQWDQJROXO$N|Q\YpEHQQHYpWQHP7DWVXL QDN KDQHP7DWXLQDN tUWD %$%$7$78, $Q (OHPHQWDU\ *UDPPDU RI WKH -DSDQHVH /DQJXDJH /RQGRQ (]W LV WDUWDOPD]]D UHSULQWEHQ D %DED 7DWVXL ]HQVKÌ >% 7
|VV]HJ\&MW|WW P&YHL@ N|WHWH 7RNLy DPHO\QHN HOV]DYiEDQ NULWL]iOMD 025,
$5,125,±IHOLVPHUpVpWDMDSiQQ\HOYQHPW|NpOHWHVYROWiUyOHUUODYLWiUyOO ,<2168.8>/((<(28168.@¶.RNXJR¶ WR LX VKLVÀ7RNLy±.|Q\YpEHQ DPHO\QHNPHJtUiViUDWXODMGRQNpSSHQ025,QDNDMDSiQQ\HOYUONLIHMWHWWQp]HWHNpV]WHW WHPHJHPOtWLD]gWYHQV]yWDJWiEOi]DWiWDPHO\V]HULQWDNpUGpVHVKiURPVRUDN|YHWN H
]NpSSHQV]HUHSHODVRUDLXHdRe\DVRU\DW\L\XY\H\R[
ZDVRUZDbZLWZXZHdZRe%$%$PHJMHJ\]LKRJ\ÄHdKDVWKHVRXQGRIH LQHFKR´ÄdDQGDQGWDQGeDUHGLVWLQJXLVKHGE\DQFLHQWXVDJHEXWDWWKH SUHVHQWWLPHWKHGLVWLQFWLRQLVQRORQJHUREVHUYHG´LP±1pKiQ\NDQDMHODPHO\H NHW%$%$IHOWQWHWHWWQHPKHO\pQYDOyXJ\DQGHKDVRQOy|VV]HYLVV]DViJMHOHQYROWH]HN EHQD]LGNEHQ768.,6+,0$LP±0$%8&+,LP$\DYDODPLQW DZDVRUODWLQEHW&ViWtUiVDLV]LPPHWULNXVNpSOHWHWPXWDWQDNDPL 12$&.Q\HOYN|Q\Y pEHQLVPHJILJ\HOKHWYROWpVD\L\HpVZXiWtUiVRNV]pSHQLOOHV]NHGQHND\DLOOHWYH
