T
ANULMÁNYKÖTET6=ė1<,%(1-È0,1
5()250È786
/(/.,3È6=725
.g/7ė
Ë5Ï
6=h/(7e6e1(.
e9)25'8/Ï-È5$
+Ï'0(=ė9È6È5+(/<Ï7(03/20,5()250È786(*<+È=.g=6e*
7e6e1(.e9)25'8/Ï-$$/.$/0È%Ï/5(1'(=(77h11(3,.21)(5(1&,$%ė9Ë
7(77(/ė$'È6$,77$57$/0$=Ï7$18/0È1<.g7(7
6=(5.(6=7ė
352)'5,05(0,+È/<
6=(5.(6=7ė$66=,6=7(16
%È1&6$%$(/(.$1'5È6 .255(.7Ò5$
.È'È51e=62/'26(',768/<2.&6$%$
)27Ï.
'21.$*È%25'g0g7g50,+È/<
$0$*<$5+$//(/8-$+È/$$'Ïe1(.)255È6$
'81$0(//e.,5()250È786(*<+È=.(5h/(75È'$<*<ĥ-7(0e1<(
*5$),.$,7(59(=e6e61<20'$,(/ė.e6=Ë7e6 6=(1'(5È.26
.,$'-$
+Ï'0(=ė9È6È5+(/<±Ï7(03/20,5()250È786(*<+È=.g=6e*
)(/(/ė6.,$'Ï
%È1&6$%$5()250È786/(/.,3È6=725
+Ï'0(=ė9È6È5+(/<±Ï7(03/20,5()250È786(*<+È=.g=6e*
$.g7(70(*-(/(1e6e77È02*$77$
1<20'$,.,9,7(/(=e6
,1129$5,$171<20'$,3$5,.)7 ,6%1
Tartalomjegyzék
(/ė6=Ï ...
%(9(=(7ė ...6 7$18/0È1<2. ...
SIMON FERENC
6=ė1<,%(1-È0,1.25$e6$9È6È5+(/<,5()250È786*,01È=,80.g1<97È5$14 HEGYI ÁDÁM
6=ė1<,3È/±6=ė1<,%(1-È0,1,0326=725),$35 IMRE MIHÁLY
6,216,5$/0$±(*<9(567g%%6=(5=ė"47
SION SIRALMA (VERS)81
ÖTVÖS PÉTER
5$-21*È6e6)(*<(/(01<(/9,$57,.8/È&,Ï,93 )$-7$1,7$
6=ė1<,%(1-È0,1.g/7e6=(7e1(.3,(7,67$"(/(0(,101
*<ė5,/-È126
6=ė1<,%(1-È0,10È57Ë52.26=/23È+2=5$*$6=7277e1(.(118 0È57Ë52.26=/23È+2=5$*6=7277e1(.9(56126 FEKETE CSABA
6=ė1<,%(1-È0,1e1(.(,e6$5()250È786e1(.(6.g1<9136 0$*<$5+$//(/8-$+È/$$'Ïe1(. ...
+ ( * < , È ' È 0
6=7(.XOWXUiOLVgU|NVpJpV+XPiQ,QIRUPiFLyWXGRPiQ\L7DQV]pN
6]ĘQ\L3iO±
6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQLPSRV]WRU¿D
S
]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQKRVV]~pOHWHVRUiQLJHQVRNJ\HUPHNHWQHP]HWW|V]V]HVHQWt]J\HUPHNHV]OHWHWWDNLNN|]OKDWDQpOWpNPHJDIHOQĘWWNRUW
$]RN DNLN D QDJ\NRU~ViJRW LV PHJpOWpN D OHONpV]FVDOiGRNEyO V]iU PD]yHPEHUHNWLSLNXVpOHWSiO\iMiWYiODV]WRWWiNDOiQ\RNOHONLSiV]WRURNKR]
PHQWHNIpUMKH]D¿~NSDSQDNWDQXOWDN$WHOMHVVpJLJpQ\HQpONOPHJHPOtW KHWMN=Vy¿iWDNLDJ\RPDLOHONpV]0DUMDODNL'iQLHOIHOHVpJHOHWWYDODPLQW -XGLWRWDNLDKyGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\LOHONLSiV]WRUKR])UHGL6iQGRUKR]PHQW IHOHVpJO EDQ (V]WHU D PDNyL OHONLSiV]WRU (FVHGL 0LNOyV QHMH OHWW
%HQMiPLQQHYĦ¿iUyOFVDNDQQ\LWWXGXQNKRJ\EHQDGHEUHFHQLNROOp JLXPEDQWDQXOWDPHO\DSUpGLNiWRULSiO\DHOVĘOpSFVĘIRNiQDNV]iPtWRWWGH NRUDLKDOiODPLDWWSDSNpQWQHPV]ROJiOW3iOYLV]RQWHOYpJH]WHDNROOpJLXPRW pVNOI|OGLHJ\HWHPHNHQLVWDQXOWPDMGD]RNUyOYLVV]DWpUYHOHONLSiV]WRUOHWW 6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQD]RQNtYOKRJ\MHOHQWĘVHWDONRWRWWDPDJ\DULURGDORP pVDUHIRUPiWXVPĦYHOĘGpVWHUOHWpQNRPRO\HJ\Ki]LNDUULHUWLVEHIXWRWW DPHO\HWQHPOHKHW¿J\HOPHQNtYOKDJ\QLpOHWSiO\iMDpUWpNHOpVHVRUiQ$
KyGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\LUHIRUPiWXVHJ\Ki]OHONLSiV]WRUDNpQWyULiVLV]HUHSHYROW DEEDQKRJ\DFVHQGHVHOOHQUHIRUPiFLyLGHMpQPHJYpGWHHJ\Ki]N|]VpJpWD NDWROLNXVWiPDGiVRNWyOYDODPLQWPHJDNDGiO\R]WDKRJ\D]DOI|OGLSDUDV]W PR]JDOPDNEDQYDOyUpV]YpWHOPLDWW+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\ODNRVViJiWPHJEQ WHVVpN/HONpV]LWHHQGĘLQW~OD%pNpVL5HIRUPiWXV(J\Ki]PHJ\HHVSHUHVHLV YROWDPHO\D]WMHOHQWHWWHKRJ\D0DJ\DU.LUiO\ViJGpONHOHWLWHUOHWpQpOĘ UHIRUPiWXVRNPLQGHQQDSLpOHWpWLVLUiQ\tWRWWD7HYpNHQ\VpJHV]pOHVWiUVD
6=(5(0/(<6DPX6]ĘQ\L%pQLiPLQpVDKyGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\LHN±%XGD SHVW+RUQ\iQV]N\6=$%$',,VWYiQ,QWp]PpQ\W|UWpQHWLIRUUiVRND'HEUHFHQL 5HIRUPiWXV.ROOpJLXPOHYpOWiUiEDQ,N|W'HEUHFHQ7LV]iQW~OL5HIRUPiWXV(J\Ki]NHU
OHW.LDGYiQ\RND'HEUHFHQL5HIRUPiWXV.ROOpJLXPIHQQiOOiViQDNpYIRUGXOyMD WLV]WHOHWpUH
'È1<,-y]VHI6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQDOHONLSiV]WRU 6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQpVNRUD±
V]HUN,05(0LKiO\+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\%HWKOHQ*iERU5HIRUPiWXV*LPQi]LXP
±,05(0LKiO\$YiURVPĦYHOĘGpVW|UWpQHWHD;9,,,V]i]DGLJ +yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\
|
GDOPLHOLVPHUWVpJQHN|UYHQGHWWPpJLV¿D3iODODSRVDQPHJWpSi]WDH]WD PHJEHFVOpVW$N|YHWNH]ĘNEHQD]WV]HUHWQpQNUHNRQVWUXiOQLPLO\HQpOHW SiO\iWMiUWEH6]ĘQ\L3iO7pQ\OHJWHOMHVHQW|QNUHWHWWHDSMDpOHWPĦYpW"
.LLQGXOiVNpQW¿J\HOHPEHNHOOYHQQQNNpWV]HUYH]HWV]RFLROyJLDLWpQ\H ]ĘW$]HOVĘH]HNN|]ODNRUD~MNRULSDSPDUDV]WiVV]RNiVDDPHO\QHND]YROW DOpQ\HJHKRJ\DUHIRUPiWXVHJ\Ki]EDQD]HJ\Ki]N|]VpJHNPLQGHQpYEHQ HOG|QWKHWWpNKRJ\DN|YHWNH]ĘHV]WHQGĘUHLVPHJYiODV]WMiNHOHONpV]NQHN D]HJ\pYLJN|]WNV]ROJiOWSUpGLNiWRUWYDJ\VHP(]HNDPDUDV]WiVRNQHP FVDNDUUDNpQ\V]HUtWHWWpNDOHONpV]HNHWKRJ\D]DGRWWN|]|VVpJYDOOiVLLJp Q\HLQHNPHJIHOHOMHQHNKDQHPEL]RQ\RVHVHWHNEHQYHV]pO\WLVMHOHQWKHWWHN DSUpGLNiWRUV]iPiUDPHUWDPDUDV]WiVQpKDRO\DQW|PHJJ\ĦOpVVpDODNXOW iWDKRODOHONpV]HOOHQDNiUOLQFVKDQJXODWLVNLDODNXOKDWRWW$V]i]DGEDQ QDJ\RQVRNV]RUHOĘIRUGXOWD]KRJ\DOHONLSiV]WRUWHOOG|]WpNpVpYHNLJiOOiV QpONOPDUDGW
$PiVLNV]HUYH]HWV]RFLROyJLDLWpQ\H]ĘDOHONpV]LNDURQEHOOD]~J\QHYH ]HWWiURQLFVDOiGRNYLVHONHGpVH$]iURQLFVDOiGRNW|EEJHQHUiFLyUDYLVV]D YH]HWKHWĘHQOHONLSiV]WRUĘV|NWĘOV]iUPD]WDNLGHQWLWiVXNPHJKDWiUR]iViEDQ H] NLPRQGRWWDQ IRQWRV V]HUHSHW MiWV]RWW W|EE HVHWEHQ LV D FVDOiGKR] YDOy WDUWR]iVDODSYHWĘPHJKDWiUR]yMDDOHONpV]LV]ROJiODWUDYDOyEV]NHVpJYROW
$%pNpVL5HIRUPiWXV(J\Ki]PHJ\HHVHWpEHQH]HND]iURQLFVDOiGRNPHJ KDWiUR]yV]HUHSHWMiWV]RWWDN$FVDOiGIĘNPpJDV]i]DGEDQLVLJ\HNH]WHN
~J\HJ\HQJHWQL¿DLNVRUViWKRJ\D]RNN|]OOHJDOiEEHJ\OHONLSiV]WRUQDN WDQXOMRQPHUWDOHONpV]GLQDV]WLiNJ\DNUDQ|U|N|OWpNHJ\PiVN|]|WWDSDUy NLiNDWVĘWHVSHUHVWpVSVS|N|WLVN|]ONYiODV]WRWWDN
W|UWpQHWHIĘV]HUN6=$%Ï)HUHQF,$OHJUpJLEELGĘNWĘODSROJiULIRUUDGDORPLJ+yGPH ]ĘYiViUKHO\+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\WDQiFVD±6=(5(0/(,6iPXHO$KyGPH- ]ĘYiViUKHO\LUHIRUPiWXVHJ\Ki]W|UWpQHWHN|W+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\±.,6
%iOLQW$%pNpVL%iQiWL5HIRUPiWXV(J\Ki]PHJ\HW|UWpQHWH%pNpVFVDED±6]HJHG&VRQJ UiG0HJ\HL/HYpOWiU'pODOI|OGLpYV]i]DGRN
6=e.(/<*iERU0HJKtYiVRNpVPDUDV]WiVRN±/HONpV]HNpVDJ\OHNH]HWYLV]RQ\DD V]i]DGL.HFVNHPpWHQ 6]iYD\/iV]OyV]HUNÄ9LGLPXVHQLPVWHOODPHLXV«” .RQ- IHUHQFLDN|WHW %XGDSHVW /¶+DUPDWWDQ .iUROL N|Q\YHN ± 6=,*(7, -HQĘ 7L]HQQ\ROFDGLNV]i]DGLOHONpV]VRUVRN(J\Ki]W|UWpQHWL6]HPOH±
6=È6=/DMRV(J\W|EEpYV]i]DGRVUHIRUPiWXVÄiURQLKi]´D'iYLGKi]\FVDOiGW|UWp- QHWH(J\Ki]W|UWpQHWL6]HPOH±
6=È6=/DMRV/HONpV]LKLYDWiVpVWiUVDGDOPLPRELOLWiVD7LV]iQW~OL5HIRUPiWXV(J\- Ki]NHUOHWEHQDV]i]DGHOVĘIHOpEHQ ³9LGLPXVHQLPVWHOODPHLXV«´.RQIHUHQFLDN|WHW V]HUN6=È9$</iV]Oy%XGDSHVW/¶+DUPDWWDQ±
+HJ\LÈGiP6]ĘQ\L3iO±6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQLPSRV]WRU¿D
$ 6]ĘQ\LFVDOiG HVHWpEHQ PLQGNpW WpQ\H]Ę IRQWRV V]HUHSHW MiWV]RWW 6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQW|EEpYWL]HGLJPHQWHVOWDSDSPDUDV]WiVPHJDOi]ySURFH G~UiMDDOyOPpJLVpOHWHYpJpQH]D]ĘpOHWpWLVEHiUQ\pNROWDWĘONH]GYH 1\pNL,VWYiQpV)OHV0LKiO\MHJ\]ĘNYH]HWpVpYHOLJ\HNH]WHNHOWiYROtWDQL DKLYDWDOiEyO(]HOOHQKLiEDNHUHVHWWVHJtWVpJHWD.iURO\LDNQiOD]~ULV]pN QpOD]HJ\Ki]NHUOHWQpOpVD]HJ\Ki]PHJ\pQpOPpJLVOHNHOOHWWPRQGDQLD SDSLiOOiViUyO0LQGH]NO|Q|VHQIiMyOHKHWHWWV]iPiUDKLV]HQĘLViURQL FVDOiGEyOV]iUPD]RWWDSMD6]ĘQ\L.RYiFV*HUJHO\9iORQ$OVyQpPHGLEHQ pV0RQRURQV]ROJiOWSUpGLNiWRUNpQWpVDPLQWIHQWHEEOiWWXN¿iEyO3iOEyOLV OHONpV]WIDUDJRWW
6]HUHPOHL6iPXHOHOpJUpV]OHWHVHQPXWDWWDEHKRJ\DQVLNORWWIpOUH3iO pOHWH $ N|YHWNH]ĘNEHQ U|YLGHQ |VV]HIRJODOMXN PLO\HQ YROW 3iO pOHW~WMD PDMGDNpWV]HUYH]HWV]RFLROyJLDLNpUGpVPHQWpQDUUDNHUHVVNDYiODV]WKR J\DQYDOyVtWRWWDPHJ6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQiURQLGLQDV]WLNXVWHUYHLW¿D3iO LOOHWYHDSDSPDUDV]WiVLQWp]PpQ\pQNHUHV]WOPHJQp]]NPHQQ\LUHYROWDN DKtYĘNHOpJHGHWWHND¿DWDO6]ĘQ\LV]ROJiODWiYDO
6]ĘQ\L3iOEHQV]OHWHWW+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\HQ6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQpV .RPiURPL=Vy¿DKDUPDGLNJ\HUPHNHNpQW6DMQRVNpWLGĘVHEEWHVWYpUHPpJ V]OHWpVHHOĘWWPHJKDOW$¿DWDO3iOYLV]RQWV]pSHQFVHSHUHGHWWpVWL]HQKpW pYHVNRUiEDQEHLUDWNR]RWWDGHEUHFHQLNROOpJLXPED1HPVRNDWWXGXQNDUUyO KRJ\DQWHOMHVtWHWW'HEUHFHQEHQGHDSMDNpVĘEELYLVV]DHPOpNH]pVHDODSMiQ
~J\WĦQLNQHPQDJ\OHONHVHGpVVHOYHWHWWHEHOHPDJiWDWDQXOiVEDKHO\HWWH LQNiEEKD]DV]|N|WWD]DQ\MiKR]9iViUKHO\UHpVQDJ\tYEHQNHUOWHDWHR OyJLDLWXGRPiQ\RNPHJLVPHUpVpW0pJLVVLNHUOWRO\DQHUHGPpQ\HVHQHO YpJH]QLHDNROOpJLXPLRV]WiO\RNDWKRJ\NOI|OGLWDQXOPiQ\RNIRO\WDWiViUD LVPpOWyQDNWDOiOWiN$+HO\WDUWyWDQiFVVHPPLO\HQDNDGiO\WQHPJ|UGtWHWW NLXWD]iVDHOpKLV]HQPHJIHOHOĘDQ\DJLIRUUiVWWXGRWWIHOPXWDWQLDPHO\HWHOH JHQGĘQHNWDOiOWDNDKKR]KRJ\HQJHGpO\H]]pNEi]HOLWDQXOPiQ\DLW1LQFVHQ
,05(0LKiO\.]GHOHPD¿]LNRWHRORJL]PXV|U|NVpJpYHO±6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQHOIHOHGHWW
|UHJNRULPĦYH,VWHQQHN7URPELWiMD«± ,0$]LVWHQLpVHPEHULV]ySiUEHV]p- GH6iURVSDWDN+HUQiG1HP]HWHJ\Ki]PĦYHOĘGpV±±±
,05(0LKiO\$YiURVPĦYHOĘGpVW|UWpQHWHD;9,,,V]i]DGLJ +yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\
W|UWpQHWHIĘV]HUN6=$%Ï)HUHQF,$OHJUpJLEELGĘNWĘODSROJiULIRUUDGDORPLJ+yGPH ]ĘYiViUKHO\+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\WDQiFVD
6=(5(0/(<6DPX6]ĘQ\L%pQLiPLQpVDKyGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\LHN±%XGD SHVW+RUQ\iQV]N\
6=(5(0/(<,P±
01/2/&+HO\WDUWyWDQiFVL/HYpOWiU$FWDVWXGLRVRUXPDFDWKROLFRUXP±
|
RO\DQIRUUiVXQNDPHO\D]WLJD]ROQiKRJ\3iOQHPYROWPpOWyDVYiMFLWD QXOPiQ\RNUDPpJLVIHOWpWHOH]KHWMNDKiWWpUEHQDSMDN|]UHPĦN|GpVpWPHUW
%HQMiPLQEDQHJ\OHYHOHWtUWDEi]HOLHJ\HWHPSURIHVV]RUiQDN-DNRE
&KULVWRSK%HFNQHN(EEHQ6]ĘQ\LD]pUWPHQWHJHWĘ]LNPHUWWXGMDKRJ\D
¿D~J\PHQWHO%i]HOEĘOKRJ\PpJFVDNN|V]|QHWHWVHPPRQGRWWD]ĘWRWW WiPRJDWy%HFNQHN$OHYpOV]|YHJpQHNLVPHUHWpEHQIHOWpWHOH]KHWMNKRJ\
3iOQHPYHWWHW~OViJRVDQNRPRO\DQDNOI|OGLWDQXOPiQ\RNDWpVDNLXWD]iVD HOĘWWVHPWDQXOWW~OMyO0LQGH]WHUĘVtWLD]LVKRJ\Ei]HOLWDUWy]NRGiViQDN FVXSiQ SpQ]J\L Q\RPDL PDUDGWDN V]HOOHPL VHPPLO\HQ gQPDJiEDQ D]
PpJQHPiUXONRGyMHOKRJ\QHPMHOHQWPHJ%i]HOEHQQ\RPWDWRWWGLVSX WiMD KLV]HQ W|EE PiV KRQ¿WiUVD V]LQWpQ QHP WXGRWW NOI|OG|Q Q\RPWDWRWW PXQNiNDWN|]UHDGQL$WDQXOPiQ\RNQDNYLV]RQWQHPFVDNDQ\RPWDWiVEDQ PHJMHOHQĘ GLVSXWiFLy D MHOH PHUW D] HJ\HWHPHNHQ NO|QE|]Ę WDQXOPiQ\L Q\LOYiQWDUWiVRNDWLVYH]HWWHNDPHO\HNEĘOPHJiOODStWKDWyHJ\HJ\GLiNHOĘ UHKDODGiVD$]YLV]RQWJ\DQ~VKRJ\DEi]HOLHJ\HWHPWDQXOPiQ\LQ\LOYiQ WDUWiVDHJ\V]HUVHPHPOtWLPHJDQHYpWPLN|]EHQDPDJ\DUGLiNRNQDNMiUy
|V]W|QGtMDWUHQGV]HUHVHQIHOYHWWHpVN|]|WW|WV]|UMHOHQWNH]HWWD]
HJ\HWHPLV]HUYHNQpO|V]W|QGtMiQDNJ\pEHQ
+D]iMiEDYLVV]DWpUYHpGHVDSMDiOWDOYH]HWHWWHJ\Ki]PHJ\HHJ\LNMHOHQWĘV J\OHNH]HWpEHQ6]HQWHVHQOHWWPiVRGOHONpV]$V]DNLURGDORPH]]HONDSFVR ODWEDQFVDNHJ\HWOHQHJ\GROJRWWDUWRWWIRQWRVQDNPHJHPOtWHQLPpJSHGLJD]W KRJ\3iOUpV]HJHVYROWpVH]pUWDV]HQWHVLHNOHWHWWpNĘWDKLYDWDOiEyO6]ĘQ\L
%HQMiPLQYLV]RQWHNNRULVVHJtWHWW¿iQPHUWPDJDPHOOpYHWWHVHJpGOHONpV]
QHN(EEĘOYLV]RQWRO\DQERWUiQ\NHUHNHGHWWKRJ\%HQMiPLQLVEHOHEXNRWW DYiViUKHO\LHNDQQ\LUDIHOKiERURGWDN3iODONDOPD]iViQGHOHJLQNiEEERWUi Q\RVYLVHONHGpVpQKRJ\GK|VYHV]HNHGpVHNEHWRUNROORWW6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQ PDUDV]WiViQDND]J\H$]J\NLPHQHWHD]OHWWKRJ\EHQPLQGD]
DSDPLQGD¿DHOYHV]tWHWWHiOOiViW%HQMiPLQHQQHNHOOHQpUHPHJPDUDGWD]
HJ\Ki]PHJ\HYH]HWĘMpQHNGH3iOWHOWLOWRWWiNDSDSLV]ROJiODWWyO(KKH]D]
%RNWyEHU).QRYHPEHU
,05( 0LKiO\6]ĘQ\L %HQMiPLQ OHYHOH -DFRE &KULVWRSK %HFN Ei]HOL SURIHVV]RUKR]
EyO,URGDORPWXGRPiQ\L.|]OHPpQ\HN±
+(*<,ÈGiP±6=g*,/iV]Oy0DJ\DURUV]iJLGLiNRNVYiMFLHJ\HWHPHNHQpVIĘLV- NROiNRQ±%XGDSHVW1U+(*<,ÈGiP$%i]HOL(J\HWHPPDJ\DU YRQDWNR]iV~Np]LUDWDL±%XGDSHVWQU 6W$%8QLYHUVLWlWVDUFKLY27KHRORJLVFKH)DNXOWlW'LVSXWDWLRQHVWKHRORJLFDH9HU- ]HLFKQLVGHU'LVSXWDWLRQHQGDULQ/XFDV*HUQOHUXD6\OODEXVFRQWURYHUVLDUXPUHOLJLRQ- LVB±-K
+HJ\LÈGiP6]ĘQ\L3iO±6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQLPSRV]WRU¿D
HVHWKH]D]pUWKR]]iNHOOWHQQQND]WLVKRJ\%HQMiPLQHOPR]GtWiViWQHP FVDN3iOERWUiQ\RVYLVHONHGpVpQHNN|V]|QKHWWHPHUWDPHJ|UHJHGHWW%HQMi PLQPiUQHPWXGWDPHJIHOHOĘHQHOOiWQLKLYDWDOiWH]pUWĘWPLQGHQNpSSHQHO DNDUWiNWiYROtWDQLDSDSLKLYDWDOiEyO
$UHQGHONH]pVQNUHiOOyIRUUiVRNYLV]RQWHQQpOiUQ\DOWDEENpSHWPXWDWQDN EHDPHO\HNEĘOHJ\RO\DQKHO\]HWUHNRQVWUXiOKDWyDPHO\EHQDSDSPDUDV]WiV pVD]iURQLFVDOiGRNMHOOHP]ĘLIRQWRVV]HUHSHWMiWV]RWWDN$SDSPDUDV]WiV HEEHQD]HVHWEHQQHPD]pYHQWHPHJ~MtWDQGyOHONpV]LDONDOPD]iVPHJKRV]
V]DEEtWiViYDONDSFVRODWRVKDQHPD]]DOPHQQ\LUHWXGRWWHJ\SUpGLNiWRUD N|]|VVpJYDOOiVLpVHUN|OFVLLJpQ\HLQHNPHJIHOHOQL
6]HUHQFVpQNUHDKHO\]HWUĘOVRNHJ\NRU~IRUUiVWXGyVtWPHUWW|EEOHYpO HJ\Ki]PHJ\HLpVHJ\Ki]NHUOHWLKDWiUR]DWDQ\DN|Q\YLpVMHJ\]ĘN|Q\YLEH MHJ\]pVWDQ~NLKDOOJDWiVLMHJ\]ĘN|Q\YpVYiGLUDWLVDUHQGHONH]pVQNUHiOO 0LQGHKKH]WiUVXOPpJHJ\RO\DQW|UWpQHWLPXQNDDPHO\D]HVHPpQ\HNXWiQ PLQWHJ\WL]HQ|WpYYHONpV]OWpVKDOORPiVEyOV]yEHOLYLVV]DHPOpNH]pVHN EĘOUHNRQVWUXiOWDD]HVHPpQ\HNHW(]XWyEELWDW|UWpQHWLNXWDWiV$V]HQWHVL UHIRUPiWDHNNOpVLiQDNPDWULNXOiMDQpYHQLVPHUL(]DPXQNDQHYpYHOHOOHQ WpWEHQQHPDQ\DN|Q\YKDQHPHJ\DQQDOHVMHOOHJĦW|UWpQHWLPXQNDDPHO\HW EHQNH]GWHNHOYH]HWQLpVHJpV]HQLJU|J]tWHWWpNEHQQHDV]HQWHVL UHIRUPiWXVHJ\Ki]W|UWpQHWpW.RUiEEDQ%DJL=ROWiQPiUIHOWpWHOH]WHKRJ\
HEEHQD]HJ\Ki]pVN|]|WWLNUyQLNiMiWYDOyV]tQĦOHJHPOpNH]HWEĘO pVKDOORPiVEyO.LV%iOLQWtUWDPHJDPHO\HWpQFVDNPHJHUĘVtWHQLWXGRN PHUWD]pYHVHPpQ\HLQpOPDJDD]HOEHV]pOĘMHJ\]LPHJKRJ\ÄPLNRU H]HNHWtURPWLEDQ´WiYR]RWW6]HQWHVUĘO(UGpO\L6iPXHOSUpGLNiWRU
6=(5(0/(<,P±6,0$/iV]Oy6]HQWHVYiURVW|UWp- QHWH6]HQWHV6]HQWHVYiURVN|]|QVpJH±
.,6%iOLQW$V]HQWHVLUHIRUPiWDHNNOpVLDiOODSRWMDQHYH]HWHVHEEWDJMDLQDNpOHWHHP- OpNH]HWHWpUGHPOĘGROJDLNYiOWR]iVDLN .%$%pNpVL%iQiWL5HIRUPiWXV(J\Ki]PHJ\H W|UWpQHWH %pNpVFVDED ± 6]HJHG &VRQJUiG 0HJ\HL /HYpOWiU 'pODOI|OGL pYV]i]D GRN±),/(3$QWDO6]RNiVOHtUiVRNDpVDV]i]DGEyO1pSL.XOW~UD±
1pSL7iUVDGDORP9±9,±7$.È&6(GLW.LVV%iOLQWDV]HQWHVLUHIRUPiWXV HNOp]VLDW|UWpQHWtUyMD .LVV%iOLQWUHIRUPiWXVOHONLSiV]WRUpOHWHpVPXQNiVViJD±
. $.LVV%iOLQW7XGRPiQ\RV(POpNQDSHOĘDGiVDL6]HQWHVPiUFLXVV]HUN /$%È',/DMRV6]HQWHV.LVV%iOLQW5HIRUPiWXVÈOWDOiQRV,VNROD±
%$*,=ROWiQ6]HQWHVYiURVUHIRUPiWXVN|]|VVpJHDV]i]DGEDQD%pOiGL,VWYiQ
*iO,VWYiQpVD.LV%iOLQWiOWDOtUWHNOp]VLDW|UWpQHWDODSMiQ 0H]ĘYiURVUHIRUPiFLypVLUR- GDORPV]HUN6=$%Ï$QGUiV%S8QLYHUVLWDV+LVWRULD/LWWHUDULD±A V]HQWHVLUHIRUPiWXVHNNOp]VLDW|UWpQHWH±N|]UHDG7$.È&6(GLW6]HQWHV1.$
>HOHNWURQLNXVGRNXPHQWXP@KWWSZZZV]HQWHVLQIRKXFGHNNOH]VLDLPDJHQDJ\-3*
|
$]LUDWRNWDQ~ViJDV]HULQW6]ĘQ\L3iO6YiMFEyOYDOyKD]DWpUpVHXWiQpGHV DSMiYDO HJ\WW V]HPpO\HVHQ MHOHQW PHJ EDQ 6]HQWHVHQ D ¿DWDORQ HO KXQ\W7|QNĘ6]LOiJ\L3iOOHONLSiV]WRUWHPHWpVpQ9DOOMXNEHĘV]LQWpQQHP OHKHWHWWYpOHWOHQKRJ\D]pSSHQPHJUHVHGĘOHONpV]LiOOiVYRQ]RWWDD]HVSH UHV¿iWDE~FV~]WDWiVUD0LQGHQHVHWUHHUHGPpQ\HVYROWV]HQWHVLOiWRJDWiVD PHUWD]HJ\Ki]PHJ\HSURWRNROOXPDV]HULQWPpJHEEHQD]pYEHQEHLNWDWWiN 6]HQWHVPiVRGOHONpV]pYp(]WN|YHWĘHQKRVV]~pYHNLJVHPPLWQHPWXGXQN UyODHJ\HGOHJ\W|UHGpNHVHQIHQQPDUDGWOHYpOEĘON|YHWNH]WHWKHWQNDUUD KRJ\%i]HOKH]KDVRQOyDQLWWLVHUĘVHQIRJODONR]WDWWiND]DQ\DJLNpUGpVHN
$OHYpOtUyMDD.iURO\LDNWyOHJ\VHVVLyI|OGHWV]HUHWHWWYROQDNpUQLPLYHOĘ PLQWPiVRGOHONpV]PiU|WpYHV]ROJiOWGHHGGLJQHPNDSRWWWHUPĘI|OGHW$
NpUYpQ\EHQDIiELiQLI|OGHNIHORV]WiViEyOV]HUHWHWWYROQDDNpUHOPH]ĘWHONHW V]HUH]QLPDJiQDN(]HND]DGDWRNDUUDXWDOQDNKRJ\DOHYpOtUyMD6]ĘQ\L 3iOYROWPHUWĘPiVRGOHONpV]NpQWV]ROJiOW6]HQWHVHQpV)iELiQVHEHVW\pQ 6]HQWHVKDWiUiEDQWDOiOKDWy
$]HOOHQHOHIRO\WDWRWWHJ\Ki]IHJ\HOPLNLYL]VJiOiVVRUiQEDQDWDQ~N HJ\WĘOHJ\LJD]WiOOtWRWWiNKRJ\NH]GHWEHQVHPPLSDQDV]QHPYROW6]ĘQ\L 3iOV]ROJiODWiUDKDQHPFVDND]XWROVyQpKiQ\pYEHQNH]GHWWHOERWUiQ\R VDQYLVHONHGQL9DOyV]tQĦOHJH]|VV]HIJJpVEHQiOOKDWDONRKROL]PXViYDOLV HJ\EHQNHOWRUYRVLYL]VJiODWV]HULQWiOODSRWDQHPYLVV]DIRUGtWKDWDWODQ OHONpV]LWHHQGĘLWHOWXGMDOiWQL(]HNV]HULQWNH]GHWEHQPLQGHQMyOLQGXOW pGHVDSMDHOLQGtWRWWDD]iURQLFVDOiGRN¿DLUDMHOOHP]Ę~WMiQpVĘHJ\QDJ\pV JD]GDJJ\OHNH]HWEHQPLQGHQNLPHJHOpJHGpVpUHYpJH]WHDGROJiW
EHQ PpJLV UREEDQW D ERPED pV PLQGHQ PHJYiOWR]RWW$ EDM HOVĘ Q\RPiUDGHFHPEHUpQEXNNDQXQNDPLNRU6]ĘQ\L3iOHJ\SXKDWR Oy]yOHYHOHWNOG|WW+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\UH1\pNL-y]VHIQHN(EEHQD]LUiQW
7$.È&6,PKWWSZZZV]HQWHVLQIRKXFGHNNOH]VLDLPDJHQDJ\-3*
7W5(/ , D%pNpVL 5HIRUPiWXV (J\Ki]PHJ\H LUDWDL .|]J\ĦOpV MHJ\]ĘN|Q\Y
±
01/2/6]ĘQ\L3iO>"@OHYHOH.iURO\L$QWDOKR]>"@>"@.iURO\LFVDOiGQHP]HW VpJLOHYpOWiUD30LVVLOHVQU
7W5(/,L$;&,,,%pNpVL5HIRUPiWXV(J\Ki]PHJ\HLUDWDL(J\Ki]N|]Vp- JHNUHYRQDWNR]yLUDWRN+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\±6]ĘQ\L3iOHJ\Ki]IHJ\HOPLJ\p- QHNWDQ~NLKDOOJDWiVDL
7W5(/,L$/;;,9%pNpVL5HIRUPiWXV(J\Ki]PHJ\HLUDWDL(J\Ki]N|]- VpJHNUHYRQDWNR]yLUDWRN6]HQWHV±0DWW\DVRYV]N\)HUHQFLJD]ROiVD6]ĘQ\L3iO HJpV]VpJLiOODSRWiUyOMDQXiU
+HJ\LÈGiP6]ĘQ\L3iO±6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQLPSRV]WRU¿D
pUGHNOĘG|WWOHKHWVpJHVYROQDHKRJ\DSMDPHOOHWWNDSMRQNiSOiQLiOOiVW 9DOyV]tQĦOHJ QHP YpOHWOHQO NOGWH 1\pNL -y]VHIQHN D OHYHOHW DNLQHN D]
DSMDD]D1\pNL,VWYiQYROWDNL%HQMiPLQHOPR]GtWiViQJ\N|G|WWPLYHO tJ\SUyEiOWDPHJD1\pNLFVDOiGRWPHJJ\Ę]QLDUUyOKRJ\WiPRJDVViNĘW ,O\HQMyOLQGXOyNDUULHUHVHWpQH]LJHQIXUFVDKLV]HQ3iO|QiOOyOHONpV]NpQW V]ROJiOWPtJNiSOiQQDN±PDLpUWHOHPEHQVHJpGOHONpV]QHN±D]RNPHQWHN DNLNPpJQHPWXGWDNNRPRO\DEEiOOiVWV]HUH]QL
(J\HWpUWHN6]HUHPOHL6iPXHOOHODEEDQKRJ\3iOUpV]HJHVPHJEt]KDWDW ODQ¿~YROWGH6]HQWHVUĘOYDOyHOPR]GtWiViWQHPFVDNHQQHNN|V]|QKHWWH XJ\DQLVD]J\P|J|WWHJ\RO\DQV]HUHOPLV]iOLVIHOWĦQLNDPHO\6]HQWHV HJ\LNOHJEHIRO\iVRVDEEHPEHUpQHNDEHFVOHWpEHJi]ROW
'RERV\*HUJHO\UĘOYDQV]yDNL&VRQJUiGYiUPHJ\HV]iPYHYĘMHpVWD QiFVEtUyMDYROWpVHJ\EHQDV]HQWHVLUHIRUPiWXVHJ\Ki]SURPLQHQVDODNMD DNLW|EEpYLJKLYDWDORVDQĘUL]WHD]HJ\Ki]LNUyQLNiWLV'RERV\IHOHVpJH 6]DODL/tGLDYROWDNLUĘODV]HQWHVLHJ\Ki]W|UWpQHWLNUyQLNDLtJ\HPOpNH]LN PHJÄDNNRUH]HQDUpV]HQDOHJV]HEE$VV]RQ\QDNWDUWRWWiN”.0LYHO6]ĘQ\L PiVNRULVEHOHNHYHUHGHWWJ\DQ~VQĘJ\HNEHKLV]HQDNDWROLNXVNiQWRUIH OHVpJpWpVOiQ\iWLVPHJN|UQ\pNH]WHQHPPHJOHSĘKRJ\DIHOWĦQĘHQV]pS /tGLDLVIHONHOWHWWHD¿J\HOPpW
(]DYRQ]DORPQHPLJD]iQYROWHJ\V]pSV]HUHOHPVRNNDOLQNiEE6]ĘQ\L 3iOJRURPEDWHUPpV]HWpWOiWKDWMXNEHQQHPLQGD]RQW~OKRJ\YDOyV]tQĦOHJ QHPLVWDOiOWYLV]RQ]iVUD$JRURPEDViJUHQGNtYOYLVV]DWHWV]ĘpVIHOKiERUt WyYROWPHUWDKDOGRNOy/tGLiW3iOtJ\YLJDV]WDOWD
„'RPLQH&RPSDWHUQRQLELGHEHWSDOSDUHSHGHVVHGFLUFDSXGFXGDIHPRUD ,VPpW'HKDWVDNtJ\YyOQDD]pQIHOHVpJHPPHJU~JQiPDWDOSiWpVPpJ JXO\iVRVK~VWIĘ]HWQpNYpOH”
+Ï5(/,E3UHVELWHULMHJ\]ĘN|Q\Y±S±
6=(5(0/(<,P %$*,,P
7DNiFV,PKWWSZZZV]HQWHVLQIRKXFGHNNOH]VLDLPDJHQDJ\-3*
7W5(/,L$;&,,,6]ĘQ\L3iOHJ\Ki]IHJ\HOPLJ\pQHNWDQ~NLKDOOJDWiVDL
7W5(/,L$/;;,96]ĘQ\L3iOHOOHQLYiGDN|VV]HIRJODOiVD
|
6]ĘQ\LWHUPpV]HWpWĘOYLV]RQWH]QHPiOOWPHVV]HPHUWMyEDUiWMiWDQDJ\
EHWHJ%DUWyN$QGUiVWLWWDVDQOiWRJDWWDPHJpVD]]DOYLJDV]WDOWDKRJ\LJ\D QDNPpJHJ\NLVERUW
„7LV]W6]ĘQ\L3iO8UDPPLQWEDUiWW\iWPHJOiWRJDWWDKLYDWODQpVIpOLWWD- VDQpVRWWDQPLQWEDUiWEDUiWW\iYDOWUpIiONRGRWWLOO\HQIRUPiQ.HOO\IHOPLW IHNV]HOLWWKLV]HQQHPYDJ\EHWHJWVDNLKDWQiOWHKR]DVVERUW9DQQHNHP KDQHNHGQLQWVKR]]V]ROJiOOĘWĦOHPpVDNH]pWV]RURQJDWWDHUĘVVHQGHQHP KDUDJEyOKDQHPEDUiWViJRVDQ”
ÒJ\JRQGRORPLWWSRQWRVDQOiWV]LND]DONRKROWyOEHIRO\iVROWHPEHUOHO NLiOODSRWDDPHO\6]DODL/tGLDHVHWpEHQQHPPHUOWNLDKDOGRNOyIpOUHVLNH UOWOiWRJDWiViEDQXJ\DQLVD]DVV]RQ\HOWHPHWpVHXWiQ6]ĘQ\LHJ\YDViUQDSL LVWHQWLV]WHOHWNHUHWpEHQSUpGLNiFLyWLVWDUWRWWD]HOKXQ\WIHOHWW$SUpGLNiFLy DODSLJpMH0iUNYHUVHYROWGHPDJiWD]LJHKLUGHWpVW3iONpSWHOHQYROW PHJWDUWDQL$V]yV]pNUHIHOPHQWpVIHOROYDVWDD]LJpWGHXWiQDFVDNDQQ\LW WXGRWWPRQGDQLKRJ\Ä%H]]HJ6]DODL/tGLDYROWD]DNLPHJDGWD,VWHQQHN DPLD],VWHQp(]HNXWiQFVDNV]QWHOHQH]HNHWPRQGRWWD6]DODL/tGLD/tGLD /tGLD´
/iWKDWMXNKRJ\6]ĘQ\LQDJ\Q\LOYiQRVViJHOĘWWRPORWW|VV]HDPHO\PLQ GHQEL]RQQ\DOOHONLLVPHUHWIXUGDOiVEyOV]iUPD]KDWRWWGHDEDUiWDLYDOYDOy JRURPEDYLVHONHGpVKDVRQOyViJDDODSMiQPpJDV]HUHOPLV]iODWVHP]iUKDW MXNNL(]DIpOUHVLNHUOWSUpGLNiFLyYLV]RQWYpJ]HWHVVpYiOWV]iPiUD MDQXiUpQD]HJ\Ki]NHUOHWPHJWiUJ\DOWDIHJ\HOPLJ\pWpVMDQXiUiQ 3iOKLYDWDORVDQLVOHPRQGRWWV]HQWHVLiOOiViUyO9pJOiSULOLViQ IRJDGWDHOD]HJ\Ki]NHUOHWDOHPRQGiVWYDJ\LVW|EEPLQWHJ\pYLJK~]yGRWW PpJD]J\9DMRQPLpUW"1HP6]ĘQ\LPLDWWKDQHPD]pUWPHUWDV]HQWHVL HNUHQGNtYOJ\RUVDQYiODV]WRWWiNPHJD]~MOHONpV]NHW6]DODL3iOWDPHO\
D]HJ\Ki]LW|UYpQ\HNNHOHOOHQNH]HWW(]DJ\RUVDViJYLV]RQWNLFVLWJ\DQ~VVi WHV]LD]J\HWpVH]DODSMiQJRQGRORPKRJ\6]ĘQ\LEXNiViWQHPFVDNDONR
7W5(/,L$;&,,,6]ĘQ\L3iOHJ\Ki]IHJ\HOPLJ\pQHNWDQ~NLKDOOJDWiVDL PiMXV
7W5(/,L$;&,,,6]ĘQ\L3iOHJ\Ki]IHJ\HOPLJ\pQHNWDQ~NLKDOOJDWiVDL PiMXV
7W5(/,L$/;;,9(J\Ki]NHUOHWLMHJ\]ĘN|Q\YLNLYRQDW6]ĘQ\L3iOJ\p- UĘOMDQXiU±$/;;,96]ĘQ\L3iOOHPRQGiVD6]HQWHVMDQXiU 7W5(/,L$/;;,9(J\Ki]NHUOHWLMHJ\]ĘN|Q\YNLYRQDWDiSULOLV
+HJ\LÈGiP6]ĘQ\L3iO±6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQLPSRV]WRU¿D
KROL]PXVDRNR]WDKDQHPD]KRJ\UiOpSHWWHJ\PDJDVUDQJ~HPEHUW\~NV]H PpUHLV0LpUWPHUHPH]WiOOtWDQL"
$]HJ\Ki]LEtUyViJSHUDQ\DJDV]HULQWLJHQVRNWDQ~FVDND/tGLiYDONDS FVRODWRVERWUiQ\RVSUpGLNiFLyMiWNLIRJiVROWD/HONpV]N|VV]HVW|EELV]RO JiODWiYDOPHJYROWDNHOpJHGYHYDJ\LVDN|]|VVpJYDOOiVHUN|OFVpWpVYDOOiVL LJpQ\HLW QHP ]DYDUWD 6]ĘQ\L NLFVDSRQJiVD 0iVRNDW YLV]RQW IHOKiERUtWRWW NLFVDSRQJypOHWHPXODWR]iVDpVGRUEp]ROiVD,JHQiUXONRGy%D]Vy0LKiO\
YDOORPiVDDNLV]HULQW6]ĘQ\LiMXOiVLJLWWDPDJiW%D]VyKi]iQiO'HNpU GHPpQKRJ\DQOHKHWD]KRJ\DWDQ~D]WiOOtWMDKRJ\DOHONpV]D]ĘKi]iEDQ EHU~JRWWĘPDJDYLV]RQWMy]DQPDUDGW"(J\LO\HQYHQGpJHVNHGpVVRUiQD JD]GDQHPPXODWRWWHJ\WWDYHQGpJpYHO"6]HULQWHPLWWDUUyOYDQV]yKRJ\
D] HPEHUHN HJ\ MHOHQWĘV UpV]H HOIRJDGWD 6]ĘQ\L NLFVDSRQJiVDLW YLV]RQW DPLNRU 3iO PHJVpUWHWWH 'RERV\ *HUJHO\W DNNRU KLUWHOHQ PLQGHQNL HOOHQH IRUGXOW$]pUWLVJRQGRORPKRJ\'RERV\PĦN|GpVHiOOKDW6]ĘQ\LHOWiYROt WiVDP|J|WWPHUWĘYROWD]DNLWĦ]|QYt]HQNHUHV]WOYLWWHD]WKRJ\6]DODL 3iOWPLQGHQiURQPHJYiODVV]iNOHONpV]QHN5iDGiVXOD]~MSUpGLNiWRU'R ERV\ IHOHVpJpQHN D WHVWYpUH YROW 0pJ D] LV HONpS]HOKHWĘ KRJ\ 'RERV\
Q\RPiViUDYiOWR]WDWWDPHJ&VRy,VWYiQDWDQ~YDOORPiViWPHUW&VRyHOĘV]|U D]WYDOORWWDKRJ\3iODNDWROLNXVNiQWRUQiOWHWWOiWRJDWiVDVRUiQQHPYROW UpV]HJPiVRGMiUDYLV]RQWD]WiOOtWRWWDKRJ\UpV]HJYROWpVDNiQWRUOiQ\iW IRJGRVWD
7XGMXNKRJ\3iONpQ\WHOHQYROWHON|OW|]QL6]HQWHVUĘOpVDSMiQiOK~]WD PHJPDJiW6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQDFVDOiGLKLYDWiVWRYiEEYLWHOpQHNpUGHNpEHQ PHJSUyEiONR]RWWD]]DOKRJ\¿iWYiViUKHO\LOHONpVV]pYiODV]WDVVDGHH]QHP VLNHUOWQHNL3iODQQ\LUDQpSV]HUĦWOHQOHWW+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\HQKRJ\N|WH OH]WpNDUUDKRJ\ÄKpWQDSRNDODWWNLWDNDURGMRQ´$PHJpOKHWpVQDJ\JRQG MiW H]pUW 3iO ~J\ SUyEiOWD PHJROGDQL KRJ\ D .iURO\L JUyIRN WiPRJDWiViW NpUWHEHQDONDOPLYHUVHNHWtUWJUyI.iURO\L-y]VHIHVNYĘMpUHDPLNRU DJUyIIHOHVpJOYHWWHJU:DOGVWHLQ:DUWHQEHUJ(U]VpEHWHW
7W5(/,L$;&,,,6]ĘQ\L3iOHJ\Ki]IHJ\HOPLJ\pQHNWDQ~NLKDOOJDWiVDL PiMXV
7$.È&6,PKWWSZZZV]HQWHVLQIRKXFGHNNOH]VLDLPDJHQDJ\-3*
7W5(/,L$;&,,,6]ĘQ\L3iOHJ\Ki]IHJ\HOPLJ\pQHNWDQ~NLKDOOJDWiVDL PiMXVËUiVRVQ\RPDQLQFVDQQDNKRJ\'RERV\EiUPLO\HQNDSFVRODWEDQLViOOW YROQD&VRyYDO
7W5(/ ,L$&;,,,9iViUKHO\L HJ\Ki] MHJ\]ĘN|Q\YL NLYRQDWD 6]ĘQ\L 3iO
J\pEHQPiUFLXV6=(5(0/(<,P
01/2/3QU.iURO\LFVDOiGQHP]HWVpJLOHYpOWiUD0LVVLOHV6]ĘQ\L3iO
|
$]iURQLFVDOiGRNUDMHOOHP]ĘJRQGRVNRGiVYLV]RQWQHPpUWLWWYpJHWPHUW 3iOQpKiQ\pYYHONpVĘEE~MDEEOHKHWĘVpJHWNDSRWW
$7UHOPLUHQGHOHWN|YHWNH]WpEHQD%iQiWEDQLVOHKHWĘYpYiOWSURWHVWiQV WHOHSHVHNOHWHOHSHGpVHDPHO\QHNN|V]|QKHWĘHQDV]i]DGYpJpLJ|VV]H VHQQpJ\UHIRUPiWXVHJ\Ki]N|]VpJM|WWH]HQDWHUOHWHQOpWUH0DJ\DULWWH EH/LHEOLQJ5LWWEHUJ9pJYiUpV'HEHOMiFVD
$]~MJ\OHNH]HWHNPHJV]HUYH]pVHQHPYROWHJ\V]HUĦIHODGDWPHUW D VHPPLEĘO NHOOHWW N|]|VVpJHNHW V]HUYH]QL LQWp]PpQ\HNHW PĦN|GWHWQL pV D]HJ\Ki]N|]VpJHNYDJ\RQL|QiOOyViJiWPHJWHUHPWHQL3iO0DJ\DULWWHEpQ NH]GKHWHWW~MpOHWHW
)RUUiVDLQNWDQ~ViJDV]HULQWHJ\NLVVHJtWVpJJHOV]HUH]KHWWHPHJ3iOD]~M OHONpV]LiOOiVWPHUWD]HJ\Ki]PHJ\HLMHJ\]ĘN|Q\YEHQVHPPLO\HQQ\RPD VLQFVDQQDNKRJ\NLQHYH]WpNYROQDĘW,WWHEpUH5iDGiVXODUUyOVLQFVDGDW KRJ\YLVV]DNDSWDHDSDOiVWMiW(J\HGODPDJ\DULWWHEHLDQ\DN|Q\YEHQWD OiOKDWyPHJDQHYHDPHO\V]HULQWM~QLXViEDQiWYHWWHD]DQ\DN|Q\Y YH]HWpVpW%RURV,VWYiQWyOpVIRO\WDWWDD]WHJpV]HQV]HSWHPEHUpLJ $UHIRUPiWXVHJ\Ki]EDQD]HVSHUHVQHNMRJDYROWHJ\HJ\J\OHNH]HWEHQ KHO\HWWHVtWĘOHONpV]UĘOJRQGRVNRGQL(KKH]QHPIHOWpWOHQONHOOHWWD]HJ\
Ki]PHJ\HN|]J\ĦOpVpQHNDMyYiKDJ\iVDPHUWD]HVSHUHVVDMiWKDWiVN|UpEHQ LVLQWp]NHGKHWHWW*\DQ~PV]HULQWHEEHQD]HVHWEHQHUUĘOOHKHWV]y$QQDN HOOHQpUHKRJ\6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQEHQDOHVSHUHVQHNPDJDPHOOpYHWWH 6]HQWPLNOyVL6HEĘN6iPXHOWD]HVSHUHVLFtPHWLJPHJWDUWRWWD,JD]
DQDSLJ\LQWp]pVEHQPiUQHPYHWWUpV]WGHDMRJDPHJPDUDGWDKKR]KRJ\
OHYHOHJU.iURO\L$QWDOKR]>"@+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\MDQXiU$Ki]DVViJUyOOiVG e%/(*iERU$QDJ\NiURO\LJUyI.iURO\LFVDOiGOHV]iUPD]iVDDOHiQ\iJLLYDGpNRNIHOWQ- WHWpVpYHO%XGDSHVW)UDQNOLQ,,WiEOD
.Ï.$,6iQGRU$%iQViJW|UWpQHWLI|OGUDM]D±1\tUHJ\Ki]D1\tUHJ\Ki]L )ĘLVNROD7XUL]PXVpV)|OGUDM]WXGRPiQ\L,QWp]HW±
7W5(/,D.|]J\ĦOpVLMHJ\]ĘN|Q\Y±
7|UWpQHOPL/HYpOWiU1DJ\EHFVNHUHN=ELUNDFUNYHQWKPDWLþQLKNQMLJDUHIRUPDWVNDFUN- YHQDRSdžWLQD1RYL,WHEHM0DJ\DULWWHEHLKi]DVViJLKDORWWLpVNHUHV]WHOpVLDQ\DN|Q\YRPQL- iULXPPDO±
02/1È5$PEUXV$WLV]iQW~OLUHIRUPiWXVIDOXVLWiUVDGDORPIRUUiVDLUyO .XWDWiV PyGV]HUWDQ.RQIHUHQFLD*\XODDXJXV]WXVV]HUN(5'0$11*\XOD*\X OD%pNpV0HJ\HL/HYpOWiU±6=$%Ï=ROWiQ-y]VHI$PDJ\DUUHIRUPiWXV HJ\Ki]V]HUYH]HWHOVĘNpWpYV]i]DGD%XGDSHVW6]HQFL0ROQiU7iUVDViJ±7Ï7+
(QGUH$WLV]iQW~OLHJ\Ki]NHUOHWLJD]JDWiViQDNpVD]HVSHUHVLHJ\Ki]OiWRJDWiVQDNUHQGMH EĘO'HEUHFHQ'HEUHFHQL5HIRUPiWXV7KHRORJLDL$NDGpPLD±
+HJ\LÈGiP6]ĘQ\L3iO±6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQLPSRV]WRU¿D
KHO\HWWHVtWĘ OHONLSiV]WRURNDW NLQHYH]]HQ 0LYHO D] LWWHEHL OHONpV] %RURV ,VWYiQVLNNDV]WiVJ\DQ~MiEDNHYHUHGHWWH]pUWIHOIJJHV]WHWWpNDKLYDWDOiEyO
$J\OHNH]HWYLV]RQWQHPPDUDGKDWRWWOHONLSiV]WRUQpONOH]pUWD]iOOiVWDODQ 3iOV]iPiUDH]HJ\QDJ\RQQDJ\OHKHWĘVpJYROW$JRQGH]]HOD]KRJ\KLYD WDORVDQQHPV]OHWHWWG|QWpV%RURVKHO\HWWHVtWpVpUĘOD]HJ\Ki]PHJ\HFVDN DUUyOKDWiUR]RWWKRJ\D]LWWHEHLOHONpV]tUiVEDQNpV]tWVHQMHOHQWpVJ\OHNH]H WHiOODSRWiUyO6DMQRVDOHYpOWiULGRNXPHQWXPRNN|]|WWQHPWDOiOKDWyRO\DQ LUDWDPHO\EHQ6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQHVSHUHVLMRJiYDOpOYHNLQHYH]WHYROQD3iO KHO\HWWHVtWĘSUpGLNiWRUUi(ONpS]HOKHWĘKRJ\NpV]OWLO\HQLUDWGHD]PiUD HONDOOyGRWW(]YLV]RQWD]WMHOHQWLKRJ\3iOD]HJ\Ki]PHJ\HWXGWDQpONO YHWWHiWD]HNOp]VLDJ\HLW$]~MOHKHWĘVpJJHOYLV]RQWPiUQHPWXGRWWPLW NH]GHQLDOLJQpKiQ\KyQDSMDV]ROJiOW0DJ\DULWWHEpQDPLNRUDYiViUKHO\L
~MWHPSORP DODSNĘOHWpWHOpUH YLVV]DWpUW V]OĘYiURViED GH RQQDQ V]ROJiODWL KHO\pUHPiUQHPWXGRWWYLVV]DXWD]QLPHUWEHQ+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\HQ DJ\YpU]pVWNDSRWWpVVDMiWpGHVDSMDWHPHWWHĘWHO
gVV]HIRJODOiVNpSSHQPHJiOODStWKDWMXNKRJ\6]ĘQ\L3iOMHOOHPHPHVV]H HOPDUDGWDSMipWyOYLV]RQWpOHWHVRNV]HPSRQWEyOKDVRQOtWRWWDNRUD~MNRUL OHONpV]VRUVRNUD(]WD]]DOLJD]ROMXNKRJ\OHONLSiV]WRULPĦN|GpVpWDODSYH WĘHQPHJKDWiUR]WDD]KRJ\N|]|VVpJHPLO\HQHUN|OFVLYLVHONHGpVWpVPLO\HQ V]DNUiOLV V]ROJiOWDWiVW YiUW HO WĘOH$] HVHWpEHQ D UpV]HJHVNHGpVW PLQGDG GLJHOWXGWiNIRJDGQLDPtJD]]DODWHOHSOpVYH]HWĘLWQHPVpUWHWWHYDJ\LVD V]HQWHVLHNW|EEpYHQNHUHV]WOPHJPDUDV]WRWWiNSDSMXNQDN$PLQWYLV]RQW iWOpSWHDKDWiUWRQQDQWyONH]GYHD]RQQDOHOLQGXOWHOOHQHDWiPDGiV6RUVD QHPFVDNDSDSPDUDV]WiVV]RNiVUHQGV]HUpQNHUHV]WOpUWpNHOKHWĘPHUWpOHWpW iURQLFVDOiGMDLVPHJKDWiUR]WDpGHVDSMDIRO\DPDWRVDQLJ\HNH]HWWSUpGLNiWR ULNDUULHUMpWHOĘVHJtWHQL
6=(5(0/(<,P±±
7W5(/,D(J\Ki]PHJ\HLN|]J\ĦOpV0DNyIHEUXiU*\RPDV]HS- WHPEHU.|U|VWDUFVDIHEUXiU
7W5(/,F(VSHUHViOWDONO|QNH]HOWLUDWRN
01/±&V0/±+/,9D+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\YiURVIHOHNH]HWLDQ\DN|Q\YLPi- VRGSpOGiQ\DLQDNJ\ĦMWHPpQ\H5HIRUPiWXVHJ\Ki]DQ\DN|Q\YHL+DORWWLDQ\DN|Q\Y
|
5|YLGtWpVHN
+Ï5(/ +yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\ÏWHPSORPL5HIRUPiWXV(J\Ki]N|]VpJOHYpO WiUD01/±&60/±+/ 0DJ\DU1HP]HWL/HYpOWiU±&VRQJUiG0HJ\HL/HYpO WiU±+yGPH]ĘYiViUKHO\L/HYpOWiU
01/2/ 0DJ\DU1HP]HWL/HYpOWiU2UV]iJRV/HYpOWiU 7/1 7|UWpQHOPL/HYpOWiU1DJ\EHFVNHUHN
6W$% 6WDDWVDUFKLYGHV.DQWRQV%DVHO6WDGW
7W5(/ 7LV]iQW~OL5HIRUPiWXV(J\Ki]NHUOHWL/HYpOWiU
+HJ\LÈGiP6]ĘQ\L3iO±6]ĘQ\L%HQMiPLQLPSRV]WRU¿D