£
Ý
Þ
! "#$%&'(')%$'$*%$
Æ
Æ
Æ
! Æ
" #$%"&
!
Æ '
!
£
Ý
!
Þ
"#$% &' ( ! ) * (+ + $ ,
*-' &./# 011 +' &$$
) )
* " !
*
*+, -
! *
*
.
*
" #$%"&
(/(
0 .
1
0
-
- Æ
!
2 !
& *
1* *
-
-+ 5( 6,
+ 53 6, * 27" -
+2 ", 586 596
+ 24
" #$%"&,**
% :
5; 65< 6 5=6
0
+ 59 6 5> 6 5?6,
5(@ 6 5(( 6
!
5(3 6 A
&
!
*
-
0
- *
" 3 !
- " #$%"&
"8
! "9
A ";
" #$%"&
" #$%"& Æ
B
+ ,
" #$%"& *
" #$ ""9>
+"& "(<,4 ""9>
""9> " #$
Æ
*
A ( 3 C
-" #$ " #$%"&
A (
""9>" #$ *
'8 +"& D'9,
+7E'9%9, '81*
+& 2"#'2, '8
A 3 " #$
" #$ '8 1*
+& 2"#'2,
'8""9>* + 7, 7
*+ , + 2",
+-, (/(
+ 7, 2" .
(/(
" #$
'8 ""9>
A ( 3 F '8 " #$
" #$
! + , '8 (/(
+$2", -
+ (/( '8 ,
Interworking Ring-Ring
STM 1
Ring-Mesh Ring-Mesh
STM 1 Ring-Ring
Interworking
Fiber Fiber
SDH demand
TRIBUTARY LOCAL
DXC 4/4 AGGREGATE
STM 16 STM 16
OLT OLT
A(B " " #$C #
" #$ (/(
- A 3
+ , + ," #$
+ " #$ ,
A + ,
0
!+ ,
.
(/(
... ...
* optional, applied in some specified scenarios
Fiber Fiber
Fiber
OTM OTM OTM
Optical Demand STM 16
STM 16
AGGREGATE 4/4 DXC LOCAL TRIBUTARY SDH demand
STM 16 Ring-Mesh
STM 1 Interworking
OLT OLT OLT
OPS* OPS* OPS*
OLT OPS*
A3B " #
* "
B
(
3 *1+ ,
8 1
9
4 *!
* B
G
¾
+ ,+ ,
+(,
23 4 $$' ' $5$ ! && +'
B +! ,
+ ,B
+ , B
B * + ,
* *1 1
*
-
G(
B
G+
,
G
@
(
G@(
B
+ ,G(
+ ,
+3,
*
! B
++ ,,G
¾
+ ,+ , +8,
4 * Æ
5(9 6
*%
3 +#F,
++ ,,G
+ , +9,
4 * 5(; 6 * !
!
H Æ
! 47
$- 8 9
* + ,
+ ,
C +C, !
G
G
(
/
G
(/
+;,
+C ,
5(< 6 + ,
+ ,G
+(
,
+<,
4 * *
- ) ) ) )
(/(
A 8B
1
2 1-2
A8B !
A 8
(3 *
(3
( 3
(3
( ( 3
Æ B
"- $+"$,B
+,
+=,
+
,
"- $+"$,B
+ ,
+>,
+
,
* " $!+ !""# "#
' +',
4 -
G ( 0
+ ,
( : 5@(,I
3 -+ ,
8 + ,
9 ' + ,B
++ ,, (
+
, +?,
'
B
+++ ,,,
G
+ ,
+(@,
!
7
"5(= 6 . $- +(, !
7
F
*
G
¾
/
¾
G
¾
+((,
@
G
¾
/
¾
G
/
¾ + ,
+(3,
'
5(> 6 ! +5(?6,
B
G
G( G
G
G
¾ + ,I
*
++ ,,G
++ ,
,G
+
,
G
*
(
+
,
BG
(
+
, +(8,
- !
B
( G
!
G
+(9,
3 *
G
+(;,
. $ $ $$ 3 4
/ +'
/
+
,
(/
+
,
+(<,
9 " ! '
G
+
,
# !
* Æ !
* *
+ *
, B
+ , G(
G
!
+ ( I( ( -I3 I,
!
!
+ 5(>6, 53@ 6
$ #! %&!' !%
* !
! !
3
BG
8
+!
,
BG (
(
+
,
(
+
,
9 B
BG
;
< * !
BG
(
+
,
, ! !
Æ
!
( )
" #$%"& "
3 & ;@
<@ 4 " #$ -
" #$ * Æ
&F.
" #$ ? &F.
(?
1 " #$
A9
*
" #$ " #$
. $ $ $ + $ $'$ 36 4
& + 7*' $$ 5$+'
$'
Topological node
SDH node with SDH equipments
County town (SDH node with SDH and WDM equipments) HUB nodes (with SDH and WDM equipments)
A9B
" #$
" #$ +,
( 9 ""8
" #$ " #$&F. " Æ
&F.
( 9 ""9>
+! , " #$&F.+!
- ,
(3 Æ
&F. (3 + ,
&F. Æ
&F. ( 9
&
+" #$
( B " #$ " #$
4
3 B " #$
" #$
" #$ (/( '8
" #$ +
" #$ " #$ ,
(/(
8 B " #$
" #$ " #$
""9>
(/( '
"3 $
$- C #
7E' (<(@
9?
""9> >9(@
9<3 ><?
7 8(@
>;< (89>
2" <(@
@ =?9
(3(@
?; 33>
A+, (83(@
<(
# ((@
;@
(B C -
( +)#),
*
C+C ,
5(8 6 ( " C
! ( ;3>(@ +9 ,
(9<>(@
+((@>, ! 9@C;3>(@
-
53( 6
(
" 3;@@+(;=<88??,
8@@@@@@ 39(@
Æ B
' +',
" !" +22"",
4
- *
+(@@ (@@@ (@@@@,
(@
*
-
7" +7",
-
* Æ
A;= + ,
! (@@@@ 22"" 4 !
*+*
, !
7" !
2& $& !
0
100 1000 10000
Methods:
Sample Size:
1xNPI
1xNPI 0.1xNPI 0.01xNPI
10xNPI Relative values:
Li-Silvester Monte Carlo Stratified Sampling R e
l.
d e v.
A v e r a g
e
A;B 7 + G3??;(@
,
4 A ;
& 7"
(@@@@ A
(@ H (@@
; H(@@@
A < !
" #$%"& " #$%"&
22"" (@@
' 38
22"" 7"
4 7"
A =
+!,
0
100 1000 10000
Methods:
Sample Size:
1xNPI 0.1xNPI
1xNPI 0.1xNPI 10xNPI 100xNPI Relative values:
Li-Silvester Monte Carlo Stratified Sampling R e
l.
d e v.
A v e a r g e
A<B 7 + G<<(@
,
0
100 10000
Li-Silvester Monte Carlo Stratified Sampling Methods:
R e l.
d e v.
Sample Size:
1xNPI
1000
10xNPI 1xNPI 10xNPI
100xNPI 1000xNPI
0.1xNPI
0.1xNPI Relative values:
A v e r a g e
A =B 7 + G;?;(@
,
7" '
" 22"" A >
!
0.1 6E-5 3E-3
30 20 10 0
100
N P I
Without Protection
Native Layer Protection
Multi-Layer Protection
[%]
1000 10000
R e l.
d e v.
A v e a r g e
Sample Size:
Absolute values:
Network Case:
A>B '
! *B
&
(%3@
8
- "
Æ
4" #$%"&!
F
- 7"
' ! +
,
8@ H , (@@
! (/(
" !
* & *
*
!
! *
'
* 38
' -;(@ !
! Æ
& -
)("!%$!
JK 7 4 L
! M$ 2K. 0
&
C A L4 @8@<>; 0 & '
7
!&!!!
5(6 &M .0 ' " C
# D 3# 9J%43@@((=3>
536 " " # " # & " & 2 4
4 '" 2C D 3#
9J%43@@( 9>;>
2 27"C - 2 " 2
D 3 #9J%43@@( 3?9=
596 J 4 K4C' '$Æ C4
!! "!! # $%&"'(
(>38 (??>" 8=(8=<
5;6 2 C # )###*!!
D 8= #>4 (??? =@=<
5<6 : C ' 2 2 " "&
*!! *'(J(??>
FLD (;<(<8
5=6 :"7' 2 #2 "&
!! "!! # +
$%&"'( (??> " 8;?8<9 (>38
5>6 2 40 . D ' 2 27 D 2 C
. # D ( # 8 J
3@@@ 3;9@
5?6 J 4 K 4 4 " C#
4 " ) $ , %
*!! ,%* '( (??> .. 98%(<
5(@6 . C 4 # "
) $ , % *!! ,%* '-...
43@@@ : >@>;
5((6 4 " C " C "
) $ , % *!! ,%* '-...
43@@@ : (=9(>@
5(36 : 240 D 2 2 ' 4
C # ) $ ,
% *!! ,%* './ 3@@( . & (@=((3
FL(??> @3%((@
5(96 ." A": $ #C
FC )### 2 *!! D ' 8? (??(
(9?9(;@(
5(;6 . "2M4#! #4
4 # 2 !! D 8 # 9 J%4
(??3 89?8;=
5(<6 C . C # 4 % # # "!3 - #
22 (??3
5(=6 D L7J4"2 4 #F '
)### 2 *!!2 D ' 83 (?>9((@;(((@
5(>6 J ' N 7 J 7 C $ 7 #
" ! " 0 )
"!!3 '(4 . & "(??9 ((8((>
5(?6 $ "! "! 2 # N(?<<
53@6 7J J 7 A FK " # C 4
)1) 5) -... $ FL3@@@ 8;%(39
53(6 7 J A FK J 4 C 4 7
' # D 3 #; "%
3@@( 93;(
