• Nem Talált Eredményt

Case Study:

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Ossza meg "Case Study: "

Copied!
62
0
0

Teljes szövegt

(1)

Development of Complex Curricula for Molecular Bionics and Infobionics Programs within a consortial* framework**

Consortium leader

PETER PAZMANY CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY

Consortium members

SEMMELWEIS UNIVERSITY, DIALOG CAMPUS PUBLISHER

The Project has been realised with the support of the European Union and has been co-financed by the European Social Fund ***

**Molekuláris bionika és Infobionika Szakok tananyagának komplex fejlesztése konzorciumi keretben

PETER PAZMANY CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY SEMMELWEIS

UNIVERSITY

(2)

Compiled by dr. Péter Mátyus

with contribution by dr. Gábor Krajsovszky Formatted by dr. Balázs Balogh

Case Study:

How to explore the scope and limitation of an unexplored reaction

(Esettanulmány: hogyan derítsük fel egy ismeretlen reakció alkalmazhatósági körét és korlátait)

Organic and Biochemistry

(Szerves és Biokémia )

semmelweis-egyetem.hu

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(3)

Outline

1. tert-Amino effect: types 2. Type 2 tert-amino effect:

with C=C: vinyl-tert-anilines and pyridazine analogues with C=O: aminobenzaldehydes

3. New types of tert-amino effect:

with biaryl systems with triaryl systems with peri-fused system

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(4)

N(CH3)2

NH2

N N

CH3

CH3

N(CH3)2

NHAc

N

X

Y N

X Y

Pinnow et al. Chem. Ber., 27, 602 (1894)

Ac2O

tert-Amino effect:

'Unusual' cyclization of a tert-aniline with ortho-X=Y group

The first synthetic example

e.g. X+Y: N=CH Generalization

Meth-Cohn and Suschitzky, 1972

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(5)

(H3C)2N

NH2

(H3C)2N

NH C O CH3

(H3C)2N

N C CH3

OAc

N N+ C H3

C H3

CH3

N N

CH3 C

H3

OAc- +CH3OAc

Ac2O Ac2O

Mechanism proposal

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(6)

tert-Amino effect: 6 types

by the size of the ring formed and/or by the mode of ring formation

Types 1-5: O. Meth-Cohn Adv. Heterocyclic Chem., 60, 1 (1996);

Type 6: V. Ojea et al. Synlett, 622, (2004);

X Y

N N

X Y

N X Y

N+ X

Y

N+

X Y

Type 1 Type 2 Type 3 Type 4

Type 5 Type 6

N X

Y X

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(7)

Reviews, X+Y: vinyl:

Type 2 tert-amino effect: the 6-membered ring formation

Y X

N

X=Y: C=C, ring closure with C-C bond formation

L. C. Groenen et al. Tetrahedron, 44, 4637 (1988)

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(8)

Reinhoudt et al.:

Carbo- and π-excessive heteroaromatics: Benzene, thiophene, benzothiophene vinyl: ββ-disubst.vinyl;

tert-amino: pyrrolidino, piperidino, morpholino stereo- and regiochemistry

Products: tetrahydropyrido-fused systems Mátyus et. al.:

π-deficient heteroaromatics; diazine vs. benzene

ββ-disubst.vinyl (in a ring); tert-amino (conf. restriction; buttressing) stereo- and regiochemistry

kinetics

thermochemistry reaction conditions

Products: tetrahydropyrido-fused systems; spiro-compounds

Type 2 tert-amino effect with X=Y vinyl

X Y

N

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(9)

N

NC CN

Ha Hb H

N+

C-

NC CN

Ha Hb H

N+

C- Hb Ha H

CN CN

N

Hb CN H CN Ha

A B C

Type 2 tert-amino effect X=Y: β,β-disubst.vinyl group

1,5-hydrogen migration followed by cyclization to 6-membered ring

L. C. Groenen et al. Tetrahedron, 44, 4637 (1988) Reviews

P. Mátyus et al. Synthesis, 16, 2625 (2006)

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(10)

W. Verboom et al. Recl. Trav. Chim. Pay-Bas, 109, 311 (1990)

Type 2 tert-amino effect: regio- and stereochemical acpects

N

X

C R3

CN C NC

H R4

N+

X

C C(CN)2

R4 R3

H

N

X

R4 CN

CN H R3

N

X

H CN

CN H R3 R4

H

N

X

R4 CN

CN R3 H

-

1,5-H

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(11)

Reinhoudt et al.:

Carbo- and π-excessive heteroaromatics: Benzene, thiophene, benzothiophene vinyl: ββ-disubst.vinyl;

tert-amino: pyrrolidino, piperidino, morpholino stereo- and regiochemistry

Products: tetrahydropyrido-fused systems Mátyus et. al.:

π-deficient heteroaromatics; diazine vs. benzene

ββ-disubst.vinyl (in a ring); tert-amino (conf. restriction; buttressing) stereo- and regiochemistry

kinetics

thermochemistry

Type 2 tert-amino effect with X=Y vinyl

X Y

N

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(12)

- 9.82 - 9.58 - 9.60 - 9.37 - 8.91

- 1.49 - 1.06 - 0.89 - 0.48 - 0.12

The HOMO and LUMO energies (eV, AM1) of 3(2H)-pyridazinones

Cl C

H3

Cl O

N N

C H3

I O

N

N H3C

O

N N

N C

H3

O

N N C

H3

O

N N

SO2Et

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(13)

N N

O C

H3

I

N N

N

O C

H3

O

CHO

N N C H3

O

CHO

NR1R2

N N

O C

H3

NR1R2

Synthesis of 5-(tert-amino)-4-pyridazinecarbaldehydes

i ii

iii

iv

Reaction conditions: (i) 1. morpholine, EtOH, rfx, 79% 2. POCl3/DMF, 70 °C, 83%;

(ii) R1R2NH;

R1R2N = N(CH3)2, pyrrolidino

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(14)

P. Mátyus et al.Heterocycles, 37, 171 (1994)

The first example of isomerization of tert-amino-ortho- vinyldiazine via tert-amino effect to tetrahydropyridodiazine

N N C H3

O

N

CN CN N

N

N C

H3

O

NC

CN N

N O

CHO

N C

H3

DMSO 150 °C, 44h

35%

CN CN

EtOH, RT

80%

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(15)

N N

O H3C

N

CN CN

O

k (10-4 sec-1)

(DMSO) Ref.

Schwartz, Mátyus 150 oC

0.98

N

CN CN

O

0.19 90 oC Reinhoudt

Kinetics

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(16)

a: X = morpholino, A = NCH3, B = CO b: X = pyrrolidino, A = NCH3, B = CO c: X = morpholino, A = O, B = C(CH3)2 a: X = CH2O, A = NCH3, B = CO

b: X = CH2, A = NCH3, B = CO c:X = CH2O, A = O, B = C(CH3)2

Reaction conditions: (i) 1,3-dimethylbarbituric acid or Meldrum’s acid, toluene, AcOH, piperidine, rt, 45 min (a, b), 4 h, toluene, piperidine (c); (ii) xylene, AlCl3, 150 °C, 8 h (a, b), DMF, 110 °C, 5 h (c)

The β-vinyl carbon incorporated into a ring: rate-increasing effect

N N C H3

O

CHO

X

N N

X

A B A O

C H3

O

O

N N

N X

B A A C

H3

O O

O

i ii

A. Schwartz et al. J. Mol. Struct. (Theochem), 528, 49 (2000)

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(17)

k (10-4 sec-1)

(DMSO, 90 °C) ΔH# (kcal mol-1)

ΔS#

(cal mol-1 K-1)

N

CN CN

O

N

N N

O O

O CH3

CH3 O

0.19 n.d. n.d.

85 20.1±0.4 -13.3±0.5

Ref.

Reinhoudt et al.

Mátyus et al.

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(18)

B. Halász-Dajka et al. 2008

Restriction of conformational flexibility of the tert.-amino group by buttressing: the rate of cyclization increases

N N C H3

O

N(CH3)2

N N C H3

O

N(CH3)2 CHO

N N C H3

O

N(CH3)2 N N O CH3

O

CH3 O

N N

N

N N C

H3

O

CH3 O

CH3 O CH3 O

POCl3/DMF 70 °C

100 °C DMF

DMB EtOH, rt

80%

85% 62%

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(19)

N N

N

N N C

H3

O

CH3 O CH3 O

X O N

N C H3

O

N

X CHO

DMB ethanol, RT

X = CH2, O X = CH2 82%

O 88%

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(20)

N N

O H3C

N

CN CN

O

N N

O H3C

N

CN CN

O Ph

k (10-4 sec-1) (DMSO)

Ref.

Schwartz, Mátyus

Dajka, Mátyus 150 oC

100 oC 0.98

2.51

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(21)

O

N OH CH2

O N OH

H CH2

O N

H O

O

CH2 H3CO

Δ

Δ

No cycloaddition (1,4-Claisen rearrangement occurs)

cycloaddition Δ

100%

Examples for the role of buttressing

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(22)

N N

N X

X

Ph O

C H3 N

N

N X O X

C H3

N N

N X O X

C H3

The conformational flexibility of the tert-amino group II:

The tert-amino nitrogen is in a fused ring

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(23)

N N

N O

O C

H3

R1

R2 O

( )n

N N

N O

O C

H3

N N

O

O

CH3 C

H3 O

R1

R2 ( )n

( )n N

N

N O

O C

H3

R1

R2 N N

O

O

CH3 C

H3 O

i ii

R1 R2 n

a: H H 1

b: H H 2

c: Ph H 1

d: Ph H 2

e: –(CH ) 1

Yield 95%

70%

82%

90%

81%

a-f a-f a-f

Reaction conditions: (i) 1,3-dimethylbarbituric acid, ethanol, 25 °C; (ii) for b-dand f: DMSO, 150 °C, for e: neat, 250 °C *.

Yield Time (h)

93% 1

52% 3

56% 3

46% *

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(24)

Cp - Cβ Hm - Cα

X-ray 3.06 2.62

X-ray 3.24 2.60

X-ray 3.19 2.62

X-ray 3.29 2.60

X-ray 3.10 2.71

Cp - Cβ and Hm- Cα distances in vinyl compounds

N N

N C

H3 O

N N

O O

O

CH3 C H3

Hm Cα

Cβ

Cp

N N

N O C H3

O

Ph N

N

O O

O

CH3 C H3

N N C H3

O N

N

O O

O

CH3 C H3

N O

Ph

N N C H3

O N

N

O O

O

CH3 C H3

N O

N N C H3

O N

N

O O

O

CH3 C H3

N O

Ao

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(25)

N N Me

O

CN CN

N

O

N N Me

O

N

O CN CN

μW

Solvent-phase reactions Solvent-free reactions

Heating Solvent °C/time Yield Heating °C/time Yield

Δ DMSO 150/44 h 35%

Δ 200/18 min 57%

Δ 200/20 min 78%

μW DMSO 210/42 min 29%

μW 200/18 min 75%

Optimization of reaction conditions

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(26)

Reaction condition: (i) pyrrolidine, K2CO3, H2O, μW, 130 °C, 3 min;

(ii) CH2(CN)2, H2O, μW, 100 °C, 10 min, then 1 drop of TFA, 200 °C, 3 min

Green preparation:

S

N

Ar – Knoevenagel condensation – cyclcization via tert-amino effect in one pot, in water in 0.3 h

N. Kaval et al. Green Chem., 6, 125 (2004)

CHO

F

CHO

N N

CN CN

50%

i ii

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(27)

CHO N

1a

N

O OH

N

2a 3a

Entry Activation mode Conditions Product (yield, %)

1 MW H2O, K2CO3(1 equiv), 90 W, 200 °C, 60 min 2a(41%), 1a(28%)

2 Δ H2O, K2CO3(1 equiv), 200 °C, 60 min -

3 MW n-BuOH, K2CO3(1 equiv), 300 W, 200 °C, 60 min 3a

4 MW n-BuOH, 300 W, 250 °C, 60 min -

5 MW H2O, 300 W, 194 °C, 60 min -

6 MW Neat, 300 W, 200 °C, 60 min -

7 MW Toluene, AlCl3(cat), 300 W, 200 °C, 30 min -

8 MW H2O, TFA (1 equiv), 150 W, 200 °C, 30 min -

9 MW Silica, 100 W, 200 °C, 60 min 2a(17%)

10 MW D2O, K2CO3(1 equiv), 90 W, 200 °C, 60 min 2a(41%)

11 MW Al2O3-KF (3:1), 100 W, 200 °C, 60 min 2a(42%)

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(28)

N

COCF3

COCF3

N O

COCF3

CF3 H

N X

COCF3

N O

CF3 H X

H+ H+

X = −, CH2

W. Verboom et al. J. Org. Chem., 1982, 3339

Type 2 tert-amino effect: X=Y is C=O

T. Lett., 1988, 4599

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(29)

New types of tert-amino effect:

Attachement of the amino and vinyl substituents to different rings

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(30)

N

N

N

Ring closure exothermic (DFT//RB3LYP//6-31(D))

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(31)

Br

NH2

Br

N

CHO

( )n N

N CH3

CH3

B(OH)2

N CH3

CH3

N CH3

CH3 CHO

( )n

i ii

iii iv

(n=1) 80%

(n=2) 81%

(n=1) 90%

(n=2) 68%

37% 67%

Reaction conditions: (i) Br(CH ) Br,i-Pr EtN, toluene, 110 °C, 15h

n = 1,2

Synthesis of diphenyl aldehydes

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(32)

CHO N

R R

CN CN

N R R malononitrile

EtOH, rt, 24h

N R R

: pyrrolidino, dimethylamino

95%

68%

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(33)

CN CN

N

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(34)

N CH2 C H

CH

X-ray

N-CH: 2.878 Å CH2-CH: 3.151 Å

N CH3 CH3 C H

CH

DFT//RB3LYP/6-31G(D) N-CH: 2.927 Å

CH3-CH: 3.577 Å

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(35)

N

A A

R R CHO

N R R

N R R

: pyrrolidino, dimethylamino indan-1,3-dione

or dimethybarbituric acid EtOH, rt , 24h

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(36)

N+ N

N O

O- O C

H3

CH3

CH3 CH3

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(37)

N+ N

N O

O- O C

H3

CH3

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(38)

N

CH3 CON3 CH3 CH3

N+ N C CH3 CH3

CH3

O C6H6 Δ -

81%

Type 4 tert-amino effect: Reaction of X=Y with the nitrogen atom

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(39)

CN NC

N R2

R1

N R2

R1 CN CN DMSO, Ar

110 ºC R1+R2 = (CH2)3 94%

160 ºC R1= H, R2 = CH3 23%

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(40)

N CN

CN

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(41)

Mechanism proposal I for dibenzo-fused derivatives

C- N

N O CH3

O

CH3 N+ O

N

N O CH3

O

CH3 N O

[1,7] H C-

N

N O CH3

O

CH3 N+ O

1 2 3

4

5 6 7

N

N

N O

O

O CH3

CH3

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(42)

N+

N O N

O- O C

H3

CH3 N

N O CH3

O

CH3 N O

H H

C- N

N O CH3

O

CH3 N+ O

H

N

N

N O

O

O CH3

CH3 CHO

N

Mechanism proposal II for formation of 8-member system via two new types (7, 8) of tert-amio effect

DMB

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(43)

i

Reaction condition: (i) μW, neat, 300 W, 100 ºC, 30 min, Ar atm.

23 % 35 %

i

N

CN CN

N

CN CN

+ N

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(44)

N

CN CN

N NC CN

N

CN

+ CN

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(45)

malononitrile EtOH, piperidine, rt, 24h

87%

96%

: pyrrolidino, dimethylamino

N N

CHO N

R R

C H3

O

N N

N R R

C H3

O

CN CN

N R R

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(46)

38%

39%

DMSO, 160 ºC Ar, 24h

DMSO, 160 ºC Ar, 96h

N N C

H3 O

CN CN

N N

CN CN

N N O

C H3

N N

N CH3 CH3

C H3

O

CN CN

N N

N O

C H3

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(47)

MeOH

N N

N

CN CN O

C H3

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(48)

First step: Buchwald SL, WO2004052939 (2004)

70% 71%

Synthesis of triphenyl aldehyde

I

Br

N CH3

CH3 B(OH)2

Br N CH3 C H3

N CH3 C H3

OHC

B(OH)2 CHO

Pd(PPh3)4, DME, 2M Na2CO3, rfx

Pd(PPh3)4, DME 2M Na2CO3, rfx

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(49)

Isomerization of triphenyl derivative:

formation of a new tribenzazecine system

92% 70%

X-ray

OHC

N C H3

CH3

CN CN EtOH, RT

N C H3

CH3 NC

NC

μW, neat 200 W, 200 °C, 3h

N CH3

CN CN

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(50)

Naphtalene derivative:

formation of ortho- and peri-fused azepine system

98% 81%

N CH3 C

H3

CHO

CN CN

EtOH, RT

N CH3 C

H3

CN CN

80 °C, 12h DMSO

N

CN CN C

H3

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(51)

N CN NC

CH3 N

C H3 NC

CN

CH3

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(52)

N CN NC N

CN NC

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(53)

X N Me

Me N X

Me Me

O NiPr2

N Me Me

O NMe2

N Me Me

O OMe

X N Me Me

O CH3

N Me Me

H NC CO2Me

N Me Me

H NC CN

N Me

Me H

O O O O

+

-

N N Me Me

Me

Me Me O O Me

1 X = sp2C 2 3 4 5

6 7 8 9 10

X Compound Me2N-X distance/Å MeO-X distance in corresponding methoxynaphthalene/Å

CON(iPr)2 2 2.764(3) 2.623(2)

CH=CHBr 2.717(5)-2.758(2)

CONMe2 3 2.698(3) 2.597(5)

CH=C(COPh)2 2.679(2)

CO2H 2.606(5) 2.559(4)

CO2Me 4 2.594(4) 2.588(3)

COMe 5 2.557(3) 2.606(9)

CH=C(CN)CO Et 6 2.531(2)

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(54)

N Me

Me H O

N Me

Me H

NO2

COPh

N Me

Me COPh

NO2

+ -

PhCOCH2NO2

J. O’Leary, Org. Biomol. Chem. 3, 3273 (2005)

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(55)

C N H3

H NO2

COPh H3C N

O2N COPh

C N H3

O2N

COPh

DMSO Δ

+ -

..

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(56)

Solvent Reaction condition Reaction time (h) Yield (%)

i DMSO 100 °C 5 81

ii DMSO 100 °C, 105 W, µW 0.7 80

iii - 180 °C 2 67

iv - 180 °C, 105 W, µW 0.7 60

i-iv EtOH, RT

DMB

N+ CH3 CH3 N

N

O C H3

O CH3 O-

N CH3 C

H3 N

N

O C

H3 O

CH3 OHC N O

CH3 C

H3

N CH3 N

N

O C H3

O CH3

O

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(57)

N+ CH3

CH3 C

H3 N

O N

O CH3

O-

N+ CH3

CH3 C

H3 N

O N

O CH3

O-

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(58)

N N N O C H3

O CH3

O

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(59)

Kinetic isotope effect

Conclusion

1. No deuterium is lost, the migration is intramolecular process

2. The magnitudes of kH/kD indicates that migration of a hydrogen takes place

73% 67%

DMSO-d6 100 °C, 3.5 h

N H3C

NC CN D

D

H D NH2

CN CN N

D3C CD3

kH/kD = 2.85 (CD3)2SO4

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(60)

Reaction conditions

solvent reaction condition reaction time (h) yield (%)1 yield (%)2

1. DMSO 60 oC 23.5 85 -

2. DMSO 100 oC 2.5 81 -

3. DMSO 100 oC, 105 W, MW 0.17 81 -

4. neat 160 oC 3 61 -

5. neat 160 oC, 106 W 0.3 80 -

6. H2O MW, 40 W, 100 oC 3.5 31 67 7. D2O MW, 40 W, 100 oC 6 39 59

N H3C

NC CN CN

CN N

H3C CH3

N H3C

CN NH2 O

+

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(61)

Mechanism proposal

for formation of ortho- and peri-fused azepine

98%

81% EtOH, RT

DMSO

DMSO 80 °C

80 °C

N CH3 C

H3

CHO CN

CN

N

CN CN C

H3 N

C H H3

CN CN

N+

C- C

H3

NC CN

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

(62)

Summary

1. tert-Amino effect with the involvement of a vinyl group may operate in mono-, bi- and triaryl systems to afford polycyclic systems with 6-10-member aza- rings

2. The reaction involves intramolecular hydrogen migration with 1,n-sigmatropic hydrogen and/or hydride migration.

3. Biological activity

4. tert-Amino effect in the nature; self-organization?

Organic and Biochemistry: Unexplored reaction case study

Hivatkozások

KAPCSOLÓDÓ DOKUMENTUMOK

Substituting this luciferin’s 6-position hydroxyl group with an amino group, the resulting ami- noluciferin (aLuc) can form amide bond with a peptide, while retaining the

In the in  vitro study, we preincubated aortic rings of healthy rats (N = 5) with vehicle (DMSO, n = 10 rings) or canagliflozin (10 µM; Canagliflozin, n = 10 rings) to test

1) A facile microwave-assisted diastereo-selective cyclization reaction was exploited for the preparation of condensed tetrahydroquinoline derivatives via the tert-amino effect. a)

The addition of ammonia and substituted primary amines to methyl maleamate (m) may lead to two reaction products (Fig. 1.), forming amino group on the vinylogue carbon of the

The three main goals of IFCN are the following: - to establish and operate a world-wide network dealing with the analysis of agricultural systems, - to analyse and predict the

Considering the shaping of the end winding space let us examine the start- ing torque variation for an induction machine equal to the model when distance between the

This study investigated the effect of reaction parameter, reaction kinetics and mechanism of transesterification of sunflower oil with methanol by using CaO/ZnO

The steady-state investigations are confirmed later by dynamic simulations, and finally the best composition control scheme is selected for the entire system – based on