$V]HUNHV]W tUMD

/HYpOV]HNUpQ\

/ ( 9 e / 6 = ( . 5 e 1 <

+iUV-y]VHItUMD

eUGHNOGpVVHOROYDVWDPDIRO\yLUDWWDYDO\LQHJ\HGLNV]iPiEDQ)(+e5

7Ï,.$7$/,1QDNÄÈUSiGNRULV]HPpO\QHYHNROYDVDWDLQDNPHJEt]KDWyViJiUyO´FtPHQtURWWPHJiOOD StWiVDLW²+DMyOpUWHPDFLNNPRQGDQGyMiWD]WNHOOOHV]&UQ|PEHOOHKRJ\D;;V]i ]DGIRO\DPiQV]OHWHWWROYDVDWRNOHJDOiEELVQHPIRJKDWyNIHO|U|NpUYpQ\&PHJKDWiUR]iVRNNpQW Ä$Q\HOYW|UWpQHWLNXWDWiVRNDODSMiXOV]ROJiOyÈUSiGNRULV]yUYiQ\RNN|]QHYHNpVWXODMGRQQHYHN ROYDVDWDLQDNKHO\HVVpJpUOKLWHOHVNpSHWWDOiQVRKDQHPQ\HUKHWQN´²tUMDDV]HU]LK

$]WKLV]HPLWWD]LGHMHDQQDNKRJ\D/YHU²/|YpUNpUGpVPHJYiODV]ROiViEDQDVRNpYWL ]HGHVGRJPiNRQPHJSUyEiOMXQNW~OOpSQL0LDGHQQHNLGV]HU&VpJHW"6RSURQWyOGpOUHWDOiOKDWyN D OYHUHN QDJ\REE J\P|OFV|V|NUH pSOW FVDOiGL Ki]DN $] H]HN NLDODNtWiViUD YRQDWNR]y

;,,V]iP~YiURVLV]DEiO\UHQGHOHW~MUDIRJDOPD]iVDQDSLUHQGUHNHUOW$UpJLKDQJ V~O\R]RWWDQOYHUHNUOEHV]pO$]LOOHWpNHVHNPDEL]RQ\WDODQNRGQDN

0LDNO|QEVpJOpQ\HJH"$]ÈUSiGNRULYLOODOXHUHJ\RO\DQIDOXQHYHNpQWNHUOWEH,9/iV]Oy NLUiO\XQN EHQ NLiOOtWRWW RNOHYHOpEH DPHO\HW D NLUiO\ UHQGHONH]pVpUH J\DNRUODWLODJ IHOV]i PROWDN$]RWWODNytMiV]RNDWUpJLPDJ\DUV]yYDOO|YNHWO|YpUHNHWXJ\DQLVDYiURVYpGHOPpUHD ID ODNP|JpWHOHStWHWWpNLJD]ViJV]HULQWPiU,9%pODyWDUpV]OHWHNEHQ$ODSRVDJ\DQ~KRJ\D IDOX D PDL 5iNyF]L XWFD IRO\WDWiViEDQ OHKHWHWW (QQHN D YpOHNHGpVQHN D PHJHUVtWpVH D N|]pSNRUL /HEHUJDVVHKHO\HWHOHNN|Q\YLDGDWRNDODSMiQYDOyV]tQ&OHJD5iNyF]LXWFDVDUUDDKRQIRJODOiVNR ULIDOXUDPXWDWDPHO\HWDN|]pSNRULYiURVWyOQ\XJDWUDDVtNViJRQOpYPDL-HUHYiQODNyWHOHSKH O\pQ EDQ WiUWDN IHO 6=$%Ï-(1 +RO YROW 6RSURQEDQ D /HEHUJDVVH" 6RSURQL 6]HPOH

²LOOHWYH*|P|UL-iQRViVDWiVDL

(]]HOV]HPEHQDOYHUHNDNpVEELLGNEHQDODNXOWDNNLVDQpPHWVpJEHWHOHSHGpVHUpYpQ NDSWiNDEDMRUHUHGHW&OHZHU¶KDWiUGRPE¶HOQHYH]pVEODOZHUHNQHYHW$SiQJHUPiQW|UHNYp VHNQHNHOOHQiOOYD%DNRQ\L5iEHO/iV]OyiUYDV]pNLWLV]WYLVHO~MViJtUyMDYDVROWDD/|YpUQHYHW

$ )1(6] LGHYiJy PHJiOODStWiVDL QHP iOOQDN H]]HO V]|JHV HOOHQWpWEHQ Y| Ä$ VRSURQL QpP/HZHU a /RHZHU >W|EEHV V]@ KQ D PDJ\DUEyO YDOy GH QpSHWLPROyJLiVDQ |VV]HNDSFVROWiN DNIQOHZHU¶GRPE¶EDMRV]WU/HZHU¶XD¶IQYHO ² $/|YpUHN W|EEHV V]iP~ DODNMiQDN D] D PDJ\DUi]DWDKRJ\DKQEO6RSURQEDQN|]QpYDODNXOWY|VRSURQLQpP/HZHU¶NHUWD/|YpUHN EHQ¶aPOYHUOYpU¶XD¶´LWWWRYiEELLURGDORPLV²$V]HUN

/HYpOV]HNUpQ\

9iURVRQEHOODYiURVYH]HWVpJRNWyEHUiQYH]HWWHEHD]$OVy/|YpU)HOV/|YpUO|YpUHN V]DYDNDW D]$OVy/YHU )HOV/YHU OYHUHN V]DYDN KHO\HWW HOIRJDGYD D] ~MViJtUy YpOHPpQ\pW DNLHMWpVEHQLV

(]DO|YpUD]RQEDQD]yWDVHPPHQWiWDN|]WXGDWEDKLV]HQPiUEHYH]HWpVHNRULVYROWDNWX GyVRN02//$<.È52/<0$È5.È52/<VWEDNLNLQNiEEDOpUNLHMWpVPHOOHWWWHWWpNOHDYRN VRW1RGHDOpQ\HJD]KRJ\D]HJ\HVV]iP~IDOXQpYQHPYLKHWiWDW|EEHVV]iP~WHONHNUH6HP W|UWpQHWpEHQVHPI|OGUDM]LODJVHPV]HUHSpEHQVHPQ\HOYWDQLODJ(]pUW LV KHO\WHOHQ ² YpOHPp Q\HPV]HULQW²D0DJ\DU+HO\HVtUiVL6]yWiUN|]OpVHÄ/|YpUHN6RSURQEDQ´ËJ\QDJ\EHW&YHO +DVRQOyNpSSHQURVV]D]pYWL]HGHVKLYDWDORVpVNHYpVEpKLYDWDORVJ\DNRUODW/YpU/YpUN|U

~W /YpU V]iOOy VWE 0LQGH]W UpV]OHWHVHQ PHJtUWDP EHQ D 6]OI|OGQN F *\U0RVRQ 6RSURQPHJ\HLSiO\i]DWRQGtMDWQ\HUWPXQNiPEDQ.pVEEU|YLGHEEHQD0DJ\DU1\HOYUV]iPi UD GH )iELiQ 3iO WiMpNR]WDWiVD V]HULQW D V]HUNHV]WEL]RWWViJ ² pSSHQ HOOHQYpOHPpQ\H PLDWW ² QHPIRJDGWDHON|]OpVUH

$V]HUNHV]W tUMD

)RO\yLUDWXQNV]iPiEDQ67$&+Ï/È6=/ÏLVPHUWHWpVpEHQ D ODSRQ VDMWyKLED PDUDGW D Ä&KLFKDJR´ QpY KHO\HVHQ WHUPpV]HWHVHQ Ä&KLFDJR´ $ V]HU]D NRUUHNW~UDXWROVyIRUGXOyMiWQHPOiWKDWWDH]pUWDQ\RPGDLEHJpSHOpVNRUNHOHWNH]HWWKLEDMDYtWiViUD QHPYROWPyGMD(]~WRQNpUMNV]tYHVHOQp]pVpW

)XWDN\,VWYiQtUMD

$0DJ\DU1\HOYHOVV]iPiEDQ%$/2*+/$-26PHJHPOpNH ]pVHROYDVKDWyDRNWyEHUpQHOKXQ\W3HQDYLQ2OJiUyO²$N|]OHPpQ\HOVVRUEDQ D]~MYLGpNLHJ\HWHPYROWSURIHVV]RUiQDNpOHWP&YpWPpOWDWMDGHNLWpUSiO\DIXWiViQDNIEEiOORPi VDLUDLV$QHNUROyJH]XWyEELUpV]pEHQ3HQDYLQ2OJDIHONpV]OpVpQHNHJ\G|QWMHOHQWVpJ&iOOR PiVD²KDEiUWXGRWWWpQ\²HPOtWHWOHQOPDUDGQHYH]HWHVHQD]KRJ\HJ\HWHPLWDQiULNLQHYH]p VpWD*|WWLQJHQEHQPHJV]HU]HWWGRNWRUiWXVDWHWWHOHKHWYpY|'202.263e7(5V]HUN)LQQXJRU pOHWUDM]LOH[LNRQ%S3HQDYLQJ|WWLQJDLOHYHOHLWLVPHUYHPyGRPEDQiOONLHJpV]tWOHJ HGRNWRUUiYiOiVW|UWpQHWpUOU|YLGHQPHJHPOpNH]QLDPLHJ\EHQD]WLVSpOGi]]DKRJ\PHQQ\LUH D YLOiJSROLWLND IJJYpQ\H YROW D] |WYHQHV pYHN PDJ\DU Q\HOYWXGRPiQ\iQDN NOI|OGL NDSFVRODW UHQGV]HUHLV

3HQDYLQ 2OJD D] ~MYLGpNL 7DQiUNpS] )LVNROD PDJ\DUQ\HOYpV] RNWDWyMD WHUYH]HWW SURPyFLyMD J\pEHQ YpJpQ NDSFVRODWED NHUOW )DUNDV *\XOiYDO -XOLXV YRQ )DUNDVVDO D J|WWLQJDL*HRUJ$XJXVW(J\HWHP)LQQXJRU6]HPLQiULXPiQDNSURIHVV]RUiYDOPLYHO²PLQWtUWD

² D] DNNRUL YLV]RQ\RN N|]|WW QHP YROW OHKHWVpJH D GRNWRUL IRNR]DWRW D NLOiWiVED KHO\H]HWW HJ\HWHPL NDUULHU HOIHOWpWHOpW 0DJ\DURUV]iJRQ PHJV]HUH]QL )DUNDV SURIHVV]RU HOYiOODOWD D QHNL V]iQWV]HUHSHWLUiQ\tWiVDDODWWD]LGHLJOHQHVHQ*|WWLQJHQEHWHOHSOWWDQiUQPHJtUWDVHOHMpQ PHJYpGWHDÄ'LH 6SUDFKH GHU XQJDULVFKHQ %HY|ONHUXQJ GHU %DWVFKND -XJRVODZLHQ´ FtP&

ROGDO WHUMHGHOP& GLVV]HUWiFLyMiW pV ILQQXJRU YDODPLQW V]OiY V]DNRQ VLNHUHV V]yEHOL YL]VJiW WHWW )DUNDV*\XODVHJtWV]HUHSHH]]HOPpJQHPV]&QWPHJD]~MYLGpNLHJ\HWHPUHNWRUDMDQXiU MiEDQ3HQDYLQWDQV]pNLSiO\i]DWiQDNHOEtUiOiVDNDSFViQV]DNYpOHPpQ\WNpUWpVNDSRWWWOHDPLQHN HUHGPpQ\HDILVNRODLWDQiUQHJ\HWHPLWDQiULNLQHYH]pVHOHWW$]~MSURIHVV]RUDVV]RQ\M~

OLXVMpQNHOWOHYHOpEHQN|V]|QWHPHJDWiPRJDWiVWÄ9pJUHPHJW|UWpQWDYiODV]WiV1DJ\RQV]p SHQN|V]|Q|PPpJHJ\V]HU3URIHVV]RU~UUyODPDGRWWNHGYH]YpOHPpQ\pW,J\HNV]HPPDMGPHJ IHOHOQLDYpOHPpQ\QHN´3HQDYLQ2OJDKRVV]DQWDUWyJD]GDJWXGRPiQ\RVP&N|GpVVHOEL]RQ\tWRWWD EHKRJ\ÄPHJIHOHOW´J|WWLQJDLSURIHVV]RUDVPiVRNEHOpMHYHWHWWEL]DOPiQDN$OHYHOHNSHGLJÒM YLGpNpV*|WWLQJDN|]|WW)DUNDV*\XODM~OLXViEDQEHN|YHWNH]HWWKDOiOiLJVWPpJD]XWiQLV M|WWHNPHQWHN

/HYpOV]HNUpQ\

9DUJD=VROWtUMD

$] DQ\DJL YLOiJ WOQN IJJHWOHQ YDOyViJ gU|N PHJPiVtWKDWDWODQ W|UYpQ\HLQHNPHJVpUWpVppUWQDJ\iUDWNHOOIL]HWQQN+LiEDDNDUSpOGiXOYDODNLÄOHEHJQL´KDNLXJ ULNDVRNDGLNHPHOHWUOEL]RQ\RVDQ|VV]H]~]]DPDJiW0iVLNSpOGDPLYHOVRNYHJ\V]HUWPpUJHW J\iUWRWWXQNpVV]yUWXQNV]pWQHPLKDWXQNLPPiUN|]YHWOHQODQHPUpJHQPpJWLV]WDpOYL]HNEO KDQHPFVDND]HJ\UHGUiJiEEYH]HWpNHVYDJ\SDODFNR]RWWYt]EO+DVRQOyDKHO\]HWDQ\HOYHVHWp EHQ LV 0LQGHQ Q\HOY HJ\HJ\ NO|Q YLOiJ PHJYDQ D VDMiW EHOV UHQGMH JRQGRONRGiVPyGMD ÄOHONLYLOiJD´PHOO\HOVHPDN|]Q\HOYQHNVHPDV]DNQ\HOYHNQHNQHPV]DEDGHOOHQWpWEHNHUOQLN

$]DQJROV]|YHJHNEHQDV]DYDNVRNV]RUHJ\V]HU&HQHJ\PiVPHOOptUYDMHOHQQHNPHJDPD J\DUEDQD]RQEDQpUWHOPHWOHQV]yKDOPD]WHUHGPpQ\H]KHWDUDJWDODQV]DYDNHJ\PiVPHOOpKiQ\iVD ÄRUV]iJJ\&OpVLNpSYLVHOYiODV]WiV´Ä8()$NXSDG|QW´Ä'e0È6=UpV]YpQ\FVHUH´ÄJpSMiUP&

HUHGHWLVpJYL]VJiODW´ÄiOODPWLWNiUKHO\HWWHV´VWE8J\DQDNNRUQ\LOYiQYDOyDQQHPOHKHWFpODPpU WpNWHOHQHJ\EHtUiVN|WMHOH]pVVHP.|WMHOH]pVNRUQDJ\RQNHOOJ\HOQQNDUUDKRJ\PLWtUXQN NO|QPLWHJ\EHpVKRYiWHVV]NDN|WMHOHW*\|NHUHVHQPiVWMHOHQWSpOGiXOD]DQJROWDQiU¶DQ JROQHP]HWLVpJ&WDQiU¶pVD]DQJROWDQiU¶D]DQJROQ\HOYpVLURGDORPWDQiUD¶ DNXW\D YHQGpJ

¶URVV] YHQGpJ¶ pV DNXW\DYHQGpJ ¶D YHQGpJVpJEH pUNH] NXW\D¶ D]RV]iJJ\&OpVL NpSYLVHO YiODV]WiV¶D]2UV]iJJ\&OpVEHQIRO\yNpSYLVHOYiODV]WiV¶pVD]RUV]iJJ\&OpVLNpSYLVHOYiODV]WiV

¶D]RUV]iJJ\&OpVLNpSYLVHONYiODV]WiVD¶D]8()$NXSDG|QW¶D]8()$iOWDOV]HUYH]HWWNXSD G|QWMH¶pVD]8()$NXSDG|QW¶D]8()$NXSDG|QWMHD'e0È6=UpV]YpQ\FVHUH¶D'e0È6=

V]HUYH]pVpEHQ IRO\y UpV]YpQ\FVHUH¶ pV D'e0È6=UpV]YpQ\FVHUH ¶D 'e0È6= UpV]YpQ\HLQHN FVHUpMH¶VWE

6RNNDOFpOV]HU&EEWHKiWKDDV]y|VV]HWpWHOHUOWHWpVHKHO\HWWHJ\V]HU&HQOHtUMXND]WDPLW PRQGDQL DNDUXQN 3pOGiLQN HVHWpEHQD] 2UV]iJJ\&OpVEHQ IRO\y NpSYLVHOYiODV]WiV YDJ\D] RU V]iJJ\&OpVL NpSYLVHON YiODV]WiVD D] 8()$ iOWDO V]HUYH]HWW NXSD G|QWMH YDJ\D] 8()$NXSD G|QWMH D 'e0È6= V]HUYH]pVpEHQ IRO\y UpV]YpQ\FVHUH YDJ\D 'e0È6= UpV]YpQ\HLQHN FVHUpMH HVHWOHJD'e0È6=UpV]YpQ\HNFVHUpMH$Q\HUHVpJiWWHNLQWKHWEEHOVKDOOiVUDLVN|QQ\HQpUW KHWV]|YHJ$]HJ\V]HU&NLIHMH]pVHNKHO\HVOHtUiViKR]HOHJHQGD]HOHPLQ\HOYWXGiVQLQFVV]N VpJDUUDKRJ\PLQGXQWDODQVHJpGN|Q\YHNHWV]DEiO\]DWRNDWIRUJDVVXQN1pKiQ\V]yYDOWROGD OpNNDO EHW&YHO W|EEHW tUXQN OH H]W D YHV]WHVpJHW D]RQEDQ YLVV]DQ\HUKHWMN D KRVV]~ ERQ\ROXOW V]y|VV]HWpWHOHN RNR]WD IRJDOPD]iVL QHKp]VpJHN NLNV]|E|OpVpYHO $] HUHGPpQ\ QRKD W|EE V]yW KDV]QiOXQNV]|YHJQNW|EEQ\LUHQHPFVDNpUWKHWEEKDQHPWDJROWDEELV