$œ A$$œ$#% %0390908,74F8#03/0

6]ypVV]yOiVPDJ\DUi]DWRN

6 = Ï e 6 6 = Ï / È 6 0 $ * < $ 5 È = $ 7 2 .

7HNLQWHWHV.DURNpV5HQGHN

5|YLGtWYH7..pV55(PHJV]yOtWiVVDOLOOHWYHOD WLQHUHGHWLEHQ6WDWXVHW2UGLQHVWLV]WHOWpNKDOOJDWyViJXNDWV]i]DGRNRQiWDUHQGLRUV]iJJ\&OpVHN pVDPHJ\HLN|]J\&OpVHNV]yQRNDL

$VWDWXVHWRUGLQHVDGHNUpWXPDLQNEDQyWDIRO\DPDWRVDQKDV]QiOWDUFKLHSLVFRSLHSLV FRSLWOSUHODWLEDURQHVSURFHUHVHWYDJ\DFQRELOHV pUVHNHNSVS|N|NWOI SDSRNEiUyNHONHONpVQHPHVHNIRUPXODY|8UNXQGHQEXFK]XU*HVFKLFKHGHU'HXWVFKHQLQ 6LHEHQEUJHQ+HUPDQQVWDGW&RUS-XUWDUWDOPLODJSRQWRVPHJIHOHOMHXJ\DQD]

PiVV]DYDNNDO7|UYpQ\HLQNEHQWHUPpV]HWHVHQQHPHO]PpQ\HNQpONO,,8OiV]OypYLQH J\HGLNGHNUpWXPiEDQRUGLQHVHWVWDWXVV]HUNH]HWEHQW&QLNIHOHOV]|U$YRQDWNR]yV]|YHJUpV]EO D]RQEDQQHPGHUONLKRJ\N|]HOHEEUONLNDNDURNNLNDUHQGHNOHKHWD]pUWPHUWH]WDNRUWiUVDN UpV]OHWH]pVQpONOLVWXGWiNFVXSiQD]YLOiJRVKRJ\H]LVD]LVUpJLpV|U|N|VV]DEDGViJEDQpO FVRSRUWUpWHJWXODMGRQNpSSHQUHQGÄHWXQXPTXHPTXHRUGLQHPHWVWDWXPLQDQWLTXDVHPSLWHUQDTXH OLEHUWDWHFRQVHUYDUHSRVVXPXV´D]D]ÄpVPLQGHQHJ\HVUHQGHWpVNDUWUpJLpV|U|N|VV]DEDGViJ EDQWDUWKDVVXQN´&RUS-XU

+DV]QiODWDD]HUHGHWLWLSUDHODWLEDURQHVSURFHUHVHWQRELOHVIRUPiYDO|VV]HNDSFVROYD 0RKiFVXWiQWHUMHGWHOpVKRORUGLQHVHWVWDWXVKROVWDWXVHWRUGLQHVVRUUHQGEHQD]HWKHO\HWWRO\

NRUD]DWTXH>&RUS-XU@J\DNUDEEDQD]DF>&RUS-XU VWE@N|WV]yYDOPtJYpJUHWyO²HJ\NpWHVHWWOHOWHNLQWYH²DVWDWXV HW RUGLQHV IRUPD YpJOHJHVOW yWD D] DODSIRUPiEDQSURFHUHV KHO\HWWPDJQDWHVW tUWDN ÄGRPLQL SUDHODWL EDURQHV PDJQDWHV QRELOHV FHWHULTXH RUGLQHV DF VWDWXV´ WHKiW ÄISDS EiUy PiJQiVXUDNQHPHVHNpVDW|EELUHQGHNpVNDURN´&RUS-XU(OWHNLQWYHH]~WWDODUpV]OHWHN WO U|YLGHQ FVXSiQ XWDOXQN Ui KRJ\ W|UYpQ\HLQN N|YHWNH]HWHVHQ NLHPHOLN D] RUV]iJJ\&OpVHQ PHJMHOHQWHNHWLQFRQYHQWXFRQJUHJDWLHONO|QtWLNDW|EELWOFHWHULVWDWXVHWRUGLQHVWHKiWD]RNWyO DNLNWiYROPDUDGWDNQHPYHWWHNUpV]WD]RUV]iJJ\&OpVPXQNiMiEDQ$VWDWXVHWRUGLQHVtJ\NHWWV pUWHOPHWQ\HUW-HOHQWHWWHiOWDOiEDQDNDURNDWpVUHQGHNHWPiVIHOONRQNUpWDQD]RNDWDFVRSRUWRNDW DPHO\HNMHOHQYROWDNpVPHJDONRWWiNDW|UYpQ\HNHW

(]~WWDOVHPpUGHNWHOHQHPOpNH]WHWQLKRJ\DVWDWXVpVRUGRKD]DLODWLQViJXQNOHJUpJLEEUpWH JpKH]WDUWR]QDN$VWDWXVWD]HJ\Ki]]DONDSFVRODWEDQUHQGpUWHOHPEHQPiUD],QWHOPHNLVKDV]QiO MDD'HFRQWLQHQGRHFFOHVLDVWLFRVWDWX $]HJ\Ki]LUHQGPHJV]LOiUGtWiViUyO65+IHMH ]HWFtPEHQ7|UYpQ\HLQNEHQJ\DNUDEEDQ.iURO\5yEHUWpYLGHNUpWXPDDÄFXQFWLUHJQLQRVWUL EDURQHVHWQRELOHVDOLLTXHFXMXVYLVVWDWXVKRPLQHV´ ÄRUV]iJXQN|VV]HVEiUyLpVQHPHVHLpVEiU PHO\iOOiV~HPEHUHL´ &RUS-XU ² yWD WDOiONR]XQN YHOH 7|UYpQ\HLQN D]HOWW D] iOODSRW MRJiOOiVWiUVDGDOPLKHO\]HWNLIHMH]pVpUHDFRQGLFLR KHO\]HWN|UOPpQ\iOODSRWVRUVVWEV]yW KDV]QiOMiN,VWYiQ,,=È92'6=.<$UDQ\EXOODPHJ~MtWiVD.1$8=1È1'25,,(QGUH V]DEDGViJOHYHOHL3HVW$WRYiEELDNEDQ|VV]HNDSFVROWiNDNHWWWpVÄFLXVFXQTXHVWDWXV HWFRQGLFLRQLVKRPLQHV´ ÄEiUPHO\iOOiV~pVVRUV~HPEHUHN´DODNEDQ~MIRUPXOiWKR]WDNOpWUH PHOO\HO PLQW MyO EHYiOW pV V]tYHVHQ KDV]QiOW IRUGXODWWDO VRNV]RU WDOiONR]XQN W|UYpQ\HLQNEHQ

&RUS-XUVWE

.DURNpUWHOHPEHQ,,8OiV]OyIHQWHEEPiUKLYDWNR]RWWGHNUpWXPiEDQWDOiOMXNHOV]|UGHLWW PiUD]RUGR UHQGUpWHJFVRSRUWYDOHJ\HWHPEHQPLQWUpJLpV|U|N|VV]DEDGViJQDN|UYHQG FVRSRUWQHYpW

$PLD]RUGRWLOOHWLRUGRSRQWLILFXP ISDSRNUHQGMHLOOHWYHVDFULRUGLQLVYLURV V]HQW UHQGKH]WDUWR]yIpUILDNDWV]HUNH]HWEHQD]Ä,QWHOPHN´EHQPiUV]LQWpQPHJWDOiOKDWy65+

²RUGRFOHULFDOLV SDSLUHQG|VV]HWpWHOEHQ/iV]OyPiVRGLNQDNPRQGRWWN|UONH OHWNH]HWWW|UYpQ\N|Q\YpEHQ/iV]Oy,,=È92'6=.<$V]DEROFVLPDMGD.iOPiQLGHMpQ WDUWRWWHV]WHUJRPL]VLQDWN|UOKDWiUR]DWDLEDQW|EEV]|UpVW|EEIpOHpUWHOHPEHQLVUiWDOiOKD

6]ypVV]yOiVPDJ\DUi]DWRN

WXQNRPQHVHFFOHVLDVWLFLRUGLQHV D]|VV]HVHJ\Ki]LUHQGHNpVRUGRHFFOHVLDVWLFXV HJ\Ki]L UHQGDODNEDQLVV]DEROFVL]VLQDWHV]WHUJRPL]VLQDW=È92'6=.<

EDQ D] HJ\Ki]LDNRQ NtYORUGLQXP DOLRUXP D]D] PiV UHQGHQ OpYNHW LV HPOtWHQHN KtYMDIHOHUUHPLQWQHPOpQ\HJWHOHQPR]]DQDWUDDILJ\HOPHW*(5,&6-Ï=6()$NRUDLUHQGLVpJ(X UySiEDQpV0DJ\DURUV]iJRQ%S7|UYpQ\HLQNEHQLJD]iEDQV]LQWpQFVDN0RKiFVXWiQ M|WWGLYDWED$W|UYpQ\HNHWWONH]GYHD]HJ\HVUHQGHNHWLVQHYN|QQHYH]LNSORUGRGRPLQRUXP SUDHODWRUXP ISDSXUDNUHQGMHRUGREDURQXP EiUyNUHQGMHRUGRGRPLQRUXP XUDNWL EiUyNPiJQiVRNUHQGMHYpJORUGRQRELOLXP QHPHVHNUHQGMH&RUS-XU

1HPKDJ\KDWMXNHPOtWHWOHQKRJ\DNDURNpVUHQGHNQHNNpWILJ\HOHPUHpUGHPHVSDUDIUi]LViW LVWDOiOQL-DJHOOyNRULpVNpVEELW|UYpQ\HLQNEHQ$]HJ\LNDGRPLQLHWYDJ\DFUHJQLFRODH XUDN pV RUV]iJODNRVRN &RUS-XU VWE D PiVLN DGRPLQL HW YDJ\DF QRELOHV XUDNpVQHPHVHNIRUPXOD&RUS-XUVWE

$]HOEELDW|UYpQ\HNEHQVRNV]RUHOIRUGXOyGRPLQLSUDHODWLEDURQHVDFHWUHJQLFRODH ISDS XUDNEiUyNpVRUV]iJODNRVRN&RUS-XUVWEDPiVLNDGRPLQL SUDHODWLEDURQHVDFHWQRELOHV ISDSXUDNEiUyNpVQHPHVHN&RUS-XU VWEHJ\V]HU&U|YLGYiOWR]DWD

$] LGp]HWW pV PiV H KHO\HQ QHP LGp]HWW IRUPXOiNDW pV D]RN SDUDIUi]LVDLW WDQXOPiQ\R]YD HOpJJp HJ\pUWHOP& KRJ\ D]RUGR pV DGRPLQXV V]DYDN FVDNQHP PLQGLJ D ISDS EiUy PiJQiV HONHO PHJMHO|OpVKH] WiUVXOQDN pV tJ\ NLPRQGDWODQXO D]D] WpWHOHV D]RQRVtWiV QpONO LV D]W D PHJJ\]GpVWWiPDV]WMiNDOiKRJ\DUHQGHNHOQHYH]pVW|UYpQ\HLQNEHQDWDQXOPiQ\R]RWWV]HUNH ]HWHVHWpQPLQGLJDISDSRNDWEiUyNDWPiJQiVRNDWHONHONHWMHOHQWL$IHQWHEEPiULGp]HWW RUGRGRPLQRUXPPHOOHWWNpWVpJHWNL]iUyDQWDQ~VNRGLNHUUODÄGRPLQLXWULXVTXHRUGLQLVHWQRELOHV FRORQRVKDEHQWHV´ ÄDPLQGNpWUHQGHQOHYXUDNQDNpVMREEiJ\RVQHPHVHNQHN´V]|YHJUpV]D]

pYLGHNUpWXPW|UYpQ\pEHQ&RUS-XUDPHO\HJ\V]HUVPLQGD]WLVHOpJJpHJ\pUWHO P&HQPXWDWMDKRJ\NRPRO\WpQ\H]QHNLJD]iEDQDMREEiJ\RVD]D]DELUWRNRVQHPHVHNHWWHNLQWHW WpN(]]HOHJ\WWD]LVWHOMHVHQYLOiJRVKRJ\NDURNQDNDQHPHVHNHWLOOHWYHD]RUV]iJODNRVRNDWLGH pUWYHDV]DEDGNLUiO\LYiURVRNRUV]iJJ\&OpVHNHQPHJMHOHQNOG|WWHLWQHYH]WpN$UHJQLFRODHa RUV]iJODNRVRNQpYW|UYpQ\HLQNEHQNH]GHWEHQDQHPHVVpJHWMHOHQWLHQQpOWiJDEEpUWHOHPEHQDQH PHVHNHWpVDV]DEDGNLUiO\LYiURVRNSROJiUViJiWOHJWiJDEEpUWHOHPEHQSHGLJPLQGHQNLYiOWViJRV HOHPHWWHKiWDSVS|N|NHWPiJQiVRNDWQHPHVHNHWpVDV]DEDGYiURVRNSROJiUDLW(UHGHWLMHOHQWp VpWD]RQEDQPLQGYpJLJPHJWDUWRWWD

$UpV]OHWHNHWLOOHWHQDNRUWiUVDNHOWWVHOHKHWHWWPLQGHQYLOiJRVpVWLV]WD,QQHQYROWKRJ\

EDQDNRURQi]iVXWiQ HOVWHHQGMNQHN WHNLQWHWWpN D] RUV]iJJ\&OpV UHQGHL KRJ\ W|UYpQ\W DONRVVDQDNDUUDQp]YHKRJ\NLNDNDURNpVNLNDUHQGHN1HKp]VpJHNV]iUPD]WDNXJ\DQLVDEEyO

²PRQGMDDV]yEDQIRUJyW|UYpQ\²KRJ\QHPYROWPHJIHOHOHQWLV]Wi]YDNLNHWNHOOD]RUV]iJ NDUDLQDNpVUHQGHLQHNHOQHYH]pVpQpUWHQLËJ\V]OHWHWWPHJDKtUQHYHVpVVRNDWLGp]HWWpYL NRURQi]iVXWiQLHOVW|UYpQ\

$]RUV]iJJ\&OpV|VV]HWpWHOpUOUHQGMpUO|VV]HKtYiViUyOpVDV]DYD]DWLMRJUyODONRWRWWPpO WiQKtUHVW|UYpQ\PHO\HWWHOMHVMRJJDOWHNLQWKHWQNDNiUDPDJ\DUUHQGLIHMOGpV]iUyN|YpQHNLV WHUPpV]HWHVHQQHPRO\DQPLQWKDDORJLNDQDJ\PHVWHUHLYDJ\DIRJDORPDONRWiVWXGRUDLtUWiNYRO QDD]LWWYL]VJiOWNpUGpVEHQPpJLVSRQWRVQDNPRQGKDWyHOLJD]tWiVWDG

.LPRQGMDKRJ\Ä0DJ\DURUV]iJNDUDLpVUHQGHLQpJ\IpOHiOODSRW~RUV]iJODNyNpUWVGNLYiOW ViJRVRN².6QHYH]HWHVHQDISDSRNEiUyNYDJ\PiJQiVRNQHPHVHNpVDV]DEDGYiURVRNWL H]HNSROJiUMRJJDOUHQGHONH]ODNRVDL².6N|]ONHUOWHNNL´$WRYiEELDNEDQD]RUV]iJJ\&

OpVUpV]WYHYLWNpWIFVRSRUWUDRV]WMDDISDSpVEiUyXUDNJ\OHNH]HWpUHpVD] RUV]iJODNRVRNUD UHJQLFRODH$]HOVWDODWLQV]|YHJEHQFRQYHQWXVLOOHWYHFRHWXVHWFRQYHQWXVSUDHODWRUXPED URQXP HW PDJQDWXPQDN > ISDSRN EiUyN pV PiJQiVRN J\&OpVH J\OHNH]HWH pV WHVWOHWpQHN@

tUMDDKRODSVS|N|NQHNWRYiEEiD]|VV]HVEiUyQDNpVPiJQiVQDNVDMiWKHO\HpVV]DYD]DWDYDQ$]

6]ypVV]yOiVPDJ\DUi]DWRN LGHWDUWR]yNWHKiWHOYLOHJpVJ\DNRUODWLODJWHOMHVV]iPEDQPLQWDNpWUHQGHJpV]HM|KHWQHND]RU V]iJJ\&OpVUHtJ\N|YHWNH]pVNpSSHQDNDURNpVUHQGHNNLIHMH]pVEHQNHWLOOHWLDUHQGHNHOQHYH]pV QHPYpOHWOHQKRJ\DW|UYpQ\EHQD]RUGRQpYLVRUGLQHPPDJQDWXPDODNEDQYHON|VV]HIJJpV EHQ NHUO HO $]RUV]iJODNRVRN PHO\ LWW LQNiEE V]&NHEE pUWHOHPEHQ V]HUHSHO pV YDOyV]tQ&OHJ D MREEiJ\RV QHPHVHNHW MHOHQWL FVDNLV DNDURN QpYYHO pUWHOPH]KHW pV HOVVRUEDQ D YiUPHJ\HL NOG|WWHNUHXWDOWRYiEEiSRQWRVDQPHJQHYH]HWWHJ\Ki]LPpOWyViJRNDWpVD]pYLGHNUpWXP ,,, W|UYpQ\pEHQ IHOVRUROW V]DEDG NLUiO\L YiURVRN %XGD 3HVW .DVVD 3R]VRQ\ 1DJ\V]RPEDW

%iUWID(SHUMHV6RSURQNOG|WWHLWIRJODOMDPDJiEDgVV]HJH]YHWHKiWNDURNDYiUPHJ\pNN|YH WHLDYHONOpVH]SRQWRVDQIHOVRUROWpVPHJQHYH]HWWHJ\Ki]LPpOWyViJRNV]DEDGNLUiO\LYiURVRN NOG|WWHLUHQGHNSVS|N|NpVEiUyNLOOHWYHPiJQiVRN

3RQWRVDQ WiPDV]WMD DOi D IHQWL pUWHOPH]pVW .|OFVH\ PiU NLIRUURWW YLV]RQ\RNDW WNU|]RU V]iJJ\&OpVLQDSOyMDLVIHEUXiUiQSpOGiXOH]WMHJ\]LIHOÄ$PDLQDSHJ\LNHYDODDOHJ IRQWRVDEEDNQDN0HUWDIUHQGHNDPDJ\DUQ\HOYJ\HD.DURNSHGLJDYDOOiVLWiUJ\IHOHWWWDQiFV NR]WDN´PiUFLXVpQSHGLJÄ$0pOWyViJRVRNRUV]iJRVOpVWWDUWDQDNVV]tY|NIiMGDOPiEDQ D.DURNpUWHOPpKH]N|]HOHGQHN´.|OFVH\)HUHQF2UV]iJJ\&OpVL1DSOy9iORJDWRWWP&YHL%S DNLHPHOpVHND]pQNLHPHOpVHLP².6$QDSOyHJ\pEKHO\HLQLVYLOiJRVDQpV HJ\pUWHOP&HQDIHQWLpUWHOHPEHQNO|QOQHNHODNDURNDUHQGHNWOPHO\XWyEELDNDWYiOWDNR]YDQH YH]LIUHQGHNQHNIWiEOiQDNPpOWyViJRVRNQDNXR

$PiUFLXVLIRUUDGDORPXWiQDIHXGiOLVYLOiJW|EEPiVNHOOpNpYHOpVGtV]OHWpYHODNDURNpV UHQGHNLVNLPHQWDGLYDWEyO.RVVXWKPiUFLXVpQD]RUV]iJJ\&OpVQ\LOYiQRVViJDHOWWMH OHQWHWWHNLKRJ\QHPpOW|EEpH]]HODPHJV]yOtWiVVDOÄ0HUWKDD]HJpV]QHP]HWNpSYLVHOLYD J\XQNQHPOHKHWQNUHQGHNW|EEp´.RVVXWK/DMRVEHV]pGHLpVtUiVDL,%SpQ

.È9È66<6È1'25

2ODV]

(]DQpSQpYKDQHPLVW~OJ\DNUDQGHHOIRUGXO0DJ\DURUV]iJRQYH]HWpNQpYNpQW 6]DEROFV6]DWPiU%HUHJ PHJ\pEHQ D] DOiEEL KHO\VpJHNEHQ pOQHN2ODV] YH]HWpNQHY& HPEHUHN .LVOpWD0iWpV]DOND1\tUHJ\Ki]D1\tUPLKiO\GL1\tUSD]RQ\J\DNRUL6]DNRO\pV7LV]DYDVYiUL 7XGRPiVRPV]HULQWPpJD%RUVRG$ED~M=HPSOpQPHJ\HL%RUVRGLYiQNiQJ\DNRULQpY².È=

0e50,./Ï6D7(6]DODSMiQDGMDPHJDMHOHQWpVW¶Q\XJDWL~MODWLQQ\HOYHWEHV]pOHPEHU LWiOLDL HPEHU¶ 5pJL PDJ\DU FVDOiGQHYHN V]yWiUD ;,9²;9,, V]i]DG %S ² $]

(:8QJ PiU SRQWRVDEE ¶ QHRODWHLQLVFK LWDOLHQLVFK¶ pV D PDJ\DUi]DWEDQ PHJMHJ\]L KRJ\DV]HUEKRUYiWEDQpVDV]ORYpQEHQDYODFKYODVL3OV]yQDNYDQYROW¶5XPlQH¶MHOHQWpVH LV(]PDJ\DURUV]iJLDGDWRNNDOLVLJD]ROKDWy²%e/$<9,/026Ä0iUDPDURVPHJ\HWiUVDGDOPDpV QHP]HWLVpJHL $ PHJ\H EHWHOHSOpVpWO D ;9,,, V]i]DG HOHMpLJ´ %S FtP&PXQNiMiEDQ NpWVpJWHOHQOD]2OiKFVDOiGQpYD]iOWDOiQRVpVLWWpVHNNRUDQpYYLVHOYDOyEDQURPiQYROWYDJ\

URPiQV|NUHPHQWYLVV]DKDD]LOOHWPDJ\DUQpPHWYDJ\UXV]LQYROW8JO\DDGDWWiUiEDQLP

²D]RQEDQPiVHOQHYH]pVHNUHLVDNDGWDP*U:ROR]I6WDQ9RORV]I6WDQ 2OD]NHUHV]WQpYQpONO6W:OD]:ROD]-R:ROD]7R9RO\R]

7:ROD] 7R:ROR] )U9ROD] $OH[9ROD] $ QpY PpJ HOIRUGXO ,]iQ LV 2ODV]'HPMHQLPËJ\WHKiW0iUDPDURVEDQD]RODV]V]yQDN¶URPiQ¶MHOHQWpVHLVOH KHWHWWVFVDNNpVEEYiOWYpJOHJHVVpMHOHQWpVYHV]WpVVHOD]¶LWiOLDLWDOMiQ¶MHOHQWpV.LMHOHQWKHWMN WHKiW KRJ\ D] eV]DNNHOHW0DJ\DURUV]iJRQ pO2ODV] YH]HWpNQHY&HNVHL QHP IHOWpWOHQO LWiOLDL V]iUPD]iV~DNKDQHPDURPiQHUHGHWLVV]yEDM|KHW

( IHOYHWpV D]RQEDQ WRYiEEL QpY pV KDQJW|UWpQHWL PHJHUVtWpVW NtYiQ $] HUHGHWL9ODFK FVDN 1DJ\ERFVNyUyODGDWROKDWyDWRYiEENpS]HWW DODNRN J\DNRULEEDN9ODVLQ a 9ODV]LQ $NQDUDKy

%HG0RMV]pQ5XV]NRYD9RORVLQa9RORV]LQ.ULFVIDOYD