9t]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNPRGHOOH]pVHDWDODMEDQ WpULQIRUPDWLNDLPyGV]HUUHO
0HQNy0
-iV]1DJ\NXQ6]ROQRNPHJ\HL1|YpQ\pV7DODMYpGHOPL6]ROJiODW7pULQIRUPDWLNDL/DERUDWyULXP6]ROQRN9t]SDUWNUW
g66=()2*/$/È6
$ WpULQIRUPDWLND OHKHW VpJHLW IHOKDV]QiOYD D Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRN PRGHOOH]pVpW NtYiQWDP PHJYDOyVtWDQL $ PyGV]HU NLSUyEiOiViW HJ\ OLQHiU UHQGV]HU |QW|] WHOHSQHN EHUHQGH]HWW KHNWiURV WiEOiQ YpJH]WHP HO $ YL]VJiOW WiEOD .XQFVRUED NOWHUOHWpQ KHO\H]NHGLNHO$*,6HV]N|]UHQGV]HUHOHKHW VpJHWEL]WRVtWDYL]VJiOWPLQWDKHO\HNV]iPROW YDJ\PpUWSiUROJiVpVSiURORJWDWiVpUWpNHLQHND]HJpV]WiEOiUDW|UWpQ NLWHUMHV]WpVpUH ËJ\ D] pULQWHWW WHUOHWHQ MHOOHP] KHO\HNHQ IHOYHWW DGDWRN PHJIHOHO LQWHUSROiOiViYDO D YL]VJiOWWiEOiUyOWHOMHVHJpV]pEHQHJ\DGDWEi]LViOOUHQGHONH]pVQNUHDPHO\D]HOHP]pVHN DODSMiXOV]ROJiOKDWQDN$IHODGDWHOYpJ]pVpKH]V]NVpJHVDWDODMYt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVDLQDN RO\DQ LG VRURV DGDWEi]LViQDN OpWUHKR]iVD DPHO\ DONDOPDV D *,6 DGWD IHOGROJR]iVL OHKHW VpJHNUH$FpORPD]YROWKRJ\D]pULQWHWWWiEOiQPHJMHOHQtWKHW HNOHJ\HQHNDWDODM NLV]iUDGiVL IHOW|OW GpVL IRO\DPDWDL D WHQ\pV]LG V]DN IRO\DPiQ *\RUV HOHP]pVHNHW OHKHVVHQHOYpJH]QLNO|QE|] |QW|] Yt]Gy]LVRNWHUYH]pVpYHO0LO\HQYiOWR]iVRNDWOHKHW HOpUQL Yt]SyWOiVVDO LOOHWYH DQQDN LG EHQL WDUWDPKDWiViW YL]VJiOQL 8J\DQFVDN HOHPH]QL OHKHW D NLV]iUDGiVL IHOW|OW GpVL IRO\DPDWRNDW ± DV]iO\pU]pNHQ\VpJ ± PHJiOODStWiVD D WHUOHWNO|QE|] UpV]HLQ $ YL]VJiODWL HUHGPpQ\HN pV D]RN pUWpNHOpV VRUiQ D NXNRULFD WHQ\pV]LGHMpW iSULOLVWyO RNWyEHU YpJpLJ GHNiGUD IHORV]WYD YL]VJiOWDP $ Yt]NpV]OHW YiOWR]iVRNDW PHJMHOHQtWYH PHJiOODStWKDWy YROW KRJ\ D] DGRWW PHWHRUROyJLDL DGDWRN PHOOHWWDWDODMEDQDYt]NpV]OHWQ\iUN|]HSpUHYiOLNNULWLNXVVi$WDODMEDQDOHJNHYHVHEED KDV]QRVtWKDWy Yt]WDUWDORP DXJXV]WXV PiVRGLN IHOpEHQ $ WHQ\pV]LG V]DN YpJpLJ D WDODM QHGYHVVpJWDUWDOPDFVDNNLVPpUWpNEHQQ|YHNV]LN0HJiOODStWKDWyPHO\HNDYL]VJiOWWiEOD MREEpVJ\HQJpEEYt]JD]GiONRGiV~UpV]HLgQW|]pVKDWiViUDPHJILJ\HOKHW KRJ\DWDODM Yt]NpV]OHWHL KRJ\DQ PyGRVXOQDN $ PRGHOO IHOiOOtWiViKR] PPV Yt]DGDJRNDW WHUYH]WHP D WHQ\pV]LG V]DN IRO\DPiQ (]HN D Yt]DGDJRN D WHQ\pV]LG V]DN D]RQ GHNiGMDLEDQ D OHJV]iUD]DEE Q\iUL LG V]DNEDQ DKRO D KDV]QRVtWKDWy Yt]WDUWDORP D WDODMEDQ DOi FV|NNHQW NHUOWHN NL|QW|]pVUH $] |QW|]pV KDWiViUD D WDODM KDV]QRVtWKDWy Yt]NpV]OHWH D OHJNULWLNXVDEE LG V]DNEDQ LV PPHO PHJKDODGWD D GLV]SRQLELOLV Yt]WDUWDORP iW $ N|YHWNH]WHWpVHN pV MDYDVODWRN UpV]EHQ UiPXWDWWDP KRJ\ D Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRN PRGHOOH]pVH PLO\HQ PyGV]HUEHOL YiOWR]WDWiVRNDW LJpQ\HO D KDJ\RPiQ\RV WDODMWpUNpSH]pVVHO V]HPEHQ $ WpULQIRUPDWLND HV]N|]HLYHO HOHPH]KHW HN W|EEHNN|]|WWHJ\WHUOHWDV]iO\pU]pNHQ\pVEHOYt]YHV]pO\H]WHWHWWUpV]HL$GRWWpJKDMODWL YLV]RQ\RN N|]|WW D WHQ\pV]LG V]DNEDQ PLNRU YiOLN NULWLNXVVi D Yt]KLiQ\ HJ\ DGRWW NXOW~UQ|YpQ\ HVHWpEHQ 0HJWHUYH]KHWQN |QW|]pVL Yt]QRUPiNDW pV |QW|]pVL IRUGXOyNDW DPHOO\HO RSWLPDOL]iOKDWMXN D] |QW|]pVHV JD]GiONRGiVW $ Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRN PRGHOOH]pVH VHJtWVpJpYHO NLDODNtWKDWXQN RO\DQ YHWpVWHUYHW DPHO\ D WDODMRN Yt]JD]GiONRGiVLWXODMGRQViJDLWNHOO HQILJ\HOHPEHYHV]L
.XOFVV]DYDNPRGHOOH]pVYt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVWpULQIRUPDWLND 8QLYHUVLW\RI.DSRVYiU)DFXOW\RI$QLPDO6FLHQFH.DSRVYiU
$%675$&7
0RGHOLQJRIWKHFKDQJHVRIZDWHUUHVRXUFHVE\*,6 00HQNy
-iV]1DJ\NXQ6]ROQRN&RXQW\6HUYLFHIRU3ODQW3URWHFWLRQDQG6RLO&RQVHUYDWLRQ*,6/DERUDWRU\6]ROQRN+9t]SDUWNUW
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
.H\ZRUGVPRGHOLQJFKDQJHVRIZDWHUUHVRXUFHV*,6
%(9(=(7e6
1|YpQ\HLQN pOHWH G|QW HQ NpW N|]HJKH] PpJKR]]i D WDODMKR] DPHO\EHQ J\|NHUHN KHO\H]NHGQHN HO pV D OHYHJ K|] LWW IHMO GLN D ]|OGW|PHJ LOO D WHUPpV N|W GLN $ IHMO GpVNK|] HOHQJHGKHWHWOHQO V]NVpJHV YL]HW FVDN NLV KiQ\DGEDQ WXGMiN OHYHOHLNHQ NHUHV]WODOHYHJ E OIHOYHQQL$Yt]G|QW UpV]pWDJ\|NHUHNiOWDODWDODMEyOYHV]LNIHO
$ WDODMRN Yt]HOOiWRWWViJD QDJ\RQ OpQ\HJHV PHUW KD Q|YpQ\HLQN QHP MXWQDN HOHJHQG Yt]KH]DNNRUODVVXODIHMO GpVNDPHO\HO EEXWyEENLKDWDWHUPpVNpS]pVUH$
KX]DPRVDEELGHLJWDUWyV]iUD]ViJEDQSHGLJHOLVSXV]WXOKDWQDN
$ Yt]QHN PLQGLJ D Q|YpQ\HN UHQGHONH]pVpUH NHOO iOOQLD $ Yt]XWiQSyWOiV W~OQ\RPyDQDFVDSDGpNWyOIJJpVPpJLVD]RQULWNDLG MiUiVLHOHPHNN|]pWDUWR]LNDPL PHVWHUVpJHVHQLVWXGXQNSyWROQL
1HP pUGHNWHOHQ WXGQL KRJ\ PHQQ\L Yt] LV YDQ D WDODMEDQ -y HVHWEHQ WDYDVV]DO D YHJHWiFLy NH]GHWHNRU D WDODMRN D V]iQWyI|OGL Yt]NDSDFLWiV PpUWpNpLJ WHOtWHWWHN DPL D]W MHOHQWLKRJ\DIHOV PHVUpWHJEHQPPQ\LIHOYHKHW Yt]YDQ(]QHPHOpJD WHQ\pV]LG V]DN VRUiQGHKDD]iWODJRV PHQQ\LVpJEHQPPpV My HORV]OiVEDQ pUNH]LNDFVDSDGpNPiUV]LQWHPLQGHQWHUPHV]WHWWQ|YpQ\QNLJpQ\pWNLHOpJtWL
$ WDODMRN IHOV FPHV UpWHJH D J\|NpU]yQD H]pUW H WDODMUpWHJ QHGYHVVpJNpV]OHWpQHNYiOWR]iVDLWHOHPH]]NÈOWDOiEDQKDDIHOYHKHW Yt]NpV]OHW'9 DOiFV|NNHQD]|QW|]pVPHJNH]GKHW DODWWFpOV]HU pVDODWWV]NVpJV]HU
|QW|]QL
$WpPDIHOYHWpVH
+RVV]~pYHNPpUpVLpVNXWDWiVLHUHGPpQ\HLDODSMiQV]iPRVDQNpV]tWHWWHNRO\DQPRGHOOW PHO\QHNVHJtWVpJpYHODWDODMYt]NpV]OHWpQHNLG EHOLYiOWR]iViWILJ\HOHPPHONtVpUKHWMN (]HN D PRGHOOHN iOWDOiEDQ D K PpUVpNOHW OpJQHGYHVVpJ FVDSDGpN YDODPLO\HQ
|VV]HIJJpVpWpVDQ|YpQ\ERUtWRWWViJRWYHV]LNILJ\HOHPEH
$ NO|QE|] PRGHOOHN D IHQWL DGDWRNDW HOHP]LN pV SUyEiOMiN D OHJYDOyV]tQ EE YiOWR]iVRNDWOHtUQL$WiEODV]LQW Yt]NpV]OHWHWiOWDOiEDQDWiEOiNMHOOHP] KHO\HLQW|UWpQ
YL]VJiODWRNPpUpVHNDODSMiQiOODStWMiNPHJLOOHWYHV]iPtWMiNDYiOWR]iVRNDWPLQWHO UH MHOH]YHDQQDNYDOyV]tQ VpJpW
$ 1|YpQ\ pV 7DODMYpGHOPL 6]ROJiODW MRJHO GMpQpO D 0e0 1$. %XGDSHVW LUiQ\tWiVD DODWW NLGROJR]iVUD NHUOW PyGV]HU D] DOiEEL FtPHQ$ Yt]WDNDUpNRV |QW|]pVL V]DNWDQiFVDGiVDWDODMHOOHQ U]pVHpVDQHGYHVVpJPpUpVDODSMiQ
$V]DNWDQiFVDGiVFpOMD
$ WDODMWXODMGRQViJRN LVPHUHWH pV HOOHQ U]pVH PHOOHWW VHJtWVpJHW DGQL D V]DNV]HU pV NiURVtWyKDWiVQpONOLYt]WDNDUpNRV|QW|]pVPHJYDOyVtWiViKR]RO\DQPyGV]HUUHODPHO\HW DJD]GDViJRNPDJXNLVHOYpJH]KHWQHN
$V]DNWDQiFVDGiVPyGV]HUH
$ WDODMWXODMGRQViJRN UpV]OHWHV YL]VJiODWiQ D Q|YpQ\HN Yt] pV OHYHJ LJpQ\pQ D WDODM KHO\V]tQHQPpUWQHGYHVVpJWDUWDOPiQpVDWDODMYt]Ki]WDUWiVLPpUOHJHUHGPpQ\HLQDODSXO GHPDJiEDQIRJODOMDD]|QW|]pVWDODMUDJ\DNRUROWKDWiViQDNHOOHQ U] YL]VJiODWiWLV
$ PyGV]HU D] ± (7 S ( DW $QWDO ± IHOKDV]QiOiViYDO Yt]Ki]WDUWiVL PpUOHJHW V]iPRO NO|QE|] Q|YpQ\IDMRN ILJ\HOHPEHYpWHOpYHO $ODSMiW NpSH]LDYL]VJiOWWiEODWDODMWDQLV]DNYpOHPpQ\HDPHO\DWDODMWDQLDODSYL]VJiODWRNPHOOHWW WDUWDOPD]]DDWDODMYt]JD]GiONRGiVLSDUDPpWHUHLWLV
$ Yt]Ki]WDUWiVL PpUOHJ D] |QW|]pVW PHJDODSR]y WDODMWDQL V]DNYpOHPpQ\HN PHOOpNOHWpYp YiOW GH J\DNRUODWL KDV]QiODWXN VDMQRV QHP MHOHQW V LQNiEE WiMpNR]WDWy MHOOHJJHOEtUQDN
$WpULQIRUPDWLNDPyGV]HUHLOHKHW VpJHWEL]WRVtWDQDNDYL]VJiOWPLQWDKHO\HNV]iPROW YDJ\ PpUW SiUROJiV pV SiURORJWDWiV pUWpNHLQHN D] HJpV] WiEOiUD W|UWpQ NLWHUMHV]WpVpUH ËJ\ D] pULQWHWW WHUOHWHQ MHOOHP] KHO\HNHQ IHOYHWW DGDWRN PHJIHOHO LQWHUSROiOiViYDO D YL]VJiOW WiEOiUyO WHOMHV HJpV]pEHQ HJ\ DGDWEi]LV iOO UHQGHONH]pVQNUH DPHO\ D]
HOHP]pVHNDODSMiXOV]ROJiOKDW
$ IHODGDW HOYpJ]pVpKH] V]NVpJHV D WDODM Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVD RO\DQ LG VRURV DGDWEi]LViQDNOpWUHKR]iVDDPHO\DONDOPDVD*,6DGWDIHOGROJR]iVLOHKHW VpJHNUH
$ V]DNPDL HOYiUiVRN WHOMHVtWpVH pUGHNpEHQ V]NVpJHV D PLQWDYpWHOHN PHJIHOHO PHQQ\LVpJpQHN pV PLQ VpJpQHN PHJKDWiUR]iVD 8J\DQFVDN IRQWRV D *,6 V]RIWYHU OHJPHJIHOHO EELQWHUSROiFLyVUXWLQMiQDNNLYiODV]WiVDDIHODGDWYpJUHKDMWiViKR]
&pORP D] YROW KRJ\ D IHOGROJR]iVRN XWiQ D] pULQWHWW WiEOiQ PHJMHOHQtWKHW HN OHJ\HQHN D WDODM NLV]iUDGiVL IHOW|OW GpVL IRO\DPDWDL D WHQ\pV]LG V]DN IRO\DPiQ *\RUV HOHP]pVHNHW OHKHVVHQ HOYpJH]QL NO|QE|] |QW|] Yt] Gy]LVRN WHUYH]pVpYHO 0LO\HQ YiOWR]iVRNDW OHKHW HOpUQL Yt]SyWOiVVDO LOOHWYH DQQDN LG EHQL WDUWDPKDWiViW YL]VJiOQL 8J\DQFVDN HOHPH]QL OHKHVVHQ D NLV]iUDGiVL IHOW|OW GpVL IRO\DPDWRNDW DV]iO\pU]pNHQ\VpJPHJiOODStWiVDDWHUOHWNO|QE|] UpV]HLQ
$1<$*e60Ï'6=(5
$YL]VJiOWWHUOHWMHOOHP]pVHUHQGHONH]pVUHiOOyDGDWRN
$YL]VJiOWWHUOHW.XQFVRUEDN|]VpJW OpV]DNUDD1DJ\NXQViJL|QW|] I FVDWRUQDPHOOHWW IHNV]LN $WHUOHWOLQHiU|QW|] WHOHSQHN EHUHQGH]HWW KHNWiURV WiEOD )HOV]tQH N|]HO VtNDPDJDVViJLV]LQWNO|QEVpJHNWHQJHUV]LQWIHOHWW±PpWHUN|]|WWYiOWR]QDN
$ YLV]RQ\ODJ VtN WHUHSYLV]RQ\RN HOOHQpUH D WHUOHW WDODMWDNDUyMD PHJOHKHW VHQ YiOWR]DWRViEUD
$ WDODM JHQHWLNDL WtSXViEyO D P YHOW UpWHJ DODWW IHOOpS V]LNHVVpJE O pV D WDODM IL]LNDLIpOHVpJpE ODGyGyDQDWDODMRNYt]NDSDFLWiVDQDJ\QDJ\KROWYt]WDUWDORPPHOOHWW$
KDV]QRVtWKDWyYt]WDUWDORPN|]HSHVDV]LNHVWDODMUpWHJHNEHQDODFVRQ\
$ WHUOHWUH MHOOHP] D W|P G|WWVpJ D WDODM WpUIRJDWV~O\D JFPN|]|WWL $ W|P G|WWVpJHWDPDJDVDJ\DJWDUWDORPDP YHOWUpWHJDODWWLV]LNHVVpJNHGYH] WOHQKDWiVD YDODPLQWDQHPPHJIHOHO P YHOpVPpO\OD]tWiVKLiQ\DRNR]]D
$WDODMYt]YH]HW NpSHVVpJHNLFVLFPQDS
$ WDODMIL]LNDL SDUDPpWHUHN 9.V] +9 '9 DODSYHW HQ EHIRO\iVROMiN D WDODM Yt]Ki]WDUWiViWH]pUWYt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNPRGHOOH]pVpQpOLQSXWDGDWNpQWV]HUHSHOQHN
$ WHUPHV]WHWW Q|YpQ\ IDMWiMD IRQWRV WpQ\H] D Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iViQDN PRGHOOH]pVpQpODWHUOHWHQ$PRGHOOH]pVQpOILJ\HOHPEHNHOOYHQQLDYiODV]WRWWQ|YpQ\
WHQ\pV]LG V]DNiWDYt]LJpQ\pWJ\|NHUH]pVLPpO\VpJpW
$PRGHOOKH]DNXNRULFiWYiODV]WRWWDPPLQWDWHUOHWHQ|QW|]pVVHODOHJJ\DNUDEEDQ WHUPHV]WHWWQ|YpQ\IpOHVpJHW
iEUD
$YL]VJiOWWHUOHWJHQHWLNXVWDODMWpUNpSH
)LJXUH*HQHWLFVRLOPDSRIWKHVWXGLHGDUHD
$IHOGROJR]iVKR]V]NVpJHVKDV]QRVtWKDWyYt]WDUWDORPDGDWEi]LVOpWUHKR]iVD
$Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVPRGHOOH]pVpKH]D]$QWDO6]iV]IpOHYt]Ki]WDUWiVLPpUOHJIHOGROJR ]iViWYiODV]WRWWDP
(O Q\H KRJ\ OHKHW Yp YiOLN D Yt]HOOiWRWWViJ pV SiURORJWDWiV PHJiOODStWiVD DGRWW Q|YpQ\UH YRQDWNR]yDQ DQQDN IHQRIi]LViWyO IJJ HQ ËJ\ D NtYiQW LG SRQWEDQ PHJIHOHO HQ V]iPROKDWy D Yt]HOOiWRWWViJ PpUWpNH D Q|YpQ\HN iOWDO N|QQ\HQ IHOYHKHW QHGYHVVpJPHQQ\LVpJHLOOHWYHDQHGYHVVpJKLiQ\D
)LJ\HOHPEH YHKHW N D WHQ\pV]LG V]DNEDQ OHKXOORWW FVDSDGpN PHOOHWW D] HVHWOHJHV
|QW|]pVLYt]DGDJRNDPHO\HNDYt]Ki]WDUWiVWPyGRVtWMiN
$Yt]Ki]WDUWiVLPpUOHJV]iPtWiViKR]V]NVpJHVDGDWRN
1|YpQ\ $] HJ\HV NXOW~UiN Yt]LJpQ\HVVpJH WHQ\pV]LGHMH J\|NHUH]pVL PpO\VpJH HOWpU LOOHWYHDIHQRIi]LViQDNPHJIHOHO HQYiOWR]LN
eJKDMODW $ SiUROJiVW pV D SiURORJWDWiVW D] pJKDMODWL WpQ\H] N|Q EHOO DODSYHW HQ D K PpUVpNOHW UHODWtY SiUDWDUWDORP KDWiUR]]D PHJ $ FVDSDGpN PHQQ\LVpJH pV D WDODM QHGYHVVpJWDUWDOPiQDNYiOWR]iVDLDWpQ\OHJHVSiURORJWDWiVWEHIRO\iVROMiN
7DODMDGRWWViJRN$]|QW|]pVLWDODMWDQLV]DNYpOHPpQ\HNH]]HONDSFVRODWEDQUpV]OHWHV DGDWRNDW V]ROJiOWDWQDN )RQWRV LVPHUQQN D WDODMV]LQWHN V]DEDGI|OGL Yt]NDSDFLWiViW YDODPLQWDKROWYt]WDUWDOPDW$NHWW NO|QEVpJpE ODKDV]QRVYt]WDUWDORPV]iPROKDWy$
KDV]QRVtWKDWy Yt]WDUWDORP LVPHUHWH DODSMiQ PHJiOODStWKDWy D] DNWXiOLV Yt]NpV]OHW pV Yt]KLiQ\DWDODMEDQ
$ OLQHiU WHUOHWHQ WDODMWDQL V]DNYpOHPpQ\ NpV]tWpVpKH] pYEHQ NpV]OW WDODMIL]LNDLIHOWiUiVRNV]iPDGDUDEYROW(]KHNWiURVV]HOYpQ\V U VpJQHNIHOHOPHJ
%iU D YL]VJiOW WHUOHW WDODMWDQLODJ QHP QDJ\RQ KHWHURJpQ D WDODM Yt]JD]GiONRGiVL WXODMGRQViJDLWQHPWNU|]LWHOMHVOHIHGHWWVpJJHO6]NVpJHVYROWDPLQWDKHO\HNEHV UtWpVH PpJNLHJpV]tW V]HOYpQ\WWiUWDPIHOD]DGRWWWHUOHWHQpYEHQ(]HNE OWDODMIL]LNDL YL]VJiODWRN NpV]OWHN ODERUDWyULXPEDQ ËJ\ D V]HOYpQ\V U VpJ KHNWiU D WDODMIL]LNDL YL]VJiODWRNDWLOOHW HQ
$J\DNRUODWEDQW|UWpQ WHUYH]pVpVPRGHOOH]pVV]iPiUDDNH]HOKHW VpJpUGHNpEHQ W|UWpQWDWHQ\pV]LG V]DNGHNiGRNUDW|UWpQ IHORV]WiVDiEUDËJ\D]HJ\HVWt]QDSRV LG V]DNRNDWHJ\VpJHVDGDWRNMHOOHP]LN
iEUD
9t]Ki]WDUWiVLPpUOHJ
)LJXUH%DODQFHRIZDWHUPDQDJHPHQWXWLOL]DWLRQ
$IHQWLPpUOHJHWJUDILNXVDQLVPHJMHOHQtWKHWMNiEUD
iEUD
9t]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNDWHUOHWHQUpWLFVHUQR]MRPWDODMWtSXVHVHWpQ
)LJXUH&KDQJHVRIZDWHUUHVRXUFHVLQFDVHRIFKHUQR]HP
$ IHQWL IHOGROJR]iV HJ\ DGRWW WHUOHWpJKDMODW WDODM pV Q|YpQ\IpOHVpJ PHJKDWiUR]RWW WXODMGRQViJDLDODSMiQNpV]OW$YL]VJiOWWHUOHWHQD]RQRVpJKDMODWLYLV]RQ\RNHJ\DGRWW Q|YpQ\IpOHVpJ PHOOHWW HOWpU WDODMWXODMGRQViJRN tJ\ HOWpU Yt]JD]GiONRGiVL WXODMGRQ ViJRNKDWiUR]KDWyNPHJ(]HNNHODPLQWDKHO\HNHQPpUWWDODMIL]LNDLSDUDPpWHUHNLQWHU SROiOiViWNtYiQWDPDYL]VJiOWWiEOiUDHOYpJH]QL (QQHN pUGHNpEHQ V]NVpJHV HJ\ RO\DQ DGDWWiEOD OpWUHKR]iVD DPHO\ D Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNDW PLQWDKHO\HNKH] N|W|WWHQ pV LG VRURVDQPXWDWMDiEUD
iEUD
.DSFVROWDGDWWiEOD$UFYLHZV]RIWYHUDODWW
)LJXUH-RLQHG$UF9LHZWDEOHV
,QWHUSROiFLyVHOMiUiVRN
9L]VJiOWDP KRJ\ D WpUEHOL LQWHUSROiFLyV HOMiUiVRN N|]O PHO\LN D] DPHO\LN OHJMREEDQ PRGHOOH]LDYt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNDWDWDODMEDQiEUD
iEUD
)HOGROJR]iVRN$UFYLHZ6SDWLDO$QDOLVWDODWW
)LJXUH,QWHUSRODWLRQV$UF9LHZ6SDWLDO$QDO\VW
0HJiOODStWKDWy KRJ\ D Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRN PRGHOOH]pVpKH] OHJDONDOPDVDEE D WiYROViJJDO IRUGtWRWWDQ DUiQ\RV LQYHUVH GLVWDQFH WR SRZHU HOMiUiV PLYHO D V~O\pUWpN KDWiVD D YL]VJiODWL WiYROViJJDO FV|NNHQ (] D]W MHOHQWL KRJ\ PLQGHQ PiV WpQ\H]
HJ\H]pVHHVHWpQ PLQpO N|]HOHEEYDQHJ\DGDWSRQW D NHUHVHWW SRQWKR] DQQiO QDJ\REE V~OO\DOV]iPtWDGLV]SRQLELOLVYt]pUWpNpQHNPHJKDWiUR]iViEDQ
(5('0e1<e6e57e.(/e6
$ Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRN PRGHOOH]pVH LG VRURV HOHP]pVH |QW|]HWOHQ WiEOiQ NXNRULFD HVHWpQ
$ WHQ\pV]LG V]DN GHNiGRNEDQ W|UWpQW IHOGROJR]iVD NXNRULFD HVHWpQ iSULOLVWyO RNWyEHULJ GHNiGRW MHOHQW $ Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRN HOHP]pVpKH] D MHOPDJ\DUi]DWRW HJ\VpJHV V]tQ NXOFFVDO NHOOHWW WHUPpV]HWHVHQ NLDODNtWDQL $ KDV]QRVYt] WDUWDOPDW PpWHUHVWDODMUpWHJUHYRQDWNR]yDQPPEHQIHMH]WHPNL
$]HO ] HNEHQOHtUWLQSXWDGDWRNDODSMiQYL]VJiOMXNPHJHO V]|UDWDYDV]LiSULOLV PiMXVQHGYHVVpJEHQMREEDQHOOiWRWWLG V]DNYt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVDLWiEUD
/iWKDWy KRJ\ D NRUDWDYDV]L My Yt]HOOiWRWWViJ XWiQ HOpJ LQWHQ]tYHQ IRJ\ D WDODM Yt]NpV]OHWH $ MREE Yt]JD]GiONRGiV~ WiEODUpV]HN D 1\L pV e.L V]pOHNHQ D J\HQJpEE DGRWWViJ~WiEODUpV]HND'LWHUOHWHQKHO\H]NHGQHNHO
$N|YHWNH] NEHQYL]VJiOMXNPHJDQ\iULM~QLXVM~OLXVDXJXV]WXVYt]NpV]OHWHNHWD WDODMEDQiEUD
iEUD
7DYDV]LYt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNiSULOLVPiMXVGHNiGRQNpQW
-HOPDJ\DUi]DW/HJHQG
+DV]QRVtWKDWyYt]WDUWDORPPPEHQFPWDODMUpWHJUHYRQDWNR]WDWYD 8VHDEOHZDWHUFRQWHQWPPIRUFPVRLOOD\HU
)LJXUH&KDQJHVRIZDWHUUHVRXUFHVSHUWHQGD\VLQVSULQJ$SULO0D\
/iWKDWyKRJ\DWHUPpV]HWHVFVDSDGpNDNXNRULFDPHJQ|YHNHGHWWYt]LJpQ\pWQHPNpSHV NLHOpJtWHQL $ WDODM Yt]NpV]OHWH WRYiEE FV|NNHQW GH D FV|NNHQpV WHPH OHODVVXOW
$XJXV]WXVEDQ PiU DV]iO\MHOHQVpJHN PXWDWNR]KDWQDN D YL]VJiOW WiEOD NHGYH] WOHQ WDODMWXODMGRQViJ~ UpV]HLQ $ PHWHRUROyJLDL YLV]RQ\RNDW ILJ\HOHPEH YpYH D WDODM Yt]NpV]OHWHDXJXV]WXVGHNiGMiEDQDOHJNHYHVHEE
$ N|YHWNH] NEHQ D WHQ\pV]LG V]DN YpJpW V]HSWHPEHU RNWyEHU PXWDWRP EH $ Q|YpQ\]HW Yt]LJpQ\H FV|NNHQ H]]HO HJ\WW D K PpUVpNOHW LV pV D UHODWtY SiUDWDUWDORP Q|YHNV]LN$WDODMEDQNLVPpUWpN Q|YHNHGpVWDSDV]WDOKDWyDYt]NpV]OHWHNEHQiEUD
9t]NpV]OHWHNHOHP]pVHD]|QW|]pVV]HPSRQWMiEyO
$] |QW|] Yt] PHQQ\LVpJpW WHKiW D WDODM QHGYHVVpJL iOODSRWiQDN Yt]Ki]WDUWiVL WXODMGRQViJiQDN LVPHUHWpEHQ ~J\ NHOO PHJKDWiUR]QL KRJ\ D] HOpJtWVH NL D Q|YpQ\
iOORPiQ\Yt]LJpQ\pWGHNiURVN|YHWNH]PpQQ\HOVHPPLO\HQN|UOPpQ\HNN|]|WWVHMiUMRQ
$Yt]KLiQ\LVPHUHWHD]|QW|]pVLQWHQ]LWiViQDNV]NVpJHVVpJpUHLVWiPSRQWXOV]ROJiO 0DLVKHO\HVD]DUpJLPHJiOODStWiVKRJ\D]|QW|]pV HONH]GKHW DPLNRU D WDODM QHGYHVVpJNpV]OHWH D GLV]SRQLELOLV Yt] WDUWRPiQ\iQDN IHOpUH FV|NNHQ (]HQ iOODSRW XWiQ XJ\DQLV D Q|YpQ\ KDPDU D QDJ\REE HQHUJLiYDO N|W G|WW QHGYHVVpJ IHOYpWHOpUH NpQ\V]HUODPHO\DYt]UDFLRQiOLVKDV]QRVtWiViWYHV]pO\H]WHWL
9L]VJiOMXNPHJKRJ\DWiEODWDODMDPLNRUpULHOD]WD]iOODSRWRWDPLNRUDYt]KLiQ\
NULWLNXVViYiOLN'9DODWWLOHV]
$]tJ\NpV]OWWpUNpSHNHQDÄPP´D'9iWMHOHQWLD]DODWWQHJDWtY ÄPP´
pUWpNHNLVPHJMHOHQQHNDPLPiUDNULWLNXVpUWpNDODWWLYt]NpV]OHWHWMHO]LiEUD
iEUD
1\iULYt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNM~QLXVM~OLXVDXJXV]WXVGHNiGRQNpQW
-HOPDJ\DUi]DWRWOiVGiEUD/HJHQGVHHDW)LJXUH
)LJXUH&KDQJHVRIZDWHUUHVRXUFHVSHUWHQGD\VLQVXPPHU-XQH-XO\$XJXVW iEUD
V]LYt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNV]HSWHPEHURNWyEHUGHNiGRQNpQW
-HOPDJ\DUi]DWRWOiVGiEUD/HJHQGVHHDW)LJXUH
)LJXUH&KDQJHVRIZDWHUUHVRXUFHVSHUWHQGD\VLQDXWXPQ6HSWHPEHU2FWREHU
iEUD
$WHUOHWYt]NpV]OHWHLDWHQ\pV]LG V]DNEDQD'9iKR]NpSHVW
-HOPDJ\DUi]DW/HJHQG
$ WDODM Yt]NpV]OHWH D '9 iKR] NpSHVW PPEHQ FP WDODMUpWHJUH:DWHUUHVRXUFHRIWKHVRLOFRPSDUHGWRWKHRIWKH DYDLODEOHZDWHUPPIRUFPVRLOOD\HU
)LJXUH :DWHU UHVRXUFHV RI WKH DUHD LQ WKH JURZLQJ SHULRG FRPSDUHG WR RI DYDLODEOHZDWHU
$ NpSL HOHP]pVHNE O OiWKDWy KRJ\ D Yt]NpV]OHW M~QLXV YpJpQ M~OLXV HOHMpQ pUL HO D KDV]QRVtWKDWyYt]NpV]OHWiW+DQHP|QW|]QNDWDODMYt]NpV]OHWHWRYiEEFV|NNHQ DXJXV]WXV YpJpUH D OHJNLVHEE D Yt]WDUWDORP $ WDODM Yt]NpV]OHWH LJHQ ODVVDQ Q|YHNV]LN FVDNV]HSWHPEHUYpJpUHpULHOD'9N|UOLpUWpNHW
9t]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNPRGHOOH]pVH|QW|]pVHVHWpQ
$] |QW|] Yt] QRUPD PHJiOODStWiViQiO FpORP D] YROW KRJ\ D Yt]KLiQ\ EHN|YHWNH]WpW HO ]]N PHJ $ WDODM QHGYHVVpJWDUWDOPiW SyWROQL V]NVpJHV D 9.V] PpUWpNpLJ GH D]
HJ\V]HUL NLDGKDWy Yt]DGDJ QH KDODGMD PHJ D PPW )LJ\HOHPEH YpYH D] |QW|]pV PyGMiW D Q|YpQ\ LJpQ\pW pV pU]pNHQ\VpJpW YDODPLQW D WDODM Yt]YH]HW NpSHVVpJpW
|QW|]pVVHO WDUWyV OHYHJ WOHQ iOODSRWRW QHP WHUHPWKHWQN (QQHN DODSMiQ D] |QW|]pV D KDV]QRVYt]WDUWDORPDN|UOHONH]GKHW iEUD
iEUD
9t]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNPPYt]DGDJRNNL|QW|]pVHXWiQDWDODMEDQ
GHNiG Yt]KLiQ\ Yt]NpV]OHW '9
-XQ PP PP
GHNiG Yt]KLiQ\ Yt]NpV]OHW '9
-XOL PP PP
GHNiG Yt]KLiQ\ Yt]NpV]OHW '9
$XJ PP PP
)LJXUH&KDQJHVRIWKHZDWHUUHVRXUFHLQWKHVRLODIWHUWKHLUULJDWLRQRIPP 9L]VJiOMXNPHJDYt]Ki]WDUWiVLPpUOHJiEUDDODSMiQKRJ\KROV]NVpJHVHONH]GHQL D]|QW|]pVWpVPLO\HQYt]DGDJRWV]iPROKDWXQN
/iWKDWyKRJ\D]|QW|]pVHNKDWiVDD]|QW|]pVWN|YHW GHNiGEDQMHOHQWNH]LN 0HJQp]KHWMNKRJ\MyOWHUYH]WHPHH]|QW|]pVL IRUGXOyNDWLOOHWYHD Yt]QRUPiNDW iEUD$ YL]VJiOW WiEOiQ D KDV]QRVtWKDWy Yt]WDUWDORP D] |QW|]pV KDWiViUD VHKRO QHP FV|NNHQW D '9 D DOi 6]HSWHPEHUEHQ D] |QW|]pVL LG V]DN EHIHMH]WpYHO PiU FV|NNHQDYt]NpV]OHWGHDNXNRULFDYt]LJpQ\HPiUDODFVRQ\DEEPLQWDM~OLXVLDXJXV]WXV HOHMHL LG V]DNRNEDQ 7HUPpV]HWHVHQ D Yt]QRUPiNDW OHKHW ÄILQRPtWDQL´ YDODPLQW D]
|QW|]pVL IRUGXOyNDW V UtWHQL GH ILJ\HOHPEH NHOO YHQQL D Q|YpQ\]HW IHQRIi]LV V]HULQWL Yt]LJpQ\pWYDODPLQW]HPV]HUYH]pVLJD]GDViJRVViJLV]HPSRQWRNDW
iEUD
$]|QW|]pVKDWiVDDWDODMYt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVDLUD
-HOPDJ\DUi]DWRWOiVGiEUD/HJHQGVHHDW)LJXUH
)LJXUH(IIHFWRILUULJDWLRQRQWKHFKDQJHVRIZDWHUUHVRXUFHVLQWKHVRLO .g9(7.(=7(7e6(.
%HPXWDWWDP HJ\IDMWD PHJROGiVW DPHO\ D WpULQIRUPDWLND HV]N|]HLYHO NpSHV LG VRURVDQ PRGHOOH]QL D Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVRNDW HJ\ DGRWW WHUOHWHQ $ PRGHOOW HJ\ NRQNUpW WHUOHWHQ HJ\ DGRWW NXOW~UQ|YpQ\ Yt]LJpQ\pW ILJ\HOHPEH YpYH pV iWODJRV D WpUVpJUH MHOOHP] PHWHRUROyJLDLYLV]RQ\RNILJ\HOHPEHYpWHOpYHODONRWWDPPHJ
$ GLJLWiOLV WHFKQLND OHKHW VpJHW DG D] DGDWRN J\RUV IHOGROJR]iViUD $ EHPXWDWRWW Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iV PRGHOO HONpV]tWpVH VRUiQ V]NVpJHV YROW HOWpUQL D WDODMWpUNpSH]pVKH] NDSFVROyGy PLQWDYpWHOH]pV pV DGDWJ\ MWpV KDJ\RPiQ\RV PyGV]HUHLW O$YL]VJiOWWHUOHWHWPLQWDKHO\HNSRQWV]HU DGDWDLDODSMiQMHOOHPH]WHP D]RN LQWHUSROiFLyMiYDO $ WDODMWDQL WpUNpSH]pVQHN H] D] ~MV]HU PyGMD QDJ\REE ILJ\HOHPEHYHV]LDWDODMWXODMGRQViJRNKHWHURJHQLWiViQDNNpUGpVpW
eJKDMODWLDGDWRNIHOGROJR]iViQiOD6]iV]IpOHPHWHRUROyJLDLN|U]HWWHUOHWUHMHOOHP]
iWODJDGDWDLYDOGROJR]WDP$V]RIWYHUHVIHOGROJR]iVQDJ\HO Q\HKRJ\DYt]NpV]OHW YiOWR]iVRN PRGHOOH]pVpKH] J\RUVDQ HO iOOtWKDWy ~M DGDWEi]LV DPHO\EHQ D K PpUVpNOHW FVDSDGpN pV UHODWtY SiUDWDUWDORP DGDWDL ± PLQW EHNpUW DGDWRN ± YiOWR]KDWQDN ËJ\ OHKHWVpJHV W|EEHN N|]|WW D WiEOD V]LQWHQ IRO\DPDWRVDQ PpUW PHWHRUROyJLDL DGDWRN IHOGROJR]iVD DPHO\ NRQNUpWDQ HO UH MHOH]KHWL D Yt]NpV]OHW YiOWR]iVRNGHNiGRNKR]WDUWR]yPPpUWpNHLW
/pWUHKR]KDWyDNRO\DQPRGHOOHNDPHO\HNV]pOV VpJHVN|UOPpQ\HNN|]|WWYL]VJiOMiN DWHUOHWWDODMiQDNYt]Ki]WDUWiViW(J\FVDSDGpNEDQV]HJpQ\DV]iO\RVpYHVHWpQHO UH MHOH]KHW PLNRU pV D WiEOD PHO\ UpV]pQ YiOLN NULWLNXVVi D Yt]KLiQ\ &VDSDGpNRV LG MiUiV HVHWpQ PHJILJ\HOKHW KRJ\ D WiEOD PHO\LN UpV]pQ pV PLNRU PLO\HQ FVDSDGpNYLV]RQ\RN PHOOHWW DODNXOKDW NL EHOYt] 6HJtWVpJHW Q\~MWKDW D WHUOHW PHOLRUiFLyVPXQNiLQDNH]HQEHOODYt]UHQGH]pVQHNDPHJWHUYH]pVpKH]
gQW|]pV HVHWpQ NLSUyEiOKDWXQN NO|QE|] Yt]QRUPiNDW PLQGHQ HJ\HV Q|YpQ\UH 0HJWHUYH]KHWMN D] RSWLPiOLV |QW|] Yt]LJpQ\W 0RGHOOH]KHWMN KRJ\ PLO\HQ KDWiVVDOYDQDWDODMYt]NpV]OHWHLUHD]|QW|]pV
0HJYL]VJiOKDWMXNKRJ\XQÄWHUPpVPHQW ´HJ\V]HULYt]DGDJPLO\HQKDWiVWJ\DNRURO DWiEODYt]Ki]WDUWiViUD
7|EE IpOH NXOW~UQ|YpQ\ NLYiODV]WiVD OHKHWVpJHV $ NXOW~UQ|YpQ\HN WHQ\pV]LGHMH NO|QE|] pV D Yt]LJpQ\N LV D IHQRIi]LVXN DODWW (J\ DGRWW WHUOHWHQ EHOO W|EE NXOW~UQ|YpQ\ YL]VJiODWiW LV HOYpJH]KHWMN NO|QNO|Q pV HJ\WWHVHQ LV D WHUOHWHW
~MUDWiEOiVtWYD $] HOWpU WDODMRN Yt]JD]GiONRGiVL WXODMGRQViJDLW ILJ\HOHPEH YpYH VHJtWVpJHWDGKDWXQNDWHUOHWYHWpVWHUYpKH]
,52'$/20
$QWDO($]LG MiUiVpVpJKDMODWNDSFVRODWDDQ|YpQ\iOORPiQ\RNYt]IRUJDOPiYDO 0HWHRUROyJLDL7XGRPiQ\RV1DSRN
ÈFV ) $ WDODMQHGYHVVpJ PRGHOOH]pVH 0HWHRUROyJLDL 7XGRPiQ\RV 1DSRN
%XGDSHVW
.HUWpV]È$WpULQIRUPDWLNDpVDONDOPD]iVDL+ROQDS.LDGy%XGDSHVW
3DUiV]ND / $ Yt]WDNDUpNRV |QW|]pVL V]DNWDQiFVDGiV D WDODM HOOHQ U]pVH pV D QHGYHVVpJPpUpVDODSMiQ0e01$È%XGDSHVW
6]iV]*7 NHL/0HWHRUROyJLD0H] JD]GD.LDGy%XGDSHVW 7DPiV-'LyV]HJL$7pULQIRUPDWLNDSUDNWLNXP'$7(()())).
7DPiV-3UHFt]LyVPH] JD]GDViJ0H] JD]GDViJL6]DNWXGiV.LDGy%XGDSHVW 9iUDOO\D\ *\ +iURPIi]LV~ WDODMUpWHJHNEHQ YpJEHPHQ Yt]PR]JiV $JURNpPLD
pV7DODMWDQ07$7$.,NLDGYiQ\D%XGDSHVW
/HYHOH]pVLFtPFRUUHVSRQGLQJDXWKRU 0HQNy0LKiO\
-iV]1DJ\NXQ6]ROQRNPHJ\HL1|YpQ\pV7DODMYpGHOPL6]ROJiODW 7pULQIRUPDWLNDL/DERUDWyULXP
6]ROQRN9t]SDUWNUW
-iV]1DJ\NXQ6]ROQRN&RXQW\6HUYLFHIRU3ODQW3URWHFWLRQDQG6RLO
&RQVHUYDWLRQ*,6/DERUDWRU\
+6]ROQRN9t]SDUWNUW
7HO)D[
HPDLOPHQNRP#RQWV]KX